Penerapan Teori Permainan dalam Strategi Pemasaran Produk Ban Sepeda Motor di FMIPA USU

  

LAMPIRAN

KUESIONER PENELITIAN

Terima kasih atas partisipasi anda menjadi responden dan secara sukarela

mengisi kuesioner penelitian ini. Pada saat ini saya:

  Nama : Charles H Simamora NIM : 080803024 Program Studi : S-1 Matematika sedang melakukan penelitian dengan judul:

Studi Kasus Teori Permainan dalam Strategi Pemasaran Produk Ban Sepeda Motor di

FMIPA USU.

  Saya sangat menghargai kejujuran anda dalam mengisi kuesioner ini. Hasil

kuesioner penelitian ini akan digunakan untuk menyelesaikan tugas akhir saya (tujuan

penelitian) dan bukan tujuan komersial.

  Nama : NIM : Jenis kelamin : Laki-laki / Perempuan Usia : Merek ban sepeda motor yang digunakan :

  Panduan Pengisian Kuesioner.

1. Bandingkanlah setiap strategi pada pemain 1 dengan setiap strategi pada pemain 2.

  Tabel Pemain 1 Pemain 2

  1 IRC Federal

  2 IRC Swallow

  3 Federal Swallow

  2. Berilah tanda centang ( √) pada salah satu kolom keputusan untuk masing- masing strategi yang anda pilih!

  Tabel 1 Strategi Keputusan No.

  IRC Federal

  IRC Federal Harga Motif

  1. Harga Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  2. Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  3. Kualitas Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  4. Jenis Ban Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan

  Tabel 2 Strategi Keputusan No.

  IRC Swallow

  IRC Swallow Harga Motif

  1. Harga Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  2. Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  3. Kualitas Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  4. Jenis Ban Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga

  Tabel 3 Strategi Keputusan

No. Federal Swallow Federal Swallow

  Harga Motif

  1. Harga Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  2. Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  3. Kualitas Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga Motif

  4. Jenis Ban Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi iklan Harga

  Hasil Kuesioner Pendahuluan No.

  4. Jenis Ban Harga

  3 Motif

  8

  2 Kualitas

  7

  3 Jenis Ban

  6

  4 Ketersediaan

  4

  6 Promosi iklan

  7

  3

  5

  3. Kualitas Harga

  5 Motif

  7

  3 Kualitas

  8

  2 Jenis Ban

  6

  4 Ketersediaan

  5

  5 Promosi iklan

  6

  4 Harga

  4

  7

  6

  Strategi Keputusan

  6 Promosi iklan

  IRC Federal

  IRC Federal

  1. Harga Harga

  6

  4 Motif

  5

  5 Kualitas

  6

  4 Jenis Ban

  7

  3 Ketersediaan

  4

  5

  4

  5

  2. Motif Harga

  6

  4 Motif

  7

  3 Kualitas

  7

  3 Jenis Ban

  8

  2 Ketersediaan

  5

  5 Promosi iklan

  6 No.

  Strategi Keputusan

  4 Kualitas

  9

  1 Jenis Ban

  7

  3 Ketersediaan

  6

  2 Promosi iklan

  4

  6

  4. Jenis Ban Harga

  6

  4 Motif

  6

  7

  8

  3 Jenis Ban

  6

  4 Ketersediaan

  4

  6 Promosi iklan

  2

  8

  5. Ketersediaan Harga

  4

  6 Motif

  4

  6 Kualitas

  6

  2 Kualitas

  2 Motif

  IRC Swallow

  7

  IRC Swallow

  1. Harga Harga

  1

  9 Motif

  5

  5 Kualitas

  8

  2 Jenis Ban

  5

  5 Ketersediaan

  3

  7 Promosi iklan

  3

  2. Motif Harga

  8

  6

  4 Motif

  7

  3 Kualitas

  7

  3 Jenis Ban

  6

  4 Ketersediaan

  3

  7 Promosi iklan

  4

  6

  3. Kualitas Harga

  4 No.

  Strategi Keputusan Federal Swallow Federal Swallow

  6

  2 Jenis Ban

  6

  4 Ketersediaan

  5

  5 Promosi iklan

  6

  4

  4. Jenis Ban Harga

  5

  5 Motif

  4

  6 Kualitas

  4 Jenis Ban

  4 Kualitas

  4

  6 Ketersediaan

  3

  7 Promosi iklan

  4

  6

  5. Ketersediaan Harga

  3

  7 Motif

  4

  6 Kualitas

  6

  8

  6

  1. Harga Harga

  2. Motif Harga

  4

  6 Motif

  5

  5 Kualitas

  6

  4 Jenis Ban

  4

  6 Ketersediaan

  4

  6 Promosi iklan

  3

  7

  6

  3 Motif

  4 Motif

  7

  3 Kualitas

  7

  3 Jenis Ban

  5

  5 Ketersediaan

  4

  6 Promosi iklan

  4

  6

  3. Kualitas Harga

  7

  4

  

Perolehan IRC Vs Federal

FEDERAL Harga Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi Iklan

  2 Ketersediaan -2 2 -4 -2 -4 Promosi Iklan -2 2 -2 -6 -6

  VAR00005 6.6667 143.467 .671 .871

  VAR00004 3.3333 116.267 .664 .880

  VAR00003 1.3333 153.067 .686 .878

  VAR00002 2.3333 128.667 .792 .850

  VAR00001 4.0000 132.800 .803 .851

  Alpha if Item Deleted

  Corrected Item-Total Correlation Cronbach's

  

Scale

Variance if

Item

Deleted

  6 Item-Total Statistics Scale Mean if Item Deleted

  N of Items .884

  Reliability Statistics Cronbach's Alpha

  2

  IRC Harga

  6

  4

  4 Jenis Ban

  4 2 -2

  6

  4

  4 6 -2 Kualitas

  4

  2

  2 4 -2 Motif

  2

  VAR00006 5.6667 107.867 .793 .853

  Perolehan IRC Vs Swallow SWALLOW Harga Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi Iklan

  IRC Harga -8 6 -4 -4 Motif

  VAR00006 1.6667 251.867 .688 .917

  VAR00005 .6667 204.267 .897 .881

  Alpha if Item Deleted

  Corrected Item-Total Correlation Cronbach's

  

Scale

Variance if

Item

Deleted

  6 Item-Total Statistics Scale Mean if Item Deleted

  N of Items .915

  Reliability Statistics Cronbach's Alpha

  4 2 -2 -6 Ketersediaan -2 -2 2 -4 -6 Promosi Iklan -4 -4 2 -6 -8 -6

  2

  2

  4 2 -2 Jenis Ban

  8

  6

  6

  4 2 -4 -2 Kualitas

  4

  2

VAR00001 -2.0000 180.800 .689 .933

VAR00002 -3.6667 186.267 .963 .868

VAR00003 -7.0000 241.200 .716 .911

  Perolehan Federal Vs Swallow SWALLOW Harga Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi Iklan

  6 Item-Total Statistics Scale Mean if Item Deleted

  VAR00005 .3333 103.067 .845 .912

  VAR00004 -1.3333 98.667 .988 .895

  VAR00003 -5.3333 109.867 .677 .931

  VAR00002 -3.3333 105.067 .655 .936

  VAR00001 -3.0000 87.600 .857 .913

  Alpha if Item Deleted

  Corrected Item-Total Correlation Cronbach's

  

Scale

Variance if

Item

Deleted

  .930

  F EDE R AL Harga -2 2 -2 -2 -4 Motif

  Cronbach's Alpha N of Items

  2 2 -2 -4 -2 Reliability Statistics

  2 Jenis Ban -2 2 -2 -4 -2 Ketersediaan -4 -2 2 -4 -6 -4 Promosi Iklan

  2

  6

  2

  4

  4 4 -2 --2 Kualitas

  2

  VAR00006 -.6667 101.867 .832 .913

  Hasil Kuesioner Formal No.

  4. Jenis Ban Harga

  25 Motif

  50

  30 Kualitas

  48

  32 Jenis Ban

  49

  31 Ketersediaan

  45

  35 Promosi iklan

  42

  38

  55

  3. Kualitas Harga

  25 Motif

  52

  28 Kualitas

  54

  26 Jenis Ban

  49

  31 Ketersediaan

  35

  45 Promosi iklan

  44

  36 Harga

  45

  55

  34

  Strategi Keputusan

  41 Promosi iklan

  IRC Federal

  IRC Federal

  1. Harga Harga

  42

  38 Motif

  49

  31 Kualitas

  55

  25 Jenis Ban

  47

  33 Ketersediaan

  39

  31

  46

  49

  2. Motif Harga

  50

  30 Motif

  48

  32 Kualitas

  53

  27 Jenis Ban

  54

  26 Ketersediaan

  41

  39 Promosi iklan

  35 No.

  Strategi Keputusan

  37 Kualitas

  56

  24 Jenis Ban

  47

  33 Ketersediaan

  51

  29 Promosi iklan

  33

  47

  4. Jenis Ban Harga

  44

  36 Motif

  43

  49

  53

  31 Jenis Ban

  46

  34 Ketersediaan

  27

  53 Promosi iklan

  28

  52

  5. Ketersediaan Harga

  39

  41 Motif

  39

  41 Kualitas

  41

  27 Kualitas

  22 Motif

  IRC Swallow

  55

  IRC Swallow

  1. Harga Harga

  39

  41 Motif

  48

  32 Kualitas

  52

  28 Jenis Ban

  39

  41 Ketersediaan

  28

  52 Promosi iklan

  25

  2. Motif Harga

  58

  44

  36 Motif

  55

  25 Kualitas

  54

  26 Jenis Ban

  47

  33 Ketersediaan

  28

  52 Promosi iklan

  32

  48

  3. Kualitas Harga

  39 No.

  Strategi Keputusan Federal Swallow Federal Swallow

  44

  34 Jenis Ban

  43

  37 Ketersediaan

  41

  39 Promosi iklan

  44

  36

  4. Jenis Ban Harga

  38

  42 Motif

  39

  41 Kualitas

  36 Jenis Ban

  35 Kualitas

  39

  41 Ketersediaan

  29

  51 Promosi iklan

  34

  46

  5. Ketersediaan Harga

  35

  45 Motif

  37

  43 Kualitas

  42

  46

  45

  1. Harga Harga

  2. Motif Harga

  36

  44 Motif

  41

  39 Kualitas

  41

  39 Jenis Ban

  34

  46 Ketersediaan

  31

  49 Promosi iklan

  28

  52

  39

  30 Motif

  41 Motif

  45

  35 Kualitas

  47

  33 Jenis Ban

  43

  37 Ketersediaan

  38

  42 Promosi iklan

  32

  48

  3. Kualitas Harga

  50

  38

  Perolehan IRC Vs Federal FEDERAL Harga Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi Iklan

  6 Item-Total Statistics Scale Mean if Item Deleted

  10

  8 8 -10 -18 -20 Promosi Iklan

  12

  6 12 -6 -16 -30 Reliability Statistics

  Cronbach's Alpha N of Items

  .899

  Scale Variance if Item Deleted

  

28

18 -10

  Corrected Item-Total Correlation Cronbach's

  Alpha if Item Deleted

  VAR00001 32.5000 2748.700 .611 .897

  VAR00002 34.8333 2863.367 .864 .881

  VAR00003 30.1667 2880.967 .601 .899

  VAR00004 40.0000 2080.000 .938 .844

  VAR00005 55.8333 2652.167 .702 .885

  8 Ketersediaan

  24

  IRC Harga

  27

  4

  18

  

30

14 -2 -18 Motif

  20

  16

  

26

  2

  30

  12 Kualitas

  30

  20

  

16

  18

  10

  4 Jenis Ban

  VAR00006 57.5000 1908.700 .882 .865

  Perolehan IRC Vs Swallow SWALLOW Harga Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi Iklan

  IRC Harga -2

  VAR00006 21.6667 4661.467 .902 .907

  VAR00005 14.3333 3563.867 .698 .925

  Alpha if Item Deleted

  Corrected Item-Total Correlation Cronbach's

  Scale Variance if Item Deleted

  6 Item-Total Statistics Scale Mean if Item Deleted

  N of Items .917

  Reliability Statistics Cronbach's Alpha

  

18

12 -26 -24 Ketersediaan -2 -2

2

4 -14 -30 Promosi Iklan -10 -12 6 -22 -36 -32

  6

  8

  14 22 -14 Jenis Ban

  

32

  26

  36

  

28

14 -24 -16 Kualitas

  30

  8

  16 24 -2 -24 -30 Motif

VAR00001 -9.0000 3641.200 .915 .879

VAR00002 -13.3333 3773.867 .814 .895

VAR00003 -21.0000 4274.800 .793 .901

  Perolehan Federal Vs Swallow SWALLOW Harga Motif Kualitas Jenis Ban Ketersediaan Promosi Iklan

  Cronbach's Alpha N of Items

  VAR00004 -18.3333 1506.267 .798 .849

  VAR00003 -28.3333 1712.667 .588 .881

  VAR00002 -21.3333 1513.067 .756 .853

  VAR00001 -18.0000 1179.200 .891 .817

  Alpha if Item Deleted

  Corrected Item-Total Correlation Cronbach's

  Scale Variance if Item Deleted

  6 Item-Total Statistics Scale Mean if Item Deleted

  .878

  12 -2 -10 -36 Reliability Statistics

  F EDE R AL Harga -8

  8 Jenis Ban -4 -2 8 -2 -22 -12 Ketersediaan -10 -6 4 -4 -14 -16 Promosi Iklan -6 -4

  2

  6

  

12

  10

  20

  

14

6 -4 -16 Kualitas

  10

  2 2 -12 -18 -24 Motif -2

  VAR00005 -8.6667 1378.667 .775 .842

  0.3

  1 X3 0.5667

  0. 1. -1.

  1. Iteration 2 cj-zj 116.

  32.

  0.

  22.

  6. 76. -5.

  4. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.8 1. 0.7333 0.4667 0.2 0.0167 -0.0167 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0167 artfcl 2 18.2667 1.2 0. 16.9333 5.8667

  0.

  0.

  0.9333 1. -1.

  36.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 6 42.

  42.

  0.

  24.

  14.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  30.8

  0.

  0.

  18.2

  0.6333 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0. 0. 0.3667 artfcl 6

  2.4 0. -6.8 -5.6 -8.4 -0.7

  0. 0. 0.0333 artfcl 5 18.4667 7.6 0. -7.8667 -5.7333

  0.7 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  2.4

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0667 artfcl 3 33.9333 13.2 0. 14.2667 18.5333

  24.8

  0.7667 0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.2333 artfcl 4 27.1333 7.6 0. 5.4667 -7.0667

  26.4

  0.9667 0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  IRC Vs FEDERAL

(untitled) Solution

Cj

  1. artfcl 2 50.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  46.

  0.

  56.

  58.

  32.

  42.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  2 0 artfcl 3 surplus

  Basic Variables

  1 X1

  1 X2

  1 X3

  1 X4

  1 X5

  1 X6 0 artfcl 1 surplus

  1 0 artfcl 2 surplus

  3 0 artfcl 4 surplus

  12. 1. -1.

  4 0 artfcl 5 surplus

  5 0 artfcl 6 surplus

  6 Quantity

  Iteration 1 cj-zj 286. 272. 300. 242. 146. 136. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. artfcl 1 34.

  48.

  60.

  44.

  28.

  0.

  0.

  10.

  0. 1. -1.

  20.

  38.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  58.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 5 40.

  38.

  38.

  20.

  12.

  48.

  54.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 3 60.

  50.

  46.

  48.

  40.

  34.

  0.

  1. artfcl 4 60.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

• 0.9333
• 0.7667
• 0.9667
• 0.6333
• 36.8649

• 0.8673
• 0.1327 0. -1.
• 4.2752
• 0.0209
• 0.2826
• 0.6732
• 1.2506

• 0.0356

• 11.5872
• 0.9238
• 15.5676
• 0.6806
• 10.4668
• 0.86
• 26.1081
• 0.0516
• 0.6708
• 81.2664
• 3.4084
• 1.9806
• 0.0578
• 0.0266
• 0.0634
• 26.7142
• 2.5763
• 0.0426
• 10.4348 0.
• 14.4348 0.
• 0.7391
• 25.0537
• 0.0745
• 0.7253

  0.

  0.6708 0.

  0. 1. -1. 0.2776 teration 4 cj-zj 0. 12.8575 0. -46.543 0.

  0.0957 -1.0957

  2.4084 0. -1.

  0.9806 0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.

  0.0578 0. 0. 0.018 -0.018 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0134

  1 X5 0. -0.3686 0. 1.2475 1. 1.2262

  0.0266 0.0941 -0.0941 0.

  0.

  0.0634 0.

  1 X3 0. 0.8677 1. -0.1471 0. -1.1045 0.0532 -0.0532

  0. -41.778 1.1702 -1.1702

  0. 0. 0.0042 artfcl 3 0. 13.7854 0.

  2.5763 1. -1. 0.4838 -0.4838 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0777

  1 X1 1. 0.1841 0. 0.5264 0. 1.2923

  0.0426 0.0245 -0.0245 0. 0. 0.0204 -0.0204 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0023 artfcl 5 0. 2.087 0.

  0. 0.087 -0.087 0.

  0.

  0.7391 1. -1.

  0. 0. 0.3478 artfcl 6 0. -3.0148 0. -9.3941 0.

  0.0745 0.0809 -0.0809 0.

  0.

  0.7253 0.

  0.

  0.0516 0.

  0.

  0.

  Iteration 3 cj-zj 0. -0.4914 0. -1.371 36.2113

  0. -1.

  3.2752 0. -1. 0. -1.

  1 X3 0. 0.6413 1. 0.6192 0.6143 -0.3514 0.0369 -0.0369 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0209 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.016 artfcl 2 0. -3.9165 0. 13.2531 10.6241 13.027

  0.2826 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.6732 0.

  0. 0. 0.0442 artfcl 3 0. 3.6953 0. 7.43 27.371 -8.2162 0.4423 -0.4423 0.

  0. 0. 0.344 artfcl 6 0. -2.6978 0.

  0.

  0.6806 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0246 -0.0246 0.

  0. 0. 0.0012 artfcl 5 0. 2.4275 0.

  0. 0. 0.0369 -0.0369 0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.0356 0.

  1 X1 1. 0.2801 0. 0.2015 -0.2604 0.973

  0. 0. 0.1916

  0.

  1.2506 0.

  0. 1. -1. 0.2812

• 21.6269 0.
• 42.3004
• 0.9957
• 0.0043
• 1.0055
• 0.9327
• 0.0673
• 2.4318
• 0.0205
• 0.0629
• 0.0124
• 0.0504
• 0.1869
• 0.0582
• 0.0134

• 0.1772
• 0.1514
• 0.8124

• 15.2363 0.
• 34.1903
• 0.4825
• 0.6194
• 36.7625
• 28.3925
• 45.3945
• 1.1291
• 1.7219
• 1.6919 0.6919 -1.
• 0.0216
• 0.0695
• 0.1693
• 0.0569
• 16.1091
• 9.8656
• 0.2528
• 0.5822
• 21.7844
• 12.2834
• 35.5289
• 0.7924
• 0.1098

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.1693 0.0912 -0.0912 0.

  1. 0. -1.5669 0.6959 -2.9548 0.0882 -0.0882

  1 X2 0.

  0. 0. 0.1238

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 10.5709 19.8297 2.161 0.0931 -0.0931 0.5003 -0.5003 0.5303 -0.5303 -1.

  1.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.007 surplus 4

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0695 0.

  0.0216 0.0981 -0.0981

  0. 1. 1.4032 -0.2462 1.4983

  1 X3 0.

  0.

  0.01

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.1098 0.

  0.7924

  0.1238 -0.1238

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.2355 artfcl 6

  0.5822 0.

  1 X1 1.

  0.2528 0.0705 -0.0705

  0. 0. -14.978

  0.

  0. 0. 0.003 artfcl 5

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0569 0.0659 -0.0659 -0.006 0.006 0.

  0. 0. 1.0299 0.2754 1.8802

  0. 0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.1291

  0.7219

  0.0124 0.

  1. 0. -1.9379 0. -3.0306 0.0849 -0.0849

  1 X2 0.

  0. 0. 0.0062

  0.

  0.0504 0.

  0. 0. 0.5331 1. 0.109 0.0047 -0.0047 0.0252 -0.0252 0.0267 -0.0267

  1 X5 0.

  0. 0. 0.0085

  0.

  0.0629

  0.

  0.0205 0.1043 -0.1043

  0. 1. 1.5344 0. 1.5252

  1 X3 0.

  1.4318 0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.0055

  0.

  0.

  0.

  Iteration 5 cj-zj

  0.1869 0.0725 -0.0725 0.0351 -0.0351 0.

  0. 0. 0.0056

  0.

  0. 0. 0.3361 artfcl 6

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1. 0.2982 Iteration 6 cj-zj

  0.6194 0.

  0.4825 0.2187 -0.2187

  0.1815 -0.1815

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.8124 1. -1.

  1 X1 1.

  0.1514

  0.1772 0.477 -0.477

  0. 0. -6.3906 0. -8.1101

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0013 artfcl 5

  0.

  0.0134 0.0139 -0.0139 0.

  0.0582 0.0589 -0.0589

  0. 0. 0.8831 0. 1.8502

  0. 1. -1. 0.2216

• 30.0825
• 31.3595
• 32.7976
• 1.5049 0.5049 -1.
• 2.0806 1.0806 -1.
• 0.0167
• 17.4499 0.5206 -0.5206 -1.
• 0.0226

• 15.6306
• 15.8193
• 11.0963
• 0.2161
• 0.5442
• 14.4519
• 15.5403
• 21.7014
• 0.2888
• 0.5363
• 0.9231 -0.0769 -1.
• 2.0147
• 0.0311
• 15.6044
• 1.2821
• 38.9231
• 0.0769
• 23.7582
• 11.4872
• 39.2308 0.2308 -0.2308 -1.
• 0.0385
• 1.0147
• 26.9451
• 28.9744
• 40.4615
• 0.5385

  0.

  0.

  1.

  0. 0. 1.4908 -1.4908 0.4139 surplus 2 0. 1.2088 0.

  1.

  0. 0. -1.

  0.

  0.0769 0.

  0.0311 0.0073 surplus 4 0. -4.022 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1 X3 0. 0.7253 1. 0.9451 0.641 0.4615 0.0385 -0.0385 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 1.0037 -1.0037 0.2344

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1.

  0.5385 0. 0. -1.

  1.0147 0.0623 surplus 3 0. -8.7253 0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  1 X1 1. 0.1319 0. -0.3736 -0.3077 -0.4615

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0549 -0.0549 0.0165 artfcl 5 0. 5.1648 0. -0.967 -0.0513 10.9231 0.0769 -0.0769 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0385 0.

  1.0147

  0. 0. -1.

  0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.

  1. 0.5383 -0.5383 0.

  4.11

  0. 0. 0.1532 surplus 2 0. 5.9057 0. -9.2534

  0.

  0.

  1.

  0. 0. 0.0128 surplus 4 0. 2.9548 0. 5.9411 21.8861 -6.5697 0.3536 -0.3536 0. 0. 0.7996 -0.7996 -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0167 0.

  0.

  1 X3 0. 0.5796 1. 0.4951 0.1572 -0.2141 0.0295 -0.0295 0.

  0. 0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.

  teration 7 cj-zj 0. -4.2633 0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 5.1648 0. -0.967 -0.0513 10.9231

  0. 1. -1.

  0. 1. -1. 0.1749 Iteration 8 cj-zj

  0.

  0.

  0.5363 0.

  0.

  0.2888 0.

  0. 0. 0.2397 artfcl 6 0. -4.6798 0.

  0.5442 0.

  0. 0. 0.0589

  0.

  0.2161 0.

  0. 0. 0.0069 artfcl 5 0. 0.4165 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0226 0. 0. 0.0295 -0.0295 0.

  1 X1 1. 0.389 0. 0.4204 0.5462 0.7308

  0. 0. 1.8645 -1.8645 0.326

• 0.0423
• 19.0503
• 1.4648 0. 0.1972 -0.1972 0.
• 2.1247
• 27.2314
• 11.6714 0. 0.507 -0.507 -1.
• 2.6405
• 0.0352

• 0.0929
• 30.5272
• 29.1643 0.
• 0.2535
• 0.0691
• 0.0423
• 19.0503
• 1.4648 0. 0.1972 -0.1972 0.
• 2.1247
• 27.2314
• 11.6714 0. 0.507 -0.507 -1.
• 2.6405
• 0.0352
• 0.0929
• 30.5272
• 29.1643 0.
• 0.2535

  2.1247 0.6358 surplus 2 0. 19.7586 0.

  0. 0. -1. 1. 3.5634 -3.5634

  0.

  0.0423 0.0117 -0.0117 0.0047 surplus 4 0. 14.3823 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1 X3 0. 0.507 1. 0.9859 0.6432 0. 0.0352 -0.0352 0.

  0.0691

  0. 0. 0.0915 -0.0915

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.33 0. -0.5171 -0.6714 0. 0.007 -0.007 0.

  1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 3.7042 -3.7042 -1.894 1.894 0.5567 Iteration

  1.

  0.2535 0. 0. -1.

  0.0929 0.0057 surplus 3 0. 10.4064 0.

  0. 0. 0.0915 -0.0915

  0.

  0.

  1 X6 0. 0.4728 0. -0.0885 -0.0047 1. 0.007 -0.007 0.

  0. 0. 3.5915 -3.5915

  0. 0. 0.0423 -0.0423 0.0121 -0.0121 0.0191

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0352 0.

  1 X1 1. 0.3501 0. -0.4145 -0.3099 0.

  2.6405 0.4581

  0.

  10 cj-zj

  0. 0. 3.7042 -3.7042 -1.894 1.894 0.5567 Iteration

  0.

  0.

  0.0423 0.0117 -0.0117 0.0047 surplus 4 0. 14.3823 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1 X3 0. 0.507 1. 0.9859 0.6432 0. 0.0352 -0.0352 0.

  2.1247 0.6358 surplus 2 0. 19.7586 0.

  0.

  0. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  Iteration 9 cj-zj

  0. 0. -1. 1. 3.5634 -3.5634

  1.

  1.

  0. 0. 0.0423 -0.0423 0.0121 -0.0121 0.0191

  0.2535 0. 0. -1.

  0.0929 0.0057 surplus 3 0. 10.4064 0.

  0. 0. 0.0915 -0.0915

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1 X6 0. 0.4728 0. -0.0885 -0.0047 1. 0.007 -0.007 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0352 0.

  1 X1 1. 0.3501 0. -0.4145 -0.3099 0.

  2.6405 0.4581

  0. 0. 3.5915 -3.5915

  0.

  11

• 0.0159
• 0.0767
• 0.0833
• 28.3651
• 47.0159
• 19.709 0.
• 0.8016
• 2.4577
• 38.9683
• 65.6508
• 36.7355 0.
• 0.8651 0.8651 -1.
• 3.0979

• 0.0595

• 0.0258
• 0.1038
• 20.5238
• 50.7619
• 42.3651 0.
• 0.9762
• 2.1349
• 0.0541
• 23.1592
• 5.4013
• 23.6688
• 0.1911
• 11.1465
• 35.5796
• 18.7006
• 29.8344
• 0.0955 0.0955 -1.
• 0.0605
• 0.2484
• 30.0382
• 29.9363
• 20.5605
• 0.4459

  0.

  0.0541 0. 0. 0.0096 surplus 4 0. 0. -6.293

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1 X2 0. 1. 1.7643 1.7197 1.1338 0.2229 0.0637 -0.0637 0.

  0. 0. 0.0223 -0.0223 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  12 cj-zj 0. 0. 0.0382 -0.414 -0.6433 -0.7389 0.0032 -0.0032 0.

  2.1349 0.4603 Iteration

  0. 0. 4.5714 -4.5714

  1.

  0.9762 0. 0. -1.

  0.1911 0.

  0. 0. -1. 1. 1.6624 -1.6624 0. 0. 0.4713 surplus 2

  1.

  0.

  0.4459 0. 0. -1.

  0. 0. 1.2611 -1.2611 -1. 1. 0.0127 surplus 3 0. 0. -1.3503

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.2484 0.

  0. 0. 0.0764 -0.0764 0. 0. 0.0159 surplus 6 0. 0. -8.9809 -9.707 -5.8217 9.6306

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0605 0.

  1 X1 1. 0. -0.7261 -1.1338 -0.7771 0.0382

  0. 0. 1.3312 -1.3312 0. 0. 0.2357

  0.

  0.

  1.

  0.

  0.

  0.1038 0.0013 surplus 3

  0.

  0.

  0.8016 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0833 0.0231 -0.0231 0.0093 surplus 4

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. -1. 1. 4.7619 -4.7619

  1 X2 0. 1. 1.9722 1.9444 1.2685 0. 0.0694 -0.0694 0.

  0.0767

  0. 0. 0.119 -0.119

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0159 0.

  cj-zj 0. 0. -0.6508 -1.1587 -1.0899 0.

  0.

  2.4577 0.5026 surplus 2

  0. 0. 0.131 -0.131

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0258 0.

  1 X6 0. 0. -0.9325 -1.0079 -0.6045 1.

  0. 0. 0.0714 -0.0714 0.004 -0.004 0.0159

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0595 0.

  1 X1 1. 0. -0.6905 -1.0952 -0.754 0.

  3.0979 0.2751

  0. 0. 5.2381 -5.2381

  0.

  0.

  1.

  0.

  0. 0. 1.879 -1.879 0. 0. 0.4331

• 0.0217
• 0.0307

• 17.0253
• 1.3574
• 22.8736
• 24.7148
• 11.5379 -28.426 0.3069 -0.3069 -1.
• 0.0343
• 29.0686
• 20.3899
• 0.3971

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.9892 -0.9892 0. 0. 0.296

  1 X1 1. 0.4116 0. -0.426 -0.3105

  0.13

  0.0343 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0542 -0.0542 0. 0. 0.0199 surplus 6 0. 5.0903 0. -0.9531 -0.0505 10.7653 0.0758 -0.0758 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.9856 -0.9856 -1. 1. 0.0614 surplus 3 0. 0.7653 0. -28.722

  0.3971 0. 0. -1.

  1.

  1.

  0.

  0. 0. -1. 1. 1.4693 -1.4693 0. 0. 0.5054 surplus 2 0. 6.3177 0.

  0. 0. 0.0235 -0.0235 0.

  Iteration

  13 cj-zj

  0.

  0. -0.4513 -0.6679 -0.7437 0.0018 -0.0018 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0361 -0.0361 0.

  1 X3 0. 0.5668 1. 0.9747 0.6426 0.1264 0.0361 -0.0361 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.0307 0. 0. 0.0054 surplus 4 0. 3.5668 0.

  0. 0. 1.8375 -1.8375 0. 0. 0.4404

  (untitled) Solution

X1 X2

  X5 X6 RHS Dual

  Minimize 1.

  1.

  1.

  1.

  1.

  1. Constraint 1 34.

  48.

  60.

  44.

  28. 12. >= 1. -0.0018 Constraint 2 50.

  46.

  56.

  58.

  32. 42. >= 1.

  0. Constraint 3 60.

  50.

  46.

  48.

  40. 34. >= 1.

  0. Constraint 4 60.

  54.

  58.

  48.

  20. 38. >= 1.

  0. Constraint 5 40.

  38.

  38.

  20.

  12. 10. >= 1. -0.0235 Constraint 6 42.

  36.

  42.

  24.

  14. 0. >= 1.

  0. Solution-> 0.0199 0. 0.0054 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.03

  0. 1. -1. 0.3824

  0.

  4.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  14.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  1. Iteration 2 cj-zj

  0. -3.7059

  0. -1.

  3.7941 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. artfcl 1

  0.

  42.

  0.

  0.

  34.

  38.

  40.

  22.

  6.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  24.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 6 26.

  0.

  0.8824 0.

  0.

  0.5588 0.

  0.7941 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.2059 artfcl 5 -6.2353 -0.6471 0. 12.0588 -10.4118 -6.2941 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.4412 artfcl 6

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.6176 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.1176 artfcl 2

  7.6471 0. 2.9412 -42.5882 -0.7059 0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.9412 0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0147 artfcl 4

  0. 0. 0.0588

  1 X3 1.0588 0.9118 1. 0.7353 0.8529 0.3235 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0147 -0.0147 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 5 34.

  0.

  IRC Vs SWALLOW

(untitled) Solution

Cj

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  12.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 2 44.

  66.

  64.

  50.

  12.

  6. 1. -1.

  34.

  0.

  1 0 artfcl 2 surplus

  Basic Variables

  1 X1

  1 X2

  1 X3

  1 X4

  1 X5

  1 X6 0 artfcl 1 surplus

  2 0 artfcl 3 surplus

  60.

  3 0 artfcl 4 surplus

  4 0 artfcl 5 surplus

  5 0 artfcl 6 surplus

  6 Quantity

  Iteration 1 cj-zj 254. 280. 326. 236. 114.

  70. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. 0. -1. artfcl 1 34.

  52.

  20.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  10.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 4 44.

  42.

  54.

  48.

  12.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1. artfcl 3 72.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  62.

  0. 1. -1.

  68.

  50.

  58.

  22.

  0.

  0.

  0.

• 91.1765
• 17.2353
• 164.0588
• 35.4706 0. -1.
• 4.7941
• 29.5294
• 2.7059 0.
• 10.1176
• 39.1765
• 13.4118 1. -1.
• 0.8824
• 23.7647
• 0.9412
• 13.1765
• 7.2353 0. 8.2941 -36.0588 -5.4706 0.
• 0.7941
• 0.5588
• 18.4706
• 14.2941 0.
• 16.8824
• 35.8235 -9.5882 0.
• 0.6176
• 48.0625 0.

• 15.5625
• 4.0313 3.0313 -1.
• 0.9375

• 13.6875
• 0.8437
• 0.5937
• 19.3125 0.
• 18.8125
• 7.875 -9.125 0.
• 0.6562
• 45.4034 0.
• 20.8487 0.
• 29.6134 0. -1.
• 3.7269 2.7269 -1.
• 0.5126
• 0.4874 0. -1.
• 12.4538 1. -1.
• 0.9076
• 0.0504
• 18.6218 0.
• 0.7437 0.7437 -1.
• 0.0126
• 13.7311
• 0.8487
• 0.0399
• 22.0588 0.
• 13.3529 0.
• 12.2353 0.
• 0.9706

  1.

  0.

  0.0504 0. 0. 0.042 surplus 3 -1.2941 -7.6555 0. 34.4958 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.9076 0.

  artfcl 1 -7.6471 -9.6134 0. -13.395 0.

  0. 0. -1.

  0. 1. -1. 0.3438 Iteration 4 cj-zj 0.5882

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.6562 0.

  0. 0. 3.042 -3.042 0. 0. 1.2983

  1 X3 0.5882 1.0966 1. 0.6513 0. 0.3866 0. 0. 0.0231 -0.0231 0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.9706 0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0672 -0.0672 0. 0. 0.0273 artfcl 6 1.2941

  0.

  0.0399 0.

  1 X5 0.5294 -0.3487 0. 0.6933 1. -0.395 0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1. 0.0084 -0.0084 0. 0. 0.1597

  0.8487 0.

  0.

  0. 5.8992 0. -4.9244 0.

  0.0126 0. 0. 0.0105 artfcl 4 6.9412

  0.

  0.

  0. 1. -1.

  0. 0. 0.4063 artfcl 6 -2.875

  0.

  0.

  0.

  0.

  1.

  0. 0. 0.0625 surplus 3 -25.25 8.125 0. 3.125 -45.25 -0.75 0. 0. 1.0625 -1.0625 -1.

  0.

  0.

  0. 0. 0.0625

  0.

  0.

  0.9375 0.