Plant Science 156 2000 235 – 244
Analysis of transgenic grapevine Vitis rupestris and Nicotiana benthamiana plants expressing an Arabis mosaic 6irus coat protein
gene
Albert Spielmann
a,
, Stoyanka Krastanova
b
, Ve´ronique Douet-Orhant
a
, Paul Gugerli
c
a
Laboratoire de biochimie, Uni6ersite´ de Neuchaˆtel, Emile-Argand
11
,
2007
Neuchaˆtel, Switzerland
b
ProfigenAgri6itis, Columbia Crest Dri6e, PO Box
188
, Paterson, WA
99345
, USA
c
Station Fe´de´rale de Recherches en Production Ve´ge´tale de Changins,
1260
Nyon, Switzerland Received 13 September 1999; received in revised form 20 March 2000; accepted 20 March 2000
Abstract
A disarmed LBA4404 strain of Agrobacterium tumefaciens harboring a binary vector which contained chimeric genes encoding the neomycin phosphotransferase npt II and the coat protein CP of Arabis mosaic nepo6irus ArMV was used in co-cultivation
experiments with leaf discs of Nicotiana benthamiana and somatic embryos of the grapevine rootstock cultivar Vitis rupestris. Transgenic N. benthamiana expressing the ArMV CP gene were regenerated and six independent lines were characterized.
Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay ELISA performed on leaf tissue demonstrated the accumulation of the ArMV CP in five of the six lines analyzed. Immunosorbent electron microscopy ISEM studies revealed the presence of virion-like isometric
particles VLPs reacting to a rabbit antiserum specific to ArMV virions. ArMV-CP expressing transgenic N. benthamiana lines showed protection against ArMV expressed as a delay in infection and a reduction of the percentage of infected plants. Four
independent transgenic lines of V. rupestris transformed with the ArMV CP gene were regenerated and characterized. In contrast to N. benthamiana, transgenic V. rupestris did not accumulate the ArMV CP at levels detectable by ELISA and no VLPs could
be observed by ISEM. Northern blot analysis showed that the ArMV CP mRNA was expressed at lower level in V. rupestris compared with N. benthamiana. The reason for this difference in transgene expression andor mRNA stability between grapevine
and N. benthamiana is unclear, but the genetic state of the transgenes homozygous in N. benthamiana versus hemizygous in V. rupestris may have an effect on gene expression. © 2000 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords
:
Coat protein-mediated virus resistance; Nepovirus; Grapevine; Nicotiana benthamiana; Plant virus resistance www.elsevier.comlocateplantsci
1. Introduction
Nepoviruses are plant viruses with polyedric particles which are transmitted via soil-inhabiting
longidorid nematodes Xiphinema and Longidorus spp.. They are responsible for economically im-
portant diseases, especially of perennial plants such as grapevine and fruit trees. Their genome is
composed of two separately encapsidated positive single-stranded RNAs. In grapevine, the most
damaging and
widespread nepoviruses
are Grape6ine fanleaf 6irus GFLV and Arabis mosaic
6 irus ArMV, both responsible for the disease
known as infectious degeneration or ‘court-noue´’. The disease is controlled by soil disinfection using
nematicides. This
procedure is
forbidden in
Switzerland, Germany, Italy and some States in the USA, due to the high toxicity of the chemical
dichlorpropen. Virus-resistant
transgenic grapevine plants would be an ecological alterna-
tive to control the disease. Since the first report on resistance to Tobacco
mosaic 6irus TMV in transgenic tobacco plants expressing TMV coat protein CP [1], similar
results have been obtained for a broad spectrum
Corresponding author. Tel.: + 41-32-7182222; fax: + 41-32- 7182201.
E-mail address
:
albert.spielmannbota.unine.ch A. Spielmann. 0168-945200 - see front matter © 2000 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S0168-94520000259-4
of plant viruses [2]. CP-mediated protection against nepoviruses has been demonstrated in transgenic
Nicotiana benthamiana expressing the ArMV CP gene [3], the Tomato ringspot 6irus CP gene [4], or
the GFLV CP gene [5], and in transgenic N. tabacum expressing the Strawberry latent ringspot 6irus CP
gene [6], or the Grape6ine chrome mosaic 6irus CP gene [7]. The formation of virus-like particles result-
ing from the accumulation of transgenic nepovirus CP in plant tissues was demonstrated for the ArMV
CP in N. benthamiana [8]. Genetic transformation of various grapevine tissues and regeneration of
transgenic plants have been reported for a number of grapevine rootstocks and cultivars [9]. Recents
reports described the regeneration of transgenic grapevine plants expressing a chimeric GFLV CP
gene after transformation of somatic embryos of the rootstock cvs 110 Richter [10,11], Gloire de Mont-
pellier, 3309 Couderc, Millardet de Grasset 101-14 [11], 41B and SO4, and the Vitis 6inifera variety
Chardonnay [12]. In these cases, expression of the GFLV CP transgene leads to the accumulation of
the CP in transgenic tissue detected by ELISA, but the presence of virion-like isometric particles
VLPs was not reported.
In this paper, we describe the expression of a chimeric ArMV CP gene in an annual herbaceous
species, N. benthamiana, and a woody perennial species, V. rupestris. The transgenic N. benthamiana
lines expressed the ArMV CP gene at high levels and accumulation of ArMV CP resulted in the forma-
tion of VLPs in plant tissue. In contrast, none of the transgenic V. rupestris lines accumulated the ArMV
CP at a detectable level. Data from northern blot experiments showed that the apparent lack of
ArMV CP protein accumulation in V. rupestris tissue was correlated to differences in transgene
expression levels andor RNA stability in grapevine tissues compared with N. benthamiana. Little or no
transgene mRNA could be detected in transgenic grapevine tissues. Progeny of ArMV CP-expressing
transgenic N. benthamiana lines showed resistance against ArMV.
2. Materials and methods