Hasil Kuisioner KESIMPULAN DAN SARAN

BAB 4 IMPLEMENTASI DAN PENGUJIAN

4.1 Hasil Kuisioner

Dalam penelitian ini penulis mengambil beberapa sample sebagai salah satu dasar pengujian dalam melakukan perhitungan Metode AHP dan Metode SAW, adapun sample yang dilakukan penulis yaitu dengan menyebarkan kuisioner di kalangan mahasiswa Fasilkom-TI sebanyak 40 Responden. Adapun hasil rangkuman keseluruhan dari kuisioner yang didapat oleh penulis yaitu sebagai berikut : 4.1.1 Nilai Perbandingan Tiap Matriks pada Metode AHP Tabel 4.1 Nilai Perbandingan Kriteria Tabel 4.2 Nilai Perbandingan Alternatif untuk Kriteria Tarif Telepon Tarif Telepon Tarif Telepon = 1 Simpati Simpati = 1 Tarif Telepon SMS = 0.333 Simpati AS = 7 Tarif Telepon Internet = 0.333 Simpati IM3 = 3 Tarif Telepon Layanan = 2 Simpati XL = 4 Tarif Telepon Bonus = 4 Simpati 3 Three = 3 SMS SMS = 1 Simpati Mentari = 8 SMS Internet = 2 Simpati AXIS = 3 SMS Layanan = 4 AS AS = 1 SMS Bonus = 6 AS IM3 = 0.2 Internet Intenet = 1 AS XL = 0.333 Universitas Sumatera Utara Internet Layanan = 3 AS 3 Three = 0.2 Internet Bonus = 5 AS Mentari = 2 Layanan Layanan = 1 AS AXIS = 0.2 Layanan Bonus = 3 IM3 IM3 = 1 Bonus Bonus = 1 IM3 XL = 2 IM3 3 Three = 1 IM3 Mentari = 6 IM3 AXIS = 1 XL XL = 1 XL 3Three = 0.5 XL Mentari = 5 XL AXIS = 0.2 3Three 3 Three = 1 3 Three Mentari = 6 3 Three AXIS = 1 Mentari Mentari = 1 Mentari AXIS = 0.166 AXIS AXIS = 1 Tabel 4.3 Nilai Perbandingan Alternatif untuk Kriteria SMS Tabel 4.4 Nilai Perbandingan Alternatif untuk Kriteria Internet Simpati Simpati = 1 Simpati Simpati = 1 Simpati AS = 0.5 Simpati AS = 6 Universitas Sumatera Utara Simpati IM3 = 0.125 Simpati IM3 = 6 Simpati XL = 0.142 Simpati XL = 4 Simpati 3 Three = 0.25 Simpati 3 Three = 2 Simpati Mentari = 2 Simpati Mentari = 8 Simpati AXIS = 0.2 Simpati AXIS = 9 AS AS = 1 AS AS = 1 AS IM3 = 2 AS IM3 = 1 AS XL = 0.2 AS XL = 0.333 AS 3 Three = 0.5 AS 3 Three = 0.2 AS Mentari = 4 AS Mentari = 3 AS AXIS = 0.333 AS AXIS = 4 IM3 IM3 = 1 IM3 IM3 = 1 IM3 XL = 2 IM3 XL = 0.333 IM3 3 Three = 5 IM3 3 Three = 0.2 IM3 Mentari = 9 IM3 Mentari = 3 IM3 AXIS = 4 IM3 AXIS = 4 XL XL = 1 XL XL = 1 XL 3Three = 4 XL 3Three = 0.333 XL Mentari = 8 XL Mentari = 5 XL AXIS = 3 XL AXIS = 6 3Three 3 Three = 1 3Three 3 Three = 1 3 Three Mentari = 5 3 Three Mentari = 7 Universitas Sumatera Utara 3 Three AXIS = 0.5 3 Three AXIS = 8 Mentari Mentari = 1 Mentari Mentari = 1 Mentari AXIS = 0.166 Mentari AXIS = 2 AXIS AXIS = 1 AXIS AXIS = 1 Tabel 4.5 Nilai Perbandingan Alternatif untuk Kriteria Layanan Tabel 4.6 Nilai Perbandingan Alternatif untuk Kriteria Bonus Simpati Simpati = 1 Simpati Simpati = 1 Simpati AS = 2 Simpati AS = 3 Simpati IM3 = 8 Simpati IM3 = 0.5 Simpati XL = 4 Simpati XL = 0.25 Simpati 3 Three = 9 Simpati 3 Three = 5 Simpati Mentari = 4 Simpati Mentari = 6 Simpati AXIS = 4 Simpati AXIS = 0.5 AS AS = 1 AS AS = 1 AS IM3 = 7 AS IM3 = 0.25 AS XL = 3 AS XL = 0.166 AS 3 Three = 8 AS 3 Three = 3 AS Mentari = 3 AS Mentari = 4 AS AXIS = 3 AS AXIS = 0.25 IM3 IM3 = 1 IM3 IM3 = 1 IM3 XL = 0.2 IM3 XL = 0.333 Universitas Sumatera Utara IM3 3 Three = 2 IM3 3 Three = 6 IM3 Mentari = 0.2 IM3 Mentari = 7 IM3 AXIS = 0.2 IM3 AXIS = 1 XL XL = 1 XL XL = 1 XL 3Three = 6 XL 3Three = 8 XL Mentari = 1 XL Mentari = 9 XL AXIS = 1 XL AXIS = 3 3Three 3 Three = 1 3Three 3 Three = 1 3 Three Mentari = 0.166 3 Three Mentari = 2 3 Three AXIS = 0.166 3 Three AXIS = 0.166 Mentari Mentari = 1 Mentari Mentari = 1 Mentari AXIS = 1 Mentari AXIS = 0.142 AXIS AXIS = 1 AXIS AXIS = 1 4.1.2 Nilai Perbandingan Tiap Matriks pada Metode SAW Nilai bobot pada matriks kriteria Perhitungan Metode SAW diperoleh dari hasil perhitungan nilai eigen vector Matriks Prioritas dari perhitungan Metode AHP. Tabel 4.7 Nilai Bobot untuk Perhitungan Metode SAW Kriteria Bobot Tarif Telepon 0,153 SMS 0,410 Internet 0,284 Layanan 0,103 Bonus 0,049 Universitas Sumatera Utara Tabel 4.8 Nilai Alternatif Setiap Kriteria Alternatif Tarif Telepon SMS Internet Layanan Bonus Simpati 0,364 0.036 0.379 0.360 0.125 AS 0.038 0.063 0.072 0.248 0.065 IM3 0.157 0.375 0.072 0.032 0.185 XL 0.100 0.266 0.146 0.112 0.383 3 Three 0.157 0.097 0.270 0.023 0.034 Mentari 0.027 0.025 0.035 0.112 0.024 AXIS 0.157 0.139 0.025 0.112 0.185

4.2. Implementasi Sistem