Helping Being enthusiastic Being enthusiastic in making

4. Doing their work

according to the instruction.  Actively engaged on their work.  Making good use of the hours.  Doing other necessary activities related to the task, such as fetching equipment.  Being distracted while doing their work.  Wasting time.  Almost all students do their work according to the instruction.  Almost or a half of the whole students do their work according to the instruction.  Only several students do their work according to the instruction. □ High □ Medium □ Low □ High □ Medium □ Low

5. Helping

motivate their friends.  Willing to learn together with their friends.  Helping their friends to learn the materials.  Saying something that supports their friends.  Talking away to their friends out of the context of the lessons.  There are many students who motivate their friends.  There are some students who motivate their friends  There are only few students who motivate their friends. □ High □ Medium □ Low □ High □ Medium □ Low

6. Being enthusiastic

with Chinese whispers and group grid technique.  Eager to participate in playing Chinese whispers and applying group grid technique.  Feeling of energetic interest in playing Chinese whispers and applying group grid technique.  Loosing energetic interest in playing Chinese whispers and applying group grid technique.  Almost all students enjoy doing Chinese whispers and group grid technique.  Almost or a half of the whole students enjoy doing Chinese whispers and group grid technique.  Only several students enjoy doing Chinese whispers and group grid technique. □ High □ Medium □ Low □ High □ Medium □ Low Additional comments XXMMYYYY: Additional comments XXMMYYYY: Students’ Response during the Learning Process by Using Chinese Whispers and Group Grid Technique No. Number of Items Indicators Criteria Categories XXMMYYYY XXMMYYYY

1. Being enthusiastic in making

a group for doing Chinese whispers game and group grid technique.  Having and showing an interest in making a group.  Eager to work with other people in groups.  Getting to know each other really well.  Respecting their group members.  Having no interest in making a group.  Not interested in getting to know each other.  All students have been in group of four less than three minutes.  Almost all students have been in a group of four less than three minutes.  Almost or a half of students have been in a group of four less than three minutes. □ High □ Medium □ Low □ High □ Medium □ Low

2. Being serious in memorizing