60 wanted. The lecturer used it as the evaluation media to monitor the progress and
improvement the students.
2. The Students’ Experiences in Using Reflection to Facilitate Learner
Autonomy
The researcher displayed the result of data which discusses the students‟
experiences in using reflection to facilitate learner autonomy in the Micro Teaching class E.
Table 4.6 The Students’ Experiences in Using Reflection
No. Statement
SD D
U A
SA
26 In my opinion, reflection can facilitate
me to display my autonomy in the Micro Teaching class.
- 12.5
- 50
37.5
27 Reflection can be an introspection way
for me as a student and also a teacher candidate.
- -
12.5 18.75 68.75
28 Through the use of reflection, I can see
my own progress in the Micro Teaching class.
- 18.75 6.25
50 25
29 Through the use of reflection, I
improve my reasoning skill, my creative idea, my problem solving, and
my awareness in the Micro Teaching class.
- 12.5
12.5 50
25
Total -
10.94 7.81 42.19 39.06
The data showed that the results were positive from the total percentage of the statements about the students‟ experiences in implementing reflection to
facilitate learner autonomy in the Micro Teaching class. It was shown by 39.06 of the respondents chose
“strongly agree” statement and 42.19 of the PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
61 respondents chose
“agree” statement. 7.81 of the respondents chose “uncertain” statement and 10.94 of the respondents chose “disagree” statement.
It was clear that the total percentage of the positive statements was higher than the negative statements which indicated that writing reflection could facilitate
students‟ autonomy in the Micro Teaching class E. Statement number 26 stated
the students‟ opinion of reflection which could facilitate the students to display their autonomy. From the data, 31.25 of
the respondents chose “strongly agree” statement and 37.5 of the respondents
chose “agree” statement. The statement was confirmed by the student in the
interview. Student III
: Aku tulis apa aja kesalahanku, masalahku dan penyelesaiannya sehingga aku bisa pakai itu sebagai pengingat-
ingat pas aku lupa sama bikin aku biar aku nggak melakukan kesalahan yang sama lagi. Aku harus mampu mengevaluasi diriku
sendiri untuk apa yang sudah aku lakukan dan apa yang harus aku tingkatkan dan kembangin juga.
Translation
: I wrote down my mistakes, my problems and the problem solving so I could make it as a reminder when I forgot and
also to avoid me doing the same mistakes. I could judge my own result. I had to be able to evaluate what I had done and what I
should improve and develop. Own Translation
The student wrote what they had experienced during the learning processes. According to Boud et al. 1985, reflection is a process of finding
experiences and learning new things. The students had an opportunity to write as much as possible. Boud et al. 1985 explains that reflection does not only deal
with intellectual activities, but also affects activities in which individuals engage PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
62 to explore their experiences in order to lead the new understanding and better
attitude. Reflection also can be related to the mental activity. Statement number 27 stated that the reflection could be an introspection
medium for the students as the students and also teacher candidates. 68.75 of the respondents chose
“strongly agree” and 18.75 of the respondents chose “agree” statement. The information was supported by the student in the
interview. Student II
: Aku bisa lihat laporan perjalananku dari awal semester sampai sekarang. Apa aja yang aku dapetin, apa aja
yang aku tingkatkan atau aku singkirkan. Aku dapat mengontrol diriku sendiri, mengatur waktuku dan menyiapkan dengan baik.
Refleksi bikin aku tau apa kebutuhanku. Translation
: I could see the reports from the beginning of the semester up to now. What I had got, what I should improve and
throw away. I could control myself, manage my time and be well- prepared. The reflection could facilitate me to see my needs. Own
Translation
Making reflection has several benefits for the students and also the lecturer. The lecturer could make the students‟ reflection as a tool to reflect on the
teaching methods, as an evaluation media to decide the appropriate methods for the students Burden Byrd, 1994. Benson 2011 adds that reflection is
indispensable to enhance learner autonomy. Reflection can facilitate the cognitive and behavioral processes by which individual takes control of the stream of
experiences they are subject to. In this point, the students had to understand themselves first by writing the reflection. They were able to see their weaknesses,
their strengths, their progress and their appropriate ways to handle themselves. PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
63 Statement number 28 stated that the students could see their own progress
in the Micro Teaching class through the use of reflection. 25 of the respondents chose
“strongly agree” statement and 50 of the respondents chose “agree” statement which indicated that the student could use the reflection as a medium
to see their progress, improvement and development in their learning processes in the Micro Teaching course. The result of the interview supported the progress
of the student through the use of reflection. In the interview, the student said that: Student I
: Refleksi bisa sebagai laporan dalam proess belajarku buat melihat progressku, mencatat hal-hal penting dan
memantau perbaikanku. Ya bisa buat mengevaluasi. Translation
: Reflection could be a written report in my learning process to see my progress, note the important things, and monitor
my improvements. I could evaluate myself. Own Translation
Statement number 29 stated that the students improved their reasoning skills, their creative idea, their problem solving and their awareness in the Micro
Teaching class through the use of reflection. 25 of the respondents chose “strongly agree” statement and 50 of the respondents chose “agree” statement.
It was also supported by the student‟s statement. The student said that: Student II
: Aku mencoba melihat kekurangan dan kelebihanku dan aku menulis itu dalam refleksi pertamaku. Habis itu aku
simpulkan apa tujuanku di mata kuliah ini, contohnya kayak aku ingin dapat nilai yang bagus, bisa mengajar dan menjadi guru
yang baik. Aku mendaftar kebutuhanaku apa aja buat belajar di kelas ini, jadwalku dan kira-kira apa yang aku seharusnya lakukan
buat mencapai tujuanku di refleksiku. Di refleksiku, aku juga menuliskan kesalahanku, masalahku dan rencana-rencanaku,
nasihat, saran, masukan dari teman-teman dan dosenku tentang simulasi mengajarku. Menurutku, menulis refleksi dapat
membantuku untuk memantau kemajuanku dan prosesku di mata kuliah ini. Ini juga membantuku buat mikir lagi tentang apa yang
64 udah aku alami aku dan aku lakukan dan juga untuk mencari
solusi dari masalah dan rintangan yang aku hadapi. Ketika aku membaca refleksiku lagi, ini dapat mengingatkanku untuk tidak
melakukan kesalahan yang sama lagi. Translation
: I saw weaknesses and strengths and I wrote it down in my first reflection. I tried to conclude my goals in this
course, such as getting a good score, being able to teach and be a good teacher. I listed my needs, my schedules and what I should do
to achieve my goals in my reflections. In my reflection, I also noted my mistakes, my problems, my plans, feedback, advice and
suggestion from my friends and my lecturer for my teaching simulations. In my opinion, writing reflection could help me to see
my own progress and improvement in this course. It helped me to rethink about what I had done and experienced and also to find out
the problem solving of my obstacles and my problems. It also could be a medium to evaluate what I had done and experienced.
When I reread my reflections, it reminded me to avoid doing the same mistakes. Own Translation
From the transcription of the interview, it indicated that the student used reflection as a medium to facilitate their autonomy. The students wrote down the
feedback from their friends and their lecturer and made it as a reflection which could be evaluation medium to see what they had done and experienced. The
reflection played the role as a reminder for the student to avoid making the same mistakes because they had already written what they had experienced. Reflection
raised students‟ awareness and responsibility in learning processes. It triggered
them to be active, independent and responsible in their learning processes. From the observation, it was confirm
ed that “students could accept and be open minded in getting the suggestions, recommendation and feedback from the lecturer and
their friends as the observers when they had teaching simulation.”
Watson 2006 says that real learning can be built on students‟ own
existing cognitive structures and must relate to their needs and interest. It was an PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI