The Information Risks (and the Sector Rotation Puzzle) During the Financial Crisis
The Information Risks (and the Sector Rotation Puzzle) During the Financial Crisis
40E0'&$0/0,G( 0%( /D,( G/".H( /$&.H0%1( .&%( P,( )"#%+( ,M,%( &/( /D,( 0%+#G/$=( ',M,'S( Z,( .&%( #G,( +&/&( )$"E( "#$( G/&$/:#Y(+&/&P&G,(/"()0%+("#/(G"E,(,EY0$0.&'(,M0+,%.,(&P"#/(/D0G(Y$"P',EA( C&P',(6?(GD"[G(."EY#/&/0"%G($,),$$0%1(/"(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G()"$(/D,(Q#$"Y,&%(E&$H,/GA(CD,(Y&="))($0GH2(/D,( /"/&'("%,(0G($,Y"$/,+(&'"%1([0/D(C3F2(0/G($,'&/0M,([,01D/()"$(&%=(")(/D,(69(q(6(/0E,(G,$0,GA(N"$(/D,(69(0%+#G/$0,G( /D,( $,'&/0M,( [,01D/( ")( 43F( &%+( L3F( &$,( $,Y"$/,+2( [D0',( )01#$,G( a1$,,%( D01D'01D/,+b( )"$( /D,( E&$H,/( &$,( /D,( &M,$&1,(',M,'(")(/D,(0%+#G/$=(+&/&A(
C&P',(6?( TIR Composition During the Crisis in the European Market
I&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b( `&="))(
N#''(G&EY',G(
C"/&'(
C3F( (
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k( ( 43F( ( k( k
( akb(
C3F( akb( 43F L3F( L"[(!"%,G(Q#$"4/"UU(
43F( L3F( akb(
akb(
akb(
8>AB;B\ :6A?766 B;A7; ><A88 6ABB7B <A>668 :6A8<7B 88AB?B?( :6A8<7B( B9A9> >6A69 c0'(g(1&G(
6A86;B(
>A87B9( :6A?766(
8>A869\ :?AB\?9 ;;A98 <<A6; >A?7B7 <AB;6? :6AB?<7 87A>\8<( :6A8?8>( 9>A8< 6BA7B C,.D%"'"1=(
6A;6<9(
>AB9\6( :6A69<6(
8>A?\\< :6A<<;6 9?AB9 6\A>> >A>7<6 <A9B;7 :6A;><8 86A9BB<( :6A<6\9( 96A<? 69AB? -#/"E"P0',G(g(Y&$/G(
>A>;B7(
<A\>\6( :6A;786(
8;A77<9 :6A>766 B<A6B >;A9< >A\6<7 ;A?76\ :<A6<97 76A97\?( :6A7\8?( 7?AB\ 8\A>6 T&G0G($,G"#$.,G(
>A???>(
<A;B>9( :6AB?\9(
8;A;B9B :6A67;7 B6A9; >9A68 <A?<?< 7A79>\ :>A77>7 87AB>?7( :>A6>79( 9<A>9 6;AB> F,/&0'(
6A99;B(
<A88B9( :6A;?\8(
8<A?6\\ :?A9?<9 B8A7; >7A88 6AB;>; <A?\77 :6A<<<? 8<A?;?7( :?A\87<( B?A\> >\A?9 3%G#$&%.,(
6A8>88(
>A7?7B( :6A?B9?(
8<A\66; :6A>9BB 9;A66 6<A9\ >A;6;> 8A97B6 :>A>8?\ 8;A6<;B( :>A??<;( 9\A86 6?A7\ N""+(g(P,M,$&1,(
6A\><8(
<A8?78( :6A8\7<(
8>A;7<\ :?A7;<9 7\AB< 8?A>B 6A7698 >A;887 :6A6>;6 8>A79<8( :?AB889( ;;A68 <<A9; C$&M,'(&%+(',0G#$,(
6A>;7;(
>A>6>9( :?A\8<9(
88A?9;6 :6A?6B9 B>A\8 >BA?; >A?B?8 <AB77\ :6A;977 88A9B;\( :6A<<BB( B\A<; >?A;8 N0%&%.0&'(G,$M0.,G(
6ABB69(
<A6;7>( :6A<\78(
87A>988 :6A?9?B 97A6? 68A\? >A>976 8A>??9 :6A\67B 87A;?<<( :6AB;76( \>A68 BA9; `,$G"%&'(g(D"#G,D"'+(
6A7767(
>A9?8>( :6A>;\\(
1""+G( 6AB7;?(
8?A;\\? :6A?<>8 97A;8 68A<; 6AB779 <A6<7B :6A<B\\ 88A??7<( :6A><6>( 9\A>< 6?ABB *,+0&(
>A\;>>( :6A>?7;(
8>A77B7 :?A\9B< B\A?6 >?A\\ 6A7769 >AB<>\ :6A696? 8<A>679( :?A\7<7( 9?AB< 6\A>B T&%HG(
6A;B8;(
>A\<;>( :6A>8\;(
88A;B88 :6A6BB? 9\A7; 6?A88 >A;7?8 8A\B<< :>A<><? 8;AB?9>( :>A?BB>( 9\A8> 6?A79 J"%G/$#./0"%(&%+(
6A;7<6(
>A\869( :6A<68>(
E&/,$0&'G( 6A7>7\(
88A78>B :6A?<>< 97A9> 68A69 >A88?B 8A<8;\ :6A\?;> 8<A97>;( :6A;B<6( 9BABB 6>A>< 3%+#G/$0&'(1""+G(&%+(
>AB??8( :6A>?>9(
G,$M0.,G( 6A7B<7(
88AB6?> :6A6?6; 9BA7; 6>A88 >A>>B7 8A?\;9 :6A9;\< 87A;>9>( :6AB<?6( \>A77 BA87 JD,E0.&'G(
>A968?( :6A>79>(
8<A78>8 :?A\\8> 9?A7B 6\A8< 6A9B;7 <A7>98 :6A;76\ 8;A96B>( :6A87B?( 99A>? 66A9? e,&'/D(.&$,(
6A;6;?(
>A9<<9( :6A><<\(
<\A6\6? :?A76<7 8\A66 7?A9\ 6A;9;> >A\>\7 :6A>8<< 8>A8868( :?A;8>6( 76A;8 89A<; C,',."E#%0.&/0"%G(
6A;68B(
>A;;96( :6A?87B(
8>A9<>9 :6A?9>> B<A6\ >;A96 6A;8<> >AB;;; :6A6><< 8?A;?<<( :?A;B;B( ;?A>8 <\AB; W/0'0/0,G(
6A\7<?(
<A87>6( :6A8B9;(
8<A9?9> :?A9?\7 B;A;? ><A8? 6ABBB> <A<<>6 :6A778\ 8;A;;87( :6A>\>;( 9<A6< 6;A9B (
6A<;69(
>A86>7( :6A?7;\(
-%(&PG"'#/,(C3F($,+#./0"%(/""H(Y'&.,("%'=(0%(/D$,,(0%+#G/$0,GK(/,.D%"'"1=2(P&%HG2(&%+(/,',."EE#%0.&/0"%GA( CD,G,( G&E,( 0%+#G/$0,G( d"0%/'=( GD"[,+( &( $,+#./0"%( 0%( /D,( Y&="))( $0GH( a&'"%1( [0/D( /D,( *,+0&( 0%+#G/$=bA( 3%( /D,( GY,.0)0.( .&G,( ")( C,',."EE#%0.&/0"%G2( &%( 0%.$,&G,( 0%( /D,( $,'&/0M,( [,01D/( ")( L3F( .&%( P,( )"#%+A( 3/( 0G( ,M,%( 0%/,$,G/0%1(/"("PG,$M,(/D&/()0M,(0%+#G/$0,G(GD"[,+(&($,+#./0"%(0%(/D,($,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(C3F](/D$,,(")(/D,E(a0A,A2( T&G0G(F,G"#$.,G2(N""+(&%+(T,M,$&1,2(&%+(3%+#G/$0&'(O""+G(&%+(4,$M0.,Gb(&$,(%"/("M,$'&YY,+([0/D(/D,(Y$,M0"#G( /D$,,( &%+( GD"[,+( &%( 0%.$,&G,( 0%( Y&="))( $0GH( &%=[&=A( 3%( /D,( .&G,( ")( C,',."EE#%0.&/0"%2( &%( 0%.$,&G,( 0%( /D,(
B>>(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
$,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(L3F(.&%(P,("PG,$M,+2(/D,("/D,$(/D$,,(.&G,G(/&H,(Y'&.,(&'"%1([0/D(&%(0%.$,&G,(")(/D,(&PG"'#/,( ',M,'(")(C3FA(
CD,(G&E,(."EY#/&/0"%G()"$(/D,(W4(*&$H,/(&$,($,Y"$/,+(0%(C&P',(66A(669(q(6(&$,(/D,(/0E,(G,$0,G(&%&'=X,+A( 4/0''2(/D,(1$,,%(D01D'01D/,+()01#$,G()"$(/D,(E&$H,/(&$,(/D,(&M,$&1,(',M,'(")(/D,(0%+#G/$=(+&/&A(
C&P',(66( TIR Composition During the Crisis in the USA Market
I&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b( `&="))( C"/&'(
N#''(G&EY',G(
C3F( ( k(
43F(
k(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k( ( 43F( ( k(
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( 4g`(7??(
43F( L3F( akb(
akb(
akb(
6A>B<6 >A6>99( :?A9;6?( 8?A887; :?A9;6? 7BA\< 8>A?B 6AB;?< <A?89; :6A>99> 8>A>7B7( :6A>99>( ;9A<6 <6A;\ -+M,$/0G0%1( (
>A>87; <A\<?7( :6A;99?( 8>A\8B\ :6A>6>< B6A9> >9A69 >A696< <A\9B< :6A9?;? 87A>\<>( :6A>\B7( B6A97 >9A67 -,$"GY&.,(g(+,),%G,(
6A7?6B >A;<9<( :6A6877( 8<A8696 :?A9?B? B?A87 >\A77 6AB76< <A>B6\ :6A7>?7 8;A8B<<( :6A<?;<( 97A\6 68A?\ -1$0.#'/#$&'(Y$"+#./G(
>A<<9? <A\B89( :6A;>\9( 86A??>6 :?A7B67 <7A?B ;8A\< <A66;B 7A<<<9 :>A>6B> 86A7;BB( :6A?7<7( 8BA7> 7>A89 -0$()$,01D/(g(."#$0,$G(G0(
>A68<8 <A;;67( :6A7688( 86A<;?? :?A\68B ;?A8? <\A;? >A?987 <A;?7B :6A7>6> 8>A69BB( :6A6<?>( B8A<? >7AB? -0$'0%,G(G0(
>A7699 8A>;\9( :6ABB?B( 86A8B?> :6A?>89 7BA99 8>A6> >A\7?8 7A?B87 :>A6>86 86A9796( :?A\6>B( 8>A\B 7BA?< -'#E0%#E(
>A;7?; 8A;?\<( :6A\\78( 8<A>\6? :6A68<> 7BA>\ 8>AB6 8A6>?B BAB<<7 :<A;6>\ 8;AB6;9( :>A9;6?( B\A6\ >?A96 -YY&$,'(g(&..,GG"$0,G(
6A\>;B <A<>B<( :6A869>( 8>A;><9 :?A9B88 ;6A;; <9A<8 <A6?>> 7A7?66 :>A<\9\ 8<A;?96( :6AB<9>( B>A8; >BA78 -YY&$,'($,/&0'(
>A7?<8 8A>\8\( :6ABB;;( 86A<;;8 :6A?<B7 79A8? 86A;? >A7B8> 8A<B9? :6A9?<9 86A>?>6( :6A<\<\( BBA>B >>AB< -YY'0.&/0"%(G")/[&$,(
<A8?6B 7A9\;6( :>A88\<( 86A78?\ :6A>;86 76A;6 89A<\ >A<868 8A?<88 :6A;\<? 86A\;8\( :6A<\96( 9>A79 6BA8> -#/"(Y&$/G(g(,R#0Y(
6A\?B6 <A<\;8( :6A78?9( 87A<;;; :6A??6\ ;7A?< <8A\B <A<>?? ;A6<<6 :>A96<6 87A9;B8( :6A\;B>( ;\A\< <?A?B -#/"E"P0',(E&%#)&./#$,$G(
>AB6\9 8A9<B\( :>A68B8( 88A<9;8 :6A>B7< 7\A<\ 8?A;6 8A;88; \A;B\; :7A?<7? 7>A?6;7( :<A?>8>( ;?A?; <\A\8 L0M(P&%HG(
>A?BB9 <A7;?<( :6A7?B\( 8>A<7>7 :6A?67< ;BA<8 <>A;; <A\96; BA8B?6 :<A8997 8;A;\\<( :>A699;( ;>AB8 <BA>; T0"/,.D%"'"1=(
>A7\;7 8A<?7?( :6A;BB7( <9A\;77 :?A;>9< <BA8; ;>A78 6A98>; <A><87 :6A<\69 8<A?<6>( :?A;67?( 88A6\ 77A96 T$,[,$G(
6A7?99 >A8B?>( :?A\;67( <9A\>7> :?A<>B8 <8A?7 ;7A\7 6A7\8\ <A?9>8 :6A89B7 89A>79>( :?A7\;>( 8?A?9 7\A\> T$"&+.&G/0%1(g(.&P',(C@(
>A<<8; <A\\>\( :6AB778( 8<A\;<> :6A><>7 B?A>6 >\AB\ >A\?7B ;A7B>; :<A;;;\ 77AB\?9( :>A9;9<( B9A>> >6AB9 T#0'+0%1(Y$"+#./G(
>A6B78 <A969;( :6AB679( 88A\<<B :6A?8;; ;6A?? <\A?? <A?9>? ;A8\B\ :<A867\ 7>A7;\;( :>A><>8( ;7A<7 <8A;7 J&G0%"G(g(1&E0%1(
>A\?B; 7A?9\>( :>A>686( 8<A7?7B :6A?7>; 8BA78 7>A8; <A?9<\ ;A?B9; :>A\\8B 8\A>;7\( :>A6867( B6A76 >9A8\ J"EE,$.0&'(Y$0%/0%1(
6A9<?8 <A<86;( :6A778<( 8;A76>< :?A\?\9 79A78 86A8; >A;<\\ 7A7B\< :>A\<\8 7>A;98;( :>A<B<>( 9?AB< 6\A>B J"EY#/,$(g(,',./$($,/&0'(
<A?;86 7A<BB>( :>A>99?( 8>A78\9 :6A<7;; 7\A>\ 8?AB6 >A\;>; 7A698> :>A>>6; 8>A978?( :6A7<>9( ;\A?? <6A?? J"EY#/,$(D[&$,(
>A6B<7 <AB;8<( :6A7;\6( 86A;9<> :6A?;;< ;BA\; <>A?8 >A?\<6 <A;B67 :6A7B98 8>A\9\9( :6A>67<( BBA?? ><A?? J"EY(G/"$&1,(g(Y,$0YD,$&'G( <A8\<9 7A98;7( :>A>9\8( <\A67\< :6A8<\\ ;>A9\ <BA66 >A779< 8A7?>9 :6A\887 8<A698>( :6A889B( B8A7? >7A7? J"%G/$#./0"%(g(,%10%,,$0%1( >A7B96 8A77>;( :6A\98;( 8<A7\69 :6A?89\ 7>A97 8BA67 <AB8?; ;A;7<; :>A\6<6 8<AB96B( :>A?9>8( B6A8\ >9A76 J"%G/$#./0"%(g()&$E(E&.D0%,( >A6;6> <AB<<B( :6A;?<7( 8>A\8;\ :6A?;6; ;;A>6 <<AB\ <A??7; 7A76>; :>A7?B? 87A8BB;( :>A6;7>( 9;A<; 6<A;8 J"%G/$#./0"%(E&/,$0&'G(
>A7<9> 8A8B;9( :6A\9?>( 88A><<> :6A>667 ;6A69 <9A9> <A7687 ;A7<79 :<A?>6< 8;A>>;B( :6A99B8( ;>A8B <BA7< L,Y&$/E,%/(G/"$,G(
>A6??9 <A;67>( :6A7<>B( 8>A<\;7 :?A\\<9 ;8A98 <7A6; <A6;7? 7A9\;\ :>AB<69 8;A<>;\( :>A??>B( B<A<6 >;A;\ L0G/$0P#/"$G(
6A7996 >ABBBB( :6A>6?B( 8<A79B< :?AB77? ;>A<; <BA;8 >A??8\ <A79>; :6A7BBB 88A?<9\( :6A?<88( ;7A7; <8A88 L0M,$G0)0,+(.D,E0.&'G(
6A9<76 <A69<8( :6A<BB;( 8<A>B78 :?A\68\ ;;A86 <<A7\ >A>77? 8A>8B< :6A\\>> 8;A\?;B( :6A;>7\( 96A;6 69A<\ L0M(."EE(g(Y$")(G,$M(
6AB68B <A?688( :6A<66\( 8<A7>?? :?A9797 ;7A88 <8A7; 6A7>B< >A;??\ :6A>;<7 89A7B98( :?A\>68( B>A\< >BA?B L0M()0%GMG(
>A7\98 8A769<( :6A\>76( 8>A;?;B :6A<<B8 ;\A8B <?A7< 8A?77? BA78?; :<A897; 8;A>>8B( :>A76>>( B>A?B >BA\< L0M,$G0)0,+(E,/&'G(g(E0%0%1( >AB;7B 8A976B( :>A6<>B( 8<A\7;9 :6A6?\9 7>A?8 8BA\; 8A7699 9A>6?6 :<A;\6< 88A\;?7( :>A7;?<( ;\A<; <?A;8 L$#1($,/&0'(
6A9968 <A6;76( :6A>BB8( 8?A<7\> :?A79B8 87A\9 78A?> >A?\9? <A8B6> :6A<B<< <\A7;67( :?A98\;( ;6A9B <9A6< Q',./$0.(#/0'0/0,G(
6A>B\? >A>9?9( :6A??8<( 88A?<>8 :?A<\BB <\A;? ;?A8? 6AB>6; <A?8?9 :6A<6\> 8<A<9>7( :?A979B( ;7A?\ <8A\6 Q',./$0.&'(."EY(g(,R#0Y(
6AB7?9 >A\B6>( :6A><99( 86A;\76 :?A\?\7 B<A8> >;A79 >A<8>6 8A?;\B :6AB>B; 8>A88\9( :6A8??<( 96A?; 69A\8 Q',.(,R(E&%#)A(
>A7B7; 8A7?69( :6A\6B<( 8>A79\? :6A><\; ;8A;; <7A<8 >A8<96 8A87<; :>A?677 87A>77>( :6A<9\;( ;9A\8 <6A?; eF(g(,EY'"=E,%/(G,$M(
<A?;?> 7A<?<9( :>A>;;?( 8>AB><6 :6A;6B< B6A<B >9A;< <A6<B; 7A8>6> :>A>9<; 8>A6><<( :6A;;<;( B>A97 >BA67 Q%M$(g()&.0'0/0,G(G,$M(
>A6>>B <ABB>\( :6A;<;>( 8<A<;;\ :?AB868 87A<6 78A;\ >A?\>; <A8;67 :6A<;9\ <\A78;B( :?A9;6?( ;>A9\ <BA66 N,$/0'0G,$(g(&1$0(.D,E0.&'G(
:6A76;>( ;<AB6 <;A>\ N""+(+0G/$0P#/"$G(
>A9?\8 8AB?<B( :6A9889( <\A>>6< :6A?;<6 7BA;> 8>A<9 <A7;9< 7A\89< :>A<9?6 8?A?6>7(
6A;B>B >A\66?( :6A><8B( 8>A8676 :?A7;>; 87A7B 78A8< 6A\7>? <A7>?; :6A7;9; 88A778;( :6A?6;;( ;8A96 <7A6\
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
B><
aC&P',(66(."%/0%#,+b(
I&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b( `&="))(
N#''(G&EY',G(
C"/&'(
C3F( ( k(
43F(
k(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k( ( 43F( ( k(
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( N""+($,/&0'(
43F( L3F( akb(
akb(
akb(
6AB<>>( >A\\98( :6A>;>;( 8>A6?\6 :?A7\\B 8BA7? 7>A7? >A?;<7 <A<>69 :6A>798 <BA9969( :?AB;7<( ;?A9> <\A69 N""/[,&$(
>A<?7?( 8A?<\6( :6AB>;\( 8>AB7<8 :?AB7\B 88A?? 7;A?? >A8\87 8A<\<B :6A9\\> 8<A>>7?( :6A>677( ;8A?? <;A?? N"$,G/(Y$"+#./G(
>A<997( 8A?89?( :6A;99?( 86A;\\6 :?A\;<6 7BA?7 8>A\7 <A>B79 7A\\99 :>AB><? 87A<\>7( :6AB98<( ;7A7> <8A89 O&G(#/0'0/0,G(
6A;88B( >A99\8( :6A>B?<( 8<A\;86 :?AB7B\ 7\A;; 8?A<8 >A;7\8 8A\8?> :>A>9?\ 8;A6;\6( :6A;<\7( B6A99 >9A6> O,%,$&'(E,$.D(G/"$,G(
>A6;\\( <A;<99( :6A87\\( 8?A6>69 :?A9B8B 7\A\6 8?A?\ >A\6\? 8A\?89 :6A\979 8?A89;6( :6A<B79( ;\A>\ <?AB6 O"'+(
>A\>?6( 8A\\<?( :>A?B;8( 86A79B8 :?A<9B7 69A;; 96A<8 <A8;>6 ;A6;7< :>AB?<< 8<A98;<( :6A6<7<( 8>A?? 79A?? eh.&$,(+0G/(
>A669B( <AB;;>( :6A;>B\( 8<A>>>6 :?A;B\\ 86ABB 79A>< 6A9>8> <A<6\\ :6A8\7B 87A?7>;( :?A9698( 78AB> 87A>9 e,&'/D(.&$,(,R#0Y(
6A;<\9( >AB\;\( :6A6896( 86A?7?9 :?AB68\ ;>A>B <BAB< 6A77>; >AB99; :6A><;? 88A<>>;( :?A\<?\( B7A<6 >8A;\ e,&'/D(.&$,()&.0'0/0,G(
>A867;( 8A8<89( :>A6699( 8BABB;< :?AB\>\ <BA8> ;>A79 <A;67B 9A77?> :8A\<87 7BAB6><( :6A\\77( 8?A88 7\A7; e,&'/D(.&$,(G#YY'0,G(
6A\66;( <AB<6;( :6A9>88( 89A9\?\ :?AB<69 8?A66 7\A9\ 6A;><< 7A6796 :<A7<89 ;9A7>\;( :6A<69>( <BA>\ ;>AB6 e"E,()#$%0GD0%1G(
>A6<B>( <A9\?;( :6AB;B>( 87A8>6; :?A\66< 76A7B 89A8< >A9?86 7A?\\? :>A>\8\ 87A??;9( :6A<;\<( 7\A;B 8?A<< e"E,(0EY$"M,($,/&0'(
>A8>76( 8A6><>( :6A;9B;( 8?A\>9; :6A?;89 ;<A6? <;A\? >A97\> 8A98\9 :6A\\?; 86A?87>( :6A<;<6( ;9A89 <6A7> e"E,P#0'+0%1(
<A??78( 7A6999( :>A>?8<( 8>A8969 :6A<>9; ;?A>B <\AB< 7A8>86 \A<B;6 :<A\76\ 8>A68\?( :>A8;?;( ;>A>; <BAB8 e"/,'G(
>A>;><( <A\<<9( :6A;\89( 8<A?9<; :6A67;> ;9A>> <6AB9 <A?<96 7A78\< :>A766> 87A>7>6( :6A\?>?( B7AB8 >8A>; e"#G,D"'+(&YY'0&%.,G(
6A999B( <A<B99( :6A7>6>( 87A?>?\ :6A?8B; ;9A9; <6A68 >A;779 7A?>>9 :>A<;B? 8BA6>87( :6AB897( B<A9B >;A6< e"#G,D"'+(Y$"+#./G(
6A88;9( >A8<>B( :?A\9?B( 8?A<67B :?A<\8B 8?A>8 7\AB; 6A<6B\ >A<?9B :?A\\?9 8>A\67\( :?A7>6<( 7>A;> 8BA<9 e"#G,([&$,G(g(GY,.0&'/0,G( 6A;786(
>A\7\9( :6A<<88( 87A?9<7 :?A9B?9 ;7A>; <8AB8 >A<>\6 8A9696 :>A89\6 76A;;?;( :6A9<><( B<A;6 >;A<\ 3%+#G/$0&'(."%1'"E,$&/,G(
6AB\6?( <A?;77( :6A<?>?( 8>A8B>7 :6A?886 9?A6\ 6\A96 >A>;\\ 8A89B7 :>A>6B; 8\A86;9( :6AB?B;( BBA?? ><A?? 3%+#G/$0&'(1&G,G(
>A???6( <A8>7<( :6A86\;( 86A88<\ :?A98?8 7\A>? 8?A9? >A<9\B 8A69\8 :6AB\\B 8>A\79\( :6A8>B?( B\A>\ >?AB6 3%+#G/$0&'(E&.D0%,$=(
6A;<B7( >A96BB( :6A6\96( 8>A7>6? :?A9\>\ B8A7> >7A89 >A668; <AB<87 :6A;6\\ 8<A<B;8( :6A8<>?( 99A8? 66A;? 3%G#$&%.,(P$"H,$G(
6AB\69( <A>8>\( :6A88>>( 88A8B>B :?A9;77 ;?A?6 <\A\\ 6A9\;< <A69B; :6A>\6< 8?A7?\\( :?AB6?6( 78A\\ 87A?6 3%/,1$&/,+("0'(g(1&G(
6A;6>B( >A;;;9( :6A?7;>( <\A;?7< :?A79?; 78A\B 87A?< >A>9?? <A9?<6 :6A7><6 8?A?8\6( :6A>8>;( 96A79 69A8> 3%/,1$&/,+(/,',."E(G,$M(
6A;8>7( >A9?6?( :6A67;6( 86A>B<? :?A;9?8 79A9; 86A68 >A?77B <A86<< :6A<7B7 <\ABB>7( :?A\7?7( B?A?> >\A\9 3%/,$%,/($,/&0'(
>A\9;<( 7A<\6?( :>A887\( 87A<B?> :6A><76 7?A7? 8\A7? <A7>79 ;A6<;< :>A;6?8 8>A7866( :6A8B<<( 7;A88 8<A7; 3%/,$%,/(G")/[&$,(g(G,$M(
<AB\68( ;A;><B( :>AB>9<( 86A69\\ :6AB>B< ;<A<6 <;A;\ >A8;?> 8A>>\8 :6AB;\> 86A9<?<( :6A>8>;( B?A>< >\ABB 3C(."%G(g("hGMG(
>AB997( 8A\778( :>A6;6?( 8<A;?9> :6A6;77 7<A\< 8;A?B <A8B\8 ;A?9<6 :>A;?<B 8>A9?>;( :6A9B;>( B>A?; >BA\8 I,0G#$,(Y$"+#./G(
6A\<B7( <A86;>( :6A8\?;( 8<A;<>\ :?AB9\; 7>A\B 8BA?< >A>\\? 8A<<<B :>A?<8B 8;A\76<( :6A>>?<( 7\A\B 8?A?< I0),(g(D,&'/D(0%G(
6A99<<( <A<6B7( :6A8B;;( 88A7?9; :6A6>B\ B;A<\ ><A;6 <A888> ;AB96> :<A<<B? 8\A>?\9( :>A\<>>( 9BA9B 6>A6< *&%&1,+(D,&'/D(.&$,(
>A8<>;( 8A<BB;( :6A\8B\( 88A8\B6 :?AB\88 8?AB\ 7\A>6 >A;?B? 7A6\\B :>A7\>; 8\A9;6;( :6A78<6( 7\A7> 8?A89 *,/&'(g(1'&GG(."%/(
6A\9?6( <A8B66( :6A7?69( 8<A>;;; :?A9?;< 7<A;\ 8;A<6 >A<<;; 8A689B :6A96>6 8<A;B97( :6A8?B>( BBA;; >>A<8 *"/"$.=.',(E&%#)&./#$,$G( >A9>B;(
8A\B79( :>A>??\( 88A><69 :6A76>< ;9AB6 <6A>\ <A;B9; BA6?6> :<A8>>7 89A6\;\( :>A;;<B( BBA9< >>A6B *"M0,G(g(,%/,$/&0%E,%/(
>A?\7>( <A7>8;( :6A8<B9( 8?AB\8\ :6A?\?; B7A97 >8A67 >A?\B7 <A\B;? :6A9B97 8BA>87B( :6A;;?7( 99A<\ 66A;6 *#'/0:'0%,(0%G#$&%.,(
>A>;><( <A\;;;( :6AB88;( 8<A\9?B :6A>689 ;\A;< <?A<B <AB8\\ BA869\ :<A;;\? 8\A877?( :>A;88>( B>A?B >BA\< *#'/0(#/0'0/0,G(
>A<?>?( 8A6B;B( :6A968;( 8<A88;B :6A6\B> ;7A\9 <8A?> 6A7>>> >AB;68 :6A><\> 88A9B;;( :?A99<\( B6A<> >9A;9 c))0.,(,',./$"%0.G(
<A69\>( 7A;9;>( :>A8\B<( 8<A\69? :6A7<>6 ;6A<7 <9A;7 >AB>?< 7A877B :>AB<7< 7?A6<B8( :>A6<\8( B9A>6 >6AB\ c))0.,(G,$M(g(G#YY'0,G(
6A;;>6( >A9B;?( :6A><B6( 8<A?68? :?AB\>\ ;8A?\ <7A\6 6A\6<B <A9;67 :6A\8B9 7?A886>( :6A8\6B( B;A7\ ><A86 c0'(g(1&G(+$0''0%1(
<A66<<( 7A>>89( :>A66<6( 8?A88<8 :?A\<?; 88A?8 77A\; <A8686 7AB696 :>A<?8? 8?A>\>8( :6AB?87( B<A\9 >;A?> c0'(g(1&G(,R#0Y(g(G,$M(
>A;;??( 8A8?8?( :6AB7\>( <\A\878 :?A9;>8 8\A?> 7?A\9 <A<;6\ 7AB?\7 :>A<8BB 86A669>( :6AB;6\( B7A?7 >8A\7 c0'(g(1&G(,UY'"$(g(Y$"+(
>A<B<?( <A\B86( :6A;698( 8?AB>8? :?AB7<? 8;A7< 7<A8B <A66?\ 7A88;< :>A<<78 8>A99?8( :6ABB;6( B;A?7 ><A\7 c0'(g(1&G($,)0%1(g(E&$H(
>A<?>;( 8A??><( :6AB<?B( 8<A>8<B :?A\9;7 7BA?? 8<A?? <A;??\ ;A>>79 :>A;>7? 8>A6;><( :6A9;<;( B?A\\ >\A?6 `&.H&1,+()""+G(
6A6;6?( >A??><( :?A9<76( 86AB?9< :?A<\99 8BAB7 7>A>7 6A>;B> >A>;67 :?A\\8< 8<A\;78( :?AB>\;( B<A<9 >;A;> `&Y,$(Y&.H&10%1(
6A\898( <A8768( :6A7?9\( 8<AB696 :?A9;\8 7BA;6 8>A<\ >A<??> 8A>>?< :6A\>?6 87A8\;B( :6A68<8( 7\A77 8?A87 `&Y,$(Y$"+#./G(
>A6>?>( <AB;B\( :6A;97\( 88AB8>< :6A?77; ;>A;> <BA<9 >A9B<6 7A\\\< :<A6>;> 7>A6?\9( :>A6\9>( B?A<> >\A;9 `,$G"%&'(Y$"+#./G(
6A96;B( <A679<( :6A<7>9( 8>A9<<; :?A;?;B 88A97 77A67 >A>;86 8A878\ :>A6\?9 8\A6BB\( :6A8B;>( ;BA<9 <>A;> `D&$E&.,#/0.&'G(
6A77\9( >A;77<( :6A?96<( 8?AB>>7 :?A;??6 77A7? 88A7? 6A8\69 >A7\;B :6A6?8\ 8>A78\;( :?AB><B( ;7A7? <8A7? `D"/"1$&YD0.(Y$"+#./G(
>A79B;( 8A;\6?( :>A>>66( 8BA<896 :?A\>\\ 86A9B 79A6< <A;B76 BA8?;7 :<AB<68 7?A<B\B( :6A;;>B( 88A7; 77A88
B>8(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
aC&P',(66(."%/0%#,+b(
I&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b( `&="))( C"/&'(
N#''(G&EY',G(
C3F( ( k(
43F(
k(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k( ( 43F( ( k(
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( `$"Y,$/=(g(.&G#&'/=(0%G#$(
43F( L3F( akb(
akb(
akb(
6A;B\6 >A\<B<( :6A>7\;( 8>A99>> :?A9?;8 ;8A?> <7A\9 >A8<;9 8A6<66 :6A;\8< 86A?6<6( :6A<B>B( 96A?> 69A\9 `#P'0GD0%1(g(Y$0%/0%1(
6A7??7 >A77>7( :6A?\\6( 8<A?7\> :?A9?B6 B<A88 >;A7; >A887B 8A;BB< :>A><6; 8BAB66?( :6AB\8;( 9?A8> 6\A79 F&0'$"&+G(
6A9\6\ <A68B8( :6A>9B8( 8?A\?8? :?AB9>; ;?AB\ <\A>6 >AB6\7 8A7\B> :6A9BB9 8?A9879( :6A8>98( B;A?B ><A\< F,&'(,G/&/,(0%MG/(/$#G/G(
>A6\68 <AB\>8( :6A;>68( 8>AB7<8 :6A66;6 ;9A98 <6A6; <A87?< 7A99\> :>A8<99 86A86><( :6A99?\( BBA6> >>A99 F,G/&#$&%/G(
6AB<;> >A\>9<( :6A69>6( 8?A<;9; :?A;\9? 7\A?7 8?A\7 6A97>? <A?7B6 :6A>?76 <\A8>?>( :?A\<>;( BBA<9 >>A;> 4")/(+$0%HG(
6A7;6< >A;9<9( :6A668>( 86A76;> :?A7>\< 8BA7? 7>A7? 6A8?<\ >A779> :6A678< 87A6>69( :?A;;9B( 7BA\< 8>A?B 4Y,.0&'/=(.D,E0.&'G(
6A7?<; >A;B;<( :6A6B>8( 8<A9?97 :?AB>>\ ;6A;; <9A<8 6A9<\6 <A>B\\ :6A88?9 8<A\>97( :?A9\7<( ;>A68 <BA9; 4Y,.0&'/=(G/"$,G(
>A679< <A;9\<( :6A7<8B( 86A7\\6 :6A?6<9 ;;A?; <<A\8 <A?8B\ 7A6\>\ :>A688\ 86A<?7;( :6A;?<;( B8AB; >7A>8 4/,,'(:Y$0.,(0%+,U(
>A;688 8A7<<;( :6A\<\;( 8>AB9>B :6A>?>9 ;>A?6 <BA\\ 8A6??> BA?;87 :>A\;8< 86A\;?7( :>A8?9?( 96A>< 69ABB 4=G/,EG(G")/[&$,(
>A>966 <A9><?( :6A7>>;( <\A9>B\ :?A\B<? ;<A\? <;A6? >A6877 <A;8>8 :6A8\;\ 86A?\;9( :?A\98?( ;7AB8 <8A>; C0$,G(g($#PP,$(
>A9>\7 7A?77>( :>A>B;7( 87A?<6\ :6A8?89 ;6AB6 <9A>\ 8AB;<? 9A\B96 :8A>676 8;A\89\( :>A\89<( ;\A\7 <?A?7 C"P&.."(
6A\;7? <A78<6( :6A7799( 8<A\\76 :?A7<6\ <8A6> ;7A99 6A;7>; >A\66\ :6A>7\8 8<A>8\?( :?AB7?8( 7\A7\ 8?A86 C$&+0%1(."EY(g(+0G/$0P#/"$G( 6A9B69 <A<BB>( :6A7?;7( 88A;?;B :?A\;<6 ;<A\< <;A?B >A7?9? 8A>9\9 :6AB96\ 86A7<;9( :6A<\9<( B9A8B >6A7< Z0$,',GG(/,',."E(G,$M(
<A6688 7A<B69( :>A><\9( 86A;\;< :6A6;>7 76A\? 89A6? <A>>>B ;A?>8? :>A9?6< 8;A7?>6( :6AB\6\( ;<A\B <;A?< e=Y(EH/G(g(G#Y(.%/(
6A7>B8 >A77?\( :?A\99>( <9AB<9B :?A8<\? 88A8> 77A79 6A\86B >A\9<9 :6A?8>6 <8A\>88( :?A7;78( 78A>; 87AB8 eh.(G,$M0.,G(
6A;<\; >A9697( :6A67B6( 86A?7<\ :?A7;;\ 8\A?? 76A?? 6A\988 <A86;7 :6A8<>6 86A\6B7( :?A\?7;( ;<A>< <;ABB F,10"%&'(P%HG(
>A8\6; 8A66;?( :6A;;<B( 8?A8>6? :?A\>;? 77A;; 88A<8 <A978< ;A\869 :<A?9B7 88A8B;9( :6ABB>>( 7BA8? 8>A;? CD$)/GhE1,()0%(
>A;9>9 8AB67B( :6A\<<>( 8?A\\77 :?A\B89 7?A8< 8\A7B 8A8>\> BAB9;? :<A<7;\ 8<A6686( :6A;79?( 8\A<\ 7?A;6 4Y,.()0%&%.,(
>A<96> 8A?888( :6A;79;( 86A?6?6 :6A?88; ;>A\9 <BA?> <A7>>< ;A?769 :>A7>\; 86AB\9?( :6A;\B7( ;BA66 <>A9\ J"%G()0%&%.,(
>A888; 8A>?B7( :6AB9\9( 8>A7<98 :6A<<<\ B8A7< >7A8B <A7?>B ;A;?B7 :<A6?8\ 8;A\9\B( :>A<966( B;A;\ ><A<6 -GG(E1/(g(.#G/(P%H(
>A<667 <AB<?B( :6A86;?( <BA\78\ :6A6897 96A66 69A9\ <A<?>8 7A88\9 :>A68B8 <\A8?>B( :6A968;( 98A7? 67A7? 3%M(P%H(g(P$"H(
>A9>B9 8A;>B9( :6AB87?( <BAB?B; :6A>B<6 B>A\; >BA?8 8A<B76 BA686B :>AB;;; <9AB<\6( :>A??6\( B>A<; >BA;8 L&/&(Y$"(g("#/(GMG(
6A88\; >A88?>( :?A\\\;( 8?A\;86 :?AB9\? B9A\< >6A?B 6AB;\9 <A6<;7 :6A<;;B 8<A7B<9( :6A6B9<( 9;A>> 6<AB9 eE(,%/(Gh[&$,(
>A9B<7 8A9?76( :6A\>B\( 8?A6>>? :?A9<8> 8<A>B 7;AB< <A<7B> 7A867\ :>A?799 <9A?6<?( :6A?79B( 76A8> 89A79 J"EEA(,R#0YE,%/(
>A;;76 8A;>B?( :6A\<7<( 86A9>77 :6A>787 ;8A9> <7A69 >A<>?> <A968; :6A8\8< <\A6B8;( :6A6\B8( 9?A6< 6\A9B Q',.(E&%#(GMG(
>A789> 8A<B<\( :6A99>;( 8<A?86> :6A8<>B B;A66 ><A9\ >A;?;7 7A?B?7 :>A8;8? 89A7\8\( :6A9\67( B;AB; ><A>8 4h."%(,R#0YE,%/(
<A99BB ;A8?6>( :>A879>( <9A8?>; :6A766\ ;6A76 <9A8\ >A\<7\ 8A9<;B :6A\??9 <\A>\99( :6A>B<7( ;BA?? <<A?? 4,E0."%+#./"$G(
>A\<B\ 8A\?99( :6A\87<( <\A;>9\ :6A6;7\ 7\A\< 8?A?B >A7;6< 8A>B9? :6AB6;B 8?A6>9\( :6A>;B9( B<A97 >;A67 c0'(g(1&G(G/"$&1,(g(/$&%GY(
>A8?9< 8A<67>( :6A\8;B( 87A66>B :6A8BB; B7A\? >8A6? >A89;> 8AB?\; :>A>><8 8BA>6?<( :6A9B;?( 98A<9 67A;> Q+#.&/0"%(G,$M0.,G(G0(
<A6B78 ;A???8( :>AB<B;( 87A;><9 :?A7B;; >6A?; B9A\8 <A;9\; ;A77B> :>A9;B; 8<AB<>?( :?A8;<9( 6;A6B 9<A9< 4Y'A(."%GA(G,$M0.,G(G0(
>A7?\7 8A8B9;( :6A\<6;( 8<A6<?? :6A?6<; 7>A8B 8BA7< >A978\ 7A?<<8 :>A6B97 8<A>9?<( :6A<>\7( ;6A?< <9A\B -#/"E"/0M,($,/&0'(G0(
6A\9?? <A;7>;( :6A;8;B( 87A?9>> :6A?;;B ;8AB9 <7A>> >A8?<9 8A<B?? :6A\;;> 88A\\<>( :6A<>;;( ;BA8B <>A7< e"E,()#$%0GD($,/&0'(G0(
>A;<76 8A;?;7( :6A\;69( 8>A799< :6A?\B9 77A\; 88A?8 >A9\86 7A?\?\ :>A6\;\ 8<A67>7( :6A<<8\( ;?AB; <\A>8 3%+A(Y"[,$(Y$"+(g(,%,$1=(/$( >A>7\7 8A>6?<( :>A?>B9( 89A6;6; :6A?9>7 7<A<9 8;A;> >A86B? 8A\6\> :>A7?>> 7?A9;7\( :6A8>9\( 7BA66 8>A9\
3%(/D,(W4-(E&$H,/2(&($,+#./0"%(0%(/D,(&PG"'#/,(',M,'(")(C3F(.&%(P,($,Y"$/,+(0%(6;(0%+#G/$0,GK(-YY'0.&/0"%( 4")/[&$,2( T0"/,.D%"'"10,G2( J"EY#/,$( &%+( Q',./$0.&'( F,/&0'2( J"EY#/,$( 4/"$&1,( &%+( `,$0YD,$&'G2( L0MA( J"EEA( &%+( `$"),GG0"%&'( 4,$M0.,G2( Q%M0$"%E,%/( &%+( N&.0'0/=( 4,$M0.,2( N""+( F,/&0'2( e,&'/D.&$,( L0G/$0P#/0"%2( 3%G#$&%.,( T$"H,$G2(3%/,$%,/(4")/[&$,(&%+(4,$M0.,G2(*#'/0:#/0'0/0,G2(4=G/,EG(4")/[&$,2(C"P&.."2(J"EE,$.0&'(QR#0YE,%/G2( 4,E0:J"%+#./"$(QR#0YE,%/G2(&%+(4,E0."%+#./"$GA(CD,($,+#./0"%(")(/D,($,'&/0M,(',M,'(")(C3F(/"(/D,(/"/&'(/&H,( Y'&.,(0%(>B(0%+#G/$0,G(P#/("%'=()0M,(.&G,G([,$,("M,$'&YY,+([0/D(/D,(Y$,M0"#G(6;(a0A,A2(Q%M0$"%E,%/(&%+(N&.0'0/=( 4,$M0.,2(N""+(F,/&0'2(3%G#$&%.,(T$"H,$G2(C"P&.."2(&%+(J"EE,$.0&'(QR#0YE,%/GbA(c%'=(,01D/(0%+#G/$0,G(GD"[,+( &%(0%.$,&G,(0%(/D,($,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(L3F]("%'=(3%G#$&%.,(T$"H,$G(0G(0%.'#+,+(0%(/D,('&/,G/('0G/A(3%(>8(0%+#G/$0,G2(&( $,+#./0"%(0%(Y&="))($0GH(+#$0%1(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G([&G("PG,$M,+A(N"#$/,,%(.&G,G(&$,("M,$'&YY,+([0/D(&($,+#./0"%(0%(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
B>7
&PG"'#/,(C3F2([D0',(/D$,,(&$,(/D,("M,$'&YG([0/D(&($,+#./0"%(0%($,'&/0M,([,01D/A( c#$( ."%.'#G0"%( 0G( G0EY',K( 5"( .',&$( "M,$'&YG( .&%( P,( )"#%+( [0/D( Q#$"Y,( ,U.,Y/( /D,( .&G,( )"$( /D,( ^/,.D%"'"1=_(.&G,A( N0%&''=2(C&P',(6>(0G($,Y"$/0%1(+&/&(."EY#/,+()"$(/D,(!&Y&%,G,(E&$H,/(+#$0%1(/D,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(Y,$0"+A(
C&P',(6>( TIR Composition During the Crisis in the Japanese Market
I&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b( `&="))(
N#''(G&EY',G(
kk (
C"/&'(
C3F( (
43F(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k ( 43F( (
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( Cc`3l(
43F( L3F akb(
akb(
akb(
8>A>9\7 :6A6;\9 B<AB< >;A>B >A?86B <A7B>> :6A7<?; 8>A98;6( :6A7<?;( BBA;\ >>A<6 N0GD,$0,G(
6A7\6?(
>AB;;6( :6A6;\9(
8>A\77? :?A9\?\ ;7AB< <8A>B >A?68? <A799; :6A7B8; 8<A9B9\( :6A>>B9( BBA\B >>A?< *0%0%1(
6ABBB?(
<A677<( :6A<778(
88A<<77 :6A6?6? 7\A?? 86A?? <A<\<7 7A\69B :>A7>7> 8>A;;76( :6AB;><( ;\AB\ <?A>6 J"%G/$#./0"%(
>A<8\>(
8A>?9\( :6A9;;?(
8;AB;66 :6A68;> B<A?< >;A\B >A8><9 8A>><6 :6AB\\> 8>A;?7?( :6A779?( 9;A7\ 6<A86 N""+G(
6AB976(
<A<7;7( :6A7;\;(
8>A86?6 :?A;\<; B7A97 >8A67 6A;?>B >A97>6 :6A>8\8 8<A9?7>( :?A\8B?( B7A9? >8A>? C,U/0',G(
6A><B>(
>A67;?( :?A\688(
88A69>< :6A?>B8 B\A?< >?A\B >A?B>9 <A;9<9 :6A;66? 8<AB<>;( :6A<7\;( 98A<\ 67A;6 `#'Y(g(Y&Y,$(
6A;76>(
>A\8>;( :6A<??6(
8<A9876 :?A\7?> ;6A\? <9A6? >A68>9 <A\7?> :6A9?B8 87AB786( :6A><6;( ;9A67 <6A97 c0'(g(."&'(Y$"+G(
6A\76>(
<A7??\( :6A7<7?(
8>A669\ :?A\;?\ ;<AB< <;A>B >A7<\B 8A;7?? :>A66?8 87A<9<\( :6A;<<B( BBA86 >>A7\ F#PP,$(Y$"+#./G(
>A?B?9(
<A79??( :6A7?B9(
8?A9B;B :?A\78; ;<AB? <;A<? >A\<8; 8A\6;7 :6A\96\ 8?A<6?;( :6A<B>B( ;\A>; <?AB8 O'&GG(g(.,$&E0.G(
>A6;\?(
<A;;;6( :6A8\9;(
8<A6<66 :6A>?9> 96A7; 69A88 >AB>>8 8ABBB< :>A?78\ 8<A?6<9( :6A9B\<( \6A87 9A77 3$"%(g(G/,,'(
6A\;8<(
<A8<8B( :6A8968(
88A9>67 :6A<7?? B<A8> >;A79 <A69;\ 7A99\B :>AB?>9 87A9\?B( :>A66<>( B9A6\ >6A96 5"%:),$$"#G(E,/G(
>A>BB7(
8A6?>B( :6A9<9\(
88A7776 :6A8>>; 96A>< 69ABB >A\6?7 7A<?\> :>A<\9B 87A6B\>( :>A??B<( 9<A;9 6;A<> *,/&'(Y$"+#./G(
>A6\>?(
<A\<?;( :6AB76<(
8<A67>9 :?A\\96 BBA8\ >>A76 >A>869 <A999\ :6A;8B6 8>A<78\( :6A7?8>( \6A<> 9A;9 *&.D0%,$=(
6A;\87(
>A\98;( :6A>9B\(
88A9<>< :6A>B>> 9BA7> 6>A89 >AB>\9 8A\>\? :>A6\\> 88A;6B7( :6A\>B<( 9BA;8 6>A<; Q',./$0.(E&.D0%,(
6AB\9B(
<A>8>7( :6A87<B(
8<A?B7; :6A>\7> 9;A7< 6<A8B >A8>8< 8A>\>< :6A9;9? 8<A76\<( :6A969\( \BA<B >A;< C$&%GY"$/(,R#0YA(
6A\B\7(
<A8B76( :6A8\;\(
86AB;;\ :6A6?78 9?AB6 6\A>\ >AB;BB 8A9BB? :>A6?\< 8<A>8\\( :6A9B77( 99A\> 66A?9 `$,.0G0"%(0%G/$A(
6A\67<(
<A>B\6( :6A<;\;(
86A;B>; :6A6?\> 9>A;B 6BA<< >A<8<8 8A?B<7 :6AB<?6 8>A8B6B( :6A796\( \6A8< 9A7B c/D,$(Y$"+#./G(
6A999<(
<A>6\;( :6A<86B(
86A8<?\ :6A?68; 9>A66 6BA9\ >A;>?< 8A7?>\ :6A99>; 86A9?B\( :6A77??( 9>A<8 6BA;; F,&'(,G/&/,(
6AB<BB(
>A\9><( :6A><7;(
8>A\;8B :6A8B>9 B8AB> >7A>9 <A7\9< ;A>9?B :>A;9>8 8>AB?9B( :>A?896( B;A<7 ><A;7 I&%+(/$&%GY"$/(
>A;>8\(
8A79B\( :6A\B6>(
8?A89>8 :?AB>B9 BBA>; >>AB8 6A7;8; >A;8>7 :6A?BB\ 8?AB9\B( :?AB;?6( B?A7> >\A89 *&$0%,(/$&%GY"$/(
6A<9<<(
>A<>B?( :?A\8>?(
8<A<7>> :6A>>\9 ;7A?; <8A\8 <A8BB\ ;A<>6? :>A98<> 88A\B\7( :6A\<B?( ;9A6< <6A9B -0$(/$&%GY"$/(
>A89>6(
8A<;?8( :6A9\?<(
8<A><>8 :?A\66B ;?AB7 <\A>7 6A9?BB <A>6?7 :6A8?>9 8<A;\7?( :?A9?<<( 7BA>; 8>AB8 Z&$,D"#G,(
6A\B;6(
<A8B6;( :6A7??\(
8<AB8?8 :6A??88 ;\A67 <?A97 >A>66; <AB\96 :6A79;7 86ABB6?( :6A><?>( BBA78 >>A8; 3%)"(g(."EE#%0.&/0"%( >A>7B?(
6A97\9(
<A<>?7( :6A87>8(
8>A7;\< :6A<67\ BBA89 >>A7> 6A9<97 <A6B>? :6A<<<; 8>A?86?( :6A?<>?( BBA<\ >>A;6 Q',.A(Y"[,$(g(1&G(
<A\9\;( :6A;\9<(
8>AB<<6 :?A<9?; 8?AB> 7\A>9 6A9<;< <A>7<B :6A86B< 8<A7;6>( :?A8B;>( <<A;? ;;A8? 4,$M0.,(
6A>87B(
>A69B;( :?A\<89(
87A?B;9 :6A6>?B 9?A9B 6\A6< 6A7B9; >A96\8 :6A>8?9 88A??9<( :6A?6;7( 96A\< 69A?B `D&$E&.,#/0.&'(
6A;B?8(
<A?B87( :6A<97\(
8>A6<89 :?A;897 ;<AB6 <;A>\ 6AB9B6 <A?>9> :6A>866 8?A\988( :?A\?\9( B<A<? >;AB? ZD"',G&',(
6A<9\9(
>A867B( :6A?6B\(
87A;B;\ :6A87>; 96A<B 69A;< >A99?? 7A6\<? :>A<6<? 88A78?\( :6A9799( 9?A<; 6\A;8 F,/&0'(
>A6><;(
<A\?98( :6AB97>(
88A98>6 :6A?6B< B8A<B >7A;< 6A\;;; <A78>> :6A7B7; 88A8968( :6A6?8B( B?A66 >\A9\ 4,.#$0/0,G(
6A;B?\(
<A?7?;( :6A<;B\(
88A86;7 :6A\<7< 9?AB< 6\A>B <A86>8 ;A68B? :>AB<8; 88A89;>( :>A668<( BBA<> >>A;9 3%G#$&%.,(
<A??9;(
7A<\B>( :>A<\B<(
86A8;9\ :6A6<>< B<A7< >;A8B <A878\ 7A\B6< :>A76;7 8>A68>7( :6A9\\8( B7A89 >8A7> c/D,$()0%&%.0&'G(
>A6B99(
<AB6<8( :6A7<\\(
8<A97\? :6A<<<9 B8A9\ >7A66 <A;9>7 ;AB<;9 :<A?78< 87A<<B<( :>A6\\9( B>A?> >BA\9 JD,E0.&'(
>A<?88(
8A?;6?( :6AB966(
8<A>6<< :6A?8<7 99A77 66A87 6A\<6; <A8869 :6A76?> 8<A9BB7( :6A8?7B( \<A?9 ;A\> T&%HG(
6A77>7(
>AB>;9( :6A6B9<(
8<A<877 :6A<9>7 B8A9B >7A6< <A68<9 7A7988 :>A88?; 8<AB?<9( :6A9\<;( BBA7\ >>A86 (
>A8?\B(
8A>;??( :6A98;7(
!#G/( '0H,( 0%( /D,( Q#$"Y,&%( .&G,2( [,( "PG,$M,( &%( &PG"'#/,( C3F( $,+#./0"%( 0%( /D$,,( 0%+#G/$0,GK( -0$( C$&%GY"$/2( 3%)"( &%+( J"EE#%0.&/0"%2( 4,$M0.,A( -( G/$"%1,$( "M,$'&Y( [0/D( /D,( -E,$0.&%( .&G,( 0G( .',&$]( E"$,"M,$2( 0/( 0G( 0%/,$,G/0%1( /"( %"/0.,( /D&/( &''( /D,( /D$,,( 0%+#G/$0,G( d"0%/'=( GD"[( &( $,+#./0"%( 0%( /D,( Y&="))( $0GH( a&%+( /"/&'( $0GH( &G( [,''bA(-%&'=X0%1(/D,($,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(C3F("M,$(/D,(/"/&'($0GH2(/D,($,+#./0"%(0G(E"$,()$,R#,%/K(68(.&G,G2(/["(&$,(
B>;(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
"M,$'&YY,+( [0/D( /D,( Y$,M0"#G( "%,G2( ,U.,Y/( -0$( C$&%GY"$/A( 3%( %0%,( 0%+#G/$0,G2( &%( 0%.$,&G,( 0%( /D,( Y,$.,%/&1,( ")( L3F(.&%(P,("PG,$M,+A(3%(/D,(4,$M0.,(0%+#G/$=2(/D,(&PG"'#/,($,+#./0"%(0%(C3F(d"0%,+(&($,+#./0"%(0%(L3F([,01D/A(
N0%&''=2( [,( .&%( /$=( /"( ."EY&$,( /D,( /["( .$0G,G( 0%( /,$EG( ")( 0EY&./( "M,$( /D,( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( 0%( /D,( /D$,,( &%&'=X,+(E&$H,/G(0%(C&P',G(6<:67A(
C&P',(6<( TIR Composition Compared in the Two Crisis: The Japanese Market
CD,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a6\\\:>??<b( `&="))(
CD,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b(
C"/&'(
C3F( ( k (
43F(
`&="))( C"/&'( C3F(
k ( 43F( ( k
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( Cc`3l(
>>A<6 6AB8;; >A\8?8 :6A6\<9( 8?A;??8( :6A6\<9( 79A9\ 86A66 N0GD,$0,G(
>A?86B(
<A7B>>( :6A7<?;( 8>A98;6 :6A7<?; BBA;\
>>A?< 6AB8\\ >A\\6B :6A>869( 86A7?96( :?A;9?<( 78AB9 87A>> *0%0%1(
>A?68?(
<A799;( :6A7B8;( 8<A9B9\ :6A>>B9 BBA\B
<?A>6 >A<8>6 8A66?8 :6AB;9>( 8<A?6\>( :?A7>86( >\A;8 B?A<; J"%G/$#./0"%(
<A<\<7(
7A\69B( :>A7>7>( 8>A;;76 :6AB;>< ;\AB\
6<A86 6AB?<9 <A?8>8 :6A<<97( 8<A\\;6( :?AB\69( 7\A67 8?A97 N""+G(
>A8><9(
8A>><6( :6AB\\>( 8>A;?7? :6A779? 9;A7\
>8A>? 6A69B6 >A??87 :?A96B8( 8?ABB\?( :?A8>?\( 76A8\ 89A76 C,U/0',G(
6A;?>B(
>A97>6( :6A>8\8( 8<A9?7> :?A\8B? B7A9?
67A;6 6AB6>> >A\\\B :6A>9B7( 8>A\>6<( :?ABB?6( 7\A96 8?A6\ `#'Y(g(Y&Y,$(
>A?B>9(
<A;9<9( :6A;66?( 8<AB<>; :6A<7\; 98A<\
<6A97 >A8677 8A?>BB :6A;6>>( 8?A?>B>( :?A;7BB( 8?AB\ 7\A>6 c0'(g(."&'(Y$"+G(
>A68>9(
<A\7?>( :6A9?B8( 87AB786 :6A><6; ;9A67
>>A7\ >A8><7 <A\7>7 :6A7>\?( <9A;98B( :?A7>7<( <8A<7 ;7A;7 F#PP,$(Y$"+#./G(
>A7<\B(
8A;7??( :>A66?8( 87A<9<\ :6A;<<B BBA86
<?AB8 >A9BB6 8A;97B :6A9?9;( <9A7\\6( :?AB;>;( 8>A6; 7BA98 O'&GG(g(.,$&E0.G(
>A\<8;(
8A\6;7( :6A\96\( 8?A<6?; :6A<B>B ;\A>;
9A77 >A6778 <AB7>9 :6A7\B8( 8>A7;8B( :6A?\67( ;9A<< <6A;B 3$"%(g(G/,,'(
>AB>>8(
8ABBB<( :>A?78\( 8<A?6<9 :6A9B\< \6A87
>6A96 >A6;<6 <A9\;6 :6AB<<?( 88A896?( :?A\88>( 78A8\ 87A76 5"%:),$$"#G(E,/G(
<A69;\(
7A99\B( :>AB?>9( 87A9\?B :>A66<> B9A6\
6;A<> >A;?7> 8A;<9> :>A?<<?( 8<A9<6?( :6A7??8( B<A9? >;A>? *,/&'(Y$"+#./G(
>A\6?7(
7A<?\>( :>A<\9B( 87A6B\> :>A??B< 9<A;9
9A;9 6A9;?8 <A66?> :6A>8\9( 8?A6987( :?AB6\9( 7BA7\ 8>A86 *&.D0%,$=(
>A>869(
<A999\( :6A;8B6( 8>A<78\ :6A7?8> \6A<>
6>A<; 6AB969 <A67;> :6A<B88( 8<A78;<( :6A6>77( 96A9\ 69A66 Q',./$0.(E&.D0%,(
>AB>\9(
8A\>\?( :>A6\\>( 88A;6B7 :6A\>B< 9BA;8
>A;< >A7<B> 8A8<?8 :6A9\<>( 8>AB<>;( :6A79<>( 9<A;> 6;A<9 C$&%GY"$/(,R#0YA(
>A8>8<(
8A>\><( :6A9;9?( 8<A76\< :6A969\ \BA<B
66A?9 >A6<>9 <A7;B9 :6A8<7?( 8?A>>6>( :?A\;??( ;;A\? <<A6? `$,.0G0"%(0%G/$A(
>AB;BB(
8A9BB?( :>A6?\<( 8<A>8\\ :6A9B77 99A\>
9A7B >A>;77 <AB6<6 :6A88B;( <9A\9;7( :6A6\B;( 9>AB< 6BA>B c/D,$(Y$"+#./G(
>A<8<8(
8A?B<7( :6AB<?6( 8>A8B6B :6A796\ \6A8<
6BA;; 6A\\?7 <A<B77 :6A<97?( 86A?<??( :6A?<;?( B8A9? >7A>? F,&'(,G/&/,(
>A;>?<(
8A7?>\( :6A99>;( 86A9?B\ :6A77?? 9>A<8
><A;7 >A;>>8 8A8B69 :6A98\8( 86A<7;B( :6A?8\;( 7;AB7 8<A>7 I&%+(/$&%GY"$/(
<A7\9<(
;A>9?B( :>A;9>8( 8>AB?9B :>A?896 B;A<7
>\A89 6A8B<< >A<?\\ :?A9<;7( <;A>68\( :?A8\?\( 79A;9 86A<> *&$0%,(/$&%GY"$/(
6A7;8;(
>A;8>7( :6A?BB\( 8?AB9\B :?AB;?6 B?A7>
<6A9B >A;<\8 8A87\6 :6A96\B( 8?A9?\<( :?A9?9<( 88A8> 77A79 -0$(/$&%GY"$/(
<A8BB\(
;A<>6?( :>A98<>( 88A\B\7 :6A\<B? ;9A6<
8>AB8 >A<9>9 8A>6B; :6A9<89( 8<A7?>\( :?A\69?( 7?A?8 8\A\; Z&$,D"#G,(
6A9?BB(
<A>6?7( :6A8?>9( 8<A;\7? :?A9?<< 7BA>;
>>A8; 6A\;<< <A8\?; :6A7>B8( 8<AB7;;( :?A;;>;( 8<A<9 7;A;> 3%)"(g(."EE#%0.&/0"%( 6A9<97(
>A>66;(
<AB\96( :6A79;7( 86ABB6? :6A><?> BBA78
>>A;6 <A<;9; 7A9?6> :>A8<>;( 86A\<><( :6A96\\( B8A96 >7A6\ Q',.A(Y"[,$(g(1&G(
<A6B>?( :6A<<<;( 8>A?86? :6A?<>? BBA<\
;;A8? 6A<>7< >A>6?> :?A998\( 8?A?<;<( :?A?9;\( \A9>( \?A69 4,$M0.,(
6A9<;<(
<A>7<B( :6A86B<( 8<A7;6> :?A8B;> <<A;?
69A?B >A;?B> 8AB\68 :>A698>( 87A797B( :6A;8?6( B7A?\ >8A\6 `D&$E&.,#/0.&'(
6A7B9;(
>A96\8( :6A>8?9( 88A??9< :6A?6;7 96A\<
>;AB? 6A798B >AB799 :6A6B86( 8>A77\?( :?A89>\( 86A6< 79A9B ZD"',G&',(
6AB9B6(
<A?>9>( :6A>866( 8?A\988 :?A\?\9 B<A<?
6\A;8 >A;9;7 8A\867 :>A>776( 87A;<8B( :6A;6<\( B6A7B >9A8< F,/&0'(
>A99??(
7A6\<?( :>A<6<?( 88A78?\ :6A9799 9?A<;
>\A9\ >A>7;9 8A?7B? :6A9??>( 88A<B>9( :6A6B\>( ;7A7? <8A7? 4,.#$0/0,G(
6A\;;;(
<A78>>( :6A7B7;( 88A8968 :6A6?8B B?A66
>>A;9 <A;;<> ;A76>? :>A9899( 8<AB8;B( :>A69?B( B;A77 ><A87 3%G#$&%.,(
<A86>8(
;A68B?( :>AB<8;( 88A89;> :>A668< BBA<>
>8A7> 6A\<99 <A<6>B :6A<B<\( 86A8B8<( :?A;;68( 89A68 76A9; c/D,$()0%&%.0&'G(
<A878\(
7A\B6<( :>A76;7( 8>A68>7 :6A9\\8 B7A89
>BA\9 >A8?79 8A>7B6 :6A976<( 8<A89B9( :6A<;6>( B<A7< >;A8B JD,E0.&'(
<A;9>7(
;AB<;9( :<A?78<( 87A<<B< :>A6\\9 B>A?>
;A\> 6A;78B >AB9>> :6A6>B7( 8?A7>78( :?A9BB<( BBA96 >>A6\ T&%HG(
6A\<6;(
<A8869( :6A76?>( 8<A9BB7 :6A8?7B \<A?9
>>A86 >A;66< 8A7>\8 :6A\696( 8>A<896( :6A68\9( 7\A\7 8?A?7 (
<A68<9(
7A7988( :>A88?;( 8<AB?<9 :6A9\<; BBA7\
Z0/D(G/&$/()$"E(/D,(G0EY',G/(.&G,2(!&Y&%K(>B(0%+#G/$0,G(GD"[(&%(0%.$,&G,(0%(P"/D(&PG"'#/,(&%+($,'&/0M,(C3F]( "%'=(0%( /D,( `#'Y( &%+( `&Y,$( 0%+#G/$=( /D,(."%/$&./0"%(0%( Y&="))( $0GH( ."#'+("))G,/(/D,( C3F(/$,%+A(c%'=( /D,( c/D,$( N0%&%.0&'($,10G/,$,+(&%(0%.$,&G,(0%(/D,(Y,$.,%/&1,(")(L3FA(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
B>B
C&P',(68( TIR Composition Compared in the Two Crisis: The European Market
CD,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a6\\\:>??<b( `&="))(
CD,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b(
C"/&'(
C3F( (
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k( ( 43F( ( k( k(
( akb(
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( L"[(!"%,G(Q#$"4/"UU( 6ABB7B(
43F( L3F(
88AB?B? :6A8<7B B9A9> >6A69 6A\88? <A>86\ :6A>\B\( 8?A?<;?( :6A>\B\( B?A>7 >\AB7 c0'(g(1&G(
<A>668( :6A8<7B(
87A>\8< :6A8?8> 9>A8< 6BA7B >A6>68 <A78B8 :6A8>;?( 8?A6\BB( :?A;\<8( 89A;< 76A<B C,.D%"'"1=(
>A?7B7(
<AB;6?( :6AB?<7(
86A9BB< :6A<6\9 96A<? 69AB? <AB7\> ;A<<\B :>A79?7( 8?AB?8?( :>A6<;>( 9>AB9 6BA>> -#/"E"P0',G(g(Y&$/G(
>A>7<6(
<A9B;7( :6A;><8(
76A97\? :6A7\8? 7?AB\ 8\A>6 >A>\;6 8A?8<8 :6AB8B<( 8<A>6<>( :6A<<6>( B;A6\ ><A96 T&G0G($,G"#$.,G(
>A\6<7(
;A?76\( :<A6<97(
87AB>?7 :>A6>79 9<A>9 6;AB> >A69>< 8A<<66 :>A6899( 8\A;6<7( :6A>;69( 79AB> 86A>9 F,/&0'(
<A?<?<(
7A79>\( :>A77>7(
8<A?;?7 :?A\87< B?A\> >\A?9 6A9\?> <A<>B; :6A8<B8( 8<A6\7?( :6A?9?9( B7A>? >8A9? 3%G#$&%.,(
6AB;>;(
<A?\77( :6A<<<?(
8;A6<;B :>A??<; 9\A86 6?A7\ >A7896 8A8;?6 :6A\6>?( 8>A9;\6( :6A78\?( 96A?6 69A\\ N""+(g(P,M,$&1,(
>A;6;>(
8A97B6( :>A>8?\(
8>A79<8 :?AB889 ;;A68 <<A9; 6A79?9 >AB?77 :6A6>8B( 86A7B6>( :?A>>89( 6\A\9 9?A?> C$&M,'(&%+(',0G#$,(
6A7698(
>A;887( :6A6>;6(
88A9B;\ :6A<<BB B\A<; >?A;8 >A??6; <A;7B\ :6A;7;>( 87A>B\?( :6A>9?B( BBA<< >>A;B N0%&%.0&'(G,$M0.,G(
>A?B?8(
<AB77\( :6A;977(
BA9; >A?66< <A7?\8 :6A8\96( 8>A;99?( :6A66;8( B8A7> >7A89 `,$G"%&'(g(D"#G,D"'+(
>A>976(
8A>??9( :6A\67B(
87A;?<< :6AB;76 \>A68
1""+G( 6AB779(
88A??7< :6A><6> 9\A>< 6?ABB >A8?9; <A9BB? :6A8;97( <BA9B;>( :6A>;?9( 97A9; 68A68 *,+0&(
<A6<7B( :6A<B\\(
8<A>679 :?A\7<7 9?AB< 6\A>B >A99B> 7A?;?7 :>A6B<<( 8>A\8;?( :6ABB>?( 96A78 69A8; T&%HG(
6A7769(
>AB<>\( :6A696?(
8;AB?9> :>A?BB> 9\A8> 6?A79 >A??6? <A8B76 :6A8B8?( 8>A86B7( :6A>B>;( 9;A<8 6<A;; J"%G/$#./0"%(&%+(
>A;7?8(
8A\B<<( :>A<><?(
E&/,$0&'G( >A88?B(
8<A97>; :6A;B<6 9BABB 6>A>< 6A;897 >A\<<? :6A>987( 8<AB\8>( :6A?<<;( 9?A8B 6\A7< 3%+#G/$0&'(1""+G(&%+(
8A<8;\( :6A\?;>(
G,$M0.,G( >A>>B7(
BA87 >A?76B <A767\ :6A8;8>( 86A;888( :6A6;\8( B\A9B >?A6< JD,E0.&'G(
8A?\;9( :6A9;\<(
87A;>9> :6AB<?6 \>A77
8;A96B> :6A87B? 99A>? 66A9? >A6?9; <A;9<6 :6A7B87( 8>AB897( :6A6?\<( B?A87 >\A77 e,&'/D(.&$,(
6A9B;7(
<A7>98( :6A;76\(
8>A8868 :?A;8>6 76A;8 89A<; >A>;79 <A;<;8 :6A<B?7( <BA;9\6( :?A7;86( 86A6; 79A98 C,',."EE#%0.&/0"%G(
6A;9;>(
>A\>\7( :6A>8<<(
8?A;?<< :?A;B;B ;?A>8 <\AB; >A\<98 8A\\\; :>A?;6>( 86A>>;;( :6A7;6B( B7ABB >8A>< W/0'0/0,G(
6A;8<>(
>AB;;;( :6A6><<(
8;A;;87 :6A>\>; 9<A6< 6;A9B 6A79\7 >A;;?? :6A?B?;( 8?A>8;\( :?AB<7<( ;9A;\ <6A<6 (
6ABBB>(
<A<<>6( :6A778\(
C&P',(67( TIR Composition Compared in the Two Crisis: The American Market
CD,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a6\\\:>??<b( `&="))( C"/&'(
CD,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b(
C3F( ( k
43F(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k ( 43F( ( k k
( akb(
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( 4g`(7??(
6AB;?<( <A?89;( :6A>99>( 8>A>7B7 :6A>99> ;9A<6 <6A;\( 6AB??7 >A9?7; :6A6?76( <\A<997( :6A6?76( 7<A;6 8;A<\ -+M,$/0G0%1(
>A696<( <A\9B<( :6A9?;?( 87A>\<> :6A>\B7 B6A97 >9A67( <A?B77 7A>;<8 :>A69B\( 86A7;98( :6A7B76( B6A\\ >9A?6 -,$"GY&.,(g(+,),%G,(
6AB76<( <A>B6\( :6A7>?7( 8;A8B<< :6A<?;< 97A\6 68A?\( >A6>9> <A;B?> :6A78>?( 8>A?6<9( :?A\;<9( ;>A7? <BA7? -1$0.#'/#$&'(Y$"+#./G(
<A66;B( 7A<<<9( :>A>6B>( 86A7;BB :6A?7<7 8BA7> 7>A89( >A>969 8A?7>9 :6ABB6?( 8<A;\99( :?A8<6;( >8A<B B7A;< -0$()$,01D/(g(."#$0,$G(G0(
>A?987( <A;?7B( :6A7>6>( 8>A69BB :6A6<?> B8A<? >7AB?( <A??B< 8AB;68 :6AB78?( <;A9<\<( :6A?B8B( ;6A>B <9AB< -0$'0%,G(G0(
>A\7?8( 7A?B87( :>A6>86( 86A9796 :?A\6>B 8>A\B 7BA?<( <A?8;6 7A6>88 :>A?B98( 8?A779<( :6A8998( B6A;6 >9A<\ -'#E0%#E(
8A6>?B( BAB<<7( :<A;6>\( 8;AB6;9 :>A9;6? B\A6\ >?A96( <A?8?< 7A>;\; :>A>>\>( 8>A<?8?( :6A>>?>( 78AB8 87A>; -YY&$,'(g(&..,GG"$0,G(
<A6?>>( 7A7?66( :>A<\9\( 8<A;?96 :6AB<9> B>A8; >BA78( >A><\6 <AB9B7 :6A7898( 8?A99>;( :?A\<8<( ;?A<8 <\A;; -YY&$,'($,/&0'(
>A7B8>( 8A<B9?( :6A9?<9( 86A>?>6 :6A<\<\ BBA>B >>AB<( <A7B;? 7A979? :>A>9>?( <9A\77<( :6A8;>B( ;8A6? <7A\? -YY'0.&/0"%(G")/[&$,(
>A<868( 8A?<88( :6A;\<?( 86A\;8\ :6A<\96 9>A79 6BA8>( 7A?<>\ 9A6>9? :<A?\7>( <9A?9?>( :6A9>8B( 79A\7 86A?7 -#/"(Y&$/G(g(,R#0Y(
<A<>??( ;A6<<6( :>A96<6( 87A9;B8 :6A\;B> ;\A\< <?A?B( >A?;96 <A97\> :6AB\66( 8;A866>( :6A?<77( 7BA96 8>A6\ -#/"E"P0',(E&%#)&./#$,$G( 8A;88;( \A;B\;( :7A?<7?( 7>A?6;7 :<A?>8> ;?A?; <\A\8( >A78\8 8A8<7\ :6A99;8( 8>A7>;B( :6A6;\B( ;>A?6 <BA\\ L0M(P&%HG(
<A\96;( BA8B?6( :<A8997( 8;A;\\< :>A699; ;>AB8 <BA>;( >A>><9 <ABB8< :6A77?8( 86A?B\7( :6A?B8<( ;\A>\ <?AB6 T0"/,.D%"'"1=(
6A98>;( <A><87( :6A<\69( 8<A?<6> :?A;67? 88A6\ 77A96( <A;;B\ 7AB886 :>A?B;>( <;A687?( :?A9689( <\A>7 ;?AB7 T$,[,$G(
6A7\8\( <A?9>8( :6A89B7( 89A>79> :?A7\;> 8?A?9 7\A\>( >A?9B6 <A>BB6 :6A6\??( <;A<6<<( :?A<?<6( >7A8B B8A7< T$"&+.&G/0%1(g(.&P',(C@( >A\?7B( ;A7B>;( :<A;;;\( 77AB\?9 :>A9;9< B9A>> >6AB9( >A\<9> 8A9>;B :6A9997( <\A6>;8( :6A86?>( B8A;9 >7A<> T#0'+0%1(Y$"+#./G(
<A?9>?( ;A8\B\( :<A867\( 7>A7;\; :>A><>8 ;7A<7 <8A;7( >AB<>B 8AB><9 :6A\\66( 8>A67?7( :?A\<6;( 8;AB\ 7<A>6 J&G0%"G(g(1&E0%1(
<A?9<\( ;A?B9;( :>A\\8B( 8\A>;7\ :>A6867 B6A76 >9A8\( >A\69> 8A9B87 :6A\7;>( 8?A6<6\( :?A\699( 8;A\B 7<A?< J"EE,$.0&'(Y$0%/0%1(
>A;<\\( 7A7B\<( :>A\<\8( 7>A;98; :>A<B<> 9?AB< 6\A>B( >A67\< <A98B> :6A;9B\( 8<A9B<;( :?AB8;8( 88A>> 77AB9
B>9(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
aC&P',(67(."%/0%#,+b(
CD,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a6\\\:>??<b( `&="))( C"/&'(
CD,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b(
C3F( ( k (
43F(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k ( 43F( ( k
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( J"EY#/,$(g(,',./$($,/&0'(
>A\;>;( 7A698>( :>A>>6;( 8>A978? :6A7<>9 ;\A?? <6A?? 8A>?79 BA67?< :>A\88;( 86A69?\( :6A;>79( 77A>6 88AB\ J"EY#/,$(D[&$,(
>A?\<6( <A;B67( :6A7B98( 8>A\9\9 :6A>67< BBA?? ><A?? <A6>\6 7A?\?7 :6A\;68( <9A7<?9( :6A87B8( B8A<? >7AB? J"EY(G/"$&1,(g( Y,$0YD,$&'G(
>A779<( 8A7?>9( :6A\887( 8<A698> :6A889B B8A7? >7A7? 7A6979 9A>6B6 :<A?<6<( <;A9\?>( :6AB799( 79A?> 86A\9 J"%G/$#./0"%(g(
,%10%,,$0%1( <AB8?;( ;A;7<;( :>A\6<6( 8<AB96B :>A?9>8 B6A8\ >9A76 <A6\<> 7A;86; :>A8898( 8<A<\\6( :?A\7;>( <\A?7 ;?A\7 J"%G/$#./0"%(g()&$E(
E&.D0%,( <A??7;( 7A76>;( :>A7?B?( 87A8BB; :>A6;7> 9;A<; 6<A;8 >A8BB\ 8A6778 :6A;BB7( 8?A<;\\( :?A\;>;( 7BA<9 8>A;> J"%G/$#./0"%(E&/,$0&'G(
<A7687( ;A7<79( :<A?>6<( 8;A>>;B :6A99B8 ;>A8B <BA7< >A>;<; 8A?;88 :6A9??9( 88A<?;B( :6A?>9<( 7BA6? 8>A\? L,Y&$/E,%/(G/"$,G(
<A6;7?( 7A9\;\( :>AB<69( 8;A<>;\ :>A??>B B<A<6 >;A;\ >A7B7; 8A>\96 :6AB>>7( 8?A?B7?( :6A>>99( B6A<8 >9A;; L0G/$0P#/"$G(
>A??8\( <A79>;( :6A7BBB( 88A?<9\ :6A?<88 ;7A7; <8A88 6AB?77 >A;?\7 :?A\?8?( <8A;8<6( :?A8<>6( 8BA9? 7>A>? L0M,$G0)0,+(.D,E0.&'G(
>A>77?( 8A>8B<( :6A\\>>( 8;A\?;B :6A;>7\ 96A;6 69A<\ >A8<<7 8A6B;< :6AB8>9( 86AB<6?( :6A??;9( 7BABB 8>A>< L0M(."EE(g(Y$")(G,$M(
6A7>B<( >A;??\( :6A>;<7( 89A7B98 :?A\>68 B>A\< >BA?B >A6>6? <A;;B\ :6A78;\( 8>A6B<9( :6A>??8( BBA;? >>A8? L0M()0%(GMG(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( L0M,$G0)0,+(E,/&'G(g(
8A?77?( BA78?;( :<A897;( 8;A>>8B :>A76>> B>A?B >BA\< %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
E0%0%1( 8A7699( 9A>6?6( :<A;\6<( 88A\;?7 :>A7;?< ;\A<; <?A;8 >A9886 8A\7B> :>A66<6( 8>A;>B<( :?A\;96( 87A96 78A6\ L$#1($,/&0'(
>A?\9?( <A8B6>( :6A<B<<( <\A7;67 :?A98\; ;6A9B <9A6< >A7\99 8A<8\> :6AB7?8( 8?A>8B6( :?A;6?8( <8A9B ;7A6< Q',./$0.(#/0'0/0,G(
6AB>6;( <A?8?9( :6A<6\>( 8<A<9>7 :?A979B ;7A?\ <8A\6 6ABB<8 <A6B>8 :6A<\\?( 88A?\98( :?A8\69( <7A67 ;8A97 Q',./$0.&'(."EY(g(,R#0Y(
>A<8>6( 8A?;\B( :6AB>B;( 8>A88\9 :6A8??< 96A?; 69A\8 >A<\>? <A\\?; :6A7\97( 8?A?7BB( :6A6<\7( B6A>9 >9AB> Q',.(,R(E&%#)A(
>A8<96( 8A87<;( :>A?677( 87A>77> :6A<9\; ;9A\8 <6A?; <A\B;? ;AB>6\ :>AB87\( 8?A98\\( :6A9\;6( ;\A?7 <?A\7 eF(g(,EY'"=E,%/(G,$M(
<A6<B;( 7A8>6>( :>A>9<;( 8>A6><< :6A;;<; B>A97 >BA67 <A79B? ;A7\;7 :<A??\;( 87A;><8( :>A>9<9( B7A9\ >8A66 Q%M$(g()&.0'0/0,G(G,$M(
>A?\>;( <A8;67( :6A<;9\( <\A78;B :?A9;6? ;>A9\ <BA66 <A?;?6 7A7?<; :>A88<;( 88A<\\>( :?A9?9B( <<A6? ;;A\? N,$/0'0G,$(g(&1$0(.D,E0.&'G( <A7;9<( 7A\89<( :>A<9?6( 8?A?6>7 :6A76;> ;<AB6 <;A>\ <A>>;\ 8AB>8< :6A8\B8( <6A;\89( :?AB77\( 7?A89
8\A7> N""+(+0G/$0P#/"$G(
6A\7>?( <A7>?;( :6A7;9;( 88A778; :6A?6;; ;8A96 <7A6\ >A68\< <AB;6B :6A;6>8( 8>A9;<>( :?AB<?9( 87A<> 78A;9 N""+($,/&0'(
>A?;<7( <A<>69( :6A>798( <BA9969 :?AB;7< ;?A9> <\A69 >A8<\< 8A8<8; :6A\\7<( 88A\\87( :?A96<<( 8?AB; 7\A>8 N""/[,&$(
>A8\87( 8A<\<B( :6A9\\>( 8<A>>7? :6A>677 ;8A?? <;A?? <A>968 7A7>?\ :>A><\7( 8?A7;87( :?A979>( <9A<> ;6A;9 N"$,G/(Y$"+#./G(
<A>B79( 7A\\99( :>AB><?( 87A<\>7 :6AB98< ;7A7> <8A89 >A\??< 8AB86B :6A9868( <9A9<88( :6A6?;7( ;?A?\ <\A\6 O&G(#/0'0/0,G(
>A;7\8( 8A\8?>( :>A>9?\( 8;A6;\6 :6A;<\7 B6A99 >9A6> >A?;77 <A;<>9 :6A7;B<( 8<A68<8( :?A98?9( 7<A;7 8;A<7 O,%,$&'(E,$.D(G/"$,G(
>A\6\?( 8A\?89( :6A\979( 8?A89;6 :6A<B79 ;\A>\ <?AB6 >A9?\? 8A7><9 :6AB68B( <BA\?7?( :6A67B8( ;BA8\ <>A76 O"'+(
<A8;>6( ;A6;7<( :>AB?<<( 8<A98;< :6A6<7< 8>A?? 79A?? <A><\? 7A<9<9 :>A6889( <\A9<97( ?A?<<7( :6A7; 6?6A7; eh.&$,(+0G/(
6A9>8>( <A<6\\( :6A8\7B( 87A?7>; :?A9698 78AB> 87A>9 >A76>> 8A8?;< :6A9\86( 8>A\9;>( :?A;9\<( <;A<\ ;<A;6 e,&'/D(.&$,(,R#0Y(
6A77>;( >AB99;( :6A><;?( 88A<>>; :?A\<?\ B7A<6 >8A;\ >A67>> <A8979 :6A<<<;( <9A>79B( :?AB\7<( 7\A;< 8?A<B e,&'/D(.&$,()&.0'0/0,G(
<A;67B( 9A77?>( :8A\<87( 7BAB6>< :6A\\77 8?A88 7\A7; >A776> 8A;;69 :>A66?;( 87A>B8\( :?A<B<>( 6BA;9 9>A<> e,&'/D(.&$,(G#YY'0,G(
6A;><<( 7A6796( :<A7<89( ;9A7>\; :6A<69> <BA>\ ;>AB6 >AB8>? 8A\<77 :>A6\<7( 88A88>9( :?A9<;<( <9A6< ;6A9B e"E,()#$%0GD0%1G(
>A9?86( 7A?\\?( :>A>\8\( 87A??;9 :6A<;\< 7\A;B 8?A<< >A8B<> 8A776< :>A?B96( 87A;799( :6A>B?7( ;6A68 <9A9; e"E,(0EY$"M,($,/&0'(
>A97\>( 8A98\9( :6A\\?;( 86A?87> :6A<;<6 ;9A89 <6A7> <A>96\ 7A7;6< :>A>B\8( 8?A\9;8( :6A8B9\( ;8A99 <7A6> e"E,P#0'+0%1(
7A8>86( \A<B;6( :<A\76\( 8>A68\? :>A8;?; ;>A>; <BAB8 <A>>\6 7A77B; :>A<>97( 86A9\B7( :6A<68>( 7;A88 8<A7; e"/,'G(
<A?<96( 7A78\<( :>A766>( 87A>7>6 :6A\?>? B7AB8 >8A>; >A9<<< 8A9\;7 :>A?;<>( 8>A6<;9( :6A8\6>( B>A>B >BAB< e"#G,D"'+(&YY'0&%.,G(
>A;779( 7A?>>9( :>A<;B?( 8BA6>87 :6AB897 B<A9B >;A6< >A86>> 8A8?\6 :6A\\;\( 87A>\6>( :6A<<<7( ;;AB9 <<A>> e"#G,D"'+(Y$"+#./G(
6A<6B\( >A<?9B( :?A\\?9( 8>A\67\ :?A7>6< 7>A;> 8BA<9 6A\7\\ <A<6;B :6A<7;9( 8?A\?9\( :?A>8<B( 6BA\; 9>A?8 e"#G,[&$,G(g(GY,.0&'/0,G( >A<>\6( 8A9696( :>A89\6( 76A;;?; :6A9<>< B<A;6 >;A<\ 6A\<87 <A7>8; :6A7\?>( 87A66;>( :?A99\?( 77A\?
88A6? 3%+#G/$0&'(."%1'"E,$&/,G(
>A>;\\( 8A89B7( :>A>6B;( 8\A86;9 :6AB?B; BBA?? ><A?? >A7\9; 8A>9;\ :6A;99<( <\A<9>>( :6A8<98( 97A>? 68A9? 3%+#G/$0&'(1&G,G(
>A<9\B( 8A69\8( :6AB\\B( 8>A\79\ :6A8>B? B\A>\ >?AB6 >A;6\\ 8A8\B6 :6A9BB<( 86AB8<;( :?A9968( 8;A\7 7<A?7 3%+#G/$0&'(E&.D0%,$=(
>A668;( <AB<87( :6A;6\\( 8<A<B;8 :6A8<>? 99A8? 66A;? >A?B?6 <A7>88 :6A878<( 86A>;<;( :?A\7<<( ;7A77 <8A87 3%G#$&%.,(P$"H,$G(
6A9\;<( <A69B;( :6A>\6<( 8?A7?\\ :?AB6?6 78A\\ 87A?6 >A;6?9 8A;6<8 :>A??>7( 8<A8?B>( :6A<7B<( ;BAB9 <>A>> 3%/,1$&/,+("0'(g(1&G(
>A>9??( <A9?<6( :6A7><6( 8?A?8\6 :6A>8>; 96A79 69A8> 6A99?> <A?;<< :6A69<>( <9A;><B( :?A7\;9( 7?A88 8\A7; 3%/,1$&/,+(/,',."E(G,$M(
>A?77B( <A86<<( :6A<7B7( <\ABB>7 :?A\7?7 B?A?> >\A\9 >A<?B; <A\<98 :6A;<?\( 86A8?9\( :?A\669( 77A\6 88A?\ 3%/,$%,/($,/&0'(
<A7>79( ;A6<;<( :>A;6?8( 8>A7866 :6A8B<< 7;A88 8<A7; >A7\\6 <A;996 :6A?9\?( >\A7>B6( :?A8B87( 8<A7B 7;A8< (
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
B>\
aC&P',(67(."%/0%#,+b(
CD,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a6\\\:>??<b( `&="))( C"/&'(
CD,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b(
C3F( ( k
43F(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k ( 43F( ( k k
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( 3%/,$%,/(G")/[&$,(g(G,$M(
>A8;?>( 8A>>\8( :6AB;\>( 86A9<?< :6A>8>; B?A>< >\ABB( 7A9>8< \A\??B :8A?B;8( 86A6B>7( :>A;\69( ;;A?< <<A\B 3C(."%G(g("hGMG(
<A8B\8( ;A?9<6( :>A;?<B( 8>A9?>; :6A9B;> B>A?; >BA\8( >A9\?> 7A<\BB :>A7?B8( 8;A878<( :6A8696( 7;A7; 8<A88 I,0G#$,(Y$"+#./G(
>A>\\?( 8A<<<B( :>A?<8B( 8;A\76< :6A>>?< 7\A\B 8?A?<( >A8;6> 8A>986 :6A9>>9( 8>A78\<( :?AB;78( 86A\\ 79A?6 I0),(g(D,&'/D(0%G(
<A888>( ;AB96>( :<A<<B?( 8\A>?\9 :>A\<>> 9BA9B 6>A6<( >A688> <AB>\6 :6A798\( 8>A7?66( :6A?B<<( ;BAB> <>A>9 *&%&1,+(D,&'/D(.&$,(
>A;?B?( 7A6\\B( :>A7\>;( 8\A9;6; :6A78<6 7\A7> 8?A89( >A8?;7 8A?7;7 :6A;7??( 8?A;B88( :?A<<>9( >?A6B B\A9< *,/&'(g(1'&GG(."%/(
>A<<;;( 8A689B( :6A96>6( 8<A;B97 :6A8?B> BBA;; >>A<8( >A<B>? 8A>?;> :6A9<8>( 8<A;?B6( :?A96?;( 88A>? 77A9? *"/"$.=.',(E&%#)&./#$,$G( <A;B9;( BA6?6>( :<A8>>7( 89A6\;\ :>A;;<B BBA9< >>A6B( >A9986 8A98B6 :6A\;>\( 8?A8\BB( :6A>;\>( ;8A;; <7A<8 *"M0,G(g(,%/,$/&0%E,%/(
>A?\B7( <A\B;?( :6A9B97( 8BA>87B :6A;;?7 99A<\ 66A;6( <A>?96 7A<;B9 :>A67\B( 8?A><8?( :6AB;98( 96A99 69A6> *#'/0:'0%,(0%G#$&%.,(
<AB8\\( BA869\( :<A;;\?( 8\A877? :>A;88> B>A?B >BA\<( >A;9\\ 8A8B68 :6AB968( <\A98?9( :6A>9>6( B6A\B >9A?< *#'/0(#/0'0/0,G(
6A7>>>( >AB;68( :6A><\>( 88A9B;; :?A99<\ B6A<> >9A;9( <A\<B6 BA>7>> :<A<67?( 87AB66?( :>A6;8<( ;7A>\ <8AB6 c))0.,(,',./$"%0.G(
>AB>?<( 7A877B( :>AB<7<( 7?A6<B8 :>A6<\8 B9A>6 >6AB\( 8AB?B6 9A<>9\ :<A;>69( 8<A8988( :6A\<8<( 7<A86 8;A7\ c))0.,(G,$M(g(G#YY'0,G(
6A\6<B( <A9;67( :6A\8B9( 7?A886> :6A8\6B B;A7\ ><A86( >A6<\< <A;\6< :6A77>?( 8>A?87>( :?AB\9\( 76A89 89A7> c0'(g(1&G(+$0''0%1(
<A8686( 7AB696( :>A<?8?( 8?A>\>8 :6AB?87 B<A\9 >;A?>( 8A?7>B ;A8769 :>A<\\6( <BA6988( :?A96>7( <<A9B ;;A6< c0'(g(1&G(,R#0Y(g(G,$M(
<A<;6\( 7AB?\7( :>A<8BB( 86A669> :6AB;6\ B7A?7 >8A\7( <A<\>> 7A<68\ :6A\>>B( <;A6B78( :?AB9BB( 8?A\B 7\A?< c0'(g(1&G(,UY'"$(g(Y$"+(
<A66?\( 7A88;<( :>A<<78( 8>A99?8 :6ABB;6 B;A?7 ><A\7( >AB6\B 8A8?7? :6A;97<( <9A>799( :?A77;6( <>A\\ ;BA?6 c0'(g(1&G($,)0%1(g(E&$H(
<A;??\( ;A>>79( :>A;>7?( 8>A6;>< :6A9;<; B?A\\ >\A?6( 6A\6>< <A<6?? :6A<\BB( 8>A>>;<( :?A;98\( 8\A?? 76A?? `&.H&1,+()""+G(
6A>;B>( >A>;67( :?A\\8<( 8<A\;78 :?AB>\; B<A<9 >;A;>( 6A8\6\ >A78>; :6A?7?B( 86A<>8B( :?A>;\>( >7A;> B8A<9 `&Y,$(Y&.H&10%1(
>A<??>( 8A>>?<( :6A\>?6( 87A8\;B :6A68<8 7\A77 8?A87( >A>9\; 8A?\78 :6A9?79( 88A?\<6( :6A??8>( 77A;6 88A<\ `&Y,$(Y$"+#./G(
>A9B<6( 7A\\\<( :<A6>;>( 7>A6?\9 :>A6\9> B?A<> >\A;9( >A;;B> 8A76?9 :6A98<;( 8?A9B?9( :6A67B\( ;>A96 <BA6\ `,$G"%&'(Y$"+#./G(
>A>;86( 8A878\( :>A6\?9( 8\A6BB\ :6A8B;> ;BA<9 <>A;>( >A>;9\ <AB>?6 :6A876>( <\A??9B( :?A<;79( >7A>6 B8AB\ `D&$E&.,#/0.&'G(
6A8\69( >A7\;B( :6A6?8\( 8>A78\; :?AB><B ;7A7? <8A7?( >A?BB\ <A8B;< :6A<\98( 8?A>>;<( :?A;9<8( 89A9B 76A6< `D"/"1$&YD0.(Y$"+#./G(
<A;B76( BA8?;7( :<AB<68( 7?A<B\B :6A;;>B 88A7; 77A88( >A;6<? 7A67<B :>A78?B( 8\A>\\?( :6A>6?7( 8BA;8 7>A<; `$"Y,$/=(g(.&G#&'/=(0%G#$( >A8<;9( 8A6<66( :6A;\8<( 86A?6<6 :6A<B>B 96A?> 69A\9( >A68>B <A\9;6 :6A98<8( 8;A>87>( :?A\\B;( 78A6> 87A99 `#P'0GD0%1(g(Y$0%/0%1(
>A887B( 8A;BB<( :>A><6;( 8BAB66? :6AB\8; 9?A8> 6\A79( 6AB;;8 >A9\;; :6A6<?6( <\A?6;B( :?AB\;\( B?A76 >\A8\ F&0'$"&+G(
>AB6\7( 8A7\B>( :6A9BB9( 8?A9879 :6A8>98 B;A?B ><A\<( >A>9?< <A96;9 :6A7<;7( 8?A>7;7( :?A97;8( 77AB8 88A>; F,&'(,G/&/,(0%MG/(/$#G/G(
<A87?<( 7A99\>( :>A8<99( 86A86>< :6A99?\ BBA6> >>A99( 6A?<6; >A<<<8 :6A<?69( 77AB\66( :?A\B>7( B8AB? >7A<? F,G/&#$&%/G(
6A97>?( <A?7B6( :6A>?76( <\A8>?> :?A\<>; BBA<9 >>A;>( >A6898 <AB8>? :6A7\<;( 8>A79;?( :?A9B<6( 78AB\ 87A>6 4")/(+$0%HG(
6A8?<\( >A779>( :6A678<( 87A6>69 :?A;;9B 7BA\< 8>A?B( >A?;9< <A88<8 :6A<B76( <\A\<<>( :?A8897( <>A;> ;BA<9 4Y,.0&'/=(.D,E0.&'G(
6A9<\6( <A>B\\( :6A88?9( 8<A\>97 :?A9\7< ;>A68 <BA9;( >A?9\; <A;\>7 :6A;?>\( 8<A8?\?( :?A9<7<( 7>A66 8BA9\ 4Y,.0&'/=(G/"$,G(
<A?8B\( 7A6\>\( :>A688\( 86A<?7; :6A;?<; B8AB; >7A>8( <A?66> 8A\7\B :6A\897( <\A>9B7( :6A>B9<( ;7A;? <8A8? 4/,,'(:Y$0.,(0%+,U(
8A6??>( BA?;87( :>A\;8<( 86A\;?7 :>A8?9? 96A>< 69ABB( >A;?>8 8A8?B? :6A9?8;( 8?A\89\( :6A6>6B( ;>A6; <BA98 4=G/,EG(G")/[&$,(
>A6877( <A;8>8( :6A8\;\( 86A?\;9 :?A\98? ;7AB8 <8A>;( <A<6>\ 7A<887 :>A?<6;( <9A?6<?( :6A88<>( B6A?8 >9A\; C0$,G(g($#PP,$(
8AB;<?( 9A\B96( :8A>676( 8;A\89\ :>A\89< ;\A\7 <?A?7( <A6B77 7A9>79 :>A;7?>( 87A8\6B( :6A<<B9( 7?A89 8\A7> C"P&.."(
6A;7>;( >A\66\( :6A>7\8( 8<A>8\? :?AB7?8 7\A7\ 8?A86( >A;9;> 8A99>7 :>A6\;<( 88A\9<>( :?A8;B?( >6A>; B9AB8 C$&+0%1(."EY(g( +0G/$0P#/"$G(
>A7?9?( 8A>9\9( :6AB96\( 86A7<;9 :6A<\9< B9A8B >6A7<( 6A\B;7 <A;79\ :6A;9><( 87A\B\B( :6A?>>?( ;?AB7 <\A>7 Z0$,',GG(/,',."E(G,$M(
<A>>>B( ;A?>8?( :>A9?6<( 8;A7?>6 :6AB\6\ ;<A\B <;A?<( 8A\98> 9A888< :<A8;?6( 8?A\B77( :6A7696( 8<A9B 7;A6< e=Y(EH/G(g(G#Y(.%/(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( eh.(G,$M0.,G(
6A\86B( >A\9<9( :6A?8>6( <8A\>88 :?A7;78 78A>; 87AB8( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( F,10"%&'(P%HG(
6A\988( <A86;7( :6A8<>6( 86A\6B7 :?A\?7; ;<A>< <;ABB( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( CD$)/GhE1,()0%(
<A978<( ;A\869( :<A?9B7( 88A8B;9 :6ABB>> 7BA8? 8>A;?( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( 4Y,.()0%&%.,(
8A8>\>( BAB9;?( :<A<7;\( 8<A6686 :6A;79? 8\A<\ 7?A;6( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( J"%G()0%&%.,(
<A7>><( ;A?769( :>A7>\;( 86AB\9? :6A;\B7 ;BA66 <>A9\( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
<A7?>B( ;A;?B7( :<A6?8\( 8;A\9\B :>A<966 B;A;\ ><A<6( <A>689 7A87\8 :>A>88;( 86A668B( :6AB7\B( B9A8? >6A;? -GG(E1/(g(.#G/(P%H(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( 3%M(P%H(g(P$"H(
<A<?>8( 7A88\9( :>A68B8( <\A8?>B :6A968; 98A7? 67A7?( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( L&/&(Y$"(g("#/(GMG(
8A<B76( BA686B( :>AB;;;( <9AB<\6 :>A??6\ B>A<; >BA;8( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( (
6AB;\9( <A6<;7( :6A<;;B( 8<A7B<9 :6A6B9< 9;A>> 6<AB9( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
B<?(
CeQ(35NcF*-C3c5(F34f(35(CeQ(I-CQ4C(JF3434(
aC&P',(67(."%/0%#,+b(
CD,(Y$,M0"#G(.$0G0G(a6\\\:>??<b( `&="))( C"/&'(
CD,('&/,G/(.$0G0G(a>??;:>??\b(
C3F( ( k
43F(
`&="))( C"/&'(
C3F(
k ( 43F( ( k k
C3F( akb( 43F( L3F( eE(,%/(Gh[&$,(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( J"EEA(,R#0YE,%/(
<A<7B> 7A867\( :>A?799( <9A?6<? :6A?79B 76A8> 89A79( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
>A<>?> <A968;( :6A8\8<( <\A6B8; :6A6\B8 9?A6< 6\A9B( 8A6;6> ;A9B99 :>AB6BB( <\A7?9?( :6A;>??( 7\A;6 8?A<\ Q',.(E&%#(GMG(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( 4h."%(,R#0YE,%/(
>A;?;7 7A?B?7( :>A8;8?( 89A7\8\ :6A9\67 B;AB; ><A>8( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
>A\<7\ 8A9<;B( :6A\??9( <\A>\99 :6A>B<7 ;BA?? <<A??( 7A<6;9 9A<9B< :<A?B?7( <;A;?9\( :6A96B>( 7\A69 8?A9> 4,E0."%+#./"$G(
>A7;6< 8A>B9?( :6AB6;B( 8?A6>9\ :6A>;B9 B<A97 >;A67( 8A88<7 BA6>9; :>A;976( <BA;;;\( :6AB87B( ;7A?6 <8A\\ c0'(g(1&G(G/"$&1,(g(/$&%GY(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( Q+#.&/0"%(G,$M0.,G(G0(
>A89;> 8AB?\;( :>A>><8( 8BA>6?< :6A9B;? 98A<9 67A;>( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( 4Y'A(."%GA(G,$M0.,G(G0(
<A;9\; ;A77B>( :>A9;B;( 8<AB<>? :?A8;<9 6;A6B 9<A9<( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( -#/"E"/0M,($,/&0'(G0(
>A978\ 7A?<<8( :>A6B97( 8<A>9?< :6A<>\7 ;6A?< <9A\B( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( e"E,()#$%0GD($,/&0'(G0(
>A8?<9 8A<B??( :6A\;;>( 88A\\<> :6A<>;; ;BA8B <>A7<( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( 3%+A(Y"[,$(Y$"+(g(,%,$1=(/$( >A86B? 8A\6\>( :>A7?>>( 7?A9;7\ :6A8>9\ 7BA66 8>A9\( %AGA(
>A9\86 7A?\?\( :>A6\;\( 8<A67>7 :6A<<8\ ;?AB; <\A>8( %AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA(
%AGA( %AGA( %AGA( %AGA( (
%AGA(
%AGA(
CD,( Q#$"Y,&%( .&G,( GD"[G( "%'=( %0%,( 0%+#G/$0,G( D&M0%1( D01D,$( Y&="))( $0GH( 0%( /D,( '&/,G/( .$0G0G( 0)( ."EY&$,+( [0/D(/D,(Y$,M0"#G("%,](6>(G,./"$G(GD"[,+(D01D,$(',M,'(")(&PG"'#/,(C3FA(CD,($,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(C3F(0%.$,&G,+(0%( 68(0%+#G/$0,G2([D0',("%'=()0M,(0%+#G/$0,G(GD"[,+(&%(0%.$,&G,(0%(/D,($,'&/0M,([,01D/(")(L3FA(CD,G,(,M0+,%.,G(&$,( G/$"%1'=(."D,$,%/([0/D(+&/&()"$(/D,(,%/0$,(E&$H,/K(/D,(0EY&./(")(/D,(0%)"$E&/0"%($0GH([&G(M,$=(0EY"$/&%/(&%+([&G( #G#&''=(")(G=G/,E&/0.(G"#$.,A(
3%(/D,(-E,$0.&%(.&G,2(89(0%+#G/$0,G(0%+0.&/,(&%(0%.$,&G,(0%(/D,(Y&="))($0GHA(B7(0G(/D,(%#EP,$(")(0%+#G/$0,G( D&M0%1(&(D01D,$(&PG"'#/,(',M,'(")(C3F2([D0',(9>(GD"[(&%(0%.$,&G,(0%(/D,($,'&/0M,(0%+0.&/"$A(4/0''(0%(/D0G(.&G,2(/D,( E&0%( G"#$.,( ")( 0%)"$E&/0"%( $0GH( 0G( /D,( G=G/,E&/0.( "%( a9B( .&G,Gb( [D0',( L3F( 0%.$,&G,G( 0/G( 0EY&./( "%'=( "%( 68( 0%+#G/$0,GA(QM,%(0%(/D,(-E,$0.&%(,M0+,%.,(C3F(0G(G01%0)0.&%/()"$(/D,(.$0G0G2(,GY,.0&''=(&/(G=G/,E&/0.(',M,'A(