Dampak Desentralisasi terhadap Sektor riil
!
!
"
)
! #$
(
%&&'
$
(
)
*(
+
,
(
"
+
"
-
,
-
+
(
.
"
"
"
(
/
!
(
$
1
"
#
$
#
$ # *
(# (
* * '
# *
+ (
) # *
(
#
) ,
#
#
#)
#
* *
*
( + )
)
&
*
# *
( #%
*
*
%
/ *
& #
"
*
( #
*'
* ( '$
*
#
#
*
#
#
% *
+
*
(
(
$ +
+
#
**
#
(
#
(
+
+
( #
0
)
&<
*
#
.
#
$'
+
#%
"
#
(
*
#
#
*
" #*
(
#
% $
+
(
)
$
*
)
#
$
# $
2
+ *
46
(
( *
" (
#
* &
# '$
#* +
%
#
(
. (
*
(
" # &
# ) , *
#
#
**
* (
0 #
% &" '
(
#
#
" ( $ ( #
$
#
( #
+ *
#
#
" (
* &
# * ( #*
'
+
# *
+
( + * #
( #
% +
+ (
$ #
&
. '
+
*-
#
(
#
#
#
) 33
+
+ *
$+ *
. + + )
( #
# )1
#(#
#
#(
"
* "
(
+
+ #
:
;
*
#
(
*
# (
# * * :3664;$
# + *
# *
*
.
)
#
*
'
+
#
( #
*
# )1 *
* %
*)
#
.
#
*
# (
),
%
*
4555
&
+ *
#
-
(
#*
# +
)
+
#
#.
%
#(#
#
#%
$
# ( # #
7
# (
.
*
6 8494555
*
+
(
#
#
#( # *
#0
#
.
#
+ $ .
* - .
* #
# (
# ( $ +
- (
#
#
.
#
#
$
#
( #
*
(
*
#
#
- + $
(
*
)
*
'
#
*
*
0
*
)
#
* *
(
455=
(
(
( #
#
$
*
(# + ( #"
# (
#
# 1 # $
%
(# +
#) %
% )
#
% #
)
#
# (
+
#
( #"
+
%
$
* (
# ( *
( #
.
# (
# +
*-
2
(
*
=
452= *
# +
# +
# )
# * + *
*
*
* (
( #"
#
(
%
.
#
# - #
(
+ #
&
'
%
(
#
$
*
*
" # + #
# $
(
+
%
( " * #
#
)
+
% #
%
7
* ( *
#
*
)
+
( #"
+ *
$ +
# ** *% .
%
* ( *
)
+ *
+
#
"(
&
'
)
* >
0 !# (
:>! ; + *
1 #
+ (
#
)
#
#
*
+ >!
*
(
# #
0 #
@ 3; (
(
# #
" #
#@ 8; # #
#
# @ =; #
(# *# # 7 # #
*
(
# @ 2;
#
)
#
*
* + *
(
( #
# :
(
(
+ *
*
*
*
#
* #%
( #
(
;
#
" *
*
%
#
0
(
% + *
%
.
*
+
# ,
( #
$(
+
#
#
#
#
) 0
(
* #
#(
(
#
!, 4555)
#
(
(
# (
#
%
+
)
(
+ *
#
.
#
(
#
#
+ *
#
.
* $
*
#
(
*
(
.
# ( +
#
)
** +
, *
( +
#
*
* 2-? 0
# 3664
#
+ * #
*
)
#
#
*
*
$ +
4;
*@ A; ( *
(
*
# +
@ B; ( *
#
@ ?; (# *#
>!
( #
#
$
#
0
)
%
( #
*) 0
)&
# $& * (
45$
1 # :
(#
*
%
7
(
#
9 4?9A 3663;)
#
#
#
(
* + *
# )
#
*
** ( +
* + *
% *
# (
(# *# (# #
** *% .
** * * *
( % *
#
#
(
(
)
*
#
!
# (
" #
#
# ( #
( *
+
$
(
7
(
#
)
" #
%
#
+
(
#
(
*
# (
#
+ * #
+
#
#
$
#
3
*
7
(
#
7
#
%
(
+
9
(
(
#
(# (
)
#
" #
. +
#
# (
(
#
#
(
#
#$ ( #
(
(
)
% *
# (
(& # *
'(
#
(
9
+ *
#
( #
&
1
%
(
*
(
(# ( ) >
$
#
:3663;
# (
1 *% # $ #
#
*( *
*
(#
-(#
.
+ * #
%
$
%
. #%
7
(
*
#
(
( *
# ( #.
+ *
+
(
+
"
0
" $
( *
(
.
#(
+ )
(
$ ( #
,
+
#
+ )'
+
#
#
" * +
% '
# *
**
*
7 ,
)
$
*
) A3
( #
*
*
(
$ (# (
#
( ( *
+ % *
*
( #
( #
(
*
+
%
7
(
#
# $ #
7
+ *
#
#
%
*
(
" #
"
*
#(
#
( #
+
# 7 #
-
#
%
#
@ 3;
$ #
+ *
. # *
, #
+
*
33A
$
(
*
:23 4 '5 '&& @ A;
8;
(
#
(
(
>
$ 3664;)
(
#
#@ A;
+
# 7
* *
*
*
+
#
#.
%
#
% + *
4555
*
# (
#
+ * * 7
#
$
#
#
+ *
7
$
(
4;
+ *
@
(
#
4;
# *
" # #
, " " $ $ 3664;$
*
#
#
-
# (
(
(
*
*
#$
*
$
#
*
4; 4A ( #
# " *@ 3;
33$A66 )
*
7
# ( #
+
*
:
;
#$ #
#
4;
(
# + @ 3;
#
+ #
+ #
#
$
( *
3668
+
A3
*
><
*
( ( #
# (
:B;
(
$+
#@ =; (
@ B; , # )
( + *
"
(
+ # %
" @ A; *
** *
,
*
:
(
(
( # + *
# *
4555 + *
3=
*
*
#
$
(
(
+ *
# ' #
7 # # 7 #
$
(
$ ( #
( $ # ( # $
#
* ( " #
#
(
#
+ )
+ *
)
@ 8;
+
#
-
+
#
, # @ A;
3;
( #
#
(
33
#
3666
#
3=
*
#
+ &
#
+
(
#
*(
%
.
*
#
#
84
4555) #
& %
( *'
*
# * )
)
# (
#
%
3668
(
(
9
)
#
#
, #
(
@
#( %
:
*
0
#
+ #
)<
4
# " * ( A666 9 A
+
# (
+ #
( *
3664;)
. # *
*
*
(
(
# (
#
(
#
#(
#
#
(
(
@ 3;
A6 "
(
(
+
( =)666 ( # A@ 8;
# *
(
() 36)666 ( #
(
#
(
:, ##$ >)$
)$
# (
4; (
+ # #
# +
#
*
** *$ *
( +
# #
%
>
$ 3664;)
#
B3
#
(
:
+
(
( #
455=-3666
(
* *
@7
( =6)666 ( #
(
+
# (
4;
+
*
(
, #
+ ## ( + *
# (#
%
*$ (
#
(
%
8A? C
.
(
( #
% * (
#
3666)
* @ 3;
#
%
# *@ A;
. # *
+ )
** *
# + *
(
#
* A66 %
* +
(
# 36 "
# .
% % 3=
: "> # +$ 1) # +$
+ * ( #
)
(
)
*
#
3666)
0 #
(
( 7
%
)
*
# *
$
#
#
(
. #
$
(
(
#
#
#- # # + * . . " #
(
#
+ #
+ =6 %
*
#
$
+
* + *
*
*
+
( *
$
**
*
.
*
# (
( - (
(
A3
*
#
) :, ##$ >)$ )$ 3664;
4)
#7+ *
#7
#
*
+ #
+
*
9
#7
#
7
( * *
( #
*
*
+
-
+ + *
#
-7
0
#
(
( #%
* #
$
+ * (
3666
*
.
0 + * ( #
%
#
* .
0
(
0
*
)
( +
)
*
>E
*
F)
$
**
#
+
*
*
(
#
#
%
* *
#
)
#
#
# *
# A
()36)866
G3
()=3)366
()43=)666
# *
*
+ #
9
#7, #
-
0
% # *
)
+
#
(
# -
. ( # (
* *
.
#
%
+ *
# *
(
#(
+ * #
* . + -. + + *
" # 7 #
# )
(
# 3666$
+
# (
7
#
( #
.
( # (
* *
.
A26
( #
#
#
% ,
* $
$
#
+ )
*
366
( #
#
. +
)
%# + ( #
# + *
* #
+
*
#
# 7 #
(
( # +
*
+ )
# *$ #
#
0 *
+ *
, #$ >)$
) : 3664;$ (
. +
*
** *
*
# "
. 866
( #
# )
**
(
$
" " (
$ ( # + *
" (
# * (
0 #
* # +
.
(
*
+
+ &*
% ' : "> # +$ 1)< )$ 3664;)
,#
#
" 7
( *
()B8)666
G 4B
() 453)666
*
+
*
6
9
3
()86)666
()A3)666
()?2)666
()4B6)666
*-
! #$ %&&6
**
( * *
+
*
+
**
*
+
#
# + ( #
* (
(
. # * )
*
+ ( *
( *
+
* )
*
*
( *
( * *
*
# +
#
(
#
(
$+ *"
# * (
( #
&"
" " 7
(
*' # (
#
+
+
%
( *
#
(( # (
* * %
)&
#
#
# +
( *
9( #
" #
* * (
)
#
# +
( *
. (
#
(
$'
* (
#
# (
* *
)
** +
( # (
+ # (
%
"
( *
+ *
( #
#
$
(
#
#
(
#
(
( #
( #
+ %
(
( ( *
-( *
#
(
(
*
+ # ) :, ##$ >)$
)$ 3664;
#
( #
( #
* (
+ $
*
# + *
# 7)
#
+
:3664;$ #
( #
#
*
*
* (
#
#
# *
. #
*# *
#
# . "
+ * #
*
$ #
( # #
*- *
#(
*
#
#
+ #
#
( ( - ( + * * #
+ $
+
" # 7
(
" #
#
+
)&,
*
)
( #
# $& *
+ )
!
%
(
" +
+
.# .
( #
#
*
+
##
.
( *
7
.
#
#+
$( #
#
*
7
+ #
# , #
*
"
#
#
+
# ) , ##$ >)$
( *
#
)$ :3664;
#
*
#%
# )
( #
*
(
+ * +
*
7
( *
# ** *% .
(
)
+ -. +
+
*
*
+
(
#
#
#" ( )
#
* *)
(
# *+ *
# $
*
*
#
$
#
( #
(
( * #
" +
#
#
*
%
*
(
(
#
*
#
*
*
#
7 *
"
$
#
+ *
( #
%
(
*
. + -. +
)
*
(
*
*
$
#
*
%
( # + *
#%
(
#
# D
+
#
(#
7
)
7
(
#
(
, # $
( #
.
3666 (
#
# " * #*
8 + # # ( )
% *
"
.
% *
( % *
+
(
(
#
( #
46 + # # (
#
# )
+ * #
#* 8
+ # # (
# (#
# 33? C) : "> # +$ 1) # +$ 1)
!
"
)
! #$
(
%&&'
$
(
)
*(
+
,
(
"
+
"
-
,
-
+
(
.
"
"
"
(
/
!
(
$
1
"
#
$
#
$ # *
(# (
* * '
# *
+ (
) # *
(
#
) ,
#
#
#)
#
* *
*
( + )
)
&
*
# *
( #%
*
*
%
/ *
& #
"
*
( #
*'
* ( '$
*
#
#
*
#
#
% *
+
*
(
(
$ +
+
#
**
#
(
#
(
+
+
( #
0
)
&<
*
#
.
#
$'
+
#%
"
#
(
*
#
#
*
" #*
(
#
% $
+
(
)
$
*
)
#
$
# $
2
+ *
46
(
( *
" (
#
* &
# '$
#* +
%
#
(
. (
*
(
" # &
# ) , *
#
#
**
* (
0 #
% &" '
(
#
#
" ( $ ( #
$
#
( #
+ *
#
#
" (
* &
# * ( #*
'
+
# *
+
( + * #
( #
% +
+ (
$ #
&
. '
+
*-
#
(
#
#
#
) 33
+
+ *
$+ *
. + + )
( #
# )1
#(#
#
#(
"
* "
(
+
+ #
:
;
*
#
(
*
# (
# * * :3664;$
# + *
# *
*
.
)
#
*
'
+
#
( #
*
# )1 *
* %
*)
#
.
#
*
# (
),
%
*
4555
&
+ *
#
-
(
#*
# +
)
+
#
#.
%
#(#
#
#%
$
# ( # #
7
# (
.
*
6 8494555
*
+
(
#
#
#( # *
#0
#
.
#
+ $ .
* - .
* #
# (
# ( $ +
- (
#
#
.
#
#
$
#
( #
*
(
*
#
#
- + $
(
*
)
*
'
#
*
*
0
*
)
#
* *
(
455=
(
(
( #
#
$
*
(# + ( #"
# (
#
# 1 # $
%
(# +
#) %
% )
#
% #
)
#
# (
+
#
( #"
+
%
$
* (
# ( *
( #
.
# (
# +
*-
2
(
*
=
452= *
# +
# +
# )
# * + *
*
*
* (
( #"
#
(
%
.
#
# - #
(
+ #
&
'
%
(
#
$
*
*
" # + #
# $
(
+
%
( " * #
#
)
+
% #
%
7
* ( *
#
*
)
+
( #"
+ *
$ +
# ** *% .
%
* ( *
)
+ *
+
#
"(
&
'
)
* >
0 !# (
:>! ; + *
1 #
+ (
#
)
#
#
*
+ >!
*
(
# #
0 #
@ 3; (
(
# #
" #
#@ 8; # #
#
# @ =; #
(# *# # 7 # #
*
(
# @ 2;
#
)
#
*
* + *
(
( #
# :
(
(
+ *
*
*
*
#
* #%
( #
(
;
#
" *
*
%
#
0
(
% + *
%
.
*
+
# ,
( #
$(
+
#
#
#
#
) 0
(
* #
#(
(
#
!, 4555)
#
(
(
# (
#
%
+
)
(
+ *
#
.
#
(
#
#
+ *
#
.
* $
*
#
(
*
(
.
# ( +
#
)
** +
, *
( +
#
*
* 2-? 0
# 3664
#
+ * #
*
)
#
#
*
*
$ +
4;
*@ A; ( *
(
*
# +
@ B; ( *
#
@ ?; (# *#
>!
( #
#
$
#
0
)
%
( #
*) 0
)&
# $& * (
45$
1 # :
(#
*
%
7
(
#
9 4?9A 3663;)
#
#
#
(
* + *
# )
#
*
** ( +
* + *
% *
# (
(# *# (# #
** *% .
** * * *
( % *
#
#
(
(
)
*
#
!
# (
" #
#
# ( #
( *
+
$
(
7
(
#
)
" #
%
#
+
(
#
(
*
# (
#
+ * #
+
#
#
$
#
3
*
7
(
#
7
#
%
(
+
9
(
(
#
(# (
)
#
" #
. +
#
# (
(
#
#
(
#
#$ ( #
(
(
)
% *
# (
(& # *
'(
#
(
9
+ *
#
( #
&
1
%
(
*
(
(# ( ) >
$
#
:3663;
# (
1 *% # $ #
#
*( *
*
(#
-(#
.
+ * #
%
$
%
. #%
7
(
*
#
(
( *
# ( #.
+ *
+
(
+
"
0
" $
( *
(
.
#(
+ )
(
$ ( #
,
+
#
+ )'
+
#
#
" * +
% '
# *
**
*
7 ,
)
$
*
) A3
( #
*
*
(
$ (# (
#
( ( *
+ % *
*
( #
( #
(
*
+
%
7
(
#
# $ #
7
+ *
#
#
%
*
(
" #
"
*
#(
#
( #
+
# 7 #
-
#
%
#
@ 3;
$ #
+ *
. # *
, #
+
*
33A
$
(
*
:23 4 '5 '&& @ A;
8;
(
#
(
(
>
$ 3664;)
(
#
#@ A;
+
# 7
* *
*
*
+
#
#.
%
#
% + *
4555
*
# (
#
+ * * 7
#
$
#
#
+ *
7
$
(
4;
+ *
@
(
#
4;
# *
" # #
, " " $ $ 3664;$
*
#
#
-
# (
(
(
*
*
#$
*
$
#
*
4; 4A ( #
# " *@ 3;
33$A66 )
*
7
# ( #
+
*
:
;
#$ #
#
4;
(
# + @ 3;
#
+ #
+ #
#
$
( *
3668
+
A3
*
><
*
( ( #
# (
:B;
(
$+
#@ =; (
@ B; , # )
( + *
"
(
+ # %
" @ A; *
** *
,
*
:
(
(
( # + *
# *
4555 + *
3=
*
*
#
$
(
(
+ *
# ' #
7 # # 7 #
$
(
$ ( #
( $ # ( # $
#
* ( " #
#
(
#
+ )
+ *
)
@ 8;
+
#
-
+
#
, # @ A;
3;
( #
#
(
33
#
3666
#
3=
*
#
+ &
#
+
(
#
*(
%
.
*
#
#
84
4555) #
& %
( *'
*
# * )
)
# (
#
%
3668
(
(
9
)
#
#
, #
(
@
#( %
:
*
0
#
+ #
)<
4
# " * ( A666 9 A
+
# (
+ #
( *
3664;)
. # *
*
*
(
(
# (
#
(
#
#(
#
#
(
(
@ 3;
A6 "
(
(
+
( =)666 ( # A@ 8;
# *
(
() 36)666 ( #
(
#
(
:, ##$ >)$
)$
# (
4; (
+ # #
# +
#
*
** *$ *
( +
# #
%
>
$ 3664;)
#
B3
#
(
:
+
(
( #
455=-3666
(
* *
@7
( =6)666 ( #
(
+
# (
4;
+
*
(
, #
+ ## ( + *
# (#
%
*$ (
#
(
%
8A? C
.
(
( #
% * (
#
3666)
* @ 3;
#
%
# *@ A;
. # *
+ )
** *
# + *
(
#
* A66 %
* +
(
# 36 "
# .
% % 3=
: "> # +$ 1) # +$
+ * ( #
)
(
)
*
#
3666)
0 #
(
( 7
%
)
*
# *
$
#
#
(
. #
$
(
(
#
#
#- # # + * . . " #
(
#
+ #
+ =6 %
*
#
$
+
* + *
*
*
+
( *
$
**
*
.
*
# (
( - (
(
A3
*
#
) :, ##$ >)$ )$ 3664;
4)
#7+ *
#7
#
*
+ #
+
*
9
#7
#
7
( * *
( #
*
*
+
-
+ + *
#
-7
0
#
(
( #%
* #
$
+ * (
3666
*
.
0 + * ( #
%
#
* .
0
(
0
*
)
( +
)
*
>E
*
F)
$
**
#
+
*
*
(
#
#
%
* *
#
)
#
#
# *
# A
()36)866
G3
()=3)366
()43=)666
# *
*
+ #
9
#7, #
-
0
% # *
)
+
#
(
# -
. ( # (
* *
.
#
%
+ *
# *
(
#(
+ * #
* . + -. + + *
" # 7 #
# )
(
# 3666$
+
# (
7
#
( #
.
( # (
* *
.
A26
( #
#
#
% ,
* $
$
#
+ )
*
366
( #
#
. +
)
%# + ( #
# + *
* #
+
*
#
# 7 #
(
( # +
*
+ )
# *$ #
#
0 *
+ *
, #$ >)$
) : 3664;$ (
. +
*
** *
*
# "
. 866
( #
# )
**
(
$
" " (
$ ( # + *
" (
# * (
0 #
* # +
.
(
*
+
+ &*
% ' : "> # +$ 1)< )$ 3664;)
,#
#
" 7
( *
()B8)666
G 4B
() 453)666
*
+
*
6
9
3
()86)666
()A3)666
()?2)666
()4B6)666
*-
! #$ %&&6
**
( * *
+
*
+
**
*
+
#
# + ( #
* (
(
. # * )
*
+ ( *
( *
+
* )
*
*
( *
( * *
*
# +
#
(
#
(
$+ *"
# * (
( #
&"
" " 7
(
*' # (
#
+
+
%
( *
#
(( # (
* * %
)&
#
#
# +
( *
9( #
" #
* * (
)
#
# +
( *
. (
#
(
$'
* (
#
# (
* *
)
** +
( # (
+ # (
%
"
( *
+ *
( #
#
$
(
#
#
(
#
(
( #
( #
+ %
(
( ( *
-( *
#
(
(
*
+ # ) :, ##$ >)$
)$ 3664;
#
( #
( #
* (
+ $
*
# + *
# 7)
#
+
:3664;$ #
( #
#
*
*
* (
#
#
# *
. #
*# *
#
# . "
+ * #
*
$ #
( # #
*- *
#(
*
#
#
+ #
#
( ( - ( + * * #
+ $
+
" # 7
(
" #
#
+
)&,
*
)
( #
# $& *
+ )
!
%
(
" +
+
.# .
( #
#
*
+
##
.
( *
7
.
#
#+
$( #
#
*
7
+ #
# , #
*
"
#
#
+
# ) , ##$ >)$
( *
#
)$ :3664;
#
*
#%
# )
( #
*
(
+ * +
*
7
( *
# ** *% .
(
)
+ -. +
+
*
*
+
(
#
#
#" ( )
#
* *)
(
# *+ *
# $
*
*
#
$
#
( #
(
( * #
" +
#
#
*
%
*
(
(
#
*
#
*
*
#
7 *
"
$
#
+ *
( #
%
(
*
. + -. +
)
*
(
*
*
$
#
*
%
( # + *
#%
(
#
# D
+
#
(#
7
)
7
(
#
(
, # $
( #
.
3666 (
#
# " * #*
8 + # # ( )
% *
"
.
% *
( % *
+
(
(
#
( #
46 + # # (
#
# )
+ * #
#* 8
+ # # (
# (#
# 33? C) : "> # +$ 1) # +$ 1)