The Information Risks (and the Asset Allocation Puzzle) During the Financial Crisis
The Information Risks (and the Asset Allocation Puzzle) During the Financial Crisis
3/( 0G( ,&G=( /"( 1,/( G0E0'&$0/0,G( [D0',( /&H0%1( &( '""H( &/( /D,( +=%&E0.G( ")( /D,( Y$0.,( 0%+,U( )"$( /D,( /D$,,( G/".H( ,U.D&%1,GA( N01#$,( <( +,Y0./G( D"[( 4g`( 7??( &%+( L!:Q#$"4/"UU( 0%+,U,G( &$,( M,$=( /$&.H0%12( D&M0%1( &( G/$"%1( ."$$,'&/0"%(0%(/D,0$(Y&/DA(
3%( C&P',( <2( $,'&/0"%G( P,/[,,%( $0GHG( &%+( $,/#$%G(0%( /D,( /D$,,( E&$H,/G( &$,( GD"[%A( CD,( $,/#$%:/":$0GH( $&/,( 0G( '"[,$( 0%( /D,( Q#$"Y,&%( *&$H,/( /D&%( 0%( /D,( W4-( *&$H,/K( CD0G( ,M0+,%.,( 0G( +#,( /"( /D,( $,'&/0M,( 1&Y( 0%( G/&%+&$+( +,M0&/0"%G(aq67A87k(0%(Q#$"Y,("M,$(W4-b2(/[0.,(/D&%(/D,($,'&/0M,(1&Y(0%(/D,($,/#$%(aqBA89k2("%'=bA(J"EY#/0%1( /D,( G&E,( $&/0"( P#/( ,U.'#+0%1( /D,( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH2( E"$,( ,R#0'0P$&/,+( $,G#'/G( &$,( )"#%+K( CD,( $,/#$%( Y,$( #%0/( ")( Y&=")):$0GH(0G(R#0/,(/D,(G&E,(0%(/D,(/["(E&$H,/G(a6?A67k(MGA(6?A89kbA(CD,(D01D,$($,/#$%(Y,$(#%0/(")(/"/&':$0GH(0%( /D,(W4-(0G(+#,(/"(/D,(."EY$,GG0"%(")(/D,(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GHA(CD,(/["(E&$H,/G(&$,(M,$=(G0E0'&$(0%(/D,(E,.D&%0GE( ")($0GH(Y$0.0%1(P#/(&$,(M,$=(+0)),$,%/(&G(Y,$(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH2(0/G(/"',$&%.,(&%+2()0%&''=2(0/G(Y$0.0%1A(
CD,(Y$,M0"#G()01#$,G(.&%(%"[(P,(."EY#/,+()"$(/0E,(',%1/D(")(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a!#'=(<2(>??;(/"(*&$.D(<62( >??\b( &%+( )"$( /D,( Y$,M0"#G("%,( a5"M,EP,$( 62( 6\\\( /"(*&$.D( <62(>??<bA( 40%.,( /D,( Y,$0"+G( &$,(.D"G,%( )$"E( &( /"Y:Y,&H(/"(&()'""$:+$"Y2($,/#$%G(&$,("PM0"#G'=(%,1&/0M,A(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
Figure 3. I"%1:/,$E(G/".H(0%+,U,G(."EY&$,+(a!&%(>2(6\\>(o(6??bA(
C&P',(<( Return and Risks for Financial Markets in the Long Run
L(o(T(r(J( -hL( (
`&="))($0GH(akb( akb( 4llQ(3%+,U(
Z,,H'=($,/#$%(akb( 4/+A(L(akb(
akb(
C"/&'(3F(akb(
6?A689\( 4`l(3%+,U(
?A68>9(
>A87B9(
6?A8B;\( C`l(3%+,U(
6A>;B9(
C&P',(8(GD"[G(/D,($,G#'/G()"$(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0GA(CD,(Y&="))($0GH([&G(R#0/,(,R#0'0P$&/,+(P,/[,,%(/D,(Q#$"Y,&%( &%+(/D,(W4-(*&$H,/A(CD,('"[,$(',M,'(")(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH(',/(/D,(W4-(*&$H,/(D&M,(&(GE&'',$(G/&%+&$+(+,M0&/0"%( ")($,/#$%G2(/D#G(&''"[0%1(&($,+#.,+(',M,'(")(&M,$&1,(%,1&/0M,(Y,$)"$E&%.,A(
C&P',(8( Return and Risks for Financial Markets in the 2006-2009 Crisis
L(o(T(r(J( -hL( (
`&="))($0GH(akb( akb( 4llQ(3%+,U(
Z,,H'=($,/#$%(akb( 4/+A(L(akb(
akb(
C"/&'(3F(akb(
:6BA6B;\( 4`l(3%+,U(
:?A<?7?(
<A>668(
:\A8\BB(
6A8<7B(
6ABB7B(
:6<AB<9\( C`l(3%+,U(
<A7B>>(
:6?AB??B(
6A7<?;(
>A?86B(
:69AB>>;(
-(M,$=(+0)),$,%/(G/"$=(/""H(Y'&.,(0%(/D,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G2(&G(="#(.&%(G,,(0%(C&P',(7A(CD,(&PG"'#/,(',M,'(")( Q#$"Y,&%($0GH([&G(R#0/,(/D,(G&E,(")(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a<A>8>k(MGA(<A>66kb2(P#/(/D,(0EY&./(")(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH( [&G(M,$=('"[,$(a6A>\9k(MGA(6A8<;kb(&%+(D01D,$(Y&="))($0GH(,E,$1,+(a6A\88k(MGA(6ABB;kbA(3%(/D,(.&G,(")(/D,( W4-( $0GH2( /D,( G0/#&/0"%( 0G( ."EY',/,'=( +0)),$,%/K( CD,( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( 0%.$,&G,( /"( ',M,'( M,$=( %,U/( /"( /D"G,( "PG,$M,+(0%(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a6AB?6k(MGA(6AB;?kb([D0',(/D,(Y&="))($0GH([&G('"[,$(a6A6?7k(MGA(6A>99kbA(
4"E,(."%.'#G0"%G(.&%(P,(G/$"H,("#/(&P"#/(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0GK( a6b(CD,($,/#$%:/":Y&="))($0GH($&/0"(/,%+G(/"(P,(G/&P',(&.$"GG(/D,(E&$H,/G]( a>b(CD,($,/#$%:/":$0GH($&/0"(0G(+0M,$/0%1(&.$"GG(/D,(E&$H,/G(a&'"%1([0/D($0GH(&M,$G0"%Gb](
B69(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
a<b(C"/&'($0GH(0%.$,&G,G(0%(&(D"E"1,%,"#G([&=(+#$0%1(&''(/D,(.$0G,G]( a8b(CD,(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH(0%.$,&G,G(+#$0%1(/D,(.$0G0G2(P#/(D&M,(&(G/$"%1,$(0EY&./(0%(Q#$"Y,]( a7b(CD,(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH([&G(&(G01%0)0.&%/(+$0M,$(")('&/,G/(.$0G0G(0%(Q#$"Y,(aP#/(%"/(0%(W4-bA(
C&P',(7( Return and Risks for Financial Markets in the 1999-2003 Crisis
L(o(T(r(J( -hL( (
`&="))($0GH(akb( akb( 4llQ(3%+,U(
Z,,H'=($,/#$%(akb( 4/+A(L(akb(
akb(
C"/&'(3F(akb(
:>7A96;>( 4`l(3%+,U(
6A>\B\(
6A\88?(
:67A<<96( C`l(3%+,U(
:?A>;?9(
>A9?7;(
:\A>\;B(
CD,(+0))0.#'/0,G([,(&''(D&+(0%(.D&'',%10%1(/D,(.$0G0G(.&%(P,(,UY'&0%,+K(a6b(Z,(+"($,R#0$,(/""'G(/"(."%/$"'(/D,( 0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH(P#/([,(E&0%'=(D&M,(/""'G(/"(E&%&1,(Y&="))($0GH](&%+(a>b(Y&="))($0GH(0G(&(1'"P&'(+$0M,$(P#/(/D,( "YY"G0/,(0G(/$#,()"$(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH2($,R#0$0%1(E"$,('".&'(Y"'0.0,GA(O'"P&'(&GG,/(&''".&/0"%(E01D/(P,(&)),./,+(P=( /D,('".&'0X,+(0EY&./(")(/D,(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GHA(
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kA(CD,( ."$$,'&/0"%([0/D(/D,(!&Y&%,G,(*&$H,/(0G(E#.D('"[,$2(P,0%1(86A6<k()"$(/D,(Q#$"Y,&%(*&$H,/(&%+(86A\7k()"$(/D,( W4-("%,A(CD,()01#$,()"$(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(0G(B\k([D0',()"$(/D,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(0G(98A7BkA(
C"( #%+,$G/&%+( D"[( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( E&=( &)),./( /D,( ."$$,'&/0"%( 0%+,U( ")( /D,( $,/#$%G2( [,( .&%( &%&'=X,( /D,( $,'&/0"%GD0Y(,U0G/0%1(P,/[,,%(/D,($0GH0%,GG(")(/D,(/["(E&$H,/G2(M,$=(."$$,'&/,+(0%+,,+K(CD,(."$$,'&/0"%(P,/[,,%( /D,0$(GD"$/:/,$E(G/&%+&$+(+,M0&/0"%(0G(B;A7kA(-(."EY',/,'=(+0)),$,%/(G/"$=(.&%(P,()"#%+()"$(/D,(Cc`3l(0%+,UK( 3/G( $0GH( 0G( '"[( ."$$,'&/,+( P"/D( [0/D( /D,( W4-( E&$H,/( a6\A<Bkb( &%+( /D,( Q#$"Y,&%( "%,( a>?A<;kbA( CD,( &P"M,( ."$$,'&/0"%G(&$,(."EY#/,+("M,$(1$"GG($0GH(+&/&2(/D#G(0%.'#+0%1(/D,(/"/&'(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH(aC3FbA(3)([,(."EY#/,(/D,( G&E,(."$$,'&/0"%G(E"M0%1()$"E(%,/(Y&="))($0GH(+&/&2(/D,()0%&'($,G#'/G(&$,(R#0/,(+0)),$,%/K(/D,(."$$,'&/0"%(P,/[,,%( W4-(&%+(Q#$"Y,(0G(+,.'0%0%1([D0',(P"/D(."$$,'&/0"%G([0/D(!&Y&%,G,(E&$H,/G(&$,(0%.$,&G0%1A(4,,(C&P',(;A(
C&P',(;( Correlation Index Between Short-Term Total Risks and Payoff Risks in the Market Price Indexes
C`l(0%+,U( 4D"$/:/,$E(/"/&'($0GHG( 4llQ(0%+,U(
4llQ(0%+,U(
4`l(0%+,U(
4`l(0%+,U(
?AB;78<;<><(
C`l(0%+,U(
?A>?<7B?67;(
?A6\<B?;66>(
4D"$/:/,$E(Y&="))($0GHG( 4llQ(0%+,U(
4`l(0%+,U(
?AB??;889;6(
C`l(0%+,U(
?A<9B?7<7;7(
?A<\>>B7;6>(
c#$( ."%.'#G0"%( 0G( G0EY',K( CD,( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( E01D/( &)),./( /D,( &GG,/( &''".&/0"%( +,.0G0"%A( CD,( &./#&'( $,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(/D,(!&Y&%,G,(0%M,G/E,%/(.&%(P,("M,$G/&/,+(P=(#%+#,(P,%,)0/GA(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
B6\
CD,(G&E,(,M0+,%.,(.&%%"/(P,()"#%+(+#$0%1('&G/(.$0G0GA(C&P',(B(."EY#/,G(/D,(G&E,(."$$,'&/0"%(0%+,U,G(0%( /D,(/0E,(',%1/D(")(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a!#'=(>??;:*&$.D(>??\bA(C["(,M0+,%.,G(,E,$1,()$"E()01#$,G(&$,(0EY$,GG0M,K( a6b(CD,(&PG"'#/,(',M,'(")($0GH:."$$,'&/0"%(0%(E&$H,/G(0%.$,&G,2(+#,(/"(."%/&10"%(,)),./G]( a>b(5"($,',M&%/(.D&%1,G(.&%(P,("PG,$M,+(P,/[,,%(."EY#/&/0"%(0%(^1$"GG_(&%+(^%,/_(."EY#/&/0"%()"$(/D,(
."$$,'&/0"%(P,/[,,%(W4-(&%+(Q#$"Y,&%(E&$H,/GA(
C&P',(B( Correlation Index in Short-Term Risks During the 2006-2009 Crisis
C`l(3%+,U( C"/&'(GD"$/:/,$E($0GH(a0%.'#+,G(C3Fb( 4llQ(3%+,U(
4llQ(3%+,U(
4`l(3%+,U(
4`l(3%+,U(
?A9B>?;B7<7(
C`l(3%+,U(
4D"$/:/,$E(Y&="))($0GH(aC3F(,U.'#+,+b( 4llQ(3%+,U(
4`l(3%+,U(
?A9B><B>9;7(
C`l(3%+,U(
?A<><;B7B76(
?A>;B\8>679(
3)([,(."EY&$,(/D,(."EY#/,+($,G#'/G([0/D(/D"G,($,),$$,+(/"(/D,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a0A,A2(5"M,EP,$(6\\\:*&$.D( >??<b2(G,,(C&P',(92(&(M,$=(+0)),$,%/(G/"$=(.&%(P,()"#%+K( a6b(CD,(&PG"'#/,(',M,'("$($0GH(."$$,'&/0"%(0%(E&$H,/G(+,.$,&G,(P,'"[('"%1:/,$E(',M,']( a>b(5"($,',M&%/(.D&%1,G(.&%(P,("PG,$M,+(P,/[,,%(."EY#/&/0"%(0%(^1$"GG_(&%+(^%,/_(."EY#/&/0"%()"$(/D,(
."$$,'&/0"%(0%M"'M0%1(/D,(!&Y&%,G,(E&$H,/A(
C&P',(9( Correlation Index in Short-Term Risks During the 2000-2003 Crisis
C`l(3%+,U( C"/&'(GD"$/:/,$E($0GH(a0%.'#+,G(C3Fb( 4llQ(3%+,U(
4llQ(3%+,U(
4`l(3%+,U(
4`l(3%+,U(
?AB69>;>>6<(
C`l(3%+,U(
?A<??9><;>(
?A>9\BBB<98(
4D"$/:/,$E(Y&="))($0GH(aC3F(,U.'#+,+b( 4llQ(3%+,U(
4`l(3%+,U(
?AB;<;7<9<7(
C`l(3%+,U(
?A>\9<?\B86(
?A>9>?>\\69(
c#$( G,."%+( ."%.'#G0"%( 0G( G/0''( G0EY',K( CD,( >???:>??<( .$0G0G( .',&%,+( /D,( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( 0%( /D,( 1'"P&'( )0%&%.0&'( E&$H,/G2( [D0',( /D,( >??B:>??\( [&G( #%&P',( /"( $,&.D( G#.D( &( $,G#'/A( CD,( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( [&G( &%( 0EY"$/&%/( +$0M,$( ")( /D,( '&/,G/( )0%&%.0&'( .$0G0G( &%+( %"(&))"$+&P',( ."EY&$0G"%G( .&%( P,( +"%,( [0/D"#/( ."%G0+,$0%1( /D,(0EY&./(")(/D,(G"#$.,G(")(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GHA(
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
B>?(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
N01#$,(8(+,Y0./G(/D,(&M,$&1,(Y,$.,%/&1,(."EY"G0/0"%(")(/D,(C3F(0%(/D,(/D$,,(E&$H,/G(&'$,&+=(Y$,G,%/,+(0%( /D,(Y$,M0"#G(Y&$&1$&YDG(")(/D,(Y&Y,$A(CD,(W4-(.&G,(0G(.',&$A( CD,(GY,.0)0.(.&G,(")(W4-(0G(.',&$A(CD,(D01D,$($,',M&%.,(")(/D,(&M,$&1,(L3F(,UY'&0%G([D=(/D,(0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( 0EY&./G( E&$H,/G( ,R#0'0P$0#E( 0%( &( +0)),$,%/( [&=( /D&%( 0%( Q#$"Y,A( -/( /D,( G&E,( /0E,2( +0)),$,%/( /""'G( &$,( $,R#0$,+(/"(.D&'',%1,(/D,(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GHK(e0++,%(0%)"$E&/0"%(0G(E"$,($,',M&%/(0%(/D,(W4-([D0',(0%)"$E&/0"%( +0G/$0P#/0"%(E#G/(P,()".#G,+(0%(Q#$"Y,A(
6??k \?k
><A88k(
>;A>Bk(
9?k
8>A?Bk
B?k ;?k 7?k
-MA(L3F -MA(43F
8?k B;A7;k(
B<AB<k(
<?k
7BA\<k
Figure 4. I"%1:/,$E(C3F(0%(G/".H(0%+,U,G(."EY&$,+(&%+(GY'0/(P,/[,,%(43F(&%+(L3FA(
5"[( ',/( #G( ,U&E0%,( +&/&( 0%( /D,( /["( .$0G0G( $,Y"$/,+( 0%( C&P',( \A( CD,( 0%.$,&G,( ")( G=G/,E&/0.( G"#$.,G( ")( 0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH(+#$0%1(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(0G(,M0+,%/(0%(&''(E&$H,/G2(/,''0%1(#G(/D&/(/D,(E,.D&%0GE(")(0%)"$E&/0"%( +0G/$0P#/0"%(0G(/"(P,(0EY$"M,+(0%(%,U/($,1#'&/"$(&./0M0/0,GA(
C&P',(\( TIR Composition During the Crisis
-M,$&1,([,01D/(k(L3F( N#''(6\\>:>??\(
-M,$&1,([,01D/(k(43F(
B;A7;8<(
><A8<7B(
L!Q( J$0G0G(>??;:>??\(
B9A96;>(
>6A69<9(
J$0G0G(6\\\:>??<(
B?A>8\;(
>\AB7?8(
N#''(6\\>:>??\(
7BA\>;8(
8>A?B<;(
4`l( J$0G0G(>??;:>??\(
;9A<?\8(
<6A;\?;(
J$0G0G(6\\\:>??<(
7<A;?7;(
8;A<\88(
N#''(6\\>:>??\(
B<AB<8?(
>;A>;;?(
C`l( J$0G0G(>??;:>??\(
BBA;9B7(
>>A<6>7(
J$0G0G(6\\\:>??<(
79A9\86(
86A6?7\(
3%( /D,( .&G,( ")( /D,( Q#$"Y,&%( E&$H,/2( /D,( 0%.$,&G,( [&G( GE&'',$( P,.&#G,( /D,( D01D,$( '"%1:/,$E( $,',M&%.,( ")( 43FA( 3%( /D,( .&G,( ")( W4( E&$H,/2( /D,( 0%.$,&G,( [&G( G/$"%1]( /D,( ,))0.0,%.=( ")( /D,( E&$H,/G( [&G( D0/( P=( /D,( D01D,$( $,',M&%.,( ")( 43FA( 3%( P"/D( .&G,G2( /D0G( ,M0+,%.,( .&%( ,UY'&0%( /D,( ',GG( ,))0.0,%.=( ")( /D,( &#/D"$0/0,GV( &./0"%K( ',1&'(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
B>6
/""'G(&$,(E&0%'=(P&G,+("%(Y&="))($0GH(a,A1A2(0%/,$,G/($&/,(Y"'0.0,Gb(&%+("%(0%)"$E&/0"%(&G=EE,/$0,G(a,A1A2(L3FbA(-( M,$=(+0)),$,%/(G/"$=(/""H(Y'&.,(0%(/D,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0GK(CD,(43F(',M,'G([,$,(1,%,$&''=('"[,$(/D&%(/D,('"%1:/,$E( "%,(0%(&''(/D,(E&$H,/G2(Y&$/0.#'&$'=(0%(!&Y&%(&%+(Q#$"Y,A(CD0G(.&%(D,'Y(#G(/"(#%+,$G/&%+([D=(/D,(,UY,$0,%.,(")( /D,( 6\\\:>??<( .$0G0G( [&G( R#0/,( #G,',GG( /"( .D&'',%1,( /D,( >??;:>??\( .$0G0G( a0A,A2( '&/,( +,/,./0"%2( '"[( ,))0.&.=( ")( /""'G2(&%+(D01D(."%/&10"%(,)),./G2(,/.AbA(