jurnal daya saing 7 3
!
"
"
#$ %
*
!
& '()
'(")+
!
*
!
-
"
12+
"/0/
('", +
.
*
!
.
3
# &&(% 4
" 54
4
4
3 !
6
"
(
#
%
#$$%) %*
"
!
!
!
!
"
#$$%
&
"
#$$$)+#
&
'"
&
!
'
"
!
74
#$$$
8
9
: ;
<
#$$-)*./
!
,"
!
"
5
#$$%) *%+ *%-
!
=- =
=0
/
!
8 3
*..9) .
)
!
1
>
!
"
'
'
2 3
*..4
,"
*.-
#$$-)
68? <
1
/
&
5
#$$#)-* !
!
&
!
"
5
#$$#)-*
"
)
!
,"
*..4
#$$*
!
!
!
!
"
!
& "
*..%
&
#$$*
"
!
< <
,"
*..4
#$$*
"
)
!
'
4
%
"
#
2
%"
=
2 3
/
*.6$
*..%
&
&
#
3
!
#
4
"
'"
<
%
/
:
=
3
<
0
<
%"
7
*..%
*..$
&
&
'
;
)
< =><
?
*<
?
#
<
3?
%
<
?
+
< @
?
-
<
?
)
< =
<
<
3
<
< @
<
<
*
#
%
+
-
!
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
) ;
,
!
(
:
<
<
<
< @
<
*
A
$ 996
$ ##%
$ %9.
$ *4#
$ *.%
3
! C
# 9%%
# %+4
% -4.
* *$$
* 499
$ $*$
$ $#*
$ $$*
$ #4+
$ $6*
(# > $ -+4
> $ *94
> ## 9.9
> * .$$
B,
C
B
B) $ $$$
)
)
< = > $ *94? $ 996 <
# 9%% DDD
? $ ##% <
# %+4 DD
3 ? $ %9. <
% -4. DDD
$ *4# < @
* *$$
$ *.% <
* 499 D
?
)
C
DDD >
DD >
D
>
!
< @
> $ #4+
3
"
"
"
"
!
!
!
> *E
> -E
> *$E
3
$ *4#
!
,
3
!
&
3
"
< = > $ *94? $ 996 <
# 9%% DDD
? $ ##% <
# %+4 DD
3 ? $ %9. <
% -4. DDD
!
$
)
$ *.% <
* 499 D
?
!
,
#$$+
!
;
&
&
,
,
"
"
#$$+
"
&
,
"
&
&
&
!
+
F
"
G
8
!
#$$+
C
<
!
!
!
"
"
#$$*
C;
!
'"
!
&
'
!
'
!
"
H I
'
#$$#
!
!
!
& '
!
!
!
!
!
3
*
"
C
"
3
!
"
"
&
!
!
!
!
3
3
!
!
3
3
3
3
3
<
!
A
F
C
"
@
"
C
%"
@
"
@
3
,
" "
@
F
@
"
"
@
A
F
"
!
@
!
F
@
$ +.+ +. +E
"
F
$ -+4
"
-+ 4E
C
F
@
&
!
@
!
@
@
#
"
&
&
&
$ +-%
&
E
+- %
3
"
!
"
!
"
"
" !# " !
5
@
"
"
"
&
0
J
"
!
3
!
"
0
"
"
!
:
3
!
!
3
&
!
:
3
!
!
0
:
3
A
$ -+4
!
"
>*E0
(#
3
3
3
-+ 4E
A
!
;
#$$%
3
;
*..9
8
F
(
;
(8
<
(
(8
3
7
#$$- 3
, H
C
5
F
F *..9
( 3 & F
;
8
?
8 3
C
*..*
8
C 3
5*
*%9 *++
;
@
( 3
*..9
$
2K!
,
6 ?
&
H &
8
@
A
;
8
FF
54
8
;
,
1 A
FF
;
,
"
"
#$ %
*
!
& '()
'(")+
!
*
!
-
"
12+
"/0/
('", +
.
*
!
.
3
# &&(% 4
" 54
4
4
3 !
6
"
(
#
%
#$$%) %*
"
!
!
!
!
"
#$$%
&
"
#$$$)+#
&
'"
&
!
'
"
!
74
#$$$
8
9
: ;
<
#$$-)*./
!
,"
!
"
5
#$$%) *%+ *%-
!
=- =
=0
/
!
8 3
*..9) .
)
!
1
>
!
"
'
'
2 3
*..4
,"
*.-
#$$-)
68? <
1
/
&
5
#$$#)-* !
!
&
!
"
5
#$$#)-*
"
)
!
,"
*..4
#$$*
!
!
!
!
"
!
& "
*..%
&
#$$*
"
!
< <
,"
*..4
#$$*
"
)
!
'
4
%
"
#
2
%"
=
2 3
/
*.6$
*..%
&
&
#
3
!
#
4
"
'"
<
%
/
:
=
3
<
0
<
%"
7
*..%
*..$
&
&
'
;
)
< =><
?
*<
?
#
<
3?
%
<
?
+
< @
?
-
<
?
)
< =
<
<
3
<
< @
<
<
*
#
%
+
-
!
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
) ;
,
!
(
:
<
<
<
< @
<
*
A
$ 996
$ ##%
$ %9.
$ *4#
$ *.%
3
! C
# 9%%
# %+4
% -4.
* *$$
* 499
$ $*$
$ $#*
$ $$*
$ #4+
$ $6*
(# > $ -+4
> $ *94
> ## 9.9
> * .$$
B,
C
B
B) $ $$$
)
)
< = > $ *94? $ 996 <
# 9%% DDD
? $ ##% <
# %+4 DD
3 ? $ %9. <
% -4. DDD
$ *4# < @
* *$$
$ *.% <
* 499 D
?
)
C
DDD >
DD >
D
>
!
< @
> $ #4+
3
"
"
"
"
!
!
!
> *E
> -E
> *$E
3
$ *4#
!
,
3
!
&
3
"
< = > $ *94? $ 996 <
# 9%% DDD
? $ ##% <
# %+4 DD
3 ? $ %9. <
% -4. DDD
!
$
)
$ *.% <
* 499 D
?
!
,
#$$+
!
;
&
&
,
,
"
"
#$$+
"
&
,
"
&
&
&
!
+
F
"
G
8
!
#$$+
C
<
!
!
!
"
"
#$$*
C;
!
'"
!
&
'
!
'
!
"
H I
'
#$$#
!
!
!
& '
!
!
!
!
!
3
*
"
C
"
3
!
"
"
&
!
!
!
!
3
3
!
!
3
3
3
3
3
<
!
A
F
C
"
@
"
C
%"
@
"
@
3
,
" "
@
F
@
"
"
@
A
F
"
!
@
!
F
@
$ +.+ +. +E
"
F
$ -+4
"
-+ 4E
C
F
@
&
!
@
!
@
@
#
"
&
&
&
$ +-%
&
E
+- %
3
"
!
"
!
"
"
" !# " !
5
@
"
"
"
&
0
J
"
!
3
!
"
0
"
"
!
:
3
!
!
3
&
!
:
3
!
!
0
:
3
A
$ -+4
!
"
>*E0
(#
3
3
3
-+ 4E
A
!
;
#$$%
3
;
*..9
8
F
(
;
(8
<
(
(8
3
7
#$$- 3
, H
C
5
F
F *..9
( 3 & F
;
8
?
8 3
C
*..*
8
C 3
5*
*%9 *++
;
@
( 3
*..9
$
2K!
,
6 ?
&
H &
8
@
A
;
8
FF
54
8
;
,
1 A
FF
;
,