Research Procedure RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

were conducted to get the data which used to make sure about the result of observation. By applying these triangulations techniques, the researcher expected the data is consistent, because the data were collected more than one time and data source. d. Analysis Negative Case Analysis negative case is finding different data from the data has been found. If the data there is no different from the data that has been found, therefore the data is reliable data. In this research, the researcher did not found the different data from the data has been found. e. Using References Using references is there are supporters to prove the data that has been found. Such as: photos, authentic document, record tools and camera. The researcher used authentic document, photos and camera as the references in this research. 2.Transferability External Validity Transferability external validity determines validity of degree that the result of research can be applied to population where sanple taken. In order to the the others people can understand the result of qualitative research, the researcher must make report clearm systematic, detail and reliable. If the reader get illustration clearly, so, the result of the research is transferability external validity. 3. Dependability Realibility Dependability realibility is conducted by audit to the whole process of research. 4. Confirmability Objectivity Confirmability objectivity is quite same with dependability realibility, so the verivication can be conducted similarly. 13 .

H. Data Analysis

Data analysis is the process of organizing the data in order to get the pattern of other explanation from, whereas data interpretation is the process of giving meaning to the result of data analysis. 14 To analyze the data, the researcher observed all of the action during the class so that the researcher can explain how one aspect influences another aspect. In this research, the researcher analyzed the data qualitatively by following steps: 1. Data Reduction Data reduction means making summary, choosing the important things, so the data gave describing clearly and the researcher easily to collect the data. The researcher used data reduction as along as doing the research. 2. Data Display Data display is used to explain the data in order to be meaningful. Data description finished in the form narrative, graphic or table. Through the presentation of these data, the data organized, arranged in a pattern of relationship, so it more easily 13 Ibid, pp. 368-378 14 Ag. Bambang Setiyadi, MetodePenelitian Untuk Penelitian Bahasa Asing Yogyakarta: GrahaIlmu, 2006,p.94