93 explanation that LKS Formatif 1 consisted of three chapters. The result of the analysis
is as seen on the table above. According to the categorization, the LKS Formatif 1‟s
achievement is on the good level of achievement. Next result is the representation of the LKS
Formatif 2‟s achievement in fulfilling the technical requirement. There are five chapters on this LKS. The result is
presented on the table below.
Table 4.8 LKS Formatif 2’s fulfillment on technical requirement
LKS Formatif 2 Fulfillment
Evaluating aspect Chap.1
Chap.2 Chap.3
Chap.4 Chap.5
1. The topic should be bold and
the font size is bigger 1
1 1
1 1
2. Using short sentence. No
more than 10 words in one sentence
3. Using frame to differentiate
the instructional 1
1 1
1 1
4. The comparison between
picture and the words is harmonious
1 1
1 1
5. Using appropriate picture
1 1
1 1
Total percentage 80
80 80
40 80
Average percentage 72
Each chapter has the same percentage except for chapter 4. Chapter 1, 2, 3, and 5 fulfill this requirement until 80. Chapter 4 only fulfills this requirement by
40. Chapter 1, 2, 3, and 5 fulfill 4 out of 5 criteria. They only miss the point on the second criterion on this requirement. The average percentage of the LKS Formatif 2
in fulfilling technical requirement places it into fair level of achievement.
94 The last one is the achievement which is done by the LKS Formatif 3 in
fulfilling the technique requirement. The result of the analysis is as seen on the table below. There are 7 chapters on this LKS.
Table 4.9 LKS Formatif 3 fulfillment on technique requirement
LKS Formatif 3
Fulfillment Evaluating aspect
Chap.1 Chap.2
Chap.3 Chap.4
Chap.5 Chapt.6
Chap.7 1.
The topic should be bold and the font
size is bigger
1 1
1 1
1 1
1
2. Using short
sentence. No more than 10 words in one
sentence 3.
Using frame to differentiate the
instructional
1 1
1 1
1 1
1
4. The comparison
between picture and the words is
harmonious
1 1
1 1
1 1
5. Using appropriate
picture
1 1
1 1
1 1
Total percentage
80 80
80 80
80 40
80
Average percentage
74,28
The data which is presented above shows that the higher percentage achieved by the LKS Formatif 3 is 80. The lowest achievement in fulfilling this requirement
is on the same number as the LKS Formatif 2 which is 40. The highest achievement is one chapter 1, 2, 4, 5, and 7. The lowest percentage is achieved by chapter 6.
1. The topics should be bold and the font is bigger
All of the English LKS which are analyzed by the researcher show a perfect achievement in fulfilling this criterion. From the total numbers of the chapters in
95 these LKS, each one of them fulfills this criterion well. Based on the finding, the
researcher gives each chapter 1 point due to the perfect achievement. The comparison between the topics‟ letter size and the ordinary explanation
letter size is as seen in the following picture. Each topic in every chapter is given a special treatment. Special treatment here means that each of them is given a frame.
The following picture is taken from LKS Formatif 2. It is the picture of the first chapter of the second LKS. This LKS Formatif 2 is used by XI grade of vocational
high school students.
Figure 4.51 The front size of the topic
Another point is that these three English LKS show a great consistency in way of writing down the topic in the same font type and also same letter size. Each topic is
written with bigger size and in the bold mode.
2. Using short sentence
According to the research finding, all three LKS Formatif failed in fulfilling this point. The result finding shows that all of these three English LKS have not
fulfilled this criterion. The researcher found that these three LKS had a tendency to
