MAPEL SISTEM DAN INSTALASI REFRIGERASI P
PERFORMANCE ASSESMENT
NAME
: ………………………………………..
CLASS
: XI PTU ….
Section
Overall
A
Sub - Criteria Name or
Description
Safety Component
Bends
Tube Lengths & Positions
Silver Brazing
B
C
1
2
always use safety glasses when required
always use safety gloves when required
3
4
tools & equipment in safe condition
always use safe work practice
For Objective Assessment Only
requirement or
add (extra aspect
maximum
nominal size
information)
yes
2
yes
2
yes
2
yes
2
5
work area always clean and tidy
yes
No
A.1
A.2
A.3
Aspect - Description
Is the bend at 45°
Overal length
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Bends
B.1
Is the bend at 45°
Tube Lengths & Positions
B.2
Overal length
Silver Brazing
B.3
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Bends
Is the bend at 90°
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of
2
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
Very Good
0-1 degree
2-3 degree
>3 degree
90 mm ± 2mm
1
0.5
0
1
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
100%
80 to 99%
less than 80%
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
100%
80 to 99%
less than 80%
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
100%
90 mm ± 4mm
90 mm ± > 5mm
0.5
0
0.5
0.25
0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
0
0.5
0.25
0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
0
0.5
0-1 degree
2-3 degree
>3 degree
90 mm ± 2mm
90 mm ± 4mm
90 mm ± > 5mm
0-1 degree
2-3 degree
>3 degree
100 mm ± 2mm
100 mm ± 4mm
100 mm ± > 5mm
Multiply
Factor
score
Total
2
2
10
*1
*1
*1
*1
2
*1
2
2
6
*2
2
*2
2
*2
2
Section
Sub - Criteria Name or
Description
No
Aspect - Description
soldering?
D
E
F
G
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Bends
Is the bend at 180°
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Bends
Is the bend at 90°
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
For Objective Assessment Only
requirement or
add (extra aspect
maximum
nominal size
information)
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
133 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
133 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
133 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
0-1 degree
1
Acceptable
2-3 degree
0.5
Not Acceptable
>3 degree
0
Very Good
145 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
145 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
145 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
133 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
133 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
133 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
0-1 degree
1
Acceptable
2-3 degree
0.5
Not Acceptable
>3 degree
0
Very Good
180 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
180 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Multiply
Factor
score
Total
Section
Sub - Criteria Name or
Description
No
Aspect - Description
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
overall
Pressure Test
there No leaks when pressure tested to 1050 kpa or 150 Psig
overall
Finish
Are the tubes straight?
H
I
Are the tubes still round, not oval and without dents?
Has the specimen been cleaned and polished?
For Objective Assessment Only
requirement or
add (extra aspect
maximum
nominal size
information)
Not Acceptable
180 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
70 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
70 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
70 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
70 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
70 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
70 mm ± > 5mm
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Yes
No
yes
0.5
no
0
yes
0.25
no
0
yes
0.25
no
0
Multiply
Factor
score
Total
NAME
: ………………………………………..
CLASS
: XI PTU ….
Section
Overall
A
Sub - Criteria Name or
Description
Safety Component
Bends
Tube Lengths & Positions
Silver Brazing
B
C
1
2
always use safety glasses when required
always use safety gloves when required
3
4
tools & equipment in safe condition
always use safe work practice
For Objective Assessment Only
requirement or
add (extra aspect
maximum
nominal size
information)
yes
2
yes
2
yes
2
yes
2
5
work area always clean and tidy
yes
No
A.1
A.2
A.3
Aspect - Description
Is the bend at 45°
Overal length
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Bends
B.1
Is the bend at 45°
Tube Lengths & Positions
B.2
Overal length
Silver Brazing
B.3
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Bends
Is the bend at 90°
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of
2
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
Very Good
0-1 degree
2-3 degree
>3 degree
90 mm ± 2mm
1
0.5
0
1
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
100%
80 to 99%
less than 80%
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
100%
80 to 99%
less than 80%
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
Very Good
Acceptable
Not Acceptable
100%
90 mm ± 4mm
90 mm ± > 5mm
0.5
0
0.5
0.25
0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
0
0.5
0.25
0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
0
0.5
0-1 degree
2-3 degree
>3 degree
90 mm ± 2mm
90 mm ± 4mm
90 mm ± > 5mm
0-1 degree
2-3 degree
>3 degree
100 mm ± 2mm
100 mm ± 4mm
100 mm ± > 5mm
Multiply
Factor
score
Total
2
2
10
*1
*1
*1
*1
2
*1
2
2
6
*2
2
*2
2
*2
2
Section
Sub - Criteria Name or
Description
No
Aspect - Description
soldering?
D
E
F
G
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Bends
Is the bend at 180°
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Bends
Is the bend at 90°
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
For Objective Assessment Only
requirement or
add (extra aspect
maximum
nominal size
information)
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
133 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
133 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
133 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
0-1 degree
1
Acceptable
2-3 degree
0.5
Not Acceptable
>3 degree
0
Very Good
145 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
145 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
145 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
133 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
133 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
133 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
0-1 degree
1
Acceptable
2-3 degree
0.5
Not Acceptable
>3 degree
0
Very Good
180 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
180 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Multiply
Factor
score
Total
Section
Sub - Criteria Name or
Description
No
Aspect - Description
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Silver Brazing
complete solders ring with no drop of soldering or too much of soldering
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
Tube Lengths & Positions
Overal length
Flaring
Burrs been removed, correct size and no split
overall
Pressure Test
there No leaks when pressure tested to 1050 kpa or 150 Psig
overall
Finish
Are the tubes straight?
H
I
Are the tubes still round, not oval and without dents?
Has the specimen been cleaned and polished?
For Objective Assessment Only
requirement or
add (extra aspect
maximum
nominal size
information)
Not Acceptable
180 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
70 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
70 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
70 mm ± > 5mm
0
100%
0.5
80 to 99%
0.25
less than 80%
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Very Good
70 mm ± 2mm
1
Acceptable
70 mm ± 4mm
0.5
Not Acceptable
70 mm ± > 5mm
0
Very Good
1
Acceptable
0.5
Not Acceptable
0
Yes
No
yes
0.5
no
0
yes
0.25
no
0
yes
0.25
no
0
Multiply
Factor
score
Total