Problematika Normatif Pengadilan Hak Asasi Manusia sebagai Upaya Hukum untuk Perlindungan Hak Asasi Manusia di Indonesia.
F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !?!-! 9!+!
F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !?!-! 9!+!
999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !
999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !
F
F
"
!
3!6
H
?
3&>:,2 *:7
*:7
*>6)3
6#
7736
*>6)3
6#
!
! 3&>':6
1
1
( 1 11
!
(7
(7
#
"
11
11
! 1
1 "
( !
1
3
%
*,,42**6
#
"
#
"
"1
! ( 1
"1
1
!
3
*,,*E);57
3
*,,*E);57);:6
!
!
) 3
6
38
*,,&2 &;46
1"
"!
1
1"(!
" ( "1
1
!
1
! %
3*,,42*)6
"1
#
"1
(
"1
1 !
3*,,)2 )56 "
(
(7
7
!
(
!
(
!
3*,,&2;6
(
77
(
9
" 1
0
%
13*,,&2'46
%
13*,,&2'46
!
#
!
99( *4%
*,,, 1
17
7
! %
! 1
1
!O
1
!O
(
!
(
!
!
(
7
(
7 !
3*,,;2&
!
3*,,;2&7
3*,,;2&7*6
!
77
!
"
"
1"
1
!
"
1 3
#6 ! #
*
#!
3
#!
3
*,,*2 );57
);57);:6
#
# 7
7 !
1
7
7
!
" !
( (
!
#
!
!
(
1
!
(
1
("
"
1"!
#
(
(
1
(
1
3*,,*2 );>7
);>7)4,6 "
!
7
7
3
6
1
! !1
7
!1
71
!
#1
#1
!
%
7
!
%
7%
#
1
!
1
1
0
.
!
%
%
!O
& 4
99( )>%&>>>!
"!
(
1
1 # "
#
1
7
1
7
"
! #
#
1
( F
!
(
(
!
!1
(
(
1
#
"
"
3
1&>>52',7
3
1&>>52',7'&6
" 3
6 1
36
77
"
7
7
#
#
!1
1
!1
1
1
7
1
7
"
7
7
C
7
7
" #7
#7#
F
7
7
#
38
*,,&2&:&6
!
1"
!
99 ( )> % &>>>
1" !
1
#
!
#
"1
"1
!
(
1" ! (
)>%&>>>1
A
1
A
&499( )>%&>>>
(
1
1
U A
!
3#
6
1
3
6
(
( (
!
(1
1(
"
1
1
! 7
7 3
6
!1
!9
%!
!9
%!
%!
!
99 ( *4 % *,,,
!
!
5
5
1
3'11
: >6
&,' 99 ( )> % &>>>
!
1
#
7
7 !
1
!
! 7
7
@1
A
A
> 99 ( *4 % *,,,
"
1
"
1 #
1
"1
7
"1
71
2
1
2
E
E
E
E
#
E
E
#E
#E
#
"77" 37
"
376
E
E
E
E
# #
7
7
E
E
1
1
#
E
E
#E
#E
1
1
"
1
"
1
1
771
>
1
1
99( *4%*,,,
1
1
1
1
!
1
"!
"! (
(
!
1
8
1
8
1
1
#
! 8
!#"
1
!
%
3*,,42 4'7
4'74;6
!#
#1
!
1
1
97
1
9
97
!1
!
1
1
99 ( *4%*,,,
7
7
# "
!1
!
8
99( *4%*,,,
! !
1
1
"
7
7
@
A 1
1
#
!
1
#
! !
!
#
!99( *4%*,,,
1 1 "
!
1
!
1
"
1
!
#
1
1
99( *4%*,,,
99( *4%*,,,
99( )>%&>>>
!
)>%&>>>
!
!
1
!
!
"&,'3&699(
'3&699( )>%
!
"&,
&>>> 1
99( *4%
*,,, %
1
0
&,'99(
%
1
0
&,'99(
*4%*,,,
%*,,,
)>%&>>>'5:>99( *4
1#
(
!
%
#
D 3%D6
"
! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1
"&'8
*,,&
.!1&,'99( )>
!
% &>>> %
1
!
!
1
(
! 1
! &,' 99 ( )> % &>>>O
(
! %
!
1
!
!
'4 99 ( *4 *,,,
"
!
" 7
7
! 1
1
1
97
979
396 "
5:3&69""
2
5:3&69""
2
&
1#&36E
1#&36E
1#&36E
*
1
# 1
)
3
6436E
3
6436E
)
1
#
) 3
6 &*
36E
6E
3
6E
'
1
#
&:
36
!
*4%*,,,
*,,,
1
99( *4%
"
7
7 1
7
7 45,
1
1
"
3*,,*2:46
"!
3*,,*2:46
"!
7
7
!
1
1
!O);99(
!O );99( *4%*,,,"
"
#
!
"
!
"
#
!
! #
1
!
1
"
1
!
1
"
7
7
1
!
!
' 1 !
8
"
#
(
1
"
"
7
7
1
%1
); 99 ( *4 %
*,,,
!
1""1
(
# 1
99 ( *4 % *,,,
1
36 9
( )%*,,*
);99( *4%*,,,
( ( ) % *,,*
=
3*,,'2&6"##
@#A
!
1 =
3*,,'2)7
=
3*,,'2)7'6
#
!
" 7
7 1
! #
1
1
@
"
/
"
A
( )%*,,*1
@
)%*,,*1
@
77
#
A
#
1
7
7
8!
8!
3*,,4254699( *4%*,,,
! #
1"
99 ( *4 % *,,,
3*,,42''62
3*,,42''62
7
7 #
"
#
*: 99&>';#
*: 99&>';#
E
E
97
97
#
1
7
1
71
!
1
7
1
71
!
1
1
1
1
7
1
7
1
1
1
E
1
E
#
7
7
#
!
1
!
')99(
')99( *4
%*,,,
3
*,,,2
')77
>>6
')
"
!
!
(
!
7
7
#
#
#1
"1
!
1
"1
!
"
"
45,
1
"
1"!
1"!
7
7
(
1"
"1
!
!
"
( "1
!
"1
"1
1
! %7
%7
1
"1
"1
7
7"1
(
!
!
99 ( *4 % *,,, 1
!
!
1
7
7
!7
!7
!
0
7
7 #
!
!
1
"
!D%!9%!!
!D%!9%!!
*,,&
!
82+!
D0
7
D0
7*,,&?
82-
9
8
*,,& !
=
=
82
(
! *,,* = % *,,&
(
!
82
(
!9!
!
*,,;
!
9
"1
+21
+21
1&>>57
7
82-
9
&>>: !
=(
82+
F
1 &>:5
2
? " *,,, !2 11
82
9-
*,,* !
82
!
*,,) !
%
82
9
%
*,,4
3
6!
2.
!
1
1
" *,,*
8
8 !
2
.
!
@.
!
A +
?
5&
%JH 8
R
%JH 8
R!
*,,4
%
1 @9
!
A
!
A8( &:H:F*
&:H:F*
F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !?!-! 9!+!
999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !
999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !
F
F
"
!
3!6
H
?
3&>:,2 *:7
*:7
*>6)3
6#
7736
*>6)3
6#
!
! 3&>':6
1
1
( 1 11
!
(7
(7
#
"
11
11
! 1
1 "
( !
1
3
%
*,,42**6
#
"
#
"
"1
! ( 1
"1
1
!
3
*,,*E);57
3
*,,*E);57);:6
!
!
) 3
6
38
*,,&2 &;46
1"
"!
1
1"(!
" ( "1
1
!
1
! %
3*,,42*)6
"1
#
"1
(
"1
1 !
3*,,)2 )56 "
(
(7
7
!
(
!
(
!
3*,,&2;6
(
77
(
9
" 1
0
%
13*,,&2'46
%
13*,,&2'46
!
#
!
99( *4%
*,,, 1
17
7
! %
! 1
1
!O
1
!O
(
!
(
!
!
(
7
(
7 !
3*,,;2&
!
3*,,;2&7
3*,,;2&7*6
!
77
!
"
"
1"
1
!
"
1 3
#6 ! #
*
#!
3
#!
3
*,,*2 );57
);57);:6
#
# 7
7 !
1
7
7
!
" !
( (
!
#
!
!
(
1
!
(
1
("
"
1"!
#
(
(
1
(
1
3*,,*2 );>7
);>7)4,6 "
!
7
7
3
6
1
! !1
7
!1
71
!
#1
#1
!
%
7
!
%
7%
#
1
!
1
1
0
.
!
%
%
!O
& 4
99( )>%&>>>!
"!
(
1
1 # "
#
1
7
1
7
"
! #
#
1
( F
!
(
(
!
!1
(
(
1
#
"
"
3
1&>>52',7
3
1&>>52',7'&6
" 3
6 1
36
77
"
7
7
#
#
!1
1
!1
1
1
7
1
7
"
7
7
C
7
7
" #7
#7#
F
7
7
#
38
*,,&2&:&6
!
1"
!
99 ( )> % &>>>
1" !
1
#
!
#
"1
"1
!
(
1" ! (
)>%&>>>1
A
1
A
&499( )>%&>>>
(
1
1
U A
!
3#
6
1
3
6
(
( (
!
(1
1(
"
1
1
! 7
7 3
6
!1
!9
%!
!9
%!
%!
!
99 ( *4 % *,,,
!
!
5
5
1
3'11
: >6
&,' 99 ( )> % &>>>
!
1
#
7
7 !
1
!
! 7
7
@1
A
A
> 99 ( *4 % *,,,
"
1
"
1 #
1
"1
7
"1
71
2
1
2
E
E
E
E
#
E
E
#E
#E
#
"77" 37
"
376
E
E
E
E
# #
7
7
E
E
1
1
#
E
E
#E
#E
1
1
"
1
"
1
1
771
>
1
1
99( *4%*,,,
1
1
1
1
!
1
"!
"! (
(
!
1
8
1
8
1
1
#
! 8
!#"
1
!
%
3*,,42 4'7
4'74;6
!#
#1
!
1
1
97
1
9
97
!1
!
1
1
99 ( *4%*,,,
7
7
# "
!1
!
8
99( *4%*,,,
! !
1
1
"
7
7
@
A 1
1
#
!
1
#
! !
!
#
!99( *4%*,,,
1 1 "
!
1
!
1
"
1
!
#
1
1
99( *4%*,,,
99( *4%*,,,
99( )>%&>>>
!
)>%&>>>
!
!
1
!
!
"&,'3&699(
'3&699( )>%
!
"&,
&>>> 1
99( *4%
*,,, %
1
0
&,'99(
%
1
0
&,'99(
*4%*,,,
%*,,,
)>%&>>>'5:>99( *4
1#
(
!
%
#
D 3%D6
"
! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1
"&'8
*,,&
.!1&,'99( )>
!
% &>>> %
1
!
!
1
(
! 1
! &,' 99 ( )> % &>>>O
(
! %
!
1
!
!
'4 99 ( *4 *,,,
"
!
" 7
7
! 1
1
1
97
979
396 "
5:3&69""
2
5:3&69""
2
&
1#&36E
1#&36E
1#&36E
*
1
# 1
)
3
6436E
3
6436E
)
1
#
) 3
6 &*
36E
6E
3
6E
'
1
#
&:
36
!
*4%*,,,
*,,,
1
99( *4%
"
7
7 1
7
7 45,
1
1
"
3*,,*2:46
"!
3*,,*2:46
"!
7
7
!
1
1
!O);99(
!O );99( *4%*,,,"
"
#
!
"
!
"
#
!
! #
1
!
1
"
1
!
1
"
7
7
1
!
!
' 1 !
8
"
#
(
1
"
"
7
7
1
%1
); 99 ( *4 %
*,,,
!
1""1
(
# 1
99 ( *4 % *,,,
1
36 9
( )%*,,*
);99( *4%*,,,
( ( ) % *,,*
=
3*,,'2&6"##
@#A
!
1 =
3*,,'2)7
=
3*,,'2)7'6
#
!
" 7
7 1
! #
1
1
@
"
/
"
A
( )%*,,*1
@
)%*,,*1
@
77
#
A
#
1
7
7
8!
8!
3*,,4254699( *4%*,,,
! #
1"
99 ( *4 % *,,,
3*,,42''62
3*,,42''62
7
7 #
"
#
*: 99&>';#
*: 99&>';#
E
E
97
97
#
1
7
1
71
!
1
7
1
71
!
1
1
1
1
7
1
7
1
1
1
E
1
E
#
7
7
#
!
1
!
')99(
')99( *4
%*,,,
3
*,,,2
')77
>>6
')
"
!
!
(
!
7
7
#
#
#1
"1
!
1
"1
!
"
"
45,
1
"
1"!
1"!
7
7
(
1"
"1
!
!
"
( "1
!
"1
"1
1
! %7
%7
1
"1
"1
7
7"1
(
!
!
99 ( *4 % *,,, 1
!
!
1
7
7
!7
!7
!
0
7
7 #
!
!
1
"
!D%!9%!!
!D%!9%!!
*,,&
!
82+!
D0
7
D0
7*,,&?
82-
9
8
*,,& !
=
=
82
(
! *,,* = % *,,&
(
!
82
(
!9!
!
*,,;
!
9
"1
+21
+21
1&>>57
7
82-
9
&>>: !
=(
82+
F
1 &>:5
2
? " *,,, !2 11
82
9-
*,,* !
82
!
*,,) !
%
82
9
%
*,,4
3
6!
2.
!
1
1
" *,,*
8
8 !
2
.
!
@.
!
A +
?
5&
%JH 8
R
%JH 8
R!
*,,4
%
1 @9
!
A
!
A8( &:H:F*
&:H:F*