The Dynamics of Thailands Public Policy (1)

!"
# $%

&' (") $* )

+

#*

"

",-."/0123456"78",-24921:;6"945"2645"?:=52@471"21:"4@6"2:2A@2@471"@7""
BC?BD"E733=14@0("E715.A@"21:"/012345"?F79=@4712G0

!

"

# $

% & '"

@A

B A C

(

) (

*+,-./0 12324546789:,-./;

?

'F @A G ! 2 & = A > & C#
' '
@

F '

A

JN

5KOJ N

G!

G ! & =A 6

I A

)
H

A

& =A 5 I A

!& (

(D AF '

&( ; ;5J6S

?

"

A& (( &AB A '

( A
"
$H H $I(

F

L5M & A ; ;

>

; ;5J6S N & Q

G ! & =A 5 EA H
A&A

T C

)

'#

T

G!

G ! & =A 2 EA H
A& ( (# I '

B ! '@ &( E
C

G! (

F ( L2M & Q #R ) ' @ N 6K

A& ( (#

A L ; ; 5JJ5 N 5JS6M

@

EA(

J >

&D L6M &

( I ' LKM & A 6K

I L ; ;5JK5+5JJ6M

G!

#B= & = AI F ( @
P & B !'

A

; ;5JK4

B= D= " B A

# H K &#

& A ; ;5KOJ

& Q #R ) ' @

'#

B= D= " T '@ &( E

A& (

5
B>6@G25@"
U8.1 -V:. & F

>

A A&( '@ )
' @

$ # '
$

( =A

•

' '

I ' >

(D

5K (€

; ;

# C

# F ") ( !

D

& ( #ƒ

H "

A

; J2JM F t ; ;5KOj #(

#( D

A

@ C# (A

'€(
F

A

#

D= " y & A& F &

(D A >

#

G

C# >

#

AIP

F

'

( ' ( AB=

(D A #

F@
6 t

D >

") ( !
VOMLM`P" T$ ] *^"
y

A

A

>& B A F ' ' G

= &D A

• (

y & A&

("

;

#I A

?

•

'# () ( (€A

() (

' S2 & &!

( F @ A = (B=

' O3 L # #

H @ =

'@

(

Q #R

(

(D t ; ;5J42
; 5O5M (

=A |

# '#

H

AP F y F t ; ;5J4J >

B A

'#

' A T
C

A

& AI '
I A@

I ' #(

TB T

Q #R #F@

"

F@IP
B

# (B= !A(

Q #R ) ' @ L6S

I '& 'T I T 5JJ5T

K t H O t ; ;5J42 '
'€(

(

; ;5J44 "

#A

?

! A& (C#

6O

B= D= "

T B T

K '# #I

'>

(

&( ; ;5J4SM F

A D
AL

# _"Y" ! "LZ" T $%" M MOXLa"

> " '

; ;5KJ6 N j )

(
A

S '

T 5JJ4T

C# F

C

AI 'I

C

L A

( L ; ;5KO3M (

(€

#

B A"

I A@ I 'IP ?

& AB A '

)B= D= " B A

'€(

(D A ( '

# H I

I A'

(

# "_

ƒ(& ( > & ( B= C#
F IP

# >

A ƒ( I
& F

C
I A@

ƒ&D & '

T$ ] *^"

B A " F ") ( ! I '&> I€ A C

C# F IP

Au I

" M MOZ[X"\" !

& A C

C

= A# >
I A@

$

A@

)

@' >

&! P

I T 5JJST ; J6KM

( B A (

;

! A& (

3
F @ A A& (C & =A 5 > F
) ' @ A #(

} #(

Q #R A #
?

'

'@

'@ @

B= D= "

Q #R ) ' @ €AI
I 'y

( #( '

I

IP

I A@

(

j)

A#
A

"

A@#

I A'

; ;€ (

O t I ' '# () (

Q #R (

A&A

H '

>&

IP

I A@

( r

O0205

J t C#

t ; ;5J2J ƒ A&A # '

'

#

L '!

; ;5J54 =

AB= F

' ##
! A (B=
& ( >&
•
BA '

A

F@IP

#

'

t ; ;5J2J

F

# (

> A ?

=A

(

"(

ƒ

I A@

F@ ! &D

!& (

(

B= D= "

65 t # H

B A

'€(

&( ; ;5J63 C#

A H

D

A

T 5JJ4T ; 5jSM

€A

(

P!F

H & =A I L

' I #A€A ?

@A

F

; ;5J52 #

B A

@

#

'# () (I ' '#

(C

A
!

H (
B A@

T 5JKKT ; 54h A

; ;5J54 A #

#

T 5JJ4T ; JK5M

AS

F

#

B '

( )

B=
! A B= (
IP

C I ') & C ( # '@( '# C

F t ; ;5J22 I ' ƒ
F

( (D

I A@ • €#( &D •

(D A (

L@

A&D I &#F ( A&

A@

D

I A@ • F ( (
=A '

B AIP • #A

L5JJST ;J2KM & '

A D A
D

'

S0202 C# F IP

I A@

>

' >

B= D= "

*S" M MOXZb"
) '#

; 3+64M (D €A t ; ;5J52

A

(

>I A

' ) T 5JKJT ; Sh A

#

'F IP

( I AT 5JKKT

#

@ I ' ?

( €A ' '

(D AI ' ? ) ( H

= D=

B

F B ' IP

'C @ I

!'

# & (( &AB A '

& (( &A A

!& (

H

F ( BA ( € ( | ( B A C

C# F t ; ;5J54 #(
#(

I ' AB

D ?

VOMLMZP" $T "LZ" T " M MOXLa"Y" T$ * ]
& 6K
&( ; ;5J6S
B A C
I A

T 5JKjT ; JJM F & Q #R

& ' G B AB

A H

( B A (
; ;5J42

(

&( ; ;5J4S

(

A

@ @ AF ( B I

A@#I A( =AI

(

& F ( D

( !AB= L '

F '# y!(y &#

I

F

F

BAy I# ( A

B= D= " &
"

#

H

| (

" B A '

D A

64
!F @ A

C

& ( H

A # ƒ @ F

'
'

'

A

=A = L& '

C

(

'

P # $ (
; ;5JK4 #(

F@ ") ( !
)

I

5JK5 I ' ( F ( "

@

@
)

' @
>

A

'

A

A(

A(
F

I '(

'

@

B

' @

' H

A&

( ' )y

"

G!
F@ ' @

AB A
I A@
#I
$'

& !I ' &&

A

; ;5JK5

A(

=

A #(

>

G ! & !I ' &

@
; ;5JKO

' @ Q $

(

>

'
A

>

A

' #ƒ & ( > ƒ

; ;5JK5
A

A

L

;M >

A

A €

G!
G!

# =A

C& A

( )

L ( ;M I ' ((
A

' @

'

G H ! ) (

; ;

; ;5JK4 N 6O

#

(I

A
€A t

'

#IP I 'B=

#

y

P # I &#I '

>

( @

>

( B=
! I

(F

' I '

BA

F & ( >&

; ;5JKK (

' @

A (

#

#

& =A 5 L3 Q

; ;5JKS

(

A I ((

B A > &

" I ' '( & y

' # >F
y&

"(

; ;5JJ4 A
A

!

A

H

; ;5JK5 ' @
# =A >

A

A

)

y & ! ; ;5JKS

>

; 62jM I '(& (

G $ (

!

F & = #C A !

; ;5JK4 I ' t ; ;5JK5 #(

; ;5JKS ' @

G!

'

| (

y

I ' ") ( ! I A @
F

(I

A

(

) " M MOXZO"Y"OXXL"
H P(
' F@ ' @
=

) ; ;5JKKM F & =
A

( ' )y

y I 'C

G!

'

I '(

D F@ H I( F

Q*

'

I '

D AT 5JKKT

'

I A@ EA '
OMOP"

#F t ; ;5JK4

A&A ( !

I A@

> A ?

I A

H

& L ( (

&#

L ) @ =( ' "T 5JJ6T ; 566M I F

" & =A

T 5JK5T ;2M C# y

A& (( &AF

€A 66•

( '

Q

A B A '

(y

" B

(F ( D

# ƒ P@
y F

; ;5J25

EA #
A ƒ( ! I

!

B= D= "
F

H ! ) (

H @ @ @= !A
G!

66
I

>&

#I

? P!

( ' )y
G! '

A

L>
B= D= "

A

'

A& ( (#
t P ( C# I

3
(

( =A '

A
L >

D
B)

#B

r

A & ( ((D

y&

H P!I #A

( ' )y

#

(C
D

#

P
'@( (D

A EA >

#

t ; ;5JS6 ' A(
"(

z&
G!

#

5JJ5 > F (& ' (

P

P I ' ?

r

G!

5& ' D B & D

' '

#@
!

= I F

A H

A"

AP F

#

G!

A"
A(

G!

>&
I

G!

ƒ @ B

#B= y

G!

A(& y { I ' >
F

#
'

A =

A H '

I '

@ T 5JJJM

G!
!

I '
B & D

H

" M M"OXXO"\"OXaL"
)B A
G!

#

=A A H A

A A& ( ( €
=A

6j A &( 5JJ5 ((

x

I '#

I ' A

I AF#u

G!

#

#

P

(F@I& I #A
'W

F &

&

I '

$ (

) ? I ' (

A L ; ; 5JJ5 + 5JS6M

& ' "(

A

? & y P!

A
#

D

ƒ A&A( r

#I #

#

C# ( #(

Q*

F

C

I

B A C# • '

# '

r

G! $ (

6j A &( 5JJ5 #

3 #

Au

(

A&A

>

'@(

D

A L ; ; 5JJ5 + 5JS6M ((

r

Lo& F

(

#

(
H

& y P!

! I ' L2M A (

#B=

)

&D L6M ? & y I '(

I '

L >

') I ' L5M & '

D

? & y

@A

A

H

#K D A

>

B= D= " #A =
D AI
' 'I C#

#( >
(

CA

'€(

5JJ2 ' @
'#

D A

B AP!

'

A

A
)

63Ox5JJS A

&

F r

!

#
A H

> A&& ( !F
ƒ# (D #D

(y

2F ( "

A

J (y

>F

?

>

I€ A

" y

( €#>

#C# ( ' )y

B D=

H

K5 B

B D=
D

?

#

# >

!

B=

A

B= D= "

; ;5JKK •

H

A€ B ( F@

A ƒ(

#& A & (

@

) ; ;5JJS D AI A =A& '

G! I '

( t ; ;

! I

A

D F

6OJ B

• I B ( (#A

) ; ;5JJS

I A@

I

F

( = A (# 55J B

BA ' @

; ;5JKK I ' ( #(
A ; ;5JJ6 C# #(

>
() (

( H D=

G!

# =A B D=

!#

# B D=

H (

AP

B(

2M ; ;5JJ2 # ' F (

AP F

( 6j2 B

& A ( B=

B= D= " (

I '() (

I '() (

'€(

A

(

I A@ L•

'€(

D= "

A & '

F '#
(

A

"(

# A (F &> A '
(

G!
B= D= "

I A =A &&

A

!

)
B= D= "

( C
H & '

B A"
(

(5& '

62
'

# & '

'

A

(

)

>

H

#

')

G!

(

& '

y @ AC

; ;5JK5
F

F

H

(

G!

A&A A

P!

H !

=A '

(

# EA I '

(

B= D= "

G!

"(

B= D= " F ( =A '
D A

!

! I ' >
'

A

!

'

B= D= " C# (

)

H

')

I A A@

#

( >

A D

D

A

!

B AC

# F

H > & C#

' H

C# ( "(

' @
H

G! '

F '

'

I '

(

)
DA

G ! & !I ' &

A( ? A& !I '(F
P & !F #& #&
B A @ @ C# >
? F
& (

#

H & !C# €D
#>

@

B= D= "
=> I

€A

r

(

A>

H

" I '

P &!

H >&

P & !I F (
(

' ? & !F (

? & ! F (& ( B(IBƒ A#
F K D A

A& (
'

#F

( A

B €# M
#A
r

G!
B #& ! F

!

&D

P!

G!

? ? L5JJJT ; 2M @=

& (

(

! A

& r

A ( !
&

A

(F

A A&A P@
#I

@ @ @= !A

A (

#A

?

B A EAC# y

B= D= " F & = ƒ&D A&A H D AB A

(# I ' A ( €A& (

'

P!

&!

F # AB=

'#

t ; ;5JJj # L ' #

'#
I '

G ! K#
!

A

)

I ' y G"

A

!

A ƒ# I( ' #
C

G

H P! '

( '#

? & !I 'P!

BA

? & !F

@ @ & ! =A

F

( ' >

!

'

A(

H & !(D

A

AC& A
A B

' & y

D

G (B A
A
A
A& (

Ay '(

& ! €!

B A (

IP

=A

& ( F

@

F @A C
A

F A&(
A

' #B= F
G!

I '& y

C

A& (

B ! '@ &( E
A ƒ# G ) ( #

(

(

A C& A

F • '

A
(

)

6K
OMZP"

N

F

"

B !

>& F

H

B &D I '

'@ &( E

(

(D A D

P > ƒ y F t ; ;5JJj y F &> B

=

(

!

H

#

-YZ iW &
I'

& ( ((D

E #
I B A

#>

C# F

E (

F @AC& A

E

D B

= A A€D

F G

H

ƒ

P

AF

ƒ#

A& ( > &

# IP A
>

'@ @

>

'@ &(

E

( € B €AC

E
F

? #

B €A &C C

#I & ( ((D
?

?
A#

(
H
=A E

@

A D F & ( ((D F #

I '

D #@ A A

? EA '
?

AB A& ( ((D • '# B A
(D (

#

oi*op ‘WV,-YWY: s9,,.::WW 9Y i9 N

A # '
F

#

#

(

'@( # # E

# =A A

A# ƒ @

A F

Au # ( #

BB A E

B AI ' B )

IP J tB A

E

#

#

B= D= " F D A = F zC& A

5JJK

ƒ &D

(

A >

& !I ' €
! '@ &( E

B A €

E

y

g]^^WV i

E

E #

E & =AI &!B

'

A '@ &( E F 2
=

CA

'@( "(

56+52 ( &( ; ;5JK3

I 'I A r { L

> y

& ( ((D

E
E C# =A

#

C# !
( D

G!
B= D= "

(A !

6S
'W"L I #A ?

@A
+

Q* $
&

#*

"'W L"V % #

G! ( @

& A ; ;5KOJ N

"'W O"V

""" & ") ( !
;

& Q #R ) ' @
D

F (

&( ; ;5J6S
D
"

I A@

(D AF '
?

; ;5JK4

!& (

(

D & (( &AB A '

) " M MOXZO"\"OXXLP"
;

A

"

; ;5JK5T
D

A& ( (#

D

A& ( (# I '

; ;5JK5 I B ( ( ; ;5JKJT

"'W `"V

& ") ( !

; ;5JKK
Q*

A

A ; ;5JJ6
" M MOXXL"\"OXaLP" "
'W

; ;5JJ4T

I B ( ( ; ;5JJ2T
!F '

"
@

B= D= "
Q* $

"

D ? & B !'

; ;5JK4T

!

B= D= "
c U%

"'W XP"

Q*

I A@

C

"

&( ; ;5J6S N Q

Q* $

'>& BA | (

J N ; ;5KOJ

& Q #R ) ' @ N 6K
& A 6K

I'

;
!

I A@

; ;5JK5

B= D= "

; ;5JKK

( A

A& (

B ! '@ &( E

A ; ;5JJS

`M" T "
C

)

( @

J # I &#
&(B A@

'€(
y '

'

C
"
I A

C

'#

B= D= " B A
G! F

(

( ( €#>

H

S F t ; ;5KSK #(
A

#(

F ( @

A&A | ( P & B

& A (D t ; ;5KOJ & '
(AP & B ! '

'

'I I ' )

(@A ( @

> I

(

F (B A

$ # '
& A(

A

#B= & =AI F

##

y
'

@A &

F@ ' @

OB '

@

(D A

!F

#A @ F # & = y

C

S '
#

|

A

' A&B A

D= " y & A& F

6O
&

& ( #ƒ

&

(

( Q #R ) ' @
!

P

C

A
'

!

D= "

P &

D & (( &AB A '
"

!F

A

I A@

I( ' A ( = # ' '
B ! '@ &( E F

A& ( (#
I
&

F

Q

"=

# F ") ( !

!& (

; ;5JK5 #

(D €A &

( I '(

&( ; ;5J6S F IA
" & =AF

G!
A&A

(D A >

D ?

F & A 6K

' P@

F@ ' @

5JK5+5JJ6M

"

)B= D= " B A

"

I A
=

F t ; ;5JK4 I ' 5 t ( (
G!

F

A& ( (# I '#>

I L ; ;
A L ; ; 5JJ5 N 5JS6M
A& (

( A

6j

T %"
d
(

"
F A ; L5J (y

) 5JJSM; C&A #

G!

0O

)

; #W T

U_; ; Sj;
& '

(

I '

L5JK5M;

I '(

"

g

M"e

A

TB T

•

A&(

U

A ; L5J2jM;
@

N
C& A

>

A
)

‰0

A&(

;

e

! T T g%d_)
‰0 (! )C& A

>

;

'

'

)

>

_\

%

( ;
BA

A

&& y & ";

""

6 L ; 652+6JJM;
I '& 'T I ; L5JJJM;
@(

I '(

D A; L5JKKM; +
@

'W

;

‰0 I

A( A) (

hII # ! "LZ" T i; A

• A

_

U_ #*
*

; L5JKjM; ) ) $ % $ W

( (

RSS *

%

(" * $

I AF

' A I '

%;

*

; L ( & =A 2M; A

(" !

_; t J6 •

TB T

* * Se

;

;

' N

# # *; A
!) N

*U

(

)

_

; L5JJKM;

+

I ; L5JJSM;
I '(

_; L ( & =A 5M; A
*

)

A B A '

;
+

$_

#;

T

'

U_)

I '& 'T I ; L5JJ5M;

I '(

( I A; L5JKKM;

*$

‰0

A&(

; )> A # @

f RS

'

>

#

f

' A T

‰0 (! )C& A

•(

_"

*S; A

TB T

#

%

_* ]

# # &;

)

( ' )y

T

)

U R

Q("

%

I * * # _

I ; L ( & =A 2M; A

‰0 (! )

;
‰0 >

( (

% )
) (

" ' " hSST ") N U

+

%
;
NU%!; A

‰0 (

63
'!

' ) ; L5JKJM; $ %

%"$ % H RS") $ % )

N #! " M M"OXL[\OXOL; A
"(
}

€

*

_

LZ" T $%k" M MOXLaP; A

;
A

(

H

* II

% NU%!"V ) !
‰0 C& A

PI P A

A T I ; L5JKjM; $ N

I

I '

; L5JJ4M;
)

@

I A@

>

*W "g "j U T

& '

d*
T

(& y

L ;;

5M; A
%

f H

y T

_("

)

* *

;# $

)

!

A&(M & ' A&( A & '

@

A & '

_"

• A

;

C I† T B T #F B

'

Q*

;

&; L5JJ4M;
(

‰0 >

'W

+

)

; A

!
) (

’C M; L5JK5M;

*S

‰0

A (( ;

HU

A&( A & '

(

%("S U% g f 'W

# $

% L

;
W

; L ( & =A

$

‰0 (! ) )) (;

€ ; L5JKSM; S

T %e

#

g " M M"OXZO; A

l*

‰0

( “&

&@ ;
?@ (!

;• L5JJKM; % RS

F (M; A
@

m %U

‰0 ( &> >

; L5JKKM; e%U
; L5JK3M; T %

; L ( & =A K •

A

N

$ (") $* H $I

‰0 >

( I A• A

Q* N
(

;
( I A

@ y G" ? ? I 'I “A& A ( C@ ; L5JJJM;
* W
$ % f* # N
S
; F (! ) €
'
T
(( @
' > t 5JJK y F @D
&D A
& y
A €A LeW\-,X.Yb U8-. *Z]

A & ' (

B= D= "

)f! *
>

A

% RS

"(

'

A

'

A

)

ST S %

)

!U ; A

S

; L5JJ5M; %

; L5JKOM;

Q*

N

‰0 C A ( & y

'!

#

*

; D & (D O ( &( 5JJST D &

;

g

Q*

8::X0xxccc;,9W+

YWc1;YW:x.YZWŠ;X8X•9X:.9Y–