Penentuan Dosis Ekstrak Biji Pepaya (Carica Papaya L.) Sebagai Larutan Pestisida Nabati Pada Ulat Tanaman Tomat (Helicoverpa Armigera)
Lampiran 1. Identifikasi tumbuhan
40
Lampiran 2. Determinasi hewan uji
41
Lampiran 3. Rekomendasi persetujuan etik penelitian kesehatan
42
Lampiran 4. Sampel buah dan biji pepaya
43
Lampiran 5. Karakteristik biji pepaya
a. Biji pepaya basah
b. Biji pepaya kering
44
c. Serbuk biji pepaya
45
Lampiran 6. Hasil pemeriksaan mikroskopik serbuk simplisia biji pepaya
1
2
3
4
5
6
Gambar mikroskopik serbuk simplisia biji papaya dengan perbesaran 10x10
Keterangan:
1 = berkas pembuluh (xylem)
2 = kutikula
3 = epidermis
4 = parenkim
5 = butir minyak
6 = hablur Kristal oksalat bentuk druse
46
Lampiran 7. Bagan pembuatan, skrining fitokimia, dan karakterisasi serbuk
simplisia
Biji Pepaya
dicuci sampai bersih
dikeringkan di lemari
pengering dengan suhu
±400c
Simplisia
dihaluskan
Serbuk simplisia biji pepaya
Karakterisasi Simplisia:
- Mikroskopik
- Makroskopik
Skrining Fitokimia:
- Alkaloid
- Flavonoid
- Saponin
- Tanin
- Glikosida
- Steroid/Triterpenoida
47
Lampiran 8. Bagan kerja pembuatan ekstrak biji pepaya
Biji pepaya basah 3,5 kg
dicuci sampai bersih
dikeringkan di lemari pengering
ditimbang 900 g
dilarutkan dalam15 L air
dipanaskan selama 30 menit dengan
suhu 90oC
disaring
ditambahkan air panas hingga
diperoleh eksktrak sebanyak 15 L
Ekstrak biji pepaya
48
Lampiran 9. Bagan kerja pengujian ekstrak biji papaya
560 ekor ulat
Tahap Perlakuan
Disemprotkan EBP
sebanyak 2 ml
Uji Pendahuluan
EBP
Konsentrasi
821,496 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
410,748 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
205,374 ppm
Kontrol positif
sipermetrin 50g/l
EBP
Konsentrasi
102,687 ppm
Kontrol negatif
akuades
Uji Dosis Insektisida Nabati
EBP
Konsentrasi
3285,984 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
3285,984 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
1642,992 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
821,496 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
1642,992 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
821,496 ppm
Kontrol positif
sipermetrin 50g/l
EBP
Konsentrasi
410,748 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
410,748 ppm
Kontrol negatif
akuades
49
Lampiran 10. Hasil kematian ulat tomat
50
Lampiran 11. Perhitungan pembuatan ekstrak biji papaya
Sampel yang digunakan 900 g berat kering (simplisia) dalam 15 L air
60 ��
60.000 ���
60.000 ���
900 ��
�=
�=
�� = 60.000 ppm
15 � =
1 ppm = 1
��
��
�� = 1 ���
Larutan Induk Baku II 5000 ppm
5000 µ�/��
� 100 �� = 8,3 ml
60000µ�/��
a. Konsentrasi 25,625 ppm
25,625 µ�/��
5000µ�/��
x 100 ml = 0,5 ml
b. Konsentrasi 51,25 ppm
51,,25 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 1,0 ml
c. Konsentrasi 102,5 ppm
102,5 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 2,0 ml
d. Konsentrasi 205 ppm
205,38 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 4,1 ml
e. Konsentrasi 410,75 ppm
410,75 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 8,2 ml
f. Konsentrasi 821,5 ppm
821,5 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 16,4 ml
g. Konsentrasi 1643 ppm
1643 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 32,9 ml
h. Konsentrasi 3286 ml
3286 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 65,7 ml
51
Lampiran 12. Kelompok uji insektisida nabati
52
Lampiran 13. Ekstrak biji pepaya
53
Lampiran 14. Pengamatan kematian hewan
Ulangan I
Konsentrasi
24
48
72
96
120
144
168
∑
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,625
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
205
0
0
2
2
2
2
2
20
0,2
410,75
0
1
4
4
5
5
5
50
0,5
821,5
6
7
7
8
9
9
90
0,9
1643
6
8
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3286
5
9
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
Pi
∑ mati =
�����ℎ �������� ����
�����ℎ ���� ��� ������
Contoh : ∑ mati=
Pi
2
8
Pi
x 100
x 100 = 20
10
= % kematian ulat uji dari ∑ mati , contohnya: 36�100 = 0,36
∑ Pi = Jumlah Pi ( % kematian ulat yang diuji)
Ulangan II
Konsentrasi
24
48
72
96
120
144
168
∑
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,625
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
205
0
0
2
4
4
4
4
40
0,4
410,75
0
1
2
4
6
6
6
60
0,6
821,5
4
6
8
9
9
10
10
100
1
1643
4
7
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3286
4
8
9
10
10
10
10
100
1
54
Lampiran 14 (Lanjutan)
Ulangan III
Konsentrasi
24
48
72
96
120
144
168
196
Pi
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
25,67615
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,3435
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,687
0
0
0
0
2
2
2
20
0,2
205,374
0
0
2
2
2
2
2
20
0,2
410,748
3
4
4
4
4
4
4
40
0,4
821,496
2
5
7
7
7
7
7
70
0,7
1642,992
4
8
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3285,984
5
8
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
Konsentrasi
24
48
96
120
144
168
196
∑
Pi
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,67615
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,3435
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,687
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
10
0,1
205,374
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
410,748
0
0
2
2
2
2
2
20
0,2
821,496
2
4
6
6
6
6
6
60
0,6
1642,992
4
7
9
10
10
10
10
100
1
3285,984
6
8
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
Ulangan IV
55
Lampiran 14 (Lanjutan)
Ulangan V
Konsentrasi
24
48
96
120
144
168
196
∑
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,67615
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,3435
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,687
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
10
0,1
205,374
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
10
0,1
410,748
2
2
2
2
4
4
4
40
0,4
821,496
2
5
5
7
7
7
7
70
0,7
1642,992
4
7
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3285,984
6
8
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
56
Pi
Lampiran 15. Hasil uji statistika
Descriptives
95% Confidence
Interval for Mean
N
Mean
Kontrol -
5
.0000
Kontrol +
Std.
Std.
Deviation Error
Lower
Bound
Upper
Bound Minimum Maximum
.00000
.00000 .0000
.0000
.00
.00
5 10.0000
.00000
.00000 10.0000 10.0000
10.00
10.00
821.50
5
7.8000
1.64317 .73485 5.7597
9.8403
6.00
10.00
410.75
5
4.2000
1.48324 .66332 2.3583
6.0417
2.00
6.00
205.38
5
1.8000
1.48324 .66332 -.0417
3.6417
.00
4.00
102.69
5
.8000
.83666
.37417 -.2389
1.8389
.00
2.00
51.34
5
.0000
.00000
.00000 .0000
.0000
.00
.00
25.67
5
.0000
.00000
.00000 .0000
.0000
.00
.00
1643.00
5 10.0000
.00000
.00000 10.0000 10.0000
10.00
10.00
3286.00
5 10.0000
.00000
.00000 10.0000 10.0000
10.00
10.00
Total
50 4.4600
4.39949 .62218 3.2097
.00
10.00
57
5.7103
Lampiran 15 (Lanjutan)
Multiple Comparisons
Tukey HSD
(I)
(J)
Mean
Kelompok Kelompok Difference
Uji
Uji
(I-J)
Std.
Error
95% Confidence Interval
Sig.
Lower
Bound
Upper
Bound
Kontrol (-) Kontrol (+) -10.00000* .55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
821.50
-7.80000* .55857
.000
-9.6700
-5.9300
410.75
-4.20000
*
.55857
.000
-6.0700
-2.3300
205.38
-1.80000
.55857
.068
-3.6700
.0700
102.69
-.80000
.55857
.909
-2.6700
1.0700
51.34
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
25.67
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
1643.00
-10.00000* .55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
3286.00
-10.00000* .55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
Kontrol (+) Kontrol (-) 10.00000* .55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
821.50
821.50
2.20000*
.55857
.011
.3300
4.0700
410.75
5.80000*
.55857
.000
3.9300
7.6700
205.38
8.20000*
.55857
.000
6.3300
10.0700
102.69
9.20000*
.55857
.000
7.3300
11.0700
51.34
10.00000* .55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
25.67
10.00000* .55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
1643.00
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
3286.00
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
7.80000*
.55857
.000
5.9300
9.6700
Kontrol (+) -2.20000* .55857
.011
-4.0700
-.3300
Kontrol (-)
410.75
3.60000*
.55857
.000
1.7300
5.4700
205.38
6.00000*
.55857
.000
4.1300
7.8700
102.69
7.00000*
.55857
.000
5.1300
8.8700
51.34
7.80000*
.55857
.000
5.9300
9.6700
25.67
7.80000*
.55857
.000
5.9300
9.6700
58
410.75
1643.00
-2.20000* .55857
.011
-4.0700
-.3300
3286.00
*
.55857
.011
-4.0700
-.3300
*
.55857
.000
2.3300
6.0700
Kontrol (+) -5.80000
*
.55857
.000
-7.6700
-3.9300
821.50
-3.60000
*
.55857
.000
-5.4700
-1.7300
205.38
*
.55857
.004
.5300
4.2700
*
.55857
.000
1.5300
5.2700
*
.55857
.000
2.3300
6.0700
*
.55857
.000
2.3300
6.0700
-5.80000
*
.55857
.000
-7.6700
-3.9300
-5.80000
*
.55857
.000
-7.6700
-3.9300
Kontrol (-)
102.69
51.34
25.67
1643.00
3286.00
205.38
Kontrol (-)
2.40000
3.40000
4.20000
4.20000
.55857
.068
-.0700
3.6700
Kontrol (+) -8.20000
.55857
.000
-10.0700
-6.3300
821.50
-6.00000
*
.55857
.000
-7.8700
-4.1300
410.75
-2.40000
*
.55857
.004
-4.2700
-.5300
102.69
1.00000
.55857
.737
-.8700
2.8700
51.34
1.80000
.55857
.068
-.0700
3.6700
25.67
1.80000
3286.00
Kontrol (-)
1.80000
.55857
.068
-.0700
3.6700
-8.20000
*
.55857
.000
-10.0700
-6.3300
-8.20000
*
.55857
.000
-10.0700
-6.3300
.55857
.909
-1.0700
2.6700
Kontrol (+) -9.20000
*
.55857
.000
-11.0700
-7.3300
821.50
-7.00000
*
.55857
.000
-8.8700
-5.1300
410.75
-3.40000
*
.55857
.000
-5.2700
-1.5300
205.38
-1.00000
.55857
.737
-2.8700
.8700
51.34
.80000
.55857
.909
-1.0700
2.6700
25.67
.80000
1643.00
3286.00
51.34
4.20000
*
1643.00
102.69
-2.20000
Kontrol (-)
.80000
.55857
.909
-1.0700
2.6700
-9.20000
*
.55857
.000
-11.0700
-7.3300
-9.20000
*
.55857
.000
-11.0700
-7.3300
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
.00000
Kontrol (+) -10.00000
821.50
410.75
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-7.80000
*
.55857
.000
-9.6700
-5.9300
-4.20000
*
.55857
.000
-6.0700
-2.3300
59
205.38
-1.80000
.55857
.068
-3.6700
.0700
102.69
-.80000
.55857
.909
-2.6700
1.0700
25.67
.00000
1643.00
3286.00
25.67
Kontrol (-)
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
.00000
Kontrol (+) -10.00000
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-7.80000
*
.55857
.000
-9.6700
-5.9300
410.75
-4.20000
*
.55857
.000
-6.0700
-2.3300
205.38
-1.80000
.55857
.068
-3.6700
.0700
102.69
-.80000
.55857
.909
-2.6700
1.0700
51.34
.00000
821.50
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
Kontrol (-) 10.00000
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
Kontrol (+)
1643.00
3286.00
1643.00
821.50
410.75
205.38
102.69
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
*
.55857
.011
.3300
4.0700
*
.55857
.000
3.9300
7.6700
*
.55857
.000
6.3300
10.0700
*
2.20000
5.80000
8.20000
.55857
.000
7.3300
11.0700
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
10.00000
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
Kontrol (-) 10.00000
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
Kontrol (+)
51.34
25.67
3286.00
3286.00
*
9.20000
10.00000
*
821.50
410.75
205.38
102.69
51.34
25.67
1643.00
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
*
.55857
.011
.3300
4.0700
*
.55857
.000
3.9300
7.6700
*
.55857
.000
6.3300
10.0700
*
2.20000
5.80000
8.20000
9.20000
.55857
.000
7.3300
11.0700
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
10.00000
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
10.00000
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
60
Lampiran 15 (Lanjutan)
Homogeneous Subsets
Tukey HSDa
Subset for alpha = 0.05
Kelompok Uji
N
Kontrol (-)
5
.0000
51.34
5
.0000
25.67
5
.0000
102.69
5
.8000
205.38
5
1.8000
410.75
5
821.50
5
Kontrol (+)
5
10.0000
1643.00
5
10.0000
3286.00
5
10.0000
Sig.
1
2
3
4
4.2000
7.8000
.068
1.000
1.000
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 5,000.
61
1.000
40
Lampiran 2. Determinasi hewan uji
41
Lampiran 3. Rekomendasi persetujuan etik penelitian kesehatan
42
Lampiran 4. Sampel buah dan biji pepaya
43
Lampiran 5. Karakteristik biji pepaya
a. Biji pepaya basah
b. Biji pepaya kering
44
c. Serbuk biji pepaya
45
Lampiran 6. Hasil pemeriksaan mikroskopik serbuk simplisia biji pepaya
1
2
3
4
5
6
Gambar mikroskopik serbuk simplisia biji papaya dengan perbesaran 10x10
Keterangan:
1 = berkas pembuluh (xylem)
2 = kutikula
3 = epidermis
4 = parenkim
5 = butir minyak
6 = hablur Kristal oksalat bentuk druse
46
Lampiran 7. Bagan pembuatan, skrining fitokimia, dan karakterisasi serbuk
simplisia
Biji Pepaya
dicuci sampai bersih
dikeringkan di lemari
pengering dengan suhu
±400c
Simplisia
dihaluskan
Serbuk simplisia biji pepaya
Karakterisasi Simplisia:
- Mikroskopik
- Makroskopik
Skrining Fitokimia:
- Alkaloid
- Flavonoid
- Saponin
- Tanin
- Glikosida
- Steroid/Triterpenoida
47
Lampiran 8. Bagan kerja pembuatan ekstrak biji pepaya
Biji pepaya basah 3,5 kg
dicuci sampai bersih
dikeringkan di lemari pengering
ditimbang 900 g
dilarutkan dalam15 L air
dipanaskan selama 30 menit dengan
suhu 90oC
disaring
ditambahkan air panas hingga
diperoleh eksktrak sebanyak 15 L
Ekstrak biji pepaya
48
Lampiran 9. Bagan kerja pengujian ekstrak biji papaya
560 ekor ulat
Tahap Perlakuan
Disemprotkan EBP
sebanyak 2 ml
Uji Pendahuluan
EBP
Konsentrasi
821,496 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
410,748 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
205,374 ppm
Kontrol positif
sipermetrin 50g/l
EBP
Konsentrasi
102,687 ppm
Kontrol negatif
akuades
Uji Dosis Insektisida Nabati
EBP
Konsentrasi
3285,984 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
3285,984 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
1642,992 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
821,496 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
1642,992 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
821,496 ppm
Kontrol positif
sipermetrin 50g/l
EBP
Konsentrasi
410,748 ppm
EBP
Konsentrasi
410,748 ppm
Kontrol negatif
akuades
49
Lampiran 10. Hasil kematian ulat tomat
50
Lampiran 11. Perhitungan pembuatan ekstrak biji papaya
Sampel yang digunakan 900 g berat kering (simplisia) dalam 15 L air
60 ��
60.000 ���
60.000 ���
900 ��
�=
�=
�� = 60.000 ppm
15 � =
1 ppm = 1
��
��
�� = 1 ���
Larutan Induk Baku II 5000 ppm
5000 µ�/��
� 100 �� = 8,3 ml
60000µ�/��
a. Konsentrasi 25,625 ppm
25,625 µ�/��
5000µ�/��
x 100 ml = 0,5 ml
b. Konsentrasi 51,25 ppm
51,,25 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 1,0 ml
c. Konsentrasi 102,5 ppm
102,5 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 2,0 ml
d. Konsentrasi 205 ppm
205,38 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 4,1 ml
e. Konsentrasi 410,75 ppm
410,75 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 8,2 ml
f. Konsentrasi 821,5 ppm
821,5 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 16,4 ml
g. Konsentrasi 1643 ppm
1643 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 32,9 ml
h. Konsentrasi 3286 ml
3286 µ�⁄��
5000µ�⁄��
x 100 ml = 65,7 ml
51
Lampiran 12. Kelompok uji insektisida nabati
52
Lampiran 13. Ekstrak biji pepaya
53
Lampiran 14. Pengamatan kematian hewan
Ulangan I
Konsentrasi
24
48
72
96
120
144
168
∑
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,625
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
205
0
0
2
2
2
2
2
20
0,2
410,75
0
1
4
4
5
5
5
50
0,5
821,5
6
7
7
8
9
9
90
0,9
1643
6
8
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3286
5
9
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
Pi
∑ mati =
�����ℎ �������� ����
�����ℎ ���� ��� ������
Contoh : ∑ mati=
Pi
2
8
Pi
x 100
x 100 = 20
10
= % kematian ulat uji dari ∑ mati , contohnya: 36�100 = 0,36
∑ Pi = Jumlah Pi ( % kematian ulat yang diuji)
Ulangan II
Konsentrasi
24
48
72
96
120
144
168
∑
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,625
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
205
0
0
2
4
4
4
4
40
0,4
410,75
0
1
2
4
6
6
6
60
0,6
821,5
4
6
8
9
9
10
10
100
1
1643
4
7
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3286
4
8
9
10
10
10
10
100
1
54
Lampiran 14 (Lanjutan)
Ulangan III
Konsentrasi
24
48
72
96
120
144
168
196
Pi
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
25,67615
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,3435
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,687
0
0
0
0
2
2
2
20
0,2
205,374
0
0
2
2
2
2
2
20
0,2
410,748
3
4
4
4
4
4
4
40
0,4
821,496
2
5
7
7
7
7
7
70
0,7
1642,992
4
8
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3285,984
5
8
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
Konsentrasi
24
48
96
120
144
168
196
∑
Pi
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,67615
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,3435
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,687
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
10
0,1
205,374
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
410,748
0
0
2
2
2
2
2
20
0,2
821,496
2
4
6
6
6
6
6
60
0,6
1642,992
4
7
9
10
10
10
10
100
1
3285,984
6
8
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
Ulangan IV
55
Lampiran 14 (Lanjutan)
Ulangan V
Konsentrasi
24
48
96
120
144
168
196
∑
(ppm)
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
jam
mati
25,67615
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,3435
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
102,687
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
10
0,1
205,374
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
10
0,1
410,748
2
2
2
2
4
4
4
40
0,4
821,496
2
5
5
7
7
7
7
70
0,7
1642,992
4
7
8
10
10
10
10
100
1
3285,984
6
8
10
10
10
10
10
100
1
56
Pi
Lampiran 15. Hasil uji statistika
Descriptives
95% Confidence
Interval for Mean
N
Mean
Kontrol -
5
.0000
Kontrol +
Std.
Std.
Deviation Error
Lower
Bound
Upper
Bound Minimum Maximum
.00000
.00000 .0000
.0000
.00
.00
5 10.0000
.00000
.00000 10.0000 10.0000
10.00
10.00
821.50
5
7.8000
1.64317 .73485 5.7597
9.8403
6.00
10.00
410.75
5
4.2000
1.48324 .66332 2.3583
6.0417
2.00
6.00
205.38
5
1.8000
1.48324 .66332 -.0417
3.6417
.00
4.00
102.69
5
.8000
.83666
.37417 -.2389
1.8389
.00
2.00
51.34
5
.0000
.00000
.00000 .0000
.0000
.00
.00
25.67
5
.0000
.00000
.00000 .0000
.0000
.00
.00
1643.00
5 10.0000
.00000
.00000 10.0000 10.0000
10.00
10.00
3286.00
5 10.0000
.00000
.00000 10.0000 10.0000
10.00
10.00
Total
50 4.4600
4.39949 .62218 3.2097
.00
10.00
57
5.7103
Lampiran 15 (Lanjutan)
Multiple Comparisons
Tukey HSD
(I)
(J)
Mean
Kelompok Kelompok Difference
Uji
Uji
(I-J)
Std.
Error
95% Confidence Interval
Sig.
Lower
Bound
Upper
Bound
Kontrol (-) Kontrol (+) -10.00000* .55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
821.50
-7.80000* .55857
.000
-9.6700
-5.9300
410.75
-4.20000
*
.55857
.000
-6.0700
-2.3300
205.38
-1.80000
.55857
.068
-3.6700
.0700
102.69
-.80000
.55857
.909
-2.6700
1.0700
51.34
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
25.67
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
1643.00
-10.00000* .55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
3286.00
-10.00000* .55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
Kontrol (+) Kontrol (-) 10.00000* .55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
821.50
821.50
2.20000*
.55857
.011
.3300
4.0700
410.75
5.80000*
.55857
.000
3.9300
7.6700
205.38
8.20000*
.55857
.000
6.3300
10.0700
102.69
9.20000*
.55857
.000
7.3300
11.0700
51.34
10.00000* .55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
25.67
10.00000* .55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
1643.00
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
3286.00
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
7.80000*
.55857
.000
5.9300
9.6700
Kontrol (+) -2.20000* .55857
.011
-4.0700
-.3300
Kontrol (-)
410.75
3.60000*
.55857
.000
1.7300
5.4700
205.38
6.00000*
.55857
.000
4.1300
7.8700
102.69
7.00000*
.55857
.000
5.1300
8.8700
51.34
7.80000*
.55857
.000
5.9300
9.6700
25.67
7.80000*
.55857
.000
5.9300
9.6700
58
410.75
1643.00
-2.20000* .55857
.011
-4.0700
-.3300
3286.00
*
.55857
.011
-4.0700
-.3300
*
.55857
.000
2.3300
6.0700
Kontrol (+) -5.80000
*
.55857
.000
-7.6700
-3.9300
821.50
-3.60000
*
.55857
.000
-5.4700
-1.7300
205.38
*
.55857
.004
.5300
4.2700
*
.55857
.000
1.5300
5.2700
*
.55857
.000
2.3300
6.0700
*
.55857
.000
2.3300
6.0700
-5.80000
*
.55857
.000
-7.6700
-3.9300
-5.80000
*
.55857
.000
-7.6700
-3.9300
Kontrol (-)
102.69
51.34
25.67
1643.00
3286.00
205.38
Kontrol (-)
2.40000
3.40000
4.20000
4.20000
.55857
.068
-.0700
3.6700
Kontrol (+) -8.20000
.55857
.000
-10.0700
-6.3300
821.50
-6.00000
*
.55857
.000
-7.8700
-4.1300
410.75
-2.40000
*
.55857
.004
-4.2700
-.5300
102.69
1.00000
.55857
.737
-.8700
2.8700
51.34
1.80000
.55857
.068
-.0700
3.6700
25.67
1.80000
3286.00
Kontrol (-)
1.80000
.55857
.068
-.0700
3.6700
-8.20000
*
.55857
.000
-10.0700
-6.3300
-8.20000
*
.55857
.000
-10.0700
-6.3300
.55857
.909
-1.0700
2.6700
Kontrol (+) -9.20000
*
.55857
.000
-11.0700
-7.3300
821.50
-7.00000
*
.55857
.000
-8.8700
-5.1300
410.75
-3.40000
*
.55857
.000
-5.2700
-1.5300
205.38
-1.00000
.55857
.737
-2.8700
.8700
51.34
.80000
.55857
.909
-1.0700
2.6700
25.67
.80000
1643.00
3286.00
51.34
4.20000
*
1643.00
102.69
-2.20000
Kontrol (-)
.80000
.55857
.909
-1.0700
2.6700
-9.20000
*
.55857
.000
-11.0700
-7.3300
-9.20000
*
.55857
.000
-11.0700
-7.3300
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
.00000
Kontrol (+) -10.00000
821.50
410.75
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-7.80000
*
.55857
.000
-9.6700
-5.9300
-4.20000
*
.55857
.000
-6.0700
-2.3300
59
205.38
-1.80000
.55857
.068
-3.6700
.0700
102.69
-.80000
.55857
.909
-2.6700
1.0700
25.67
.00000
1643.00
3286.00
25.67
Kontrol (-)
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
.00000
Kontrol (+) -10.00000
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-7.80000
*
.55857
.000
-9.6700
-5.9300
410.75
-4.20000
*
.55857
.000
-6.0700
-2.3300
205.38
-1.80000
.55857
.068
-3.6700
.0700
102.69
-.80000
.55857
.909
-2.6700
1.0700
51.34
.00000
821.50
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
-10.00000
*
.55857
.000
-11.8700
-8.1300
Kontrol (-) 10.00000
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
Kontrol (+)
1643.00
3286.00
1643.00
821.50
410.75
205.38
102.69
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
*
.55857
.011
.3300
4.0700
*
.55857
.000
3.9300
7.6700
*
.55857
.000
6.3300
10.0700
*
2.20000
5.80000
8.20000
.55857
.000
7.3300
11.0700
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
10.00000
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
Kontrol (-) 10.00000
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
Kontrol (+)
51.34
25.67
3286.00
3286.00
*
9.20000
10.00000
*
821.50
410.75
205.38
102.69
51.34
25.67
1643.00
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
*
.55857
.011
.3300
4.0700
*
.55857
.000
3.9300
7.6700
*
.55857
.000
6.3300
10.0700
*
2.20000
5.80000
8.20000
9.20000
.55857
.000
7.3300
11.0700
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
10.00000
*
.55857
.000
8.1300
11.8700
.00000
.55857
1.000
-1.8700
1.8700
10.00000
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
60
Lampiran 15 (Lanjutan)
Homogeneous Subsets
Tukey HSDa
Subset for alpha = 0.05
Kelompok Uji
N
Kontrol (-)
5
.0000
51.34
5
.0000
25.67
5
.0000
102.69
5
.8000
205.38
5
1.8000
410.75
5
821.50
5
Kontrol (+)
5
10.0000
1643.00
5
10.0000
3286.00
5
10.0000
Sig.
1
2
3
4
4.2000
7.8000
.068
1.000
1.000
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 5,000.
61
1.000