Problematika Normatif Pengadilan Hak Asasi Manusia sebagai Upaya Hukum untuk Perlindungan Hak Asasi Manusia di Indonesia.

F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !?!-! 9!+!
F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !?!-! 9!+!
999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 !  (F(? !
999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 !  (F(? !

F
F
 
 




" 


  
! 

3!6 
     H  



 

    ?
 3&>:,2 *:7
*:7
*>6)3
6#  


 
  77 36
*>6)3
6#  


 
  
 

    !     

  ! 3&>':6 
  
   1
1   
 
 (     1      11

 
 


 !  
  (7
(7  
 #
   
"             
11


11

 
      ! 1
  

  1 "   
 (    !
  

    1    



 3 
%

*,,42**6 





  #


"

 




  #


"


 


 "1
   

   
 ! ( 1
"1
   1
  !   
 
 

3
*,,*E);57
3
*,,*E);57);:6 
  

 !
  


 !


  ) 3
6
  
 38
     *,,&2 &;46   
1"
   
"  !
1
 
 1"(    !
  


 
  

 
    
  
 


  

 " ( "1
   
    
1
! 
1
!    %

3*,,42*)6
"1
      
   

      
     

 
    #  
 
    

   


 
"1
( 
 

 

"1
 





 
1        !
  3*,,)2 )56   "
(
(7
7    

 
    
  

  


  
!

 
  
     (  
    
 !  
      
 
  


 

    
 
 
 





(
! 

3*,,&2;6
 

  
 
  



 

  
 
  





  
(

77





  
(


 




     


 



 
 


 

 



 
 


 

  
9  
   
  

 "     1  



    
0

  
 %
13*,,&2'46    

 

 %
13*,,&2'46  
  ! 

#           
 
! 

 
99( *4%
*,,,    1 
   1 7
 7 
  

 !     %
 
 

   

 




 
 
  
  
 !  1

 1

!O
 1

!O

(


! 


(


! 


    
   
 !   
 
     
   
  
 
(
7
(
7   !
 3*,,;2&
!
 3*,,;2&7
3*,,;2&7*6 

   

       !
77


 
   
   ! 
  


 


 "





 
 

 


 "

 1" 
  1  

 ! 
  
" 
  
 
    
1  3

#6   !  # 
  *   
  

   #!  
 3

   #!  
 3

 *,,*2 );57
);57);:6     

    
 
  


# 
 

 
  #  7
7 !  

    1 
 
  7
 7   



 

!   




 "   !      



 (   (       


   
!  

 
 

#


 

!

  

 
!
 
(  
1  
  
!
 
(  
1
 (   "  

 "  
 

 1" !
 
 #


     (    

   (
  

 
    
 1 

 (
 
1  
  3*,,*2 );>7
);>7)4,6   "
  
   
  
   ! 
 
 
  

    
  7
 7  
 3 

  6 

   


  
 1
! !1
7
!1
71
!
# 1  
  

# 1  
  
 

    
   
   
  
      
!
%
7
!
%
7%

# 
  
  


  1
  ! 
 
  

 
 

   1
 1


0 


 
  
 
  





 
  
 
  



. 
!

  
 %   

% 
 

  

 


    !O     
      &  4
99( )>%&>>>  ! 


 "!
 
             (

 
1 
 
1  # "  




  
    #    
     

1
7

1
7


  
"


    
   
    



 

 

 
      ! # 
    
# 
 1
       

    
 (   F 
  !

   ( 
 

   ( 
  !

 

 
!1
 
( 



   ( 
  1
 # 
      



"



   
 



"



   
 

3


1&>>52',7

3


1&>>52',7'&6 

 

  "  3
 6  1
 
 36 



77



 

 " 
 



 
7



7
   #
   


 
   
    



 


   
  

   
   
 #

 

   
 
  

    
 !1
  1  
!1
  1   
  



 1
7

 1
7

"
   


7


7



  C




7
7

 
    
    

 "   #7
#7#     

     F 
 7
7

 
  
 #
 38
   
*,,&2&:&6 
!




1" 
 




 !  
  99 (  )> % &>>>      
 
   1" ! 
 
 
1
  
 
 # 

   ! 
#   
  "1

  "1


 
 !    
  (   
 1" !  (   

   
 

)>%&>>>1
A 

1
A 

   
  &499( )>%&>>>
  (

1

1 
U A 

!  


   

 
 3#
6  
 
  1 
 3

6 
 





 


 (
 (    (
 
 
 

  
 
!

(1
 1 (
 


  
  "  
    1   
 1
  ! 7
7 3 
6 
 



    ! 1



!9
%! 



!9
%! 


%! 




 ! 
    99 (  *4 % *,,,  

! 
  

  !
 5
 5
 1  

3 '11 
:  >6 
     &,' 99 (  )> % &>>>   
   

 !
  
 

 
 1
 #

 
        7
  7    !  
1
 

 
  
!
 

 
  
!  7
 7 

 
@1  
 A
A
       > 99 (  *4 % *,,, 

 "
1   
        
 

 


 
      

  
 
 "
    
1 #    

  1 


"1
7


"1
71
   

2
1
   

2


E
E



 E
 E

#

E
E




 
 # E

 
 # E



         

 
 #
"77"   3  7
"
3  7  6     
 
E
 
E




 E

 E



    
  # #    

    


      7
 7   
 
  E
 
  E




       
 

 

   
1


  
1


 

 
  


 #
  

 

 
E

 
E




 # E 

 # E 

1

1  
 


  
   


"   
1 

  
   


"   
1 

1
771
 > 


1

1
  99( *4%*,,, 



  


 

 
 
  
  
 1  
1
  
1



  
    1  
  
   

! 
1  






"  !

"  ! ( 
 
( 
 
!
1  

 8
 1

8
 1

 1  

 
 
 #

 


    !  8
 

    

  

 !#  "


  
 1   
  

  
 ! 



 




    %
 
 3*,,42 4'7
4'74;6 
 ! #
#1


 
    
  
  ! 
     


 
 
   
  1  
1
9 7
 
1

9 
9 7  

!1
 
 ! 
1


1

 
 
    


  
     
 
 






 
 

  99 ( *4%*,,, 

   

   
  
     
7




7 
  #    "  
    
!1  

!
 

8

  99( *4%*,,, 




 
    
 !     !  
1 
1   
  
 
  " 

   
   7
7  


  
 @     

A  1  

 1
 
 # 

 !

 1
 
 # 

 ! !  

!  

#

 ! 99( *4%*,,, 
   
 
 1 1 "   
!
1  

  



  


!
1  

       
  
  

 "
  1
 ! 


    #

 
       
 1
   
  
 
  
    
  

  
   1




99( *4%*,,,
 
   99( *4%*,,,
  

99( )>%&>>>
 
 
!
)>%&>>>
 
 
!
  

    !
  


 1 
 
 
  
 
 !    

 ! 

 "  &,' 3&699(
' 3&699( )>%
 ! 

 "  &,
&>>> 1  




   
99( *4%
*,,, % 
  1

  

0 
  &,'99(
% 
  1

  

0 
  &,'99( 
*4%*,,,
%*,,, 
)>%&>>> ' 5:>99( *4



 

1# 

(
!
%

#
 D  3%D6  
  
  "  


    !   99 (  *4 % *,,, 1   


"&'8
*,,&
.!1 &,'99( )>
!   

% &>>>   %
 
 
  

 1
 !

   
    !  

 1  

     

 (
 ! 1  
   !       &,' 99 (  )> % &>>>O 






        
 
 

 


(
 !     %

 
   
  
 
 !

1  



 
 
  
!

 
 
  
! 

 

    '4 99 (  *4  *,,, 
  "  
  !
"    7
  7  
!    1   
 1  
 


1
     
  
  


   

 97
979  
 396  "      
  5: 3&69" "    
2
  5: 3&69" "    
2
&

  1 #   &3  6 E
  1 #   &3  6 E
1 #   &3  6 E

*

  1   
#     1 
  )
3
6   436 E
3
6   436 E

)

  1   
# 
 
 
 ) 3
6    &*
3 6 E
 6 E
3
 6 E

'

  1   
# 
 
    
   &:
3 6  


         ! 
*4%*,,,
*,,,
1  

   99( *4%
   "    
  7
7 1  



          7
7 45, 
  
  
          1 
1
"
3*,,*2:46


 

"!
3*,,*2:46


 

"!


  7


  7  
 
   

     
 ! 

  

1
 

 

  

1

!O );99(
!O  );99( *4%*,,, " 
  
 "
     
 

  


 

#  
     
 !    

 
 "

 !
 
 "   
    

#
 !


 
! #

1
 !

1 

   
 "
  

1
 !

1 

   
 "
  
   

  7
7
  1
   
!  
  
 !    
 
 
  
 
     '  1   !    


  
    
 


  
    
 

 8

 
 " 

 
#
 
    
 ( 
 

 

 

 1
 "
" 

   
     

 
    7
7 
   


1
 


%  1    

 
   
 


    ); 99 (  *4 %
*,,, 
!


  1""1

(
        
 # 1 
   99 (  *4 % *,,, 
   
 1   

     
   
  36  9 
 

 ( )%*,,* 
  );99( *4%*,,, 
(    (  ) % *,,*  
 
     
 


 =
 3*,,'2&6"##   
 @  #A  
  
       !
 

 
 
1  =
 3*,,'2)7
=
 3*,,'2)7'6

 #  
         ! 
"    7
 7  1
 
 
 !  # 

1

   




 
 1

   


 

@
  "    
 
  /







 "


 A

 ( )%*,,*1

  @
)%*,,*1

  @
77
   

   
  
#
 
   
   A   


 
#
  1  
 


  
7

7
  

     
  

 
8 !
 
8 ! 
  

3*,,4254699( *4%*,,, 

  
        
 !  #


 
  
 


 
 
    
 
  
  
 
       
 1"   
 
   


 
 99 (  *4 % *,,, 
    



3 *,,42''62
3 *,,42''62


 7
7    # 
  



 
  
 
     
    

" 
     # 


   *: 99&>'; #





   *: 99&>'; #








E



E



97
97

 
 # 
 1
7
1
71
  !

 1
7
1
71
! 


 1
 
 





 1







 1


  1
7
 1
7
1
      1
 
        

 1 
 E

 1 
 E

#

 7
 7        
    # 
  
  
      
 !  
 1
 

 
 
 !    





  


 


  

   

  ')99(

  

   

  ')99( *4
%*,,,

 
 3
*,,,2




 ')77
>>6 



 ')
        "
     



  !   


        
 
         



 !  
  
     

 
  





  




   
( 

 
 !   
 
  



 
  
    7
7   



 #

   #




# 1
 "1
! 

 1
 "1
! 


  
  
   "    
  "   


 
    
       
 45,






 










 






 1 

  
    
 
   
   "  



 
 
 

1"!  
  
 

1"!
 
   

 
  7
 7       
  

   ( 
  1"   
 


 "1
 
 
 !   

 ! 
    

 
    " 
    (   "1


   
 
 ! 
 "1
  
   "1

  1
    !  %  7
%  7       
1
"1

"1
7
7"1

  ( 

 !  
          
 !

 
   99 (  *4 % *,,, 1
     


  

!
 

 
       ! 
 1   
 

 
    
 

   7
 7    

 !7
 !7 
 



!

 


   
    

 
0   
7
7    # 
 
   
!  


 
 


 ! 
 
 
 
  
1
  

" 




















!D%!9%!!
!D%!9%!!

*,,& 

 ! 



 
 8 2+ ! 




 
D0
7
D0
7 *,,&?


8 2-
 9  
8
  *,,& ! 

=
=
8 2 
 





 (
 ! *,,* = % *,,& 

 (
  ! 


8 2

(
!9!  
  !
   *,,; 

  


 

 ! 
 
 9
"1  
+ 2 1
+ 2 1 



1&>>5 7
 7  

8 2-
 9  
  &>>: ! 



=(
 8 2+ 
F 
 


    1 &>:5 
  
   


 
 2

  
 ?  " *,,, !2 11 
 

  8 2
 9 -



  *,,*      ! 
 
 8 2  

 
  !
  *,,) ! 

 %




 
 8 2
9

  
 
 %

*,,4 
3

6 !

 
2.
!


1 
1
" *,,* 
 8
8 ! 
 
 
 2
.
!


   @.   

  ! 
 
A +

 ?

 5&
%JH 8
R
%JH 8
R!
*,,4 
%
 1 @9  
  
  
 
! 

A
! 

A8( &:H:F *
&:H:F *