commit to user 31
CHAPTER III ANALYSIS
The Research will be divided into several stages. In the early stage the researcher will analyze the three major characters and decide their dominant
factor of id, ego, and superego. It is carried in order to give more visible analysis on the following stages. From this point, their dominant factor will be generalized
into broader perspective of the existence as individual with dominant id, ego, and superego.
The research will then be conducted based on the development of interaction and domination among the three major characters, recalling the major
characters as individual dominant feature of id, ego, and superego. And from the progress of the novel and the provided theory of Freudian psychoanalysis, the data
will then be analyzed into conclusion to answer the problem statement; how do the three major characters in their latent phase, with their dominant personality
features, interact and develop toward one another within abnormal circumstance; in wilderness, related with Freudian psychoanalysis theory?
A. Early Characterization of the Three Major Characters and Their
Dominant Features of Id, Ego, Superego
In this sub-chapter, the researcher will analyze the early characterization of the three major characters to find out each dominant features portrayed by
commit to user 32
Golding in relation with Freudian personality structure. The analysis of this sub- chapter is conducted to create a more visible scheme to Freudian personality
structure which consists of Id, Ego, and Superego as explained in Chapter II. And here, the researcher will take the first chapter of the novel as the main data of
analysis. Therefore the researcher will categorize and divide the data according to their significant personality features.
And to summarize the characteristic of each Freudian personality structures in the main line are as follow:
Id act based on biological demand, immediate pleasure fulfilment, and cannot differentiate between phantasm and reality, it act
regardless the surrounding social environment. It is the most primitive form of personality structure.
Ego act based on reality concept, it perceives what can be done related to the urge inside and the real condition outside, it does not
only focus on the immediate fulfilment but also in a long term survival both as one self and as a part of social environment. It is
the ratio of human being. Superego act based on the social norms, belief, and values taught
to one self, it differentiate what is right and what is wrong, what may be done and what may not. It is the conscience of people.
And from that basic term of Freudian personality structure, the data will be analyzed and classify into the dominant feature of each characters as the following
analysis.
commit to user 33
1. Ralph’s Dominant Personality Structure
No Data
Analysis Dominant
Feature 1.
2. 3.
4. 5.
“This is an island. At least I think it’s an island. That’s a
reef out in the sea. Perhaps there aren’t any grownups
anywhere.” LOTF pg 7
Ralph said nothing. Here was a coral island. Protected from
the sun, ignoring Piggy’s ill- omened talk, he dreamed
pleasantly. Piggy insisted
LOTF page 17
“I climbed a rock,” said Ralph slowly, “and I think this is an
island.” LOTF page 16
“We’d better all have names,” said Ralph, “so I’m Ralph.”
LOTF page 27
“He’s not Fatty,” cried Ralph, “his real name’s Piggy”
LOTF page 27 Observing the surrounding,
assuming rationally, “that’s a reef out in the sea.” Exact
evidential consideration
Observing surrounding
physically while acting to fulfil the body need, care less
to social value , “ignoring
Piggy’s ill omened talk”
Concluding based
on evidence
Purposing on social act in order to be prepared for
upcoming happening
Ignoring social norm for immediate joy
Ego
Ego
Ego
Ego
Id
commit to user 34
7. 8.
9. 10.
“Seems to me we ought to have a chief to decide things.”
LOTF page 28 Ralph raised a hand for
silence. “All right. Who wants Jack for chief?”
“Who wants me?” “I’m chief then.”
LOTF page 29 Ralph looked at him, eager to
offer something.
“The choir belongs to you, of course.”
“They could be the army—” “Or hunters—”
“They could be—” “Jack’s in charge of the
choir. They can be —what do
you want them to be?” LOTF page 29-30
“Listen, everybody. I’ve got to have time to think things
out. I can’t decide what to do straight off. If this isn’t an
island we might be rescued straight away. So we’ve got to
decide if this is an island. Everybody must stay round
here and wait and not go away. Three of us
—if we take more we’d get all mixed, and
lose each other —three of us
will go on an expedition and Purposing on social act in
order to be prepared for upcoming happening
Giving chance to satisfy other’s force so there will be
no more trouble lies ahead
Observing most
possible immediate force and offering
it alternative to satisfy its need to calm it down
Distribution of assignment based on objective point of
view with consideration of everyone’s
force of
personality to keep it in order and under control in order to
survive. Ego,
superego
Ego
Ego
Ego
commit to user 35
11. 12.
13. 14.
find out. I’ll go, and Jack, and, and. . . ”
LOTF page 30
“You’re no good on a job like this.”
LOTF page 31
“Look.” “You can’t come.”
“Better Piggy than Fatty,” he said at last, with the directness
of ge nuine leadership, “and
anyway, I’m sorry if you feel like that. Now go back, Piggy,
and take names. That’s your job. So long.”
LOTF page 32
“We’ll go to the end of the island,” said Ralph, “and look
round the corner.” “If it is an island—”
“We’ll try climbing the mountain from here,” he said.
“I should think this is the easiest way. There’s less of
that jungly stuff; and more pink rock. Come on.”
LOTF page 33-34
“We ought to draw a map,” said Ralph, “only we haven’t
any paper.” LOTF page 35
Objective and frank decision, ignoring social norm of the
way to say it
Objective, yet considering social
norm he
find necessary to keep everything
in order
Systematic way of thinking, logical assumptions based on
the surrounding facts, pure steps of survival objective,
long term plan.
Systematic way of thinking, logical assumptions based on
the surrounding facts, pure Ego
Ego
Ego
Ego
commit to user 36
15. 16.
“That’s the quickest way back.” “There’s no village
smoke, and no boats,” said Ralph wisely. “We’ll
make sure later; but I think it’s uninhabited.”
LOTF page 39
“You should stick a pig,” said Ralph fiercely. “They
always talk about sti
cking a pig.” Why didn’t you—?”
LOTF page 42 steps of survival objective,
long term plan.
Systematic way of thinking, logical assumptions based on
the surrounding facts, pure steps of survival objective,
long term plan.
Immediate anger Ego
Id
On this early chapter of the novel can be seen that Ralph’s role is essential. He takes decisions based on logic, he try hard to fulfil and calm every force of the
team which mainly come from Piggy’s and Jack’s. Sometimes he walks along Jack’s side, sometimes he comfort Piggy’s side. His decisions are objective and in
the term of long lasting survival. Therefore his dominant personality structure in Freudian psychoanalysis is ego.
commit to user 37
2. Jack’s Dominant Personality Structure
No Data
Analysis Dominant
Feature 1.
2. 3.
His face was crumpled and freckled, and ugly without
silliness. Out of this face stared two light blue eyes,
frustrated now, and turning, or ready to turn, to anger.
LOTF page 25 The tall boy shouted at them.
“Choir Stand still” LOTF page 25
“Kids’ names,”
said Merridew. “Why should I be
Jack? I’m Merridew.” Ralph turned to him quickly.
This was the voice of one who knew his own mind.
“Then,” went on Piggy, “that boy
—I forget—” “You’re talking too much,”
said Jack Merridew. “Shut up, Fatty.”
LOTF page 27 Description of a physically
less decent character from the writer. An immediate
possibility of
force channelling of anger.
Direct order,
without observing what things should
be done and how it should be done,
ignoring the
surrounding condition.
Frontal objection to social norm, immediate response
to the self superiority Self centred attitude, total
ignorance of social norms, frontal
defence on
his immediate comfort, due to
Piggy’s speech. Id
Id
Id
commit to user 38
4. 5.
7. 8.
9. 10.
“I ought to be chief,” said Jack with simple arrogance,
“because I’m chapter chorister and head boy. I can sing C
sharp.” LOTF page 28
“Hunters.” LOTF page 30
“We don’t want you,” said Jack, flatly. “Three’s enough.”
LOTF page 31
“We shan’t see round this co
rner,” said Jack, “because there isn’t one. Only a slow
curve —and you can see, the
rocks get worse —”
LOTF page 33 “What made this track?”
“Animals.” LOTF 34
“This is real exploring,” said Jack. “I bet nobody’s been
here before.” LOTF page 35
Self centred attitude, total ignorance of social norms.
And immediate response to the self superiority.
A profession chosen to fulfil immediate force of hunger
Objective decision, yet a harsh way to communicate
Observing logically trough physical
surrounding environment
Quick answer based on instinct, not seeing other
possibility, only what his mind firstly recalls
Expression of
immediate excitement
Id
Id
Id
Ego, Id
Ego
Id
commit to user 39
11. 12.
13. 14.
15. “We’ll get food,” cried Jack.
“Hunt. Catch things until they fetch us.”
LOTF page 39
“Green candles,” said Jack contemptuously. “We can’t eat
them. Come on.” LOTF page 40
“I was choosing a place,” said Jack. “I was just waiting
for a moment to decide where to stab him.”
“You cut a pig’s throat to let the blood out,” said Jack,
“otherwise you can’t eat the meat.”
LOTF page 41
“I was going to,” said Jack. He was ahead of them, and they
could not see his face. “I was choosing a place. Next time
LOTF page 41-42 Priority of immediate need,
hunger, purposing fastest way to fulfil it, hunting,
strengthen the satisfaction line, “until they fetch us.”
Expressing knowledge, yet focusing on physical needs,
hunger. Self defence, compliance of
the force to become superior
Expressing knowledge, yet focusing on physical needs,
hunger
Self defence, compliance of the force to become superior,
frank expression of anger and vengeance
Id
Id
Id
Id
Id
On this chapter of the novel, Jack’s role is not as much as Ralph or Piggy, but he obviously carries influencing potential which is realized and considered by
commit to user 40
Ralph in making his decision. In physical appearance, Jack is described to be less decent than the other kids, a more barbaric form of human being which resonance
to the description of Id. His actions, speech, and decisions are mainly self-centred, ignorant, and methods to fulfil his immediate needs such as food, force to become
superior, and self joy ignoring the social condition surrounding him. Therefore his dominant personality structure in Freudian psychoanalysis is Id.
3. Piggy’s Dominant Personality Structure
No Data
Analysis Dominant
Feature 1.
2. 3.
“What’s your name?” “Ralph.”
The fat boy waited to be asked his name in turn but this
proffer of acquaintance was not made; the fair boy called
Ralph smiled vaguely, stood up, and began to make his way
once more toward the lagoon. The fat boy hung steadily at
his shoulder. LOTF page 9
“I expect we’ll want to know all thei
r names, ”said the fat boy, “and make a list. We
ought to have a meeting.” LOTF page 12
“We got to find the others. We got to do something.”
Believe in and act due to the proper social norm he was
taught about
Proposing on
a social
system, what should be valued and expressing it in a
proper way he thinks socially suitable
Logical way of thinking, yet Superego
Superego
Superego
commit to user 41
4. 5.
6. LOTF page 17
“We got to do something.” Ralph looked through him.
Here at last was the imagined but never fully realized place
leaping into real life. Ralph’s lips parted in a delighted smile
and Piggy, taking this smile to himself
as a
mark of
recognition, laughed
with pleasure.
“If it really is an island—” “What’s that?”
LOTF page 17
“We can use this to call the others.
Have a
meeting. They’ll come when they hear
us —”
LOTF page 20
“He kind of spat, ”said Piggy. “My auntie wouldn’t let me
blow on account of my asthma. He said you blew
from down here.” Piggy laid a hand on his jutting abdomen.
“You try, Ralph. You’ll call the others.”
LOTF page 20 setting the priority in social
scope
Delaying the
force of
immediate happiness until he find it proper to express it
according to
the social
environment
Logical way of thinking, yet setting the priority in social
scope
Holding on a social message given to him, represented as
his auntie
telling him,
finding a way to achieve his need yet comfort other forces
in the way he finds as appropriate manner
Superego
Superego
Superego
commit to user 42
7. 8.
“That’s why Ralph made a meeting. So as we can decide
what to do. We’ve heard names. That’s Johnny. Those
two —they’re twins, Sam ’n
Eric LOTF page 26-27
“I was with him when he found the conch. I was with
him before anyone else was.” LOTF page 31
Abiding his
personal importance as he observe
that it would be more accepted
socially, and
expressing his thought in a socially proper way which he
thinks will comfort everyone.
Believe in and act due to the proper social norm he was
taught about,
and acknowledging
that his
importance in
socially justified
Superego
Superego
On this chapter, Piggy’s role is filling the whole ignored by both Ralph and Jack. While the two people focus more on the survival in different way, Jack
goes for short term and Ralph goes for long term, Piggy purposes on what is less realized by them, the importance of social value, how a society should be
conducted, a proper law and order. Therefore his dominant personality structure in Freudian psychoanalysis is Superego.
commit to user 43
B. The dominance and Interaction of the Early Characterization and