commit to user 140
besides finding other sources, he also puts his own opinion in the text. All attitudes are negative; there is only 1 positive attitude, yet it is not expressed
by the writer. It means the writer is really subjective to contradict Chris
Brown.
e. Ideology Analysis
Table 4.8.5 Ideology Analysis – ―Chris Brown Heckled By Woman In Public‖
Clause No.
Engagement Kinds of
Attitudes Appraising items
Appraised Generic
Structure 3.
Monogloss - appr.
… when a woman verbally tore
him a new asshole
Woman shouting to Chris Brown
Argument 4.
Heterogloss a woman
- judg. shouting, Fucking beater
Chris Brown
5a. Heterogloss
a woman - judg.
I hope someone beats the fucking shit out of you
Chris Brown
5b. Heterogloss
a woman - appr.
… someone beats the fucking shit
out of you Chris Brown’s
behavior 6.
Monogloss - judg.
Beat-Her-Down paid her no
attention Chris Brown
8a. Monogloss - judg.
There are even some MAYJAH douches
praising Brown calling him ―the man.‖
Chris Brown’s fans
8b. Heterogloss
Brown’s fans
+ judg
… some MAYJAH douches praising Brown calling him ―the
man.” Chris Brown
9. Monogloss
- affect
Disgusting.
The writer’s feeling to Chris Brown
10. Monogloss - judg.
Beat-Her-Down says on the
Wendy Williams Show Chris Brown
11. Heterogloss
Chris Brown - judg.
that hes misunderstood Chris Brown
commit to user 141
13a. Heterogloss
Chris Brown - affect
that Im sorry probably have been
perceived wrong Chris Brown’s
misunderstood - judg.
13b. Heterogloss
Chris Brown - judg.
Im sorry probably have been
perceived wrong Chris Brown may
be wrong 13c.
Heterogloss people
- judg.
… probably have been perceived wrong
Chris Brown
14. Heterogloss
Chris Brown - affect
I’m definitely remorseful
Chris Brown’s remorseful
16. Heterogloss
Chris Brown - judg.
that I take lightly
Chris Brown’s thought
18a. Monogloss - judg.
Then why do you always have that smug grin
on your face … Chris Brown
Reiteration 18b. Monogloss
- appr.
… that smug grin on your face
like you got away with something horrible
Chris Brown’s smile
18c. Monogloss - appr.
… that smug grin on your face like
you got away with something
horrible
Something
19. Monogloss - judg
Douche Chris Brown
It is an antagonist text because in exposing the artist, the writer only sees the bad side of the artist, Chris Brown. That is, Chris Brown has done a
mistake, and then the writer gives many negative evaluations about Chris Brown in the text without considering the positiveness of Chris Brown. Even
tough in the text is put ‘excuse’ from Chris Brown clauses number 13a and
14; the writer just puts negative comment after it clauses number 18a, 18b, 18c, and 19.
commit to user 142
It is also a left ideological text because the writer puts many negative evaluations in it. He also takes another resources from a woman who also
similar with him in case of evaluating Chris Brown. Even, there is only one positive
attitude in this text. Overall, this text is to show that the writer does not like Chris Brown. Therefore, the ideology of the writer towards this text is
left antagonist .
C. Discussion
This part discusses about the answers of the research questions on the problem statement and the relation between them as well. The significance is that
the theory, the secondary data and related researches are applied here.
1. Result
Based on the data description which contains findings, here is the result of the analysis. This result answers the three questions on problem statement.
a. The appraising items in the texts
Numbers of attitudes found in the texts are put in the table below: Table 4.9.1 Attitudes in the texts
Text Affect
Judgment Appreciation
Number positive negative positive negative positive negative positive negative
Text 1
Katy Perry 1
5 -
5 3
2 2
12 5
29.4 47.1
23.5 70.6
19.4
Text 2
Katy Perry 2
1 -
2 -
3 -
6 -
16.7 33.3
50 100
Text 3
Leona Lewis 1
2 1
5 2
6 1
13 4
17.6 41.2
41.2 76.5
23.5
Text 4
Leona Lewis 2
1 1
8 3
2 4
11 8
10.5 57.9
31.6 57.89 42.11
