40
Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K
40
Te ch
ni ca
l G ui
de lin
es fo
r Ev
al ua
tin g
th e
M an
ag em
en t E
ffe ct
iv en
es s
of A
qu at
ic , C
oa st
s an
d S
m al
l I sl
an ds
C on
se rv
at io
n A
re as
E- K
K P
3K
41 41
44
A. BACKGROUND INFORMATION OF THE CONSERVATION AREA
Conservation area CODE record conservation area CODE here
Conservation area NAME record conservation area NAME here
Conservation area LOCATION record conservation area LOCATION here Conservation area COORDINATES
Longitude WE Latitude NS
Point 1 Point 2
Point 3 Point 4
Point 5 add as required
Management Goals Note: there can be more
than one goal for each aspect or they can be
divided into sub-goals. Area Resources Goals
Socio-Economic Cultural Goals
Conservation target 1 Note: conservation
targets are the resources that will be managed.
They may be species populations, habitats
andor ecosystems. Conservation target 2
Conservation target 3 Conservation target 4
Socio-economic cultural target 1
Note: socio-economic and cultural targets include
everything that is aimed at providing incentives to
increase support for the conservation area.
Examples: alternative livelihoods, participation,
behavior change, etc. Socio-economic cultural
target 2 Socio-economic cultural
target 3 Socio-economic cultural
target 4 45
B .
EVA LU
A TI
O N
SC O
RE C
A R
D S
Le ve
l Sta
ge
R ed
1: Co
ns er
va tio
n Ar
ea
In iti
ate d
C RI
TE R
IA N
O .
Q U
ES TI
O N
A N
S W
ER VERI
FI C
A TI
O N
T O
O L
RE MA
RK S
Yes N
o
1: In
iti at
ive p
ro p
os al
Pr op
os al
t o i
ni tiat
e es tab
lis hm
en t
of t
he c on
ser vat
ion a
rea
su bm
itt ed
b y
s el
ec t
on e
L is
t of
p rop
os er
s, i
f m
or e
th an
on e.
Us er
m us
t at
tac h
in iti
at iv
e
pr op
os al
d oc
um en
ts as
r ef
er red
to i n
Ar tic
le 9 c
lau se
2 of
t he
M in
is ter
o f
M ar
in e Af
fai rs
an d
Fi sh
er ie
s Reg
ul at
ion N
um ber
PER. 02M
EN 2009.
Sel f-
exp la
nat or
y. Us
er is
as ked
t o c
hoo se on
e
fr om
a l is
t of
p rop
os er
W her
e t her
e i s
m or
e
th an
on e p
rop os
er , j
us t
sel ec
t th
e m ai
n
pr op
os er
an d
lis t
th e
ot her
p rop
os er
s in
t he
ver ifi
cat ion
c ol
um n.
I n
cas es
w her
e t he ar
ea
has al
rea dy
b een
id en
tif ied
res er
ved , t
an sw
er t
o t hi
s qu
es tion
is t
ak en
t o b
e ‘ Yes
’.
M 1
In di
vi du
al Comm
un ity
g rou
p
Res ea
rc h
in st
itu te
Ed uc
at ion
al in
st itu
te
G ov
er nm
en t
or gan
iz at
ion
N G
O
ch nic
al G
uid eli
ne s f
or E
va lu
ati ng
th e M
an ag
em en
t E ffe
cti ve
ne ss
o f A
qu ati
c, C
oa sts
a nd
S m
all Is
la nd
s C on
se rv
ati on
A re
as E
-K K
P 3K
42
Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K
43 43
46
CRITERIA NO.
QUESTION ANSWER
VERIFICATION TOOL REMARKS
Yes No
1: Initiative proposal
Proposal to initiate establishment of the conservation area is submitted to: select one
Documents as referred to in Article 11 clause 2 of the
Minister of Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number
PER.02MEN2009.
Self-explanatory. User selects ‘Yes’ to answer this
question if the proposal is as referred to in Article 11
clauses 1 and 2 of the Minister of Marine Affairs
and Fisheries Regulation Number 022009. User
must select ‘No’ for question M2b. In cases
where the area has already been identified reserved,
the answer to this question is taken to be ‘Yes’.
M2a National government or local
government without preliminary survey and map.
M2b National government or local
government with preliminary survey and map.
Documents as referred to in Article 10 of the Minister of
Marine Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number
PER.02MEN2009.
Self-explanatory. User selects ‘Yes’ to answer this
question if the proposal is as referred to in Article 10
clauses 1, 2 and 3 of the Minister of Marine
Affairs and Fisheries Regulation Number
022009. User must select ‘No’ for question M2a. In
cases where the area has already been identified
reserved, the answer to this question is taken to be
‘Yes’.
47
Level RED: stage 1 – conservation area initiated continued CRITERIA
NO. QUESTION
ANSWER VERIFICATION TOOL
REMARKS
Yes No
2. Area identification
