SETIA NOVA PUTRA GEA
24 SETIA NOVA PUTRA GEA
25 SISKA ADVENTI GEA
26 SYUKUR IRAWAN GEA
27 TERIMA GEA
28 TETI WARNI GEA
29 VIKTOR JULIUS GEA
Appendix 12
Table 12 STU DENTS’ ABILITY IN WRITING NARATIVE POST TEST IN EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
Number of
No Students' Name
1 CELSIS SOKHYANI GEA
2 DARNI MURNI YANTI GEA
3 DEWI PUTRI LASE
4 DINGKAR LIKE ME HAREFA
5 DOLI HARTONO GEA
6 ERNITA GEA
7 FENNI INDRIANI ZILIWU
8 FIBI PUTRI SARI GEA
9 IDARWATI GEA
10 INGA MASA GEA
11 IRWANTO PUTRA HAREFA
12 JULIUS GEA
13 KASMARNIAT LAHAGU
14 KRISTIN TRI PUTRI GEA
15 KRISWANTO GEA
16 LEO HIDAYAT FATALAN GEA
17 MARTIN KUSMAN ZENDRATO
18 MAWAR PUTRI YANI GEA
19 NONI PUTRI SARI HAREFA
20 PASKALENA GEA
21 RIDAYANTI GEA
22 RINIWATI GEA
23 SERLINA GEA
24 SRI JUWITA GEA
25 TETIARI LASE
26 TRI LOVE PUTRAWAN GEA
27 WIBI BERKAT TIANI GEA
28 YANIWATI GEA
29 YEFI KRISTIANI GEA
Appendix 13
Table 13 STU DENTS’ ABILITY IN WRITING NARATIVE POST TEST IN CONTROL GROUP
Number of
No Students' Name
1 AGRINA GEA
AGUS NIRMAN PUTRI
2 HAREFA
3 AMPERLIN GEA
4 ASTRIANI HAREFA
5 ATANASIUS BERKAT GEA
6 AYU PUTRI HAREFA
7 BELIFINTO ZALUKHU
8 BERKAT IMAN JAYA GEA
9 BERKAT NOBUALA GEA
10 BOBY MARTINUS GEA
11 DEDI KRISMAN GEA
12 DEPI KRISNAWATI GEA
13 ELISMAN GEA
14 ELMAN GEA
15 IWAN SETIAWAN GEA
16 JERNIH PUTRI HAREFA
17 JUMINA GEA
18 KRISTIAN GEA
NATANAEL YARMANATA
20 NOVERIUS GEA
21 NUD MEI ELFITRI GEA
PUTRI DAMAI AGUSNIAT
22 GEA
23 SARIANI HAREFA
24 SETIA NOVA PUTRA GEA
25 SISKA ADVENTI GEA
26 SYUKUR IRAWAN GEA
27 TERIMA GEA
28 TETI WARNI GEA
29 VIKTOR JULIUS GEA
Appendix 14
Table 14 MEAN, STANDARD DIVIATION AND VARIATION PRE TEST IN CONTROL GROUP
Mean
No Students' Name
Mark (X)
(X- Ẋ) (X-Ẋ)²
1 AGRINA GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
2 AGUS NIRMAN PUTRI HAREFA
3 AMPERLIN GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
4 ASTRIANI HAREFA
5 ATANASIUS BERKAT GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
6 AYU PUTRI HAREFA
0 55.83 -55.83 3116.99
7 BELIFINTO ZALUKHU
50 55.83 -5.83
8 BERKAT IMAN JAYA GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
9 BERKAT NOBUALA GEA
10 BOBY MARTINUS GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
11 DEDI KRISMAN GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
12 DEPI KRISNAWATI GEA
0 55.83 -55.83 3116.99
13 ELISMAN GEA
14 ELMAN GEA
15 IWAN SETIAWAN GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
16 JERNIH PUTRI HAREFA
17 JUMINA GEA
0 55.83 -55.83 3116.99
18 KRISTIAN GEA
19 NATANAEL YARMANATA GEA
20 NOVERIUS GEA
21 NUD MEI ELFITRI GEA
22 PUTRI DAMAI AGUSNIAT GEA
50 55.83 -5.83
23 SARIANI HAREFA
24 SETIA NOVA PUTRA GEA
0 55.83 -55.83 3116.99
25 SISKA ADVENTI GEA
26 SYUKUR IRAWAN GEA
27 TERIMA GEA
25 55.83 -30.83 950.49
28 TETI WARNI GEA
29 VIKTOR JULIUS GEA
30 YAKINI GEA
∑X=
Appendix 15
Table 15 MEAN, STANDARD DIVIATION AND VARIATION POST TEST IN CONTROL GROUP
Mean
No Students' Name
Mark (X)
(X- Ẋ) (X-Ẋ)²
1 AGRINA GEA
50 70.00 -5
2 AGUS NIRMAN PUTRI HAREFA
3 AMPERLIN GEA
75 70.00 -5
4 ASTRIANI HAREFA
75 70.00 -5
5 ATANASIUS BERKAT GEA
50 70.00 -55 3025.00
6 AYU PUTRI HAREFA
7 BELIFINTO ZALUKHU
8 BERKAT IMAN JAYA GEA
75 70.00 -5
9 BERKAT NOBUALA GEA
75 70.00 -5
10 BOBY MARTINUS GEA
11 DEDI KRISMAN GEA
12 DEPI KRISNAWATI GEA
50 70.00 -30 900.00
13 ELISMAN GEA
14 ELMAN GEA
25 70.00 -55 3025.00
15 IWAN SETIAWAN GEA
16 JERNIH PUTRI HAREFA
75 70.00 -5
17 JUMINA GEA
50 70.00 -5
18 KRISTIAN GEA
19 NATANAEL YARMANATA GEA
20 NOVERIUS GEA
70.00 -5
21 NUD MEI ELFITRI GEA
25 70.00 -55 3025.00
22 PUTRI DAMAI AGUSNIAT GEA
23 SARIANI HAREFA
24 SETIA NOVA PUTRA GEA
75 70.00 -5
25 SISKA ADVENTI GEA
26 SYUKUR IRAWAN GEA
27 TERIMA GEA
28 TETI WARNI GEA
50 70.00 -55 3025.00
29 VIKTOR JULIUS GEA
75 70.00 -5
30 YAKINI GEA
Appendix 16
Table 16 MEAN, STANDARD DIVIATION AND VARIATION PRE TEST IN EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
Mean
No Students' Name
Mark (X)
(X- Ẋ) (X-Ẋ)²
1 CELSIS SOKHYANI GEA
50 56.67 -6.67
2 DARNI MURNI YANTI GEA
3 DEWI PUTRI LASE
50 56.67 -6.67
4 DINGKAR LIKE ME HAREFA
5 DOLI HARTONO GEA
50 56.67 -6.67
6 ERNITA GEA
0 56.67 -56.67 3211.49
7 FENNI INDRIANI ZILIWU
50 56.67 -6.67
8 FIBI PUTRI SARI GEA
50 56.67 -6.67
9 IDARWATI GEA
10 INGA MASA GEA
50 56.67 -6.67
11 IRWANTO PUTRA HAREFA
50 56.67 -6.67
12 JULIUS GEA
0 56.67 -56.67 3211.49
13 KASMARNIAT LAHAGU
14 KRISTIN TRI PUTRI GEA
15 KRISWANTO GEA
50 56.67 -6.67
16 LEO HIDAYAT FATALAN GEA
17 MARTIN KUSMAN ZENDRATO
0 56.67 -56.67 3211.49
18 MAWAR PUTRI YANI GEA
19 NONI PUTRI SARI HAREFA
20 PASKALENA GEA
21 RIDAYANTI GEA
22 RINIWATI GEA
25 56.67 -31.67 1002.99
23 SERLINA GEA
24 SRI JUWITA GEA
0 56.67 -56.67 3211.49
25 TETIARI LASE
26 TRI LOVE PUTRAWAN GEA
27 WIBI BERKAT TIANI GEA
28 YANIWATI GEA
29 YEFI KRISTIANI GEA
30 YUYUN NASRANI GEA
∑X=
Appendix 17
Table 17 MEAN, STANDARD DIVIATION AND VARIATION POST TEST IN EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
No Students' Name (X- Ẋ) (X-Ẋ)²
1 CELSIS SOKHYANI GEA
75 81.70 -6.7
2 DARNI MURNI YANTI GEA
3 DEWI PUTRI LASE
75 81.70 -6.7
4 DINGKAR LIKE ME HAREFA
5 DOLI HARTONO GEA
75 81.70 -6.7
6 ERNITA GEA
25 81.70 -56.7 3214.89
7 FENNI INDRIANI ZILIWU
75 81.70 -6.7
8 FIBI PUTRI SARI GEA
75 81.70 -6.7
9 IDARWATI GEA
10 INGA MASA GEA
75 81.70 -6.7
11 IRWANTO PUTRA HAREFA
75 81.70 -6.7
12 JULIUS GEA
25 81.70 -56.7 3214.89
13 KASMARNIAT LAHAGU
14 KRISTIN TRI PUTRI GEA
15 KRISWANTO GEA
75 81.70 -6.7
16 LEO HIDAYAT FATALAN GEA
17 MARTIN KUSMAN ZENDRATO
25 81.70 -56.7 3214.89
18 MAWAR PUTRI YANI GEA
19 NONI PUTRI SARI HAREFA
20 PASKALENA GEA
21 RIDAYANTI GEA
22 RINIWATI GEA
50 81.70 -31.7 1004.89
23 SERLINA GEA
24 SRI JUWITA GEA
25 81.70 -56.7 3214.89
25 TETIARI LASE
26 TRI LOVE PUTRAWAN GEA
27 WIBI BERKAT TIANI GEA
28 YANIWATI GEA
29 YEFI KRISTIANI GEA
30 YUYUN NASRANI GEA
∑X=
Appendix 18
Table 18 THE EXAMINING OF NORMALITY IN THE PRE TEST OF EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
F(Zi)
S(Zi)
│F(Zi) - S(Zi)│
L count =L 0 0.1608 L table =L 0.05(30) 0.1610
Conclusion Normal Distribution
Appendix 19
Table 19 THE EXAMINING OF NORMALITY IN THE POST TEST OF EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
F(Zi)
S(Zi)
│F(Zi) - S(Zi)│
L count =L 0 0.1608 L table =L 0.05(30) 0.1610
Conclusion Normal Distribution
Appendix 20
Table 20 THE EXAMINING OF NORMALITY IN THE PRE TEST OF CONTROL GROUP
F(Zi)
S(Zi)
│F(Zi) - S(Zi)│
L count =L 0 0.1601 L table =L 0.05(30) 0.1610
Conclusion Normal Distribution
Appendix 21
Table 21 THE EXAMINING OF NORMALITY IN THE POST TEST OF CONTROL GROUP
F(Zi)
S(Zi)
│F(Zi) - S(Zi)│
L count =L 0 0.1596 L table =L 0.05(30) 0.1610
Conclusion Normal Distribution
Appendix 22a