Kualitas Spermatozoa Sapi Limousin Se Penyimpanan Pada efrigerator dalam Pengencer Two-Step tm Extender dengan Suplementasi Kuning Telur Bebek

44

Lampiran 1

Data hasil perlakuan P1 (Pengencer Extender ) pada ulangan pertama pertama

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

P1

P2

P3


P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

NORMAL
P3

P1+P2+P3


P1

P2

ABNORMAL
P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

Jlh total

MOTIL

1

H0


60%

63

81

92

236

22

29

31

82

318


92

78

54

224

28

22

14

64

288

2


H1

35%

41

74

66

207

17

40

46

103


310

41

45

32

118

33

30

14

77

195


3

H2

20%

10

16

25

51

17

27

20


64

115

20

15

19

54

30

26

28

84


138

4

H3

5%

11

15

9

35

72

83


77

232

267

24

16

26

66

43

20

42


105

171

5

H4

5%

10

14

7

31

70

82

43

195

226

20

17

11

48

52

38

32

122

170

6

H5

3%

18

16

26

60

102

120

17

398

458

16

21

9

46

73

52

42

167

213

7

H6

1%

0

0

0

0

46

57

20

123

123

11

6

17

34

82

76

69

227

261

8

H7

O%

0

0

0

0

66

45

107

218

218

14

29

6

49

96

152

27

275

324

9

H8

0%

0

0

0

0

88

47

27

162

162

4

3

6

13

24

34

38

98

111

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

17

47

61

125

125

9

7

11

27

53

29

63

145

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

80

77

92

249

249

17

6

14

37

87

91

104

282

172
319

45

Lampiran 2

Data hasil perlakuan P1 (Pengencer Extender ) pada ulangan pertama kedua

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H0

60%

90

60

70

220

17

9

7

33

253

80

76

93

249

15

14

21

50

292

2

H1

40%

41

61

40

142

23

29

11

63

205

43

70

48

161

21

23

17

61

222

3

H2

5%

7

11

19

28

63

92

109

264

292

21

24

16

61

60

73

53

186

247

4

H3

3%

11

9

17

39

72

102

121

295

334

24

7

16

47

83

27

36

146

193

5

H4

1%

0

0

0

0

92

77

65

234

234

19

22

12

53

93

105

61

259

312

6

H5

O%

0

0

0

0

75

62

84

221

221

11

18

14

43

88

124

105

317

360

7

H6

O%

0

0

0

0

29

67

82

178

178

17

21

19

57

119

143

121

383

440

8

H7

O%

0

0

0

0

45

56

93

194

194

6

13

9

28

93

99

107

299

327

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

88

74

105

267

267

15

8

11

34

138

96

102

336

370

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

45

68

109

222

222

16

13

23

52

119

109

166

394

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

98

87

33

218

218

5

7

4

16

77

91

87

255

446
271

46

Lampiran 3

Data hasil perlakuan P1 (Pengencer Extender ) pada ulangan ketiga

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

TERSERAP
P3
P1+P2+P3

Jlh total
TT +T

P1

P2

NORMAL
P3 P1+P2+P3

P1

ABNORMAL
P2
P3
P1+P2+P3

Jlh total
NO+AN

1

H

65%

114

65

92

271

18

9

14

42

313

72

87

57

216

19

24

16

59

335

2

H1

45%

57

72

80

209

9

18

29

50

269

77

58

73

208

21

15

22

58

266

3

H2

35%

51

42

63

156

24

18

23

65

221

50

72

69

191

18

28

31

77

268

4

H3

20%

37

19

27

83

21

13

42

76

159

74

81

54

209

31

43

29

103

312

5

H4

5%

16

7

14

37

88

57

105

250

287

27

16

19

62

75

69

77

221

283

6

H5

1%

0

0

0

0

55

68

85

208

208

9

17

15

41

77

101

82

260

301

7

H6

O%

0

0

0

0

69

63

72

204

204

21

18

7

46

133

127

89

349

395

8

H7

O%

0

0

0

0

55

86

99

240

240

11

16

13

40

127

154

105

386

426

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

108

54

115

277

277

17

7

14

38

144

99

177

420

458

10

H9

0

0

0

0

75

65

122

262

262

10

12

6

28

189

205

99

493

521

11

H10

O%
O%

0

0

0

0

101

77

43

221

221

7

9

4

20

109

165

109

383

403

47

Lampiran 4

Data hasil perlakuan P1 (Pengencer Extender ) pada ulangan keempat

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

16

7

11

34

280

92

67

77

231

29

14

26

69

300

1

H

60%

99

67

80

246

2

H1

40%

41

61

40

142

9

18

29

56

198

106

55

72

233

64

25

32

121

354

3

H2

20%

7

11

19

37

22

18

27

67

104

50

72

69

191

18

28

31

77

268

4

H3

5%

11

9

17

37

21

27

42

90

127

31

43

29

103

83

104

99

286

389

5

H4

1%

0

0

0

0

69

63

72

204

204

14

17

15

46

97

107

88

292

338

6

H5

O%

0

0

0

0

55

86

99

240

240

11

17

7

35

113

129

89

331

366

7

H6

O%

0

0

0

0

108

54

115

238

238

10

14

17

41

22

164

155

441

482

8

H7

O%

0

0

0

0

75

65

122

262

262

17

7

14

38

144

99

177

420

458

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

101

77

43

221

221

9

18

6

33

99

227

125

546

579

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

37

74

58

169

169

5

7

9

21

79

185

169

533

554

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

92

100

83

275

275

17

4

13

32

19

197

187

603

635

48

Lampiran 5

Data hasil perlakuan P1 (Pengencer Extender ) pada ulangan kelima

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

NORMAL
P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

ABNORMAL
P3

P1+P2+P3

Jlh total
NO+AN

MOTIL

1

H

60%

89

77

70

236

15

8

10

33

269

82

57

95

234

19

13

29

61

295

2

H1

40%

31

71

50

152

7

19

30

56

208

96

65

82

243

54

26

36

116

359

3

H2

20%

13

24

22

59

32

38

24

94

153

70

62

59

191

20

26

25

71

262

4

H3

5%

62

53

76

191

19

15

27

61

252

21

33

19

73

73

102

98

273

346

5

H4

O%

0

0

0

0

77

80

65

222

222

13

18

17

48

87

117

108

312

360

6

H5

O%

0

0

0

0

90

42

55

187

187

9

16

21

46

93

119

159

371

417

7

H6

O%

0

0

0

0

105

39

47

191

191

14

15

18

47

132

174

175

382

429

8

H7

O%

0

0

0

0

19

47

58

124

124

20

11

10

42

164

109

157

430

472

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

40

48

78

166

166

9

17

6

32

199

237

125

561

593

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

109

127

61

297

297

5

23

9

38

179

185

169

533

571

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

86

119

94

298

298

16

7

14

37

209

197

188

594

631

49

Lampiran 6

Data hasil perlakuan P2 (Extender –KT 10% ) pada ulangan pertama

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

Jlh
total
NO+AN

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

MOTIL

1

H

60%

63

81

92

236

22

29

31

82

318

92

78

54

224

28

22

14

66

290

2

H1

50%

51

65

75

191

17

21

24

62

253

83

55

46

189

30

24

19

73

262

3

H2

45%

45

55

50

150

22

31

27

80

230

44

55

48

147

27

29

26

82

229

4

H3

40%

53

43

47

147

26

24

27

77

224

53

50

68

171

29

32

45

106

277

5

H4

30%

57

71

13

141

30

40

64

134

275

117

64

181

95

46

141

322

6

H5

20%

31

89

120

20

60

80

200

43

60

103

30

45

75

178

7

H6

15%

21

19

67

54

61

185

252

45

29

100

60

37

127

227

8

H7

5%

15

5

20

60

42

102

102

7

13

20

51

77

128

148

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

68

70

42

180

180

9

15

11

35

62

103

96

261

300

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

51

85

44

180

180

4

10

14

28

52

106

197

355

383

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

29

37

23

94

94

8

7

10

25

71

67

107

245

270

27

70

26

30

50

Lampiran 7

Data hasil perlakuan P2 (Extender –KT 10% ) pada ulangan kedua

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H

60%

90

60

70

220

17

9

7

33

253

80

76

93

249

15

14

21

50

299

2

H1

55%

116

66

73

255

35

20

31

86

341

61

123

70

254

23

40

19

82

336

3

H2

45%

80

53

57

190

35

22

19

76

265

56

46

43

145

14

18

17

49

194

4

H3

40%

48

56

61

165

15

19

22

56

221

76

52

56

184

23

19

25

67

251

5

H4

35%

41

52

72

165

74

92

128

294

459

47

67

83

197

97

119

124

340

537

6

H5

30%

67

61

83

211

133

128

194

455

666

27

14

41

75

36

111

152

7

H6

20%

43

79

122

96

144

240

362

53

70

123

141

175

175

316

439

8

H7

5%

5

5

3

13

44

51

43

138

151

4

5

4

13

33

42

37

112

125

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

45

67

81

193

193

11

7

5

23

77

57

45

179

202

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

34

37

58

129

129

5

4

8

17

43

37

62

142

159

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

64

69

32

165

165

7

4

3

14

65

55

29

149

163

51

Lampiran 8

Data hasil perlakuan P2 (Extender –KT 10% ) pada ulangan ketiga

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

9

14

41

312

72

87

57

216

19

24

16

59

275

1

H

65%

114

65

92

271

18

2

H1

60%

29

45

62

136

6

9

11

26

162

88

47

40

175

11

5

7

23

198

3

H2

55%

57

72

80

209

9

18

29

56

265

77

58

73

208

21

15

22

58

266

4

H3

50%

57

72

87

229

10

17

31

58

287

92

65

49

206

15

17

14

56

262

5

H4

50%

63

79

87

216

9

19

27

55

261

70

35

55

160

22

10

16

48

208

6

H5

35%

54

85

77

172

107

123

96

326

498

64

66

37

167

119

121

92

332

499

7

H6

35%

55

73

44

76

72

96

70

238

314

22

24

23

69

83

97

89

269

338

8

H7

20%

20

27

29

105

69

127

196

301

16

25

41

73

90

163

204

9

H8

5%

37

68

22

54

61

73

188

210

5

6

7

18

43

52

68

163

181

10

H9

0%

7

6

9

0

35

27

38

100

100

9

10

8

27

68

91

68

227

254

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

19

22

16

57

57

11

6

7

24

101

82

68

251

275

52

Lampiran 9

Data hasil perlakuan P2 (Extender –KT 10% ) pada ulangan keempat

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H

60%

108

95

90

293

20

14

9

43

336

69

93

102

264

13

17

23

53

317

2

H1

55%

76

60

92

228

12

21

33

66

294

88

74

90

252

24

19

27

70

322

3

H2

45%

92

63

84

239

40

26

28

94

333

76

59

58

193

19

23

23

65

258

4

H3

40%

55

62

73

190

17

21

26

64

254

102

71

68

241

31

26

30

87

328

5

H4

30%

18

26

31

75

53

65

80

198

273

26

22

29

77

72

78

101

251

328

6

H5

20%

37

33

60

130

75

72

104

251

381

83

43

88

214

141

65

140

346

560

7

H6

15%

33

40

44

117

56

89

75

220

337

24

34

80

138

57

76

106

239

377

8

H7

5%

10

16

7

23

88

163

100

351

373

9

16

11

36

74

134

102

310

346

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

83

42

22

147

147

14

22

11

47

204

242

130

576

623

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

217

42

56

315

315

10

28

14

52

184

190

174

548

600

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

85

72

87

244

244

21

12

19

52

214

102

193

509

561

53

Lampiran 10

Data hasil perlakuan P2 (Extender –KT 10% ) pada ulangan kelima

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

33

269

82

57

95

234

19

13

29

61

295

1

H

60%

89

77

70

236

15

8

10

2

H1

55%

89

75

101

265

14

25

35

74

339

106

94

110

310

29

24

35

88

398

3

H2

45%

85

73

99

257

38

30

33

101

358

96

80

72

248

24

31

28

83

331

4

H3

40%

75

83

96

254

23

28

34

85

339

85

91

50

226

26

33

21

80

306

5

H4

35%

14

16

22

52

80

79

92

251

303

31

28

33

92

118

98

86

302

394

6

H5

20%

8

18

19

45

67

82

87

236

281

19

17

28

64

80

96

102

272

336

7

H6

15%

22

17

35

74

84

80

95

259

333

61

33

79

173

129

73

150

352

525

8

H7

5%

15

11

4

30

132

112

57

301

331

14

7

18

39

116

58

167

341

380

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

77

44

220

342

342

15

29

13

48

225

280

125

630

678

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

215

64

79

358

358

15

22

17

54

185

202

174

561

615

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

80

75

82

237

237

19

13

14

46

214

196

193

513

559

54

Lampiran 11

Data hasil perlakuan P3 (Extender –KT 15% ) pada ulangan pertama

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

82

318

92

78

54

224

28

22

14

64

288

1

H

60%

68

81

92

236

22

29

31

2

H1

55%

73

92

106

271

27

29

38

94

365

87

92

73

252

26

35

21

82

334

3

H2

45%

96

92

114

302

45

40

41

126

428

97

81

90

268

33

34

30

97

365

4

H3

45%

106

103

100

309

53

48

39

140

449

82

90

69

241

33

43

28

104

345

5

H4

40%

118

113

120

351

59

56

50

165

516

99

99

73

271

45

51

35

131

402

6

H5

30%

59

55

46

160

130

123

124

377

537

110

87

77

265

36

29

15

80

345

7

H6

15%

46

55

35

136

114

132

110

356

492

27

25

18

275

100

90

85

70

345

8

H7

5%

15

14

10

39

101

122

100

323

362

16

14

19

49

103

91

89

283

332

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

77

44

220

321

321

14

28

10

52

215

290

125

630

682

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

215

64

79

358

358

15

20

19

54

185

112

174

471

525

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

80

75

82

237

237

19

13

15

47

119

106

193

518

565

55

Lampiran 12

Data hasil perlakuan P3 (Extender –KT 15% ) pada ulangan kedua

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

17

9

7

33

253

80

76

93

249

15

14

21

50

299

9

24

130

103

73

76

252

32

22

19

73

325

41

177

90

49

28

167

26

18

9

53

220

1

H

60%

90

60

70

220

2

H1

55%

31

35

40

106

8

7

3

H2

50%

51

85

136

14

27

4

H3

40%

46

41

48

135

12

10

11

33

168

51

62

75

188

12

17

23

52

240

5

H4

40%

41

52

76

169

13

17

23

53

222

36

41

61

138

19

19

26

64

202

6

H5

35%

27

14

42

79

54

133

175

20

25

45

55

90

145

190

7

H6

30%

15

9

8

32

41

23

26

90

122

9

7

16

37

25

62

78

8

H7

20%

20

13

16

49

85

61

77

223

272

15

22

13

50

53

76

47

156

206

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

134

114

98

346

346

5

7

9

21

135

105

190

430

451

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

65

57

76

198

198

11

16

23

50

167

183

153

503

553

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

90

43

69

202

202

14

5

8

27

160

178

107

445

472

56

Lampiran 13

Data hasil perlakuan P3 (Extender –KT 15% ) pada ulangan ketiga

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

14

42

313

72

87

57

216

19

24

16

59

275

1

H

65%

114

64

92

271

18

9

2

H1

60%

145

101

53

299

24

15

9

48

347

80

94

82

256

22

27

24

73

329

3

H2

50%

120

102

88

310

21

18

17

56

366

91

76

96

263

27

23

29

79

342

4

H3

50%

67

119

98

284

13

22

21

56

340

98

92

76

266

32

31

26

91

357

5

H4

45%

97

91

107

295

22

21

27

70

365

104

83

88

275

38

32

34

104

379

6

H5

45%

62

82

79

223

20

24

25

69

292

82

101

98

282

35

44

43

122

404

7

H6

40%

74

95

95

264

35

34

36

105

369

60

87

86

233

32

44

48

124

357

8

H7

35%

37

25

35

97

85

78

102

265

362

24

34

36

94

69

92

95

256

350

9

H8

30%

94

84

92

270

94

84

92

270

540

28

25

38

91

78

97

101

276

367

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

107

186

20

395

395

7

5

8

20

104

165

208

477

497

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

89

125

165

379

379

8

9

5

22

169

188

195

552

574

57

Lampiran 14

Data hasil perlakuan P3 (Extender –KT 15% ) pada ulangan keempat

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H

60%

108

95

90

246

20

14

9

34

280

69

93

102

231

13

17

23

69

300

2

H1

55%

76

115

71

341

16

19

17

52

393

118

88

81

287

27

21

23

71

358

3

H2

50%

100

61

84

232

24

13

11

48

280

100

71

56

227

26

20

19

65

292

4

H3

45%

75

75

40

234

22

20

17

59

293

69

89

73

231

22

29

29

80

311

5

H4

40%

95

101

12

236

33

32

13

78

314

78

95

78

251

30

36

36

102

353

6

H5

30%

24

18

14

54

81

76

49

296

350

28

25

38

91

83

76

91

250

341

7

H6

15%

19

22

55

76

95

60

231

286

20

27

25

72

72

88

81

241

313

8

H7

0%

0

0

0

0

89

84

96

279

279

4

3

7

14

108

128

201

437

451

9

H8

O%

0

0

0

0

85

79

109

273

273

7

9

2

18

199

195

187

581

599

10

H9

O%

0

0

0

0

94

87

93

274

274

4

8

10

22

167

134

128

429

451

11

H10

O%

0

0

0

0

58

69

73

200

200

9

6

5

20

106

145

99

350

370

58

Lampiran 15

Data hasil perlakuan P3 (Extender –KT 15% ) pada ulangan kelima

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H

60%

89

77

70

236

15

8

10

33

269

82

57

95

234

19

13

29

61

295

2

H1

55%

106

135

91

332

21

17

16

54

386

103

74

81

258

27

20

28

75

333

3

H2

55%

80

119

51

250

20

19

13

52

302

76

92

58

226

24

29

24

77

303

4

H3

45%

52

81

67

200

18

18

22

58

258

88

72

65

225

33

24

32

89

314

5

H4

40%

75

82

73

230

32

27

30

89

319

93

78

75

246

41

32

43

116

362

6

H5

30%

15

14

12

41

86

67

85

238

279

33

31

26

90

81

82

83

246

336

7

H6

10%

21

19

17

57

76

71

95

242

299

22

20

15

57

84

86

83

253

310

8

H7

5%

5

5

5

18

82

64

70

216

234

11

14

20

45

91

77

87

255

300

9

H8

0%

0

0

0

0

92

84

69

245

245

4

8

5

17

99

112

132

343

360

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

79

76

46

201

201

7

9

5

20

148

179

100

427

447

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

88

57

99

244

244

5

3

10

18

107

98

130

335

353

59

Lampiran 16

Data hasil perlakuan P4 (Extender –KT 20% ) pada ulangan pertama

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

78

54

224

28

22

14

64

288

1

H

60%

63

81

92

236

22

29

31

82

318

92

2

H1

50%

77

86

74

237

30

34

40

104

341

69

96

73

238

24

30

22

76

314

3

H2

40%

56

93

83

232

26

41

49

116

348

83

112

79

274

32

39

28

99

373

4

H3

40%

67

81

86

234

36

41

56

133

367

96

92

56

244

42

37

25

104

348

5

H4

35%

20

18

15

53

80

84

90

254

307

23

18

15

66

107

97

67

271

337

6

H5

30%

21

25

19

65

91

99

96

286

351

19

20

16

55

94

101

74

269

324

7

H6

15%

13

15

10

38

102

103

100

305

343

17

20

14

51

83

108

82

269

320

8

H7

5%

6

5

8

19

104

107

102

313

332

13

18

11

42

91

117

84

292

334

9

H8

0%

0

0

0

0

89

97

67

253

253

10

13

11

34

195

204

190

589

623

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

75

87

89

251

251

14

19

8

41

199

214

195

608

649

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

105

125

80

310

310

9

13

16

38

188

193

212

593

631

60

Lampiran 17

Data hasil perlakuan P4 (Extender –KT 20% ) pada ulangan kedua

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

60

70

220

17

9

7

33

253

80

76

93

249

15

14

21

50

299

1

H

60%

90

2

H1

50%

105

93

120

318

22

16

14

52

370

90

92

66

248

19

19

17

55

303

3

H2

50%

76

116

77

269

19

23

12

54

323

81

53

85

219

22

14

25

61

280

4

H3

50%

48

76

134

258

16

19

25

60

318

88

72

92

252

28

23

31

82

334

5

H4

45%

66

84

107

257

27

26

25

78

335

103

94

109

306

38

35

42

115

421

6

H5

40%

83

100

115

298

40

37

33

110

408

113

104

114

331

48

45

50

143

474

7

H6

35%

37

24

19

80

93

113

94

300

380

36

37

19

92

91

108

127

326

418

8

H7

10%

20

18

6

44

101

124

71

296

340

20

16

9

45

96

98

110

304

349

9

H8

0%

0

0

0

0

126

98

95

319

319

16

9

17

42

99

107

157

363

405

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

87

82

90

259

259

17

11

7

35

180

175

119

474

509

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

92

114

119

225

225

6

9

5

20

100

124

162

386

406

61

Lampiran 18

Data hasil perlakuan P4 (Extender –KT 20% ) pada ulangan ketiga

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

NORMAL
P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

ABNORMAL
P3

P1+P2+P3

Jlh total
NO+AN

MOTIL

1

H

65%

114

65

92

271

18

9

14

42

313

72

87

57

216

19

24

16

59

275

2

H1

60%

63

101

53

217

12

16

10

38

255

83

98

75

256

25

29

23

77

333

3

H2

50%

79

51

85

215

18

11

19

48

263

90

78

88

256

30

26

30

86

342

4

H3

50%

105

74

94

283

28

20

25

73

356

105

93

105

303

39

35

40

114

417

5

H4

45%

86

89

109

284

28

28

34

90

374

89

106

92

287

38

45

40

123

410

6

H5

45%

104

70

93

267

40

28

45

103

370

101

118

103

322

48

56

51

155

477

7

H6

45%

112

77

106

295

50

48

47

181

476

112

122

95

329

60

64

66

190

519

8

H7

30%

17

19

22

56

79

83

90

253

309

21

16

14

51

82

65

76

223

274

9

H8

30%

18

23

26

67

84

93

107

284

351

13

21

19

53

87

95

87

269

322

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

75

84

36

195

195

12

4

9

25

125

99

105

329

354

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

94

57

33

184

184

6

8

7

21

110

115

88

318

339

62

Lampiran 19
Data hasil perlakuan P4 (Extender –KT 20% ) pada ulangan keempat

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO

HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H

60%

108

95

90

246

20

14

19

34

280

69

93

102

231

13

17

23

69

300

2

H1

50%

81

24

29

134

19

24

29

72

206

101

109

75

285

23

24

21

71

356

3

H2

45%

26

31

29

86

26

31

29

86

172

61

81

82

224

18

22

28

68

292

4

H3

40%

36

31

35

102

36

31

35

102

204

71

99

64

234

27

33

28

88

322

5

H4

30%

38

30

36

104

38

30

36

104

208

84

84

69

237

39

35

37

111

348

6

H5

20%

15

17

21

53

75

82

100

257

310

22

14

12

48

123

97

66

286

334

7

H6

5%

8

7

10

25

877

90

87

264

289

8

7

6

21

85

94

75

257

278

8

H7

0%

0

0

0

0

108

123

78

309

309

11

14

9

34

194

204

175

573

607

9

H8

0%

0

0

0

0

86

90

75

251

251

12

7

6

25

197

107

132

436

461

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

78

89

90

257

257

8

7

7

23

108

134

122

364

387

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

121

65

119

305

305

3

9

4

16

189

190

197

40

56

63

Lampiran 20

Data hasil perlakuan P4 (Extender –KT 20% ) pada ulangan kelima

TIDAK TERSERAP
NO HARI

TERSERAP

Jlh total

NORMAL

ABNORMAL

Jlh total

MOTIL
P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

TT +T

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

P1

P2

P3

P1+P2+P3

NO+AN

1

H

60%

89

77

70

236

15

8

10

33

269

82

57

95

234

19

13

29

61

295

2

H1

50%

119

125

114

358

27

20

20

67

425

91

83

104

278

28

26

39

93

371

3

H2

45%

97

75

86

258

40

36

23

99

357

72

108

91

271

41

46

43

129

400

4

H3

40%

112

85

104

301

55

50

37

142

443

81

96

71

248

55

50

42

147

395

5

H4

20%

16

18

14

48

84

102

115

301

349

22

11

13

46

121

85

93

299

345

6

H5

5%

16

18

14

22

107

85

96

288

310

7

11

14

32

75

93

87

255

287

7

H6

0%

9

6

7

0

142

157

73

372

372

9

13

16

38

148

179

100

427

465

8

H7

0%

0

0

0

0

97

106

107

310

310

6

9

5

20

108

128

201

437

457

9

H8

0%

0

0

0

0

65

76

81

222

222

11

6

7

24

185

202

174

561

585

10

H9

0%

0

0

0

0

59

68

57

184

184

17

4

13

34

215

290

125

630

664

11

H10

0%

0

0

0

0

112

125

99

336

336

5

3

10

18

204

242

130

576

594

64

Lampiran 21

Rata-rata motilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
60
60
65
60
60
61,00
2,24
35
40
45
40
40
40,00
3,54
20
5
35
20
20
20,00
10,61
5
3
20
5
5
7,60
6,99
5
1
5
1
0
2,40
2,41
3
0
1
0
0
0,80
1,30
1
0
0
0
0
0,20
0,45
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00

65

Lampiran 22

Rata-rata motilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 10%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
60
60
65
60
60
61,00
2,24
50
55
60
55
55
55,00
3,54
45
45
55
45
45
47,00
4,47
40
40
50
40
40
42,00
4,47
30
35
50
30
35
36,00
8,22
20
30
35
20
20
25,00
7,07
15
20
35
15
15
20,00
8,66
5
5
20
5
5
8,00
6,71
0
0
5
0
0
1,00
2,24
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00

66

Lampiran 23

Rata-rata motilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 15%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
60
60
65
60
60
61,00
2,24
55
55
60
55
55
56,00
2,24
45
50
50
50
55
50,00
3,54
45
40
50
45
45
45,00
3,54
40
40
45
40
40
41,00
2,24
30
35
45
30
30
34,00
6,52
15
30
40
15
10
22,00
12,55
5
20
35
0
5
13,00
14,40
0
0
30
0
0
6,00
13,42
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00
0
0
0
0
0
0,00
0,00

67

Lampiran 24

Rata-rata motilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 20%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
I
II
III
IV
60
60
65
60
50
50
60
50
40
50
50
45
40
50
50
40
35
45
45
30
30
40
45
20
15
35
45
5
5
10
30
0
0
0
30
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

Ulangan
V
60
50
45
40
20
5
0
0
0
0
0

Ratarata

SD

Motilitas
61,00
52,00
46,00
44,00
35,00
28,00
20,00
9,00
6,00
0,00
0,00

2,24
4,47
4,18
5,48
10,61
16,05
19,36
12,45
13,42
0,00
0,00

68

Lampiran 25

Rata-rata viabilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
74,18
87,33
87,00
88,18
87,89
84,92
6,02
64,84
70,09
79,92
72,40
74,32
72,31
5,54
43,27
11,84
70,42
34,46
38,47
39,69
20,98
13,01
11,23
54,15
29,40
76,09
36,77
27,93
13,69
0,00
12,70
0,00
0,00
5,28
7,24
13,21
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,64
5,91
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

69

Lampiran 26

Rata-rata viabilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 10%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
I
II
III
IV
74,18
87,33
87,00
73,84
74,18
74,59
83,71
78,01
65,35
71,74
80,77
71,83
64,93
71,74
80,49
74,94
48,79
35,92
79,42
27,28
48,79
32,12
33,59
26,53
33,18
24,33
35,02
15,32
8,55
36,10
8,84
0,00
0,00
10,47
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

Ulangan
V
87,89
78,56
71,66
75,05
17,01
15,53
21,73
8,57
0,00
0,00
0,00

Ratarata

SD

Motilitas
82,05
77,81
72,27
72,10
41,68
32,51
28,16
15,47
2,09
0,00
0,00

7,34
3,84
5,50
5,70
24,10
13,60
5,72
11,89
4,68
0,00
0,00

70

Lampiran 27

Rata-rata viabilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 15%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
I
II
III
IV
74,18
83,84
87,00
87,48
74,21
81,48
86,12
86,08
70,44
80,35
84,64
83,22
68,94
77,35
83,50
79,81
68,04
76,02
80,87
75,21
29,72
38,35
76,31
20,56
27,43
26,99
71,35
19,24
10,77
17,94
26,72
0,00
0,00
0,00
50,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

Ulangan
V
87,89
85,78
81,97
77,13
72,07
14,84
19,31
7,84
0,00
0,00
0,00

Ratarata

SD

Motilitas
84,08
82,74
80,13
77,35
74,44
35,96
32,87
12,65
10,00
0,00
0,00

5,76
5,15
5,64
5,35
4,77
24,27
21,88
10,16
22,36
0,00
0,00

71

Lampiran 28

Rata-rata viabilitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 20%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
74,18
85,85
87,00
84,70
87,89
83,92
83,92
69,51
83,84
84,82
60,33
84,26
76,55
76,55
66,86
83,32
81,81
50,00
72,42
70,88
70,88
65,53
79,76
78,89
55,93
67,93
69,61
69,61
18,48
76,13
75,91
50,00
13,95
46,89
46,89
17,31
72,73
72,10
17,06
7,05
37,25
37,25
11,04
20,93
66,67
8,65
0,00
21,46
21,46
5,73
12,33
18,66
0,00
0,00
7,34
7,34
0,00
0,00
19,01
0,00
0,00
3,80
3,80
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

72

Lampiran 29

Rata-rata normalitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
78,03
83,41
78,53
77,84
79,74
79,51
2,30
61,66
72,10
77,98
66,78
72,82
70,27
6,24
39,00
24,62
71,51
71,51
68,31
54,99
21,80
39,50
24,60
66,95
26,37
21,01
35,68
18,82
28,09
16,91
21,70
13,63
13,31
18,73
6,23
21,46
12,96
13,45
9,27
10,78
13,58
4,72
16,28
11,85
11,11
8,44
8,95
11,33
3,12
15,64
11,56
9,47
8,16
8,67
10,70
3,05
12,97
9,08
8,16
5,42
6,28
8,38
2,95
12,01
8,48
5,42
5,23
5,82
7,39
2,90
11,47
5,88
4,92
3,86
5,20
6,26
3,00

73

Lampiran 30

Rata-rata normalitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 10%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
78,03
83,41
88,13
83,43
79,74
82,55
3,91
71,28
75,58
78,56
78,35
78,01
76,36
3,08
64,10
74,51
78,53
74,52
74,69
73,27
5,40
61,93
73,05
78,29
73,09
73,46
71,96
6,03
44,41
36,25
77,11
38,49
32,58
45,77
18,04
11,89
11,15
29,23
34,52
23,59
22,08
10,39
9,38
10,53
20,44
23,61
18,59
16,51
6,26
7,47
10,40
10,71
10,41
10,42
9,88
1,36
0,00
8,00
10,03
9,47
9,21
7,34
4,17
0,00
0,00
8,66
8,48
8,61
5,15
4,70
0,00
0,00
0,00
7,52
7,45
2,99
4,10

74

Lampiran 31

Rata-rata normalitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 15%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
78,03
83,41
78,53
83,43
79,74
80,63
2,63
78,01
78,65
77,83
80,00
77,42
78,38
1,01
76,89
77,71
76,90
77,35
74,25
76,62
1,37
73,35
75,47
74,90
74,27
71,58
73,91
1,52
70,04
67,97
72,51
71,05
67,96
69,91
1,98
67,45
22,06
69,75
26,48
26,74
42,50
23,91
20,16
9,10
65,27
22,93
18,31
27,15
21,93
14,79
5,91
26,76
5,54
14,95
13,59
8,67
10,83
4,78
24,75
5,07
4,86
10,06
8,60
8,71
0,00
4,32
3,08
4,73
4,17
3,14
7,44
0,00
3,86
2,96
4,69
3,79
2,70

75

Lampiran 32

Rata-rata normalitas pada pengencer Two-step tm E xtender-KT 20%

MOTIL
HARI
H
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

MOTIL

Ratarata

SD
Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan Ulangan
Motilitas
I
II
III
IV
V
78,03
83,41
78,53
83,43
80,13
80,71
2,60
76,10
81,66
76,85
80,51
75,11
78,05
2,87
73,39
78,34
74,86
76,80
67,42
74,16
4,21
70,01
75,48
72,66
72,34
62,71
70,64
4,84
17,21
72,70
69,99
67,99
13,04
48,19
30,26
17,04
69,83
67,49
14,39
10,99
35,95
29,95
15,74
22,29
63,24
7,65
8,77
23,54
22,96
12,47
12,95
18,57
5,76
6,04
11,16
5,36
6,22
10,48
16,34
5,56
4,75
8,67
4,83
5,97
6,70
6,85
5,41
4,12
5,81
1,11
5,45
5,14
6,35
2,53
3,59
4,61
1,53

76

Lampiran 33

1. Analisis Motilitas
ANOVA

H

H1

H2

H3

H4

H5

H6

H7

H8

H9

H10

Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total

Sum of
Squares

df

,000
80,000
80,000
813,750
200,000
1013,750
2913,750
650,000
3563,750
4901,350
445,200
5346,550
4679,600
763,200
5442,800
3192,150
1406,800
4598,950
1584,150
2430,800
4014,950
393,750
1730,000
2123,750
135,000
720,000
855,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000

3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19

Mean
Square

F

,000
5,000

Sig.
,000

1,000

271,250
12,500

21,700

,000

971,250
40,625

23,908

,000

1633,783
27,825

58,716

,000

1559,867
47,700

32,702

,000

1064,050
87,925

12,102

,000

528,050
151,925

3,476

,041

131,250
108,125

1,214

,337

45,000
45,000

1,000

,418

,000
,000

.

.

,000
,000

.

.

77

Lampiran 34

Multiple Comparisons
Bonferroni
Depen
(I)
dent
Kelompo
Varia
k
ble

H

H1

H2

H3

(J) Kelompok

Extender 10KT
Extender Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 15KT
10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
20KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Entender Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 15KT
10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
20KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Extender Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 15KT
10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
20KT
Extender 15KT
Extender Extender 10KT

Mean
Difference
(I-J)

Std.
Error

Sig.

95% Confidence
Interval
Lower
Upper
Bound
Bound

,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
,00000
-15,00000*
-16,00000*
-12,00000*
15,00000*
-1,00000
3,00000
16,00000*
1,00000
4,00000
12,00000*
-3,00000
-4,00000
-27,00000*
-30,00000*
-26,00000*
27,00000*
-3,00000
1,00000
30,00000*
3,00000
4,00000
26,00000*
-1,00000
-4,00000
-34,40000*

1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
1,41421
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
2,23607
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
4,03113
3,33617

1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
,556
,000
1,000
,556
,000
,000
,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000

-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-4,2544
-21,7268
-22,7268
-18,7268
8,2732
-7,7268
-3,7268
9,2732
-5,7268
-2,7268
5,2732
-9,7268
-10,7268
-39,1270
-42,1270
-38,1270
14,8730
-15,1270
-11,1270
17,8730
-9,1270
-8,1270
13,8730
-13,1270
-16,1270
-44,4363

4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
4,2544
-8,2732
-9,2732
-5,2732
21,7268
5,7268
9,7268
22,7268
7,7268
10,7268
18,7268
3,7268
2,7268
-14,8730
-17,8730
-13,8730
39,1270
9,1270
13,1270
42,1270
15,1270
16,1270
38,1270
11,1270
8,1270
-24,3637

78

Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Extender
Extender
10KT
H4
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Extender
Extender
10KT
H5
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Extender
Extender
10KT
H6
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
H7

Extender

Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT

-37,40000*
-36,40000*
34,40000*
-3,00000
-2,00000
37,40000*
3,00000
1,00000
36,40000*
2,00000
-1,00000
-33,60000*
-38,60000*
-32,60000*
33,60000*
-5,00000
1,00000
38,60000*
5,00000
6,00000
32,60000*
-1,00000
-6,00000
-24,20000*
-33,20000*
-27,20000*
24,20000*
-9,00000
-3,00000
33,20000*
9,00000
6,00000
27,20000*
3,00000
-6,00000
-19,80000
-21,80000
-19,80000
19,80000
-2,00000
,00000
21,80000
2,00000
2,00000
19,80000
,00000
-2,00000
-8,00000
-12,00000
-9,00000

3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
3,33617
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
4,36807
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
5,93043
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
7,79551
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647

,000
,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,000
1,000
1,000
,005
,000
,002
,005
,892
1,000
,000
,892
1,000
,002
1,000
1,000
,131
,078
,131
,131
1,000
1,000
,078
1,000
1,000
,131
1,000
1,000
1,000
,521
1,000

-47,4363
-46,4363
24,3637
-13,0363
-12,0363
27,3637
-7,0363
-9,0363
26,3637
-8,0363
-11,0363
-46,7406
-51,7406
-45,7406
20,4594
-18,1406
-12,1406
25,4594
-8,1406
-7,1406
19,4594
-14,1406
-19,1406
-42,0407
-51,0407
-45,0407
6,3593
-26,8407
-20,8407
15,3593
-8,8407
-11,8407
9,3593
-14,8407
-23,8407
-43,2515
-45,2515
-43,2515
-3,6515
-25,4515
-23,4515
-1,6515
-21,4515
-21,4515
-3,6515
-23,4515
-25,4515
-27,7842
-31,7842
-28,7842

-27,3637
-26,3637
44,4363
7,0363
8,0363
47,4363
13,0363
11,0363
46,4363
12,0363
9,0363
-20,4594
-25,4594
-19,4594
46,7406
8,1406
14,1406
51,7406
18,1406
19,1406
45,7406
12,1406
7,1406
-6,3593
-15,3593
-9,3593
42,0407
8,8407
14,8407
51,0407
26,8407
23,8407
45,0407
20,8407
11,8407
3,6515
1,6515
3,6515
43,2515
21,4515
23,4515
45,2515
25,4515
25,4515
43,2515
23,4515
21,4515
11,7842
7,7842
10,7842

79

H8

Entender
Extender
Extender 15KT
10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
20KT
Extender 15KT
Extender 10KT
Extender Extender 15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 15KT
10KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
15KT
Extender 20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender 10KT
20KT
Extender 15KT

8,00000
-4,00000
-1,00000
12,00000
4,00000
3,00000
9,00000
1,00000
-3,00000
,00000
,00000
-6,00000
,00000
,00000
-6,00000
,00000
,00000
-6,00000
6,00000
6,00000
6,00000

6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
6,57647
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264
4,24264

1,000
1,000
1,000
,521
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000

-11,7842
-23,7842
-20,7842
-7,7842
-15,7842
-16,7842
-10,7842
-18,7842
-22,7842
-12,7633
-12,7633
-18,7633
-12,7633
-12,7633
-18,7633
-12,7633
-12,7633
-18,7633
-6,7633
-6,7633
-6,7633

27,7842
15,7842
18,7842
31,7842
23,7842
22,7842
28,7842
20,7842
16,7842
12,7633
12,7633
6,7633
12,7633
12,7633
6,7633
12,7633
12,7633
6,7633
18,7633
18,7633
18,7633

80

Lampiran 35
Bootstrap for Multiple Comparisons
Bonferroni
Depen
(I)
dent
Kelompo
Varia
k
ble

Extender

Extender
10KT
H
Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

Extender

H1

Extender
10KT

Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

(J)
Kelompok
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT

Mean
Differen
ce (I-J)

Bias

Bootstrapa
BCa 95% Confidence
Std.
Interval
Error
Lower
Upper

,00000

-,00917b

1,40210b

-2,50000b,c

2,50000b

,00000

-,01006f

1,33371f

-2,50000c,f

2,51938f

,00000

-,02860h

1,38003h

-2,62394c,h

2,50000h

,00000

,00917b

1,40210b

-2,50000b,c

2,50000b

,00000

,00081k

1,34631k

-2,50000c,k

2,50000k

,00000

-,02259m 1,39079m

-2,50000c,m

2,50000m

,00000

,01006f

1,33371f

-2,51938c,f

2,50000f

,00000

-,00081k

1,34631k

-2,50000c,k

2,50000k

,00000

-,01836b

1,35893b

-2,50000b,c

2,50000b

,00000

,02860h

1,38003h

-2,50000c,h

2,62394h

,00000

,02259m

1,39079m

-2,50000c,m

2,50000m

,00000

,01836b

1,35893b

-2,50000b,c

2,50000b

-15,00000 -,07391d

2,15717d

-19,32949c,d

-16,00000 -,04112g

1,77434g

-19,76190c,g

10,83333d
12,50000g

-12,00000 -,08169i

2,49674i

-17,50000c,i

-7,50000i

15,00000

,07391d

2,15717d

10,83333c,d

19,32949d

-1,00000

,03590h

1,77558h

-4,60388c,h

2,50000h

3,00000

-,01013n

2,48303n

-2,40735c,n

7,50000n

16,00000

,04112g

1,77434g

12,50000c,g

19,76190g

1,00000

-,03590h

1,77558h

-2,50000c,h

4,60388h

4,00000

-,04117d

2,16153d

-,67487c,d

7,50000d

12,00000

,08169i

2,49674i

7,50000c,i

17,50000i

-3,00000

,01013n

2,48303n

-7,50000c,n

2,40735n

81

Extender

Extender
10KT
H2
Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

Extender

Extender
10KT
H3
Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

H4

Entender

Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT

,04117d

2,16153d

-7,50000c,d

,67487d

-27,00000 -,13067d

4,96615d

-36,72411c,d

-30,00000 -,10092g

4,86633g

-40,00000c,g

17,50000d
20,81284g

-26,00000 -,14278i

4,87088i

-35,50000c,i -16,41101i

27,00000

,13067d

4,96615d

17,50000c,d

36,72411d

-3,00000

,03015h

2,47747h

-7,09801c,h

2,41030h

1,00000

-,01894n

2,66621n

-3,75000c,n

6,66667n

30,00000

,10092g

4,86633g

20,81284c,g

40,00000g

3,00000

-,03015h

2,47747h

-2,41030c,h

7,09801h

4,00000

-,04304d

2,41589d

-,72044c,d

8,75000d

26,00000

,14278i

4,87088i

16,41101c,i

35,50000i

-1,00000

,01894n

2,66621n

-6,66667c,n

3,75000n

-4,00000

,04304d

2,41589d

-8,75000c,d

,72044d

-34,40000 -,03970d

3,63279d

-41,00000c,d

-37,40000 -,08792g

3,31475g

-42,83333c,g

27,50000d
30,00000g

-36,40000 -,04079i

3,76105i

-43,00000c,i -28,73634i

34,40000

,03970d

3,63279d

27,50000c,d

41,00000d

-3,00000

-,05334h

2,44604h

-7,29070c,h

2,00000h

-2,00000

-,01177n

3,09677n

-8,00000c,n

4,00000n

37,40000

,08792g

3,31475g

30,00000c,g

42,83333g

3,00000

,05334h

2,44604h

-2,00000c,h

7,29070h

1,00000

,04932d

2,79281d

-5,00000c,d

6,25000d

36,40000

,04079i

3,76105i

28,73634c,i

43,00000i

2,00000

,01177n

3,09677n

-4,00000c,n

8,00000n

-1,00000

-,04932d

2,79281d

-6,25000c,d

5,00000d

-33,60000

,03983d

3,74635d

-42,02872c,d

-38,60000

,02725g

1,38749g

-41,47912c,g

27,62069d
36,00000g

-32,60000 -,05501i

4,62839i

-41,77459c,i -23,20083i

-4,00000

82

Extender
10KT

Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

Entender

Extender
10KT
H5
Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

Entender

H6
Extender
10KT

Extender
15KT

Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT

33,60000

-,03983d

3,74635d

27,62069c,d

42,02872d

-5,00000

-,00939h

3,65985h

-10,66667c,h

2,93721h

1,00000

-,11915n

5,80668n

-9,51848c,n

12,53696n

38,60000

-,02725g

1,38749g

36,00000c,g

41,47912g

5,00000

,00939h

3,65985h

-2,93721c,h

10,66667h

6,00000

-,08120d

4,60526d

-3,75000c,d

15,22987d

32,60000

,05501i

4,62839i

23,20083c,i

41,77459i

-1,00000

,11915n

5,80668n

-12,53696c,n

9,51848n

-6,00000

,08120d

4,60526d

-15,22987c,d

3,75000d

-24,20000

,06114d

3,13542d

-31,04310c,d

-33,20000

,05774g

2,79521g

-39,00000c,g

18,80000d
28,66667g

-27,20000 -,12340i

6,87293i

-40,83333c,i -12,54236i

24,20000

-,06114d

3,13542d

18,80000c,d

-9,00000

,01272h

4,09623h

-16,79061c,h -1,43837h

-3,00000

-,21879n

7,61111n

-17,57920c,n 12,01848n

33,20000

-,05774g

2,79521g

28,66667c,g

39,00000g

9,00000

-,01272h

4,09623h

1,43837c,h

16,79061h

6,00000

-,17900d

7,39776d

-8,33333c,d

21,66667d

27,20000

,12340i

6,87293i

12,54236c,i

40,83333i

3,00000

,21879n

7,61111n

-12,01848c,n 17,57920n

-6,00000

,17900d

7,39776d

-21,66667c,d

8,33333d

-19,80000

,02428d

3,74870d

-28,16780c,d

-21,80000

,16854g

5,28152g

-32,35095c,g

14,66667d
12,19590g

-19,80000 -,07724i

8,38105i

-38,31925c,i

-3,34836i

19,80000

-,02428d

3,74870d

14,66667c,d

28,16780d

-2,00000

,17408h

6,47360h

-14,16667c,h 11,01761h

,00000

-,13281n

9,34410n

-19,19307c,n 17,54620n

21,80000

-,16854g

5,28152g

12,19590c,g

2,00000

-,17408h

6,47360h

-11,01761c,h 14,16667h

31,04310d

32,35095g

83

Extender
20KT

Extender

Extender
10KT
H7
Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

Entender

Extender
10KT
H8
Extender
15KT

Extender
20KT

Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
10KT
Extender
15KT

2,00000

-,23363d

9,88908d

19,80000

,07724i

8,38105i

,00000

,13281n

9,34410n

-17,54620c,n 19,19307n

-2,00000

,23363d

9,88908d

-21,07757c,d 17,58617d

-8,00000

-,00484d

2,87821d

-15,00000c,d -5,00000d

-12,00000

,13346g

6,39750g

-25,00000c,g

,00000g

-9,00000

-,08229i

5,44329i

-20,83333c,i

,00000i

8,00000

,00484d

2,87821d

5,00000c,d

15,00000d

-4,00000

,17061h

6,99851h

-18,33333c,h

8,75000h

-1,00000

-,09338n

6,25723n

-15,00000c,n 10,03696n

12,00000

-,13346g

6,39750g

,00000c,g

25,00000g

4,00000

-,17061h

6,99851h

-8,75000c,h

18,33333h

3,00000

-,20619d

8,45809d

-13,68103c,d 18,75000d

9,00000

,08229i

5,44329i

1,00000

,09338n

6,25723n

-10,03696c,n 15,00000n

-3,00000

,20619d

8,45809d

-18,75000c,d 13,68103d

,00000

,00000e

,00000e

,00000c,e

,00000e

,00000

,00000e

,00000e

,00000c,e

,00000e

4,12462j

-20,00000c,j

-3,75000j

,00000

3,03601j
,00000e

,00000e

,00000c,e

,00000e

,00000

,00000l

,00000l

,00000c,l

,00000l

4,12865e

,00000

3,05187e
,00000e

,00000e

,00000c,e

,00000e

,00000

,00000l

,00000l

,00000c,l

,00000l

4,12354e

6,00000

3,05455e
3,03601j

4,12462j

3,75000c,j

20,00000j

6,00000

3,05187e

4,12865e

3,75000c,e

20,00000e

6,00000

3,05455e

4,12354e

3,75000c,e

20,00000e

-6,00000

-6,00000

-6,00000

-17,58617c,d 21,07757d
3,34836c,i

,00000c,i

38,31925i

20,83333i

-20,00000c,e -3,75000e

-20,00000c,e -3,75000e

84

Lampiran 36

2. Analisis Viabilitas
ANOVA

H

H1

H2

H3

H4

H5

H6

H7

H8

H9

H10

Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total

Sum of
Squares
21,842
613,366
635,208
274,522
806,048
1080,571
4671,461
2731,273
7402,734
5822,998
3892,884
9715,883
12173,195
6440,418
18613,612
4236,531
7668,503
11905,034
3163,118
4822,888
7986,007
694,817
1241,100
1935,917
278,347
2376,801
2655,147
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000

df
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19
3
16
19

Mean
Square
7,281
38,335

F

Sig.

,190

,902

91,507
50,378

1,816

,185

1557,154
170,705

9,122

,001

1940,999
243,305

7,978

,002

4057,732
402,526

10,081

,001

1412,177
479,281

2,946

,065

1054,373
301,431

3,498

,040

231,606
77,569

2,986

,062

92,782
148,550

,625

,609

,000
,000

.

.

,000
,000

.

.

85

Lampiran 37

Multiple Comparisons
Bonferroni
Depen
(J)
dent
(I)
Varia Kelompok Kelompo
k
ble
Extender
10KT
Extender
Entender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender
15KT
10KT
Extender
H
20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender
10KT
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender
10KT
20KT
Extender
15KT
Extender
H1
10KT
Extender
Entender
15KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender
15KT
10KT
Extender
20KT
Entender
Extender
Extender
10KT
15KT
Extender
20KT

95% Confidence
Interval
Lower
Upper
Bound
Bound

Mean
Differenc
e (I-J)

Std.
Error

Sig.

2,86800

3,91588

1,000

-8,9123

14,6483

,83800

3,91588

1,000

-10,9423

12,6183

1,39400

3,91588

1,000

-10,3863

13,1743

-2,86800

3,91588

1,000

-14,6483

8,9123

-2,03000

3,91588

1,000

-13,8103

9,7503

-1,47400

3,91588

1,000

-13,2543

10,3063

-,83800

3,91588

1,000

-12,6183

10,9423

2,03000

3,91588

1,000

-9,7503

13,8103

,55600

3,91588

1,000

-11,2243

12,3363

-1,39400

3,91588

1,000

-13,1743

10,3863

1,47400

3,91588

1,000

-10,3063

13,2543

-,55600

3,91588

1,000

-12,3363

11,2243

-5,75000

4,48901

1,000

-19,2544

7,7544

4,48901
10,42000

,203

-23,9244

3,0844

-4,64000

4,48901

1,000

-18,1444

8,8644

5,75000

4,48901

1,000

-7,7544

19,2544

-4,67000

4,48901

1,000

-18,1744

8,8344

1,11000

4,48901

1,000

-12,3944

14,6144

10,42000 4,48901

,203

-3,0844

23,9244

4,67000

4,48901

1,000

-8,8344

18,1744

5,78000

4,48901

1,000

-7,7244

19,2844

86

Extender
20KT

Entender

Entender 4,64000
Extender
-1,11000
10KT
Extender
-5,78000
15KT
Extender
32,40800
10KT
*

4,48901

1,000

-8,8644

18,1444

4,48901

1,000

-14,6144

12,3944

4,48901

1,000

-19,2844

7,7244

8,26328

,007

-57,2667

-7,5493

Extender
39,79800 8,26328
15KT
*

,001

-64,6567

-14,9393

Extender
31,19000 8,26328
20KT
*

,010

-56,0487

-6,3313

,007

7,5493

57,2667

1,