Initiative proposal Initiative proposal

ch nic al G uid eli ne s f or E va lu ati ng th e M an ag em en t E ffe cti ve ne ss o f A qu ati c, C oa sts a nd S m all Is la nd s C on se rv ati on A re as E -K K P 3K 12 Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K 13 13 16 Level Stage Red 1: Conservation Area Initiated CRITERIA NO. QUESTION ANSWER VERIFICATION TOOL REMARKS Yes No

1: Initiative proposal

Proposal to initiate establishment of the conservation area submitted by select one List of proposers, if more than one. User must attach initiative proposal documents as referred to in Article 9 clause 2 of the Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number PER.02MEN2009. Self-explanatory. User is asked to choose one from a list of proposers. Where there is more than one proposer, just select the main proposer and list the other proposers in the verification column. In cases where the area has already been identified reserved, the answer to this question is taken to be ‘Yes’. M1 Individual Community group Research institute Educational institute Government organization NGO 17 Level RED: stage 1 – conservation area initiated continued CRITERIA NO. QUESTION ANSWER VERIFICATION TOOL REMARKS Yes No

1: Initiative proposal

Proposal to initiate establishment of the conservation area is submitted to: select one Documents as referred to in Article 11 clause 2 of the Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number PER.02MEN2009. Self-explanatory. User selects ‘Yes’ to answer this question if the proposal is as referred to in Article 11 clauses 1 and 2 of the Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number 022009. User must select ‘No’ for question M2b. In cases where the area has already been identified reserved, the answer to this question is taken to be ‘Yes’. M2a National government or local government without preliminary survey and map. M2b National government or local government with preliminary survey and map. Documents as referred to in Article 10 of the Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number PER.02MEN2009. Self-explanatory. User selects ‘Yes’ to answer this question if the proposal is as referred to in Article 10 clauses 1, 2 and 3 of the Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number 022009. User must select ‘No’ for question M2a. In cases where the area has already been identified reserved, the answer to this question is taken to be ‘Yes’. ch nic al G uid eli ne s f or E va lu ati ng th e M an ag em en t E ffe cti ve ne ss o f A qu ati c, C oa sts a nd S m all Is la nd s C on se rv ati on A re as E -K K P 3K 14 Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K 15 15 18 Level RED: stage 1 – conservation area initiated continued CRITERIA NO. QUESTION ANSWER VERIFICATION TOOL REMARKS Yes No

2. Area identification