0.1 1
10 100
1 10
100 1000
10000 GATE LENGTH L
G
[ nm] G
A T
E D
E L
A Y
C V
I [
p s
]
Si MOSFETs CNT FETs
I I I - V FETs
NMOS
Benchmarking Benchmarking
Nanotransistor Nanotransistor
Progress Progress
Source: Intel compilation of published data Source: Intel compilation of published data
Lithography Must Break Through Lithography Must Break Through
to Shorter Wavelength EUV 13.5nm to Shorter Wavelength EUV 13.5nm
Extreme Ultraviolet Extreme Ultraviolet
1000 1000
100 100
10 10
’ ’
89 89
’ ’
91 91
’ ’
93 93
’ ’
95 95
’ ’
97 97
’ ’
99 99
’ ’
01 01
’ ’
03 03
’ ’
05 05
’ ’
07 07
’ ’
09 09
’ ’
11 11
Feature size Feature size
EU V EU V
Lithography Lithography
Wavelength Wavelength
193nm extensions 193nm extensions
248nm 248nm
nm nm
Gap Gap
Source: Intel
Lithography Must Break Through Lithography Must Break Through
to Shorter Wavelength EUV 13.5nm to Shorter Wavelength EUV 13.5nm
Extreme Ultraviolet Extreme Ultraviolet
Source: Intel
1000 1000
100 100
10 10
’ ’
89 89
’ ’
91 91
’ ’
93 93
’ ’
95 95
’ ’
97 97
’ ’
99 99
’ ’
01 01
’ ’
03 03
’ ’
05 05
’ ’
07 07
’ ’
09 09
’ ’
11 11
Feature size Feature size
EU V EU V
Lithography Lithography
Wavelength Wavelength
193nm extensions 193nm extensions
248nm 248nm
nm nm
Gap Gap
EUV LLC EUV LLC
Prototype EUV Tool Demonstrated Prototype EUV Tool Demonstrated
EUV LLC invested heavily to spur innovation EUV LLC invested heavily to spur innovation
EUV Lithography in EUV Lithography in
Commercial Development Commercial Development
EUV Micro exposure tool MET EUV Micro exposure tool MET
EUV MET Image 804 EUV MET Image 804
Integrated development in progress Integrated development in progress
y y
Source power and lifetime Source power and lifetime
y y
Defect free mask fabrication and handling Defect free mask fabrication and handling
y y
Optics lifetime Optics lifetime
y y
Resist performance Resist performance
Source: Intel
EUV Source Power Increased EUV Source Power Increased
0.1 0.1
1 1
10 10
100 100
1000 1000
Jul Jul
- -
01 01
Jan Jan
- -
02 02
Jul Jul
- -
02 02
Jan Jan
- -
03 03
Jul Jul
- -
03 03
Jan Jan
- -
04 04
Jul Jul
- -
04 04
Jan Jan
- -
05 05
Jul Jul
- -
05 05
Jan Jan
- -
06 06
EUV Power at Intermediate Focus [W] EUV Power at Intermediate Focus [W]
115 W Production Requirement 115 W Production Requirement
Exponential fit to data Exponential fit to data
Average of reported data Average of reported data
SEMATECH Source Workshops SEMATECH Source Workshops
Source: SEMATECH
EUV Mask Blank Defects Reduced EUV Mask Blank Defects Reduced
Results from SEMATECH Results from SEMATECH
Source: SEMATECH
0.001 0.01