C. Theoretical Framework
Textbooks are a common element in English teaching. Textbooks are regarded as the most vital means for conveying knowledge, for measuring what
students do and do not learn in class. Besides, textbooks also help teachers to put instructions in class by supplying various exciting activities, appropriate reading
texts, and meaningful examples, exercises, and also questions. Considering the importance of textbooks previously mentioned, the
researcher assumes that a lot of teachers need to select textbooks to be applied in class. This is because the teachers need to find materials, exercises, activities and
or ideas to teach the students. Moreover, the fact that each day most teachers have several classes in a row makes it difficult for them to have enough time to prepare
their own materials. Other assumption of teachers‟ using textbooks is class is that the teachers need to give the same topic, the same materials, the same exercise,
and even the same activities to the students in the same grade so that the teachers could measure the students‟ success in learning particular topics.
However, teachers might not have full freedom to select textbooks since there is a fact that the government has provided textbooks to support the current
2013 Curriculum to be distributed to schools. Yet, the prescribed textbooks have not been distributed thoroughly to all schools in Indonesia since the production
process have not finished yet. This might lead the teachers to dilemma whether they need to wait for the prescribed textbooks or to select at least one of textbooks
published in markets considering the needs to find out one to teach in class. If the teachers prefer to select and use textbooks published in markets, the problem
which might then rise is the limitation such as budget, time and resources, which
could affect the teachers in the process of proper textbooks selection. Therefore, it is theoretically important to conduct a study on how teachers actually carry out a
textbook selection. Selecting an appropriate textbook is considered as an important and
challenging process as it has a big influence on students‟ engagement, motivation to learn, and language performance. Brown 2004: 25 states that textbooks
selection is a process of matching the theory of learning with the needs in a textbook right before teachers use the books. The criteria used in the process of
selecting textbooks itself have been mentioned by Masuhara 1998: 257 and Byrd 2001. They reveal that a good textbook should suit to the needs of students,
teachers and the administrators. This study will interpret teachers‟ lived experience in textbook selection.
The researcher aims to elaborate and interpret how a teacher gives meanings to the process of textbook selection. To answer the question of the study, the researcher
would conduct a qualitative study. To interpret how the SMA English teacher assigns meanings to the textbook selection, the researcher mainly used
Masuhara‟s textbook evaluation steps and Masuhara‟s list of needs in selecting textbook. To improve the trustworthiness, the researcher interviewed the
participants in two periods, before and after analysis. The following is the construct of theoretical framework of the study.
Construct 1 Category
Construct 2 Indicator
Lived experience is
the reflection of meaningful
experience covering
understanding, Understanding Textbooks
selection is a process of
selecting certain
textbooks which is
- Definition of textbooks
selection -
Criteria of a good textbook
- Meaning of textbooks
selection for teachers -
Reasons why teachers