commit to user
2. Students cannot answer inference Q well
• Ss can answer inference Q well • Ss can complete the exercise quicker
3. Students cannot identify the paragraph topic
• Ss can identify the paragraph topic • Ss can complete the exercise quicker
4. Students cannot identify the mean idea
• Ss can identify the mean idea • Ss can complete the exercise quicker
5. Student’s mean score was 57 • Ss’ mean score in pre-test 68
• Ss’ mean score in post-test 72
6. Ss needed extra time to complete the task • Ss complete the task on time
7. Ss hesitated to guess the meaning of new words
• Ss were confident to guess the new words 8.
Ss hesitated to share their ideas • Ss were confident to share their ideas
B. Classroom situation when teaching using
directed reading implemented
Before the implementation of directed reading After the implementation of directed reading
9. Students has low motivation • Ss had high motivation
10. Students don’t like reading • Students love reading
11. Students culture awareness is low • Students culture awareness is high
12. Students interested is low • Students interested is high
13. Students come without their reading material • Students bring their reading material
14. Students talk about unrelated topic • Students talk about related topic
15. Students do not ask question • Ss ask many questions to the teacher and
their peers 16. Students do not participate in discuss
• Students participate in discuss eagerly 17. Student do the exercises reluctantly
• Student do the exercises without being asked
18. Teacher dominated in choosing the topic • Ss chose their reading topic
19. Teacher did monotonous pre-reading activity • Teacher did vary pre-reading activity
20. Teacher always uses the text book • Teacher uses vary the text book, materials
21. Teacher has no sense in selecting materials • Teacher improve on selecting texts
commit to user The improvement of students’ reading comprehension and class situation in
table 4.7 because the students paid attention and interested in reading texts which have connection with their likes so they are familiar with the topics. When the topic
talks about Boun Bang Fai that is a Laos’ culture, the students felt familiar with the topic. This is the comment of student Lattana says
“ ວ ຊ
ົ ວ
ລ ວ ຍ ູ ລ ມ
ຽ ລ ຍ”
“if the reading text was taken from the cultures know well and like it” furthermore during the implementation of directed
reading text the students have learn al lots of vocabulary and translate in to second language. By having an adequate vocabulary the students are easier to comprehend
the text.
“ ວ ຊ
ົ ໜ
ພ ມ ຍ ູ ລ ຄ
ໍ ຍ, ຍ ມ
ົ ”
“if the reading text was taken from newspaper I know, I can read it easier and can guess the meaning”
When directed reading was implemented the students read a lot of kind of texts and as a result the students’ vocabulary increased rapidly. The students used
many strategies in learning vocabulary during the teaching learning process. Furthermore the students’ motivation was increased amazingly as a result the class
situation got much better when the directed reading were implemented, motivation to reading the text, to know that what is the text about, to know what does the writer
want to say in the text. The motivation here is the key to encourage themselves to participate in reading skill.
The improvement of the students after directed reading implemented also can be seen in the result of Post-tests. There were two post-tests; Post-test 1 was the post-
test after cycle 1 completed and Post-test 2 was completed. The result of Post-test described in the Table 4.16.
commit to user t
s t
h t
c d
c
T
GradeSco A80-100
B70-79 C60-69
D50-59 F0-49
Mean scor
Number o Students
The test 1 is 68
students and the result of
higher than the t-table 2
concluded th directed read
comprehens
Grap Table 4.16 T
re Pre-tes
3 5
5 4
13
re
of 3
table above and the me
d the mean s f the t-test for
the t-table 2.02 at the d
hat there is s ding compre
ion is show
phi
c
4.17 Th
50 100
The Score o
st percenta
10.0 16.0
16.0 13.3
43.3
57
30 Students
shows the m ean score o
score was fr r non indepe
2.02, and i degree of sig
significant d ehension. Th
in the graph
he mean Sco Pre
Test, of Pre-test, P
age Post-test
6 6
10 6
2
3
mean score p of post-test 2
rom the total endent score
in cycle 2 th gnificant a 0
difference be he students’
hic below.
ore of Pre-te Post Test I,
Post-test 1 a
t 1 percenta
20.0 20.0
33.3 20.0
6.7
68
0 Students
pre-test is 57 2 is 72. The
l of score an , the t-comp
he t-computa .05, so
etween them mean score
est, Post-tes Post
Test II and Post-tes
age Post-test
7 8
10 15
30
7, the mean e total of st
nd divided b putation in cy
ation 2.81 ,
is rej m. It can be c
e improvem
st 1 and Pos st 2
t 2 percentag
23.3 26.7
33.3 16.7
0.0
72
0 Students
score of po tudent was
by 30. Base ycle 1 5.75
is higher th jected and it
concluded th ment of readi
t-test 2
Students of
30
ge
st- 30
on is
han t is
hat ing
Students of
30
commit to user It showed that the students’ reading comprehension is increasing significantly.
The students’ confidences in doing the exercises are increased, also the correctness and time efficiency. Before the directed reading was implemented the students always
needed extra time to complete the exercise and the correctness of their answers was low.
The finding of teaching learning process described there were some changes before and after the directed reading implemented in reading class. During the
implementation of directed reading the teaching learning process was inspiring and exciting; many students asked questions about the topic that make the class alive,
there were enthusiastic among the students about new vocabulary and try to guess the meaning including the shy students. Just before they share their work with their peers,
one of the shy student say
“ ຍ ູ ໜ
ມ ຄວ ມ ວໜ
ູ ມ”
“I were the one toward in presenting in the group” this situation made me over the moon. At that time the topic was Boat Racing festival.
When the text relevant to students’ life implemented, the students were more confidence and motivated to read and comprehends the text and directed reading
provide that better when students choose their own topic in reading. There were many marvelous students’ comments about the teaching learning process using directed
reading. Student P says “now the reading class is interesting and inspiring especially the text taken from internet and newspaper that related with my live, culture and we
can choose the topic”. The student S says “I enjoy the reading class very much”, he is one of the students who were low in English language. Almost everybody stated in
their interview that they enjoy reading class. Even better all of them spoke in English. The result of the questionnaire supported the using of directed reading in
reading was fun and interesting. The student stated that they enjoyed and motivated to read more. The result of the questionnaire can be seen in Table 4.18
commit to user
Table 4.18 The Result of Questionnaires
No Questionnaires Students’ response
Percentage 1 Text
in reading
take from internet, newspaper are interesting
always 100 2
Using directed reading make the students comprehend the text easier and need
more always
usually sometime
50 35
15
3 The length using directed reading make
the students interested, enjoy in reading the text
always usually
70 30
4 The topic connects with students’ lives
and they can follow usually
sometime 70
20 5
The text from the internet, newspaper and magazine are related to their live
rarely sometime
85 15
6 The students can choose their own topic
always 100 7
Using directed reading increase their vocabulary
always sometime
80 20
8 The text from the internet, newspaper,
magazine and other book is convenience always
sometime 70
30 9
They want the teacher to use the text from the internet, newspaper, magazine
and other books always
sometime 95
5 10
Usage directed reading in teaching reading motivate students to study more
reading comprehension always
usually 90
10
The table above showed that the students had positive attitude about using directed reading in reading skill. The students loved having reading class; they could
not wait to have reading class so when a student who was low in English language says “Mr. Souk I never learn English well like this before”. Besides they could
improve their reading comprehension, they also got the update information about
commit to user what is going on around them so they have an intrinsic educational value. The most
important thing is the students love reading.
C. Discussion