36
Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K
36
Te ch
ni ca
l G ui
de lin
es fo
r Ev
al ua
tin g
th e
M an
ag em
en t E
ffe ct
iv en
es s
of A
qu at
ic , C
oa st
s an
d S
m al
l I sl
an ds
C on
se rv
at io
n A
re as
E- K
K P
3K
37 37
40
conclusions can also be translated into change in effectiveness over time. Then, the conclusions can also be translated into recommendations or proposed
programsactivities for the subsequent year andor period.
D. Report Structure
The report of the findings of the evaluation of the management of an aquatic, coasts, and small islands conservation area should be presented as structured in
Table 4 below: Table 4 – Recommended structure of a report on the findings of an evaluation of the
management of an aquatic, coasts and small islands conservation area
Title Abstract or Summary
Table of Contents Description of evaluation team
Introduction Background Management, conservation area resources, and local socio-economic and
cultural objectives Evaluation findings – level of conservation area
Conclusions and Recommendations Priority Recommendations
Appendices especially findings of monitoring of management, area resources, and socio-economic and cultural aspects
41
RECOMMENDATIONS AND FOLLOW UP ACTION A. Recommendations
From the results of the evaluation of the management effectiveness of the conservation area, to progress to the next level of sustainable management, at a
minimum it is recommended that the following steps be taken:
a. Evaluation result: Level 1 Red
Immediately establish a conservation area management unit
Immediately prepare a conservation area management plan
b. Evaluation result: Level 2 Yellow
Implement institutional strengthening
Build conservation area infrastructure
Perform key management activities
c. Evaluation result: Level 3 Green
Practice good conservation area management
d. Evaluation result: Level 4 Blue
Take measures to network with non-governmental organizations to
contribute to management of the conservation area
Forge partnerships with other non-governmental parties to manage the conservation area
e. Evaluation result: Level 5 Gold
Undertake monitoring and evaluation to maintain the sustainability of the
management of the conservation area
B. Follow Up Action
From the results of the evaluation of the management effectiveness of the conservation area, the problems and weaknesses the management facing in managing the
area can be identified. The managers of the conservation area can then draft follow up plans based on the recommendations for improving management effectiveness.
For government, the results of the conservation area management evaluation can be used as the basis for evaluating performance, which can then be used to give awards
or mete out punishments for conservation area management.
Awards
Awards are given to management teams that have managed the conservation area effectively to graduate to the next level. The form the awards take will be
regulated by the Director General of Marine, Coasts and Small Islands Areas.
Punishments
Punishments are meted out to management teams for not implementing the recommendations for a particular level within a certain timeframe, so there is no
improvement in management performance and no subsequent change in level. The form the punishments will take will be regulated by the Director General of Marine,
Coasts and Small Islands.
38
Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K
38
Te ch
ni ca
l G ui
de lin
es fo
r Ev
al ua
tin g
th e
M an
ag em
en t E
ffe ct
iv en
es s
of A
qu at
ic , C
oa st
s an
d S
m al
l I sl
an ds
C on
se rv
at io
n A
re as
E- K
K P
3K
39 39
42
CHAPTER VI CONCLUSION
These technical guidelines for evaluating the management effectiveness of aquatic, coasts and small islands conservation areas are part of the effort to achieve the
target of sustainable management of conservation areas.
Enacted in Jakarta On 9 October 2012
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF MARINE, COASTS AND SMALL ISLANDS
Signed SUDIRMAN SAAD
Deemed a true copy of the original Head of Legal Affairs, Organization and Public Relations
Achmad Satiri
43 Appendix II: Decree of the Director General of Marine, Coasts and Small Islands
Number KEP.44KP3K2012 concerning Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and
Small Islands Conservation Areas.
LIST OF SCORE CARDS FOR EVALUATING THE MANAGEMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF AQUATIC, COASTS AND SMALL ISLANDS CONSERVATION AREAS
FORM DESCRIPTION
1 BACKGROUND INFORMATION OF THE CONSERVATION
AREA 2
EVALUATION SCORE CARDS: a. RED LEVEL 1: CONSERVATION AREA INITIATED
b. YELLOW LEVEL 2: CONSERVATION AREA ESTABLISHED
c. GREEN LEVEL 3: CONSERVATION AREA MANAGED MINIMALLY
d. BLUE LEVEL 4: CONSERVATION AREA MANAGED OPTIMALLY
e. GOLD LEVEL 5: SELF-RELIANT CONSERVATION AREA
Enacted in Jakarta On 9
th
October 2012
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF MARINE, COASTS AND SMALL ISLANDS
Signed SUDIRMAN SAAD
Deemed a true copy of the original Head of Legal Affairs, Organization and Public Relations Bureau
Achmad Satiri
