Results and Analysis
Results and Analysis
Linear Structure Model Analysis
MF,( IU-( 0D( &%( &%&'=/0.&'( &HH$"&.F( "HH"D0/,( /"( /F,( E[H'"$&/"$=( U&./"$( -%&'=D0D( XEU-YA( MF0D( D/#+=( ."%+#./,+( &( IU-( ")( /F$,,( #%"ZD,$W&Z',h0GH'0.0/( W&$0&Z',D( X0A,A2( 3I2( Z$&%+( ,R#0/=2( &%+( "$1&%0K&/0"%&'( H,$)"$G&%.,YA( I"%D0D/0%1( ")( /F,( 4/$#./#$&'( *"+,'( &%+( *,&D#$,G,%/( *"+,'2( &( 4E*( H$"W0+,D( &%( ,)),./0W,( D"'#/0"%( /"( /F,( .&#D,:,)),./( $,'&/0"%( Z,/N,,%( 0GH'0.0/h'&/,%/( W&$0&Z',DA( MF,( G"+,'D( W,$0)0,+( 0%( /F0D( D/#+=( &$,( +0W0+,+( 0%/"( /F$,,( H&$/De( X6Y( W,$0)=0%1( /F,( 1""+%,DD:"):)0/( ")( *,&D#$,G,%/( *"+,'a( X>Y( W,$0)=0%1( /F,( 1""+%,DD:"):)0/( ")( 4/$#./#$&'( *"+,'a( &%+( X<Y( W,$0)=0%1( /F,( "W,$&''( G"+,'\D( 1""+%,DD:"):)0/( /"( G&V,( D#$,( 0/( ."%)"$GD(/"(/F,(1""+%,DD:"):)0/(0%+0.,DA(MF&/(0D2(/F,(1""+%,DD:"):)0/(")(/F,("W,$&''(4E*(N&D(f#+1,+(N0/F($,'&/,+( 1""+%,DD:"):)0/(0%+0.,D(Xd0&G&%/"H"#'"D(`(401#&N2(>???YA(
Analyzing Fit of Measurement Model
MF,( )&./"$( '"&+0%1D( ")( '&/,%/h0GH'0.0/( W&$0&Z',D( &%+( G&%0),D/h,[H'0.0/( W&$0&Z',D( G&0%'=( G,&D#$,( /F,( 0%/,%D0/=(")('0%,&$(."$$,'&/0"%(Z,/N,,%(,[H'0.0/(&%+(0GH'0.0/(W&$0&Z',DA(-()&./"$('"&+0%1(.'"D,(/"(6(0%+0.&/,D(/F,( ,[H'0.0/(W&$0&Z',(0D($,'&/0W,'=(.&H&Z',(")(G,&D#$0%1(/F,(0GH'0.0/("%,A(3%(/F0D(D/#+=2(&''(,[H'0.0/(W&$0&Z',D\()&./"$( '"&+0%1D(&$,(Z,/N,,%(?A9(&%+(?Ab2(F,%.,(/F,(D&/0D)=0%1($,'0&Z0'0/=A(I"%D,R#,%/'=2(&''(,[H'0.0/hG&%0),D/(W&$0&Z',D( 0%( /F,( G"+,'\D( G,&D#$,G,%/( D=D/,G( &$,( .&H&Z',( ")( &HH$"H$0&/,'=( G,&D#$0%1( /F,( 0GH'0.0/h'&/,%/( W&$0&Z',DA( *"$,"W,$2( /F,( -W,$&1,( @&$0&%.,( E[/$&./,+( X-@EY( 0D( #D,+( /"( .&'.#'&/,( /F,( ,[H'&%&/"$=( H"N,$( ")( W&$0&%.,( Z,/N,,%( 0GH'0.0/h'&/,%/( W&$0&Z',D( W,$D#D( ,[H'0.0/hG&%0),D/( "%,Da( /F,( F01F,$( /F,( @E( W&'#,2( /F,( 1$,&/,$( /F,( $,'0&Z0'0/=(&%+(."%W,$1,%/(W&'0+0/=(")(&('&/,%/h0GH'0.0/(W&$0&Z',A(CD#&''=2(/F,(@E(W&'#,(G#D/(Z,('&$1,$(/F&%(?A7(/"( 0%+0.&/,(/F,(,[H'&%&/"$=(W&$0&%.,(")(&%(,[H'0.0/(W&$0&Z',(0D('&$1,$(/F&%(G,&D#$,G,%/(,$$"$(XU"$%,''(`(O&$.V,$2( 6b96YA( 3%( /F0D( D/#+=2( &''( -@ED( &$,( '&$1,$( /F&%( ?A72( F,%.,( /F,( ,[H'0.0/( W&$0&Z',D\( ,[.,'',%/( $,'0&Z0'0/=( &%+( ."%W,$1,%/(W&'0+0/=(X4,,(M&Z',(>(&%+(U01#$,(>YA(
M&Z',(>( Q1'?*"4-.34'85+-%&(.%=.P"+(1&"*"4-.R#(-"*.84.-:".P%'"0.
JZD,$W&Z',(W&$0&Z',De(
C%"ZD,$W&Z',h0GH'0.0/(W&$0&Z',D(
.,%/$&'0K,+(+#&'(G,&D#$,G,%/(
U&./"$('"&+0%1(
@&$0&%.,(,[/$&./,+(X@EY
?A;;( 3I(XLY(
?A;<( P$&%+(,R#0/=(XP%Y(
?A;B( L(m(P%(
?A;b( J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
S 6 6(
?A97(
S > 6(
?A98(
?A;9(
C435T(4E*(MJ(@E]3US(McE(3*L-IM4(JU(-IIC*CO-MEd(35MEOOEIMC-O(I-L3M-O( ;;7
Analyzing Fit of Structure Model
Path analysis results of structure model.(-)/,$(/F,("W,$&''(G"+,'(H&DD,+(/F,(1""+%,DD:"):)0/(/,D/2(M&Z',(<( DF"ND( D#.F( $,D#'/D( &D( /F,( H&$&G,/,$( ,D/0G&/,D2( 4AEA( &%+( I$0/0.&'( ]&/0"( XIA]AY( Z,/N,,%( 0GH'0.0/( W&$0&Z',DA( -/( M&0N&%( '0D/,+( Z0"/,.F( )0$GD2( 3I( &%+( Z$&%+( ,R#0/=( XL( m( P%Y( F&W,( D01%0)0.&%/( 0%/,$&./0W,( 0%)'#,%.,( "%( "$1&%0K&/0"%&'(,)),./0W,%,DD(XBY(X5(n(?A;9;YA(MF&/(0D2(&(."GH&%=(H'&%%0%1(/"(&..#G#'&/,(3I(0%("$+,$(/"(Z"'D/,$( "$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(DF"#'+(0%.$,&D,(Z$&%+(,R#0/=(&/(/F,(D&G,(/0G,()"$(D=%,$1=A(
M&Z',(<( T+-:.U4+0#(8(.A"(10-(.%=.-:".R-&15-1&+0.P%'"0.
L&/F(.",))0.0,%/D(Z,/N,,%(0GH'0.0/(W&$0&Z',D(
T. O&Z,'( 3I(XLY(
ED/0G&/,( 4AEA(
IA]A(
&( P$&%+(,R#0/=(XP%Y(
ĺ( J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
?A896(
?A?B<(
;A79b(
ooo(
Z( L(m(P%(
ĺ( J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
?A>b;(
.( ;%-"K( ooo (0%+0.&/,D(T(p(?A??6A(
ĺ( J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
Coefficient of determination.( -'D"( V%"N%( &D( 4R#&$,+( *#'/0H',( I"$$,'&/0"%( X4*IY2( /F,( I",))0.0,%/( ")( d,/,$G0%&/0"%( 0D( /F,( +,1$,,( ")( ,[H'&%&/"$=( H"N,$( ")( ^0%+,H,%+,%/( W&$0&Z',_( $,1&$+0%1( ^+,H,%+,%/( W&$0&Z',_(
#%+,$(,&.F(0GH'0.0/(W&$0&Z',A(3%("/F,$(N"$+D2(/F,(A > (W&'#,(DF"N%(0%(M&Z',D(8(&%+(7(XM&Z',(7(N&D(+,$0W,+()$"G( M&Z',( 8Y( 0%+0.&/,D( /F&/( /F,( 0GH'0.0/( 0%+,H,%+,%/( W&$0&Z',( F&D( &+,R#&/,( ,[H'&0%0%1( &Z0'0/=( "%( /F,( 0GH'0.0/(
+,H,%+,%/(W&$0&Z',($,DH,./0W,'=A(
M&Z',(8( 6%"==858"4-(. +V.2 V.F8"&+&5:85+0.A"?&"((8%4.
IF&%1,(D/&/0D/0.D( *"+,'( A. A(DR#&$,( -+f#D/,+(A(DR#&$,( /F,(,D/0G&/,
4/+A(,$$"$(")(
+)>( 401A(E(.F&%1, 6(
A(DR#&$,(.F&%1,( E(.F&%1, +)6(
bB( ?A???( >(
?A99B & ( ?AB99(
?ABB<(
?A<6B(
?AB9B(
6BbA>69( >(
b;( ?A??<( ;%-"(A( & (L$,+0./"$De(XI"%D/&%/Y2(P%2(&%+(La( Z (L$,+0./"$De(XI"%D/&%/Y2(P%2(L2(&%+(P%(m(LA(
?A9b7 Z ( ?A968(
M&Z',(7( 6%"==858"4-(.%=.W"-"&*84+-8%4.
3I(XLY2(P$&%+(,R#0/=(XP%Y(W,$D#D(J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
?AB99(
3I(XLY2(P$&%+(,R#0/=(XP%Y2(&%+(L(m(P%(W,$D#D(J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
?A968(
The Indices of Fit of the Overall Model
MF,(H#$H"D,(")(&+"H/0%1(4E*(0%(/F,(G"+,'0%1(HF&D,(")(/F0D(D/#+=(0D(/"(,[H'"$,(/F,($,'&/0"%DF0H(Z,/N,,%( #%"ZD,$W&Z',( W&$0&Z',D( N0/F0%( /F,( 4/$#./#$&'( *"+,'2( /"( ,[&G0%,( NF,/F,$( /F,( *,&D#$,G,%/( *"+,'( F&D( G,&D#$,G,%/($,'0&Z0'0/=("$(%"/2(&%+(&'D"(/"(G,&D#$,(/F,("W,$&''(1""+%,DD:"):)0/(,)),./D(")(/F0D(D/#+=(#D0%1(D#.F(
0%+0.,D(&D( > Ȥ 2(+A)A2(TU3(X1""+%,DD:"):)0/(0%+,[Y2(-TU3(X&+f#D/,+(1""+%,DD:"):)0/(0%+,[Y2(5U3(X%"$G,+()0/(0%+,[Y2( IU3( X."GH&$&/0W,( )0/( 0%+,[Y2( ]*]( X$""/( G,&%( DR#&$,( $,D0+#&'Y2( &%+( ]*4E-( X$""/( G,&%( DR#&$,( ,$$"$( ")(
&HH$"[0G&/0"%YA(3%(G"D/(.&D,D2(0/(0D($,R#0$,+(/F&/( > Ȥ h'K=K(p(72(6(q(XE3(q(?Ab2(6(q(;E3(q(?Ab2(6(q(6E3(q(?Ab2(APA( p( ?A?72( &%+( APRIU( p( ?A?7( XP&1"KK0( `( S02( 6b99YA( MF,( 1""+%,DD:"):)0/( ")( /F,( "W,$&''( G"+,'( 0%( /F0D( D/#+=( 0D(
;;;( C435T(4E*(MJ(@E]3US(McE(3*L-IM4(JU(-IIC*CO-MEd(35MEOOEIMC-O(I-L3M-O( D&/0D)=0%12(10W,%(/F,()&./(/F&/( > Ȥ h'K=K(p(7(&%+(XE32(UXE32(&%+(;E3(&$,(&''('&$1,$(/F&%(?Ab?2(N0/F(/F,(APA(W&'#,( DG&'',$(/F&%(?A?72(&D(DF"N%(0%(M&Z',(;A(
M&Z',(;( U(("((*"4-.%=.E8-.%=.-:".>/"&+00.P%'"0.
d,/,$G0%&/0"%(0%+,[( > Ȥ (
APA. APRIU. U0/(W&'#,(
?A?>7( ?A?>;(
Standardized Results of SEM Analysis
U01#$,(>(0%+0.&/,D(/F,($,D#'/(")(."GH#/,$:&0+,+(D/&%+&$+0K&/0"%(")(/F,(G"+,'\D("W,$&''()$&G,N"$Ve(
3I(XLY(
J$1&%0K&/0"%&'( " ?A8<(
?A<?
P$&%+(,R#0/=(XP%Y
H,$)"$G&%.,(XBY(
L(m(P%(
E8?1&".YA(4/&%+&$+0K,+($,D#'/D(")(4E*(&%&'=D0DA(
Analytical Testing of Path Effect for the Structural Model
U"$(/F,(/,D/(")(,[/$&%,"#D(W&$0&Z',2(/F0D(D/#+=(H,$)"$G,+(&(F0,$&$.F0.&'($,1$,DD0"%(&%&'=D0D(XD,,(M&Z',(8Y2( )"''"N,+( Z=( .,%/$&'0K,+( F0,$&$.F0.&'( $,1$,DD0"%( &%&'=D,D( &%+( -:/,D/D( ")( B( W,$D#D( L2( P%2( &%+( L( m( P%A( MF,D,( &%&'=D,D(N,$,(0%/,%+,+(/"(/,D/(NF,/F,$(/F,(D01%0)0.&%.,(")(H&$/0&':$,1$,DD0"%(.",))0.0,%/(5(0D(D#ZD/&%/0&/,+(X0A,A2( NF,/F,$(5(0D(K,$"("$(%"/YA(MF,(/,D/($,D#'/D(&$,(DF"N%(0%(M&Z',(BA(
C435T(4E*(MJ(@E]3US(McE(3*L-IM4(JU(-IIC*CO-MEd(35MEOOEIMC-O(I-L3M-O( ;;B
M&Z',(B( 6%"==858"4-(.
C%D/&%+&$+0K,+(.",))0.0,%/D(
4/&%+&$+0K,+(.",))0.0,%/D(
*"+,'(
401A( P(
6(XI"%D/&%/Y. <A96B(
?A???( L(
?A???( P%(
?A???( >(XI"%D/&%/Y(
;A997(
?A8>>(
?A>b;(
6<A<8<(
?A???( L(
?A???( P%(
bA6bB(
?A???( L(m(P%(
;A<B<(
?A66;(
?A>b;(
6<A<8<(
?A???( ;%-"A(d,H,%+,%/(W&$0&Z',e(J$1&%0K&/0"%&'(,)),./0W,%,DDXBYA(
67A8?B(
U$"G(M&Z',(B(N,(V%"N(/F&/(/F,(L&/F(I",))0.0,%/(")(P%(m(L(W,$D#D(B(0D(5(n(?A;9;(0%D/,&+(")(?2(0%+0.&/0%1( /F,(,[/$&%,"#D(,)),./(")(P%(m(L("%(BA( MF,(&Z"W,:G,%/0"%,+(&%&'=D0D(1,%,$&/,+(/F,()"''"N0%1(W,$0)0,+($,D#'/De( X6Y(3I(&..#G#'&/0"%(,[,$/D(&(H"D0/0W,(&%+(D01%0)0.&%/(,)),./("%("$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,(&/(M&0N&%('0D/,+(
Z0"/,.F()0$GD(N0/F(&(?A89(D/&%+&$+0K,+(H&/F(.",))0.0,%/(/F&/(D#HH"$/D(c6a( X>Y( MF,( 0%.$,&D,+( Z$&%+( ,R#0/=( ,[,$/D( &( H"D0/0W,( &%+( D01%0)0.&%/( ,)),./( "%( "$1&%0K&/0"%&'( H,$)"$G&%.,( &/( M&0N&%('0D/,+(Z0"/,.F()0$GD(N0/F(&(?A<?(D/&%+&$+0K,+(H&/F(.",))0.0,%/(/F&/(D#HH"$/D(c>a( X<Y( 3I( &..#G#'&/0"%( &%+( 0%.$,&D,+( Z$&%+( ,R#0/=( F&W,( H"D0/0W,( &%+( D01%0)0.&%/( 0%/,$&./0W,( 0%)'#,%.,( "%( "$1&%0K&/0"%&'(H,$)"$G&%.,2(N0/F(&(?A;b(D/&%+&$+0K,+(H&/F(.",))0.0,%/(/F&/(D#HH"$/D(c<A(