Uji Efektifitas Bakteri Kitinolitik Terhadap Penyakit Layu Fusarium Pada Tanaman Bawang Merah
Lampiran 1. Bagan Penelitian
U
FKTB3
10%
FKHB2
10%
BKTB2
FKSB1
30%
FKSA3
30%
FKBA1
30%
FKTHB3
50%
FKHA3
20%
FKHB2
50%
FKSB2
40%
FKHB3
10%
FKSA2
30%
FKTA1
50%
FKHA2
40%
FKTB3
30%
FKHA2
30%
FKTB1
30%
FKBB1
20%
FKTA3
50%
FKSB2
50%
FKTB2
10%
BKTA3
FKSA1
40%
FKSB3
10%
FKSB1
20%
FKTA2
40%
FKHB1
10%
FKSA1
30%
BKBA2 FKBB1
50%
FKBA3
20%
FKTB3
40%
FKBB2
10%
FKHA1
20%
FKHB3 FKHA1
20%
10%
FKHB2
30%
FKBA1
40%
FKHB1
10%
FKBA2
10%
FKTA1
20%
FKBB3
50%
FKTA2
10%
FKSB1
10%
FKTB1
10%
FKTA2 BKHB1
20%
FKHB2
20%
FKSB3
30%
BKSA2
FKBB1
30%
FKBA3
30%
FKBA2
40%
FKHB1
40%
FKBB1
40%
FKBA1
10%
FKHA1
30%
BKB2
FKHA3
10%
FKTB1
20%
FKSA2
20%
BKSA3
FKHA2
50%
FKBB3
40%
FKSB2
20%
FKSA1
20%
FKTA1
30%
FKBB3
30%
FKBB3
20%
FKTB2
30%
FKTA3
40%
FKTA1
40%
BKSB1
FKBB2
50%
FKSB3
40%
BKHB3
FKSA2
10%
BKHA1
FKBA3
10%
BKHA2
FKSB3
20%
BKTB3
FKTB2
40%
FKBB2
40%
FKSB2
10%
FKBA1
50%
BKSB3
FKBA2
50%
FKTA3
30%
FKHA1
50%
FKBB2
30%
BKBB1
FKTB1
50%
FKSB3
50%
FKBB1
10%
FKB3
10%
FKHB3
40%
FKSA1
10%
BKHB1
FKBA1
20%
FKTB1
40%
FKTA2
50%
FKTB3
20%
BKTA1
FKTA3
20%
FKBA2
30%
FKSA3
10%
S
FKBB2
20%
30
Universitas Sumatera Utara
FKSB1
50%
FKHA3
40%
BKBA3
BKBB3
FKSA3
40%
FKHA1
40%
BKSB2
FKSA1
50%
BKTA2
FKTA3
10%
FKHB1 FKHA3
50%
30%
FKTA3
50%
FKSA2
40%
BKHA3
FKTA1
10%
FKSB1
40%
FKHA3
50%
BKTB1
FKHB2
40%
BKSB2
30%
FKHA2
10%
FKBA2
20%
FKSA2
50%
FKTB2
20%
FKTB2
50%
FKHB1
30%
FKBA3
40%
BKBA1
FKSA3
20%
FKTA2
30%
BKSA1
FKTB3
50%
FKHA2
20%
FKSA3
50%
Keterangan:
BKHA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol A
BKHB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol B
BKTA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging A
BKTB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging B
BKBA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara A
BKBB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara B
BKSA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir A
BKSB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir B
FKHA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol A
FKHB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol B
FKTA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging A
FKTB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging B
FKBA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara A
FKBB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara B
FKSA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir A
FKSB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir B
31
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 2.
Data Pengamatan Zona Hambat Bakteri Kitinolitik Hari ke-2
PERLAKUAN
I
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
37.50
62.50
462.50
46.25
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
2 HIS
II
37.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
75.00
37.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
475.00
47.50
III
50.00
37.50
50.00
62.50
62.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
512.50
51.25
TOTAL
RATAAN
125.00
125.00
137.50
162.50
200.00
125.00
125.00
137.50
137.50
175.00
1450.00
145.00
41.67
41.67
45.83
54.17
66.67
41.67
41.67
45.83
45.83
58.33
483.33
48.33
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2000.00
1041.67
3041.67
222.22
52.08
4.27
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
70083.33
14.93
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHA1
N
1
2
3
3
41.6667
FKHA2
3
41.6667
FKHB1
3
41.6667
FKHB2
3
41.6667
FKHA3
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKHB3
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKHB4
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKHA4
3
54.1667
54.1667
54.1667
FKHB5
3
58.3333
58.3333
FKHA5
3
Sig.
66.6667
.078
.069
.057
32
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
I
37.50
2 HIS
II
37.50
III
37.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
62.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
62.50
512.50
51.25
37.50
50.00
75.00
37.50
50.00
57.50
50.00
62.50
495.00
49.50
TOTAL
RATAAN
112.50
37.50
50.00
125.00
41.67
50.00
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
50.00
475.00
47.50
137.50
162.50
200.00
112.50
137.50
157.50
162.50
175.00
1482.50
148.25
45.83
54.17
66.67
37.50
45.83
52.50
54.17
58.33
494.17
49.42
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2404.38
766.67
3171.04
267.15
38.33
6.97
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
4
5
73260.21
12.53
a
Duncan
Subset for
alpha =
0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
3
37.5000
FKBB1
3
37.5000
FKBA2
3
41.6667
41.6667
FKBA3
3
45.8333
45.8333
45.8333
FKBB2
3
45.8333
45.8333
45.8333
FKBB3
3
52.5000
52.5000
FKBA4
3
54.1667
54.1667
FKBB4
3
54.1667
54.1667
FKBB5
3
FKBA5
3
Sig.
52.5000
58.3333
58.3333
66.6667
.153
.062
.153
.303
.115
33
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
37.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
62.50
475.00
47.50
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
2 HIS
II
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
50.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
37.50
62.50
462.50
46.25
III
37.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
450.00
45.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
112.50
125.00
125.00
150.00
175.00
112.50
125.00
137.50
150.00
175.00
1387.50
138.75
37.50
41.67
41.67
50.00
58.33
37.50
41.67
45.83
50.00
58.33
462.50
46.25
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1609.38
937.50
2546.88
178.82
46.88
3.81
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
64171.88
14.80
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTA1
N
1
2
3
37.5000
FKTB1
3
37.5000
FKTA2
3
41.6667
FKTA3
3
41.6667
FKTB2
3
41.6667
FKTB3
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKTA4
3
50.0000
50.0000
FKTB4
3
50.0000
50.0000
FKTA5
3
58.3333
FKTB5
3
58.3333
Sig.
.064
.056
34
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
2 HIS
II
50.00
50.00
50.00
50.00
75.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
50.00
75.00
537.50
53.75
I
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
75.00
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
512.50
51.25
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
50.00
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
50.00
475.00
47.50
TOTAL
RATAAN
125.00
137.50
150.00
175.00
200.00
112.50
125.00
150.00
162.50
187.50
1525.00
152.50
41.67
45.83
50.00
58.33
66.67
37.50
41.67
50.00
54.17
62.50
508.33
50.83
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2479.17
1250.00
3729.17
275.46
62.50
4.41
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
77520.83
15.55
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKSB1
N
1
2
3
4
5
3
37.5000
FKSA1
3
41.6667
41.6667
FKSB2
3
41.6667
41.6667
FKSA2
3
45.8333
45.8333
45.8333
FKSA3
3
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
FKSB3
3
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
FKSB4
3
54.1667
54.1667
54.1667
54.1667
FKSA4
3
58.3333
58.3333
58.3333
FKSB5
3
62.5000
62.5000
FKSA5
3
Sig.
66.6667
.100
.100
.096
.096
.089
35
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
Perlakua
n
galat
total
FK=
KK=
I
12.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
12.00
25.00
12.00
12.00
148.00
18.50
2 HIS
II
25.00
12.00
12.00
25.00
12.00
12.00
25.00
12.00
135.00
16.88
III
25.00
25.00
12.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
187.00
23.38
TOTAL
RATAAN
62.00
62.00
49.00
75.00
49.00
62.00
62.00
49.00
470.00
58.75
20.67
20.67
16.33
25.00
16.33
20.67
20.67
16.33
156.67
19.58
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Ftab
0,05
0.01
Ket
7.00
197.17
28.17
0.57
2.66
4.03
tn
16.00
23.00
788.67
985.83
49.29
9204.17
35.85
36
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Data Pengamatan hari ke-3
PERLAKUAN
I
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
69.20
38.50
46.20
53.80
46.20
61.50
507.70
50.77
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
3 HSI
II
46.20
53.80
38.50
53.80
69.20
38.50
53.80
46.20
53.80
53.80
507.60
50.76
III
53.80
38.50
53.80
69.20
69.20
53.80
53.80
61.50
53.80
61.50
568.90
56.89
TOTAL
RATAAN
138.50
138.50
146.10
176.80
207.60
130.80
153.80
161.50
153.80
176.80
1584.20
158.42
46.17
46.17
48.70
58.93
69.20
43.60
51.27
53.83
51.27
58.93
528.07
52.81
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1618.25
937.91
2556.16
179.81
46.90
3.83
FK=
KK=
83656.32
12.97
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHB1
N
1
2
3
3
43.6000
FKHA1
3
46.1667
46.1667
FKHA2
3
46.1667
46.1667
FKHA3
3
48.7000
48.7000
FKHB2
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKHB4
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKHB3
3
53.8333
53.8333
FKHA4
3
58.9333
58.9333
FKHB5
3
58.9333
58.9333
FKHA5
3
Sig.
69.2000
.123
.059
.096
37
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
46.20
38.50
53.80
61.50
61.50
38.50
53.80
53.80
69.20
69.20
546.00
54.60
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
3 HSI
II
38.50
38.50
46.20
53.80
69.20
38.50
38.50
46.20
69.20
69.20
507.80
50.78
III
38.50
53.80
53.80
61.50
61.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
53.80
53.80
530.50
53.05
TOTAL
RATAAN
123.20
130.80
153.80
176.80
192.20
123.20
146.10
153.80
192.20
192.20
1584.30
158.43
41.07
43.60
51.27
58.93
64.07
41.07
48.70
51.27
64.07
64.07
528.10
52.81
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2399.77
863.45
3263.23
266.64
43.17
6.18
FK=
KK=
83666.88
12.44
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
3
41.0667
FKBB1
3
41.0667
FKBA2
3
43.6000
FKBB2
3
48.7000
48.7000
FKBA3
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKBB3
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKBA4
3
FKBA5
3
64.0667
FKBB4
3
64.0667
FKBB5
3
64.0667
Sig.
58.9333
.106
.094
58.9333
.392
38
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
3 HSI
II
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
53.80
38.50
53.80
53.80
46.20
69.20
507.60
50.76
I
38.50
38.50
46.20
53.80
69.20
46.20
38.50
53.80
69.20
69.20
523.10
52.31
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
db
JK
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
78101.42
12.87
III
38.50
53.80
46.20
61.50
61.50
38.50
38.50
46.20
53.80
61.50
500.00
50.00
Kt
2252.57 250.29
861.92 43.10
3114.49
TOTAL
RATAAN
115.50
138.50
146.20
169.10
184.50
123.20
130.80
153.80
169.20
199.90
1530.70
153.07
38.50
46.17
48.73
56.37
61.50
41.07
43.60
51.27
56.40
66.63
510.23
51.02
Ftab
0,05
2.39
Fhit
5.81
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTA1
N
1
2
3
4
5
3
38.5000
FKTB1
3
41.0667
41.0667
FKTB2
3
43.6000
43.6000
FKTA2
3
46.1667
46.1667
46.1667
FKTA3
3
48.7333
48.7333
48.7333
FKTB3
3
51.2667
51.2667
51.2667
FKTA4
3
56.3667
56.3667
56.3667
FKTB4
3
56.4000
56.4000
56.4000
FKTA5
3
61.5000
61.5000
FKTB5
3
Sig.
66.6333
.100
.101
.100
.094
.093
39
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
38.50
53.80
53.80
61.50
61.50
38.50
38.50
53.80
53.80
61.50
515.20
51.52
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
3 HSI
II
53.80
46.20
53.80
53.80
69.20
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
69.20
538.30
53.83
III
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
53.80
38.50
46.20
53.80
61.50
53.80
499.90
49.99
TOTAL
RATAAN
130.80
146.20
161.40
169.10
184.50
115.50
130.90
161.40
169.10
184.50
1553.40
155.34
43.60
48.73
53.80
56.37
61.50
38.50
43.63
53.80
56.37
61.50
517.80
51.78
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1674.34
550.31
2224.65
186.04
27.52
6.76
FK=
KK=
80435.05
10.13
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKSB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
38.5000
FKSA1
3
43.6000
43.6000
FKSB2
3
43.6333
43.6333
FKSA2
3
FKSA3
3
53.8000
53.8000
FKSB3
3
53.8000
53.8000
FKSA4
3
56.3667
56.3667
FKSB4
3
56.3667
56.3667
FKSA5
3
FKSB5
3
Sig.
48.7333
48.7333
61.5000
61.5000
.270
.270
.124
.126
40
Universitas Sumatera Utara
I
30
38
3 HSI
II
38
38
III
38
30
30
38
38
38
38
38
288.00
36.00
38
38
30
38
38
30
288.00
36.00
30
30
30
30
38
38
264.00
33.00
PERLAKUAN
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
TOTAL
RATAAN
106
106
35.33
35.33
98
106
98
106
114
106
840.00
105.00
32.67
35.33
32.67
35.33
38.00
35.33
280.00
35.00
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Ftab
0,05
0.01
Ket
0.47
2.66
4.03
tn
Perlakua
n
galat
total
7.00
61.33
8.76
16.00
23.00
298.67
360.00
18.67
FK=
KK=
29400.00
12.34
41
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Data Pengamatan Hari ke-4
PERLAKUAN
I
42.10
47.40
57.90
57.90
73.70
47.40
52.60
57.90
52.60
63.20
552.70
55.27
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
db
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
4 HSI
II
52.60
63.20
52.60
63.20
68.40
42.10
57.90
52.60
57.90
63.20
573.70
57.37
JK
III
57.90
47.40
63.20
68.40
68.40
52.60
57.90
63.20
57.90
63.20
600.10
60.01
Kt
RATAAN
152.60
158.00
173.70
189.50
210.50
142.10
168.40
173.70
168.40
189.60
1726.50
172.65
50.87
52.67
57.90
63.17
70.17
47.37
56.13
57.90
56.13
63.20
575.50
57.55
Ftab
0,05
2.39
Fhit
1197.37 133.04
574.55 28.73
1771.92
TOTAL
4.63
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
99360.08
9.31
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
47.3667
FKHA1
3
50.8667
50.8667
FKHA2
3
52.6667
52.6667
FKHB2
3
56.1333
56.1333
56.1333
FKHB4
3
56.1333
56.1333
56.1333
FKHA3
3
57.9000
57.9000
FKHB3
3
57.9000
57.9000
FKHA4
3
63.1667
63.1667
FKHB5
3
63.2000
63.2000
FKHA5
3
70.1667
42
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Sig.
.085
PERLAKUAN
4 HSI
II
42.10
47.40
47.40
57.90
68.40
42.10
42.10
47.40
57.90
73.70
526.40
52.64
I
47.40
42.10
57.90
63.20
63.20
42.10
57.90
57.90
73.70
73.70
579.10
57.91
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
.169
III
42.10
57.90
57.90
57.90
63.20
47.40
52.60
57.90
57.90
57.90
552.70
55.27
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2000.93
812.71
2813.64
222.33
40.64
5.47
FK=
KK=
.167
.145
TOTAL
RATAAN
131.60
147.40
163.20
179.00
194.80
131.60
152.60
163.20
189.50
205.30
1658.20
165.82
43.87
49.13
54.40
59.67
64.93
43.87
50.87
54.40
63.17
68.43
552.73
55.27
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
91654.24
11.53
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
43.8667
FKBB1
3
43.8667
FKBA2
3
49.1333
3
4
49.1333
FKBB2
3
50.8667
50.8667
FKBA3
3
54.4000
54.4000
54.4000
FKBB3
3
54.4000
54.4000
54.4000
FKBA4
3
59.6667
59.6667
59.6667
FKBB4
3
63.1667
63.1667
FKBA5
3
64.9333
64.9333
FKBB5
3
Sig.
68.4333
.087
.082
.082
.137
43
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
4 HSI
II
47.40
47.40
57.90
57.90
57.90
42.10
57.90
57.90
57.90
73.70
558.00
55.80
I
42.10
42.10
47.40
57.90
73.70
47.40
42.10
57.90
73.70
73.70
558.00
55.80
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
47.40
57.90
47.40
63.20
63.20
42.10
47.40
47.40
57.90
63.20
537.10
53.71
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2147.30
831.09
2978.39
238.59
41.55
5.74
FK=
KK=
TOTAL
RATAAN
136.90
147.40
152.70
179.00
194.80
131.60
147.40
163.20
189.50
210.60
1653.10
165.31
45.63
49.13
50.90
59.67
64.93
43.87
49.13
54.40
63.17
70.20
551.03
55.10
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
91091.32
11.70
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
43.8667
FKTA1
3
45.6333
FKTA2
3
49.1333
49.1333
FKTB2
3
49.1333
49.1333
FKTA3
3
50.9000
50.9000
FKTB3
3
54.4000
54.4000
54.4000
FKTA4
3
59.6667
59.6667
59.6667
FKTB4
63.1667
3
63.1667
FKTA5
3
64.9333
FKTB5
3
Sig.
64.9333
70.2000
.090
.086
.080
.080
44
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
42.10
57.90
57.90
68.40
68.40
47.40
42.10
63.20
57.90
68.40
573.70
57.37
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
4 HSI
II
57.90
52.60
57.90
57.90
68.40
42.10
52.60
57.90
63.20
68.40
578.90
57.89
III
42.10
47.40
57.90
57.90
57.90
42.10
47.40
57.90
63.20
57.90
531.70
53.17
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1624.71
553.36
2178.07
180.52
27.67
6.52
FK=
KK=
TOTAL
RATAAN
142.10
157.90
173.70
184.20
194.70
131.60
142.10
179.00
184.30
194.70
1684.30
168.43
47.37
52.63
57.90
61.40
64.90
43.87
47.37
59.67
61.43
64.90
561.43
56.14
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
94562.22
9.37
a
Duncan
PERLAKUAN
Subset for
alpha =
0.05
N
1
2
3
FKSB1
3
43.8667
FKSA1
3
47.3667
FKSB2
3
47.3667
FKSA2
3
52.6333
FKSA3
3
57.9000
57.9000
FKSB3
3
59.6667
59.6667
FKSA4
3
61.4000
61.4000
FKSB4
3
61.4333
61.4333
FKSA5
3
64.9000
FKSB5
3
64.9000
Sig.
.074
52.6333
.079
.163
45
Universitas Sumatera Utara
4 HSI
PERLAKUAN
I
47
47
31
42
52
52
42
47
360.00
45.00
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
II
47
52
42
42
42
52
42
36
355.00
44.38
III
52
47
36
31
42
47
47
42
344.00
43.00
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
7.00
16.00
23.00
545.29
335.33
880.63
77.90
20.96
3.72
FK=
KK=
TOTAL
RATAAN
146
146
109
115
136
151
131
125
1059.00
132.38
48.67
48.67
36.33
38.33
45.33
50.33
43.67
41.67
353.00
44.13
Ftab
0,05
2.66
0.01
Ket
4.03
*
46728.38
10.38
46
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
5 HSI
II
56.00
64.00
56.00
64.00
68.00
48.00
60.00
56.00
64.00
64.00
600.00
60.00
I
48.00
56.00
60.00
60.00
72.00
48.00
56.00
64.00
60.00
64.00
588.00
58.80
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
60.00
56.00
64.00
68.00
68.00
56.00
60.00
64.00
60.00
64.00
620.00
62.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
164.00
176.00
180.00
192.00
208.00
152.00
176.00
184.00
184.00
192.00
1808.00
180.80
54.67
58.67
60.00
64.00
69.33
50.67
58.67
61.33
61.33
64.00
602.67
60.27
Sk
Db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
723.20
298.67
1021.87
80.36
14.93
5.38
FK=
KK=
108962.13
6.41
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
50.6667
FKHA1
3
54.6667
FKHA2
3
58.6667
58.6667
FKHB2
3
58.6667
58.6667
FKHA3
3
60.0000
60.0000
FKHB3
3
61.3333
61.3333
FKHB4
3
61.3333
61.3333
FKHA4
3
64.0000
64.0000
FKHB5
3
64.0000
64.0000
FKHA5
3
Sig.
54.6667
69.3333
.219
.074
.153
.124
47
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
5 HSI
II
44.00
48.00
52.00
56.00
68.00
44.00
44.00
52.00
60.00
76.00
544.00
54.40
I
48.00
48.00
60.00
64.00
64.00
44.00
60.00
60.00
76.00
76.00
600.00
60.00
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
44.00
60.00
60.00
60.00
64.00
48.00
56.00
60.00
64.00
64.00
580.00
58.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
136.00
156.00
172.00
180.00
196.00
136.00
160.00
172.00
200.00
216.00
1724.00
172.40
45.33
52.00
57.33
60.00
65.33
45.33
53.33
57.33
66.67
72.00
574.67
57.47
Sk
Db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2116.80
618.67
2735.47
235.20
30.93
7.60
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
99072.53
9.68
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
4
3
45.3333
FKBB1
3
45.3333
FKBA2
3
52.0000
52.0000
FKBB2
3
53.3333
53.3333
FKBA3
3
57.3333
57.3333
FKBB3
3
57.3333
57.3333
FKBA4
3
60.0000
60.0000
FKBA5
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKBB4
3
66.6667
66.6667
FKBB5
3
Sig.
72.0000
.121
.128
.078
.180
48
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
44.00
44.00
52.00
60.00
76.00
48.00
44.00
60.00
76.00
76.00
580.00
58.00
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
Db
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
5 HSI
II
48.00
48.00
60.00
60.00
64.00
44.00
60.00
60.00
60.00
76.00
580.00
58.00
III
44.00
60.00
48.00
64.00
64.00
44.00
48.00
52.00
60.00
64.00
548.00
54.80
JK
Kt
2400.53 266.73
789.33 39.47
3189.87
TOTAL
RATAAN
136.00
152.00
160.00
184.00
204.00
136.00
152.00
172.00
196.00
216.00
1708.00
170.80
45.33
50.67
53.33
61.33
68.00
45.33
50.67
57.33
65.33
72.00
569.33
56.93
Fhit
6.76
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
97242.13
11.03
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTA1
N
1
2
3
4
3
45.3333
FKTB1
3
45.3333
FKTA2
3
50.6667
50.6667
FKTB2
3
50.6667
50.6667
FKTA3
3
53.3333
53.3333
FKTB3
3
57.3333
57.3333
FKTA4
3
61.3333
61.3333
61.3333
FKTB4
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKTA5
3
68.0000
68.0000
FKTB5
3
Sig.
72.0000
.176
.075
.069
.069
49
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
5 HSI
II
60.00
56.00
60.00
60.00
68.00
44.00
56.00
60.00
68.00
72.00
604.00
60.40
I
44.00
60.00
60.00
72.00
72.00
56.00
52.00
64.00
60.00
72.00
612.00
61.20
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
Db
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
107520.53
8.23
III
48.00
52.00
60.00
64.00
60.00
48.00
52.00
64.00
68.00
64.00
580.00
58.00
JK
Kt
1370.13 152.24
501.33 25.07
1871.47
TOTAL
RATAAN
152.00
168.00
180.00
196.00
200.00
148.00
160.00
188.00
196.00
208.00
1796.00
179.60
50.67
56.00
60.00
65.33
66.67
49.33
53.33
62.67
65.33
78.67
608.00
60.80
Fhit
6.07
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKSB1
N
1
2
3
3
49.3333
FKSA1
3
50.6667
FKSB2
3
53.3333
53.3333
FKSA2
3
56.0000
56.0000
4
56.0000
FKSA3
3
60.0000
60.0000
FKSB3
3
62.6667
62.6667
FKSA4
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKSB4
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKSA5
3
66.6667
FKSB5
3
69.3333
Sig.
60.0000
.150
.138
.052
.055
50
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
I
52.00
52.00
40.00
44.00
56.00
60.00
44.00
52.00
400.00
50.00
Sk
Db
Perlakuan
galat
total
7.00
16.00
23.00
FK=
KK=
5 HSI
II
52.00
60.00
44.00
44.00
52.00
60.00
44.00
40.00
396.00
49.50
III
60.00
56.00
44.00
40.00
56.00
52.00
52.00
44.00
404.00
50.50
JK
Kt
821.33 117.33
266.67 16.67
1088.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
164.00
168.00
128.00
128.00
164.00
172.00
140.00
136.00
1200.00
150.00
54.67
56.00
42.67
42.67
54.67
57.33
46.67
45.33
400.00
50.00
Fhit
7.04
Ftab
0,05
2.66
0.01
Ket
4.03
**
60000.00
8.16
51
Universitas Sumatera Utara
U
FKTB3
10%
FKHB2
10%
BKTB2
FKSB1
30%
FKSA3
30%
FKBA1
30%
FKTHB3
50%
FKHA3
20%
FKHB2
50%
FKSB2
40%
FKHB3
10%
FKSA2
30%
FKTA1
50%
FKHA2
40%
FKTB3
30%
FKHA2
30%
FKTB1
30%
FKBB1
20%
FKTA3
50%
FKSB2
50%
FKTB2
10%
BKTA3
FKSA1
40%
FKSB3
10%
FKSB1
20%
FKTA2
40%
FKHB1
10%
FKSA1
30%
BKBA2 FKBB1
50%
FKBA3
20%
FKTB3
40%
FKBB2
10%
FKHA1
20%
FKHB3 FKHA1
20%
10%
FKHB2
30%
FKBA1
40%
FKHB1
10%
FKBA2
10%
FKTA1
20%
FKBB3
50%
FKTA2
10%
FKSB1
10%
FKTB1
10%
FKTA2 BKHB1
20%
FKHB2
20%
FKSB3
30%
BKSA2
FKBB1
30%
FKBA3
30%
FKBA2
40%
FKHB1
40%
FKBB1
40%
FKBA1
10%
FKHA1
30%
BKB2
FKHA3
10%
FKTB1
20%
FKSA2
20%
BKSA3
FKHA2
50%
FKBB3
40%
FKSB2
20%
FKSA1
20%
FKTA1
30%
FKBB3
30%
FKBB3
20%
FKTB2
30%
FKTA3
40%
FKTA1
40%
BKSB1
FKBB2
50%
FKSB3
40%
BKHB3
FKSA2
10%
BKHA1
FKBA3
10%
BKHA2
FKSB3
20%
BKTB3
FKTB2
40%
FKBB2
40%
FKSB2
10%
FKBA1
50%
BKSB3
FKBA2
50%
FKTA3
30%
FKHA1
50%
FKBB2
30%
BKBB1
FKTB1
50%
FKSB3
50%
FKBB1
10%
FKB3
10%
FKHB3
40%
FKSA1
10%
BKHB1
FKBA1
20%
FKTB1
40%
FKTA2
50%
FKTB3
20%
BKTA1
FKTA3
20%
FKBA2
30%
FKSA3
10%
S
FKBB2
20%
30
Universitas Sumatera Utara
FKSB1
50%
FKHA3
40%
BKBA3
BKBB3
FKSA3
40%
FKHA1
40%
BKSB2
FKSA1
50%
BKTA2
FKTA3
10%
FKHB1 FKHA3
50%
30%
FKTA3
50%
FKSA2
40%
BKHA3
FKTA1
10%
FKSB1
40%
FKHA3
50%
BKTB1
FKHB2
40%
BKSB2
30%
FKHA2
10%
FKBA2
20%
FKSA2
50%
FKTB2
20%
FKTB2
50%
FKHB1
30%
FKBA3
40%
BKBA1
FKSA3
20%
FKTA2
30%
BKSA1
FKTB3
50%
FKHA2
20%
FKSA3
50%
Keterangan:
BKHA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol A
BKHB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol B
BKTA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging A
BKTB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging B
BKBA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara A
BKBB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara B
BKSA : Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir A
BKSB : Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir B
FKHA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol A
FKHB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Haranggaol B
FKTA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging A
FKTB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Tongging B
FKBA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara A
FKBB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Bakara B
FKSA : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir A
FKSB : Filtrat Bakteri Kitinolitik Samosir B
31
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 2.
Data Pengamatan Zona Hambat Bakteri Kitinolitik Hari ke-2
PERLAKUAN
I
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
37.50
62.50
462.50
46.25
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
2 HIS
II
37.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
75.00
37.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
475.00
47.50
III
50.00
37.50
50.00
62.50
62.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
512.50
51.25
TOTAL
RATAAN
125.00
125.00
137.50
162.50
200.00
125.00
125.00
137.50
137.50
175.00
1450.00
145.00
41.67
41.67
45.83
54.17
66.67
41.67
41.67
45.83
45.83
58.33
483.33
48.33
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2000.00
1041.67
3041.67
222.22
52.08
4.27
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
70083.33
14.93
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHA1
N
1
2
3
3
41.6667
FKHA2
3
41.6667
FKHB1
3
41.6667
FKHB2
3
41.6667
FKHA3
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKHB3
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKHB4
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKHA4
3
54.1667
54.1667
54.1667
FKHB5
3
58.3333
58.3333
FKHA5
3
Sig.
66.6667
.078
.069
.057
32
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
I
37.50
2 HIS
II
37.50
III
37.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
62.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
62.50
512.50
51.25
37.50
50.00
75.00
37.50
50.00
57.50
50.00
62.50
495.00
49.50
TOTAL
RATAAN
112.50
37.50
50.00
125.00
41.67
50.00
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
50.00
475.00
47.50
137.50
162.50
200.00
112.50
137.50
157.50
162.50
175.00
1482.50
148.25
45.83
54.17
66.67
37.50
45.83
52.50
54.17
58.33
494.17
49.42
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2404.38
766.67
3171.04
267.15
38.33
6.97
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
4
5
73260.21
12.53
a
Duncan
Subset for
alpha =
0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
3
37.5000
FKBB1
3
37.5000
FKBA2
3
41.6667
41.6667
FKBA3
3
45.8333
45.8333
45.8333
FKBB2
3
45.8333
45.8333
45.8333
FKBB3
3
52.5000
52.5000
FKBA4
3
54.1667
54.1667
FKBB4
3
54.1667
54.1667
FKBB5
3
FKBA5
3
Sig.
52.5000
58.3333
58.3333
66.6667
.153
.062
.153
.303
.115
33
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
37.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
62.50
475.00
47.50
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
2 HIS
II
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
50.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
37.50
62.50
462.50
46.25
III
37.50
50.00
37.50
50.00
62.50
37.50
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
450.00
45.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
112.50
125.00
125.00
150.00
175.00
112.50
125.00
137.50
150.00
175.00
1387.50
138.75
37.50
41.67
41.67
50.00
58.33
37.50
41.67
45.83
50.00
58.33
462.50
46.25
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1609.38
937.50
2546.88
178.82
46.88
3.81
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
64171.88
14.80
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTA1
N
1
2
3
37.5000
FKTB1
3
37.5000
FKTA2
3
41.6667
FKTA3
3
41.6667
FKTB2
3
41.6667
FKTB3
3
45.8333
45.8333
FKTA4
3
50.0000
50.0000
FKTB4
3
50.0000
50.0000
FKTA5
3
58.3333
FKTB5
3
58.3333
Sig.
.064
.056
34
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
2 HIS
II
50.00
50.00
50.00
50.00
75.00
37.50
50.00
50.00
50.00
75.00
537.50
53.75
I
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
75.00
37.50
37.50
50.00
50.00
62.50
512.50
51.25
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
50.00
37.50
37.50
50.00
62.50
50.00
475.00
47.50
TOTAL
RATAAN
125.00
137.50
150.00
175.00
200.00
112.50
125.00
150.00
162.50
187.50
1525.00
152.50
41.67
45.83
50.00
58.33
66.67
37.50
41.67
50.00
54.17
62.50
508.33
50.83
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2479.17
1250.00
3729.17
275.46
62.50
4.41
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
77520.83
15.55
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKSB1
N
1
2
3
4
5
3
37.5000
FKSA1
3
41.6667
41.6667
FKSB2
3
41.6667
41.6667
FKSA2
3
45.8333
45.8333
45.8333
FKSA3
3
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
FKSB3
3
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
50.0000
FKSB4
3
54.1667
54.1667
54.1667
54.1667
FKSA4
3
58.3333
58.3333
58.3333
FKSB5
3
62.5000
62.5000
FKSA5
3
Sig.
66.6667
.100
.100
.096
.096
.089
35
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
Perlakua
n
galat
total
FK=
KK=
I
12.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
12.00
25.00
12.00
12.00
148.00
18.50
2 HIS
II
25.00
12.00
12.00
25.00
12.00
12.00
25.00
12.00
135.00
16.88
III
25.00
25.00
12.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
187.00
23.38
TOTAL
RATAAN
62.00
62.00
49.00
75.00
49.00
62.00
62.00
49.00
470.00
58.75
20.67
20.67
16.33
25.00
16.33
20.67
20.67
16.33
156.67
19.58
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Ftab
0,05
0.01
Ket
7.00
197.17
28.17
0.57
2.66
4.03
tn
16.00
23.00
788.67
985.83
49.29
9204.17
35.85
36
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Data Pengamatan hari ke-3
PERLAKUAN
I
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
69.20
38.50
46.20
53.80
46.20
61.50
507.70
50.77
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
3 HSI
II
46.20
53.80
38.50
53.80
69.20
38.50
53.80
46.20
53.80
53.80
507.60
50.76
III
53.80
38.50
53.80
69.20
69.20
53.80
53.80
61.50
53.80
61.50
568.90
56.89
TOTAL
RATAAN
138.50
138.50
146.10
176.80
207.60
130.80
153.80
161.50
153.80
176.80
1584.20
158.42
46.17
46.17
48.70
58.93
69.20
43.60
51.27
53.83
51.27
58.93
528.07
52.81
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1618.25
937.91
2556.16
179.81
46.90
3.83
FK=
KK=
83656.32
12.97
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHB1
N
1
2
3
3
43.6000
FKHA1
3
46.1667
46.1667
FKHA2
3
46.1667
46.1667
FKHA3
3
48.7000
48.7000
FKHB2
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKHB4
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKHB3
3
53.8333
53.8333
FKHA4
3
58.9333
58.9333
FKHB5
3
58.9333
58.9333
FKHA5
3
Sig.
69.2000
.123
.059
.096
37
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
46.20
38.50
53.80
61.50
61.50
38.50
53.80
53.80
69.20
69.20
546.00
54.60
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
3 HSI
II
38.50
38.50
46.20
53.80
69.20
38.50
38.50
46.20
69.20
69.20
507.80
50.78
III
38.50
53.80
53.80
61.50
61.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
53.80
53.80
530.50
53.05
TOTAL
RATAAN
123.20
130.80
153.80
176.80
192.20
123.20
146.10
153.80
192.20
192.20
1584.30
158.43
41.07
43.60
51.27
58.93
64.07
41.07
48.70
51.27
64.07
64.07
528.10
52.81
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2399.77
863.45
3263.23
266.64
43.17
6.18
FK=
KK=
83666.88
12.44
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
3
41.0667
FKBB1
3
41.0667
FKBA2
3
43.6000
FKBB2
3
48.7000
48.7000
FKBA3
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKBB3
3
51.2667
51.2667
FKBA4
3
FKBA5
3
64.0667
FKBB4
3
64.0667
FKBB5
3
64.0667
Sig.
58.9333
.106
.094
58.9333
.392
38
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
3 HSI
II
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
53.80
38.50
53.80
53.80
46.20
69.20
507.60
50.76
I
38.50
38.50
46.20
53.80
69.20
46.20
38.50
53.80
69.20
69.20
523.10
52.31
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
db
JK
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
78101.42
12.87
III
38.50
53.80
46.20
61.50
61.50
38.50
38.50
46.20
53.80
61.50
500.00
50.00
Kt
2252.57 250.29
861.92 43.10
3114.49
TOTAL
RATAAN
115.50
138.50
146.20
169.10
184.50
123.20
130.80
153.80
169.20
199.90
1530.70
153.07
38.50
46.17
48.73
56.37
61.50
41.07
43.60
51.27
56.40
66.63
510.23
51.02
Ftab
0,05
2.39
Fhit
5.81
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTA1
N
1
2
3
4
5
3
38.5000
FKTB1
3
41.0667
41.0667
FKTB2
3
43.6000
43.6000
FKTA2
3
46.1667
46.1667
46.1667
FKTA3
3
48.7333
48.7333
48.7333
FKTB3
3
51.2667
51.2667
51.2667
FKTA4
3
56.3667
56.3667
56.3667
FKTB4
3
56.4000
56.4000
56.4000
FKTA5
3
61.5000
61.5000
FKTB5
3
Sig.
66.6333
.100
.101
.100
.094
.093
39
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
38.50
53.80
53.80
61.50
61.50
38.50
38.50
53.80
53.80
61.50
515.20
51.52
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
3 HSI
II
53.80
46.20
53.80
53.80
69.20
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
69.20
538.30
53.83
III
38.50
46.20
53.80
53.80
53.80
38.50
46.20
53.80
61.50
53.80
499.90
49.99
TOTAL
RATAAN
130.80
146.20
161.40
169.10
184.50
115.50
130.90
161.40
169.10
184.50
1553.40
155.34
43.60
48.73
53.80
56.37
61.50
38.50
43.63
53.80
56.37
61.50
517.80
51.78
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1674.34
550.31
2224.65
186.04
27.52
6.76
FK=
KK=
80435.05
10.13
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKSB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
38.5000
FKSA1
3
43.6000
43.6000
FKSB2
3
43.6333
43.6333
FKSA2
3
FKSA3
3
53.8000
53.8000
FKSB3
3
53.8000
53.8000
FKSA4
3
56.3667
56.3667
FKSB4
3
56.3667
56.3667
FKSA5
3
FKSB5
3
Sig.
48.7333
48.7333
61.5000
61.5000
.270
.270
.124
.126
40
Universitas Sumatera Utara
I
30
38
3 HSI
II
38
38
III
38
30
30
38
38
38
38
38
288.00
36.00
38
38
30
38
38
30
288.00
36.00
30
30
30
30
38
38
264.00
33.00
PERLAKUAN
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
TOTAL
RATAAN
106
106
35.33
35.33
98
106
98
106
114
106
840.00
105.00
32.67
35.33
32.67
35.33
38.00
35.33
280.00
35.00
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Ftab
0,05
0.01
Ket
0.47
2.66
4.03
tn
Perlakua
n
galat
total
7.00
61.33
8.76
16.00
23.00
298.67
360.00
18.67
FK=
KK=
29400.00
12.34
41
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Data Pengamatan Hari ke-4
PERLAKUAN
I
42.10
47.40
57.90
57.90
73.70
47.40
52.60
57.90
52.60
63.20
552.70
55.27
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
db
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
4 HSI
II
52.60
63.20
52.60
63.20
68.40
42.10
57.90
52.60
57.90
63.20
573.70
57.37
JK
III
57.90
47.40
63.20
68.40
68.40
52.60
57.90
63.20
57.90
63.20
600.10
60.01
Kt
RATAAN
152.60
158.00
173.70
189.50
210.50
142.10
168.40
173.70
168.40
189.60
1726.50
172.65
50.87
52.67
57.90
63.17
70.17
47.37
56.13
57.90
56.13
63.20
575.50
57.55
Ftab
0,05
2.39
Fhit
1197.37 133.04
574.55 28.73
1771.92
TOTAL
4.63
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
99360.08
9.31
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
47.3667
FKHA1
3
50.8667
50.8667
FKHA2
3
52.6667
52.6667
FKHB2
3
56.1333
56.1333
56.1333
FKHB4
3
56.1333
56.1333
56.1333
FKHA3
3
57.9000
57.9000
FKHB3
3
57.9000
57.9000
FKHA4
3
63.1667
63.1667
FKHB5
3
63.2000
63.2000
FKHA5
3
70.1667
42
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Sig.
.085
PERLAKUAN
4 HSI
II
42.10
47.40
47.40
57.90
68.40
42.10
42.10
47.40
57.90
73.70
526.40
52.64
I
47.40
42.10
57.90
63.20
63.20
42.10
57.90
57.90
73.70
73.70
579.10
57.91
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
.169
III
42.10
57.90
57.90
57.90
63.20
47.40
52.60
57.90
57.90
57.90
552.70
55.27
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2000.93
812.71
2813.64
222.33
40.64
5.47
FK=
KK=
.167
.145
TOTAL
RATAAN
131.60
147.40
163.20
179.00
194.80
131.60
152.60
163.20
189.50
205.30
1658.20
165.82
43.87
49.13
54.40
59.67
64.93
43.87
50.87
54.40
63.17
68.43
552.73
55.27
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
91654.24
11.53
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
43.8667
FKBB1
3
43.8667
FKBA2
3
49.1333
3
4
49.1333
FKBB2
3
50.8667
50.8667
FKBA3
3
54.4000
54.4000
54.4000
FKBB3
3
54.4000
54.4000
54.4000
FKBA4
3
59.6667
59.6667
59.6667
FKBB4
3
63.1667
63.1667
FKBA5
3
64.9333
64.9333
FKBB5
3
Sig.
68.4333
.087
.082
.082
.137
43
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
4 HSI
II
47.40
47.40
57.90
57.90
57.90
42.10
57.90
57.90
57.90
73.70
558.00
55.80
I
42.10
42.10
47.40
57.90
73.70
47.40
42.10
57.90
73.70
73.70
558.00
55.80
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
47.40
57.90
47.40
63.20
63.20
42.10
47.40
47.40
57.90
63.20
537.10
53.71
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2147.30
831.09
2978.39
238.59
41.55
5.74
FK=
KK=
TOTAL
RATAAN
136.90
147.40
152.70
179.00
194.80
131.60
147.40
163.20
189.50
210.60
1653.10
165.31
45.63
49.13
50.90
59.67
64.93
43.87
49.13
54.40
63.17
70.20
551.03
55.10
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
91091.32
11.70
a
Duncan
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
43.8667
FKTA1
3
45.6333
FKTA2
3
49.1333
49.1333
FKTB2
3
49.1333
49.1333
FKTA3
3
50.9000
50.9000
FKTB3
3
54.4000
54.4000
54.4000
FKTA4
3
59.6667
59.6667
59.6667
FKTB4
63.1667
3
63.1667
FKTA5
3
64.9333
FKTB5
3
Sig.
64.9333
70.2000
.090
.086
.080
.080
44
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
42.10
57.90
57.90
68.40
68.40
47.40
42.10
63.20
57.90
68.40
573.70
57.37
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
4 HSI
II
57.90
52.60
57.90
57.90
68.40
42.10
52.60
57.90
63.20
68.40
578.90
57.89
III
42.10
47.40
57.90
57.90
57.90
42.10
47.40
57.90
63.20
57.90
531.70
53.17
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
1624.71
553.36
2178.07
180.52
27.67
6.52
FK=
KK=
TOTAL
RATAAN
142.10
157.90
173.70
184.20
194.70
131.60
142.10
179.00
184.30
194.70
1684.30
168.43
47.37
52.63
57.90
61.40
64.90
43.87
47.37
59.67
61.43
64.90
561.43
56.14
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
94562.22
9.37
a
Duncan
PERLAKUAN
Subset for
alpha =
0.05
N
1
2
3
FKSB1
3
43.8667
FKSA1
3
47.3667
FKSB2
3
47.3667
FKSA2
3
52.6333
FKSA3
3
57.9000
57.9000
FKSB3
3
59.6667
59.6667
FKSA4
3
61.4000
61.4000
FKSB4
3
61.4333
61.4333
FKSA5
3
64.9000
FKSB5
3
64.9000
Sig.
.074
52.6333
.079
.163
45
Universitas Sumatera Utara
4 HSI
PERLAKUAN
I
47
47
31
42
52
52
42
47
360.00
45.00
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
II
47
52
42
42
42
52
42
36
355.00
44.38
III
52
47
36
31
42
47
47
42
344.00
43.00
Sk
db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
7.00
16.00
23.00
545.29
335.33
880.63
77.90
20.96
3.72
FK=
KK=
TOTAL
RATAAN
146
146
109
115
136
151
131
125
1059.00
132.38
48.67
48.67
36.33
38.33
45.33
50.33
43.67
41.67
353.00
44.13
Ftab
0,05
2.66
0.01
Ket
4.03
*
46728.38
10.38
46
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
5 HSI
II
56.00
64.00
56.00
64.00
68.00
48.00
60.00
56.00
64.00
64.00
600.00
60.00
I
48.00
56.00
60.00
60.00
72.00
48.00
56.00
64.00
60.00
64.00
588.00
58.80
FKHA1
FKHA2
FKHA3
FKHA4
FKHA5
FKHB1
FKHB2
FKHB3
FKHB4
FKHB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
60.00
56.00
64.00
68.00
68.00
56.00
60.00
64.00
60.00
64.00
620.00
62.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
164.00
176.00
180.00
192.00
208.00
152.00
176.00
184.00
184.00
192.00
1808.00
180.80
54.67
58.67
60.00
64.00
69.33
50.67
58.67
61.33
61.33
64.00
602.67
60.27
Sk
Db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
723.20
298.67
1021.87
80.36
14.93
5.38
FK=
KK=
108962.13
6.41
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKHB1
N
1
2
3
4
3
50.6667
FKHA1
3
54.6667
FKHA2
3
58.6667
58.6667
FKHB2
3
58.6667
58.6667
FKHA3
3
60.0000
60.0000
FKHB3
3
61.3333
61.3333
FKHB4
3
61.3333
61.3333
FKHA4
3
64.0000
64.0000
FKHB5
3
64.0000
64.0000
FKHA5
3
Sig.
54.6667
69.3333
.219
.074
.153
.124
47
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
5 HSI
II
44.00
48.00
52.00
56.00
68.00
44.00
44.00
52.00
60.00
76.00
544.00
54.40
I
48.00
48.00
60.00
64.00
64.00
44.00
60.00
60.00
76.00
76.00
600.00
60.00
FKBA1
FKBA2
FKBA3
FKBA4
FKBA5
FKBB1
FKBB2
FKBB3
FKBB4
FKBB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
III
44.00
60.00
60.00
60.00
64.00
48.00
56.00
60.00
64.00
64.00
580.00
58.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
136.00
156.00
172.00
180.00
196.00
136.00
160.00
172.00
200.00
216.00
1724.00
172.40
45.33
52.00
57.33
60.00
65.33
45.33
53.33
57.33
66.67
72.00
574.67
57.47
Sk
Db
JK
Kt
Fhit
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
2116.80
618.67
2735.47
235.20
30.93
7.60
FK=
KK=
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
99072.53
9.68
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKBA1
N
1
2
3
4
3
45.3333
FKBB1
3
45.3333
FKBA2
3
52.0000
52.0000
FKBB2
3
53.3333
53.3333
FKBA3
3
57.3333
57.3333
FKBB3
3
57.3333
57.3333
FKBA4
3
60.0000
60.0000
FKBA5
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKBB4
3
66.6667
66.6667
FKBB5
3
Sig.
72.0000
.121
.128
.078
.180
48
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
I
44.00
44.00
52.00
60.00
76.00
48.00
44.00
60.00
76.00
76.00
580.00
58.00
FKTA1
FKTA2
FKTA3
FKTA4
FKTA5
FKTB1
FKTB2
FKTB3
FKTB4
FKTB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
Db
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
5 HSI
II
48.00
48.00
60.00
60.00
64.00
44.00
60.00
60.00
60.00
76.00
580.00
58.00
III
44.00
60.00
48.00
64.00
64.00
44.00
48.00
52.00
60.00
64.00
548.00
54.80
JK
Kt
2400.53 266.73
789.33 39.47
3189.87
TOTAL
RATAAN
136.00
152.00
160.00
184.00
204.00
136.00
152.00
172.00
196.00
216.00
1708.00
170.80
45.33
50.67
53.33
61.33
68.00
45.33
50.67
57.33
65.33
72.00
569.33
56.93
Fhit
6.76
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
97242.13
11.03
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKTA1
N
1
2
3
4
3
45.3333
FKTB1
3
45.3333
FKTA2
3
50.6667
50.6667
FKTB2
3
50.6667
50.6667
FKTA3
3
53.3333
53.3333
FKTB3
3
57.3333
57.3333
FKTA4
3
61.3333
61.3333
61.3333
FKTB4
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKTA5
3
68.0000
68.0000
FKTB5
3
Sig.
72.0000
.176
.075
.069
.069
49
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
5 HSI
II
60.00
56.00
60.00
60.00
68.00
44.00
56.00
60.00
68.00
72.00
604.00
60.40
I
44.00
60.00
60.00
72.00
72.00
56.00
52.00
64.00
60.00
72.00
612.00
61.20
FKSA1
FKSA2
FKSA3
FKSA4
FKSA5
FKSB1
FKSB2
FKSB3
FKSB4
FKSB5
TOTAL
RATAAN
Sk
Db
Perlakuan
galat
total
9.00
20.00
29.00
FK=
KK=
107520.53
8.23
III
48.00
52.00
60.00
64.00
60.00
48.00
52.00
64.00
68.00
64.00
580.00
58.00
JK
Kt
1370.13 152.24
501.33 25.07
1871.47
TOTAL
RATAAN
152.00
168.00
180.00
196.00
200.00
148.00
160.00
188.00
196.00
208.00
1796.00
179.60
50.67
56.00
60.00
65.33
66.67
49.33
53.33
62.67
65.33
78.67
608.00
60.80
Fhit
6.07
Ftab
0,05
2.39
0.01
Ket
3.46
**
Subset for alpha = 0.05
PERLAKUAN
FKSB1
N
1
2
3
3
49.3333
FKSA1
3
50.6667
FKSB2
3
53.3333
53.3333
FKSA2
3
56.0000
56.0000
4
56.0000
FKSA3
3
60.0000
60.0000
FKSB3
3
62.6667
62.6667
FKSA4
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKSB4
3
65.3333
65.3333
FKSA5
3
66.6667
FKSB5
3
69.3333
Sig.
60.0000
.150
.138
.052
.055
50
Universitas Sumatera Utara
PERLAKUAN
BKHA
BKHB
BKBA
BKBB
BKTA
BKTB
BKSA
BKSB
TOTAL
RATAAN
I
52.00
52.00
40.00
44.00
56.00
60.00
44.00
52.00
400.00
50.00
Sk
Db
Perlakuan
galat
total
7.00
16.00
23.00
FK=
KK=
5 HSI
II
52.00
60.00
44.00
44.00
52.00
60.00
44.00
40.00
396.00
49.50
III
60.00
56.00
44.00
40.00
56.00
52.00
52.00
44.00
404.00
50.50
JK
Kt
821.33 117.33
266.67 16.67
1088.00
TOTAL
RATAAN
164.00
168.00
128.00
128.00
164.00
172.00
140.00
136.00
1200.00
150.00
54.67
56.00
42.67
42.67
54.67
57.33
46.67
45.33
400.00
50.00
Fhit
7.04
Ftab
0,05
2.66
0.01
Ket
4.03
**
60000.00
8.16
51
Universitas Sumatera Utara