Pengaruh Perbandingan Gula Putih dengan Gula Merah dan Penambahan Santan terhadap Mutu Abon Jamur Tiram
71
Lampiran 1.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar air
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,5477
3,4439
G2S1
3,6702
3,7259
G3S1
3,9932
3,9223
G4S1
5,4547
3,9960
G5S1
6,5311
4,9981
G1S2
6,6095
5,0764
G2S2
6,9248
5,7572
G3S2
7,4244
5,9183
G4S2
8,4313
7,4704
G5S2
8,5515
8,4140
G1S3
9,2478
9,2046
G2S3
9,4430
9,3565
G3S3
9,7549
9,5219
G4S3
9,8145
10,0363
G5S3
11,6336
12,3861
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
6,9916
7,3961
7,9155
9,4507
11,5292
11,6859
12,6820
13,3427
15,9017
16,9655
18,4523
18,7995
19,2767
19,8507
24,0197
214,2598
3,4958
3,6980
3,9577
4,7254
5,7646
5,8430
6,3410
6,6714
7,9509
8,4827
9,2262
9,3997
9,6384
9,9254
12,0098
7,1420
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
JK
KT
F. hitung
190,3020 13,5930
33,7004
25,4662
6,3665
15,7842
163,2176 81,6088 202,3283
163,1113 163,1113 404,3928
0,1773
0,1773
0,4396
1,6182
0,2023
0,5015
6,0502
0,4033
196,3522
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05 0,01
2,42 3,56
3,06 4,89
3,68 6,36
4,54 8,68
4,54 8,68
2,64 4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=1530,2427
KK
= 8,89%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
72
Lampiran 2.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar abu
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
6,0599
6,0253
G2S1
5,0379
5,0962
G3S1
4,7620
4,5141
G4S1
4,0819
4,0418
G5S1
3,3166
3,4108
G1S2
6,0620
5,9927
G2S2
4,8097
4,8883
G3S2
4,7900
4,4959
G4S2
3,9730
4,2434
G5S2
3,8231
3,6419
G1S3
5,0478
5,8371
G2S3
4,5752
5,2275
G3S3
4,5330
4,9274
G4S3
3,9698
4,6808
G5S3
3,4089
4,6088
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
12,0853
10,1341
9,2761
8,1237
6,7275
12,0546
9,6980
9,2859
8,2164
7,4650
10,8849
9,8027
9,4604
8,6506
8,0177
139,8829
6,0426
5,0670
4,6381
4,0619
3,3637
6,0273
4,8490
4,6429
4,1082
3,7325
5,4424
4,9014
4,7302
4,3253
4,0089
4,6628
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
14 16,7950
4 15,7659
2 0,0123
1 0,0110
1 0,0013
8 1,0168
15 1,7148
29 18,5097
KT
1,1996
3,9415
0,0062
0,0110
0,0013
0,1271
0,1143
F. hitung
10,4939
34,4783
0,0538
0,0964
0,0112
1,1118
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=652,2409
KK
= 7,25%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
73
Lampiran 3.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar protein
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
9,0054
8,0899
G2S1
9,4455
8,2343
G3S1
9,7414
8,4123
G4S1
9,8616
8,5233
G5S1
11,3322
9,6163
G1S2
8,8111
8,3955
G2S2
9,9650
8,4848
G3S2
10,2177
8,5233
G4S2
10,2941
8,7530
G5S2
11,4670
8,8166
G1S3
9,0278
8,5275
G2S3
9,3067
8,5318
G3S3
9,7464
9,2548
G4S3
10,7178
9,5345
G5S3
10,9643
9,9828
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
17,0953
17,6799
18,1537
18,3849
20,9485
17,2066
18,4499
18,7410
19,0472
20,2836
17,5553
17,8384
19,0012
20,2523
20,9471
281,5847
8,5477
8,8399
9,0768
9,1924
10,4742
8,6033
9,2249
9,3705
9,5236
10,1418
8,7776
8,9192
9,5006
10,1261
10,4735
9,3862
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
11,7579
10,3030
0,5578
0,5551
0,0027
0,8970
13,4486
25,2064
0,8398
2,5758
0,2789
0,5551
0,0027
0,1121
0,8966
F. hitung
0,9367
2,8729
0,3111
0,6192
0,0030
0,1251
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=2642,9980
KK
= 10,09%
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
74
Lampiran 4.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar lemak
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
23,0433
21,8050
G2S1
22,3240
21,4249
G3S1
21,8852
21,3926
G4S1
21,6968
21,3743
G5S1
21,4618
20,4171
G1S2
24,1372
24,0083
G2S2
24,0570
23,6328
G3S2
24,0363
22,9528
G4S2
23,9846
22,2473
G5S2
23,2809
22,2393
G1S3
28,2205
25,8639
G2S3
28,1201
24,7918
G3S3
25,5177
24,5683
G4S3
24,3416
24,5391
G5S3
24,2647
24,4373
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
44,8483
43,7488
43,2778
43,0711
41,8789
48,1455
47,6898
46,9891
46,2320
45,5202
54,0844
52,9119
50,0860
48,8806
48,7020
706,0664
22,4241
21,8744
21,6389
21,5356
20,9395
24,0727
23,8449
23,4945
23,1160
22,7601
27,0422
26,4560
25,0430
24,4403
24,3510
23,5355
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
14 88,1520
4 13,3819
2 71,6841
1 71,5931
1
0,0910
8
3,0860
15 13,4278
29 101,5798
KT
6,2966
3,3455
35,8420
71,5931
0,0910
0,3858
0,8952
F. hitung
7,0338
3,7372
40,0387
79,9757
0,1017
0,4309
**
*
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=16617,6598
KK
= 4,02%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
75
Lampiran 5.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar serat kasar
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
7,0423
6,3934
G2S1
7,3131
6,8202
G3S1
7,3144
6,3513
G4S1
7,1512
6,1950
G5S1
7,5305
6,2273
G1S2
6,6478
7,9519
G2S2
6,7863
7,9132
G3S2
7,0907
6,9510
G4S2
6,2441
8,3293
G5S2
7,2040
6,8257
G1S3
6,7060
7,8371
G2S3
7,0059
7,1649
G3S3
7,8615
7,6737
G4S3
7,9315
7,6855
G5S3
7,8071
7,9885
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
13,4357
14,1333
13,6657
13,3463
13,7578
14,5997
14,6994
14,0417
14,5734
14,0297
14,5431
14,1708
15,5353
15,6170
15,7957
215,9445
6,7178
7,0666
6,8329
6,6731
6,8789
7,2999
7,3497
7,0209
7,2867
7,0148
7,2715
7,0854
7,7676
7,8085
7,8978
7,1981
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
db
JK
KT
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
4,1394
0,1144
2,6817
2,6814
0,0002
1,3434
6,5595
10,6989
0,2957
0,0286
1,3408
2,6814
0,0002
0,1679
0,4373
F.
hitung
0,6761
0,0654
3,0662
6,1318
0,0005
0,3840
tn
tn
tn
*
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=1554,4004
KK
= 9,19%
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
76
Lampiran 6.
Data pengamatan analisis nilai skor warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,6667
3,8000
G2S1
3,7333
3,9333
G3S1
4,0667
4,2000
G4S1
4,7333
4,7333
G5S1
3,6667
4,2000
G1S2
3,8667
3,6667
G2S2
3,9333
3,6667
G3S2
3,5333
4,2667
G4S2
3,8667
3,9333
G5S2
4,0000
3,8667
G1S3
2,9333
3,2667
G2S3
3,4667
3,6000
G3S3
3,8667
3,7333
G4S3
3,8667
3,7333
G5S3
4,0000
4,0000
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
7,4667
7,6667
8,2667
9,4667
7,8667
7,5333
7,6000
7,8000
7,8000
7,8667
6,2000
7,0667
7,6000
7,6000
8,0000
115,8000
3,7333
3,8333
4,1333
4,7333
3,9333
3,7667
3,8000
3,9000
3,9000
3,9333
3,1000
3,5333
3,8000
3,8000
4,0000
3,8600
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
F. hitung
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
3,1831
1,3372
0,9102
0,9102
0,0000
0,9357
0,5978
3,7809
0,2274
0,3343
0,4551
0,9102
0,0000
0,1170
0,0399
5,7053
8,3885
11,4201
22,8401
0,0000
2,9349
**
**
**
**
tn
*
0,05
2,42
3,06
3,68
4,54
4,54
2,64
F Tabel
0,01
3,56
4,89
6,36
8,68
8,68
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=446,9880
KK
= 5,17%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
77
Lampiran 7.
Data pengamatan nilai skor aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
2,9333
2,9333
G2S1
3,2000
3,0000
G3S1
3,2000
3,0000
G4S1
3,2000
3,0667
G5S1
3,2667
3,1333
G1S2
3,2667
3,1333
G2S2
3,2667
3,1333
G3S2
3,3333
3,1333
G4S2
3,3333
3,1333
G5S2
3,3333
3,1333
G1S3
3,4000
3,2000
G2S3
3,4000
3,2000
G3S3
3,5333
3,2667
G4S3
3,5333
3,2667
G5S3
3,8667
3,2667
Total
Rataan
Total
5,8667
6,2000
6,2000
6,2667
6,4000
6,4000
6,4000
6,4667
6,4667
6,4667
6,6000
6,6000
6,8000
6,8000
7,1333
97,0667
Rataan
2,9333
3,1000
3,1000
3,1333
3,2000
3,2000
3,2000
3,2333
3,2333
3,2333
3,3000
3,3000
3,4000
3,4000
3,5667
3,2356
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
0,6287
0,1176
0,4536
0,4500
0,0036
0,0575
0,4267
1,0554
0,0449
0,0294
0,2268
0,4500
0,0036
0,0072
0,0284
F.
hitung
1,5789
1,0339
7,9740
15,8203
0,1276
0,2526
tn
tn
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan:
FK
=314,0646
KK
= 5,21%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
78
Lampiran 8.
Data pengamatan nilai skor rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
2,9333
3,4000
G2S1
3,0000
3,4667
G3S1
3,0667
3,5333
G4S1
3,0667
3,6000
G5S1
3,1333
3,6000
G1S2
3,2667
3,6000
G2S2
3,2667
3,6667
G3S2
3,4000
3,7333
G4S2
3,4000
3,7333
G5S2
3,4000
3,8000
G1S3
3,4000
3,8667
G2S3
3,6000
3,8667
G3S3
3,6000
3,8667
G4S3
3,6000
4,0000
G5S3
3,6667
4,2000
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
6,3333
6,4667
6,6000
6,6667
6,7333
6,8667
6,9333
7,1333
7,1333
7,2000
7,2667
7,4667
7,4667
7,6000
7,8667
105,7333
3,1667
3,2333
3,3000
3,3333
3,3667
3,4333
3,4667
3,5667
3,5667
3,6000
3,6333
3,7333
3,7333
3,8000
3,9333
3,5244
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
1,3754
0,1724
1,1843
1,1842
0,0001
0,0187
1,3067
2,6821
0,0982
0,0431
0,5921
1,1842
0,0001
0,0023
0,0871
F.
hitung
1,1278
0,4949
6,7976
13,5944
0,0009
0,0268
tn
tn
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=372,6513
KK
= 8,37%
tn
= tidak nyata
**
= sangat nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
79
Lampiran 9.
Data pengamatan nilai skor tekstur
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,6667
3,6667
G2S1
3,5333
3,4000
G3S1
3,4000
3,3333
G4S1
3,4000
3,2000
G5S1
3,3333
3,2000
G1S2
3,2667
3,2000
G2S2
3,2667
3,1333
G3S2
3,2667
3,1333
G4S2
3,2667
3,1333
G5S2
3,2000
3,0667
G1S3
3,2667
3,0000
G2S3
3,2000
3,0000
G3S3
3,1333
2,9333
G4S3
3,1333
2,8000
G5S3
2,7333
2,8000
Total
Rataan
Total
7,3333
6,9333
6,7333
6,6000
6,5333
6,4667
6,4000
6,4000
6,4000
6,2667
6,2667
6,2000
6,0667
5,9333
5,5333
96,0667
Rataan
3,6667
3,4667
3,3667
3,3000
3,2667
3,2333
3,2000
3,2000
3,2000
3,1333
3,1333
3,1000
3,0333
2,9667
2,7667
3,2022
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
1,2421
0,2806
0,8554
0,8542
0,0012
0,1061
0,2111
1,4532
0,0887
0,0701
0,4277
0,8542
0,0012
0,0133
0,0141
F.
hitung
6,3038
4,9842
30,3895
60,6947
0,0842
0,9421
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan:
FK
= 307,6268
KK
= 3,70%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
80
Lampiran 10.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
2,2667
2,9333
G2S1
2,6667
2,9333
G3S1
2,7333
3,0000
G4S1
3,6667
4,1333
G5S1
3,6667
4,2000
G1S2
2,6667
3,2000
G2S2
2,7333
3,2667
G3S2
3,2000
3,6000
G4S2
4,0000
3,7333
G5S2
4,0000
3,9333
G1S3
3,4667
3,8000
G2S3
3,8000
4,0000
G3S3
3,9333
4,0000
G4S3
3,9333
4,0667
G5S3
3,9333
3,8000
Total
Rataan
Total
5,2000
5,6000
5,7333
7,8000
7,8667
5,8667
6,0000
6,8000
7,7333
7,9333
7,2667
7,8000
7,9333
8,0000
7,7333
105,2667
Rataan
2,6000
2,8000
2,8667
3,9000
3,9333
2,9333
3,0000
3,4000
3,8667
3,9667
3,6333
3,9000
3,9667
4,0000
3,8667
3,5089
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
7,5221
3,7961
2,2199
2,1342
0,0856
1,5061
1,0422
8,5643
0,5373
0,9490
1,1099
2,1342
0,0856
0,1883
0,0695
F.
hitung
7,7329
13,6588
15,9744
30,7164
1,2324
2,7095
**
**
**
**
tn
*
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=369,3690
KK
= 7,51%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
81
Lampiran 11.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,3333
3,8000
G2S1
3,4000
3,8000
G3S1
3,4667
3,8000
G4S1
3,5333
3,8667
G5S1
3,6000
3,8667
G1S2
3,6667
3,8667
G2S2
3,6667
3,9333
G3S2
3,7333
3,9333
G4S2
3,7333
3,9333
G5S2
3,7333
3,9333
G1S3
3,7333
4,0000
G2S3
3,8000
4,0000
G3S3
3,8000
4,0000
G4S3
3,8667
4,0667
G5S3
4,0000
4,0667
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
7,1333
7,2000
7,2667
7,4000
7,4667
7,5333
7,6000
7,6667
7,6667
7,6667
7,7333
7,8000
7,8000
7,9333
8,0667
113,9333
3,5667
3,6000
3,6333
3,7000
3,7333
3,7667
3,8000
3,8333
3,8333
3,8333
3,8667
3,9000
3,9000
3,9667
4,0333
3,7978
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
0,4954
0,0673
0,4145
0,4109
0,0036
0,0136
0,5489
1,0443
0,0354
0,0168
0,2073
0,4109
0,0036
0,0017
0,0366
F.
hitung
0,9670
0,4595
5,6640
11,2287
0,0992
0,0466
tn
tn
*
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=432,6935
KK
= 5,04%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
82
Lampiran 12.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
4,0000
4,2667
G2S1
4,2000
4,2667
G3S1
4,4000
4,2667
G4S1
4,5333
4,5333
G5S1
4,6667
4,6667
G1S2
3,4000
3,4000
G2S2
3,6000
3,6000
G3S2
3,6000
3,8667
G4S2
3,6667
4,0667
G5S2
3,8000
4,1333
G1S3
3,4667
3,3333
G2S3
3,4667
3,3333
G3S3
3,4667
3,3333
G4S3
3,5333
3,4000
G5S3
3,5333
3,6000
Total
Rataan
Total
8,2667
8,4667
8,6667
9,0667
9,3333
6,8000
7,2000
7,4667
7,7333
7,9333
6,8000
6,8000
6,8000
6,9333
7,1333
115,4000
Rataan
4,1333
4,2333
4,3333
4,5333
4,6667
3,4000
3,6000
3,7333
3,8667
3,9667
3,4000
3,4000
3,4000
3,4667
3,5667
3,8467
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
F. hitung
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
5,4436
0,6732
4,6222
4,3556
0,2667
0,1481
0,2556
5,6991
0,3888
0,1683
2,3111
4,3556
0,2667
0,0185
0,0170
22,8224
9,8783
135,6522
255,6522
15,6522
1,0870
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=443,9053
KK
= 3,39%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
83
Lampiran 13.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik tekstur
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,4667
3,6667
G2S1
3,5333
3,7333
G3S1
3,6000
3,8000
G4S1
3,6000
4,0667
G5S1
3,8667
4,2667
G1S2
3,3333
3,7333
G2S2
3,6000
3,8667
G3S2
3,6000
3,9333
G4S2
3,6000
3,9333
G5S2
3,8000
4,0000
G1S3
3,1333
3,6667
G2S3
3,5333
3,7333
G3S3
3,5333
3,9333
G4S3
3,6000
4,0000
G5S3
3,6667
4,0000
Total
Rataan
Total
7,1333
7,2667
7,4000
7,6667
8,1333
7,0667
7,4667
7,5333
7,5333
7,8000
6,8000
7,2667
7,4667
7,6000
7,6667
111,8000
Rataan
3,5667
3,6333
3,7000
3,8333
4,0667
3,5333
3,7333
3,7667
3,7667
3,9000
3,4000
3,6333
3,7333
3,8000
3,8333
3,7267
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
0,7298
0,6187
0,0347
0,0320
0,0027
0,0764
0,8733
0,8733
0,0521
0,1547
0,0173
0,0320
0,0027
0,0096
0,0582
F.
hitung
0,8953
2,6565
0,2977
0,5496
0,0458
0,1641
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=416,6413
KK
= 6,47%
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 1.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar air
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,5477
3,4439
G2S1
3,6702
3,7259
G3S1
3,9932
3,9223
G4S1
5,4547
3,9960
G5S1
6,5311
4,9981
G1S2
6,6095
5,0764
G2S2
6,9248
5,7572
G3S2
7,4244
5,9183
G4S2
8,4313
7,4704
G5S2
8,5515
8,4140
G1S3
9,2478
9,2046
G2S3
9,4430
9,3565
G3S3
9,7549
9,5219
G4S3
9,8145
10,0363
G5S3
11,6336
12,3861
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
6,9916
7,3961
7,9155
9,4507
11,5292
11,6859
12,6820
13,3427
15,9017
16,9655
18,4523
18,7995
19,2767
19,8507
24,0197
214,2598
3,4958
3,6980
3,9577
4,7254
5,7646
5,8430
6,3410
6,6714
7,9509
8,4827
9,2262
9,3997
9,6384
9,9254
12,0098
7,1420
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
JK
KT
F. hitung
190,3020 13,5930
33,7004
25,4662
6,3665
15,7842
163,2176 81,6088 202,3283
163,1113 163,1113 404,3928
0,1773
0,1773
0,4396
1,6182
0,2023
0,5015
6,0502
0,4033
196,3522
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05 0,01
2,42 3,56
3,06 4,89
3,68 6,36
4,54 8,68
4,54 8,68
2,64 4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=1530,2427
KK
= 8,89%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
72
Lampiran 2.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar abu
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
6,0599
6,0253
G2S1
5,0379
5,0962
G3S1
4,7620
4,5141
G4S1
4,0819
4,0418
G5S1
3,3166
3,4108
G1S2
6,0620
5,9927
G2S2
4,8097
4,8883
G3S2
4,7900
4,4959
G4S2
3,9730
4,2434
G5S2
3,8231
3,6419
G1S3
5,0478
5,8371
G2S3
4,5752
5,2275
G3S3
4,5330
4,9274
G4S3
3,9698
4,6808
G5S3
3,4089
4,6088
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
12,0853
10,1341
9,2761
8,1237
6,7275
12,0546
9,6980
9,2859
8,2164
7,4650
10,8849
9,8027
9,4604
8,6506
8,0177
139,8829
6,0426
5,0670
4,6381
4,0619
3,3637
6,0273
4,8490
4,6429
4,1082
3,7325
5,4424
4,9014
4,7302
4,3253
4,0089
4,6628
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
14 16,7950
4 15,7659
2 0,0123
1 0,0110
1 0,0013
8 1,0168
15 1,7148
29 18,5097
KT
1,1996
3,9415
0,0062
0,0110
0,0013
0,1271
0,1143
F. hitung
10,4939
34,4783
0,0538
0,0964
0,0112
1,1118
**
**
tn
tn
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=652,2409
KK
= 7,25%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
73
Lampiran 3.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar protein
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
9,0054
8,0899
G2S1
9,4455
8,2343
G3S1
9,7414
8,4123
G4S1
9,8616
8,5233
G5S1
11,3322
9,6163
G1S2
8,8111
8,3955
G2S2
9,9650
8,4848
G3S2
10,2177
8,5233
G4S2
10,2941
8,7530
G5S2
11,4670
8,8166
G1S3
9,0278
8,5275
G2S3
9,3067
8,5318
G3S3
9,7464
9,2548
G4S3
10,7178
9,5345
G5S3
10,9643
9,9828
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
17,0953
17,6799
18,1537
18,3849
20,9485
17,2066
18,4499
18,7410
19,0472
20,2836
17,5553
17,8384
19,0012
20,2523
20,9471
281,5847
8,5477
8,8399
9,0768
9,1924
10,4742
8,6033
9,2249
9,3705
9,5236
10,1418
8,7776
8,9192
9,5006
10,1261
10,4735
9,3862
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
11,7579
10,3030
0,5578
0,5551
0,0027
0,8970
13,4486
25,2064
0,8398
2,5758
0,2789
0,5551
0,0027
0,1121
0,8966
F. hitung
0,9367
2,8729
0,3111
0,6192
0,0030
0,1251
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=2642,9980
KK
= 10,09%
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
74
Lampiran 4.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar lemak
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
23,0433
21,8050
G2S1
22,3240
21,4249
G3S1
21,8852
21,3926
G4S1
21,6968
21,3743
G5S1
21,4618
20,4171
G1S2
24,1372
24,0083
G2S2
24,0570
23,6328
G3S2
24,0363
22,9528
G4S2
23,9846
22,2473
G5S2
23,2809
22,2393
G1S3
28,2205
25,8639
G2S3
28,1201
24,7918
G3S3
25,5177
24,5683
G4S3
24,3416
24,5391
G5S3
24,2647
24,4373
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
44,8483
43,7488
43,2778
43,0711
41,8789
48,1455
47,6898
46,9891
46,2320
45,5202
54,0844
52,9119
50,0860
48,8806
48,7020
706,0664
22,4241
21,8744
21,6389
21,5356
20,9395
24,0727
23,8449
23,4945
23,1160
22,7601
27,0422
26,4560
25,0430
24,4403
24,3510
23,5355
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
14 88,1520
4 13,3819
2 71,6841
1 71,5931
1
0,0910
8
3,0860
15 13,4278
29 101,5798
KT
6,2966
3,3455
35,8420
71,5931
0,0910
0,3858
0,8952
F. hitung
7,0338
3,7372
40,0387
79,9757
0,1017
0,4309
**
*
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=16617,6598
KK
= 4,02%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
75
Lampiran 5.
Data pengamatan analisa kadar serat kasar
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
7,0423
6,3934
G2S1
7,3131
6,8202
G3S1
7,3144
6,3513
G4S1
7,1512
6,1950
G5S1
7,5305
6,2273
G1S2
6,6478
7,9519
G2S2
6,7863
7,9132
G3S2
7,0907
6,9510
G4S2
6,2441
8,3293
G5S2
7,2040
6,8257
G1S3
6,7060
7,8371
G2S3
7,0059
7,1649
G3S3
7,8615
7,6737
G4S3
7,9315
7,6855
G5S3
7,8071
7,9885
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
13,4357
14,1333
13,6657
13,3463
13,7578
14,5997
14,6994
14,0417
14,5734
14,0297
14,5431
14,1708
15,5353
15,6170
15,7957
215,9445
6,7178
7,0666
6,8329
6,6731
6,8789
7,2999
7,3497
7,0209
7,2867
7,0148
7,2715
7,0854
7,7676
7,8085
7,8978
7,1981
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
db
JK
KT
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
4,1394
0,1144
2,6817
2,6814
0,0002
1,3434
6,5595
10,6989
0,2957
0,0286
1,3408
2,6814
0,0002
0,1679
0,4373
F.
hitung
0,6761
0,0654
3,0662
6,1318
0,0005
0,3840
tn
tn
tn
*
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=1554,4004
KK
= 9,19%
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
76
Lampiran 6.
Data pengamatan analisis nilai skor warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,6667
3,8000
G2S1
3,7333
3,9333
G3S1
4,0667
4,2000
G4S1
4,7333
4,7333
G5S1
3,6667
4,2000
G1S2
3,8667
3,6667
G2S2
3,9333
3,6667
G3S2
3,5333
4,2667
G4S2
3,8667
3,9333
G5S2
4,0000
3,8667
G1S3
2,9333
3,2667
G2S3
3,4667
3,6000
G3S3
3,8667
3,7333
G4S3
3,8667
3,7333
G5S3
4,0000
4,0000
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
7,4667
7,6667
8,2667
9,4667
7,8667
7,5333
7,6000
7,8000
7,8000
7,8667
6,2000
7,0667
7,6000
7,6000
8,0000
115,8000
3,7333
3,8333
4,1333
4,7333
3,9333
3,7667
3,8000
3,9000
3,9000
3,9333
3,1000
3,5333
3,8000
3,8000
4,0000
3,8600
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
F. hitung
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
3,1831
1,3372
0,9102
0,9102
0,0000
0,9357
0,5978
3,7809
0,2274
0,3343
0,4551
0,9102
0,0000
0,1170
0,0399
5,7053
8,3885
11,4201
22,8401
0,0000
2,9349
**
**
**
**
tn
*
0,05
2,42
3,06
3,68
4,54
4,54
2,64
F Tabel
0,01
3,56
4,89
6,36
8,68
8,68
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=446,9880
KK
= 5,17%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
77
Lampiran 7.
Data pengamatan nilai skor aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
2,9333
2,9333
G2S1
3,2000
3,0000
G3S1
3,2000
3,0000
G4S1
3,2000
3,0667
G5S1
3,2667
3,1333
G1S2
3,2667
3,1333
G2S2
3,2667
3,1333
G3S2
3,3333
3,1333
G4S2
3,3333
3,1333
G5S2
3,3333
3,1333
G1S3
3,4000
3,2000
G2S3
3,4000
3,2000
G3S3
3,5333
3,2667
G4S3
3,5333
3,2667
G5S3
3,8667
3,2667
Total
Rataan
Total
5,8667
6,2000
6,2000
6,2667
6,4000
6,4000
6,4000
6,4667
6,4667
6,4667
6,6000
6,6000
6,8000
6,8000
7,1333
97,0667
Rataan
2,9333
3,1000
3,1000
3,1333
3,2000
3,2000
3,2000
3,2333
3,2333
3,2333
3,3000
3,3000
3,4000
3,4000
3,5667
3,2356
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
0,6287
0,1176
0,4536
0,4500
0,0036
0,0575
0,4267
1,0554
0,0449
0,0294
0,2268
0,4500
0,0036
0,0072
0,0284
F.
hitung
1,5789
1,0339
7,9740
15,8203
0,1276
0,2526
tn
tn
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan:
FK
=314,0646
KK
= 5,21%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
78
Lampiran 8.
Data pengamatan nilai skor rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
2,9333
3,4000
G2S1
3,0000
3,4667
G3S1
3,0667
3,5333
G4S1
3,0667
3,6000
G5S1
3,1333
3,6000
G1S2
3,2667
3,6000
G2S2
3,2667
3,6667
G3S2
3,4000
3,7333
G4S2
3,4000
3,7333
G5S2
3,4000
3,8000
G1S3
3,4000
3,8667
G2S3
3,6000
3,8667
G3S3
3,6000
3,8667
G4S3
3,6000
4,0000
G5S3
3,6667
4,2000
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
6,3333
6,4667
6,6000
6,6667
6,7333
6,8667
6,9333
7,1333
7,1333
7,2000
7,2667
7,4667
7,4667
7,6000
7,8667
105,7333
3,1667
3,2333
3,3000
3,3333
3,3667
3,4333
3,4667
3,5667
3,5667
3,6000
3,6333
3,7333
3,7333
3,8000
3,9333
3,5244
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
1,3754
0,1724
1,1843
1,1842
0,0001
0,0187
1,3067
2,6821
0,0982
0,0431
0,5921
1,1842
0,0001
0,0023
0,0871
F.
hitung
1,1278
0,4949
6,7976
13,5944
0,0009
0,0268
tn
tn
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=372,6513
KK
= 8,37%
tn
= tidak nyata
**
= sangat nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
79
Lampiran 9.
Data pengamatan nilai skor tekstur
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,6667
3,6667
G2S1
3,5333
3,4000
G3S1
3,4000
3,3333
G4S1
3,4000
3,2000
G5S1
3,3333
3,2000
G1S2
3,2667
3,2000
G2S2
3,2667
3,1333
G3S2
3,2667
3,1333
G4S2
3,2667
3,1333
G5S2
3,2000
3,0667
G1S3
3,2667
3,0000
G2S3
3,2000
3,0000
G3S3
3,1333
2,9333
G4S3
3,1333
2,8000
G5S3
2,7333
2,8000
Total
Rataan
Total
7,3333
6,9333
6,7333
6,6000
6,5333
6,4667
6,4000
6,4000
6,4000
6,2667
6,2667
6,2000
6,0667
5,9333
5,5333
96,0667
Rataan
3,6667
3,4667
3,3667
3,3000
3,2667
3,2333
3,2000
3,2000
3,2000
3,1333
3,1333
3,1000
3,0333
2,9667
2,7667
3,2022
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
1,2421
0,2806
0,8554
0,8542
0,0012
0,1061
0,2111
1,4532
0,0887
0,0701
0,4277
0,8542
0,0012
0,0133
0,0141
F.
hitung
6,3038
4,9842
30,3895
60,6947
0,0842
0,9421
**
**
**
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan:
FK
= 307,6268
KK
= 3,70%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
80
Lampiran 10.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik warna
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
2,2667
2,9333
G2S1
2,6667
2,9333
G3S1
2,7333
3,0000
G4S1
3,6667
4,1333
G5S1
3,6667
4,2000
G1S2
2,6667
3,2000
G2S2
2,7333
3,2667
G3S2
3,2000
3,6000
G4S2
4,0000
3,7333
G5S2
4,0000
3,9333
G1S3
3,4667
3,8000
G2S3
3,8000
4,0000
G3S3
3,9333
4,0000
G4S3
3,9333
4,0667
G5S3
3,9333
3,8000
Total
Rataan
Total
5,2000
5,6000
5,7333
7,8000
7,8667
5,8667
6,0000
6,8000
7,7333
7,9333
7,2667
7,8000
7,9333
8,0000
7,7333
105,2667
Rataan
2,6000
2,8000
2,8667
3,9000
3,9333
2,9333
3,0000
3,4000
3,8667
3,9667
3,6333
3,9000
3,9667
4,0000
3,8667
3,5089
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
7,5221
3,7961
2,2199
2,1342
0,0856
1,5061
1,0422
8,5643
0,5373
0,9490
1,1099
2,1342
0,0856
0,1883
0,0695
F.
hitung
7,7329
13,6588
15,9744
30,7164
1,2324
2,7095
**
**
**
**
tn
*
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=369,3690
KK
= 7,51%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
81
Lampiran 11.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik aroma
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,3333
3,8000
G2S1
3,4000
3,8000
G3S1
3,4667
3,8000
G4S1
3,5333
3,8667
G5S1
3,6000
3,8667
G1S2
3,6667
3,8667
G2S2
3,6667
3,9333
G3S2
3,7333
3,9333
G4S2
3,7333
3,9333
G5S2
3,7333
3,9333
G1S3
3,7333
4,0000
G2S3
3,8000
4,0000
G3S3
3,8000
4,0000
G4S3
3,8667
4,0667
G5S3
4,0000
4,0667
Total
Rataan
Total
Rataan
7,1333
7,2000
7,2667
7,4000
7,4667
7,5333
7,6000
7,6667
7,6667
7,6667
7,7333
7,8000
7,8000
7,9333
8,0667
113,9333
3,5667
3,6000
3,6333
3,7000
3,7333
3,7667
3,8000
3,8333
3,8333
3,8333
3,8667
3,9000
3,9000
3,9667
4,0333
3,7978
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
0,4954
0,0673
0,4145
0,4109
0,0036
0,0136
0,5489
1,0443
0,0354
0,0168
0,2073
0,4109
0,0036
0,0017
0,0366
F.
hitung
0,9670
0,4595
5,6640
11,2287
0,0992
0,0466
tn
tn
*
**
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=432,6935
KK
= 5,04%
**
= sangat nyata
*
= nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
82
Lampiran 12.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik rasa
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
4,0000
4,2667
G2S1
4,2000
4,2667
G3S1
4,4000
4,2667
G4S1
4,5333
4,5333
G5S1
4,6667
4,6667
G1S2
3,4000
3,4000
G2S2
3,6000
3,6000
G3S2
3,6000
3,8667
G4S2
3,6667
4,0667
G5S2
3,8000
4,1333
G1S3
3,4667
3,3333
G2S3
3,4667
3,3333
G3S3
3,4667
3,3333
G4S3
3,5333
3,4000
G5S3
3,5333
3,6000
Total
Rataan
Total
8,2667
8,4667
8,6667
9,0667
9,3333
6,8000
7,2000
7,4667
7,7333
7,9333
6,8000
6,8000
6,8000
6,9333
7,1333
115,4000
Rataan
4,1333
4,2333
4,3333
4,5333
4,6667
3,4000
3,6000
3,7333
3,8667
3,9667
3,4000
3,4000
3,4000
3,4667
3,5667
3,8467
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
F. hitung
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
5,4436
0,6732
4,6222
4,3556
0,2667
0,1481
0,2556
5,6991
0,3888
0,1683
2,3111
4,3556
0,2667
0,0185
0,0170
22,8224
9,8783
135,6522
255,6522
15,6522
1,0870
**
**
**
**
**
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=443,9053
KK
= 3,39%
**
= sangat nyata
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara
83
Lampiran 13.
Data pengamatan nilai hedonik tekstur
Ulangan
Perlakuan
1
2
G1S1
3,4667
3,6667
G2S1
3,5333
3,7333
G3S1
3,6000
3,8000
G4S1
3,6000
4,0667
G5S1
3,8667
4,2667
G1S2
3,3333
3,7333
G2S2
3,6000
3,8667
G3S2
3,6000
3,9333
G4S2
3,6000
3,9333
G5S2
3,8000
4,0000
G1S3
3,1333
3,6667
G2S3
3,5333
3,7333
G3S3
3,5333
3,9333
G4S3
3,6000
4,0000
G5S3
3,6667
4,0000
Total
Rataan
Total
7,1333
7,2667
7,4000
7,6667
8,1333
7,0667
7,4667
7,5333
7,5333
7,8000
6,8000
7,2667
7,4667
7,6000
7,6667
111,8000
Rataan
3,5667
3,6333
3,7000
3,8333
4,0667
3,5333
3,7333
3,7667
3,7667
3,9000
3,4000
3,6333
3,7333
3,8000
3,8333
3,7267
Tabel Sidik Ragam
SK
Perlakuan
G
S
S (linier)
S (kuadrat)
GxS
Galat
Total
db
JK
KT
14
4
2
1
1
8
15
29
0,7298
0,6187
0,0347
0,0320
0,0027
0,0764
0,8733
0,8733
0,0521
0,1547
0,0173
0,0320
0,0027
0,0096
0,0582
F.
hitung
0,8953
2,6565
0,2977
0,5496
0,0458
0,1641
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
tn
F Tabel
0,05
0,01
2,42
3,56
3,06
4,89
3,68
6,36
4,54
8,68
4,54
8,68
2,64
4,00
Keterangan :
FK
=416,6413
KK
= 6,47%
tn
= tidak nyata
Universitas Sumatera Utara