Institutional Background and the Role of External Appraisers

Institutional Background and the Role of External Appraisers

B@-(0D(&(."KK"%(.H&$&./,$0D/0.(")(/H,()0%&%.0&'(D/&/,K,%/DA(3%(>??;2(/H,(B0%&%.0&'(-.."#%/0%1(4/&%+&$+D( N"&$+( jB-4Nk( 0DD#,+( /H,( )0$D/( ."KG$,H,%D0M,( )$&K,Q"$[( )"$( K,&D#$0%1( )&0$( M&'#,( S4/&/,K,%/( ")( B0%&%.0&'( -.."#%/0%1( 4/&%+&$+D( j4B-4k( 67VTA( g%( *&=( >?662( /H,( 3-4N( 0DD#,+( /H,( 3%/,$%&/0"%&'( B0%&%.0&'( I,G"$/0%1( 4/&%+&$+D( j3BI4k( 6<2( Fair Value Measurement2( 0%( "$+,$( /"( 1#0+,( /H,( G$,G&$,$D( ")( )0%&%.0&'( D/&/,K,%/D( 0%( ,D/0K&/0%1()&0$(M&'#,A(

3%(0/D('&/,D/(+".#K,%/D2(/H,(3-4N(+,)0%,D()&0$(M&'#,(&D(/H,(&K"#%/()"$(QH0.H(&%(&DD,/("$('0&J0'0/=(."#'+(J,( ,F.H&%1,+( Sexit priceT( J,/Q,,%( K&$[,/( G&$/0.0G&%/D( 0%( &%( "$+,$'=( /$&%D&./0"%A( -'/H"#1H( +,$0M,+( )$"K( /H,( %,#/$&'( ,FG,./&/0"%D( ")( 0%+,G,%+,%/2( [%"Q',+1,&J',2( Q0''0%1( G&$/0,D2( /H,( K,&D#$,K,%/( G$".,DD( 0D( ")/,%( 0%)'#,%.,+(J=(/H,(G,$D"%&'("G0%0"%D(")(/H,(M&'#,$(&%+($,'0&J0'0/=(."%.,$%D(0%,M0/&J'=(&$0D,A(N"/H(/H,(i#&'0/&/0M,(

Ononvalue appraisalsP( GH&D,D( ")( /H,( M&'#&/0"%( G$".,+#$,( SI,=%"'+D2( 6U98T 6 ( &%+( /H,( i#&%/0/&/0M,( ."%D0+,$&/0"%D( $,'&/0%1( /"( /H,( M&'#&/0"%( /,.H%0i#,D( &$,( D/$"%1'=( &)),./,+( J=( /H,( D#J_,./0M,( J,'0,M,D( ")( /H,(

M&'#,$2( ',//0%1( 0KG"$/&%/( M&'#,:&)),./0%1:G$"G,$/0,D( ")( /H,( 0/,KD( J,0%1( &/( ',&D/( G&$/0&''=( DH&G,+( J=( /H,( &GG$&0D,$`D(,D/0K&/0"%D(Se0%12(>??UTA(

RH,$,)"$,2( /H,( $,'0&J0'0/=( ")( /H,( +0D.'"D,+( &%+( $,."1%0],+( )&0$( M&'#,( +,G,%+D( "%( /H,( D#0/&J0'0/=( ")( /H,( 0%)"$K&/0"%(D"#$.,DA(gJD,$M&J',(0%G#/D()$"K(i#"/,+(G$0.,D(")(0+,%/0.&'(0/,KD(/$&+,+(0%(&./0M,(K&$[,/D(SLevel 1 inputsT($,G$,D,%/(/H,(0+,&'(0%)"$K&/0"%2(,KJ"+=0%1(/H,(%,#/$&'(,FG,./&/0"%D(")(0%+,G,%+,%/(K&$[,/(G&$/0.0G&%/DA( W"Q,M,$2(J,.&#D,(")(/H,(G&$/0.#'&$(.H&$&./,$0D/0.D(")(/H,("J_,./(")(/H,(M&'#&/0"%("$(")(/H,(D#J_,./D(0%M"'M,+(0%( /H,(/$&%D&./0"%2(/H,()&0$(M&'#,(0D(")/,%("%'=(0%+0$,./'=(,D/0K&/,+A(3%(/H0D(.&D,2(i#"/,+(G$0.,D(")(."KG&$&J',(0/,KD2( K&$[,/( G$0.,D(")( 0+,%/0.&'( 0/,KD( /$&+,+( 0%( 0%&./0M,( K&$[,/D( "$("/H,$(K&$[,/:$,'&/,+( 0%)"$K&/0"%( S0%/,$,D/( $&/,D2( =0,'+(.#$M,D2(.$,+0/($0D[D(&%+(+,)&#'/($&/,D2(,/.AT($,G$,D,%/(/H,("%'=(&M&0'&J',(+&/&(/"(G$0.,(&DD,/Db'0&J0'0/0,D(SLevel

2 inputsTA( 4"K,/0K,D( S)"$( ,F&KG',( )"$( )0F,+( /&%10J',( &DD,/D( "$( )"$( 0+,%/0)0,+( 0%/&%10J',( &DD,/DT2( "JD,$M&J',( 0%G#/D( +"( %"/( ,F0D/( &%+( /H,( M&'#&/0"%( G$".,+#$,( H&D( /"( J,( J&D,+( "%( #%"JD,$M&J',2( )0$K:1,%,$&/,+( 0%G#/D( $,)',./0%1(K&$[,/(G&$/0.0G&%/D`(&DD#KG/0"%D(SLevel 3 inputsTA(

3%( /H,( G$,D,%.,( ")( d,M,'( >( "$( d,M,'( <( 0%G#/D2( /H,( )&0$( M&'#,( K,&D#$,K,%/( $,D#'/D( )$"K( &GG$"G$0&/,( M&'#&/0"%(/,.H%0i#,D(#D,+(/"(,'&J"$&/,(/H,(&M&0'&J',(+&/&A(LD0%1(/H,(/$&+0/0"%&'(M&'#&/0"%(&GG$"&.H,D(SK&$[,/( &GG$"&.H2( ."D/( &GG$"&.H2( "$( 0%."K,( &GG$"&.HT2( /H,( M&'#,$( Q0''( +,M,'"G( &%( &GG$&0D&'( K"+,'( /"( ,D/0K&/,( )&0$( M&'#,( Smark-to-model fair valueT( QH"D,( $,'0&J0'0/=( Q0''( +,G,%+( K&0%'=( "%( /H,( i#&'0/=( ")( /H,( 0%G#/D( &+"G/,+( Sd&#F(c(d,#]2(>??UTA(

-D( &( $,D#'/2( ,D/0K&/0"%( ,$$"$D( "$( 0%/,%/0"%&'( +&/&( K&%0G#'&/0"%D( ."#'+( H0+,( ,M,%( J,H0%+( M&'#&/0"%( /,.H%0i#,D( &GG&$,%/'=( J&D,+( "%( +0$,./( "JD,$M&/0"%D( ")( /H,( K&$[,/D > 2( 0%/$"+#.0%1( D"K,( $,'0&J0'0/=( ."D/D( /H&/(

+,)'&/,( /H,( "GG"$/#%0/0,D( ")( &( B@-A( 3%+,,+2( /H,( H01H,$( ."KG',F0/=( ")( )0%&%.0&'( D/&/,K,%/( )01#$,D( K,&D#$,+( &/( /H,0$()&0$(M&'#,(J""D/D(/H,(informational asymmetry(0DD#,(&K"%1(G$,G&$,$D2(&#+0/"$D(&%+(#D,$D(")(/H,(&.."#%/0%1( 0%)"$K&/0"%2( $,+#.0%1( )#%+0%12( &%+( 0%M,D/K,%/( "GG"$/#%0/0,D2( &%+( ."%/$&D/0%1( &%( ,))0.0,%/( &''".&/0"%( ")( /H,( $,D"#$.,D(SN,%D/"%2(N$"KQ0.H2(d0/&%2(c(f&1,%H"),$2(>??;TA( (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( ((((((((((((((((((((((((( 6

( O5"%M&'#,(&GG$&0D&'DP(GH&D,D(G&$/0.#'&$'=(."%.,$%(/H,(0+,%/0)0.&/0"%(")(/H,(O#%0/(")(&.."#%/P(&%+(/H,(.H"0.,(")(0/D(OH01H,D/(&%+( J,D/(#D,PA( > ( 3%()&./2(&'/H"#1H(/H,(market approach .&%(J,(."%D0+,$,+(/H,(OK"D/(+0$,./(&%+(D=D/,K&/0.(&GG$"&.H(0%(,D/0K&/0%1(K&$[,/(M&'#,P(

S3@4^2(G&$A(7T2(/H,(#%.,$/&0%/0,D(G$"+#.,+(J=(/H,(&+_#D/K,%/D(K&+,("%(D,M,$&'(M&$0&J',D(.H&$&./,$0]0%1("%'=(G&$/0&''=(."KG&$&J',( G&D/(/$&%D&./0"%D(."#'+(J,(,M,%(1$,&/,$(/H&%(/H"D,($,D#'/0%1()$"K(/H,(+0D."#%/0%1(")()#/#$,(G&="))D(Sincome approachT("$()$"K(/H,( ,D/0K&/,(")(/H,(."D/D(%,.,DD&$=(/"($,G'&.,(/H,(D,$M0.,(.&G&.0/=(")(/H,(0/,K(Scost approachTA(4,,(^"'Q,''2(^&%%&+&=2(&%+(f#(S6U9<TA(

B-3I(@-dLE(C34^dg4LIE2(EhREI5-d(-aaI-34EI4( ;87

3%( "$+,$( /"( &'',M0&/,( 0%)"$K&/0"%&'( &D=KK,/$=( ."D/D2( )0$KD( Q0/H( J,//,$( 0%M,D/K,%/( G$"_,./D( ."#'+( )0%+( Q"$/H=( /"( D,%+( &( ."D/'=( D01%&'( /"( /H,( K&$[,/( &J"#/( /H,( i#&'0/=( ")( /H,0$( )&0$( M&'#,( ,D/0K&/,DA( 4#.H( &( D/$&/,1=( &''"QD(0+,%/0)=0%1(/H,(G$")0/&J',(J#D0%,DD,D(/H&/2("%(/H,(."%/$&$=(")(/H,0$(',DD(J$0D[(."KG,/0/"$D2(.&%(."M,$(/H,( ,FG,%+0/#$,D(+#,(/"(/H,(D01%&'(G$"+#./0"%(Q0/H(/H,(G"D0/0M,(,)),./D("%('0i#0+0/=(&%+(."D/(")(.&G0/&'A(

-()#''(+0D.'"D#$,(H&D(J,,%(."%D0+,$,+(&D(&%(,))0.0,%/(/""'(/"($,&.H(/H0D(G#$G"D,A(RH,(&.&+,K0.('0/,$&/#$,(H&D( &'$,&+=( DH"Q,+( &%( &DD".0&/0"%( J,/Q,,%( &( Q0+,$( +0D.'"D#$,( &%+( &( '"Q,$( J0+:&D[( DG$,&+( "$( &( H01H,$( /$&+0%1( M"'#K,( SW,&'=2( W#//"%2( c( a&',G#2( 6UUUX( d,#]( c( @,$$,..H0&2( >???TA( *"$,"M,$2( $,D,&$.H,D( +".#K,%/,+( &( G"D0/0M,( '0%[( J,/Q,,%( .&G0/&':$0D0%1( &./0M0/=( &%+( +0D.'"D#$,( SB$&%[,'2( *.50.H"'D2( c( f0'D"%2( 6UU7X( d&%1( c( d#%+H"'K2( >???T( &D( Q,''( &D( &( D01%0)0.&%/( %,1&/0M,( $,'&/0"%( J,/Q,,%( ."D/( ")( ,i#0/=( .&G0/&'( &%+( )0%&%.0&'( +0D.'"D#$,(SN"/"D&%2(6UUVX(N"/"D&%(c(a'#K',,2(>??>TA(*"$,($,.,%/'=2(/H,(#D,)#'%,DD(")(0%)"$K&/0"%(&J"#/(/H,( M&'#&/0"%(&DD#KG/0"%D(&+"G/,+(J=(/H,(K&%&1,$D(0%(,M&'#&/0%1(/H,()&0$(M&'#,(")()0$KD`(&DD,/Db'0&J0'0/0,D(H&D(J,,%( DH"Q,+( SN&$/H2( >??;TA( N"/H( K&$[,/( G&$/0.0G&%/D( &%+( )0$KD( J,%,)0/( )$"K( &( +,/&0',+( +0D.'"D#$,( &J"#/( /H,( 0%G#/( #D,+(/"(+,M,'"G()&0$(M&'#,(K"+,'A(-(H01H,$(/$&%DG&$,%.=("%(/H,(M&'#&/0"%(G$".,+#$,D($,+#.,D(/H,(%"0D,(0%(/H,( )0%&%.0&'(0%)"$K&/0"%(&%+(+,.$,&D,D(/H,($,i#0$,+($&/,(")($,/#$%("%(/H,(0%M,D/K,%/(G$"_,./(SNH&/2(>??9TA(

W"Q,M,$2(/H,(0DD#,(")(&(full fair value disclosure ."#'+(%"/(."KG',/,'=(D"'M,(/H,(0%)"$K&/0"%&'(&D=KK,/$=( G$"J',KA( -( ),Q( 0%M,D/"$D2( 0%( )&./2( &$,( D"GH0D/0.&/,+( ,%"#1H( /"( #%+,$D/&%+( /H,( M&'#,( 0KG'0.&/0"%D( ")( +&/&( $,1&$+0%1( M,$=( ."KG',F( M&'#&/0"%( /,.H%0i#,DA( N,.&#D,( ")( ."1%0/0M,( ."D/D( "$( '0K0/&/0"%D2( K"D/( ")( /H,( K&$[,/( G&$/0.0G&%/D(."#'+(J,(G&$/0&''=(#%&J',(/"(G$".,DD()""/%"/,(+0D.'"D#$,(SW"+1,2(e,%%,+=2(c(*&0%,D2(>??8TA(RH,( 0%)"$K&/0"%&'( &D=KK,/$=( G$,M0"#D'=( H=G"/H,D0],+( J,/Q,,%( 0%)"$K,+( &%+( #%0%)"$K,+( K&$[,/( G&$/0.0G&%/D( 0D( %"Q(D#11,D/,+(&1&0%(+0D/0%1#0DH0%1(%&lM,(&1&0%D/(D"GH0D/0.&/,+(0%M,D/"$DA(

B"$(/H0D($,&D"%2(/H,($,.$#0/K,%/(")(&%(0%+,G,%+,%/(M&'#,$(.&%(J,(."%D0+,$,+(&D(&%(&'/,$%&/0M,(K,.H&%0DK(/"( /H,( )&0$( M&'#,( +0D.'"D#$,A( 3%( )&./2( D,M,$&'( $,&D"%D( .&%( J,( &'',1,+( /"( &DD#K,( &( )$,i#,%/( #D,( ")( D#.H( ."$G"$&/,( 1"M,$%&%.,(/""'A(

B0$D/2(/H,(G$"),DD0"%&'(D[0''D(")(/H,(&.."#%/&%/D(&$,(/$&+0/0"%&''=("$0,%/,+(0%($,."$+0%1(QH&/(H&D(J,,%(+"%,( 0%(/H,(G&D/(SQ$0/0%1(+"Q%(/H,(H0D/"$0.&'(."D/(")(/H,(J&'&%.,(DH,,/(0/,KDT2($&/H,$(/H&%(0%(,D/0K&/0%1(&DD,/b'0&J0'0/=`D( K&$[,/( G$0.,( Sa&/"%( c( d0//',/"%2( 6U8?X( Y"'+J,$12( 6U;7TA( -.."#%/&%/D( H&M,( /$&+0/0"%&''=( J,,%( OcostersP( %"/( M&'#,$D(Sd0&%12(>??6TA(RH,$,)"$,2(/H,(."D/D(0%.#$$,+(0%("J/&0%0%1(/H,(&GG$&0D&'([%"Q',+1,(."#'+(J,(H01H,$(/H&%( /H,(J,%,)0/D(G"/,%/0&''=(&DD".0&/,+(Q0/H(/H,(%,Q(&.."#%/0%1(K"+,'2(,DG,.0&''=(QH,%(/H,(#%&M&0'&J0'0/=(")(d,M,'(6(

0%G#/( ',&+D( /"Q&$+D( /H,( #D,( ")( M,$=( ."KG',F( M&'#&/0"%( /,.H%0i#,D < A( 3%+,,+2( ,KG0$0.&'( ,M0+,%.,( D#GG"$/( /H,( &J"M,( 0%/#0/0"%D\( &GG$&0D&'D( ."%+#./,+( J=( ,F/,$%&'( &GG$&0D,$D2( &'J,0/( %"/( &#+0/,+( J=( "%,( ")( /H,( N01( 8( )0$KD2(

,FH0J0/(1$,&/,$(&..#$&.=(/H&%(/H"D,(."%+#./,+(J=(0%/,$%&'(&GG$&0D,$D(&%+(&//,D/,+(J=(/H,(K"D/(0KG"$/&%/(&#+0/"$D( SC0,/$0.H2(W&$$0D2(c(*#'',$2(>??6TA(

4,."%+2(&%(,F/,%D0M,(0%M"'M,K,%/(")(,F/,$%&'(&GG$&0D,$D()"$()0%&%.0&'($,G"$/0%1(G#$G"D,D(."#'+($,D#'/()$"K( /H,(0%/,%D,('"JJ=0%1(&./0M0/=(,%1&1,+(J=(%&/0"%&'(&%+(0%/,$%&/0"%&'(&GG$&0D&'(0%D/0/#/,DA(40%.,(/H,(J,10%%0%1(")( 6UU?D2(/H,(0%/$"+#./0"%(")()&0$(M&'#,(&.."#%/0%1(0%()0%&%.0&'(D/&/,K,%/D(H&D(J,,%(."%D0+,$,+(&D(&(%,Q(J#D0%,DD( (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( (((((((((((((((((((((((((

< ( 3%($,DG"%+0%1(/"(/H,(3-4N(EC Fair Value Measurements2(/H,(3@4^('0D/D(/H,()"''"Q0%1($,&D"%D(/"(,FG'&0%(QH=(/H,(&.."#%/0%1( D/&%+&$+(D,//,$D(DH"#'+(%"/(G$"M0+,(&%=(1#0+&%.,(/"(K,&D#$,(/H,()&0$(M&'#,(")()0%&%.0&'(0/,KD\(S6T(M&'#&/0"%(0%M"'M,D(/H,(,F,$.0D,(")(

G$"),DD0"%&'( _#+1K,%/A( -$$0M0%1( &/( /H,( K"D/( &GG$"G$0&/,( )&0$( M&'#,( ,D/0K&/,( .&%( J,( &( ."KG',F( ,F,$.0D,( ,KG'"=0%1( &( $&%1,( ")( D/".H&D/0.( &%+( H,#$0D/0.( &GG$"&.H,DX( S>T( /H,$,( 0D( &( D01%0)0.&%/( J"+=( ")( [%"Q',+1,( "%( M&'#&/0"%( /,.H%0i#,D( &%+( /H,"$=( /H&/( 0D( ."%D/&%/'=(,M"'M0%1X(&%+(S<T(G$"M0+0%1(&(D#G,$)0.0&'(D#KK&$=(")(M&'#&/0"%(K,/H"+D(&%+(/,.H%0i#,D(0%(/H,(J"+=(")(&(D/&%+&$+(K&=( ,%."#$&1,(/H"D,(Q0/H(0%D#))0.0,%/(#%+,$D/&%+0%1(/"(/$,&/(/H,(D/&%+&$+D(&D(&(O$,.0G,(J""[P(QH0.H(.&%(J,(#D,+(/"(G$"+#.,(/H,(+,D0$,+( $,D#'/DA(

;8;( B-3I(@-dLE(C34^dg4LIE2(EhREI5-d(-aaI-34EI4(

"GG"$/#%0/=( )"$( /H,( &GG$&0D&'( ."KK#%0/=( SN,H$,%D2( 6UU8TA( -( ."%.$,/,( ."%/$0J#/0"%( 0%( D"'M0%1( D"K,( G$"J',KD( '0%[,+(/"(/H,(0%/$"+#./0"%(")(&(%,Q(M&'#&/0"%(G&$&+01K(."%D/&%/'=(."K,D()$"K(/H,(&.&+,K0.(SD,,2()"$(,F&KG',2( C"$.H,D/,$2( >??8T( &D( Q,''( &D( /H,( G$"),DD0"%&'( &GG$&0D&'( Q"$'+( S/H,( -GG$&0D&'( 3%D/0/#/,( &%+( /H,( 3%/,$%&/0"%&'( @&'#&/0"%( 4/&%+&$+D( ^"#%.0'( j3@4^k( 0DD#,+( D,M,$&'( +".#K,%/D( /"( ."KK,%/( "%( /H,( B-4Nb3-4N( )&0$( M&'#,( G$"_,./DTA( ^"%D0+,$&/0"%D( &J"#/( /H,( $"',( ")( /H,( 0%+,G,%+,%/( M&'#,$( 0%.'#+,+( 0%( /H,( &.."#%/0%1( +".#K,%/D( ")( 0KG"$/&%/( D/&%+&$+( D,//,$D( D,,K( /"( /,D/0)=( /H,( ,)),./0M,%,DD( ")( /H,( &GG$&0D,$D`( D/$&/,1=A( RH,( 3-4N( &%+( K&%=( &#+0/0%1( G$&./0.,D( D#GG"$/( /H,( #D,( ")( &%( 0%+,G,%+,%/( M&'#,$( /"( +,/,$K0%,( )&0$( M&'#,A( -/( /H,( D&K,( /0K,2( /H,( ^&%&+0&%( -.."#%/0%1( 4/&%+&$+D( N"&$+( ,KGH&D0],D( /H&/( M&'#&/0"%( 0D( &( )0,'+( ")( [%"Q',+1,( &%+( ,FG,$/0D,( &G&$/( )$"K(/$&+0/0"%&'()0%&%.0&'(&.."#%/0%1(&%+(+,,KD(/"(J,(#D,)#'()"$(&(/H"$"#1H(#%+,$D/&%+0%1(")(3@4^(+".#K,%/D( S^&%&+0&%( -.."#%/0%1( 4/&%+&$+( N"&$+( j^-4Nk2( >??7TX( /H,( -.."#%/0%1( 4/&%+&$+D( N"&$+( j-4Nk2( 0%D/,&+2( $,i#0$,D(0%M,D/K,%/(G$"G,$/=(/"(J,(&GG$&0D,+(J=(,F/,$%&'(M&'#,$(&/(',&D/(,M,$=()0M,(=,&$D(S4/&/,K,%/(")(4/&%+&$+( -.."#%/0%1(a$&./0.,(j44-ak(5"A(6UTA(

W"Q,M,$2(/H,(0%M"'M,K,%/(")(&%(,F/,$%&'(&GG$&0D,$(1,%,$&/,D(&(%,Q(&1,%.=($,'&/0"%DH0G(QH"D,(."D/D(."#'+( /"/&''=( .&%.,'( "#/( /H,( ,FG,./,+( J,%,)0/DA( 3%( )&./2( ."%.,$%D( &J"#/( /H,( $,&'( 0%+,G,%+,%.,( ")( /H,( ,F/,$%&'( M&'#,$( H&M,(J,,%($&0D,+(J=(/H,(&GG$&0D,$D`(."KK#%0/=(0/D,')A(-D(&(."%D,i#,%.,(")(/H,(.'0,%/(G$,DD#$,(&%+(/H,($,D#'/0%1( O$,&GG"0%/K,%/( ."%.,$%DP2( /H,( ,F/,$%&'( &GG$&0D,$( ."#'+( J,( /,KG/,+( /"( M&'0+&/,( /H,( G$0.,( D#11,D/,+( J=( /H,( K&%&1,$2( +$&Q0%1( #G( &( OK&+,( &D( 0%D/$#./,+P( &GG$&0D&'( $,G"$/( 0%( "$+,$( /"( K,,/( /H,( .'0,%/`D( $,i#0$,K,%/D( Se0%%&$+2(d,%[2(c(f"$]&'&2(6UUVX(f"$]&'&2(d,%[2(c(e0%%&$+2 6UU9X(f"'M,$/"%(c(Y&''0K"$,2(6UUUX(f"'M,$/"%2( >???X(Y&''0K"$,(c(f"'M,$/"%2(>???X(-K0+#(c(-'#["2(>??VX(e0%12(>??9TA(

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