THE USE OF COOPERATIVE LEARNING IN SMALL GROUP DISCUSSIONS IN GENRE-BASED READING CLASS (A CLASSROOM ACTION RESEARCH - Diponegoro University | Institutional Repository (UNDIP-IR)

(1)

Appendix 1-3: Students’ Score

1.

List of Pre-test Score in Pre-cycle (Genres)

N o

Name Reg.

Number

Descripti ve

Narrative Recount Report 1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

3 2 2 1

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000

22

3 3 2 2

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000

25

3 3 3 2

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000

35

2 2 3 2

5. VELIATI 16105001

96

3 3 4 2

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

2 2 3 2

7. FERDIANTO 16105000

47

2 2 2 2

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

3 3 2 3

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000

56

3 2 3 1

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

3 3 3 2

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

2 2 3 1

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000

85

2 3 2 2

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000

94

3 2 2 2

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001

76

2 2 2 2

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000

98

4 3 3 3


(2)

. SITORESMI 74 17

.

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001

09

3 2 2 1

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002

17

3 2 2 2

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001

25

3 3 2 2

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001

27

2 2 3 1

Averages 54 = 2,7 49= 2,45 51 = 2,55 38 = 1,9

2.

List of Pre-test Score in Pre-cycle (Reading Purposes)

N o

Name Reg.

Number

Reading to search info and skim

Reading for general comprehension

Total

1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

6 2 8

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000

22

8 2 10

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000

25

9 2 11

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000

35

7 2 9

5. VELIATI 16105001

96

9 3 12

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

8 1 9

7. FERDIANTO 16105000

47

8 0 8

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

8 3 11

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000

56

7 2 9


(3)

. 68 11

.

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

7 1 8

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000

85

7 2 9

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000

94

7 2 9

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001

76

7 1 8

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000

98

8 5 13

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

9 3 12

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001

09

7 1 8

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002

17

6 3 9

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001

25

8 2 10

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001

27

7 1 8

Averages 151 = 62,92 41 = 25,62 9,6 =

48

3.

List of Post-test Score (Genres) in Cycle 1

N o

Name Reg.

Number

Descripti ve

Narrative Recount Report 1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

4 3 4 2

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000

22

4 4 4 3


(4)

25

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000

35

3 3 4 3

5. VELIATI 16105001

96

4 4 4 3

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

4 3 4 3

7. FERDIANTO 16105000

47

3 2 3 2

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

5 4 4 3

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000

56

4 3 3 2

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

4 4 4 3

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

3 3 4 3

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000

85

3 3 3 3

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000

94

4 3 4 2

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001

76

3 3 3 2

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000

98

4 4 5 4

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

5 4 4 3

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001

09

4 3 3 2

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002

17

4 3 3 3

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001

25

5 4 4 3

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001

27

3 2 4 2


(5)

4.

List of Post-test Score (Reading Purpose) in Cycle 1

N o

Name Reg.

Number

Reading to search info and skim

Reading for general comprehension

Total

1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

9 4 13

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000

22

10 5 15

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000

25

10 6 16

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000

35

8 5 13

5. VELIATI 16105001

96

9 6 15

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

9 5 14

7. FERDIANTO 16105000

47

7 3 10

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

10 6 16

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000

56

8 4 12

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

9 6 15

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

8 5 13

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000

85

7 5 12

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000

94


(6)

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001

76

8 3 11

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000

98

10 7 17

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

10 6 16

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001

09

9 3 12

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002

17

7 6 13

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001

25

9 7 16

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001

27

8 3 11

Averages 173 = 72,08 100 = 62,5 273 =

68,25

5.

List of Post-test Score (Genres) in Cycle 2

N o

Name Reg.

Number

Descripti ve

Narrative Recount Report 1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

4 3 4 4

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000

22

5 4 5 4

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000

25

5 4 5 5

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000

35

4 3 4 3

5. VELIATI 16105001

96

5 4 4 4

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

4 3 4 4


(7)

47 8. FIRDAUSAH

AMALIA

16105000 49

5 4 5 5

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000

56

4 4 4 4

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

5 4 5 4

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

4 4 5 4

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000

85

5 4 4 4

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000

94

5 3 4 4

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001

76

4 3 5 4

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000

98

5 4 5 5

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

5 4 5 4

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001

09

4 3 4 3

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002

17

5 4 5 4

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001

25

5 4 5 3

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001

27

4 3 4 3

Averages 91 72 89 80

6.

List of Post-test Score (Reading Purpose) in Cycle 2

N o

Name Reg.

Number

Reading to search info

Reading for general


(8)

and skim comprehension 1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

11 4 15

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000

22

12 6 18

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000

25

12 7 19

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000

35

8 6 14

5. VELIATI 16105001

96

10 7 17

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

9 6 15

7. FERDIANTO 16105000

47

8 5 13

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

11 8 19

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000

56

10 6 16

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

11 7 18

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

10 7 17

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000

85

9 8 17

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000

94

9 7 16

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001

76

10 6 16

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000

98

12 7 19

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

10 8 18

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001

09


(9)

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002

17

10 8 18

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001

25

11 6 17

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001

27

9 5 14

Averages 201 = 83,75 129 = 80,625 330 =


(1)

25

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000 35

3 3 4 3

5. VELIATI 16105001 96

4 4 4 3

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

4 3 4 3

7. FERDIANTO 16105000 47

3 2 3 2

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

5 4 4 3

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000 56

4 3 3 2

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

4 4 4 3

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

3 3 4 3

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000 85

3 3 3 3

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000 94

4 3 4 2

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001 76

3 3 3 2

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000 98

4 4 5 4

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

5 4 4 3

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001 09

4 3 3 2

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002 17

4 3 3 3

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001 25

5 4 4 3

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001 27

3 2 4 2


(2)

4.

List of Post-test Score (Reading Purpose) in Cycle 1

N

o

Name Reg.

Number

Reading to search info and skim

Reading for general comprehension

Total

1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

9 4 13

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000 22

10 5 15

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000 25

10 6 16

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000 35

8 5 13

5. VELIATI 16105001 96

9 6 15

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

9 5 14

7. FERDIANTO 16105000 47

7 3 10

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

10 6 16

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000 56

8 4 12

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

9 6 15

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

8 5 13

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000 85

7 5 12

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000 94


(3)

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001 76

8 3 11

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000 98

10 7 17

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

10 6 16

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001 09

9 3 12

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002 17

7 6 13

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001 25

9 7 16

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001 27

8 3 11

Averages 173 = 72,08 100 = 62,5 273 =

68,25

5.

List of Post-test Score (Genres) in Cycle 2

N

o

Name Reg.

Number

Descripti ve

Narrative Recount Report

1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

4 3 4 4

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000 22

5 4 5 4

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000 25

5 4 5 5

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000 35

4 3 4 3

5. VELIATI 16105001 96

5 4 4 4

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

4 3 4 4


(4)

47 8. FIRDAUSAH

AMALIA

16105000 49

5 4 5 5

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000 56

4 4 4 4

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

5 4 5 4

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

4 4 5 4

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000 85

5 4 4 4

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000 94

5 3 4 4

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001 76

4 3 5 4

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000 98

5 4 5 5

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

5 4 5 4

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001 09

4 3 4 3

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002 17

5 4 5 4

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001 25

5 4 5 3

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001 27

4 3 4 3

Averages 91 72 89 80

6.

List of Post-test Score (Reading Purpose) in Cycle 2

N

o

Name Reg.

Number

Reading to search info

Reading for general


(5)

and skim comprehension 1. ARIEF

FATHURROZIQ

16105000 13

11 4 15

2. BAITUL IQRO 16105000 22

12 6 18

3. BINA FIRMASIH 16105000 25

12 7 19

4. DEWI AYUNITA 16105000 35

8 6 14

5. VELIATI 16105001 96

10 7 17

6. DIAH A. FATMAWATI

16105000 38

9 6 15

7. FERDIANTO 16105000 47

8 5 13

8. FIRDAUSAH AMALIA

16105000 49

11 8 19

9. HELLY MELYANA 16105000 56

10 6 16

10 .

KARTIKA PRATIWI 16105000 68

11 7 18

11 .

IKA IZZI NAHLIATI 16105001 74

10 7 17

12 .

MAZIA RIZKY I. 16105000 85

9 8 17

13 .

M. MASESRA P. 16105000 94

9 7 16

14 .

M. ARI AZHARI 16105001 76

10 6 16

15 .

NOVIKA AMELIA 16105000 98

12 7 19

16 .

KRISTANTI SITORESMI

16105000 74

10 8 18

17 .

OKKY WESTA A. 16105001 09


(6)

18 .

RISKA CAHYA N. 16105002 17

10 8 18

19 .

SEPTI SUSANTI 16105001 25

11 6 17

20 .

SETIA DERMAWAN 16105001 27

9 5 14

Averages 201 = 83,75 129 = 80,625 330 =