Firm Performance Theory Development 1. Agency Theory
36
performance in Pakistan. Positive relationship between corporate governance and firm performance has been observed Cheema and Din, 2003.
2. Impact of family involvement in ownership managementand direction on financial performance of the Lebanesefirms Salloum Charbel, Bouri Elie,
Samara Georges, 2013.
This research is purposed to understand better how family involvement in ownership management and direction affects the financial performance of the
Lebanese companies. In order to authenticate our hypotheses, we collected primary data by using a quantitative method. In fact, we performed an inquiry by surveying 75
Lebanese companies listed companies in the Beirut Stock Exchange 2012 through a questionnaire formed by closed and semi-open questions and modulators. Research
model parameters estimated using statistical package for the social science using Spearman test of correlation through the SPSS program. This study use independent
variable, they are family involvement in ownership management and entrenchement and asymmetric altruism, and dependent variable using return on asset ROA and
earning before interest taxes EBIT. While finishing the empirical study, we concluded that family involvement in ownership and management has a positive
relationship with the financial performance of the Lebanese company. Moreover, issues like entrenchment and asymmetric altruism did not prove to have a significant
relationship with the financial performance. The essential reason to the results previously stated is that family managers in Lebanon act as stewards by considering
37
the success of the company as their own, rather than agents seeking to achieve their personal benefit on the expense of the company Charbel and Georges 2013.
3. The Impact of Board Size on Firm Value: Evidence from The Asian Real Estate Industry Josephus P. Weterings and Dirk M. Swagerman, 2011.
This study examines the impact of board size on firm value as measured by Tobin’s Q for a sample of 155 ordinary property firms and real estate investment
trusts REITs listed in Hong Kong, Malaysia and Singapore. This study use independent variable, they are boa
rd size, market cup and debt equity. And toni’s q as dependent variable. This section provides OLS regression result from the main
samples. In contrast with findings of prior research, researcher presents evidence for a positive relationship between board size and firm value for listed ordinary property
firms. Results on REITs are not significant because of limited sample size. Results are robust to a number of controls including firm size and leverage Wetering and
Swagerman 2011. Limitation of this study include, among others, endogeneity of variables, limited sample size and the time frame of my dataset.
4. Ownership Structure, Corporate Governance And Firm Value: Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies Jenny Jung-wha Lee and Zhihua Zhang, 2010
This research investigates the effects of ownership structures and corporate governance on firms’ performances in the Chinese capital market, which is in the
early developmental stage of a socialist market economy. First, we examined
38
companies that issued A stock listed on Shanghai and Shenzhen Stock Exchanges from 2004
–2007 to analyze the effects of various facets of ownership structures and corporate governance on firm’s values. Second, we examined the firms’
performances under varying proportions of state ownership to examine the impact on ownership structures and corporate governance. This study use independent variable,
they are oenership structure, government structure, as depenent variable using return on asset ROA and tobin’s Q also firm size, leverage and growth ratio as control
variable. To examine the impact of corporate governance on firm performance using regression model analysis.
Largest shareholder ownership, and managerial ownership were found to negatively affect the firms’ value and board members and institutional ownerships
were found to positively affect firms’ values. We also examined the effect of interactions between firms’ performances and corporate governance structures on
board independence and the existence of audit committees on the valuation of firms with high performance values Lee and Zhang 2010. There are several limitation of
this study. Our measure tobin’s q is limited in the evaluating the market vale due to the nontradable shares. In relation to corporate governance measurement, we need to
develop the index for the overall corporate governance variables.
39
Table 2.1 The Relevan Previous Research
No. Researcher
Year
Title Variable
Result Summary Similarity
Difference
1. Khaliq Ur Rehman
Cheema and Muhammad
Sadat Din 2013
Impact of Corporate
Governance on
Performance of Firms: A
Case Study of Cement
Industry in Pakistan
Variable: board size,
family controlled
firms, firm performance
Variable: CEO duality, Sample
:
data of fifteen companies of
the cement industries of
Pakistan including
family and non- family
Period: period of 2007 to
2011. The researcher
found that CEO duality is
negatively and significantly related
to cement industry performance, as the
performance indicator for firm is
EPS. Family and non-family firms
has also impact on
cement firm’s performance. Its
shows that board size do not affect
the performance of a firm.
2. Salloum Charbel,
Bouri Elie, Samara
Georges 2013
Impact of family
involvement in ownership
managementa nd direction
on financial performance
of the Lebanese-
firms Variable:
family involvement,
firm performance
Variable: asymmetric
altruism. Sample:
Used 75 Lebanese
companies family firms,
none family firms, and listed
companies in the Beirut Stock
Exchange Period: 2012.
Method: Spearman test.
The result showed that entrench-ment
and asymmetric altruism did not
prove to have a significant
relationship with the financial
performance.