PRACTICAL APPLICATION: HEALTH AND SOCIAL SECURITy
1 4 9
x I . H E A LT H A N D S O C I A L S E C U R I T y
Danida: Tool Kit: Best Practices for Including Indigenous Peoples in Sector Programme Support,
2004.
Nepal: Creation of social security and afirmative action programmes
There is broad political agreement that the existing inequality between indigenous peoples
and dominant communities in Nepal needs to be addressed. Indigenous peoples in Nepal in general
have lower wealth, educational achievement, health and political inluence than the national average.
However, there is also signiicant diversity among the indigenous groups in Nepal. Some groups, such
as the Thakali and the Newar, are actually above the national average in most statistics, while others,
such as the Chepang or the Raute are severely marginalized. To deal with the large diversity and
target support to those groups that need it most, the indigenous peoples’ umbrella organization, Nepal
Federation of Indigenous Nationalities NEFFIN, independently started dividing indigenous peoples
into ive categories, ranging from advantaged to endangered. Government and donors have since
adopted this categorization also. The Ministry of Local Development, for example, started providing
cash transfers to individuals from the highly marginalized and endangered indigenous groups in
2008.
Some indigenous organizations are calling for generalized ethnic-based afirmative action to beneit
all indigenous people. This is complicated somewhat by the very substantial socio-economic differences
among the groups. While the ive categories are useful in differentiating the indigenous peoples, the
system is based on neither objective criteria nor recurrent data collection. Therefore, some voices
are now calling for a more dynamic system, in which afirmative action would be based on a regularly
reviewed set of socio-economic criteria. Thus, disadvantaged indigenous groups would qualify
based on their level of disadvantage, rather than on the basis of their status as indigenous people.
However, these discussions are ongoing in the constitution-making process, and no comprehensive
policy has yet been devised. Programme to Promote ILO Convention No. 169,
project reports Nepal, 2008-9; Bennett, Lynn and Parajuli, Dilip 2007. Nepal
Inclusion Index: Methodology, First Round Findings and Implications
for Action. Draft paper.
United States: Suicide prevention programs Suicide accounts for nearly one in ive deaths among
Native American and Alaskan Native youths 15- 19 year olds; a considerably higher proportion of
deaths than for any other ethnic groups within the United States. In fact, differences in suicide rates
between Native American and Alaskan Native youths and other ethnic youths have been noted for over
three decades.
Suicide prevention programmes that are culturally appropriate and incorporate culturally speciic
knowledge and traditions have been shown to be the most successful and well received by
Native American and Alaskan Native indigenous communities. Such prevention programmes are
largely successful because they incorporate positive messages regarding cultural heritage that increase
the self-esteem and sense of mastery among Native American and Alaskan Native youths, and focus on
protective factors in a culturally appropriate context. They also teach culturally relevant coping methods
such as traditional ways of seeking social support. http:indigenousissuestoday.blogspot.
com200802suicide-native-american-and-alaskan. html.
Brazil: Enawene Nawe The Enawene Nawe are a small Amazonian
indigenous people who live in the forests of Mato Grosso, Brazil. They were irst contacted in 1974,
when they numbered only 97 individuals. Today their population is around 500.
The Enawene Nawe have refused to get closer to the towns and hospitals because of the health
problems and suffering they have experienced when they came in contact with the outsiders. They are
also aware that they should not rely on outsiders for healthcare. Therefore, in addition to their herbalists,
shamans and mastersingers, community members are receiving training in Western healthcare
and medicines. The new specialists are called “Baraitalixi” or “little herbalists”. The training is
conducted in the longhouses in their language and in the presence of everyone. The Baraitalixi,
1 5 0
I N D I G E N O U S T R I B A L P E O P L E S ’ R I G H T S I N P R A C T I C E – A G U I D E T O I L O C O N V E N T I O N N O . 1 6 9
supported by professional health staff via radio contact, are advising and treating up to 80 cases a
month.
A special ward has also been set up for the indigenous people at the local hospital with hooks
for the hammocks of the Enawene Nawe, and space is provided for relatives to stay. The hospital staff is
also given basic training about the Enawene Nawe to ease contact.
Case prepared by Choncuirinmayo Luithui. ‘Healthcare and the Enawene Nawe’ in: How
Imposed Development Destroy the Health of Tribal peoples; Survival International Publication, 2007.
Australia There are signiicant disparities in health status
between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and other Australians, encompassing
their whole life cycles. There is a 17-year gap in life expectancy between the indigenous peoples and
other Australians, higher mortality rates, earlier onset of diseases and more incidences of stress-related
problems affecting social and mental wellbeing.
In July 2003, the Australian Health Ministers agreed to establish a National Strategic Framework
for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health NSFATSIH
whose key goal is: “To ensure that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples enjoy
a healthy life equal to that of the general population that is enriched by a strong living culture, dignity and
justice.” Building on this endorsement, in December 2007,
the Council of Australian Governments COAG committed to work with indigenous communities
to close the gap on indigenous disadvantage, recognizing that special measures are needed
to improve indigenous peoples’ access to health services and that the active involvement of these
peoples is crucial in the design, delivery, and control of these services.
COAG declared its commitment to:
close the life expectancy gap within a •
generation by 2030 halve the gap in mortality rates for indigenous
• children under ive by 2018
halve the gap in literacy and numeracy •
outcomes by 2018 In addition COAG has also agreed to:
provide access to early childhood education •
for all four-year-olds living in remote indigenous communities by 2013
halve the gap in Year 12 or equivalent •
attainment rates by 2020 halve the gap in employment outcomes by
• 2018
Further, the Australian Government established the National Indigenous Health Equality Council in July
2008 to advise on the development and monitoring of health-related goals and targets.
In New South Wales, a special policy has been developed to address the high level of need
related to mental health and wellbeing in Aboriginal communities and the relatively low levels of utilisation
of specialist mental health services. The Aboriginal Mental Health and Well Being Policy 2006-2010 sets
out strategies and actions to:
Enhance key working partnerships such •
as those between the Area mental health services and Aboriginal Community Controlled
Health Services ACCHSs; Improve mental health leadership to
• ensure appropriate service responsiveness
for Aboriginal people, their families and carers across emergency and acute, early
intervention and prevention, and rehabilitation and recovery services;
Develop speciic mental health programs for
• Aboriginal people of all ages who have or are
at risk of mental illness.; Increase expertise and knowledge through a
• range of data and evaluation activities;
Strengthen the Aboriginal mental health •
workforce, both in increased positions in Area Health Services and ACCHSs and in training
and skill development.
Council of Australian Governments’ Meeting, Melbourne 20 December, 2007: http:www.coag.
gov.aucoag_meeting_outcomes2007-12-20; Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health
Performance Framework, 2008 Report; http:www. health.gov.au;
http:www.health.gov.auinternetministers publishing.nsfContentmr-yr08-nr-nr104.htm;
New South Wale Aboriginal Mental Health and Well Being Policy 2006-2010: http:www.health.nsw.gov.
1 5 1
x I . H E A LT H A N D S O C I A L S E C U R I T y
aupoliciespd2007pdfPD2007_059.pdf. Case prepared by: Chonchuirinmayo Luithui
India Indigenous peoples in India known as Scheduled
Tribes fall way behind the rest of the national population in terms of key health indicators see
table in section 11.1. For example, the rate of child mortality among Scheduled Tribes is 58 higher
than for the rest of the Indian population. Health care is a major problem in the remote and isolated
areas where the majority of indigenous peoples live, and lack of food security, sanitation and safe
drinking water, poor nutrition and high poverty levels aggravate the situation.
Most indigenous communities in India continue to be dependent on forest and natural resources for
their livelihood and subsistence. However, through processes of modernization and development
and the accompanying destruction of indigenous habitats, indigenous systems of medicine, skills and
natural resources used in traditional remedies are fast disappearing.
There are no speciic policies to target health care of indigenous peoples in India yet, but the health
situation of Scheduled Tribes has found mention in the 11
th
Five Year Plan 2007 -2012 and a comprehensive strategy has been laid out in the
Draft National Tribal Policy, 2006. The approach of the 11
th
Five Year Plan is to “attempt a paradigm shift with respect to the overall
empowerment of the tribal people”. The Plan provides for increased efforts to make available
affordable and accountable primary health care facilities to Scheduled Tribes and to bridge the
yawning gap in rural healthcare services. Periodic reviews are to be conducted on the delivery system
and function of the health care institutions under three broad headings to optimise service in the tribal
areas: i health infrastructure; ii manpower; and iii facilities, like medicine and equipment.
The Draft National Tribal Policy 2006 proposes a detailed, targeted strategy, which aims to address
the speciic problems faced by indigenous peoples in relation to health and medical care. This includes
enhancing access to modern healthcare by developing new systems and institutions; a synthesis
of Indian systems of medicine like Ayurveda and Siddha with tribal systems and modern medicine;
decentralizing control of medical staff to village and district level; area-speciic methods for provision of
clean drinking water, which take into account the different kinds of terrain in tribal areas.
The Policy is still a draft but an encouraging feature also relected in the Eleventh Plan is the recognition
of the need for strategies, which combine indigenous medicine with mainstream allopathic systems.
8
Moving away from a purely service-delivery approach has the potential to make healthcare in
interior tribal areas much more accessible, while also providing scope for indigenous peoples to contribute
their extensive traditional knowledge. Social Justice, Eleventh Five Year Plan 2007-2012,
Planning Commission, Government of India; http: tribal.nic.ininalContent.pdf.
8 It is also signiicant to note that the National Health Policy, 2002 recognises the need for special measures and separate schemes, tailor-
made to the health needs of scheduled tribes, among other vulnerable groups, and emphasises the need to strengthen alternative systems of
medicine
xII. TRADITIONAL OCCUPATIONS,
LABOUR RIGHTS AND vOCATIONAL TRAINING
1 5 3
x I I . T R A D I T I O N A L O C C U PAT I O N S , L A B O U R R I G H T S A N D V O C AT I O N A L T R A I N I N G
The ILO’s concern for indigenous peoples started as early as 1920, primarily as a concern for their
conditions as exploited workers see section 14.1. This concern led, among other things, to the
adoption of the ILO’s Forced Labour Convention No. 29 in 1930. Continued research during the
1950s showed that indigenous peoples had a need for special protection in the many cases where they
were victims of severe labour exploitation, including discrimination, and forced and child labour. In
recognition of the need to address the situation of indigenous peoples in a holistic and comprehensive
way, ILO Convention No. 107 was adopted in 1957. The Convention has a special section on conditions
of employment and was adopted with a view to “improve the living and working conditions of these
populations by simultaneous action in respect of all the factors which have hitherto prevented them
from sharing fully in the progress of the national community”
preamble, ILO Convention No. 107. Due to the continued and crucial relevance of
labour rights for indigenous peoples, Convention No. 169 and the UN Declaration on the Rights of
Indigenous Peoples also include special provisions on employment and labour rights.