70 Based on the explanation above, it is reasonable to say there is significant
improvement in the experimental group‟s pronunciation ability after getting treatment using Audio Lingual Method.
4.5.2.2 Control Group using Songs’ Post-test Analysis
The second one is the post-test analysis of control group using songs as the media. The post-test score for control group using songs as the media implies that there is
little improvement in the students‟ pronunciation ability. The improvement can be seen from the mean score. Compared to the pre-test score, the mean score of post-
test increased by two points from 65 to 67. Here is the post-test score of the control group using songs.
Table 4.6 Post-test of Control Group using Songs
No Students’ Code
Score Average
Rater 1 Rater 2
Rater 3
1 C1-01
69 71
71 70
2 C1-02
67 69
69 68
3 C1-03
60 61
62 61
4 C1-04
73 73
70 72
5 C1-05
63 64
63 63
6 C1-06
65 67
66 66
7 C1-07
55 57
54 55
8 C1-08
59 61
60 60
9 C1-09
65 67
66 66
10 C1-10
67 69
69 68
11 C1-11
61 63
61 62
12 C1-12
61 63
63 62
13 C1-13
67 68
69 68
14 C1-14
76 77
76 76
15 C1-15
71 70
72 71
16 C1-16
60 61
60 60
17 C1-17
60 61
60 60
18 C1-18
71 72
71 71
19 C1-19
78 79
81 79
71
20 C1-20
73 75
75 74
21 C1-21
60 61
60 60
22 C1-22
87 87
87 87
23 C1-23
65 67
67 66
24 C1-24
54 55
57 55
25 C1-25
70 69
69 70
26 C1-26
65 67
66 66
27 C1-27
71 71
69 70
28 C1-28
67 69
70 69
29 C1-29
68 69
68 68
Mean 67
Based on the data above, we can find that only two students that are considered having poor pronunciation ability, meanwhile in the pre-test there are
four students included in this group. In the post-test data, we can find twenty two students are considered having average ability in pronunciation. However, only
nineteen students are considered in this level when the pre-test done. The last is good ability level. In the good ability level, there are two
students included in this level in the pre-test. Nevertheless, in the post-test we can find there are five students considered having good pronunciation ability.
Overall, we can say that there is little improvement of students‟ pronunciation ability after getting treatment using songs as the media. The scores
of the pre-test are varied from 55 to 87.
4.5.2.3 Control Group using Fidel Charts
