Kesimpulan Saran Pemodelan jaringan saraf tiruan (artificial neural networks) untuk identifikasi kawanan lemuru dengan menggunakan deskriptor hidroakustik

8 KESIMPULAN DAN SARAN

8.1 Kesimpulan

Dalam disertasi ini Metode JSTPB dan Analisis Statistik digunakan untuk melakukan identifikasi dan klasifikasi kawanan lemuru, protolan, sempenit, campuran dan non-lemuru. Hasil penelitian ini menunjukkan bahwa kecepatan dan ketelitian identifikasi dan klasifikasi dengan JSTPB dapat ditingkatkan dengan menggunakan model JST, deskriptor utama, dan komposisi data latih dan data uji yang tepat. Tingkat ketepatan identifikasi yang dapat dicapai dengan Metode Statistik, JSTPB1, JSTPB2, dan JSTPB3 adalah masing sebesar 98,2, 100, 70, dan 73,3 dengan jumlah iterasi masing-masing 8, 10, 32, dan 14 iterasi. Dari hasil identifikasi dan klasifikasi yang dilakukan dapat disimpulkan bahwa: 1 Dengan ketepatan seperti yang disebutkan diatas, model JSTPB1 dan JSTPB3 dengan arsitektur 88-1, dan JSTPB2 dengan arsitektur 1515-1 layak digunakan untuk identifikasi dan klasifikasi kawanan ikan. 2 Kelompok deskriptor morfometrik adalah kelompok deskriptor yang sangat berperan dalam proses identifikasi dan klasifikasi, diikuti kelompok deskriptor energetik dan kelompok deskriptor batimetrik. Dari kelompok deskriptor morfometrik dihasilkan deskriptor panjang L, tinggi H, luas A, elongasi E, dan keliling P sedangkan dari kelompok deskriptor energetik dihasilkan deskriptor rataan intensitas hamburan balik SV Er, densitas volume Dv dan dari kelompok deskriptor batimetrik dihasilkan deskriptor ketinggian relatif Trel. 3 Dilihat dari jumlah data yang dibutuhkan maka identifikasi dengan JSTPB1, JSTPB2, JSTPB3 dapat dilakukan dengan baik jika data uji berjumlah 26,3 dari total data yang tersedia atau 35,7 dari total data latih yang tersedia. Dalam disertasi ini, komposisi data uji dan data latih yang digunakan masing- masing adalah 30 dan 84 pola data.

8.2 Saran

Pemodelan jaringan saraf tiruan sebaiknya dilakukan seperti pada proses pemodelan JSTPB1 dimana deskriptor masukan ditentukan berdasarkan hasil analisis statistik sedangkan proses selanjutnya dapat dilakukan dengan baik dengan JST. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan proses pemodelan seperti ini akan memberikan hasil yang lebih baik. Mengingat jumlah spesies kawanan ikan pelagis ekonomis yang tersedia dalam penelitian ini terbatas maka disarankan agar dilakukan uji coba jaringan dengan menggunakan jumlah spesies kawanan ikan yang lebih banyak untuk melihat sampai seberapa banyak variasi spesies kawanan ikan yang dapat diidentifikasi dengan baik dengan menggunakan JSTPB1. DAFTAR PUSTAKA [Anonim] Artificial Neural Network in Medicine, http:www.MedicineNet.org . 15-05-2005. Bahri, T., and Fr ĕon, P. 2000. Spatial Structure of Coastal Pelagic Schools descriptors in the Mediterian Sea. Fisheries Research, 48:157-166. Barange, M., and Hampton, I. 1997. Spatial Structure of co-occuring Anchovy and Sardine Population from Accoustic Data Implication for Surveys Design. Fisheries Oceanography, 62:94-108. Blaxter, J.S.H., and Hunter, J.R. 1982. The Biology of the Clupeoid Fishes, Adv. Mar. Biol ., 20:1-23. Breder, C.M., and Halpern, F. 1946. Innate and Acquaired Behaviour affecting the Aggregation of Fishes. Physiol. Zool. Sociobiol., 6:277-288. Budiharjo, T., Amin, E.M., dan Rusmaji. 1990. Estimasi Pertumbuhan dan Tingkat Kematian Ikan Lemuru sardinella longiceps di Selat Bali. Jurnal Penelitian Perikanan Laut , 56:79-90. Cacoullos, T., and Styan. 1973. Discriminate Analysis and Applications. Academic Press, New York. Cochrane, K.L., Butterwoth, D.S., De Oliveira, J.A.A., and Roel, B.A. 1998. Management Procedurs in a Fishery Based on Highly Variable Stocks with Conflicting Objectives: Experiences in the South African Pelagic Fishery. Fish Biology and Fisheries , 8:177-214. Coetzee, J. 2000. Use of Shoal Analysis and Patch Estimation System SHAPES to Characterise Sardine Schools. Aquat. Liv. Res., 131:1-10. Demuth, H., and Beale, M. 1998. Neural Network Toolbox for Use with MATLAB, User’s Guide Ver.3.0. 371-515 [1371] Departemen Kelautan dan Perikanan, http:www.dkp.go.id . 30-08-2006 Diner, N., Weill, A., Coail, J.Y., and Coudevil, J.M. 1989. “Ines-Movies”: A New Acoustic Data Acquisition and Processing System. ICES Journal of Marine Science , 45: 255-267. Direktorat Jenderal Perikanan. 1979. Buku Pedoman Pengenalan Sumber Perikanan Laut. Bagian I: Jenis-Jenis Ikan Ekonomis Penting. Direktorat Jenderal Perikanan. Departemen Pertanian. Jakarta. 53-98 [102] Dwiponggo, A., dan Subani, W. 1971. Masalah Perikanan Lemuru dan Bagan di Selat Bali. LPP 17. Laporan Penelitian Perikanan Laut, 1:92-122. Fausett, L. 1994. Fundamentals of Neural Networks, Architectures, Algorithms, and Aplications. Prentice-Hall, Inc., Upper Saddle River, New Jersey. 223- 336 [461] Fauziyah. 2005. Identifikasi, Klasifikasi dan Analisis Struktur Spesies Kawanan Ikan Pelagis Berdasarkan Metode Deskriptor Akustik. Disertasi tidak dipublikasikan. Sekolah Pascasarjana, Institut Pertanian Bogor. Bogor. [203] Fr ěon, P., Gerlotto, F., and Soria, M. 1993. Change in School Structure According to External Stimuli: Description and Influence on Accoustic assesment. Fisheries Research, 15:45-66. Fr ěon, P., and Misund, O.A. 1999. Dynamic of Pelagic fish Distribution and Behaviour: Effects on Fisheries and Stock Assessmenet. Fishing News Books Ltd. London. 97-223 [348] Georgakarakos, S., and Paterakis, G. 1993. “School”: A Software For Fish-School Identification. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 8: 94-108. Gerlotto, F., and Fr ĕon, P. 1988. School Structure Observed in Some Clupeid Species. ICESFAST Work Group, Olstend, Belgium, 19-22 April 1988. Hara, I. 1987. Swimming Speed of Sardine School on the Basis of Aerial Survey. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi . 532:223-227. Haralabous, J., and Georgakarakos, S. 1996. Artificial Neural Networks as a Tool for Species Identification of Fish Schools. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 53:173-180. He, Pingguo. 1989. Fish Behaviour and Its Application in Fisheries. Newfoundland and Labrador Institute of Fisheries and Marine Technology. 101-129 [238] Hebb, O.D. 1949. The Organization of Behaviour. Wiley Publications. Hect-Nielsen 1990. Neurocomputing. Addison-Wesley. MA. 95-134 [433] Inakage, D., and Hirano, T. 1983. Vertical Distribution of the Japanese Sardine in Relation to Temperature and Thermocline at the Purse Seine Fishing Grounds Southeast of Hokkaido. Bull. Jap.Soc.Sci.Fish., 4910:1533-1539. Jaya, I and Sriyasa, W. 2004. Fish School Identification in The Bali Straits Using Acoustic Descriptors and Artificial Neural Networks Techniques. International Journal of Remote Sensing and Earth Sciences. Vol.14:43- 49. Kosko, B. 1992. Neural Networks For Signal Processing. Prentice-Hall International Editions. 25-73 [399] Kreyszig, E. 1988. Advanced Engineering Mathematics. 6 th ed. John Wiley Sons. New York. 932-954 [1294] Kusumadewi, S. 2004. Membangun Jaringan Sel Syaraf Tiruan Menggunakan Matlab Excel Link. Graha Ilmu. Yogyakarta. [407] Laevastu, T. and Hayes, M.L. 1982. Fisheries Oceanography and Ecology. Fishing News Books Ltd. London. 56-71 [199] Laevastu, T., and Hela, I. 1970. Fisheries Oceanography. Fishing News Books Ltd. London. 75-89 [238] Lawrence. 1992. Introduction to Neural Networks and Expert System. California Scientific Software. [264] Lawson, G.L., Barange, M., and Fr ĕon, P. 2001. Species Identification of Pelagic Fish Schools on the South African Continental Shelf Using Acoustic Descriptors and Ancillary Information. ICES J of Marine Science, 58:275- 287. Lebart, L., Morineau, A., and Piron, M. 1995. Statistique Exploratoire Multidimensionelle. Dunot, Paris. [439] LeFeuvre, P., Rose, R., Gosine, G.A., Hale, R., Pearson, W., and Khan, R. 2000. Acoustic Species Identification in the Northwest Atlantic Using Digital Image Processing. University Newfoundland Canada. [14] Lida, K., Mukai, T., and Hwang, D.J. 1999. Target Strength Measurement of Live Fish Using a Net Cage. Proceeding of the 3 rd JSPS International Seminar on Fisheries Science in Tropical Area. Bali-Island Indonesia, 19-21 August 1999. Lu, H.J., and Lee, K.T. 1995. Species Identification of Fish Shoals Echograms by an Echo-Signal Image Processing System. J Fisheries Research, 24:99-111. MacLennan, D.N., and Simmons, E.J. 1992. Fisheries Acoustics. Chapman Hall. London. 45-101 [235] Marchal, E., and Petitgas, P. 1993. Precision of Acoustic Fish Abundance Estimates: Seperating the Number of schools from the Biomass in the Schools. Aquatic Living Resources, 6:211-219. Masse, J., and Retiere, N. 1995. Effect of Number of Transects and Identification Hauls on Acoustic Biomass Estimates Under Mixed Species Condition. Aquatic Living Resources , 8:195-199. Mynsky, M., and Papert, S. 1969. Perceptrons. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. Misund, O.A. 1993. Dynamics of Moving Masse Variability in Packing Density, Shape and Size Among Herring, Sprat, and Saithe Schools. ICES. J. Mar. Science , 50:145-160. Nguyen, D., and Widrow, B. 1990. Improving the Learning Speed of Two-Layer Neural Networks by Choosing Initial Values of the Adaptive Weight. International Joint Conference on Neural Networks, San Diego. Nugroho, D., Petit, D., Cotel, P., and Luong, N. 1997. Pelagic Fish Shoals in The Java Sea. Proceed. Acoust. Sem. Akustikan, 2:69-76. Pasaribu, P.B., Latumeten, J., and Simbolon, D. 1997. Acoustic Estimation on Fish Abundance in Makassar Straits, Indonesia. Bull. PSP. Edisi Khusus Akustik Perikanan, VI2:33-48. Patridge, B.L., Pitcher, T., Cullen, J.M., and Wilson, J. 1982. The three- dimensional structure of fish schools, Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol., 6:277-288. Pitcher, T.J., and Parish, J.K. 1982. Function of Shoaling Behaviour in Teleost. Chapman and Hall. London. [439] Radakov, D.V.1973. Schooling and Biology of Fish. John Wiley and Sons. New York. [173] Reid, D., Scalabrin, C., Petitgas, P., Masse, J., Auckland, R., Carrera, P., and Georgakarakos S. 2000. Standart protocol for the analysis of school based data from echo sounder surveys. Fisheries Research, 47:125-136. Rumelhard, D.E., and McLelland, J.L. 1986. PDP models and general issues in cognitive science. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. [391] Santoso, S. 2006. Menguasai Statistik di Era Informasi dengan SPSS 12. Elex Media Komputindo, Jakarta. [613] Shaw, E. 1961. The Development of Schooling Behaviour in Fishes II. Physiol. Zool ., 34:263-272. Siang, J.J. 2005. Jaringan Syaraf Tiruan dan Programnya Menggunakan Matlab. Penerbit Andi, Yogyakarta. [308] Simmonds, E.J., Armstrong, F., and Copland, P.J. 1996. Species Identification Using Wideband Backscatter with Neural Network and Discriminant Analysis. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 53:189-195. Storbeck, F., and Daan, B. 2001. Fish Species Recognition Using Computer Vision and a Neural Network. Fisheries Research, 51:11-15. Supranto. J., 2004. Analisis Multivariat Arti dan Interpretasi. Rineka Cipta. Jakarta. 34-91 [359] Vemuri, V. 1990. Artificial Neural Networks: Theoritical Concepts. IEEE Computer Society Press. California. USA. [127] Weill, A., Scalabrin, C., and Diner, N. 1993. MOVIES-B: an Acoustic Detection Description Software, Application to Shoal Species’ Classification. Aquat. Living Resources , 6:255-267. Williams, H., and Pullen, G. 1993. Schooling Behaviour of Jack Mackarel, Trachurus declivis Jenyns, Observed in the Tasmanian Purse Seine Fishery. Aust. J. Mar.Freshwater Res., 44:577-587. Wudianto. 2001. Analisis Sebaran dan Kelimpahan Ikan Lemuru Sardinella lemuru Bleeker, 1853 di Perairan Selat Bali; Kaitannya dengan optimasi penangkapan. Disertasi tidak dipublikasikan. Program Pascasarjana IPB. Bogor. [221] 126 Lampiran 1 Data latih mentah DATA LATIH MENTAH Nomor Index No. NS Index JK L H A P El Df Dr RAl MinDi MinAl Er Esd Sk Ku D 1 5 1 N 1234.92 32 13555 1746.00 38.6 1.46 150 40 62 9 -75.91 2.26 -0.25 -0.51 0.112 2 19 1 N 1983.27 28.01 23731 3821.00 70.8 1.17 69 31 56 9 -56.26 2.17 -0.2 -0.83 0.139 3 48 1 N 2553.79 15 14293 1242.63 170.3 1.20 91.5 38.8 57 15 -54.97 3.01 -0.58 -1.31 0.015 4 49 1 N 7093.47 19 71558 3726.38 373.3 1.00 28.5 80.9 64 23 -57 1.72 -0.03 -0.57 0.139 5 50 1 N 2362.44 15 13189 1323.13 157.5 1.22 67.5 55 13 14 -56.25 2.33 -0.2 -0.95 0.192 6 52 1 N 3357.38 12 14835 1387.25 279.8 1.22 63 58 8 6 -55.87 2.44 -0.34 -1.02 0.154 7 54 1 N 2439.89 24 14743 4471.13 101.7 1.46 108 27.7 14 1 -54.9 2.88 -0.57 -1.21 0.183 8 55 1 N 1060.21 19 13912 1182.13 55.8 1.19 122.5 12.5 21 11 -64.74 2.76 -0.52 -0.64 0.101 9 6 2 S 1001.56 32 8005 1463.75 31.3 1.31 147 41.2 130 86 -76.8 1.91 -0.06 -0.56 0.001 10 41 2 S 2055.98 7 5011 408.25 293.7 1.09 112.5 24.7 108 32.4 -58.78 6.08 -1.22 -0.81 0.079 11 42 2 S 1037.3 6 2431 220.50 172.9 1.03 115 23 111 30.4 -58.11 6.02 -1.23 -0.65 0.090 12 43 2 S 770.08 7 3043 222.00 110.0 1.00 127 15 122 17.4 -64.07 4.28 -0.4 -1.23 0.024 13 44 2 S 166.98 6 1670 44.63 27.8 0.65 136.5 8.6 132 8.4 -63.66 4.03 -0.6 -1.33 0.026 14 47 2 S 2056.38 8 4661 616.50 257.0 1.19 86 42.4 81 58.4 -56 2.47 -0.29 -1.17 0.111 15 51 2 S 2109.69 8 8151 738.00 263.7 1.16 55 63.3 50 90 -55.69 2.55 -0.37 -1.09 0.112 16 53 2 S 1886.14 13 6992 2531.25 145.1 1.46 91.5 26.8 84 26 -55.36 2.81 -0.45 -1.23 0.139 17 56 2 S 1058.55 12 9335 846.25 88.2 1.17 124 11.4 117 9 -65.39 2.38 -0.48 -0.58 0.015 18 1 3 L 67.33 4.01 204 111.375 16.8 1.25 17.5 23.9 14 2 -56.16 7.16 -1.7 0.69 0.139 19 2 3 L 70.17 2.01 134 80.38 34.9 1.23 18.5 19.6 16 2 -54.57 8.11 -1.79 0.78 0.192 20 3 3 L 176.86 19.01 845.00 324.25 9.3 1.30 45.00 38.40 34.5 17 -55.59 2.64 -0.21 -0.86 0.154 21 7 3 L 371.47 12.01 1712 511.25 30.9 1.30 56.5 16.9 49 4 -54.73 4.48 -1.3 -0.3 0.183 22 8 3 L 155.95 7.01 941 216.88 22.2 1.17 53 22.1 48 10 -57.6 3.96 -0.76 -1.02 0.101 23 15 3 L 88.79 4.02 277 83.63 22.1 1.08 34.5 19.8 31 5 -48.38 3.85 -0.53 -1.2 0.679 24 20 3 L 332.11 3.01 719 301.50 110.3 1.31 75 6.3 72 2 -62.95 2.7 -1.22 -0.23 0.024 25 21 3 L 32.55 16.01 598 150.63 2.0 1.14 60 17.8 51 4 -58.48 6.14 -1.1 -1.03 0.074 26 22 3 L 29.79 11.01 558 127.13 2.7 1.09 62.5 14.4 56 4 -62.9 3.81 -0.8 -1.12 0.028 27 23 3 L 107.95 8.01 832 148.00 13.5 1.07 67 8.2 62 1 -53.64 7.85 -1.25 -0.83 0.237 28 24 3 L 287.1 20.01 2255 357.00 14.3 1.16 60 17.8 49 2 -52.92 8.06 -1.31 -0.71 0.273 29 25 3 L 141.61 9.01 547 231.50 15.7 1.29 68.00 9.30 62 1 -55.92 6.14 -1.32 -0.52 0.087 30 26 3 L 72.32 6.01 375 131.75 12.0 1.18 61.00 16.40 56 7 -72.78 3.89 -0.82 -0.87 0.003 31 27 3 L 16.6 30.01 1049 277.13 0.6 1.22 73.5 20.1 57 2 -55.54 5.59 -1.45 -0.03 0.111 32 28 3 L 19.82 20.01 474 140.50 1.0 1.16 75.5 24.5 64 13 -58.87 5.4 -1.07 -0.95 0.065 33 4 4 C 178.87 19.01 1133 355.00 9.4 1.28 24.50 66.40 13 37 -50.33 4.9 -1.22 -0.66 0.489 34 9 4 C 176.16 8.02 709 186.25 22.0 1.17 13 69.8 8 25 -43.36 3.94 -0.72 -1.1 2.104 35 10 4 C 82.06 14.02 541 123.50 5.9 1.09 22 48.8 14 13 -47.3 4.56 -0.62 -1.21 0.827 36 11 4 C 27.82 8.02 219 73.88 3.5 1.08 27 37.2 21 10 -44.78 4.57 -1.25 -0.49 1.548 37 12 4 C 90.01 5.02 254 86.13 17.9 1.11 21.5 50 18 18 -47.81 4.57 -0.7 -1.18 0.821 38 13 4 C 120.62 4.02 362 102.88 30.0 1.10 21.5 50 18 18 -45.65 5.18 -0.98 -1.05 1.424 39 14 4 C 132.6 13.02 1227 145.25 10.2 1.01 26.5 38.4 19 9 -48.37 3.42 -0.71 -0.91 0.700 40 16 4 C 63.37 9.02 529 118.63 7.0 1.08 29 34.1 23 9 -43.73 6.58 -1.48 -0.05 2.515 41 17 4 C 65.65 10.02 489 102.75 6.6 1.05 23 47.7 17 15 -47.67 7.44 -1.15 -1.19 1.030 42 18 4 C 111.14 22.01 1012 314.75 5.0 1.26 15.5 69.6 3 23 -42.02 4.26 -0.85 -1.07 3.539 43 29 5 P 477.87 15 1338 438.75 31.9 1.31 87.5 20.5 79 14 -64.37 5.65 -1 -0.91 0.017 44 30 5 P 523.85 8 1019 250.38 65.5 1.19 104 9.6 99 6 -65.27 4.75 -1.14 -0.65 0.014 45 31 5 P 452.71 9 506 199.00 50.3 1.25 108.5 5.7 103 1 -66.96 4.41 -0.68 -0.25 0.010 46 32 5 P 522.28 9 761 343.38 58.0 1.34 98.5 14.3 93 11 -61.06 7.49 -1.05 -1.09 0.037 47 33 5 P 709.88 15 3151 589.00 47.3 1.24 115.5 14.4 107 11 -61.83 7.53 -1.02 -1.26 0.031 48 34 5 P 435.04 12 862 333.63 36.3 1.31 78 17.9 65 4 -64.73 3.06 -0.51 -1.17 0.014 49 35 5 P 802.45 24 4634 948.00 33.4 1.30 78 17.9 65 4 -60.98 4.78 -0.89 -0.97 0.035 50 36 5 P 188.97 26.01 447 205.63 7.3 1.29 52 34.2 38 13 -56.41 7.17 -1.36 -0.71 0.116 51 37 5 P 228.28 6.01 166 65.00 38.0 1.09 69 11.5 65 5 -60.34 4.74 -0.95 -0.84 0.049 52 38 5 P 211.8 2.01 59 32.88 105.4 1.03 71.5 9.5 69 5 -64.1 2.98 -0.78 -0.47 0.019 53 39 5 P 222.37 18.01 301 201.00 12.3 1.37 63 19.2 52 4 -55.86 4.26 -1.01 -0.71 0.118 54 40 5 P 172.38 26.01 387 222.88 6.6 1.35 51 32 34 7 -55.4 4.98 -1.18 -0.86 0.143 55 45 5 P 750.24 8.01 1939 675.75 93.7 1.36 49 18.3 44 6 -55.62 2.63 -0.28 -1.06 0.153 56 46 5 P 587.04 16.01 3785 823.25 36.7 1.29 33 40 24 13 -55.32 2.65 -0.5 -1.13 0.173 57 57 5 P 620.36 14.01 2325 603.75 44.3 1.29 32 46.7 24 20 -57.09 1.77 0.000 -0.66 0.089 58 58 5 P 668.81 7.01 2160 455.50 95.4 1.23 35.5 45.4 31 25 -56.4 2.09 -0.15 -0.73 0.106 Kelompok Deskriptor Morfometrik Kelompok Deskriptor Enerjetik Kelompok Deskriptor Batimetrik 127 Lampiran 2 Data latih dalam bentuk z-score DATA LATIH DALAM BENTUK ZScore NS Idx JK L H A P El Df Dr RAl MinAl MinDi Er Esd Sk Ku D 5 1 N 0.53418 2.30113 0.82618 0.99588 -0.33289 0.17017 2.27237 0.30172 -0.49123 -0.06996 -2.88411 -0.72797 0.84910 0.86370 0.50886 19 1 N 1.30158 1.79501 1.74889 3.00936 -0.10232 0.17017 0.16129 -0.16689 -0.97363 0.41224 0.03714 -0.77499 0.95556 0.06218 0.50886 48 1 N 1.88662 0.14474 0.89310 0.50743 0.61016 -0.36370 0.74770 0.23924 -0.00882 -0.71610 0.22892 -0.33614 0.14643 -1.14010 0.50886 49 1 N 6.54186 0.65212 6.08562 2.91755 2.06376 -1.43144 -0.89425 2.43132 -0.57163 3.30542 -0.07287 -1.01008 1.31754 0.71341 0.50886 50 1 N 1.69040 0.14474 0.79299 0.58555 0.51851 -0.25692 0.12220 1.08275 -0.70563 0.31580 0.03863 -0.69140 0.95556 -0.23839 0.50886 52 1 N 2.71067 -0.23580 0.94224 0.64777 1.39425 -0.25692 0.00492 1.23895 -1.00044 -0.02174 0.09512 -0.63393 0.65746 -0.41372 0.50886 54 1 N 1.76982 1.28636 0.93390 3.64022 0.11895 1.02436 1.17774 -0.33872 1.41161 0.19043 0.23932 -0.40406 0.16773 -0.88962 0.50886 55 1 N 0.35502 0.65212 0.85855 0.44873 -0.20972 -0.41709 1.55565 -1.13016 1.09001 1.10660 -1.22353 -0.46675 0.27419 0.53808 0.50886 6 2 S 0.29488 2.30113 0.32293 0.72200 -0.38516 0.22356 2.19418 0.36420 2.08162 3.11254 -3.01642 -0.91082 1.25366 0.73846 -0.45995 41 2 S 1.37614 -0.87003 0.05145 -0.30221 1.49378 -0.95096 1.29502 -0.49492 1.49201 0.52796 -0.33749 1.26772 -1.21630 0.11227 -0.30510 42 2 S 0.33153 -0.99688 -0.18249 -0.48439 0.62878 -1.27128 1.36018 -0.58344 1.57241 0.43152 -0.23789 1.23638 -1.23759 0.51303 -0.28326 43 2 S 0.05751 -0.87003 -0.12700 -0.48294 0.17838 -1.43144 1.67293 -0.99999 1.86722 -0.19533 -1.12393 0.32735 0.52970 -0.93972 -0.41429 44 2 S -0.56095 -0.99688 -0.25150 -0.65505 -0.41022 -3.29998 1.92053 -1.33322 2.13523 -0.62931 -1.06298 0.19674 0.10385 -1.19019 -0.41032 47 2 S 1.37655 -0.74319 0.01971 -0.10013 1.23099 -0.41709 0.60436 0.42669 0.76840 1.78168 0.07579 -0.61826 0.76392 -0.78943 -0.24157 51 2 S 1.43122 -0.74319 0.33617 0.01776 1.27896 -0.57725 -0.20359 1.51492 -0.06242 3.30542 0.12188 -0.57646 0.59358 -0.58905 -0.23959 53 2 S 1.20198 -0.10895 0.23108 1.75785 0.42972 1.02436 0.74770 -0.38558 0.84880 0.21936 0.17094 -0.44063 0.42324 -0.93972 -0.18599 56 2 S 0.35332 -0.23580 0.44353 0.12280 0.02228 -0.52386 1.59474 -1.18743 1.73322 -0.60038 -1.32017 -0.66528 0.35936 0.68836 -0.43216 1 3 L -0.66313 -1.24930 -0.38443 -0.59000 -0.48899 -0.09676 -1.18094 -0.53658 -1.02724 -0.93792 0.05201 1.83195 -2.23835 3.86938 -0.18599 2 3 L -0.66022 -1.50300 -0.39078 -0.62036 -0.35938 -0.20354 -1.15488 -0.76047 -0.97363 -0.93792 0.28838 2.32826 -2.42999 4.09481 -0.08077 3 3 L -0.55082 0.65339 -0.32630 -0.38372 -0.54269 0.17017 -0.46421 0.21841 -0.47783 -0.21462 0.13675 -0.52944 0.93427 -0.01296 -0.15621 7 3 L -0.35125 -0.23453 -0.24769 -0.20226 -0.38802 0.17017 -0.16449 -0.90106 -0.08922 -0.84148 0.26460 0.43183 -1.38664 1.38969 -0.09863 8 3 L -0.57226 -0.86876 -0.31760 -0.48791 -0.45032 -0.52386 -0.25571 -0.63030 -0.11602 -0.55216 -0.16207 0.16017 -0.23684 -0.41372 -0.26143 15 3 L -0.64113 -1.24804 -0.37781 -0.61721 -0.45104 -1.00434 -0.73787 -0.75006 -0.57163 -0.79326 1.20861 0.10270 0.25290 -0.86457 0.88606 20 3 L -0.39161 -1.37615 -0.33773 -0.40580 0.18053 0.22356 0.31767 -1.45298 0.52719 -0.93792 -0.95742 -0.49810 -1.21630 1.56502 -0.41429 21 3 L -0.69880 0.27285 -0.34870 -0.55219 -0.59496 -0.68402 -0.07327 -0.85420 -0.03562 -0.84148 -0.29289 1.29907 -0.96079 -0.43877 -0.31503 22 3 L -0.70163 -0.36138 -0.35233 -0.57500 -0.58995 -0.95096 -0.00812 -1.03123 0.09839 -0.84148 -0.94999 0.08180 -0.32201 -0.66420 -0.40635 23 3 L -0.62148 -0.74192 -0.32748 -0.55475 -0.51262 -1.05773 0.10917 -1.35405 0.25919 -0.98613 0.42664 2.19243 -1.28018 0.06218 0.00857 24 3 L -0.43777 0.78024 -0.19845 -0.35194 -0.50689 -0.57725 -0.07327 -0.85420 -0.08922 -0.93792 0.53368 2.30214 -1.40794 0.36275 0.08004 25 3 L -0.58696 -0.61507 -0.35333 -0.47372 -0.49686 0.11678 0.13523 -1.29678 0.25919 -0.98613 0.08769 1.29907 -1.42923 0.83865 -0.28922 26 3 L -0.65802 -0.99561 -0.36892 -0.57051 -0.52336 -0.47047 -0.04721 -0.92709 0.09839 -0.69682 -2.41879 0.12360 -0.36459 -0.03801 -0.45598 27 3 L -0.71515 2.04870 -0.30781 -0.42944 -0.60499 -0.25692 0.27857 -0.73444 0.12519 -0.93792 0.14418 1.01173 -1.70604 2.06597 -0.24157 28 3 L -0.71185 0.78024 -0.35995 -0.56202 -0.60213 -0.57725 0.33070 -0.50534 0.31279 -0.40750 -0.35087 0.91247 -0.89691 -0.23839 -0.33290 4 4 C -0.54875 0.65339 -0.30019 -0.35388 -0.54198 0.06340 -0.99850 1.67633 -1.05404 0.74977 0.91872 0.65125 -1.21630 0.48798 0.50886 9 4 C -0.55153 -0.74065 -0.33864 -0.51763 -0.45175 -0.52386 -1.29822 1.85336 -1.18804 0.17114 1.95491 0.14972 -0.15166 -0.61410 3.71507 10 4 C -0.64803 0.02043 -0.35387 -0.57852 -0.56704 -0.95096 -1.06366 0.75992 -1.02724 -0.40750 1.36917 0.47363 0.06126 -0.88962 1.17988 11 4 C -0.70365 -0.74065 -0.38307 -0.62667 -0.58422 -1.00434 -0.93334 0.15593 -0.83963 -0.55216 1.74381 0.47885 -1.28018 0.91379 2.61126 12 4 C -0.63988 -1.12119 -0.37989 -0.61478 -0.48111 -0.84418 -1.07669 0.82241 -0.92003 -0.16640 1.29335 0.47885 -0.10908 -0.81448 1.16797 13 4 C -0.60849 -1.24804 -0.37010 -0.59853 -0.39447 -0.89757 -1.07669 0.82241 -0.92003 -0.16640 1.61447 0.79753 -0.70528 -0.48886 2.36508 14 4 C -0.59620 -0.10642 -0.29167 -0.55741 -0.53625 -1.37805 -0.94637 0.21841 -0.89323 -0.60038 1.21010 -0.12195 -0.13037 -0.13820 0.92775 16 4 C -0.66719 -0.61380 -0.35496 -0.58324 -0.55916 -1.00434 -0.88122 -0.00548 -0.78603 -0.60038 1.89990 1.52894 -1.76991 2.01588 4.53101 17 4 C -0.66486 -0.48696 -0.35859 -0.59865 -0.56203 -1.16450 -1.03759 0.70265 -0.94683 -0.31106 1.31417 1.97823 -1.06725 -0.83953 1.58289 18 4 C -0.61821 1.03393 -0.31116 -0.39294 -0.57348 -0.04338 -1.23306 1.84295 -1.32204 0.07470 2.15412 0.31690 -0.42847 -0.53896 6.56393 29 5 P -0.24214 0.14474 -0.28160 -0.27262 -0.38086 0.22356 0.64345 -0.71361 0.71480 -0.35928 -1.16853 1.04308 -0.74786 -0.13820 -0.42819 30 5 P -0.19499 -0.74319 -0.31053 -0.45540 -0.14027 -0.41709 1.07349 -1.28116 1.25081 -0.74504 -1.30233 0.57289 -1.04596 0.51303 -0.43415 31 5 P -0.26794 -0.61634 -0.35704 -0.50526 -0.24911 -0.09676 1.19077 -1.48422 1.35801 -0.98613 -1.55357 0.39526 -0.06649 1.51493 -0.44209 32 5 P -0.19660 -0.61634 -0.33392 -0.36516 -0.19397 0.38372 0.93014 -1.03643 1.09001 -0.50394 -0.67645 2.00435 -0.85433 -0.58905 -0.38848 33 5 P -0.00423 0.14474 -0.11721 -0.12682 -0.27059 -0.15015 1.37321 -1.03123 1.46521 -0.50394 -0.79092 2.02525 -0.79045 -1.01486 -0.40040 34 5 P -0.28606 -0.23580 -0.32476 -0.37462 -0.34936 0.22356 0.39586 -0.84899 0.33959 -0.84148 -1.22205 -0.31002 0.29548 -0.78943 -0.43415 35 5 P 0.09070 1.28636 0.01726 0.22154 -0.37012 0.17017 0.39586 -0.84899 0.33959 -0.84148 -0.66456 0.58856 -0.51364 -0.28848 -0.39245 36 5 P -0.53840 1.54132 -0.36239 -0.49882 -0.55701 0.11678 -0.28177 -0.00027 -0.38402 -0.40750 0.01484 1.83718 -1.51440 0.36275 -0.23165 37 5 P -0.49809 -0.99561 -0.38787 -0.63528 -0.33718 -0.95096 0.16129 -1.18223 0.33959 -0.79326 -0.56941 0.56766 -0.64140 0.03713 -0.36466 38 5 P -0.51499 -1.50300 -0.39758 -0.66645 0.14544 -1.27128 0.22645 -1.28636 0.44679 -0.79326 -1.12839 -0.35182 -0.27942 0.96389 -0.42422 39 5 P -0.50415 0.52655 -0.37563 -0.50332 -0.52121 0.54388 0.00492 -0.78130 -0.00882 -0.84148 0.09661 0.31690 -0.76915 0.36275 -0.22768 40 5 P -0.55541 1.54132 -0.36783 -0.48209 -0.56203 0.43711 -0.30784 -0.11482 -0.49123 -0.69682 0.16499 0.69305 -1.13113 -0.01296 -0.17805 45 5 P 0.03716 -0.74192 -0.22711 -0.04264 0.06166 0.49049 -0.35996 -0.82816 -0.22322 -0.74504 0.13229 -0.53467 0.78522 -0.51391 -0.15819 46 5 P -0.13019 0.27285 -0.05972 0.10049 -0.34649 0.11678 -0.77697 0.30172 -0.75923 -0.40750 0.17688 -0.52422 0.31678 -0.68924 -0.11849 57 5 P -0.09603 0.01916 -0.19211 -0.11251 -0.29207 0.11678 -0.80303 0.65058 -0.75923 -0.06996 -0.08625 -0.98396 1.38141 0.48798 -0.28525 58 5 P -0.04634 -0.86876 -0.20707 -0.25636 0.07384 -0.20354 -0.71181 0.58289 -0.57163 0.17114 0.01633 -0.81678 1.06202 0.31265 -0.25150 Nomor Index Kelompok Deskriptor Morfometrik Kelompok Deskriptor Batimetrik Kelompok Deskriptor Enerjetik 128 Lampiran 3 Data latih dalam bentuk bipolar DATA LATIH DALAM BENTUK Bipolar NS Index JK L H A P El Df Dr RAl MinDi MinAl Er Esd Sk Ku D 5 1 N -0.65569 0.72067 -0.622484 -0.228018 -0.795926 -2.604938 -0.948821 -0.830986 0.72067 -0.222749 -0.95148 1 -0.087766 -0.844961 -0.977528 19 1 N -0.444198 0.733911 -0.337837 0.707035 -0.623095 -2.604938 0.181139 -0.859155 0.776536 -0.526066 -0.999129 -0.182482 -0.327128 -0.922481 -0.730337 48 1 N -0.282963 -0.133711 -0.601841 -0.454853 -0.089564 0.358025 0.255319 -0.596244 0.351955 -0.981043 -0.937934 0.145985 -0.119681 -0.829457 -0.191011 49 1 N 1 0.133044 1 0.664395 1 -0.135802 0.138585 -1 0.96648 -0.279621 -0.963907 -0.773723 1 -0.72093 -0.460674 50 1 N -0.33704 -0.133711 -0.632722 -0.418577 -0.158003 0.407407 0.181714 -0.809077 0.776536 -0.63981 -0.7241 -0.20438 0.31117 -0.767442 -0.730337 52 1 N -0.055859 -0.333778 -0.58668 -0.389681 0.498058 0.407407 0.203565 -0.774648 0.620112 -0.706161 0.188963 -0.270073 0.390957 -0.767442 -0.797753 54 1 N -0.315152 0.466489 -0.589253 1 -0.457552 -0.636933 0.259344 -0.636933 0.363128 -0.886256 -0.533114 0.386861 -0.414894 -0.751938 -0.617978 55 1 N -0.705065 0.133044 -0.612498 -0.482116 -0.703598 0.333333 -0.306498 -0.674491 0.418994 -0.345972 -0.12554 0.59854 -0.819149 -0.689922 -0.617978 6 2 S -0.72164 1 -0.777731 -0.355208 -0.83505 0.62963 -1 -0.940532 0.932961 -0.270142 -1 0.956204 -0.055851 0.968992 0.910112 41 2 S -0.423649 -0.667222 -0.861481 -0.830845 0.572791 0.08642 0.036228 0.364632 -0.363128 -0.507109 -0.955619 0.452555 -0.494681 0.627907 -0.294382 42 2 S -0.711539 -0.733911 -0.933649 -0.915451 -0.075451 -0.061728 0.074756 0.345853 -0.374302 -0.35545 -0.949462 0.489051 -0.539894 0.674419 -0.339326 43 2 S -0.787058 -0.667222 -0.91653 -0.914775 -0.412758 -0.135802 -0.26797 -0.198748 0.553073 -0.905213 -0.987234 0.664234 -0.75266 0.844961 -0.631461 44 2 S -0.957501 -0.733911 -0.954936 -0.994705 -0.85366 -1 -0.244393 -0.276995 0.329609 -1 -0.985962 0.80292 -0.922872 1 -0.833708 47 2 S -0.423536 -0.600534 -0.871271 -0.737002 0.376089 0.333333 0.19609 -0.765258 0.675978 -0.848341 -0.937968 0.065693 -0.023936 0.209302 0.289888 51 2 S -0.40847 -0.600534 -0.773647 -0.682251 0.41184 0.259259 0.213916 -0.740219 0.586592 -0.772512 -0.937001 -0.386861 0.531915 -0.271318 1 53 2 S -0.471648 -0.267089 -0.806067 0.125838 -0.224574 1 0.232892 -0.658842 0.497207 -0.905213 -0.921697 0.145985 -0.43883 0.255814 -0.438202 56 2 S -0.705534 -0.333778 -0.740528 -0.63347 -0.529709 0.283951 -0.343876 -0.793427 0.463687 -0.2891 -0.992345 0.620438 -0.848404 0.767442 -0.820225 1 3 L -0.985663 -0.866622 -0.995944 -0.964626 -0.912887 0.481481 0.186889 0.70266 -0.899441 0.914692 -0.921928 -0.934307 -0.515957 -0.829457 -0.977528 2 3 L -0.984861 -1 -0.997902 -0.978595 -0.815673 0.432099 0.278321 1 -1 1 -0.89176 -0.919708 -0.630319 -0.79845 -0.977528 3 3 L -0.954709 0.133711 -0.978014 -0.868698 -0.953054 0.604938 0.219666 -0.71205 0.765363 -0.554502 -0.913476 -0.532847 -0.130319 -0.511628 -0.640449 7 3 L -0.89971 -0.333111 -0.953762 -0.784431 -0.837028 0.604938 0.26912 -0.13615 -0.452514 -0.023697 -0.896877 -0.364964 -0.702128 -0.286822 -0.932584 8 3 L -0.960618 -0.666556 -0.975328 -0.917084 -0.883614 0.283951 0.104083 -0.298905 0.150838 -0.706161 -0.943203 -0.416058 -0.56383 -0.302326 -0.797753 15 3 L -0.979598 -0.865955 -0.993902 -0.977131 -0.884471 0.061728 0.634273 -0.333333 0.407821 -0.876777 -0.616709 -0.686131 -0.625 -0.565891 -0.910112 20 3 L -0.910833 -0.933311 -0.981538 -0.87895 -0.411019 0.62963 -0.203565 -0.693271 -0.363128 0.042654 -0.987098 -0.094891 -0.984043 0.069767 -0.977528 21 3 L -0.995492 -0.066355 -0.984923 -0.946939 -0.99206 0.209877 0.053479 0.383412 -0.22905 -0.71564 -0.958581 -0.313869 -0.678191 -0.255814 -0.932584 22 3 L -0.996272 -0.3998 -0.986042 -0.957528 -0.988451 0.08642 -0.20069 -0.345853 0.106145 -0.800948 -0.984893 -0.277372 -0.768617 -0.178295 -0.932584 23 3 L -0.974184 -0.599867 -0.978377 -0.948121 -0.930664 0.037037 0.3318 0.918623 -0.396648 -0.526066 -0.866669 -0.211679 -0.933511 -0.085271 -1 24 3 L -0.923554 0.2004 -0.938573 -0.85394 -0.925992 0.259259 0.373203 0.984351 -0.463687 -0.412322 -0.845977 -0.313869 -0.678191 -0.286822 -0.977528 25 3 L -0.964671 -0.533178 -0.986349 -0.910494 -0.918646 0.580247 0.20069 0.383412 -0.47486 -0.232227 -0.95148 -0.19708 -0.904255 -0.085271 -0.904255 26 3 L -0.984253 -0.733244 -0.991161 -0.955444 -0.938409 0.308642 -0.768833 -0.320814 0.083799 -0.563981 -0.999129 -0.29927 -0.715426 -0.178295 -0.865169 27 3 L -1 0.867289 -0.972307 -0.889934 -1 0.407407 0.222542 0.211268 -0.620112 0.232227 -0.937934 -0.116788 -0.617021 -0.162791 -0.977528 28 3 L -0.99909 0.2004 -0.988391 -0.951501 -0.997654 0.259259 0.031052 0.1518 -0.195531 -0.63981 -0.963907 -0.087591 -0.5 -0.054264 -0.730337 4 4 C -0.954141 0.133711 -0.969958 -0.854841 -0.952487 0.555556 0.522139 -0.004695 -0.363128 -0.364929 -0.7241 -0.832117 0.614362 -0.844961 -0.191011 9 4 C -0.954907 -0.5992 -0.981818 -0.930885 -0.885125 0.283951 0.922944 -0.305164 0.195531 -0.781991 0.188963 -1 0.704787 -0.922481 -0.460674 10 4 C -0.9815 -0.199066 -0.986517 -0.959162 -0.971566 0.08642 0.696377 -0.111111 0.307263 -0.886256 -0.533114 -0.868613 0.146277 -0.829457 -0.730337 11 4 C -0.996829 -0.5992 -0.995524 -0.981524 -0.984357 0.061728 0.841288 -0.107981 -0.396648 -0.203791 -0.12554 -0.79562 -0.162234 -0.72093 -0.797753 12 4 C -0.979254 -0.799266 -0.994545 -0.976004 -0.906772 0.135802 0.66705 -0.107981 0.217877 -0.85782 -0.536325 -0.875912 0.178191 -0.767442 -0.617978 13 4 C -0.970603 -0.865955 -0.991524 -0.968456 -0.841991 0.111111 0.791259 0.082942 -0.094972 -0.734597 -0.195674 -0.875912 0.178191 -0.767442 -0.617978 14 4 C -0.967217 -0.265755 -0.967328 -0.949361 -0.948329 -0.111111 0.634848 -0.467919 0.206704 -0.601896 -0.605057 -0.80292 -0.130319 -0.751938 -0.820225 16 4 C -0.986782 -0.532511 -0.986853 -0.961359 -0.965276 0.061728 0.901668 0.521127 -0.653631 0.21327 0.421092 -0.766423 -0.244681 -0.689922 -0.820225 17 4 C -0.986138 -0.465822 -0.987972 -0.968512 -0.967817 -0.012346 0.675101 0.790297 -0.284916 -0.867299 -0.418265 -0.854015 0.117021 -0.782946 -0.685393 18 4 C -0.973282 0.333778 -0.973342 -0.872979 -0.975877 0.506173 1 -0.205008 0.050279 -0.753555 1 -0.963504 0.699468 -1 -0.505618 29 5 P -0.86964 -0.133711 -0.964223 -0.817101 -0.83205 0.62963 -0.285221 0.230047 -0.117318 -0.601896 -0.990683 0.087591 -0.606383 0.178295 -0.707865 30 5 P -0.856646 -0.600534 -0.973146 -0.901988 -0.651661 0.333333 -0.336975 -0.051643 -0.273743 -0.35545 -0.992594 0.328467 -0.896277 0.488372 -0.88764 31 5 P -0.876751 -0.533845 -0.987496 -0.925139 -0.733103 0.481481 -0.434158 -0.158059 0.240223 0.023697 -0.995064 0.394161 -1 0.550388 0.394161 32 5 P -0.857089 -0.533845 -0.980363 -0.86008 -0.691631 0.703704 -0.094882 0.805947 -0.173184 -0.772512 -0.979511 0.248175 -0.771277 0.395349 -0.775281 33 5 P -0.804072 -0.133711 -0.913509 -0.749394 -0.749068 0.45679 -0.13916 0.818466 -0.139665 -0.933649 -0.983226 0.49635 -0.768617 0.612403 -0.775281 34 5 P -0.881744 -0.333778 -0.977538 -0.864474 -0.808469 0.62963 -0.305923 -0.580595 0.430168 -0.848341 -0.992509 -0.051095 -0.675532 -0.03876 -0.932584 35 5 P -0.77791 0.466489 -0.872026 -0.587619 -0.823587 0.604938 -0.090282 -0.042254 0.005587 -0.658768 -0.98084 -0.051095 -0.675532 -0.03876 -0.932584 36 5 P -0.951286 0.600534 -0.989147 -0.922154 -0.963989 0.580247 0.172513 0.70579 -0.519553 -0.412322 -0.935198 -0.430657 -0.242021 -0.457364 -0.730337 37 5 P -0.940177 -0.733244 -0.997007 -0.985524 -0.799187 0.08642 -0.053479 -0.054773 -0.061453 -0.535545 -0.972698 -0.182482 -0.845745 -0.03876 -0.910112 38 5 P -0.944834 -0.989147 -1 -1 -0.437642 -0.061728 -0.269695 -0.605634 0.128492 -0.184834 -0.989575 -0.145985 -0.898936 0.023256 -0.910112 39 5 P -0.941847 0.067022 -0.993231 -0.924238 -0.936726 0.777778 0.20414 -0.205008 -0.128492 -0.412322 -0.934022 -0.270073 -0.640957 -0.24031 -0.932584 40 5 P -0.955975 0.600534 -0.990825 -0.914381 -0.967411 0.728395 0.230592 0.020344 -0.318436 -0.554502 -0.919876 -0.445255 -0.300532 -0.51938 -0.865169 45 5 P -0.792665 -0.599867 -0.947412 -0.710302 -0.500467 0.753086 0.217941 -0.71518 0.687151 -0.744076 -0.914008 -0.474453 -0.664894 -0.364341 -0.88764 46 5 P -0.838787 -0.066355 -0.895775 -0.643835 -0.806249 0.580247 0.235193 -0.70892 0.441341 -0.810427 -0.902836 -0.708029 -0.087766 -0.674419 -0.730337 57 5 P -0.829371 -0.199733 -0.936614 -0.742748 -0.765407 0.580247 0.13341 -0.984351 1 -0.364929 -0.950027 -0.722628 0.090426 -0.674419 -0.573034 58 5 P -0.815678 -0.666556 -0.94123 -0.809553 -0.491105 0.432099 0.173088 -0.884194 0.832402 -0.43128 -0.940727 -0.671533 0.055851 -0.565891 -0.460674 Nomor Index Kelompok Deskriptor Morfometrik Kelompok Deskriptor Batimetrik Kelompok Deskriptor Enerjetik 129 Lampiran 4 Histogram deskriptor hidroakustik data latih 0.00 2000.00 4000.00 6000.00 8000.00 L 10 20 30 40 50 Fre quen cy Mean = 772.7772 Std. Dev. = 1160.15294 N = 58 0.00 10.00

20.00 30.00