Analysis of article “The Wrong Experience”

CHAPTER IV THE ANALYSIS OF TRANSITIVITY PROCESS IN WORLDVIEW’S

ARTICLE OF NEWSWEEK

4.1 ANALYSIS THE DATA

4.1.1 Analysis of article “The Wrong Experience”

In article “The Wrong Experience”, it is discovered that the process of Material gained 64 clauses, the process of Mental gained 8 clauses, the process of Relational gained 26 clauses, the process of Behavioral gained 0 clause and the process of existential gained 3 clauses. It can be seen in this following table : NO PROCESS TYPES TOTAL 1. Material 62 2. Mental 8 3. Relational 25 4. Verbal 4 5. Behavioral __ 6. Existential 3 From the findings above, we can conclude this article has the Material process as the most dominant process, and then followed by Relational process, Mental process, Verbal process, Existential process and the last one is Behavioral process. For more detail explanation, we can see the analysis of transitivity process in the article of “The Wrong Experience” below : Universitas Sumatera Utara The Wrong Experience 1. The Democratic partys two remaining candidates have become so cordial toward one another The Democratic partys two remaining candidates have become so cordial toward one another actor material goal circumstance 2. that you could easily believe that you could easily believe senser mental 3. there are few substantive differences between them There are few substantive differences between them existential existent circumstance 4. At last Thursdays debate, Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton heartily agreed on most issues At last Thursdays debate Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton heartily agreed on most issues circumstance actor material goal 5. and added and added material 6. that they were having a wonderful time chatting with one another that they were having a wonderful time chatting with one another actor material goal circumstance 7. The Republican race, by contrast, is bubbling over with tensions and personal animosities The Republican race by contrast is bubbling over with tensions and personal animosities actor circumstance material goal 8. Watch any encounter between John McCain and Mitt Romney Watch any encounter between John McCain and Mitt Romney mental phenomenon circumstance 9. and you can almost see the smoke And you can almost see the smoke senser mental phenomenon 10. steaming out of each ones ears steaming out of each one’s ears material goal Universitas Sumatera Utara 11. Consider Cuba policy Consider Cuba plicy material goal 12 Almost anyone who is being honest almost anyone who is being honest carrier relational attribute 13. Anyone will acknowledgement anyone will acknowledge actor material 14. that Americas approach toward Cuba is brain dead That Americas approach toward Cuba is brain dead carrier relational attribute 15. No one even remembers No one even remembers senser mental 16. why weve imposed a total embargo on the country why we have imposed a total embargo on the country actor material goal circumstance 17. A policy that was put into place at the height of the cold war A policy that was put into place at the height of the cold war actor material circumstance 18. when fears of Soviet missiles and communist penetration were at their peak when fears of Soviet missiles and communist penetration were at their park carrier relational attribute 19. fears of Soviet missiles and communist penetration has been maintained even though fears of Soviet missiles and communist penetration have been maintained even though actor material circumstance 20. The threat prompted it The threat prompted it actor material goal 21. The threat has collapsed The threat has collapsed actor material Universitas Sumatera Utara 22. What exactly are we afraid this moth-eaten island What exactly are we afraid This moth-eaten island circumstance relational carrier attribute circumstance 23. We will do to America today We will do to America today actor material goal 24. Our policy has the additional burden of having failed, by any measure Our policy has the additional burden of having failed by any measure carrier relational attribute circumstance 25. Weve been trying to force regime change in Cuba for 45 years We have been trying to force regime change in Cuba for 45 years actor material material goal circumstance 26. Fidel Castro is now the longest-lived head of government in the world Fidel Castro is now the longest-lived head of government in the world. token relational value 27. Every tightening of the Cuban embargo has resulted in further repression and isolation Every tightening of the Cuban embargo has resulted in further repression and isolation actor material goal 28. And yet the only changes George W. Bush has made to our Cuba policy And yet the only changes George W. Bush has made to our Cuba policy circumstance actor material goal 29. have been to impose more restrictions on travel and trade, a cruel and futile have been to impose more restrictions on travel and trade, a cruel and futile material Goal circumstance 30. doubling down on a bad bet doubling down on a bad bet material circumstance 31. Obama has advocated easing the Bush Obama has advocated easing the Bush actor material Goal 32. imposed ban on Cuban-Americans imposed ban on Cuban-Americans material goal circumstance Universitas Sumatera Utara 33. visiting the island visiting the island material goal 34. and sending money to their relatives and sending money To their relatives material goal circumstance 35. He makes a broader case for a new Cuba policy He makes a broader case for a new Cuba policy actor material goal circumstance 36. He is arguing He is arguing actor material 37. that capitalism, trade and travel will help break the regimes stranglehold on the country That capitalism, trade and travel Will help break The regime’s stranglehold on the country actor material goal circumstance 38. and help open things up And helps open things up. material goal 39. Clinton immediately disagreed Clinton immediately disagreed actor circumstance material 40. firmly supporting the current policy firmly supporting the current policy circumstance material goal 41. This places her in the strange position of arguing This places her in the strange position of arguing actor material goal circumstance 42. in effect, that her husbands Cuba policy was not hard-line enough In effect her husbands Cuba policy was not hard-line enough carrier relational attribute 43. But this is really not the best way But this is really not the best way carrier relational attribute 44. to understand Clintons position to understand Clinton’s position material goal Universitas Sumatera Utara 45. In all probability, she actually agrees with Obamas stand In all probability she actually agrees with Obamas stand circumstance actor material goal 46. She is just calculating she is just calculating actor material 47. that it would anger Cuban-Americans in Florida and New Jersey that it would anger Cuban-Americans in Florida and New Jersey actor material goal circumstance 48. This is the problem with Hillary Clinton This is the problem with Hillary Clinton carrier relational attribute 49. She is highly intelligent She is highly intelligent carrier relational attribute 50. She has real experience She has real experience carrier relational attribute 51. She is an attractive candidate She is an attractive candidate carrier relational attribute 52. but she is terrified to act on her beliefs but she is terrified carrier relational attribute 53. to act on her beliefs to act on her beliefs material goal 54. In fact, she seems so conditioned In fact she seems so conditioned senser mental phenomenon 55. by what she sees as political constraints By what she sees as political constraints senser mental phenomenon 56. that one can barely tell that one can barely tell sayer verbal Universitas Sumatera Utara 57. where her beliefs begin where her beliefs begin actor material 58. and where those constraints end and where those constraints end circumstance actor material 59. Partly, this is a generational difference Partly this is a generational difference carrier relational attribute 60. Bill and Hillary Clinton grew up in an era of Republican dominance Bill and Hillary Clinton grew up in an era of Republican dominance actor material circumstance 61. For much of the last 30 years, the Republican Party has been the party of ideas For much of the last 30 years the Republican Party has been the party of ideas circumstance existent existential circumstance 62. A point made repeatedly by Daniel Patrick Moynihan A point made repeatedly by Daniel Patrick Moynihan goal material circumstance actor 63. and Ronald Reagan was seen by much of the country and Ronald Reagan was seen by much of the country phenomenon mental senser 64. to have rescued America from malaise and retreat to have rescued America from malaise and retreat material goal circumstance 65. The Clintons careers have been shaped by the belief The Clintons careers have been shaped by the belief goal material actor 66. that for a Democrat to succeed that for a democratic to succeed actor material 67. He or she had to work within this conservative ideological framework He or she had to work within this conservative ideological framework actor material goal Universitas Sumatera Utara 68. Otherwise one would be pilloried for being weak on national security, partial to taxes and big government and out of touch with Middle Americas social values otherwise one would be pilloried for being weak on national security, partial to taxes and big government and out of touch with Middle America’s social values actor material goal circumstance 69. For 30 years this has been the right bet For 30 years this has been the right bet circumstance existential existent 70. it is it is carrier relational 71. why Bill Clinton was the only successful national Democratic politician in that period. why Bill Clinton was the only successful national Democratic politician In that period token relational value circumstance 72. But is it still the right wager? But is it still the right wager ? relational carrier attribute 73. Obama has grown up in a different landscape-with vastly different geopolitics, economics and culture. Obama has grown up in a different landscape with vastly different geopolitics, economics, and culture actor material goal circumstance 74. Bill Clinton and George W. Bush have been the defining political figures of the recent past Bill Clinton and George W. Bush has been the defining political figures of the recent past actor material goal 75. Conservatism has lost its monopoly role Conservatism has lost its monopoly role actor material goal 76. As a result, the new generation is not defensive about its beliefs As the result The new generation is not defensive About its belief carrier relational attribute circumstance Universitas Sumatera Utara 77. nor does nor does material 78. it feel trapped into the old categories like hawks versus doves and markets versus taxes. it Feel trapped Into the old categories like hawks versus doves and markets versus versus taxes senser mental phenomenon circumstance 79. This is not naivete This is not naivete carrier relational attribute 80. Obamas position on Cuba is not all hope Obamas position on Cuba is not all hope carrier relational attribute 81. Most of the older generation of Cuban-Americans are hard-line Republicans anyway Most of the older generation of Cuban-Americans are hard-line Republicans anyway token relational value circumstance 82. so its probably pointless courting them. so it is probably pointless courting them actor material goal 83. And the younger ones-under 45 or so-are far less wedded to the punitive approach and symbolic battles of the past and The younger ones- under 45 or so are far less wedded to the punitive approach and to symbolic battles of the past actor material goal 84. So Obama is taking a calculated risk So Obama Is taking A calculated risk actor material goal 85. that the time is right that the time is right carrier relational attribute 86. Cuba policy is a microcosm for this difference in attitudes Cuba policy is a microcosm for this difference in attitudes token relational value circumstance 87. Obama has spoken in favor of a proposal Obama has spoken in favor of a proposal sayer verbal target Universitas Sumatera Utara 88. made by Henry Kissinger, George Shultz, William Perry and Sam Nunn made by Henry Kissinger, George Shultz and William Perry material actor 89. in order to get the world more serious about nuclear nonproliferation In order to get The world More serious about nuclear nonproliferation material goal circumstance 90. The United States should begin to fulfill its end of the treaty The United States should begin to fulfill its end of the treaty actor material goal 91. and reduce its own nuclear arsenal and reduce its own nuclear arsenal material goal 92. Again, for all I know Again for all I know circumstance actor material 93. Hillary Clinton agrees with this approach Hillary Clinton agrees with this approach actor material goal 94. But she wont say so but she won’t say so sayer verbal phenomenon 95. Her long years of experience-in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s-warn her against such audacity Her long years of experience-in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s warn her against such audacity sayer verbal recipient target 96. But the world has changed so much but the world has changed so much Actor material goal 97. The cold war is a distant memory The cold war is a distant memory token relational value 98. Capitalism has spread across the world Capitalism has spread across the world Actor material goal 99. New threats come not from states but small bands of people New threats come not from states but small bands of people actor material goal Universitas Sumatera Utara 100. , unilateralism is discredited Unilateralism is discredited goal material 101. that perhaps it is time for America that perhaps it is Time for America circumstance carrier Relational attribute 102. to change as well To change As well material circumstance Universitas Sumatera Utara

4.1.2 Analysis of article “Stuck in the Iraq Loop”