Observation: The steps on this phase can be listed

negative opinion during the utilization of Edmodo for teaching writing. The writer used some indicators as can be seen as below: Table 4.4 Questionnaire Indicators Variables Indicators Number Edmodo is a useful tool for writing - Useful tool to share writing - Posting recount and narrative text is agood idea - Using Edmodo in English class is a good idea - Students feel writing on Edmodo is better than on paper - Writing on Edmodo is fun - Students believe Edmodo is good writing practice - Students feel their writing is better when writing on Edmodo than writing on paper - Edmodo should be used as part of writing activity due to its benefits 1 2 3 9 36 33 9 17 - Students will continue to use Edmodo outside the class - Edmodo should be a part of the writing activities in classes 25 27 Checking words, sentence, and grammar when writing on Edmodo - Students learn to write better when writing on Edmodo - Students check works carefully before posting on Edmodo - Students did not check works when writing on paper - Students check grammar carefully before posting on Edmodo - Students check sentence before posting on Edmodo - Students more careful in writing when writing on Edmodo - Students feel that they have improved their writing in English in the areas of grammar, structure, and vocabulary. 4 5 6 8 37 38 16 Write and express idea both freely and easily on Edmodo - students can write freely on Edmodo - students feel free to express themselves on Edmodo - Students have more freedom in writing when using Edmodo - Student express idea better 7 23 39 10 when writing on Edmodo - Students have more freedom in writing when using Edmodo - Students express himself easily when using Edmodo - Students feel no pressure because they have more time to write - Students can express idea better on Edmodo than in oral communication - Students not ashamed to express their thoughts on Edmodo - Students write effectively although their English is limited 39 40 14 19 26 32 Be more creative when writing on Edmodo - Students feel more creative when writing on Edmodo than on paper - Students feel that they write effectively 11 29 Fell more confident - Students feel more confident with their writing ability when writing on Edmodo than on paper 12 Write longer when writing on Edmodo than on paper - Students feel that they can write longer when writing on Edmodo than on pape 13 Comments are useful in improving writing ability - Students like to read comments because they are useful in improving writing ability 15 - Students like their friends to read others writing 2 Edmodo improves writing skill - Students feel that their writing skill have improve since they began use Edmodo 18 Group discussion on Edmodo helps students improve their writing - Students can participate in the group discussion better when they have previously discussed the issue on Edmodo - Students like to read their friend‟s idea on Edmodo - The discussion on Edmodo help students improve their writing - When students participated in discussion on Edmodo, they were free to express idea - Students take their time when participated on group discussion - Students think effectively when discussing ideas on group discussion - Students responded effectively during discussion on Edmodo - Students believe they can improve their written English if they participated in the discussion - Students can increase their knowledge on the topic discussed 20 21 22 23 24 30 31 34 35