A Simple Analytical Model

-(D0KG',(&%&'=/0.&'(K"+,'(0D(G$,D,%/,+(0%(/H0D(G&$&1$&GH(SJ&D,+("%(-.,K"1'#(c(Y0,/]K&%%2(6UUVTA(RH,( &0K(0D(/"(DH"Q(/H,($"',(G'&=,+(J=(/H,(O$,&GG"0%/K,%/(."%.,$%DP(0DD#, Q0/H(&(G"DD0J',(."''#D0M,(+,&'(J,/Q,,%( /H,(K&%&1,$(&%+(/H,(0%+,G,%+,%/(M&'#,$ 0%(+,D.$0J0%1(,F/,$%&'(&GG$&0D,$D(H0$0%1(D/$&/,1=(&+"G/,+(J=(/H,()0$K( &%+(/H,(,."%"K0.(."%D,i#,%.,D(&DD".0&/,+(/"(/H,(0KG',K,%/&/0"%(")(/H,(B@-A(

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

B-3I(@-dLE(C34^dg4LIE2(EhREI5-d(-aaI-34EI4( ;8V

Description of the Model Without “Reappointment Concerns”

^"%D0+,$(/H,()"''"Q0%1(/H$,,:+&/,(K"+,'(Q0/H($0D[(%,#/$&'(&1,%/D2(D,,(B01#$,(<\(

t(m(?(

t(m(6(

t(m(>(

3%0/0&'(0%M,D/K,%/(

3DD#0%1(")(&( )0%&%.0&'(D/&/,K,%/(

I,i#,D/(")(&%(&++0/0"%&'(&K"#%/(3(

-#+0/0%1($,G"$/D(

Figure 3A(4,i#,%.,(")(,M,%/DA(

3%(t(m(?2(/H,(K&%&1,$D(.H""D,(/"(.&$$=("#/(&(%,Q(0%M,D/K,%/(G$"_,./A(3%(t(m(62(&()0%&%.0&'(D/&/,K,%/(0D(0DD#,+( /"(."KK#%0.&/,(&%(,&$'=(D01%&'(&J"#/(/H,(D#..,DD(")(/H,(G$"_,./A(3%(t(m(>2(&%(&++0/0"%&'(&K"#%/(I(0D($,i#,D/,+(/"( /H,(DH&$,H"'+,$D(0%("$+,$(/"(."%/0%#,(/H,(G$"_,./A(

RH,(D01%( G i (+,'0M,$,+(0%(t(m(6(."#'+(J,(,0/H,$(good Si(m(gT("$(bad(Si(m(bTA(RH,(G$"_,./2(0%()&./2(.&%(D#..,,+( &%+( =0,'+( &( 1'"J&'( S g 2( "$( )&0'( &%+( =0,'+( S b A( -DD#K0%1( /H&/( S b ( n( I( n( S g 2( 0/( Q0''( J,( ."%M,%0,%/( /"( $,)0%&%.,( /H,( ."KG&%=("%'=(0)(/H,(1""+(D/&/,(g 0D(M,$0)0,+ 8 2("/H,$Q0D,(/H,(G$"_,./(0D(+$"GG,+(&/(&('0i#0+&/0"%(M&'#,(QH0.H(0D(

%"$K&'0],+( /"( ],$"A( RH,( 0%)"$K&/0"%( +,'0M,$,+( 0%( t( m( 6( 0%)'#,%.,D( /H,( 0%M,D/"$D`( +,.0D0"%2( J#/( 0/( .&%%"/( J,( ."%D0+,$,+(&D(&(+,.0D0M,()&./"$(/"(+0D.$0K0%&/,(&(J$0D[(G$"_,./()$"K(&%(#%G$")0/&J',("%,A(3%()&./2(/H,(DH&$,H"'+,$D(

+"(%"/(."KG',/,'=($,'=(#G"%(/H,(0%)"$K&/0"%(G$"+#.,+(J=(K&%&1,$D2(&%+ %"/Q0/HD/&%+0%1(/H,(0%/,$0K($,D#'/D( &$,(good /H,=(+"(%"/(0KK,+0&/,'=(/$&%D),$(/H,($,i#0$,+(&K"#%/(IA(3%("/H,$(Q"$+D2(pS S b b G g T(o(?A(3%+,,+2(/H,(D01%( ."#'+( J,( K0D',&+0%1( J,.&#D,( ")( /H,( 0%&J0'0/=( ")( /H,( W0D/"$0.&'( ^"D/( -.."#%/0%1( SW^-T( D=D/,K( /"( $,G$,D,%/( &( O/$#,(&%+()&0$(M0,QP(")(/H,("G,$&/0"%D(jQ0/H(G$"J&J0'0/=(ppS S b b G g TkA(*"$,"M,$2(0%(&(.'&DD0.(&1,%.=(D,//0%1(S!,%D,%( c(*,.['0%12(6UV;T2(K&%&1,$D(K01H/(K&%0G#'&/,(&.."#%/0%1(+&/&(0%("$+,$(/"(."'',./(I QH&/,M,$(/H,(i#&'0/=(")(/H,(

G$"_,./( 0D( jQ0/H( G$"J&J0'0/=( pppS 7 S

b b G g Tk A( B"$( /H0D( $,&D"%2( &)/,$( &%&'=]0%1( &%+( G$".,DD0%1( &.."#%/0%1( +&/&2( /H,( DH&$,H"'+,$D( 0%/,$G$,/( /H,( )#/#$,( D/&/,( ")( /H,( Q"$'+( &D( &( +0D.$,/,( $&%+"K( M&$0&J',2( &DD01%0%1( &( D#J_,./0M,( G$"J&J0'0/=( pS S b b G g T( m( ppS S b b G g T( q( pppS S b b G g T( í( pppppS S b b G g T( /"( D/&/,( b( "..#$$0%1( ,M,%( 0)( /H,( +$&Q%( #G( )0%&%.0&'( D/&/,K,%/(DH"QD(G"D0/0M,($,D#'/D2(&%+(&(G$"J&J0'0/=(j6( ; í(pS S

b b G g Tk(/"(D/&/,(gA(RH,=(/$&%D),$(/H, &K"#%/(I(QH,%,M,$ \( p S SGS b b g T b j6 p S SGS b b g Tk g ! I ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( S6T(

3%( D#.H( &( D,//0%12( &%( ,F/,$%&'( &#+0/"$( ."#'+( G'&=( &( )#%+&K,%/&'( $"',A( N=( &./0%1( &D( &( 1#&$+0&%( ")( DH&$,H"'+,$D(0%/,$,D/D(Se")K&%(c(d&Q&$$r,2(6UU<T2(/H,(&#+0/"$(."#'+(+,/,./(&.."#%/0%1(K&%0G#'&/0"%(&%+(&''"Q( &( J,//,$( &DD,DDK,%/( ")( /H,( G$"J&J0'0/=( pppS S b b G g T( G,$/&0%0%1( /"( /H,( ,F0D/,%.,( ")( &( K0D',&+0%1( D01%( .&#D,+( J=( ,&$%0%1D( K&%&1,K,%/A( 3%( )&./2( /H,( &#+0/0%1( G$".,DD( .&#D,D( &( +,.$,&D0%1( ")( pppS S b b G g T( 0%( .&D,( ")( 1,%#0%,( 1""+( G$"_,./D2()&M"$0%1(&(K"$,(,))0.0,%/($,D"#$.,(&''".&/0"%A(3%(G&$/0.#'&$2(0)(0/(0D(&DD#K,+(/H&/(/H,(,F/,$%&'(&#+0/"$(0D( &J',(/"($,G"$/(Q0/H"#/(&%=(J0&D(&J"#/(/H,($,D#'/D(DH"Q,+(J=(&%(W^-()0%&%.0&'(D/&/,K,%/2(0%(.&D,(")(1""+(G$"_,./(

pppS S b b G g T(m(?(&%+(/H,(,FG,./,+(G&="))(")(/H,(0%M,D/K,%/(G$"_,./($0D,D(")(&%(&K"#%/(,i#&'(/"(pppS S b b G g TS S g ( í( S b T( í( pppppS S b b G g TS S g ( í( S b T( t(?2(0%.$,&D0%1(/H,(.H&%.,D(/H&/(K&%&1,$D(D#..,,+(0%($&0D0%1()#%+D(SIT(0%("$+,$(/"(."%/0%#,(&( 1""+(G$"_,./A(

7 ( 3/(0D(0%+0)),$,%/(QH,/H,$(/H0D(.&DH(0%)#D0"%(0D(."%/$0J#/,+(J=(/H,(0%0/0&'(DH&$,H"'+,$D("$(J=(%,Q(DH&$,H"'+,$DA( ( -'/H"#1H(D,M,$&'(/H,"$0,D(',&+0%1(/"(&(."%)'0./(")(0%/,$,D/(J,/Q,,%(/H,(K&%&1,$(&%+(/H,(DH&$,H"'+,$D(Q"#'+(J,(&GG$"G$0&/,2(/H,( O,KG0$,( J#0'+0%1P( &DD#KG/0"%( SW&$/( c( *""$,2(6UU?X( W&$/2( 6UU<T( ."#'+( ,FG'&0%( /H,( K&%&1,$`D("GG"$/#%0D/0.( J,H&M0"$( +,D.$0J,+(

&J"M,A(RH,(O,KG0$,(J#0'+0%1P(&DD#KG/0"%(&''"QD(&'D"(/"(D#GG"D,(/H&/(pS S b T(m(

g G b IA(

( -DD#K0%1(/H,($0D[',DD(0%/,$,D/($&/,(%"$K&'0],+(/"(],$"A(

;89( B-3I(@-dLE(C34^dg4LIE2(EhREI5-d(-aaI-34EI4(

W"Q,M,$2(0/(Q0''(J,(Q"$/H=(/"(H0$,(&%(&#+0/"$(J,/Q,,%(t(m(6(&%+(t(m(>(&D('"%1(&D(/H,(M&'#,(")(/H,(&#+0/0%1( $,G"$/( S/H&/(0D( ,i#&'( /"( /H,(H01H,$(,FG,./,+(G&="))( ")(/H,(0%M,D/K,%/T( ,F.,,+D( /H,(."D/D(")( 0/D( D,$M0.,D( SKTA( 3%( "/H,$(Q"$+D2(/H,(0%M"'M,K,%/(")(&%(,F/,$%&'(&#+0/"$(',&+D(/"(&(K"$,(,))0.0,%/($,D"#$.,(&''".&/0"%(QH,%,M,$(/H,( )"''"Q0%1(0%,i#&'0/=(0D(M,$0)0,+\(

p ppS SGS b b g TS g S b T pp p ppS SGS b b g TS g S b T ! K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( S>T( RH,(&+"G/0"%(")(&(B@-2(0%D/,&+2(."#'+(+,.$,&D,(/H,(G$"J&J0'0/=(ppS S b b G g T(")(&(K0D',&+0%1(D01%(.&#D,+(J=(/H,( 0%&J0'0/=(")(&%(W^-(K"+,'(/"(."KK#%0.&/,(&(/$#,(&%+()&0$(M0,Q(")(/H,()0%&%.0&'(G,$)"$K&%.,A(N=(&DD#K0%1(/H&/2(

&D(&($,D#'/(")(/H,(0KG',K,%/&/0"%(")(B@-2(pp FVA S S b b G g T(m(?2(/H,(%,/(G$,D,%/(M&'#,(")(/H,(G$"_,./()#$/H,$(0%.$,&D,D(

")(&%(&K"#%/(,i#&'(/"(pp HCA pppS S b b G g TS S g ( í( S b T(o(?A(

W"Q,M,$2( /H,( 0KG&./( ")( /H,( 0%/$"+#./0"%( ")( B@-( 0%( /H,( 0%)"$K&/0"%( +,'0M,$,+( /"( /H,( DH&$,H"'+,$D( 0D( %"/( "JM0"#DA(3%()&./2("%("%,(H&%+(/H,(Q,''(&//,D/,+($,',M&%.,(")(K&$[,/(J&D,+(K,&D#$,K,%/(&.."#%/0%1(K"+,'(K01H/( )&.0'0/&/,(/H,(,D/0K&/,D("%()#/#$,()0%&%.0&'(,i#0'0J$0#K2(&''"Q0%1(&%(,))0.0,%/(&''".&/0"%(")(/H,($,D"#$.,DA(g%(/H,( "/H,$(H&%+2(/H,(0%)"$K&/0"%&'(&D=KK,/$=(&K"%1(K&%&1,$D2(&#+0/"$D(&%+(#%0%)"$K,+(0%M,D/"$D2(&DD".0&/,+(Q0/H( /H,($0D[(")(K&%0G#'&/0"%D(")(/H,(&.."#%/0%1()01#$,D("$010%&/,+()$"K(mark-to-model fair value2 ."#'+(0%/$"+#.,( $,'0&J0'0/=(/H&/(K01H/(."KG,%D&/,(/H,(,FG,./,+(J,%,)0/DA(

-'/H"#1H( .H&$&./,$0],+( J=( &%( information content2( B@-( K01H/( J,( )"''"Q,+( J=( &( %,1&/0M,( information valueA(3%(G&$/0.#'&$2(0/(0D(G"DD0J',(/"(DH"Q(/H,(%,1&/0M,(0KG&./(")($,'0&J0'0/=(."D/D(0%(/,$KD(")\(S6T($,+#./0"%(")( /H,(&#+0/"$D`($,G"$/(M&'#,2(+#,(/"(&(H01H,$(G$"J&J0'0/=(")(&(K0D/&[,(0%(/H,(&#+0/0%1(G$".,DDX(&%+(S>T(&%(0%.$,&D,(")( /H,(&#+0/0%1(."D/DA(

3)( ?( n( - FVA ( d( 6( 0D( /H,( G$"J&J0'0/=( /H&/( /H,( &#+0/"$( Q0''( %"/( J,( &J',( /"( &DD,DD( /H,( i#&'0/=( ")( )&0$( M&'#,( K,&D#$,K,%/D V 2(/H,(%,1&/0M,(M&$0&/0"%(0%(/H,(M&'#,(")(&#+0/,+(0%)"$K&/0"%(0D(K,&D#$,+(&D\(

Z- : FVA p ppS SGS b b g TS g S b T ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( S<A&T( RH,( 0%/$"+#./0"%( ")( ?( n( - FVA ( d( 6( 0%+#.,D( &'D"( /"( ."%D0+,$( /H,( G$"J&J0'0/=( q g ( m( fS - FVA T2( qp g S - FVA T( o( ?(

G,$.,0M,+( J=( /H,( &#+0/"$( /"( J,( K0D/&[,%'=( )"#%+( /"( H&M,( K0D$,G"$/ 9 A( B"$( /H0D( $,&D"%2( /H,( &#+0/0%1( ."D/D( &$,( "J/&0%,+(J=(&++0%1(/"(/H,($,i#0$,+(&#+0/0%1(),,(K /H,()0%,( D (/H&/(/H,(&#+0/"$(0D("J'01,+(/"(G&=(QH,%,M,$ /H,(

)0$K( 1"0%1( J&%[$#G/( Q0/H( G$"J&J0'0/=( O b H,( 0D( K0D/&[,%'=( )"#%+( SQ0/H( G$"J&J0'0/=( q g T( /"( H&M,( K0D$,G"$/,+A( *"$,"M,$2(."%D0+,$0%1(/H&/(/H,(DH&$,H"'+,$D(Q0''($,.,0M,("%'=(&(G"$/0"%( I (n(6(")( D 2(/H,(&#+0/0%1(."D/D(&DD".0&/,+( /"( /H,( 0%/$"+#./0"%( ")( &( B@-( K"+,'( Q0''( ,i#&'( K( q( S6( í( I T O b q g D 2( 0%.$,&D0%1( /H,( &#+0/0%1( ),,D( ")( &%( &K"#%/( ,i#&'(/"\(

Z p O b q g S6 ID T ! ? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( S<AJT(

RH,("M,$&''(%,1&/0M,(0KG&./(&DD".0&/,+(/"(/H,(0%/$"+#./0"%(")(B@-(&%+(/"(/H,(&#+0/0%1(G$".,DD(")()&0$(M&'#,(

K,&D#$,K,%/D(0D(10M,%(J=( Z (q( Z p(m( :(m(fS - FVA X(q g TA(

RH,$,)"$,2(/H,(0KG',K,%/&/0"%(")(/H,(H0D/"$0.&'(+&/&(Q0/H(/H,(.#$$,%/(M&'#,(")(/H,($,D"#$.,D(0%M"'M,+(0%(/H,( G$"_,./(K01H/(J,(&%(0%,))0.0,%/(G$".,DDA(3%(G&$/0.#'&$2(/H,(B@-(H&D(&%(information value("%'=(0)\(

p p HCA p ppS SGS b b g TS g S b T !: ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( S8T(

B0$KD( &+"G/0%1( B@-( %,,+( /"( D01%&'( /H,( i#&'0/=( ")( /H,0$( K,&D#$,K,%/( G$".,DD( 0%( "$+,$( /"( +,.'&$,( /H,( 1""+%,DD(")(/H,0$(G$"_,./D(&%+(/"($,+#.,( :A( (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( (((((((((((((((((((((((((

V ( RH,(G$"J&J0'0/=( 9 ( RH,(G$"J&J0'0/=(q -(,i#&'D(],$"(QH,%,M,$(/H,(W^-(D=D/,K(0D(#D,+(/"(+$&Q(#G()0%&%.0&'(D/&/,K,%/DA( g ,i#&'D(],$"(QH,%,M,$(/H,()0%&%.0&'(0%)"$K&/0"%(0D(J&D,+("%(/H,(W0D/"$0.&'(-.."#%/0%1(K"+,'A(

B-3I(@-dLE(C34^dg4LIE2(EhREI5-d(-aaI-34EI4( ;8U

-(/$&+0/0"%&'(D"'#/0"%(/"(D"'M,(/H,(0%)"$K&/0"%(&D=KK,/$=(G$"J',K(0D($,G$,D,%/,+(J=(&()#''(+0D.'"D#$,(&J"#/( /H,(M&'#&/0"%(&DD#KG/0"%D(&+"G/,+(0%(/H,(K,&D#$,K,%/(G$".,DDA(*&%&1,$D(Q0''(0DD#,(&(full fair value disclosure 0)( /H,( %,1&/0M,( ."%D,i#,%.,D( +#,( /"( ,$$"$D( 0%( /H,( K,&D#$,K,%/( G$".,DD( &%+( /"( /H,( 0%)"$K&/0"%&'( &D=KK,/$=( SQ0/H( K"$&'( H&]&$+( &%+( &+M,$D,( D,',./0"%( $,D#'/DT( Q0''( J,( H01H,$( /H&%( /H,( ."D/D( D#D/&0%,+( )"$( G$,G&$0%12(

.,$/0)=0%1( &%+( +0DD,K0%&/0%1( )&0$( M&'#,( +0D.'"D#$,\( :( o( C D A W"Q,M,$2( /H,( 0DD#,( ")( &( full fair value disclosure J,.&#D,( ")( /H,( 0%&J0'0/=( ")( /H,( #%D"GH0D/0.&/,+( 0%M,D/"$D( /"( ."%M,%0,%/'=( G$".,DD( +&/&( $,1&$+0%1( M,$=( ."KG',F( M&'#&/0"%( /,.H%0i#,D Q0''( %"/( ."KG',/,'=( $,K"M,( /H,( ."D/D( &DD".0&/,+( /"( /H,( 0%)"$K&/0"%&'(

&D=KK,/$=(G$"J',K2(&%+(&(G"$/0"%( J ( (j?2(6k(")(:(H&D(/"(J,(&++,+(/"(C D (/"(&DD,DD(/H,(/"/&'(+0D.'"D#$,(."D/DA(-D( &($,D#'/2(0/(Q0''(J,(Q"$/H=(/"(&+"G/(/H,(fair value disclosure D/$&/,1= 0)\(

C :! D

( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( S7T(

-%( &'/,$%&/0M,( &%DQ,$( /"( /H,( &J"M,( K,%/0"%,+( G$"J',K( 0D( $,G$,D,%/,+( J=( &( D,',./0"%( ")( &( ."D/'=( S K s T( ,F/,$%&'(&GG$&0D,$(/"(K,&D#$,(/H,()&0$(M&'#,(")(&DD,/D(&%+('0&J0'0/0,DA(W0$0%1(&%(,F/,$%&'(&GG$&0D,$(."#'+(0%.$,&D,( /H,(Q,''%,DD(")(DH&$,H"'+,$DA(RH,(."D/(")()&0$(M&'#,(+0D.'"D#$,(SC A T2(&)/,$(H&M0%1(,F/,$%&'0],+(/H,(K,&D#$,K,%/( G$".,DD2(Q0''(+,.$,&D,A(-/(/H,(D&K,(/0K,2(/H,(,$$"$(&%+(/H,(0%)"$K&/0"%&'(&D=KK,/$=(G$"J',KD(."#'+(J,('"Q,$( SQ0/H( JJ s T(J,.&#D,(/H,(#%D"GH0D/0.&/,+(0%M,D/"$D(&%+(&#+0/"$D(."#'+(%"Q($,'=("%(/H,(&DD#KG/0"%D(K&+,(J=(&( /H0$+( 0%+,G,%+,%/( G&$/=( S*#'',$( c( I0,+'2( >??>X( ^"//,$( c( I0.H&$+D"%2( >??>TA( 3/( 0D( Q"$/H=( /"( H0$,( &%( ,F/,$%&'( &GG$&0D,$2(0%D/,&+(")(&GG'=0%1(&(full fair value disclosure(D/$&/,1=2(0)\(

A Simple Analytical Model