Identity-building strategy in the English advertisements in Kompas Newspaper.
xiv ABSTRACT
Lelly Sepniwati. 2014. Identity-Building Strategy in the English Advertisements in Kompas Newspaper. Yogyakarta: The Graduate Program in English Language Studies, Sanata Darma University.
Advertisements have become an integral part in the contemporary community. Their significance in asserting a certain idea is widely acknowledged, especially the consumerism ideology. In spreading this ideology, the commercial advertisements have implemented various strategies to increase the capital advantage aimed by the advertisers. Concerning the calculated framework of consumerism, there is a tendency from the producers to imply an influential effect of the brands and the products on the social value toward the community. This tendency is recognized as the identity-building strategy. In this identity representation, the common technique found and analyzed by many researches is the English utilization in the non-English speaking countries. The advertisers are prone to strengthen the English implication as the international language with the manner in which it is configured, both in the grammatical and lexical choices, in the identity-building strategy. For that matter, the problems of the study are formulated into two consisting of what types of transitivity process are typically exploited in the English clauses and what representations of social actor are applied in constructing the identity-building strategy in the
Based on the indications, this study emphasized the commercial advertisement attempts to persuade the customers to buy the product by promoting additional social and psychological benefits of the merchandise, namely identity. The data were taken from a prominent newspaper which contains many commercial advertisements, namely Kompas newspaper. There were 188 English clauses contained in 59 display advertisements from the first to fourteenth June in 2012. In analyzing these clauses, there were two methods applied in the research. The transitivity process as the initial step was conducted to examine the exploitation of the grammatical and lexical choices in proposing the appealing value of social identity in the discourse. Consecutively, the social actor representation analysis was implemented to give better understanding on how the commodities and the social community are generally depicted considering the effect they have toward each other in the identity assigning strategy.
The findings show that there are two major grammatical processes in delivering the notion of identity value. The first one is the relational process and the second one is the material process. In the relational process, the direct quality and symbolic attachment is the salient advertising cues in realizing the social values shown by the highest number of intensive clause in the process. In the material process, the notions of attitude improvement and continuous action are heavily imbued in accommodating the desired values emphasized by the largest distribution of transformative clause in the data. Furthermore, the advertisers and the advertising agencies often stress this improvement and continuous action as a result of a
(2)
xv
participant strong influences toward the other. When the action refers to the consuming act, the influence of the customers is significant in the realization. However, the focus is shifted when the depicted processes denote the providers for this improvement attitude. It shows that the ones that have greater influence in realizing the transformation attitude are the brands and the products.
Further analysis focusing on the representations of the four social actors – the narratees, brands, products, and endorser – implies that the most significant aspect in the commercial discourse is the existence of the brands and the products respectively. Moreover, the prospective purchasers are usually represented as the dependant entities that cannot be separated from the existence of the company representations if they wish to acquire the desirable profiles. It can lead to the outcome that the brands and the products are becoming the badge of the inherent identity of the social community.
(3)
xvi ABSTRAK
Lelly Sepniwati. 2014. Identity-Building Strategy in the English Advertisement in Kompas Newspaper. Yogyakarta: Program Paskasarjana Kajian Bahasa Inggris, Universitas Sanata Dharma.
Iklan telah menjadi bagian integral dalam masyarakat kontemporer. Peranan penting iklan dalam menegaskan sebuah ide khususnya ideologi konsumerisme telah diakui secara luas. Dalam menyebarkan ideologi ini, iklan komersial telah menerapkan berbagai macam strategi untuk meningkatkan keuntungan finansial yang ditargetkan oleh para pengiklan. Berkenaan dengan kerangka pemikiran konsumerisme, ada kecenderungan dari produsen untuk mengimplikasikan pentingnya pengaruh merek dan produk terhadap nilai sosial masyarakat. Kecenderungan ini dikenal sebagai strategi pembentukan identitas. Dalam penggambaran identitas ini, teknik yang umum ditemukan dan dianalisis oleh banyak penelitian adalah pemanfaatan Bahasa Inggris di negara-negara yang bahasa nasionalnya bukanlah Bahasa Inggris. Para pengiklan seringkali menguatkan implikasi dari posisi Bahasa Inggris sebagai bahasa internasional di dalam strategi pembentukan identitas dengan pemilihan tata bahasa dan kosakata yang digunakan di dalam teks. Dengan bertumpu pada wacana ini, penelitian ini memiliki dua pokok permasalahan yang terdiri dari proses transitivitas apa yang biasanya digunakan di dalam klausa Bahasa Inggris dan representasi aktor sosial apa yang digunakan dalam strategi pembentukan identitas pada iklan tertulis berbahasa Inggris.
Berdasarkan indikasi tersebut, penelitian ini memfokuskan pada bagaimana iklan komersial membujuk para konsumer untuk membeli barang yang dipromosikan dengan menawarkan keuntungan sosial dan psikologis barang tersebut, yaitu identitas. Data diambil dari sebuah surat kabar terkenal yang berisikan banyak iklan komersial, yaitu harian Kompas. Ada 188 klausa Bahasa Inggris yang terdapat dalam 59 iklan display terhitung dari tanggal satu sampai empat belas Juni 2012. Dalam menganalisis klausa-klausa ini, ada dua metode yang diterapkan di dalam penelitian. Proses transitivitas adalah metode pertama untuk menelurusi eksploitasi pemilihan tata bahasa dan kosakata dalam menyiratkan nilai menarik identitas sosial di dalam wacana. Selanjutnya, analisis representasi aktor sosial dilakukan untuk memberikan pemahaman yang lebih mendalam mengenai bagaimana komoditi dan masyarakat sosial secara umumnya digambarkan di dalam strategi pembentukan identitas dengan mempertimbangkan pengaruh yang mereka miliki terhadap satu sama lain.
Hasil analisis menunjukkan bahwa ada dua proses utama transitivitas dalam menyampaikan gagasan berkenaan dengan nilai identitas. Yang pertama adalah proses relasional, dan yang kedua adalah proses material. Dalam proses relasional, pelekatan kualitas dan simbolisasi secara langsung adalah isyarat iklan yang paling menonjol dalam mewujudkan nilai-nilai sosial terlihat dari tingginya jumlah klausa intensif. Dalam proses material, konsep peningkatan diri dan tindakan yang berkesinambungan sangatlah signifikan yang mengacu pada besarnya klausa transformatif dalam mengindikasikan nilai yang diinginkan. Selain itu, pengiklan dan
(4)
xvii
biro iklan sering menekankan sisi peningkatan diri dan aksi yang berkesinambungan ini sebagai hasil dari pengaruh kuat seorang aktor terhadap aktor lainnya. Ketika proses merujuk pada kegiatan pembelanjaan, pengaruh pelanggan sangatlah penting dalam mewujudkannya. Namun, hal ini berubah ketika proses tersebut menunjukkan penyedia jasa dalam sikap peningkatan diri. Ini menunjukkan bahwa keberadaan yang memiliki pengaruh lebih kuat dalam mewujudkan sikap transformasi diri ini adalah merek dan produk.
Analisis lebih lanjut yang berfokus pada penggambaran empat aktor sosial-narratees, merek, produk, dan endorser-menampakkan aspek yang paling signifikan dalam wacana komersial yaitu keberadaan merek yang diikuti oleh produk. Selain itu, pembeli potensial biasanya digambarkan sebagai entitas non-mandiri yang tidak dapat dipisahkan dari keberadaan representasi perusahaan jika mereka ingin mendapatkan profil yang diidamkan. Hal ini dapat mengarah pada sebuah asumsi yang menyatakan bahwa merek dan produk adalah lencana yang melekat pada identitas sosial masyarakat.
(5)
IDENTITY-BUILDING STRATEGY IN THE ENGLISH ADVERTISEMENTS IN KOMPAS NEWSPAPER
A THESIS
Presented as a Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements to Obtain the Magister Humaniora (M.Hum.) Degree
in English Language Studies
by
Lelly Sepniwati 106332014
THE GRADUATE PROGRAM OF ENGLISH LANGUAGE STUDIES SANATA DHARMA UNIVERSITY
YOGYAKARTA 2014
(6)
(7)
(8)
iv
DEDICATION PAGE
My brethren, have not the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory,
with respect of persons.
For if there come unto your assembly a man with a gold ring, in goodly apparel, and there come in also a poor man in vile raiment; And ye have respect to him that weareth the gay clothing,
and say unto him, Sit thou here in a good place;
and say to the poor, Stand thou there, or sit here under my footstool: Are ye not then partial in yourselves,
and are become judges of evil thoughts? James 2:1-4 (KJV)
I dedicate this thesis to Jesus Christ, who always guides and loves me, and to my dear family, especially my late father, who is always in my heart.
(9)
v
STATEMENT OF WORK ORIGINALITY
This is to certify that all ideas, phrases, sentences, unless otherwise stated, are
the ideas, phrases, and sentences of the thesis writer. The writer understands the full
consequences including degree cancellation if she took somebody else’s ideas, phrases, or sentences without proper references.
(10)
vi
LEMBAR PERNYATAAN PERSETUJUAN
PUBLIKASI KARYA ILMIAH UNTUK KEPENTINGAN AKADEMIS
Yang bertanda tangan di bawah ini, saya mahasiswa Universitas Sanata Dharma :
Nama : Lelly Sepniwati NIM : 106332014
Demi pengembangan ilmu pengetahuan, saya memberikan kepada Perpustakaan Universitas Sanata Dharma karya ilmiah saya yang berjudul :
Identity-Building Strategy in the English Advertisements in Kompas Newspaper
beserta perangkat yang diperlukan (bila ada). Dengan demikian saya memberikan kepada Perpustakaan Universitas Sanata Dharma hak untuk menyimpan, mengalihkan dalam bentuk media lain, mengelolanya dalam bentuk pangkalan data, mendistribusikan secara terbatas, dan mempublikasikannya di internet atau media lain untuk kepentingan akademis tanpa perlu meminta ijin dari saya maupun memberikan royalti kepada saya selama tetap mencantumkan nama saya sebagai penulis.
Demikian pernyataan ini yang saya buat dengan sebenarnya. Dibuat di Yogyakarta
(11)
vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Praise to Lord Almighty that I have completed this valuable academic
journey. I am deeply grateful for His blessing and admonition in my life that have
made me able to finish this thesis. I almost failed myself to bring this work into
completion because of my weaknesses if not for His blessing and strength to
overcome them.
I am deeply thankful for those who take their time, love, and guidance to
support and encourage me in the completion of my thesis. My special gratitude goes
to Dr. B. B. Dwijatmoko, MA, my thesis advisor, for his patience and kindness in
giving me invaluable guidance and suggestion in the completion of this thesis. I
would also like to thank the distinguished lecturers: Prof. Dr. Soepomo
Poedjosoedarmo, Dr. Novita Dewi, M.S., M.A. (Hons), Dr. Fr. B. Alip, M. Pd., M.
A., Drs. Barli Bram, M.Ed., Ph.D., Dr. J. Bismoko, Dr. Alb. Budi Susanto, S.J., Prof.
Dr. Ch. Bakdi Sumanto, S.U., and Drs. F.X. Mukarto, M.S., Ph.D., for their guidance
and willingness to share their valuable thoughts and experiences during my
educational journey in Sanata Dharma University. I also express my sincere gratitude
to Mbak Lely, Pak Mul, and all staff of Sanata Dharma University for their assistance
in my study.
I also give my earnest gratitude to my kind and lovely friends and seniors in
English Language Studies, especially Mbak Orpa, Mbak Anjar, Mbak Umi, Mbak
Arin, Mbak Arina, Mbak Dame, Mbak Siska, Mas Septa, Mbak Rusdi, Devie, Mbak
(12)
viii
also like to thank my dearest friends, Susva, Frisma, Desy, Nora, Kristian, Andre,
Nisa, Yentli, and Muamar, for supporting and accompanying me in the precious
moments of my life.
My deepest gratitude goes to my late father, Pdt. Drs. Yaphie Gaman, my
beloved mother, Pdt. Awina Gaman, my elder sisters Leni, Yana, and Ani, my elder
brother, Adi, and my big family. I am sincerely grateful for their pray, patience, love,
encouragement, support, and admonition given to me to complete my study. Without
their irreplaceable presence, I would not have the strength to follow this path.
(13)
ix
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE ……… i
APPROVAL PAGE ……… ii
DEFENSE APPROVAL PAGE ………. iii
DEDICATION PAGE ……… iv
STATEMENT OF WORK ORIGINALITY ……….. v
LEMBAR PERNYATAAN PERSETUJUAN PUBLIKASI KARYA ILMIAH…… vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ……… vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS ………... ix
LIST OF TABLES ………. xi
LIST OF CHARTS ……… xii
LIST OF APPENDICES ………... xiii
ABSTRACT ……….. xiv
ABSTRAK ……… xvi
CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION ……….. 1
1.1 Background of the Study ….……… 1
1.2 Problem Formulation ……….. 7
1.3 Research Objectives ……… 7
1.4 Research Benefits ………... 8
CHAPTER II. LITERATURE REVIEW ………... 10
2.1 Advertisements .……….. 10
2.2 Printed Advertisements ……… 12
2.3 Language in Advertisements ………... 16
2.4 Identity-Building Strategy ………... 18
2.5 Discourse Analysis ……….. 20
2.6 Transitivity Processes ……….. 24
2.6.1 The Process and Participants ………. 25
2.6.1.1 Material clauses: processes of doing-and-happening………. 26
2.6.1.2 Mental clauses: processes of sensing ………. 29
2.6.1.3 Relational clauses: processes of being and having…………. 31
2.6.1.4 Behavioural clauses………. 36
1.6.1.5Verbal clauses………. 36
2.6.1.6 Existential clauses………... 37
2.6.2 Circumstances……….………... 37
(14)
x
2.7.1 Exclusion/Inclusion……….………...……. 40
2.7.2 Activation/Passivation………. 41
2.7.3 Personalization/Impersonalization……….. 42
2.8 Related Studies ………... 44
2.9 Theoretical Framework .………... 46
CHAPTER III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ………. 51
3.1 Type of the Study ..……….. 51
3.2 Source of the Data ....………... 52
3.3 Data Collection ………... 54
3.4 Data Presentation Technique ……….. 56
3.5 Data Analysis of the Study ……….. 57
3.6 Substantiation ….……… 59
CHAPTER IV. ANALYSIS RESULTS AND DISCUSSION …………... 63
4.1 The Transitivity Processes Analysis………. .……. 63
4.1.1 The Relational Process Analysis……… 65
4.1.2 The Material Process Analysis…………..……… 80
4.2 The Social Actor Representation Analysis..………. 90
4.2.1 The Exclusion/Inclusion Representations……... 90
4.2.2 The Active/Passive Representations………..……. 97
4.2.3 The Personalization/Impersonalization Representations..………….. 103
CHAPTER V. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ………… 109
5.1 Conclusions ………... 109
5.2 Recommendations ………. 111
BIBLIOGRAPHY ………... 114
(15)
xi
LIST OF TABLES
Table 2.1 The characteristics of process types ………. 26
Table 2.2 The principal categories of ‘relational’ clause... 31
Table 2.3 Examples of process in behavioural clause………... 36
(16)
xii
LIST OF CHARTS
Chart 4.1. The transitivity processes in the data ……….………….. 64
Chart 4.2. The relational processes in the data ………... 66
Chart 4.3. The material processes in the data ……….. 81
Chart 4.4. Inclusion/exclusion representations in the data ……… 91
Chart 4.5. Active/passive representations in the data ... 98
(17)
xiii
LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix 1 The Selected Display Advertisements Taken from Kompas
Newspaper……… ………. 117
Appendix 2 The Domain of the Commodity in the Selected Data………. 176
Appendix 3 The Transitivity Clauses in the Data ………..……… 178
Appendix 4 The Relational Clauses in the Data ……….……… 186
Appendix 5 The Material Clauses in the Data ……… 191
(18)
xiv ABSTRACT
Lelly Sepniwati. 2014. Identity-Building Strategy in the English Advertisements in Kompas Newspaper. Yogyakarta: The Graduate Program in English Language Studies, Sanata Darma University.
Advertisements have become an integral part in the contemporary community. Their significance in asserting a certain idea is widely acknowledged, especially the consumerism ideology. In spreading this ideology, the commercial advertisements have implemented various strategies to increase the capital advantage aimed by the advertisers. Concerning the calculated framework of consumerism, there is a tendency from the producers to imply an influential effect of the brands and the products on the social value toward the community. This tendency is recognized as the identity-building strategy. In this identity representation, the common technique found and analyzed by many researches is the English utilization in the non-English speaking countries. The advertisers are prone to strengthen the English implication as the international language with the manner in which it is configured, both in the grammatical and lexical choices, in the identity-building strategy. For that matter, the problems of the study are formulated into two consisting of what types of transitivity process are typically exploited in the English clauses and what representations of social actor are applied in constructing the identity-building strategy in the
Based on the indications, this study emphasized the commercial advertisement attempts to persuade the customers to buy the product by promoting additional social and psychological benefits of the merchandise, namely identity. The data were taken from a prominent newspaper which contains many commercial advertisements, namely Kompas newspaper. There were 188 English clauses contained in 59 display advertisements from the first to fourteenth June in 2012. In analyzing these clauses, there were two methods applied in the research. The transitivity process as the initial step was conducted to examine the exploitation of the grammatical and lexical choices in proposing the appealing value of social identity in the discourse. Consecutively, the social actor representation analysis was implemented to give better understanding on how the commodities and the social community are generally depicted considering the effect they have toward each other in the identity assigning strategy.
The findings show that there are two major grammatical processes in delivering the notion of identity value. The first one is the relational process and the second one is the material process. In the relational process, the direct quality and symbolic attachment is the salient advertising cues in realizing the social values shown by the highest number of intensive clause in the process. In the material process, the notions of attitude improvement and continuous action are heavily imbued in accommodating the desired values emphasized by the largest distribution of transformative clause in the data. Furthermore, the advertisers and the advertising agencies often stress this improvement and continuous action as a result of a
(19)
xv
participant strong influences toward the other. When the action refers to the consuming act, the influence of the customers is significant in the realization. However, the focus is shifted when the depicted processes denote the providers for this improvement attitude. It shows that the ones that have greater influence in realizing the transformation attitude are the brands and the products.
Further analysis focusing on the representations of the four social actors – the narratees, brands, products, and endorser – implies that the most significant aspect in the commercial discourse is the existence of the brands and the products respectively. Moreover, the prospective purchasers are usually represented as the dependant entities that cannot be separated from the existence of the company representations if they wish to acquire the desirable profiles. It can lead to the outcome that the brands and the products are becoming the badge of the inherent identity of the social community.
(20)
xvi ABSTRAK
Lelly Sepniwati. 2014. Identity-Building Strategy in the English Advertisement in Kompas Newspaper. Yogyakarta: Program Paskasarjana Kajian Bahasa Inggris, Universitas Sanata Dharma.
Iklan telah menjadi bagian integral dalam masyarakat kontemporer. Peranan penting iklan dalam menegaskan sebuah ide khususnya ideologi konsumerisme telah diakui secara luas. Dalam menyebarkan ideologi ini, iklan komersial telah menerapkan berbagai macam strategi untuk meningkatkan keuntungan finansial yang ditargetkan oleh para pengiklan. Berkenaan dengan kerangka pemikiran konsumerisme, ada kecenderungan dari produsen untuk mengimplikasikan pentingnya pengaruh merek dan produk terhadap nilai sosial masyarakat. Kecenderungan ini dikenal sebagai strategi pembentukan identitas. Dalam penggambaran identitas ini, teknik yang umum ditemukan dan dianalisis oleh banyak penelitian adalah pemanfaatan Bahasa Inggris di negara-negara yang bahasa nasionalnya bukanlah Bahasa Inggris. Para pengiklan seringkali menguatkan implikasi dari posisi Bahasa Inggris sebagai bahasa internasional di dalam strategi pembentukan identitas dengan pemilihan tata bahasa dan kosakata yang digunakan di dalam teks. Dengan bertumpu pada wacana ini, penelitian ini memiliki dua pokok permasalahan yang terdiri dari proses transitivitas apa yang biasanya digunakan di dalam klausa Bahasa Inggris dan representasi aktor sosial apa yang digunakan dalam strategi pembentukan identitas pada iklan tertulis berbahasa Inggris.
Berdasarkan indikasi tersebut, penelitian ini memfokuskan pada bagaimana iklan komersial membujuk para konsumer untuk membeli barang yang dipromosikan dengan menawarkan keuntungan sosial dan psikologis barang tersebut, yaitu identitas. Data diambil dari sebuah surat kabar terkenal yang berisikan banyak iklan komersial, yaitu harian Kompas. Ada 188 klausa Bahasa Inggris yang terdapat dalam 59 iklan display terhitung dari tanggal satu sampai empat belas Juni 2012. Dalam menganalisis klausa-klausa ini, ada dua metode yang diterapkan di dalam penelitian. Proses transitivitas adalah metode pertama untuk menelurusi eksploitasi pemilihan tata bahasa dan kosakata dalam menyiratkan nilai menarik identitas sosial di dalam wacana. Selanjutnya, analisis representasi aktor sosial dilakukan untuk memberikan pemahaman yang lebih mendalam mengenai bagaimana komoditi dan masyarakat sosial secara umumnya digambarkan di dalam strategi pembentukan identitas dengan mempertimbangkan pengaruh yang mereka miliki terhadap satu sama lain.
Hasil analisis menunjukkan bahwa ada dua proses utama transitivitas dalam menyampaikan gagasan berkenaan dengan nilai identitas. Yang pertama adalah proses relasional, dan yang kedua adalah proses material. Dalam proses relasional, pelekatan kualitas dan simbolisasi secara langsung adalah isyarat iklan yang paling menonjol dalam mewujudkan nilai-nilai sosial terlihat dari tingginya jumlah klausa intensif. Dalam proses material, konsep peningkatan diri dan tindakan yang berkesinambungan sangatlah signifikan yang mengacu pada besarnya klausa transformatif dalam mengindikasikan nilai yang diinginkan. Selain itu, pengiklan dan
(21)
xvii
biro iklan sering menekankan sisi peningkatan diri dan aksi yang berkesinambungan ini sebagai hasil dari pengaruh kuat seorang aktor terhadap aktor lainnya. Ketika proses merujuk pada kegiatan pembelanjaan, pengaruh pelanggan sangatlah penting dalam mewujudkannya. Namun, hal ini berubah ketika proses tersebut menunjukkan penyedia jasa dalam sikap peningkatan diri. Ini menunjukkan bahwa keberadaan yang memiliki pengaruh lebih kuat dalam mewujudkan sikap transformasi diri ini adalah merek dan produk.
Analisis lebih lanjut yang berfokus pada penggambaran empat aktor sosial-narratees, merek, produk, dan endorser-menampakkan aspek yang paling signifikan dalam wacana komersial yaitu keberadaan merek yang diikuti oleh produk. Selain itu, pembeli potensial biasanya digambarkan sebagai entitas non-mandiri yang tidak dapat dipisahkan dari keberadaan representasi perusahaan jika mereka ingin mendapatkan profil yang diidamkan. Hal ini dapat mengarah pada sebuah asumsi yang menyatakan bahwa merek dan produk adalah lencana yang melekat pada identitas sosial masyarakat.
(22)
1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
In the beginning chapter of this study, the introduction of this thesis is
presented. In the background of the study, as the opening part, it elaborates the
importance of advertisements and its relation with society, a glance of the elements in
advertisements, the types of analysis which are implemented and the classification of
the study. This part is followed by the problem formulations comprised of the
research questions which are explained further in the research objectives part.
Eventually, this chapter ends with the significance of this research in some fields of
study framed in the benefits of the study.
1.1 Background of the Study
For the past few years, many countries had been affected by the global
monetary crisis which was also referred to as the Great Recession. Indonesia was one
of several countries which managed to avoid the impact of the Great Recession. In
spite of its status as a developing country, Indonesia was able to maintain its stable
economic growth compared with many European countries which had been affected
by the recession in a great extent.
Indonesia managed to decrease the impact of the global economic crisis due to
several reasons. The main contributor was consumption. Nasution in Kompas
(12/11/2012), the Governor of Bank Indonesia, stated that, although Indonesia did not
(23)
having the most stable economic growth in the world. He explained that the main
factor behind this positive condition was brought by the enormous consumption rate
from both the household and the government sectors followed by the export and
foreign investment sectors. This positive economic condition makes Indonesia one of
the prominent marketing industries in the world.
In line with the marketing notion, it has been widely known that in order to
make the product purchased by the consumers in a great quantity and continuously,
there must be a well-developed marketing strategy to realize it. One of the most
common applications is the usage of advertising. With creative words and layouts
suitable with the context, advertisements have an ability to penetrate the mind of
society in accepting certain kind of messages which are implied in them. Hence, it is
not an understatement that advertisements are considered as one of the most powerful
devices in manipulating the subconscious realm of the audience. Simultaneously,
advertisements grow considerably in intense amount recently in Indonesia.
Advertisement is a well-known phenomenon in the global society. It is hardly
possible to avoid this type of text. It appears every time and everywhere in everyday
life. When someone rides motorcycle in the road, he or she will pass one or more
billboards along the way. For someone who loves watching television, he or she will
be exposed to an abundance of audio visual advertisements. Furthermore, it is
common to find advertisements in every kind of newspapers and magazines read by
all levels of social groups. In fact, the internet, which is regarded as the latest media
that has just emerged from the last two decades, contains advertisements in such a
(24)
Due to its main purpose, advertisements, namely commercial advertisement,
ooze with the ideology of consumerism. This ideology is imbued in advertisements
by exploiting the desires, feelings, and needs possessed by an individual (Goatly,
2000). The copywriters utilize this exploitation by offering positive values of the
products or services toward the readerships. In other words, they sell them by
entrancing the readerships of the significant benefits they can gain in their daily life.
In offering these benefits, advertisement uses different strategies deemed to be
appropriate in the respectable context of the target market. Those strategies can be in
the form of informative content, influencing approaches, emotive appeal, and brand
exposure (Armstrong, 2010). Thus, to fully grasp the situation and condition of the
prospective buyers, the advertisers from transnational and international companies
usually employ some market researchers to recognise or create fresh methods of
consumption (Goatly, 2000). Afterwards, the findings of the researches will be
utilized to segment the market according to numerous specialised niches which are
fragmented based on the income level, age, household type and locality. This strategy
is able to guide the change of culture rapidly and enable the development of modern
consumer capitalism encouraged by the powerful economic groups in the society.
One of significant techniques employed in this era is the use of the lingua
franca of advertisements which is English. It is not unusual to find English use in
some parts or entire part of an advertisement, though Indonesia is not an English
speaking country. Regarding the communicative aspect of advertising which is to
inform and persuade consumers to buy a product (Bhatia, 2006), it can be an
(25)
even literate in English. Such techniques should not be applied by the advertisers as it
is very ineffective for the financial purpose. Nevertheless, the reality speaks
otherwise.
There is an underlying motive which drives the robust of the English
exploitation in the domestic country. Bhatia (2006) argues that this seemingly
counter-intuitive and counter-productive advertisement actually relies on unconscious
planning by the national or international advertisers who assume that their
readerships are bilingual in English. This assumption foregrounds a conceptualization
of the global citizen reinforcing English as a prerequisite to be acknowledged as a
global citizen.
This particular phenomenon suggests that English enhances the values of the
advertised products or services. The advertisers consider English as a ―cool‖ language which has miraculous power to render the audience identity to become
―international, modern, rational, objective, ethno-cultural stereotypes, etc.,‖ (Bhatia, 2006). This identity-building propaganda is a formidable appeal of the product for it
is typically inclined by the contemporary society nowadays.
In turn, it can be concluded that language is in close affinity with identity
construction shown by the implication that English facilitates the identity
representation of the brands and products in advertisements. Thus, it guides to an
assumption that there is a pattern which is traceable from the linguistic element
blended with the commercial layout to represent the relation between the
merchandise items and the consumers for realizing the act of identity transforming
(26)
advertisement is viewed as a discourse in this study as it expresses identity
representation by means of specific sets of linguistic, visual and other semiotic
resources (Machin and van Leeuwen, 2007).
The view is grounded by the concept of discourse in the way it perceives text
as a tool that functions above the grammatical and lexical construction applications.
Fairclough (1995) argues that texts comprise of two fundamental social practices,
specifically cognition and representation of the reality, and social interaction. The
linguistic configurations are constructed by the producers to present and describe the
world based on their perspective to the others. This communication is motivated by
certain idea or principle which is designed to penetrate the mind of society. This
‗conversion‘ can also be used to strengthen their domination in the community. It is in line with the purpose of advertisement in this study which is to assert identity-
building propaganda in the context of Indonesia intended by the large industries
incorporated in the persuasive element for the benefit of monetary income.
To figure out the pattern in this social practice, there are two types of method
employed in this study. The first method is the application of Systemic Functional
Grammar proposed by Halliday (2004). This method is considered appropriate
because it sees the meaning mirrored by the functions of the structures and the
constituents of linguistic elements in a particular context as the primary concern
(Lock, 1996). The communicative aspect of the text is emphasized simultaneously
with the rules implemented in the formation of linguistic element.
In this grammatical configuration, this study utilizes transitivity process. It is
(27)
in representing the world and how they act and relate to each other (Thompson,
2004). In other words, it analyses the grammatical and lexical features contained in a
text and correlates them to reflect the idea, belief, opinion, notion, etc. in certain
context which is in line with the purpose of this study. Therefore, the manner in
which the English linguistic features configure the positive identity-building message
can be traced in the persuasive element of the advertisements.
The second method is closely related to the initial type. However, the major
interest is dedicated to the participants involved in the social activity. It is embodied
in the social actor representation introduced by van Leeuwen (2008). This method is
regarded as an important enclosure in the analysis for it uncovers the systematic
consideration on the way the main social actors are represented in relation with the
identity construction by the powerful economic groups in Indonesia.
Meanwhile, the source of data in this study is the English advertisement in
Kompas newspaper. The primary reason behind this is due to its nature in employing
static components to catch the readership interest at least for a short period of time
toward the advertisement (Paxon, 2010). Though print advertising is not as rich as
other types of advertisement which is merely realized by employing two modes of
communication, visual and verbal, the print advertising compensates it by elaborating
further details on the product or services creatively in a single frame to achieve a
great impact toward the target audience at first glance. However, the current printed
advertisements can also capture the ‗movement‘ aspect portrayed in the visual image by projecting an illusion of moving object, especially in car advertisements. Thus, it
(28)
advertisement to persuade the readerships to buy the product or use the service
presented in the newspaper advertisements in relation to the identity-building
strategy.
1.2 Problem Formulation
Based on the explanation above, the problems were formulated as follows.
1. What transitivity processes are typically exploited in the English clauses to
construct the identity-building strategy in the English printed advertisements?
2. What are the representations of social actors in constructing the identity-building
strategy in the English printed advertisements?
1.3 Research Objectives
As it has been mentioned earlier, the producers of advertisement attempt to
hypnotize the market to consume the product or service by applying identity-building
strategy in the discourse. Therefore, the objectives of this study are to find the traces
of this identity-building pattern employed in the grammatical and lexical features of
English contained in the print advertising and to reveal the social actor
representations in the aforementioned social practice. For that purpose, this study
utilizes transitivity processes and social actor analysis as the main tools which are
integrated in the context of the advertisements.
The aim of the first objective is to find the correlation of the actual reality
with the fabricated one depicted in the printed advertisements. In order to obtain the
objective, the representations of the world, such as belief, opinion, and ideology are
regarded as crucial matters to be investigated. With the help of the transitivity
(29)
general transitivity processes in motivating inherent image or personality fabrication
integrated in the commercial discourse in Indonesia.
Afterwards, it is deemed necessary to find how the cluster of people is
represented in realizing this identity transformation activity. Thus, the second
objective of this study is to uncover the social actor representational choices in the
referred social practice. It is congruent with the purpose of social actor
representational analysis for it assesses the categorization of people ingrained in the
discourse in terms of their roles and social strata in the society (Machin and van
Leeuwen, 2007). Through the incorporation between these two methods, there is an
expectation that the results of the analysis can reflect the manner in which an
aspirational identity is constructed through the spectacles of corporate institutions, so
that it can intensify the appeals of the brand toward the target market.
1.4 Research Benefits
Theoretically, this study can give contribution to the discourse analysis,
especially in the field of advertisement. It is intended to enrich the discussion of the
language of advertisements concerning the notion of identity reconstruction strategy
which is eloquently designed by the producers of advertisements.
In addition, the practical benefit of this study is to present better
understanding on the system of language use in advertisement. In this case, the way
English is used by the copywriters integrated with the context of the discourse for the
purpose to persuade the readers to consume the advertised products or promoted
services. Thus, the readers‘ awareness on the rhetorical device utilized in advertisements can be enhanced in order to make them more critical regarding the
(30)
discourse of advertisement, especially to avoid calculated manipulation of certain
(31)
10
CHAPTER II LITERATURE REVIEW
In this chapter, the review of theories applied in this study and their
applications are presented. There are several theories which become the foundation of
this study. They are the theory of advertisement, language in advertisement, discourse
analysis, transitivity, and social actor representation. The way these theories
implemented is summarized in the theoretical framework in the following part. In
addition, the related studies are also presented to show several similar studies
conducted in this field.
2.1 Advertisements
The term advertisement originally comes from a Latin word advertere which
means to direct attention into (Danesi, 2010). It refers to a public announcement for a
product promotion. Officially, according to Indonesian Advertising Council (2007),
an advertisement is a marketing communication message or public communication of
a specific product through the use of media which is funded by an established
promoter to some or whole public community. Instead of limiting the reference to
certain concrete goods or commercial merit, the term product can be further
generalised into goods, service, idea, event, and image. Therefore, advertisement
purpose can be expanded into proposing an idea or enhancing the image of particular
institution or company due to its possible effect in altering or influencing the mind of
(32)
product or service, this type of advertisement pays more attention on the effort of
increasing the good image of an institution or company or suggesting an idea toward
the audience.
However, the most common advertisement exposed to the society is a
corporate or commercial advertisement. It can be defined as a form of literacy that
has been paid for to associate meaning with brands (Myers, 2009). The group of
people responsible for the monetary expenses are the companies or the advertisers.
This monetary outcome is intended solely to gain more monetary income. In other
words, it is a text to sell goods or services of the producers for monetary purpose.
To reach the monetary benefit aim, advertisement cannot be separated from
the power of persuasion. In fact, this power is the integral part of advertisement. It is
unquestionable because advertising is a mean of a company designated to sell certain
commodities and services, propose an idea and enhance the image of an institution or
company (Danesi, 2002; Goddard, 1998). Mostly for the commercial advertisements,
it is a massive industry involving a great amount of capital in the business focused on
stimulating the ‗consumption of the goods and services advertised‘ (Paxson, 2010) toward the audience. Therefore, without the persuasive essence, any kind of form of
advertisement is meaningless resulting in a significant financial loss.
However, in the early time of advertisement, this giant business is considered
as a small scale industry. This industry started to flourish in the era of Industrial
Revolution in order to cope with the effect of the tender mechanization era which was
mass production (Brierley, 1995; Goatly, 2000; Paxson, 2010). At first, goods were
(33)
from the merchants without asking what the manufacturer was because everything
was created and crafted in a limited production manually. Most people directly
offered their services to the customers with the absence of organization or company.
This tradition drastically changed when machine was introduced in the Industrial
Revolution. Small scale production was abandoned gradually and converted into
mass production. Consequently, the manufacturers met new problem of how they
needed to sell their large quantities of product in a rapid way which occurred before
the birth of automatic devices. Thus, advertisements were the needed solution for this
matter.
Early advertisements were not as complicated as the current situation though.
They were usually created by the manufacturers of the advertised products with the
consequences of ‗little selling‘ (Paxson, 2010) because they did not possess the ability of selling charmingly though they knew their products thoroughly. The
competitors started to act aggressively in the early 1900s by seeking the help of
advertisement agencies which had been evolved from placing the advertisements to
be published into firms that exploits creative strategy and technique in the promoting
media.
2.2 Printed Advertisements
Media as a mean for the advertisement to be published has been taken into
consideration for many advertising agencies as an important strategy. The importance
of media is recognized greatly by the agencies in the form of their media departments
which are expected to develop appropriate media plan that is cost-effective consists
(34)
advertisements (Belch & Belch, 2003). They need to consider the effectiveness of the
advertisements through the use of certain media.
Nowadays, the types of media have been developed from the printed ones,
such as newspapers, brochures, etc., into the digital ones, such as internet. Hence,
these variations of media have affected the form of advertisements. It is hardly
possible to generalize the components or structures of advertisements in every media
because of different characteristics possessed by each type of media. Despite the
complexity, there is one type of advertisement which can reach the largest market,
namely the printed advertising (Danesi, 2002).
This advertisement employs static components thus it tries to compensate the
immobile elements by using various techniques for the readers to catch their interest
at least for a short period of time at the advertisement (Paxson, 2010). It tends to get
the attention by relying on the visual elements in which the photographs and
illustrations work carefully to cause the image transmits information as much as it
can without putting a heavy burden for the customers in gathering the meaning
(Paxson, 2010).
In making this type of advertisement, the creators interlace all or several
elements in the organization. Due to highly different organizations among many
advertisements, some experts construct slightly different elements contained in a print
advertisement. Armstrong (2010) defines six elements in the printed advertisements
consisted of headline, pictures, text, body text, typeface, and layout. Meanwhile,
(35)
photo or drawing, caption, copy, paragraph headings, logo, price, response device and
overall layout.
The first classification focuses on the organization of the execution of the
headline, pictures, and text. In other words, the main focus is the layout. Thus, the
structures of the headlines and text are not described in a satisfactory way which is
crucial in analyzing the third aspect of strategy—linguistics—in an advertisement (Myers, 2010). The latter classification is more detailed related to the ‗missing‘ elements. Unfortunately, many advertisements do not apply the whole elements in the
organization and the tendency of overlapping can be found in a high frequency. This
flaw may cause unnecessary complexity in the research.
Aside of the above organization, there is a classification which divides the
basic elements of the printed advertisements. These fundamental elements are
comprised of headlines, body copy, visual elements, and layout (Belch & Belch,
2003). By using this classification, the tendency of overlapping can be decreased
significantly because the rest of the elements can be part of those basic elements.
Furthermore, most of the printed advertisements apply these basic elements in their
structural domains.
Headlines as the first elements are considered as the most eye-catching tool in
an advertisement. These are the words which occupy the leading position of the
advertisement in order to draw the attention of the readership the most (Belch &
Belch, 2003). They are usually in the form of the largest font and separated from the
body copy. Though many advertisements contain one headline, it is not unusual to
(36)
larger than the body copy which is recognized as the subheads. The following
element is the main text which describes the product or service advertised referred as
the body copy. The main selling message for the product or service is the content of
this part. Hence, this element is usually known as the ―heart of the advertising
message‖ (Belch & Belch, 2003). Those linguistic aspects are usually accompanied by illustrations which are the third major component. Its function is to attract
attention which is similar to the purpose of the headlines. By utilizing this
component, the effectiveness of a printed advertisement can be enhanced. These
major components complement each other and form an effective and efficient print
advertisement if they are arranged in appropriate order. Thus, the physical
arrangement, mostly known as the layout, of these elements is deemed as the final
major component in the structural domains of a printed advertisement.
These structural domains are configured cleverly based on the creativity of the
producers. Though creativity does not have any boundary, the producers need to
consider the type of printed advertisement they intend to use. There are several types
of printed advertisement. Despite these varieties, display printed advertisement is the
most favourable marketing tool chosen by many corporations.
The reason of using display printed advertisements is based on the
consideration that the majority of advertisements are larger than the classified
advertisements for their stronger effort in catching the attention of the readerships.
They need to be more eye-catching than the classified advertisements because they
(37)
‗domain‘, they can be found throughout the newspaper and generally apply visual and
verbal device configurations (Belch and Belch, 2003).
The second consideration is related to the marketing region of the products or
services merchandised in this type. The marketers of branded products or services in
this advertisement are usually sold their merchandise or commercial act on a national
or regional level (Belch and Belch, 2003). They are designed for the purpose of
creating and maintaining demand for a company‘s product or service. Moreover, they act as a promoting device for the local retailers that stock and market the advertiser‘s
products.
Based on the indication presented above, an advertisement is constructed of
multiple layers of creative symbols in such a way in order to ‗mystify‘ the customers to consume the products. However, these ‗unrestricted‘ attempts to enthral the
prospective buyers actually need to take some salient considerations in creating this
money maker device. Therefore, the following discussion present the restrictions of
the communicative aspect that envelope the implied meaning camouflaged by the
creators of the advertisements.
2.3 Language in Advertisements
Due to the strategy and technique, advertisement is quite different with other
types of text, especially in the language aspect. An advertisement uses creative or
innovative language in order to catch the attention of the target audience (Myers,
2009). This cogitation is extremely crucial because every competitor compete with
each other to achieve the potential customers‘ attention which is the initial stage of
(38)
various attention getter elements, mostly humour, sex and emotion (Sutherland,
2008).
It should be taken into account that getting attention is merely one component
of effective advertisements. The advertisements are not considered fully effective if
the audience fails to direct their attentions toward the brands and the contained
messages (Sutherland, 2008). Furthermore, the various elements, such as verbal and
visual, in the advertisements should blend together in a perfect harmony. Therefore,
these diversities should be seen as a mosaic in which the uniqueness of each element
is presented together in an artistic way. For the audience to understand the content of
the advertisements, the elements should project coherence which can be captured
from the network of creativity by the advertising agencies (Matheson, 2005).
However, there is an additional crucial information about the elements in the
advertisements regarding with the language is the focus. Sugarman (2007: 29) states
that ―All the elements in an advertisement are primarily designed to do one thing and one thing only: get you read the first sentence of the copy.‖ Every element is
important because they constitute a single purpose in making the readers read the
copy. This statement leads to a conclusion that the copy of an advertisement is the
main selling point in the promotional text.
In constructing a creative and eloquent copy, the copywriters always try to
embed multiple aspects in the language. Though the language of advertisements is
innovative, the language itself is restricted. Every word counts to catch the attention
or pique the interest of the audience in order to become the potential buyers. The text,
(39)
the context (Myers, 2009). The copywriters should discuss the linguistic elements
contain in the advertisements with their production teams whether they are
appropriate or not with the other elements in advertisements. They also need to gain
agreement from the clients whether their advertisements can bring the intended image
of the product or services. The language must not cross the boundary of legal
regulatory constraints in particular domains. In brief, these skilled professionals
should create an advertisement under the supervision of bureaucrats and combine
those regulations in their works (Myers 2009).
Leaving aside the regulation constriction, this type of text offers a unique
characteristic of language differs from others. Myers (2009) argues that
advertisements do not have special register of their own because they usually adopt
various kinds of grammatical features or lexis contained in other genres. He explains
that, in the environment saturated with advertising, they need to make clever use of
language to stand out, to engage the reader/viewer, to be talked about and recycled in
popular culture. In turns, innovative use of language is constantly foregrounded for
the purpose and audience of advertising.
2.4 Identity-Building Strategy
Nowadays, the linguistic choices of many advertisements are prone to convey
a particular message to promote the brand or product toward the audience. The
accompanying persuasive aspect is the identity-building implication. Regarding the
commercialization of identity, it is very important to understand the term ―identity‖.
Machin and van Leeuwen (2007) present the explanation of what identity is regarding
(40)
is. It relates to the perspective on the way someone defines his or herself in the
community. The markers of identity are varied, from age, nationality, job and income
to social class and psychological aspects, such as free, fun, independent and loving
individual. These traits are salient to prove and acknowledge the existence of
someone in the world.
The global media, in this case is advertisements, have included identity notion
in their marketing strategies. They typically orient the additional prominent benefits
of the products toward various enticing modern lifestyles and identity indicating
identity crisis phenomenon in contemporary society (Goatly, 2000). In response, the
consumers are being led to chase the temporary perfect identity provoked by the
advertisements by purchasing and using the products. Thus, identity has become
accompanying merchandise promoted in the commercial discourse.
Intriguingly, the identity promoted in the advertisements can be categorized as
superficial identity. Machin and van Leeuwen (2007) remark the uniqueness by
stating that the consumers‘ identity is defined based on the lifestyle they indulge in, namely clusters of behaviours, attitudes, and consumption patterns of the prospective
buyers. They include this type of identity as ‗lifestyle‘ identity in which it relies heavily on the reflection of the attitudes, values and preferences in appearances,
namely dress, accessories, gadgets, and so on. Therefore, the promoted products are
becoming the markers of identity in contemporary society.
In order to enhance this lifestyle identity, there are various techniques
employed by the creators. One of them is English utilization in the message of the
(41)
domain, but it is also acknowledged as a powerful tool to provoke certain images of
the products (Bhatia, 2006). Bhatia (2006) remarks this identity implication by
emphasizing that English possesses influencing psycholinguistics behemoth in the
non-Anglophone countries. This essential role is proven from its immense
employment in product and brand information message contained in the
advertisement.
2.5 Discourse Analysis
From the above explanations, it is noticeable that the psychological benefits of
the products are regarded as an important persuasive tool. Hence, it needs to be
conveyed rhetorically in the advertising message. It leads to an assumption that
communication is the central point in the creative construction of advertising strategy.
Fiske (1990) gives a general definition of communication by stating that it is a social
interaction through messages. By assuming that people transmit and receive the
message, it is considered as a social practice within particular set of social value in a
community.
Because culture is distinct in nature, there are numerous disciplinary
approaches to study this cultural integrated communication. Hence, Fiske (1990)
divides them into two major schools in communication study. The first one concerns
with the production and exchange of meanings. It concentrates heavily on the role of
texts, especially on how messages or texts interact with people in the production of
meaning in the context of similar or different cultural environments. The way people
interpret the messages is the main focus in this school. Meanwhile, instead of
(42)
communication as the transmission of messages. The salient matter is on how the
senders and receivers encode and decode the messages through the channels and
media of communication. It suggests that intention is a crucial factor in deciding what
constitutes a message to affect the behaviour or state of mind of another.
Based on the above explanation, this study follows the second school which is
referred as the ‗process‘ school by Fiske. It is in line with the focus of the study
because it views advertisement as a persuasive tool to promote products by evoking
certain feelings associated with the brands to the mind of the consumers in the
identity fabrication act. Therefore, it uses discourse analysis as the approach in
investigating the process of communication in print advertising.
Discourse analysis gives the linguistic construction of a text a prominent
position in its focus of study. It views texts as devices that can influence and
contribute the changes of society (beliefs, attitudes, etc.), actions, social relations, and
the representation of the physical realm (Fairclough, 2003). Pertaining to this angle,
language is a site of ideology that shapes what speakers feel and think to the extent
that it is able to direct public‘s opinion to support the interest of certain powerful
groups (Matheson, 2005). It proposes that texts play a role on social change through
the meaning of language.
However, in discourse analysis, language does not stand alone. Every context
determines the way the text was shaped (Fairclough, 2003). It reinforces the notion
that the verbal element is greatly influenced in relation to other elements in a
particular text. Responding to this notion, Cook (1992) caters an option to analyze
(43)
include the participants and the purpose of this communicative discourse, the social
conditions of the target society, the medium of the discourse, and the way the
communication is conducted. These elements are encapsulated into eight types of
context presented as follow.
The first one is the concrete material which carries or relays text, namely the
substance or media. The second element is the non-grammatical features of the text,
such as music and pictures. The third element is the accompaniment of meaningful
behaviour of language referring to voice quality, gestures, facial expressions and
touch, and choice of typeface and letter sizes. The situation represented in the text is
also included in the context for it builds a relation between the surrounding objects
and people realized in the text as perceived by the participants. The text which
precedes or follows the analyzed text – co-text – is also considered as a part of the context if it is perceived as belonging to the same discourse. Intertext — mentioned by Myers (2009) in the preceding section – is included as a factor to be investigated in relation with context because, usually, there is a certain text associated with the
text under consideration that affects the interpretation though it belongs to other
discourse.
The seventh element is slightly different from the erstwhile elements because
it suggests the inclusion and exclusion roles simultaneously in the realm of discourse.
It is the participants involved in the text. Cook (1992) remarks that participants
involve their intentions and interpretations, knowledge and beliefs, interpersonal
attitudes, affiliations and feelings. Each of them simultaneously plays an inherent part
(44)
text. However, they can also be the outsiders of the discourse because the
interpretation of the meaning making process is devoted to them. Thus, they are
assigned double roles in the advertising discourse, as a part of the context and an
observer of it.
These aforementioned elements are organized in a clever way to communicate
the messages of advertisement. This act of communication is guided by the final
element of the context, the function. Based on Fiske‘s (1990) argumentation, the
function can be defined into the intention of the producer or the interpretation by the
consumers of the discourse. Either way, the analysis on advertisement discourse
needs to correlate the text and context implications utilized by the advertisers.
Regarding the function of the context, this study focuses greatly on the
intention of the producers, especially on their attempts to persuade and influence the
behaviour and mind of the targeted consumers. Hence, the participants as the ones
who play an integral part of the context as well as the receiver of the messages are the
main features in the analysis.
In order to investigate represented participants in print advertising, this study
uses two steps of analyzing method. The first one is the transitivity processes in
Systemic Functional Grammar by Halliday (2004). Then, the social actor
representation analysis proposed by Leeuwen (2008) is conducted to find out the
significance of the investigated participants in the imposing social values by the
advertisers exploited in the strategy of advertising. These methods are presented in
(45)
2.6 Transitivity Processes
As it has been mentioned previously, the language of advertisement is creative
which is established on the ground of consumerism ideology. Ergo, the analysis
focuses on the rules of the linguistic device solely cannot grip the stimulating idea
behind the English linguistic system constructed by the copywriters through the
Indonesia advertisements. Indeed, the grammatical and lexical configurations are the
fundamental requirements in enacting the social practice. However, if the analysis
implements the approach focusing on the linguistic construction forms without taking
into account the context of the unfolding activity, it may cause a misrepresentation of
the human communication complexity (Cook, 1992). On the other hand, by
conducting systemic functional grammar as the analysis tool, the functions of each
element can be investigated thoroughly in the respective contexts.
In order to analyze the grammatical construction and vocabulary choice
conducted by the copywriters to associate the products with eminence social values in
print advertising, transitivity system is considered an appropriate tool in this study
instead of the mood and thematic systems. It entails the main concern of the
transitivity system which is to allow the description of the representations of the
social world to be assessed through the clause as well as configures the significant
relation among the process, participants, and circumstances involved in the clause
(Halliday, 2004). From this perspective, language is composed of different entities in
the world which possess particular action toward the others and description of the
(46)
2.6.1 The Processes and Participants
In this system, meaning is established toward the process involved in a clause.
The focal point is that a clause consists of process or a flow of events (Halliday,
2004). The continuous flow of event with its variation experienced and intended by
the writers is captured and transferred into a clause. Simultaneously, the process
affects the choice of grammar and vocabulary in a clause by determining the way it
encodes an experience of the real world into the realm of language system
(Thompson, 2004).
Basically, there are two distinguished classes of process types, the process of
the external world (outer experience) and the process of consciousness (inner
experience). Halliday (2004) describes the grammatical categories for these
experiences as material process clauses and mental process clauses. However, in order to construct a coherent theory of experience, there is an additional component
in the system which is relational process clauses that signify relation of one fragment of experience toward another for the purpose of identifying and classifying. Aside
those three main components, there is a component which shares the characteristics
of both material and mental process clauses indicated as behavioural processes that represent the outer demonstration of inner workings, consciousness and
psychological states processes. The fifth category of process which identifies the
symbolic relationships in the human consciousness resulted in the form of
language—having the characteristics of mental and relational categories—is construed as verbal processes. Finally, existential process is included in the process type which is situated between the relational and material processes as the process
(47)
related to existence. The components of each process type are summarized in Table
2.1 below.
Table 2.1 The characteristics of process types (Halliday, 2004: 260)
Process type Category
meaning Participants, directly involved Participants, obliquely involved material: action event 'doing' 'doing' 'happening'
Actor, Goal Recipient, Client; Scope; Initiator; Attribute
behavioural 'behaving' Behaver Behaviour
mental: perception cognition desideration emotion 'sensing' ‗seeing' 'thinking' ‗wanting‘ ‗feeling‘ Senser, Phenomenon
verbal 'saying' Sayer, Target Receiver, Verbiage relational: attribution identification ‗being‘ 'attributing' 'identifying' Carrier, Attribute Token, Value Attributor, Beneficiary, Assigner
existential 'existing' Existent
2.6.1.1 Material clauses: processes of doing-and-happening
The first primary system in the process type that defines the outer experience
is the material clauses. It accounts for a quantum of change in processes of happening
through the expense of energy (Halliday, 2004). The focus in this process is the
concrete changes happening in the participants resulted from the action.
Consequently, these processes involve concrete and tangible actions (Eggins, 2004).
The actions are done by an entity which may be directed toward other entities.
The active participant that contributes the energy in the action is recognized as the
Actor. Thus, it indicates that this participant is an inherent participant that takes the action of changing which leads to a different outcome of the initial phase of the
(48)
action can be extended is the Goal (Halliday, 2004). Therefore, the Goal does not always appear in this process type which makes it an oblique participant.
Related to the two participants, there are two types of clauses which address
the issue of the one in which the outcome is registered to. The process which
indicates the confinement of the outcome of the process to the Actor is intransitive
clause which represents a ―happening‖ process (Halliday, 2004). It stresses that ‗an
entity does something‘, thus, it does not require the existence of the Goal. It is usually
proven by asking what did x do? probe. The type of process which includes the Goal
participant is called transitive clause which represents a ―doing‖ which can be probed by a question, ―what did x do to y?‖ (Halliday, 2004). Hence, the outcome is
registered on the Goal. For instance, ―the lion sprang (Halliday, 2004)‖ indicates a happening or intransitive clause in which it implies that the Actor or the lion did the
action of sprang. The outcome of the action is confined to the Actor itself which is
the inherent participant. On the other hand, in ―the lion caught the tourist‖ (Halliday, 2004), the Actor did something to the other participant which is the Goal or the
tourist. Hence, the Goal undergoes the outcome of the process which indicates a
doing or transitive clause.
Regarding the final phase of the unfolding process in one of the participants in
the clause, there are additional subtypes which are deemed important to be discussed.
Halliday (2004) presents two subtypes to distinguish the nature of the outcome. The
first one is creative clause which implies that the Actor or the Goal comes into
existence as the result of the process conducted. Ergo, the outcome of the process is
(49)
(Thompson, 2004).‖ The Goal or the Christmas pudding is brought into existence through the process conducted by the Actor. The second subtype is transformative
clause which brings the notion of different final phase condition of the initial one of
the participant. Instead of coming into existence, the participant undergoes changing
which is the effect of the process. It should be noted that the participant has already
existed before the action is conducted. However, Halliday (2004) argues that it can
also suggest maintaining the condition of initial phase of the participant because it
still has a connection with the condition of the existing participant. For example, ―My
mum never eats Christmas pudding (Thompson, 2004).‖ The sentence implies that my mum or Christmas pudding has already existed before the action. Consequently, it
indicates that the outcome of the process is to maintain the condition of the
participant of never consuming the dessert.
Aside of the inherent participants, there are also oblique participants that
contribute significant meaning in the clause. The roles included in the system are
Beneficiary and Scope. The Beneficiary participant includes the one which gains benefits from the process. In traditional grammar, it is recognized as the indirect
object which can be realized with or without preposition depends on its position
whether it precedes or follows the Goal (Thompson, 2004). The Scope, as the term
indicated, is an independent entity in the process which signifies the domain of the
existed process. It is highly restricted to intransitive clause in which it follows the
verb. Consequently, it can cause confusion whether it should be interpreted as a
Scope or a Goal. Hence, in order to highlight the differences, Halliday (2004)
(50)
Scope does not receive any effect performed by the process, (ii) the Scope can act as
the actual process in the clause, (iii) it cannot be probed by do to or do with question,
(iv) it cannot be followed by a resultative Attribute (a resultant qualitative state of the
Actor or the Goal of a completed process), (v) it is regulated to the participant of
non-personal pronoun, and (vi) possessive modification cannot be implemented in this
element.
2.6.1.2 Mental clauses: processes of sensing
In contrast with the previous clause, the Mental processes possess a focal
point toward the inner experience as the term itself refer to. Its major concern is the
quantum of change in the experience or process in the realm of consciousness
(Halliday, 2004). The focus is on the working of the inner self of a conscious being
on the surrounding event, belief, entity, and so on. Hence, the effect is mainly
directed at the participant who conducts the process himself rather than other
participant mentioned in the clause or something triggers the working of
consciousness of someone which marks the contrast with the material process.
In this process, there are usually two inherent participants involved. The first
participant is the Senser which is always recognized as human-like entity that bears the consciousness characteristic (Halliday, 2004). It is a highly isolated role which is
occupied by an entity that is acknowledged to possess abilities of feeling, thinking,
wanting or perceiving. This role is followed by the Phenomenon as the element that the process of consciousness is being reflected (Halliday, 2004). It denotes the
participant which is being projected to be felt, thought, wanted or perceived. These
(1)
194
Ad47C149
[Circ: location] right here, right now… step [Circ: location] into your new urban lifestyle
intransitive transformative
Ad47C150 choose [Goal] the right Avenue transitive transformative Ad48C153 to choose from intransitive transformative Ad48C154 light up [Goal] your home [Circ:
manner] with Plaza Crystal transitive transformative Ad49C155 [Actor] your future starts [Circ: manner]
with us intransitive creative
Ad50C159
[Actor] the real excitements that takes [Goal] you [Circ: extent] to wherever [Actor] your mind goes
transitive /
intransitive transformative Ad52C162 ride [Goal] your wishes transitive transformative
Ad53C166
[Actor] a Santika Hotel waiting for [Goal] you [Circ: Extent] no matter where [Actor] you choose to roam
transitive transformative
Ad53C167
[Actor] every Santika Hotel offers [Goal] the same winning combination of traditional designs and service that comes from the heart
transitive transformative
Ad53C168
[Circ: extent] wherever [Actor] your leisure or business travel may lead [Goal] you, [Actor] you will find [Goal] Santika Indonesia Hotels and Resorts [Circ: manner] at your service
transitive transformative
Ad54C170 share [Goal] the fun [Circ: location] at
J.Co transitive transformative Ad55C172 [Actor] a pleasant surprise is waiting
for [Goal] you transitive transformative Ad55C177 [Actor] that carries [Goal] our heritage transitive transformative
Ad55C179
[Actor] that delivers [Goal] uncompromised handling and performance
transitive transformative
Ad56C181 get [Goal] spectacular holiday [Circ:
accompaniment] with fantastic offer transitive transformative Ad57C182 unleash [Goal] your potential transitive creative Ad57C184 [Goal] who to call intransitive transformative
(2)
195
Appendix 6: The Distribution of the Social Actor Representation Data in the Data
Label descriptions: Social actors: 1. N : Narratee 2. B :Brand 3. P : Product 4. E : Endorser
Representational choices: 1. S : Suppressed
2. B : Backgrounded 3. I : Included 4. Act : Activated 5. Pas : Passivated 6. P : Personalized 7. A : Abstracted 8. Sp : Spatialized 9. In : Instrumentalized 10.So : Somatized
Code Representational Choice
S B I Act Pas P A Sp In So
Ad1C1 NBP BP BP BP
Ad2C2 N
Ad2C3 BP N NBP N BP BP Ad2C4 N BP B NBP B NBP Ad3C5 N BP
Ad3C6 N BP
Ad3C7 E E E
Ad3C8 N BP Ad3C9 N BP Ad4C10 N BP
Ad4C11 N BP BP BP
Ad4C12 N BP B BP BP BP BP BP Ad4C13 N BP B BP BP BP BP BP Ad5C14 N BP BP BP BP Ad6C15 NBP N N N
Ad6C16 NB NP N NBP N NBP
Ad6C17 NBP N N
(3)
196
Ad6C19 NBP
Ad6C20 B B B B B
Ad7C21 NBP N N NP N P N
Ad7C22 B B B B
Ad7C23 N N N N
Ad7C24 N B B B Ad7C25 NP B B B
Ad7C26 BP B P B BP
Ad8C27 NBP BP BP
Ad8C28 B B B B
Ad8C29 B B B B
Ad8C30 NBP Ad8C31 NBP
Ad9C32 BP BP BP
Ad9C33 BP BP BP BP BP
Ad10C34 BP P P P
Ad10C35 NBP N N NBP N NBP
Ad10C36 BP NBP NB BP N BP BP Ad10C37 NBP N N N N N Ad10C38 BP BP BP BP BP Ad11C39 B
Ad11C40 BP
Ad11C41 BP P P P P P Ad11C42 BP P P P P P
Ad11C43 B P P P P
Ad12C44 BP BP BP BP
Ad12C45 N N N N N N Ad12C46 BP N NBP N BP Ad12C47 BP
Ad13C48 BP
Ad13C49 NBP NBP NBP Ad13C50 B
Ad14C51 NB B B B
Ad15C52 NBP NBP NBP Ad15C53 B P P P
Ad16C54 NB N N N N N
Ad16C55 BP B BP BP BP
Ad16C56 NBP BP BP
Ad17C57 BPE E E E Ad17C58 BPE
Ad18C59 NB Ad18C60 N
Ad18C61 NBP P P P P
(4)
Ad19C62 N
Ad19C63 B B B B Ad20C64 B N N N
Ad20C65 NB BP B BP B BP Ad20C66 NB NB N NB N
Ad20C67 BP BP B BP BP BP Ad20C68 P NBP B NP NB P P Ad21C69 NBP NBP NBP NBP NBP Ad21C70 NB B NB B N
Ad21C71 NB NB NB
Ad22C72 NB N N N N N N Ad22C73 BP BP B BP BP P Ad22C74 BP
Ad22C75 B P P P
Ad22C76 NBP B BP NBP NB NBP BP Ad23C77 B
Ad23C78 BP P P P P
Ad23C79 N BP BP BP BP Ad24C80 NBP
Ad24C81 NBP NBP NBP NBP NBP NBP
Ad25C82 N B B B
Ad26C83 NB
Ad26C84 B B B B B
Ad27C85 NP P P
Ad27C86 NP P P P
Ad27C87 NP P P
Ad27C88 NB NP NP N NP P Ad28C89 NB B N N B Ad29C90 NBP N N NBP N NBP Ad29C91 N NB NB N NB B Ad30C92 NB
Ad30C93 BP BP BP P BP BP Ad30C94 BP BP BP
Ad30C95 NB NBP NB NBP N NB BP Ad31C96 NBP
Ad31C97 BP P P BP P B Ad31C98 N
Ad31C99 N BP BP BP Ad32C100 B
Ad33C101 N N N
Ad33C102 NB
Ad34C103 N P B B P BP Ad35C104 BP BP B BP BP
(5)
198
Ad35C105 P B BP P BP Ad35C106 BP P BP BP
Ad35C107 N N N N
Ad36C108
Ad36C109 NBP BP NP NBP Ad37C110 BP
Ad37C111 BP Ad37C112 N
Ad37C113 NBP BP BP
Ad37C114 B P P P
Ad38C115 NBP
Ad38C116 BP BP BP BP
Ad38C117 BP P P P P
Ad38C118 NBP N N NP N NP P Ad38C119 BP N N BP N BP
Ad39C120 NB
Ad39C121 NBP NBP NB NBP N NBP Ad39C122 NBP BP BP
Ad40C123 B B B B
Ad40C124 NB B B
Ad40C125 BP BP B BP BP Ad41C126 NBP N N N
Ad42C127 BP BP B BP BP BP Ad42C128 BP B BP BP BP BP Ad42C129 BP BP B BP BP P
Ad43C130 B B B B
Ad43C131 B
Ad43C132 N B B B
Ad43C133 NBP N N N N N
Ad43C134 NBP N N
Ad43C135 BP BP BP
Ad43C136 BP N N NBP NBP NBP
Ad44C137 NB N N
Ad44C138 BP P P
Ad44C139 BP B BP BP BP Ad44C140 BP BP BP BP BP BP Ad44C141 BP NP P N N P P Ad44C142 NBP BP BP BP BP Ad44C143 NP B B BP BP Ad44C144 NP B B BP BP Ad45C145 BP BP BP BP BP
Ad46C146 BP BP B BP BP BP Ad46C147 P B B P B P
(6)
Ad46C148 NB B B B B
Ad47C149 NB N N NB N NB Ad47C150 NB B B B B
Ad47C151 B B B B
Ad48C152 B P P P P
Ad48C153 NBP
Ad48C154 N NB NB N N NB Ad49C155 NB N NB N NB N
Ad49C156 NB B B B
Ad50C157 NBP NP N NP N NP
Ad50C158 B B B B
Ad50C159 NBP N NP N N NP
Ad51C160 B B B B B
Ad52C161 B B B B
Ad52C162 NBP N N NP N NP Ad53C163 B
Ad53C164 BP P P P P
Ad53C165 BP BP BP
Ad53C166 NBP NBP N N BP
Ad53C167 BP BP BP
Ad53C168 NB NB NB NB N NB B Ad53C169 B B B B B
Ad54C170 N BP B BP BP BP
Ad55C171 BP BP BP
Ad55C172 BP N BP N N BP Ad55C173 B BP B BP BP
Ad55C174 BP NBP BP NBP N BP BP Ad55C175 BP BP BP BP BP Ad55C176 BP BP BP BP BP Ad55C177 BP B BP B BP
Ad55C178 BP N N P N P Ad55C179 BP BP BP BP Ad55C180 BP BP B BP BP Ad56C181 NBP B P BP Ad57C182 NB N NB N N NB Ad57C183 B N N B N B
Ad57C184 NB B B
Ad58C185 N BP Ad58C186 N BP
Ad59C187 E E E