Pengaruh Konsentrasi Carboxy Methyl Cellulose dan Konsentrasi Gula Terhadap Mutu Selai Jagung
LAMPIRAN
Lampiran 1. Data pengamatan kadar airdan tabel sidik ragam kadar air
Data pengamatan kadar air
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
31,4260
29,3013
C1G1
31,0257
31,4177
C1G2
33,6295
31,9615
C1G3
34,3235
34,7486
C1G4
31,1025
32,0200
C2G1
32,0077
31,5750
C2G2
33,3894
32,5167
C2G3
35,1972
35,8093
C2G4
31,8449
33,5946
C3G1
36,6954
34,2854
C3G2
39,8652
36,9820
C3G3
39,9457
37,8260
C3G4
33,4416
34,7862
C4G1
35,4820
40,3591
C4G2
Total (%)
Rataan (%)
60,73
62,44
65,59
69,07
63,12
63,58
65,91
71,01
65,44
70,98
76,85
77,77
68,23
75,84
30,36
31,22
32,80
34,54
31,56
31,79
32,95
35,50
32,72
35,49
38,42
38,89
34,11
37,92
C4G3
43,8373
43,9353
87,77
43,89
C4G4
Total
Rataan
45,7345
43,0050
88,74
44,37
1133,07
35,41
Tabel sidik ragam kadar air
SK
db
JK
KT
F Hit.
15
546,1509 36,4101 18,0569
Perlakuan
3
310,7102 103,5701 51,3638
C
1
290,6909 290,6909 144,1632
C Lin
3
185,0871 61,6957 30,5969
G
1
181,6626 181,6626 90,0925
G Lin
9
50,3535
5,5948
2,7747
CxG
Galat
16
32,2624
2,0164
Total
31
578,4133
Keterangan : FK = 40120,3674
KK = 4,01%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
**
**
**
**
**
*
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 2. Data pengamatan kadar abu dan tabel sidik ragam kadar abu
Data pengamatan kadar abu
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
C1G1
C1G2
C1G3
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
0,28
0,32
0,36
0,42
0,37
0,42
0,47
0,55
0,45
0,50
0,55
0,61
0,63
0,74
0,84
0,97
0,29
0,35
0,38
0,42
0,40
0,43
0,49
0,56
0,45
0,55
0,57
0,62
0,58
0,70
0,85
0,93
Tabel sidik ragam kadar abu
SK
db
JK
15
1,0052
Perlakuan
3
0,7922
C
1
0,7387
C Lin
3
0,1800
G
1
0,1798
G Lin
9
0,0331
CxG
Galat
16
0,0059
Total
31
1,0111
Keterangan : FK = 9,0882
KK = 3,60%
** = Sangat nyata
Total (%)
Rataan (%)
0,57
0,68
0,74
0,83
0,76
0,85
0,96
1,11
0,90
1,05
1,12
1,23
1,21
1,45
1,69
1,90
17,05
0,29
0,34
0,37
0,42
0,38
0,43
0,48
0,55
0,45
0,52
0,56
0,62
0,61
0,72
0,85
0,95
0,53
KT
F Hit.
0,0670 182,3801
0,2641 718,5983
0,7387 2010,3195
0,0600 163,3071
0,1798 489,2731
0,0037
9,9984
0,0004
**
**
**
**
**
**
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 3. Data pengamtan kadar serat kasar dan tabel sidik ragam kadar serat
kasar
Data pengamatan kadar serat kasar
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
0,68
0,70
C1G1
0,71
0,78
C1G2
0,72
0,74
C1G3
0,77
0,80
C1G4
0,93
0,93
C2G1
0,88
0,90
C2G2
0,91
0,92
C2G3
0,98
0,97
C2G4
0,95
0,92
C3G1
0,94
0,99
C3G2
0,96
0,98
C3G3
0,91
0,94
C3G4
1,06
1,01
C4G1
1,03
1,05
C4G2
1,03
1,09
C4G3
1,01
1,09
C4G4
Total
Rataan
Total (%)
Rataan (%)
1,38
1,49
1,45
1,57
1,86
1,78
1,83
1,95
1,86
1,92
1,94
1,86
2,07
2,08
2,11
2,10
29,27
0,69
0,74
0,73
0,79
0,93
0,89
0,91
0,98
0,93
0,96
0,97
0,93
1,04
1,04
1,06
1,05
Tabel sidik ragam kadar serat kasar
SK
db
JK
KT
F.Hit
15
0,4203 0,0280 40,1334
Perlakuan
3
0,3991 0,1330 190,5295
C
1
0,3580 0,3580 512,6950
C Lin
3
0,0064 0,0021
3,0581
G
1
0,0063 0,0063
8,9523
G Lin
9
0,0148 0,0016
2,3598
CxG
Galat
16
0,0112 0,0007
Total
31
0,4315
Keterangan : FK = 26,7647
KK = 2,89%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
0,91
**
**
**
tn
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 4. Data pengamatan total mikroba dan tabel sidik ragam total mikroba
Data pengamatan total mikroba
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
5,98
C1G1
6,00
5,94
C1G2
5,99
Total
(log CFU/g)
Rataan
(log CFU/g)
11,98
11,93
5,989
5,965
C1G3
5,90
5,90
11,81
5,903
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
5,86
5,89
5,86
5,85
5,83
5,85
5,88
5,83
5,81
5,90
5,89
5,86
5,81
5,89
6,00
5,95
5,90
5,86
5,95
5,92
5,86
5,89
6,00
5,88
5,85
5,85
11,75
11,89
11,81
11,74
11,69
11,80
11,79
11,68
11,70
11,89
11,76
11,71
11,66
188,60
5,875
5,946
5,906
5,871
5,845
5,900
5,897
5,842
5,850
5,947
5,881
5,857
5,829
Tabel sidik ragam total mikroba
SK
db
JK
15
0,0672
Perlakuan
3
0,0180
C
1
0,0135
C Lin
3
0,0448
G
1
0,0438
G Lin
9
0,0044
CxG
Galat
16
0,0300
Total
31
0,0972
Keterangan : FK = 1111,6078
KK = 0,73%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
5,89
KT
0,0045
0,0060
0,0135
0,0149
0,0438
0,0005
0,0019
F.Hit
2,3865
3,2039
7,2039
7,9520
23,3637
0,2588
*
tn
*
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 5. Data pengamatan total padatan terlarut dan tabel sidik ragam total
padatan terlarut
Data pengamatan total padatan terlarut
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
38,31
C1G1
39,14
40,04
C1G2
39,47
48,05
43,37
C1G3
52,98
C1G4
48,83
37,87
C2G1
38,53
40,31
C2G2
43,53
46,34
C2G3
50,56
50,73
C2G4
54,02
41,93
38,83
C3G1
45,72
C3G2
48,44
47,38
C3G3
51,21
54,29
C3G4
51,71
44,86
41,38
C4G1
49,68
C4G2
47,48
54,41
C4G3
49,02
54,71
C4G4
53,33
Total
Rataan
Tabel Sidik ragam total padatan terlarut
SK
db
JK
KT
15
883,0892
58,8726
Perlakuan
3
144,5409
48,1803
C
1
143,7031 143,7031
C Lin
3
701,9631 233,9877
G
1
701,2400 701,2400
G Lin
9
36,5852
4,0650
CxG
Galat
16
82,8913
5,1807
Total
31
965,9805
Keterangan : FK = 69045,5211
KK = 4,90%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
Total
( Brix)
Rataan
(oBrix)
77,45
79,51
91,42
101,81
76,39
83,84
96,90
104,75
80,75
94,16
98,58
106,00
86,24
97,16
103,42
108,04
1486,42
38,724
39,755
45,710
50,905
38,196
41,920
48,449
52,376
40,376
47,078
49,292
52,998
43,119
48,581
51,712
54,019
o
46,45
F.Hit
11,3638
9,2999
27,7381
45,1652
135,3561
0,7846
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 6. Data pengamatan pH dan tabel sidik ragam pH
Data pengamatan pH
Perlakuan
C1G1
C1G2
C1G3
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Ulangan
I
4,622
4,513
4,545
4,586
4,545
4,610
4,646
4,675
4,610
4,614
4,636
4,678
4,709
4,716
4,707
4,712
II
4,661
4,623
4,595
4,596
4,554
4,611
4,685
4,660
4,641
4,650
4,728
4,749
4,612
4,783
4,813
4,827
Total
Rataan
Tabel sidik ragam pH
SK
db
15
Perlakuan
3
C
1
C Lin
Total
Rataan
9,283
9,136
9,140
9,182
9,099
9,221
9,331
9,335
9,251
9,264
9,364
9,427
9,321
9,499
9,520
9,539
148,9120
4,642
4,568
4,570
4,591
4,550
4,611
4,666
4,668
4,626
4,632
4,682
4,714
4,661
4,750
4,760
4,770
4,6535
JK
0,1421
0,0907
0,0871
KT
0,0095
0,0302
0,0871
F.Hit
4,2010
13,4057
38,6386
**
**
**
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
3
0,0210
G
1
0,0207
G Lin
9
0,0304
CxG
Galat
16
0,0361
Total
31
0,1782
Keterangan : FK = 692,9620
KK = 1,02%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
0,0070
3,1018
tn
3,24
5,29
0,0207
0,0034
0,0023
9,1996
1,4992
**
tn
4,49
2,54
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 7. Data pengamatan nilai hedonikwarna dan tabel sidik ragam nilai
hedonik warna
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,60
3,80
C1G1
4,20
4,33
C1G2
Total
(numerik)
Rataan
(numerik)
7,40
8,53
3,700
4,267
C1G3
4,20
4,07
8,27
4,133
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
4,13
3,73
4,07
4,53
4,60
3,53
4,00
3,13
4,33
3,93
3,07
3,93
4,20
4,20
3,73
3,93
4,40
4,67
3,47
4,07
4,33
4,07
3,87
3,80
4,00
4,20
8,33
7,47
8,00
8,93
9,27
7,00
8,07
7,47
8,40
7,80
6,87
7,93
8,40
128,1333
4,167
3,733
4,000
4,467
4,633
3,500
4,033
3,733
4,200
3,900
3,433
3,967
4,200
4,0042
Tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik warna
SK
db
JK
KT
15
3,2617
0,2174
Perlakuan
3
0,6494
0,2165
C
1
0,3361
0,3361
C Lin
3
1,4806
G
1
1,4694
G Lin
9
1,1317
CxG
Galat
16
1,0933
Total
31
4,3550
Keterangan : FK = 513,0672
KK = 6,53%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
F.Hit
3,1821
3,1680
4,9187
*
tn
*
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
0,4935
7,2222
**
3,24
5,29
1,4694
0,1257
0,0683
21,5041
1,8401
**
tn
4,49
2,54
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 8. Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma dan tabel sidik ragam nilai
hedonik aroma
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,87
3,67
C1G1
4,13
3,80
C1G2
Total
(numerik)
7,53
7,93
Rataan
(numerik)
3,767
3,967
C1G3
4,00
4,20
8,20
4,100
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
4,07
4,00
3,93
4,13
4,00
3,73
4,00
3,40
3,13
4,07
4,20
3,67
8,07
7,40
7,07
8,20
8,20
7,40
4,033
3,700
3,533
4,100
4,100
3,700
C3G2
3,60
3,53
7,13
3,567
C3G3
3,40
3,93
7,33
3,667
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
4,13
4,27
3,60
3,53
4,13
3,93
3,40
3,73
3,93
3,60
8,07
7,67
7,33
7,47
7,73
122,7333
4,033
3,833
3,667
3,733
3,867
3,8354
Tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik aroma
SK
db
JK
KT
15
1,1576
0,0772
Perlakuan
3
0,2415
0,0805
C
1
0,1914
0,1914
C Lin
3
0,5160
G
1
0,3934
G Lin
9
0,4001
CxG
Galat
16
1,3933
Total
31
2,5510
Keterangan : FK = 470,7335
KK = 7,69%
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
F.Hit
0,8862
0,9245
2,1974
tn
tn
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
0,1720
1,9750
tn
3,24
5,29
0,3934
0,0445
0,0871
4,5171
0,5105
*
tn
4,49
2,54
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 9. Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik
rasa
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,67
3,67
C1G1
3,93
4,00
C1G2
Total
(numerik)
Rataan
(numerik)
7,33
7,93
3,667
3,967
C1G3
4,13
3,93
8,07
4,033
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
4,20
4,07
4,13
4,20
4,40
3,87
4,07
3,87
4,47
4,13
4,33
3,80
4,47
3,93
3,73
3,93
4,20
4,33
3,87
3,93
4,20
4,33
3,87
4,20
4,53
4,27
8,13
7,80
8,07
8,40
8,73
7,73
8,00
8,07
8,80
8,00
8,53
8,33
8,73
130,6667
4,067
3,900
4,033
4,200
4,367
3,867
4,000
4,033
4,400
4,000
4,267
4,167
4,367
Tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik rasa
SK
db
JK
15
1,2089
Perlakuan
3
0,3033
C
1
0,2250
C Lin
3
0,7878
G
1
0,7471
G Lin
9
0,1178
CxG
Galat
16
0,5422
Total
31
1,7511
Keterangan : FK = 533,5556
KK = 4,51%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
4,0833
KT
0,0806
0,1011
0,2250
0,2626
0,7471
0,0131
0,0339
F.Hit
2,3781
2,9836
6,6393
7,7486
22,0459
0,3862
*
tn
*
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
Universitas Sumatera Utara
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Lampiran 10. Data pengamatan nilai skor tekstur dan tabel sidik ragam nilai skor
tekstur
Data pengamatan nilai skor tekstur
Perlakuan
C1G1
C1G2
C1G3
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Ulangan
Total
(numerik)
Rataan
(numerik)
5,93
6,53
7,13
7,87
6,33
6,87
7,73
7,93
6,47
7,07
7,33
7,93
7,40
2,967
3,267
3,567
3,933
3,167
3,433
3,867
3,967
3,233
3,533
3,667
3,967
3,700
I
3,13
3,20
3,53
3,80
3,27
3,60
3,60
3,93
3,13
3,60
3,80
4,13
3,73
II
2,80
3,33
3,60
4,07
3,07
3,27
4,13
4,00
3,33
3,47
3,53
3,80
3,67
3,53
3,80
7,33
3,667
3,67
4,40
4,07
4,13
7,73
8,53
3,867
4,267
116,1333
Rataan
Tabel sidik ragam nilai skor tekstur
SK
db
JK
15
3,6794
Perlakuan
3
0,8006
C
1
0,6934
C Lin
3
2,6494
G
1
2,6351
G Lin
9
0,2294
CxG
Galat
16
0,5956
Total
31
4,2750
Keterangan : FK = 421,4672
KK = 5,32%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
3,6292
KT
0,2453
0,2669
0,6934
0,8831
2,6351
0,0255
0,0372
F.Hit
6,5900
7,1692
18,6299
23,7264
70,7940
0,6849
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
Universitas Sumatera Utara
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Lampiran 11. Data pengamatan nilai daya oles dan tabel sidik ragam nilai daya
oles
Data pengamatan nilai daya oles
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,0
3,3
C1G1
3,5
3,7
C1G2
3,6
3,6
C1G3
3,4
4,0
C1G4
4,5
4,0
C2G1
4,7
4,3
C2G2
5,0
4,5
C2G3
4,9
4,7
C2G4
5,2
5,0
C3G1
5,5
4,9
C3G2
5,6
5,6
C3G3
5,8
5,5
C3G4
6,0
5,8
C4G1
5,5
5,8
C4G2
6,3
6,0
C4G3
6,8
6,5
C4G4
Total
Rataan
Tabel sidik ragam nilai daya oles
SK
db
JK
15
31,7322
Perlakuan
3
29,4259
C
1
29,1556
C Lin
3
1,7734
G
1
1,7431
G Lin
9
0,5328
CxG
Galat
16
0,9950
Total
31
32,7272
Keterangan : FK = 765,3828
KK = 5,10%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
Total
(cm)
Rataan
(cm)
6,30
7,20
7,20
7,40
8,50
9,00
9,50
9,60
10,20
10,40
11,20
11,30
11,80
11,30
12,30
13,30
156,5000
3,150
3,600
3,600
3,700
4,250
4,500
4,750
4,800
5,100
5,200
5,600
5,650
5,900
5,650
6,150
6,650
4,8906
KT
2,1155
9,8086
29,1556
0,5911
1,7431
0,0592
0,0622
F.Hit
34,0178
157,7270
468,8332
9,5059
28,0291
0,9520
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
Universitas Sumatera Utara
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Lampiran 12. Gambar Produk
C1G1U1
C1G2U1
C1G3U1
C2G1U1
C2G2U1
C2G3U1
C3G1U1
C3G2U1
C3G3U1
C4G1U1
C4G2U1
C1G4U1
C2G4U1
C3G4U1
C4G4U1
C4G3U1
Universitas Sumatera Utara
C1G1U2
C1G2U2
C1G3U2
C1G4U2
C2G1U2
C2G2U2
C2G3U2
C2G4U2
C3G1U2
C3G2U2
C3G3U2
C3G4U2
C4G1U2
C4G2U2
C4G3U2
C4G4U2
Keterangan : C1 = CMC 0,25%, C2 = CMC 0,50%, C 3= CMC 0,75%,
C4 = CMC 1,00%,G1 = Gula 30%, G2 = Gula 40%,
G3 = Gula 50%, G4 = Gula 60%,U1= Ulangan 1, dan
U2 = Ulangan 2.
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 1. Data pengamatan kadar airdan tabel sidik ragam kadar air
Data pengamatan kadar air
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
31,4260
29,3013
C1G1
31,0257
31,4177
C1G2
33,6295
31,9615
C1G3
34,3235
34,7486
C1G4
31,1025
32,0200
C2G1
32,0077
31,5750
C2G2
33,3894
32,5167
C2G3
35,1972
35,8093
C2G4
31,8449
33,5946
C3G1
36,6954
34,2854
C3G2
39,8652
36,9820
C3G3
39,9457
37,8260
C3G4
33,4416
34,7862
C4G1
35,4820
40,3591
C4G2
Total (%)
Rataan (%)
60,73
62,44
65,59
69,07
63,12
63,58
65,91
71,01
65,44
70,98
76,85
77,77
68,23
75,84
30,36
31,22
32,80
34,54
31,56
31,79
32,95
35,50
32,72
35,49
38,42
38,89
34,11
37,92
C4G3
43,8373
43,9353
87,77
43,89
C4G4
Total
Rataan
45,7345
43,0050
88,74
44,37
1133,07
35,41
Tabel sidik ragam kadar air
SK
db
JK
KT
F Hit.
15
546,1509 36,4101 18,0569
Perlakuan
3
310,7102 103,5701 51,3638
C
1
290,6909 290,6909 144,1632
C Lin
3
185,0871 61,6957 30,5969
G
1
181,6626 181,6626 90,0925
G Lin
9
50,3535
5,5948
2,7747
CxG
Galat
16
32,2624
2,0164
Total
31
578,4133
Keterangan : FK = 40120,3674
KK = 4,01%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
**
**
**
**
**
*
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 2. Data pengamatan kadar abu dan tabel sidik ragam kadar abu
Data pengamatan kadar abu
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
C1G1
C1G2
C1G3
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
0,28
0,32
0,36
0,42
0,37
0,42
0,47
0,55
0,45
0,50
0,55
0,61
0,63
0,74
0,84
0,97
0,29
0,35
0,38
0,42
0,40
0,43
0,49
0,56
0,45
0,55
0,57
0,62
0,58
0,70
0,85
0,93
Tabel sidik ragam kadar abu
SK
db
JK
15
1,0052
Perlakuan
3
0,7922
C
1
0,7387
C Lin
3
0,1800
G
1
0,1798
G Lin
9
0,0331
CxG
Galat
16
0,0059
Total
31
1,0111
Keterangan : FK = 9,0882
KK = 3,60%
** = Sangat nyata
Total (%)
Rataan (%)
0,57
0,68
0,74
0,83
0,76
0,85
0,96
1,11
0,90
1,05
1,12
1,23
1,21
1,45
1,69
1,90
17,05
0,29
0,34
0,37
0,42
0,38
0,43
0,48
0,55
0,45
0,52
0,56
0,62
0,61
0,72
0,85
0,95
0,53
KT
F Hit.
0,0670 182,3801
0,2641 718,5983
0,7387 2010,3195
0,0600 163,3071
0,1798 489,2731
0,0037
9,9984
0,0004
**
**
**
**
**
**
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 3. Data pengamtan kadar serat kasar dan tabel sidik ragam kadar serat
kasar
Data pengamatan kadar serat kasar
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
0,68
0,70
C1G1
0,71
0,78
C1G2
0,72
0,74
C1G3
0,77
0,80
C1G4
0,93
0,93
C2G1
0,88
0,90
C2G2
0,91
0,92
C2G3
0,98
0,97
C2G4
0,95
0,92
C3G1
0,94
0,99
C3G2
0,96
0,98
C3G3
0,91
0,94
C3G4
1,06
1,01
C4G1
1,03
1,05
C4G2
1,03
1,09
C4G3
1,01
1,09
C4G4
Total
Rataan
Total (%)
Rataan (%)
1,38
1,49
1,45
1,57
1,86
1,78
1,83
1,95
1,86
1,92
1,94
1,86
2,07
2,08
2,11
2,10
29,27
0,69
0,74
0,73
0,79
0,93
0,89
0,91
0,98
0,93
0,96
0,97
0,93
1,04
1,04
1,06
1,05
Tabel sidik ragam kadar serat kasar
SK
db
JK
KT
F.Hit
15
0,4203 0,0280 40,1334
Perlakuan
3
0,3991 0,1330 190,5295
C
1
0,3580 0,3580 512,6950
C Lin
3
0,0064 0,0021
3,0581
G
1
0,0063 0,0063
8,9523
G Lin
9
0,0148 0,0016
2,3598
CxG
Galat
16
0,0112 0,0007
Total
31
0,4315
Keterangan : FK = 26,7647
KK = 2,89%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
0,91
**
**
**
tn
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 4. Data pengamatan total mikroba dan tabel sidik ragam total mikroba
Data pengamatan total mikroba
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
5,98
C1G1
6,00
5,94
C1G2
5,99
Total
(log CFU/g)
Rataan
(log CFU/g)
11,98
11,93
5,989
5,965
C1G3
5,90
5,90
11,81
5,903
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
5,86
5,89
5,86
5,85
5,83
5,85
5,88
5,83
5,81
5,90
5,89
5,86
5,81
5,89
6,00
5,95
5,90
5,86
5,95
5,92
5,86
5,89
6,00
5,88
5,85
5,85
11,75
11,89
11,81
11,74
11,69
11,80
11,79
11,68
11,70
11,89
11,76
11,71
11,66
188,60
5,875
5,946
5,906
5,871
5,845
5,900
5,897
5,842
5,850
5,947
5,881
5,857
5,829
Tabel sidik ragam total mikroba
SK
db
JK
15
0,0672
Perlakuan
3
0,0180
C
1
0,0135
C Lin
3
0,0448
G
1
0,0438
G Lin
9
0,0044
CxG
Galat
16
0,0300
Total
31
0,0972
Keterangan : FK = 1111,6078
KK = 0,73%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
5,89
KT
0,0045
0,0060
0,0135
0,0149
0,0438
0,0005
0,0019
F.Hit
2,3865
3,2039
7,2039
7,9520
23,3637
0,2588
*
tn
*
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 5. Data pengamatan total padatan terlarut dan tabel sidik ragam total
padatan terlarut
Data pengamatan total padatan terlarut
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
38,31
C1G1
39,14
40,04
C1G2
39,47
48,05
43,37
C1G3
52,98
C1G4
48,83
37,87
C2G1
38,53
40,31
C2G2
43,53
46,34
C2G3
50,56
50,73
C2G4
54,02
41,93
38,83
C3G1
45,72
C3G2
48,44
47,38
C3G3
51,21
54,29
C3G4
51,71
44,86
41,38
C4G1
49,68
C4G2
47,48
54,41
C4G3
49,02
54,71
C4G4
53,33
Total
Rataan
Tabel Sidik ragam total padatan terlarut
SK
db
JK
KT
15
883,0892
58,8726
Perlakuan
3
144,5409
48,1803
C
1
143,7031 143,7031
C Lin
3
701,9631 233,9877
G
1
701,2400 701,2400
G Lin
9
36,5852
4,0650
CxG
Galat
16
82,8913
5,1807
Total
31
965,9805
Keterangan : FK = 69045,5211
KK = 4,90%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
Total
( Brix)
Rataan
(oBrix)
77,45
79,51
91,42
101,81
76,39
83,84
96,90
104,75
80,75
94,16
98,58
106,00
86,24
97,16
103,42
108,04
1486,42
38,724
39,755
45,710
50,905
38,196
41,920
48,449
52,376
40,376
47,078
49,292
52,998
43,119
48,581
51,712
54,019
o
46,45
F.Hit
11,3638
9,2999
27,7381
45,1652
135,3561
0,7846
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 6. Data pengamatan pH dan tabel sidik ragam pH
Data pengamatan pH
Perlakuan
C1G1
C1G2
C1G3
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Ulangan
I
4,622
4,513
4,545
4,586
4,545
4,610
4,646
4,675
4,610
4,614
4,636
4,678
4,709
4,716
4,707
4,712
II
4,661
4,623
4,595
4,596
4,554
4,611
4,685
4,660
4,641
4,650
4,728
4,749
4,612
4,783
4,813
4,827
Total
Rataan
Tabel sidik ragam pH
SK
db
15
Perlakuan
3
C
1
C Lin
Total
Rataan
9,283
9,136
9,140
9,182
9,099
9,221
9,331
9,335
9,251
9,264
9,364
9,427
9,321
9,499
9,520
9,539
148,9120
4,642
4,568
4,570
4,591
4,550
4,611
4,666
4,668
4,626
4,632
4,682
4,714
4,661
4,750
4,760
4,770
4,6535
JK
0,1421
0,0907
0,0871
KT
0,0095
0,0302
0,0871
F.Hit
4,2010
13,4057
38,6386
**
**
**
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
3
0,0210
G
1
0,0207
G Lin
9
0,0304
CxG
Galat
16
0,0361
Total
31
0,1782
Keterangan : FK = 692,9620
KK = 1,02%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
0,0070
3,1018
tn
3,24
5,29
0,0207
0,0034
0,0023
9,1996
1,4992
**
tn
4,49
2,54
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 7. Data pengamatan nilai hedonikwarna dan tabel sidik ragam nilai
hedonik warna
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,60
3,80
C1G1
4,20
4,33
C1G2
Total
(numerik)
Rataan
(numerik)
7,40
8,53
3,700
4,267
C1G3
4,20
4,07
8,27
4,133
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
4,13
3,73
4,07
4,53
4,60
3,53
4,00
3,13
4,33
3,93
3,07
3,93
4,20
4,20
3,73
3,93
4,40
4,67
3,47
4,07
4,33
4,07
3,87
3,80
4,00
4,20
8,33
7,47
8,00
8,93
9,27
7,00
8,07
7,47
8,40
7,80
6,87
7,93
8,40
128,1333
4,167
3,733
4,000
4,467
4,633
3,500
4,033
3,733
4,200
3,900
3,433
3,967
4,200
4,0042
Tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik warna
SK
db
JK
KT
15
3,2617
0,2174
Perlakuan
3
0,6494
0,2165
C
1
0,3361
0,3361
C Lin
3
1,4806
G
1
1,4694
G Lin
9
1,1317
CxG
Galat
16
1,0933
Total
31
4,3550
Keterangan : FK = 513,0672
KK = 6,53%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
F.Hit
3,1821
3,1680
4,9187
*
tn
*
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
0,4935
7,2222
**
3,24
5,29
1,4694
0,1257
0,0683
21,5041
1,8401
**
tn
4,49
2,54
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 8. Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma dan tabel sidik ragam nilai
hedonik aroma
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,87
3,67
C1G1
4,13
3,80
C1G2
Total
(numerik)
7,53
7,93
Rataan
(numerik)
3,767
3,967
C1G3
4,00
4,20
8,20
4,100
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
4,07
4,00
3,93
4,13
4,00
3,73
4,00
3,40
3,13
4,07
4,20
3,67
8,07
7,40
7,07
8,20
8,20
7,40
4,033
3,700
3,533
4,100
4,100
3,700
C3G2
3,60
3,53
7,13
3,567
C3G3
3,40
3,93
7,33
3,667
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
4,13
4,27
3,60
3,53
4,13
3,93
3,40
3,73
3,93
3,60
8,07
7,67
7,33
7,47
7,73
122,7333
4,033
3,833
3,667
3,733
3,867
3,8354
Tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik aroma
SK
db
JK
KT
15
1,1576
0,0772
Perlakuan
3
0,2415
0,0805
C
1
0,1914
0,1914
C Lin
3
0,5160
G
1
0,3934
G Lin
9
0,4001
CxG
Galat
16
1,3933
Total
31
2,5510
Keterangan : FK = 470,7335
KK = 7,69%
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
F.Hit
0,8862
0,9245
2,1974
tn
tn
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
0,1720
1,9750
tn
3,24
5,29
0,3934
0,0445
0,0871
4,5171
0,5105
*
tn
4,49
2,54
8,53
3,78
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 9. Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik
rasa
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,67
3,67
C1G1
3,93
4,00
C1G2
Total
(numerik)
Rataan
(numerik)
7,33
7,93
3,667
3,967
C1G3
4,13
3,93
8,07
4,033
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Rataan
4,20
4,07
4,13
4,20
4,40
3,87
4,07
3,87
4,47
4,13
4,33
3,80
4,47
3,93
3,73
3,93
4,20
4,33
3,87
3,93
4,20
4,33
3,87
4,20
4,53
4,27
8,13
7,80
8,07
8,40
8,73
7,73
8,00
8,07
8,80
8,00
8,53
8,33
8,73
130,6667
4,067
3,900
4,033
4,200
4,367
3,867
4,000
4,033
4,400
4,000
4,267
4,167
4,367
Tabel sidik ragam nilai hedonik rasa
SK
db
JK
15
1,2089
Perlakuan
3
0,3033
C
1
0,2250
C Lin
3
0,7878
G
1
0,7471
G Lin
9
0,1178
CxG
Galat
16
0,5422
Total
31
1,7511
Keterangan : FK = 533,5556
KK = 4,51%
** = Sangat nyata
* = Nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
4,0833
KT
0,0806
0,1011
0,2250
0,2626
0,7471
0,0131
0,0339
F.Hit
2,3781
2,9836
6,6393
7,7486
22,0459
0,3862
*
tn
*
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
Universitas Sumatera Utara
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Lampiran 10. Data pengamatan nilai skor tekstur dan tabel sidik ragam nilai skor
tekstur
Data pengamatan nilai skor tekstur
Perlakuan
C1G1
C1G2
C1G3
C1G4
C2G1
C2G2
C2G3
C2G4
C3G1
C3G2
C3G3
C3G4
C4G1
C4G2
C4G3
C4G4
Total
Ulangan
Total
(numerik)
Rataan
(numerik)
5,93
6,53
7,13
7,87
6,33
6,87
7,73
7,93
6,47
7,07
7,33
7,93
7,40
2,967
3,267
3,567
3,933
3,167
3,433
3,867
3,967
3,233
3,533
3,667
3,967
3,700
I
3,13
3,20
3,53
3,80
3,27
3,60
3,60
3,93
3,13
3,60
3,80
4,13
3,73
II
2,80
3,33
3,60
4,07
3,07
3,27
4,13
4,00
3,33
3,47
3,53
3,80
3,67
3,53
3,80
7,33
3,667
3,67
4,40
4,07
4,13
7,73
8,53
3,867
4,267
116,1333
Rataan
Tabel sidik ragam nilai skor tekstur
SK
db
JK
15
3,6794
Perlakuan
3
0,8006
C
1
0,6934
C Lin
3
2,6494
G
1
2,6351
G Lin
9
0,2294
CxG
Galat
16
0,5956
Total
31
4,2750
Keterangan : FK = 421,4672
KK = 5,32%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
3,6292
KT
0,2453
0,2669
0,6934
0,8831
2,6351
0,0255
0,0372
F.Hit
6,5900
7,1692
18,6299
23,7264
70,7940
0,6849
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
Universitas Sumatera Utara
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Lampiran 11. Data pengamatan nilai daya oles dan tabel sidik ragam nilai daya
oles
Data pengamatan nilai daya oles
Ulangan
Perlakuan
I
II
3,0
3,3
C1G1
3,5
3,7
C1G2
3,6
3,6
C1G3
3,4
4,0
C1G4
4,5
4,0
C2G1
4,7
4,3
C2G2
5,0
4,5
C2G3
4,9
4,7
C2G4
5,2
5,0
C3G1
5,5
4,9
C3G2
5,6
5,6
C3G3
5,8
5,5
C3G4
6,0
5,8
C4G1
5,5
5,8
C4G2
6,3
6,0
C4G3
6,8
6,5
C4G4
Total
Rataan
Tabel sidik ragam nilai daya oles
SK
db
JK
15
31,7322
Perlakuan
3
29,4259
C
1
29,1556
C Lin
3
1,7734
G
1
1,7431
G Lin
9
0,5328
CxG
Galat
16
0,9950
Total
31
32,7272
Keterangan : FK = 765,3828
KK = 5,10%
** = Sangat nyata
tn = Tidak nyata
Total
(cm)
Rataan
(cm)
6,30
7,20
7,20
7,40
8,50
9,00
9,50
9,60
10,20
10,40
11,20
11,30
11,80
11,30
12,30
13,30
156,5000
3,150
3,600
3,600
3,700
4,250
4,500
4,750
4,800
5,100
5,200
5,600
5,650
5,900
5,650
6,150
6,650
4,8906
KT
2,1155
9,8086
29,1556
0,5911
1,7431
0,0592
0,0622
F.Hit
34,0178
157,7270
468,8332
9,5059
28,0291
0,9520
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F 0.05
2,35
3,24
4,49
3,24
4,49
2,54
Universitas Sumatera Utara
F 0.01
3,41
5,29
8,53
5,29
8,53
3,78
Lampiran 12. Gambar Produk
C1G1U1
C1G2U1
C1G3U1
C2G1U1
C2G2U1
C2G3U1
C3G1U1
C3G2U1
C3G3U1
C4G1U1
C4G2U1
C1G4U1
C2G4U1
C3G4U1
C4G4U1
C4G3U1
Universitas Sumatera Utara
C1G1U2
C1G2U2
C1G3U2
C1G4U2
C2G1U2
C2G2U2
C2G3U2
C2G4U2
C3G1U2
C3G2U2
C3G3U2
C3G4U2
C4G1U2
C4G2U2
C4G3U2
C4G4U2
Keterangan : C1 = CMC 0,25%, C2 = CMC 0,50%, C 3= CMC 0,75%,
C4 = CMC 1,00%,G1 = Gula 30%, G2 = Gula 40%,
G3 = Gula 50%, G4 = Gula 60%,U1= Ulangan 1, dan
U2 = Ulangan 2.
Universitas Sumatera Utara