4
Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K
Te ch
ni ca
l G ui
de lin
es fo
r Ev
al ua
tin g
th e
M an
ag em
en t E
ffe ct
iv en
es s
of A
qu at
ic , C
oa st
s an
d S
m al
l I sl
an ds
C on
se rv
at io
n A
re as
E- K
K P
3K
5 5
8
a conservation area
Aspect Strategies and Activity Programs
Management Human resource development
Institutional management Infrastructure capacity building
Development of
community organizationsinstitutions
Development of partnerships Establishing an aquatic conservation area network
Developing a sustainable funding system Monitoring and evaluation
Area resources Protecting fish habitats and populations
Rehabilitating fish habitats and populations Research and development
Use of fish resources Eco tourism and environmental services
Surveillance and control Monitoring and evaluation
Socio-economic cultural
Community socio-economic development Community empowerment
Preservation of culture and traditions Monitoring and evaluation
D. Organization of the Technical Guidelines
This manual for evaluating the management effectiveness of aquatic, coasts and small islands conservation areas contains procedures or standards for evaluating the
performance of the sustainable management of a particular aquatic conservation area. Following is an outline of the content of each chapter:
Chapter I – Introduction, including background, purpose and objectives, scope,
and organization of the technical guidelines.
Chapter II – Theoretical framework for Effectiveness of the Management of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas, including an overview of
the management effectiveness of aquatic, coasts and small islands conservation areas, which will act as the benchmark for the management, area resources, and
socio-economic and cultural aspects, and implementation of the management of an aquatic conservation area by a management organization unit national or
local government as a form of social responsibility to the public.
Chapter III – Method for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas, which is a process for determining
the effectiveness outcomes and impacts of activity programs against targets that will be achieved systematically and objectively. This evaluation seeks to
explain why the outcomes, effects and impacts of activities are achieved or not. And whether the activities are effective, as targeted.
9
the data collected and analyzed, and follow-up recommendations for the management of conservation areas. Reporting is done periodically and at various
levels, or as needed.
Chapter V – Recommendations and Follow Up, contains the recommendations and follow up for managers to implement in order to achieve an effective level of
management.
Chapter VI – Conclusion.
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND TERMS
Below are some of the common abbreviations and terms used in these guidelines for evaluating the management effectiveness of aquatic, coasts and small islands
conservation areas:
E-KKP3K: Efektivitas Pengelolaan Kawasan Konservasi Perairan, Pesisir dan Pulau-
Pulau Kecil Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas
Evaluation: a process for determining the relevance, efficiency, effectiveness and
impacts of program activities against targets that are to be achieved systematically and objectively. This evaluation seeks to explain why the outputs, effects and
impacts of activities are achieved or not.
Reporting: a key activity in development processes. Reporting is done to provide
relevant and accurate datainformation quickly to stakeholders as material for decision making in keeping with existing conditions, and for making relevant
policies. Reporting is carried out regularly and at various levels.
Level Red: or stage 1 conservation area initiated, and the area has been
reserved by decree.
Level Yellow: or stage 2 conservation area established – stage 1 +
management agency formed and management plan prepared.
Level Green: or stage 3 conservation area managed minimally – stage 2 +
organizational strengthening and core management activities.
Level Blue: or stage 4 conservation area managed optimally – stage 3 +
management of the conservation area running effectively.
Level Gold: or stage 5 self-reliant conservation area – stage 4 + sustainable
funding mechanism by decree, contributions from non-governmental organizations.
IKU KKP: Indikator Kinerja Utama Pembangunan Kelautan dan Perikanan Marine
and Fisheries Development Key Performance Indicators
6
Technical Guidelines for Evaluating the Management Effectiveness of Aquatic, Coasts and Small Islands Conservation Areas E-KKP3K
Te ch
ni ca
l G ui
de lin
es fo
r Ev
al ua
tin g
th e
M an
ag em
en t E
ffe ct
iv en
es s
of A
qu at
ic , C
oa st
s an
d S
m al
l I sl
an ds
C on
se rv
at io
n A
re as
E- K
K P
3K
7 7
10
A. Background
