PENINJAUAN KEMBALI PIDANA PENJARA PENDEK TERHADAP PENCURIAN KAYU DI HUTAN SERTA PERMASALAHANNYA (Studi Kasus Beberapa Wilayah Hukum di Sumatera Barat).

I. P E N D A H U L U A N

1,1

Latar Felakanq
l"lii$i,rLirh

l"lasa l ah

[)$.L"tl.i$iar],.\,,rn

cl,nTr r..rpaya p*:n an

d--._--._l-

\

,,

00


L"r

.1.

hl..\ 14:1..r(1r

ar qlar l,r.e.j,rh,{t,rfl )/,ilfl

pnl.iii\n hill.l y,:lru

{:i:l..rl,iLrtl r.,lr-nslr}

tt'Litl.l

'f.,*n;:,..,r r clrrr,,ln d anql

sc|car"*

t* [i:r*


'himhl..rLl.]yii(

m{.}l.]ta,.ltli

r.rrr

t{..1I'i

l,;,.

fri,r.li,rh stir'[(..\ li'j.dfirtt
l,ioj
l.:rii

j

i.\

h"r'l:,.lIl


ii\lt,,t

,,

[,tfi

h,.,rr'^r.,rri, d i.

'[o'l::J,il
:i.

t]

h,{da1::i.

1::clrrr:rLt"i,,rn Il,ilyLl

;r..t

l]L,lflr,il

o,1.

di.

(irlr

hLl

j,

hl.rl.;LUn
J.

li.

l.

FHn I

si.,:11:ra


l]1.{

J,i

yanql

r{..r hl.rliL.rm

j.

Jr]o:1. ii\ l,i {"t 1,1,i$1

i::ev-.1. al,r.t-r,

j.ni.

.-lcln.l,,llt

p:i.d,nrra^


l"lAtt,t1,tl"l

L.rfir d

[c]r",r Iirl r-.r'1.. bHi
l:r,:,r r"

j.r]U [:],,tcl,it r]ffir.liirn

y,rr)U :::rHd,,ln

ii.j i. iirri

l:ny,i]\ L:aq.i.ar

i. di.

hLrllL.(nr ;rj.c1;ln;ir
mH r-{..1 *

tr:er" jad j.

Iclr'L.l L.,,rfr],:r

s

firi,r(:::,rrn--ina{:::.rr1l

i:r puneqal.; hr..rhlrm,, $,i\.l,irl'r

[,ir],, /ihi.[r,,rtn',za y,Rr]c

l':.ur"u'r;;lh,nn i:ffr",itehLrt tlid,..rh

{l

i

r


i:i1]:r i,\

l: ,r

n

(:J r.i.

fifl

r:i

y nf
::;.,r

[r,r

nn oIeh

r"i::r1iti!


l.i

r-;:\

.1.*n0*lrlr;,1

dirii\!i!$lj.Al i{.,i.I-jL..Ll. h ("1,(-)) [,]i(h{.rn i:i{'i:,,1r..1 l. i.(fi,,r hm.i.,r1r'j (i:i )
'[il ltt..tn yi r](:.l ltlr.,,ln cJ,,,t[,,ltrU, I)amp]al,; (:J,,il-.:i. l,if,.j ahi],ltiall j.nj,
a;:al::i.1.* t:i.dal,; a:l:i.hi'ln0qLr.l.anqi 1}(,-+(:::di r-c\ {li.n j. ,r.{l:ilr mHnr.mlft..tll,;

iln lr,,,thav,r yanq sanu,*t hritp,'rr- ll'el.:,41.:i. t:i.clali

cli]\F .j j. r,^J,il m*rn L..r$ j. i.n tr+tapri .jr.{0,r '[0irl]itd;:1p
:::i

r+ 5: ti:: r'- 'L

i. l


kcjrr'-j

l'r,.!i i:';\dang

il":\r1

rtcli.tJ)./it qfil,n(ijo {J,rn Ii:i1l"),rl]
j an$

,,

sia

ja

.1.

j.n q l,i l..rl.J !J,:1\rl

.l


{::)f

t:tii:;

[:nr"h;,t-"

r' clj.

Illt"(l';:i.

t

?

l';,t:rn

]...,(.jd ijt

'[

ti+

1riifi

1,;

n i:r .l

m t:t

!l't it l: t.l

1:renrlr..tr;ir..r1.;

yitriq

i
n,,ir

ilp,ilh

uy

j.,1,

;,r r," ;,r

a

l,r.

1,.

r..rr"

,,

iiln

)

l::ie...nyHhAr,i

fl

i:.(i]

ftHnlL.t

l,;:i.rn,rn yi,:rfte f i d.il

pii'i: d,aF,rI mer,"L..rsal.. l:1..i.1.,[t..1r"fi:1.

*r'L,

hn.l.- h.:r.1. lrilr"siri;ti:r,,r'[

rii.

a

[;rs

I

rjil,;clncla.lil,;,,1tr r;ert:aT"a L]ili!i dAft !:icll)plrr"Tt ir,rh,r

f----t'

menq1,rl,;i.hil

Ii';nn

bt..rrJ;:ya,,

liir',,ri:ja

nril"ra

n

y,t

irlrncal,;

l,l

[:i,,]J

.

hL.L:1.

hr-:i.*i:i.ti Hl';fit)fit i.r
r".j.i:ri:i.s;

)r,,rn

ad,r.lah smha ,,,ri allj.hr'[

j.

al,,Ja

,r

J,;

iii

l,r,

i,\ft

d

ii:l

rJ,ll1:til t:

li];i.,,,\.1.

lt: ,,\han

Dii\ t:

cliiirrr

{Ji,\pi,\l:

Ici]l;r)(:1.J.

li

L,r,:i\

.1.

:i.

t,.r,ii: .l i.rrql,,L.rrrq;"rrr

t]i.1rL:ri:\:i. hail.:i.Jl (ftnil.atimrr*ihi.p

(t.i. y rr(l J;r.l|fi|']

i:jfllhfiq,::\j iiJaj.hAI clar-j.
h

qtt

j. rl;r

ILr ditHr"iti],
,l;.rdi. ltpahi.:liirki,mhl,,ltnyit l,ir-j.sr:i.li,

i:trr

i,l

t.til';r,:,t

l.;m

t

)

.

hiclah-"i:t;(.'j]i,Jrb,rn

,,in j.rri "

ma

l,;,.1r

L:;,t ri3(,rri,fiq mcll.:i.l:nt: ar:l;,rny.l l:orh.rq,',\:i. trr{:::(rfi) pn.i.r".rs.r.,,

hh,r"Ll1tiralaa11

;,t l,;

j.

h,:,r'[nviil

l::) Hr

r)

{J

d,nm

1..{ 11: L.,r

1::,,,r

lr.

r'l

[fi

Ll i:,r

piir

f c1i.r"a*ni.lan

r..r'h,*l,n

tl

.i. :i.

,n1] y,:rflcl $tG,i.(:itr"a l:cl*ellrr,"r..rh,*n

nq

l,i {..1u

"

1r.,,:\l-li.,\h,,

t:t,rn yfi n {t'[:ri

iij.r'

iii.r

[rt*r",tnar hlr'[al (Veqclr"i)
rnft (i.lj.t',,
(flrlt$ j.rn)

tiifr"lh

$$r"|fi

cla1:ai: cll.laatH-

{:1,

r) t"tdar,r

,.ll,rfi) l.r$alt,r

t,
sr+h,rq,r

L.ldar",'r )

1

j.

l::]Lln

j ij,\ (:1,,i J,;L..l,rLita$

l)r,jflflc\r'L.tlti cl.raca
l'fiil l,i rer,r!r:i. dan
F r"l-;\n i\ h-fi){i}r

,, l,iL.rhc-r-ii:i.h,:lrrrya,, i::r:..-nrtr:lt
,nn. D,*.larn h;rl ini pc'nqtrer"tian irl.tLan

r,:l

i:ri.,r

l,;,iln h,rnya llel.:Bdar

3- HASIL PENELITIAN.

S.1. Keadaan Daerah Penel itian

"

j. di :lndfin{ii'!:iia
hfir d j.fin [;i\r"ii\fiyiir -t; ).11. y"

Si"rmatera Barat ad;l1,i.rh sa.l.ah lr,.rtLr

r-*--rl\

diirnqli:,rn :lLras wilayah
$c,.'h,rtcl"ti areal

rl:1,,;l::'l9,, Z:.:;()

perLaniarr diilfr

tiH.1. filL:tii.

Ir'

f " (::]

I:r

hny,::\

i. n

fit

e

1;]

r- Lt |:] iJl

l?i

a

n

h{..\'Li\l"t

"

n d,enaLt" tanah [:,nncirr:::;,, r-i. Ii.$ ci,nn .l ,:r i. n -- rr i. n ,
Fe,.'r-re1iti"ln ini {Ji. 1,r1.:Ltl..,nn di. licrt,:lnt,,tdyi"\ Jrr',rdar}g tn$ni:til"1(.lal-

gitl.tnqlai.

[j:,

r"

i,;'

irr [tar-ak hany,iii

rlj.arflcla[:

fl]ew.rl,; j.

hitq

ii\

i. h,Li. dLine ! rl},rh,r lir'[:*im;:rriyi:,r lj'adanq

1j. d;rrj.

dirr"i. daer-,rh--dac,.r';:rlr :1.;r:i.nny;"\.

*,:rn:p:iTtq i Ir-L llctarnaily;.:r

li:',,,rtlanq;

(J{"ti1ii\r'l yi,lirq

[ ciHj.rc1an

ni.l.,:,t

j.-n j. llini

mer"an[,,r clar]

l.;.,,,rw"1s*rrr

hr..rtfin
yanU

t

{iitii

.l.

lrr,.i

heql

i tr-r

[:t,.,r r''

r-r yel l]

l,;riynbi]:l

1::cl n.,,1

i, hH

[an lindLlnq "

d

r"

3i|l ri y

n]o'r"LrF,Jl,i,iri :[l,rL{ho'[,r fr'r'o[]in1iri,

hnmp:i"rrrL1

.j r-rrJ;:r

fi clapa k

;: (il ri rJ

r-r

r;l r-r

li

hc.rtr*r"nqen yi:inq

j.Llaw.i o.Lelr pr'.,triclatat"lq ,,t\tiinfi y n!)

d).

r..rntLrl.

hlr'[al]

irr$cir,,rl.r!:,i, $Lrndr'[ei'r'fi ll;,rr-i:rt

p{irr]ye1l)il

Dj.

,:r.cj;l

1ihaI

:i.r

rrHr"rr.] 1,,\l),,

j.

];irh

d

{!i{d:i

sc) hact,'t

i.

j.tfi][ilUl,:an
[.(,:r

lii

l]:Jli]

[

]. ,, l.

j.l,iLl

L

i::11i,
I

1:3clb,.rri*rj.

li::17

h*r

5

-

I(ES I I'IPULAN

DAN SARAN

5- 1, Kesimpulan,
1.

,-----lt

\

" 6tnti\r'i.\ r,ir.rmber- d;.iy;i\ "r,1.$fir ( hr..rt,*n ) d,ln n:i.r*yi.l r",,1l,;;r't:
rrs:mpLL yai lr(-lh{infJi(rt y,rnn t" j-ntba.L [:.r.i. ri.l.].,, haili hL"rrlLl,:.ry,r
k*rsi(il.j nhtfiir"i:\.1r1 ,lritliiy,,'\r'fil.rii\'l al.;;ln mcln-i *cJ j,
h,i:r j.l.;
Fl.,(,].,3
slrnrL:er'- fil.ry.r

,,1:L;r\rri 1ii$,,ii,LJ,r

i.

denqar

sclmhuyan "i '/i"r1:iir')

,".'..-'.'.,''.
,,,,,..,,.y*1";rlltrtl",,
c,l.c:lt itftl::r,ri)

pt*itqlt"l"t::lal.:
l"1

an '[Hr"h,tcl,ltFr l.;'.,ltJi]!larl

I.)i.tt,,,tg

i,:.{i,'lh

ll.

cl:i.h

i. ri cl

t..t

tt

j.rdnr'1.;frrl

t..1 .,

Ll

"

l..J

l\l

$

,,

i1i

"1

,:r

t..1

tl,tn,,tfr f:l(+fl{Ji.ri. y,trl{..1

1::n'nyidi.l,; p :l.r"j.
lr

r.,r

n

riiri.) L:r,::ril,.,l ri

l.

c/

fir,rrn;i\

l.j.liil

i::Jc.}

y,rrct

rjA

rJ:L I

c+ r::t ,::r

1|:;afil4r
i:, I.

,r

(l

tl t.,:ti tl

j.

i:,t

tt

d,i.l.i,lfil

ii 7 "

l''lah:i.m ;;:irlttn''r cj j. |i'Hn i.:t,rd j..l.,rn l!eqclr':i. li:l,rd.rn!.:J F;,\dii
Lurr..rnrfiy rncil.j a L:Lllrl{,rn F;i.ditn"i l::rcllt.r.j ar"a ptlncloI l,;n1::atla
d

,'l

l.an

tr..r

, l,.l [L.rla rl]Hn.j i,rc.lli h .1.ff$1:,trj.,rr hr..t i:*1n l.:i.r{lLrr)o ri. n;i. [ft]lt,:i\h
]c.lil:;j, li r.,l|! $ ) y.lrq d:i..[nn.jLrl.i d"rr"i
(J j.[:,ontllla fi,s.1. *;t-ul.
l,:,

:.:.),

hL"t

:i.

i Fli ,1,,n)/dh liu Iamadya l':',tdiinq

,

ijrri l.:,.lyr.( d:i l'i ,,t ,;t s;,t r1 h(-ti::,,:\rJ
:1 j,fl{l firi}
I,ii:: t,::rmady;:r li',td,rn
h,*r'l.r d j,itlrql.i,.iL !}ilmen.j,,tl.:.

l'l,tRi.r:[

al]

pe'r-1,;.:ir-a

Uc'.r'l fi

r.lr

j.

r/J

L*lrr..irr 1.9{ril6,, la,ir"c]rr*i 1:c:nl:i.nt3ry.,r liem;:clrt,:,tlt,rttla,,lrl l.ci'.l.Ll!l-t,..ir"

'L:

5,

r..r

j.,r|J lrr..r'[i*n .l;j"ndunQ

d,iiir I"

]i

l:1$:lAl,:1..{-"I::r(ill:l.al,;L"r

yairr.l

'[i.cJ,rl.1

,

?. Saran-Saran ,
1,, l':'e.:'r'1. r..t ciiLi.rl.ialt cl;rn i F i. l,l i. r' l't A fi
i. il
r,ienl,;t; j. pi{ili,\l1i.l {:cirhad,tF F{,,'-r
{:::1..1r

i,t

l':,

ci'r

:i. F)orl.i,"\'L.Ltlla
l';aylt tl j. l';,,ttu'ta15atr

i1t

l:i,*

.1.

,

r,

!:r,

raA iq

hr..t[*r .li.ndLtlrU ter"lt l;,,rm* di t]i..l.,ixy,rh
hu*,r..tLlrtri.rtt l,"tnalt,, ptilfi(:etah,tn

}_-----/'\

*i:r"nri:i., y,:lnq

;r

b

i'\n li

r-1.,1 d i. v" a{iiii\

l.j.

l.;

i.

i:i'r'[:ny,:il

tr-,r

firt*l,;,t.1,lt

h,,rltt"ttr

(Iti:\{.,1Fr..ll.]

pi*rr yi.t.l.

liiit{fi{\r"a

j.nst;rrtq;i. y;irl0

t..t

Lii'r1fi"j

li"

li'(il-r':l

r..r

r' ,t

ht..(titll

r'r
:i.

rl

[]

s

r"

L.l

j. d:i.

rl d rt r] Q -"

tnrrqAll

l:]cifi(:.Jcitlr'lfigiitrl tllfi:3iii

hnn ,,

pctrlq vl4ti}i.lfl

til i'i

mci". cJ

y,:rj [Lr

i:it

j.,,,t

t;{':'lti,,l1::

'nfi:i:l

[o]r'1.;i,rj.

I y,,,ri f.rr

'L:

d,:rL.L

i,\'1,:ir

{:::,::\

f-it

her-lt,ltl';lt
Foi.rl {::l

rnrlfl{ir)

,,

L(ny;t

cli,ltidL{pl':Ar}./i:i:i.nl{ [i.J'11;rr]

cla;:n[

]{iinq:Je L:;thLi

l'i

r,:r1ll

h,t l

:i

fr,ti:'-'F,'i\'-:;

jrl:L dit:j,id.,:rkanr
r:rFitl'i ll hiltll!:i..!. .- lrart:i.l y.r tl

porqlL,\.j.i. haylt j.rrj, yan

j.

tHr"$eht-t1: diFl,*.r'o1$l]
A.

j.r- dlt|l

F,i.d,'ilr],,r tjiit.L"rtlt
hflrl(litll:r)yrl tl{lllfll j l'iir-l'iarl

"rnt liuil cj,,t
r50+r"'L,t Fr-orlHcjLlI" p(ilrl,.lrlclan{.J-"l..lndAn6;rn yflrl0
yi1lll!:J hfirr"l';;1li. Li:irl {:JHlllJilltl
Ii:r'lfl j.fitr.ilfi
cliil.l.,,, it
lru L.rn

!

hfil.:i.r

{:.anq;1 pov",l i.ndL.lrt!:,Jiirrt

j.

ti:\'n.rdy,t [rrfidanfi

iJffrl(::,tr'1,,1

!j..tnl,.li'i pitluna ',
,t1.;;tn [:or j ,rcj i. 1:$r"lltHl]'Llt
,'d I'l j. h,:r'L yi:rr)
'i', f'(*r 1i-rrry,t ,uciinit:iity r"c( l'i .'t {: l'i {'rrrl
f) (:' r a l:

j,

L:iti!{i,;l lAi, i''i;At;''

i. trler-h;t.,tt,rr flHr'fi ;:t11. itl';t..t
,rji,.lu Li:) L,.rhltr y.lnQ a l';,"\r1

rilfin!.ll fiFkan

i"ifrd;rntti:rn tr*n

r' ,j, l!

c1,,lr"

('l:Leirh ::;nhah i. [t..t para

da L:*:ng "

l,:.

. I

Llri i:L-ll'i

#(ii'.l.,trni,l

rtorlci\

r"i$ :ll,,rh

,,r

i:,rlt ticlaJ'1

LJ

j

l:;,t t'r,:,t

"

illl ;:er::ion:i..l Llo.l. i $;;i l: lli t'::;t{lil:
llllil,t}r 'l :intlr"trrt1
li5 ii
|,; {:, ht..l [,rr]",1\rl r lnHni:linQiit :l tli\si d,tfi J' \"l rl
cl j.
l,ln L;.:t jil,,rdy..t\ frr;:\ cl it\ fl !J ,, ,::icl r" hit giAr';ilrlfi d ll
fll'lll*i:lr"itfia

l-'Hr.lLrnyit di.t;rfihith

.i

t..1fi.1.

{::l

',

"..\

*cilri.nq1q1i:l daF,al:
r::{ilFct{
li::'r).r'.1.

iIl{i?rr.i,ar:L ii\n l';

iir'l [1t9,:i:l tJnri.,lan

Li,]i\i.

i';

d"i\rl

"

Ll|ryri tjj,

l:.:i.n

j,'r1-\

l';{i+flthijjL:l

ancanr&n hlrl.;i-tman *c-icara

j.

i]

dLla.L

{ii} l'1

ci

i'iil

-""----"--noXil * c) -"-"-"--^"

r

ifi []

13 "

ii

ll

tl;,,'tn l';

r:i

p:i cJijj\fi,r/

DAFTAR KEPUSTAKAAN

F^-r'\

r
li,:11...11\l

li:ji

''Lll-,irj.li.tjr.,1.-i1r.h.......1;i.;i.t:[.(j1,:n.-....[].i:rr.ttt.:[.d.iii.L:r.j$.iii.!:::!.'',

1l${:i
.L

"

[y fi'1'' lvl]i. c::ll:i. clil\I]

ilr:'

r"(ri

*:r"

4

I {iri:rlr!,

" ,li'l'j.*L|l:rr i;

i,rrh Frrirl.rnr l::'Fif ht-l [i ]i.
( [] l{ tc}lici! r' l.(thJ:1. )
"

I'lii\ -i d\:l.

:l r.t,nt"t

i.

1

lr;rrt,t *

J.

"

[::r":1.

an

q,r

"

yi;rl.;,lr'[il r rill,;t:;ar";l

]. c]{:3 /.1

Iiar"\-t

"

,,

.i,'7iiil

-.-" -" (:r o 4 [:i )]( o o -- -- -- -- --

i..J

,,

Li[i]t]t,r l:rli.mh,'r

r/{llCr

-- -"

i

"

!i:.ril...,li.y.li.:1i.qq.|n.......j:i.!::t,q1...,..1:::.U.:.Q.!:1.!1.1i-jji.

/l

J]arkar'La

',

.1.

.

Ltr'O6,,

', l\lnmnr"

6lii