Pengaruh Perbandingan Sari Bengkoang dengan Sari Asam Jawa Dan Jenis Zat Penstabil Terhadap Mutu Sirup Asam Jawa
72
Lampiran 1
Data pengamatan analisa kadar vitamin C (mg/100 g)
Ulangan
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
I
II
14,3288
14,7609
14,5341
15,2170
15,3087
15,6264
15,9801
16,4027
16,5232
17,6166
17,9168
17,3652
19,0221
19,2191
18,9556
14,7805
14,6641
14,6122
15,3371
15,7889
15,3954
16,2421
16,3309
16,0216
17,7407
17,4322
17,8011
18,3668
19,0064
18,9015
Total
Rataan
29,1093
29,4250
29,1463
30,5541
31,0976
31,0218
32,2222
32,7336
32,5448
35,3573
35,3490
35,1663
37,3889
38,2255
37,8571
14,5547
14,7125
14,5732
15,2771
15,5488
15,5109
16,1111
16,3668
16,2724
17,6787
17,6745
17,5832
18,6945
19,1128
18,9286
497,1988
Total
Rataan
16,5733
Data sidik ragam kadar vitamin C (mg/100 g)
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
14
4
1
1
2
1
1
8
JK
KT
71,386
71,015
139,886
1,826
0,242
0,061
0,181
0,129
5,099
17,754
139,886
1,826
0,121
0,061
0,181
0,016
15
0,881
29
72,267
Keterangan:
FK = 8.240,222
KK = 1,462%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
0,059
F hit.
86,860
302,430
2382,903
31,102
2,059
1,039
3,079
0,275
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
73
Lampiran 2
Data pengamatan analisa total padatan terlarut (ᴼBrix)
Ulangan
Perlakuan
Total
Rataan
I
II
80,20
40,10
S1P1
40,00
40,20
81,00
40,50
S1P2
40,60
40,40
81,20
40,60
S1P3
40,40
40,80
73,20
36,60
S2P1
36,00
37,20
73,60
36,80
S2P2
37,20
36,40
76,40
38,20
S2P3
36,40
40,00
73,20
36,60
S3P1
37,20
36,00
72,40
36,20
S3P2
36,00
36,40
72,40
36,20
S3P3
36,40
36,00
66,60
33,30
S4P1
33,40
33,20
66,20
33,10
S4P2
33,40
32,80
66,40
33,20
S4P3
33,60
32,80
62,60
31,30
S5P1
31,20
31,40
63,00
31,50
S5P2
31,40
31,60
63,40
31,70
S5P3
31,60
31,80
Total
Rataan
1071,80
35,73
Daftar Sidik Ragam Total Padatan Terlarut (ᴼBrix)
SK
db
JK
KT
F hit.
Perlakuan
14
295,499
21,107
34,792 **
S
4
291,765
72,941
120,233 **
S Lin
1
570,288
570,288
940,035 **
S Kuad
1
0,461
0,461
0,760 tn
P
2
0,971
0,485
0,800 tn
P Lin
1
0,800
0,800
1,319 tn
P Kuad
1
0,171
0,171
0,281 tn
SxP
8
2,763
0,345
0,569 tn
Galat
15
9,100
0,607
Total
29
304,599
Keterangan:
FK = 38.291,841
KK = 2,180%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
74
Lampiran 3.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar total asam (%)
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
Total
Rataan
Ulangan
I
II
0,6832 0,6456
0,6342 0,6654
0,6234 0,6390
0,6291 0,6096
0,6296 0,6586
0,6286 0,6549
0,6049 0,6249
0,6195 0,6254
0,6054 0,6152
0,5653 0,5819
0,5419 0,5845
0,5345 0,5647
0,5247 0,5553
0,5253 0,5555
0,5010 0,5421
Total
Rataan
1,3288
1,2996
1,2624
1,2387
1,2882
1,2835
1,2298
1,2449
1,2206
1,1472
1,1264
1,0992
1,0800
1,0808
1,0431
0,6644
0,6498
0,6312
0,6194
0,6441
0,6418
0,6149
0,6225
0,6103
0,5736
0,5632
0,5496
0,5400
0,5404
0,5216
17,9732
0,5991
Data sidik ragam total asam (%)
SK
db
JK
KT
Perlakuan
14
0,061
0,004
S
4
0,058
0,014
S Lin
1
0,109
0,109
S Kuad
1
0,004
0,004
P
2
0,001
0,001
P Lin
1
0,001
0,001
P Kuad
1
0,0004
0,0004
SxP
8
0,002
0,00025
Galat
15
0,006
0,0004
Total
29
0,067
Keterangan:
FK = 10,768
KK = 3,284%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F hit.
11,210
37,269
282,508
9,085
1,326
1,728
0,924
0,652
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
75
Lampiran 4.
Data Pengamatan viskositas (mPa.s)
Ulangan
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
I
II
36
30
36
34
26
30
32
24
30
28
24
30
28
22
26
36
28
34
34
28
36
30
20
32
32
22
28
28
24
24
Total
Rataan
72
58
70
68
54
66
62
44
62
60
46
58
56
46
50
36,0
29,0
35,0
34,0
27,0
33,0
31,0
22,0
31,0
30,0
23,0
29,0
28,0
23,0
25,0
872
Total
Rataan
29,067
Daftar analisis viskositas (mPa.s)
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
JK
14
553,867
4
248,533
1
240,000
1
3,048
2
280,267
1
7,200
1
273,067
8
25,067
15
52,000
29
605,867
Keterangan:
FK = 25.346,133
KK = 6,406%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
KT
39,562
62,133
240,000
3,048
140,133
7,200
273,067
3,133
3,467
F hit.
11,412
17,923
69,231
0,879
40,423
2,077
78,769
0,904
**
**
**
tn
**
tn
**
tn
F.05
2,32
3,06
4,54
4,54
3,68
4,54
4,54
2,64
F.01
3,37
4,89
8,68
8,68
6,36
8,68
8,68
4,00
Universitas Sumatera Utara
76
Lampiran 5.
Data pengamatan nilai pH
Perlakuan
Ulangan
I
II
S1P1
2,614
2,686
S1P2
2,657
2,690
S1P3
2,614
2,701
S2P1
2,668
2,684
S2P2
2,708
2,729
S2P3
2,743
2,729
S3P1
2,802
2,733
S3P2
2,805
2,772
S3P3
2,842
2,775
S4P1
2,902
2,801
S4P2
2,918
2,826
S4P3
2,921
2,843
S5P1
3,041
2,901
S5P2
3,061
2,910
S5P3
3,086
2,916
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
5,300 2,650
5,347 2,674
5,315 2,658
5,352 2,676
5,437 2,719
5,472 2,736
5,535 2,768
5,577 2,789
5,617 2,809
5,703 2,852
5,744 2,872
5,764 2,882
5,942 2,971
5,971 2,986
6,002 3,001
84,078
2,803
Daftar analisis data pH
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
0,409
0,029
4
0,401
0,100
1
0,393
0,393
1
0,008
0,008
2
0,006
0,003
1
0,006
0,006
1
0,000 0,0004
8
0,002 0,0002
15
0,061
0,004
29
0,470
Keterangan:
FK = 235,637
KK = 2,267%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F hit.
7,243 **
24,858 **
97,341 **
2,002 tn
0,754 tn
1,415 tn
0,093 tn
0,057 tn
F.05
2,32
3,06
4,54
4,54
3,68
4,54
4,54
2,64
F.01
3,37
4,89
8,68
8,68
6,36
8,68
8,68
4,00
Universitas Sumatera Utara
77
Lampiran 6.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
Total
Rataan
I
II
4,2000
3,8667
4,1333
4,0667
3,8000
3,8000
3,7333
3,8667
3,6000
3,4667
3,4000
3,6000
3,5333
3,5333
3,2000
4,2000
4,4000
3,9333
3,8000
4,0000
3,9333
3,8667
3,6667
3,8000
3,6000
3,5333
3,3333
3,3333
3,2000
3,4000
Total
Rataan
8,4000
8,2667
8,0667
7,8667
7,8000
7,7333
7,6000
7,5333
7,4000
7,0667
6,9333
6,9333
6,8667
6,7333
6,6000
4,2000
4,1333
4,0333
3,9333
3,9000
3,8667
3,8000
3,7667
3,7000
3,5333
3,4667
3,4667
3,4333
3,3667
3,3000
111,8000
3,7267
Daftar sidik ragam nilai hedonik warna
SK
db
JK
KT
F hit.
Perlakuan
14
2,308
0,165
5,825
S
4
2,241
0,560 19,798
S Lin
1
4,434
4,434 156,696
S Kuad
1
0,005
0,005
0,183
P
2
0,057
0,028
1,005
P Lin
1
0,057
0,057
2,010
P Kuad
1
0,000
0,000
0,000
SxP
8
0,010
0,001
0,043
Galat
15
0,424
0,028
Total
29
2,732
Keterangan:
FK = 416,641
KK = 4,514%
** = sangat nyata
tn = tidak nyata
**
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
78
Lampiran 7.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
Total
I
II
8,2667
S1P1
3,9333 4,3333
8,0000
S1P2
3,8667 4,1333
8,1333
S1P3
3,9333 4,2000
8,0000
S2P1
3,7333 4,2667
7,9333
S2P2
3,8000 4,1333
7,8000
S2P3
3,8667 3,9333
7,5333
S3P1
4,0000 3,5333
7,2000
S3P2
3,5333 3,6667
6,5333
S3P3
3,2667 3,2667
6,0000
S4P1
2,9333 3,0667
5,8667
S4P2
3,0000 2,8667
5,8000
S4P3
2,8667 2,9333
5,4667
S5P1
2,8667 2,6000
5,0667
S5P2
2,5333 2,5333
4,8000
S5P3
2,2667 2,5333
Total
Rataan
Rataan
4,1333
4,0000
4,0667
4,0000
3,9667
3,9000
3,7667
3,6000
3,2667
3,0000
2,9333
2,9000
2,7333
2,5333
2,4000
102,4000
3,4133
Daftar sidik ragam nilai hedonik aroma
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
10,572
0,755
4
10,162
2,541
1
19,521
19,521
1
0,475
0,475
2
0,243
0,121
1
0,242
0,242
1
0,001
0,001
8
0,168
0,021
15
0,560
0,037
29
11,132
Keterangan:
FK = 349,525
KK = 5,661%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F hit.
20,228
68,050
522,893
12,724
3,250
6,482
0,018
0,562
**
**
**
**
tn
*
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
79
Lampiran 8.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
Total
I
II
8,47
S1P1
4,33
4,13
8,40
S1P2
4,27
4,13
8,33
S1P3
4,27
4,07
8,20
S2P1
4,13
4,07
8,13
S2P2
4,00
4,13
8,00
S2P3
4,00
4,00
7,93
S3P1
4,00
3,93
7,93
S3P2
4,00
3,93
7,80
S3P3
3,87
3,93
7,53
S4P1
3,80
3,73
7,47
S4P2
3,73
3,73
6,87
S4P3
3,33
3,53
6,53
S5P1
3,40
3,13
5,87
S5P2
2,87
3,00
5,20
S5P3
2,60
2,60
Total
Rataan
Rataan
4,23
4,20
4,17
4,10
4,07
4,00
3,97
3,97
3,90
3,77
3,73
3,43
3,27
2,93
2,60
112,67
3,76
Daftar sidik ragam nilai hedonik rasa
SK
db
JK
KT
F hit.
Perlakuan
14
6,670
0,476
53,595
S
4
6,070
1,517 170,708
S Lin
1
10,404
10,404 1170,417
S Kuad
1
1,499
1,499 168,583
P
2
0,313
0,157
17,617
P Lin
1
0,304
0,304
34,225
P Kuad
1
0,009
0,009
1,008
SxP
8
0,287
0,036
4,033
Galat
15
0,133
0,009
Total
29
6,803
**
**
**
**
**
**
tn
**
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Keterangan:
FK = 423,126
KK = 2,510%
** = sangat nyata
tn = tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
80
Lampiran 9
Data pengamatan bahan baku
Gizi/sari
Kadar Vitamin C (mg/100 g bahan)
Total asam (%)
Total padatan terlarut
pH
Bengkoang
87,26
4
5,914
Asam jawa
1,25
8
2,069
Universitas Sumatera Utara
81
Lampiran 10
Foto Produk
S1P1U1
S1P2U1
S1P3U1
S2P1U1
S2P2U1
S1P3U1
S3P1U1
S3P2U1
S3P3U1
S4P1U1
S4P2U1
S4P3U1
S5P1U1
S5P2U1
S5P3U1
Keterangan : S = Perbandingan sari bengkoang dengan sari asam jawa
S1 = 30% : 70%
S2 = 40% : 60%
S3 = 50% : 50%
S4 = 60%: 40%
S5 = 70% : 30%
Jenis zat penstabil : P1 = Xanthan gum
P2 = Gum arab
P3 = Guar gum
Universitas Sumatera Utara
82
S1P1,P2,P3,U2
S2P1,P2,P3,U2
S4P1,P2,P3,U2
S3P1,P2,P3,U2
S5P1,P2,P3,U2
Keterangan:
Keterangan : S = Perbandingan sari bengkoang dengan sari asam jawa
S1 = 30% : 70%
S2 = 40% : 60%
S3 = 50% : 50%
S4 = 60%: 40%
S5 = 70% : 30%
Jenis zat penstabil :
P1 = Xanthan gum
P2 = Gum arab
P3 = Guar gum
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 1
Data pengamatan analisa kadar vitamin C (mg/100 g)
Ulangan
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
I
II
14,3288
14,7609
14,5341
15,2170
15,3087
15,6264
15,9801
16,4027
16,5232
17,6166
17,9168
17,3652
19,0221
19,2191
18,9556
14,7805
14,6641
14,6122
15,3371
15,7889
15,3954
16,2421
16,3309
16,0216
17,7407
17,4322
17,8011
18,3668
19,0064
18,9015
Total
Rataan
29,1093
29,4250
29,1463
30,5541
31,0976
31,0218
32,2222
32,7336
32,5448
35,3573
35,3490
35,1663
37,3889
38,2255
37,8571
14,5547
14,7125
14,5732
15,2771
15,5488
15,5109
16,1111
16,3668
16,2724
17,6787
17,6745
17,5832
18,6945
19,1128
18,9286
497,1988
Total
Rataan
16,5733
Data sidik ragam kadar vitamin C (mg/100 g)
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
14
4
1
1
2
1
1
8
JK
KT
71,386
71,015
139,886
1,826
0,242
0,061
0,181
0,129
5,099
17,754
139,886
1,826
0,121
0,061
0,181
0,016
15
0,881
29
72,267
Keterangan:
FK = 8.240,222
KK = 1,462%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
0,059
F hit.
86,860
302,430
2382,903
31,102
2,059
1,039
3,079
0,275
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
73
Lampiran 2
Data pengamatan analisa total padatan terlarut (ᴼBrix)
Ulangan
Perlakuan
Total
Rataan
I
II
80,20
40,10
S1P1
40,00
40,20
81,00
40,50
S1P2
40,60
40,40
81,20
40,60
S1P3
40,40
40,80
73,20
36,60
S2P1
36,00
37,20
73,60
36,80
S2P2
37,20
36,40
76,40
38,20
S2P3
36,40
40,00
73,20
36,60
S3P1
37,20
36,00
72,40
36,20
S3P2
36,00
36,40
72,40
36,20
S3P3
36,40
36,00
66,60
33,30
S4P1
33,40
33,20
66,20
33,10
S4P2
33,40
32,80
66,40
33,20
S4P3
33,60
32,80
62,60
31,30
S5P1
31,20
31,40
63,00
31,50
S5P2
31,40
31,60
63,40
31,70
S5P3
31,60
31,80
Total
Rataan
1071,80
35,73
Daftar Sidik Ragam Total Padatan Terlarut (ᴼBrix)
SK
db
JK
KT
F hit.
Perlakuan
14
295,499
21,107
34,792 **
S
4
291,765
72,941
120,233 **
S Lin
1
570,288
570,288
940,035 **
S Kuad
1
0,461
0,461
0,760 tn
P
2
0,971
0,485
0,800 tn
P Lin
1
0,800
0,800
1,319 tn
P Kuad
1
0,171
0,171
0,281 tn
SxP
8
2,763
0,345
0,569 tn
Galat
15
9,100
0,607
Total
29
304,599
Keterangan:
FK = 38.291,841
KK = 2,180%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
74
Lampiran 3.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar total asam (%)
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
Total
Rataan
Ulangan
I
II
0,6832 0,6456
0,6342 0,6654
0,6234 0,6390
0,6291 0,6096
0,6296 0,6586
0,6286 0,6549
0,6049 0,6249
0,6195 0,6254
0,6054 0,6152
0,5653 0,5819
0,5419 0,5845
0,5345 0,5647
0,5247 0,5553
0,5253 0,5555
0,5010 0,5421
Total
Rataan
1,3288
1,2996
1,2624
1,2387
1,2882
1,2835
1,2298
1,2449
1,2206
1,1472
1,1264
1,0992
1,0800
1,0808
1,0431
0,6644
0,6498
0,6312
0,6194
0,6441
0,6418
0,6149
0,6225
0,6103
0,5736
0,5632
0,5496
0,5400
0,5404
0,5216
17,9732
0,5991
Data sidik ragam total asam (%)
SK
db
JK
KT
Perlakuan
14
0,061
0,004
S
4
0,058
0,014
S Lin
1
0,109
0,109
S Kuad
1
0,004
0,004
P
2
0,001
0,001
P Lin
1
0,001
0,001
P Kuad
1
0,0004
0,0004
SxP
8
0,002
0,00025
Galat
15
0,006
0,0004
Total
29
0,067
Keterangan:
FK = 10,768
KK = 3,284%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F hit.
11,210
37,269
282,508
9,085
1,326
1,728
0,924
0,652
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
75
Lampiran 4.
Data Pengamatan viskositas (mPa.s)
Ulangan
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
I
II
36
30
36
34
26
30
32
24
30
28
24
30
28
22
26
36
28
34
34
28
36
30
20
32
32
22
28
28
24
24
Total
Rataan
72
58
70
68
54
66
62
44
62
60
46
58
56
46
50
36,0
29,0
35,0
34,0
27,0
33,0
31,0
22,0
31,0
30,0
23,0
29,0
28,0
23,0
25,0
872
Total
Rataan
29,067
Daftar analisis viskositas (mPa.s)
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
JK
14
553,867
4
248,533
1
240,000
1
3,048
2
280,267
1
7,200
1
273,067
8
25,067
15
52,000
29
605,867
Keterangan:
FK = 25.346,133
KK = 6,406%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
KT
39,562
62,133
240,000
3,048
140,133
7,200
273,067
3,133
3,467
F hit.
11,412
17,923
69,231
0,879
40,423
2,077
78,769
0,904
**
**
**
tn
**
tn
**
tn
F.05
2,32
3,06
4,54
4,54
3,68
4,54
4,54
2,64
F.01
3,37
4,89
8,68
8,68
6,36
8,68
8,68
4,00
Universitas Sumatera Utara
76
Lampiran 5.
Data pengamatan nilai pH
Perlakuan
Ulangan
I
II
S1P1
2,614
2,686
S1P2
2,657
2,690
S1P3
2,614
2,701
S2P1
2,668
2,684
S2P2
2,708
2,729
S2P3
2,743
2,729
S3P1
2,802
2,733
S3P2
2,805
2,772
S3P3
2,842
2,775
S4P1
2,902
2,801
S4P2
2,918
2,826
S4P3
2,921
2,843
S5P1
3,041
2,901
S5P2
3,061
2,910
S5P3
3,086
2,916
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
5,300 2,650
5,347 2,674
5,315 2,658
5,352 2,676
5,437 2,719
5,472 2,736
5,535 2,768
5,577 2,789
5,617 2,809
5,703 2,852
5,744 2,872
5,764 2,882
5,942 2,971
5,971 2,986
6,002 3,001
84,078
2,803
Daftar analisis data pH
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
0,409
0,029
4
0,401
0,100
1
0,393
0,393
1
0,008
0,008
2
0,006
0,003
1
0,006
0,006
1
0,000 0,0004
8
0,002 0,0002
15
0,061
0,004
29
0,470
Keterangan:
FK = 235,637
KK = 2,267%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F hit.
7,243 **
24,858 **
97,341 **
2,002 tn
0,754 tn
1,415 tn
0,093 tn
0,057 tn
F.05
2,32
3,06
4,54
4,54
3,68
4,54
4,54
2,64
F.01
3,37
4,89
8,68
8,68
6,36
8,68
8,68
4,00
Universitas Sumatera Utara
77
Lampiran 6.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
S1P1
S1P2
S1P3
S2P1
S2P2
S2P3
S3P1
S3P2
S3P3
S4P1
S4P2
S4P3
S5P1
S5P2
S5P3
Total
Rataan
I
II
4,2000
3,8667
4,1333
4,0667
3,8000
3,8000
3,7333
3,8667
3,6000
3,4667
3,4000
3,6000
3,5333
3,5333
3,2000
4,2000
4,4000
3,9333
3,8000
4,0000
3,9333
3,8667
3,6667
3,8000
3,6000
3,5333
3,3333
3,3333
3,2000
3,4000
Total
Rataan
8,4000
8,2667
8,0667
7,8667
7,8000
7,7333
7,6000
7,5333
7,4000
7,0667
6,9333
6,9333
6,8667
6,7333
6,6000
4,2000
4,1333
4,0333
3,9333
3,9000
3,8667
3,8000
3,7667
3,7000
3,5333
3,4667
3,4667
3,4333
3,3667
3,3000
111,8000
3,7267
Daftar sidik ragam nilai hedonik warna
SK
db
JK
KT
F hit.
Perlakuan
14
2,308
0,165
5,825
S
4
2,241
0,560 19,798
S Lin
1
4,434
4,434 156,696
S Kuad
1
0,005
0,005
0,183
P
2
0,057
0,028
1,005
P Lin
1
0,057
0,057
2,010
P Kuad
1
0,000
0,000
0,000
SxP
8
0,010
0,001
0,043
Galat
15
0,424
0,028
Total
29
2,732
Keterangan:
FK = 416,641
KK = 4,514%
** = sangat nyata
tn = tidak nyata
**
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
78
Lampiran 7.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
Total
I
II
8,2667
S1P1
3,9333 4,3333
8,0000
S1P2
3,8667 4,1333
8,1333
S1P3
3,9333 4,2000
8,0000
S2P1
3,7333 4,2667
7,9333
S2P2
3,8000 4,1333
7,8000
S2P3
3,8667 3,9333
7,5333
S3P1
4,0000 3,5333
7,2000
S3P2
3,5333 3,6667
6,5333
S3P3
3,2667 3,2667
6,0000
S4P1
2,9333 3,0667
5,8667
S4P2
3,0000 2,8667
5,8000
S4P3
2,8667 2,9333
5,4667
S5P1
2,8667 2,6000
5,0667
S5P2
2,5333 2,5333
4,8000
S5P3
2,2667 2,5333
Total
Rataan
Rataan
4,1333
4,0000
4,0667
4,0000
3,9667
3,9000
3,7667
3,6000
3,2667
3,0000
2,9333
2,9000
2,7333
2,5333
2,4000
102,4000
3,4133
Daftar sidik ragam nilai hedonik aroma
SK
Perlakuan
S
S Lin
S Kuad
P
P Lin
P Kuad
SxP
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
10,572
0,755
4
10,162
2,541
1
19,521
19,521
1
0,475
0,475
2
0,243
0,121
1
0,242
0,242
1
0,001
0,001
8
0,168
0,021
15
0,560
0,037
29
11,132
Keterangan:
FK = 349,525
KK = 5,661%
** = sangat nyata
* = nyata
tn = tidak nyata
F hit.
20,228
68,050
522,893
12,724
3,250
6,482
0,018
0,562
**
**
**
**
tn
*
tn
tn
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Universitas Sumatera Utara
79
Lampiran 8.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
Total
I
II
8,47
S1P1
4,33
4,13
8,40
S1P2
4,27
4,13
8,33
S1P3
4,27
4,07
8,20
S2P1
4,13
4,07
8,13
S2P2
4,00
4,13
8,00
S2P3
4,00
4,00
7,93
S3P1
4,00
3,93
7,93
S3P2
4,00
3,93
7,80
S3P3
3,87
3,93
7,53
S4P1
3,80
3,73
7,47
S4P2
3,73
3,73
6,87
S4P3
3,33
3,53
6,53
S5P1
3,40
3,13
5,87
S5P2
2,87
3,00
5,20
S5P3
2,60
2,60
Total
Rataan
Rataan
4,23
4,20
4,17
4,10
4,07
4,00
3,97
3,97
3,90
3,77
3,73
3,43
3,27
2,93
2,60
112,67
3,76
Daftar sidik ragam nilai hedonik rasa
SK
db
JK
KT
F hit.
Perlakuan
14
6,670
0,476
53,595
S
4
6,070
1,517 170,708
S Lin
1
10,404
10,404 1170,417
S Kuad
1
1,499
1,499 168,583
P
2
0,313
0,157
17,617
P Lin
1
0,304
0,304
34,225
P Kuad
1
0,009
0,009
1,008
SxP
8
0,287
0,036
4,033
Galat
15
0,133
0,009
Total
29
6,803
**
**
**
**
**
**
tn
**
F.05
2,320
3,060
4,540
4,540
3,680
4,540
4,540
2,640
F.01
3,370
4,890
8,680
8,680
6,360
8,680
8,680
4,000
Keterangan:
FK = 423,126
KK = 2,510%
** = sangat nyata
tn = tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
80
Lampiran 9
Data pengamatan bahan baku
Gizi/sari
Kadar Vitamin C (mg/100 g bahan)
Total asam (%)
Total padatan terlarut
pH
Bengkoang
87,26
4
5,914
Asam jawa
1,25
8
2,069
Universitas Sumatera Utara
81
Lampiran 10
Foto Produk
S1P1U1
S1P2U1
S1P3U1
S2P1U1
S2P2U1
S1P3U1
S3P1U1
S3P2U1
S3P3U1
S4P1U1
S4P2U1
S4P3U1
S5P1U1
S5P2U1
S5P3U1
Keterangan : S = Perbandingan sari bengkoang dengan sari asam jawa
S1 = 30% : 70%
S2 = 40% : 60%
S3 = 50% : 50%
S4 = 60%: 40%
S5 = 70% : 30%
Jenis zat penstabil : P1 = Xanthan gum
P2 = Gum arab
P3 = Guar gum
Universitas Sumatera Utara
82
S1P1,P2,P3,U2
S2P1,P2,P3,U2
S4P1,P2,P3,U2
S3P1,P2,P3,U2
S5P1,P2,P3,U2
Keterangan:
Keterangan : S = Perbandingan sari bengkoang dengan sari asam jawa
S1 = 30% : 70%
S2 = 40% : 60%
S3 = 50% : 50%
S4 = 60%: 40%
S5 = 70% : 30%
Jenis zat penstabil :
P1 = Xanthan gum
P2 = Gum arab
P3 = Guar gum
Universitas Sumatera Utara