Disadvantages of Jigsaw Technique

technique in the class to give the students opportunity to understand text they are reading by interacting with their friends about the text. The jigsaw activity allows the students to comprehend a text by understanding this text in their own group. The jigsaw activity also allows students to communicate with their teammate about the material so they can develop their reading skill, and also their communication skill. In general, the Jigsaw technique is assumed by the writer as a technique that can help students to get better understanding in reading and also as a technique that can give students opportunity to develop their: a. Positive interdependence, which means that every group member is reliant to their teammates’ understanding about a text to get a full comprehension about the text. b. Individual accountability which means that each student is responsible to another group member’s understanding about a text, so that every group member should master their part well. c. Communication skills in which students work in small heterogeneous group in jigsaw technique so that every student gets the same opportunity to make an oral interaction so that they get chance develop their communication skill. d. Purposeful talk which means that every student can get a better understanding of the text because they get the explanation about the text from their own teammates’ which are using familiar English words to describe the concept.

F. Relevant Studies

In implementing the study, several relevant studies that discuss the effectiveness of certain technique in promoting students’ achievement are taken as a guideline. First, a skripsi 37 written in 2011 by Inayati entitled The Effectiveness of Jigsaw Technique in Improving Students’ Reading Comprehension at the Eighth Grade of SMP Islam Parung. This research conclude to a result that the use of 37 Megasari Nurul Inayati, The Effectiveness of Jigsaw Technique in Improving Students’ Reading Comprehension at the Eighth Grade of SMP Islam Parung, Jakarta: Department of English Education, 2011, p. i. jigsaw technique is more effective in teaching reading comprehension than the use of Grammar Translation Method that proven by the experimental class’ gain score which higher than control class’ gain score. Consequently, a skripsi 38 written in 2010 by by Solekha entitled “The Effectiveness of Interactive Learning in Teaching Narrative Text”. This study is purposed to describe the objective condition of the effectiveness of interactive learning in teaching narrative text at the second grade of SMA Muhammadiyah 8 Ciputat. The result of the study shows that teaching narrative text by using interactive learning is effective which can be seen from the students’ score in the data analysis. Finally, a skripsi 39 entitled “The Effectiveness of Group Work in Teaching Reading” by Ulfah from University Islam Negeri Syarif Hidayatullah, Jakarta. The results revealed that teaching reading by using group work is more effective than teaching reading without using group work. The similarity of all the researches above with this skripsi is that this skripsi was aimed to measure the effectiveness of a certain technique in teaching a material in English language teaching. On the other hand, unlike the previous researches that have been explained above, this skripsi was focused on the effectiveness of Jigsaw technique on students’ ability in exposition text.

G. Research Hypotheses

This research was aimed to find the empirical evidence whether or not Jigsaw technique is effective on students’ ability in reading exposition text. To accomplish this objective, two hypotheses were proposed to be tested, which are: H : Jigsaw technique has no significant effectiveness in learning reading of exposition text. H a : Jigsaw technique has significant effectiveness in learning reading of exposition text. 38 Nur Ajeng Solekha, The Effectiveness of Interactive Learning in Teaching Narrative Text, Jakarta: Department of English Education, 2010, p. iv. 39 Maria Ulfah, The Effectiveness of Group Work in Teaching Reading, Jakarta: Department of English Education, 2010, p. iv.

Dokumen yang terkait

The Effectiveness of Pictures in Text in Improving Students’ Reading Comprehension (A Quasi-experimental Study at the Eight Grade Students of MTsN 13 Jakarta).

0 18 178

Comparing The Effectiveness Of Using Jigsaw Technique And Students Team Achievement Divisions Technique In Enhancing Students’ Reading Comprehension (A Quasi Experimental Research At Second Grade Students Of Mts Salafiyah Depok)

2 44 148

The effectiveness of using mind mapping technique on students’ reading of narrative text: a quasi-experimental study at the second grade of MAN 19 Jakarta

0 4 181

The Effectiveness of Using Jigsaw Technique to Develop Students’ Reading Comprehension on Narrative Text; A Quasi Experimental Study at the Eleventh Grade Students of SMA Negeri 63 Jakarta Selatan

0 6 139

The Effectiveness Of Using Reading, Encoding, Annotating And Pondering (Reap) Technique Towards Students’ Reading Skill Of Descriptive Text (A Quasi-Experimental Study At The Seventh Grade Of Mts Salafiyah)

5 18 138

The Effectiveness of Jigsaw Technique in Teacihing Reading Conprehension : An Experimental Study at the Second Grade of MAN 2 Bekasi

0 6 61

The Effectiveness of Using Teams Games Tournaments (TGT) in Teaching Reading of Narrative Text, (A Quasi-Experimental Study at the Second Year Students of SMPN I Pakuhaji)

0 10 0

The Effectiveness of Teaching Verbs by Using Cooperative Learning (A-Quasi Experimental Study at the Second Year Students of SMPN 169 Jakarta)

0 4 158

THE IMPLEMENTATION OF JIGSAW TECHNIQUE IN TEACHING READING COMPREHENSION AT SECOND YEAR STUDENTS OF SMAN1 KRUI

0 21 58

THE EFFECTIVENESS OF JIGSAW TECHNIQUE IN TEACHING READING RECOUNT TEXT (AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY AT THE SECOND GRADE STUDENTS OF SMP N 1 KALIMANAH IN ACADEMIC YEAR 2013/2014) - repository perpustakaan

0 0 11