77
Lampiran 12. Data ANOVA pengaruh lama penyimpanan terhadap DOBI lanjutan
C.
Suhu penyimpanan = 30
o
C
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.116 4
.029 21.586
.002 Within Groups
.007 5
.001 Total
.122 9
Post Hoc Tests Homogeneous Subsets
DOBI
Duncan Suhu30C
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
3 4
minggu 4 2
2.4400 minggu 3
2 2.5100
2.5100 minggu 2
2 2.5650
2.5650 minggu 1
2 2.6300
minggu 0 2
2.7550 Sig.
.114 .193
.136 1.000
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
D. Suhu penyimpanan = 35
o
C
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.198 4
.050 33.514
.001 Within Groups
.007 5
.001 Total
.206 9
Post Hoc Tests
Homogeneous Subsets DOBI
Duncan Suhu35C
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
3 4
minggu 4 2
2.3300 minggu 3
2 2.4450
minggu 2 2
2.5050 2.5050
minggu 1 2
2.5650 minggu 0
2 2.7550
Sig. 1.000
.180 .180
1.000 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
78
Lampiran 12. Data ANOVA pengaruh lama penyimpanan terhadap DOBI lanjutan
E.
Suhu penyimpanan = 40
o
C
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.704 4
.176 63.552
.000 Within Groups
.014 5
.003 Total
.718 9
Post Hoc Tests Homogeneous Subsets
DOBI
Duncan Suhu40C
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
3 4
minggu 4 2
1.9750 minggu 3
2 2.2550
minggu 2 2
2.4250 minggu 1
2 2.5550
minggu 0 2
2.7550 Sig.
1.000 1.000
.057 1.000
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
79
Lampiran 13. Data ANOVA pengaruh suhu penyimpanan terhadap DOBI A.
Lama penyimpanan = 1 minggu
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.059 4
.015 5.208
.050 Within Groups
.014 5
.003 Total
.073 9
Post Hoc Tests Homogeneous Subsets
DOBI
Duncan minggu1
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
40 celcius 2
2.5550 35 celcius
2 2.5650
30 celcius 2
2.6300 2.6300
25 celcius 2
2.7150 20 celcius
2 2.7450
Sig. .229
.090 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
B. Lama penyimpanan = 2 minggu
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.120 4
.030 37.625
.001 Within Groups
.004 5
.001 Total
.124 9
Post Hoc Tests Homogeneous Subsets
DOBI
Duncan minggu2
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
3 40 celcius
2 2.4250
35 celcius 2
2.5050 30 celcius
2 2.5650
25 celcius 2
2.6900 20 celcius
2 2.7150
Sig. 1.000
.087 .417
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
80
Lampiran 13. Data ANOVA pengaruh suhu penyimpanan terhadap DOBI lanjutan
C. Lama penyimpanan = 3 minggu
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.262 4
.066 25.196
.002 Within Groups
.013 5
.003 Total
.275 9
Post Hoc Tests Homogeneous Subsets
DOBI
Duncan minggu3
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
3 4
40 celcius 2
2.2550 35 celcius
2 2.4450
30 celcius 2
2.5100 2.5100
25 celcius 2
2.6350 2.6350
20 celcius 2
2.7250 Sig.
1.000 .258
.058 .138
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
D.
Lama penyimpanan = 4 minggu
ANOVA DOBI
Sum of Squares df
Mean Square F
Sig. Between Groups
.622 4
.155 75.849
.000 Within Groups
.010 5
.002 Total
.632 9
Post Hoc Tests Homogeneous Subsets
DOBI
Duncan minggu4
N Subset for alpha = 0.05
1 2
3 40 celcius
2 1.9750
35 celcius 2
2.3300 30 celcius
2 2.4400
25 celcius 2
2.6000 20 celcius
2 2.6900
Sig. 1.000
.059 .104
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.
81
Lampiran 14. Data analisis reologi CPO selama 4 minggu penyimpanan pada suhu 20, 25, 30, 35, dan 40
o
C A.
Analisis reologi CPO selama 0 minggu penyimpanan
1. Suhu Penyimpanan = 20
o
C Ulangan 1
Point Tau Pa
D 1s Eta Pas
1 4.421
4.575 0.966
2 7.521
13.810 0.545
3 10.230
24.550 0.417
4 13.450
34.790 0.387
5 18.660
44.120 0.423
6 21.950
54.550 0.402
7 22.940
64.840 0.354
8 26.820
74.470 0.360
9 27.640
85.380 0.324
10 29.880
95.670 0.312
11 32.860
105.000 0.313
12 34.700
115.600 0.300
13 36.690
126.200 0.291
14 38.590
136.600 0.283
15 40.660
146.000 0.278
16 42.850
156.500 0.274
17 44.940
167.200 0.269
18 45.500
176.200 0.258
19 47.030
186.500 0.252
20 48.520
197.200 0.246
21 52.410
206.700 0.254
22 53.050
217.500 0.244
23 54.820
227.900 0.241
24 57.910
237.100 0.244
25 58.260
247.800 0.235
26 63.120
258.300 0.244
27 64.340
265.200 0.243
28 64.810
275.800 0.235
29 66.530
286.400 0.232
30 68.040
295.600 0.230
31 68.910
306.200 0.225
32 69.340
316.700 0.219
33 70.220
326.000 0.215
34 72.310
336.500 0.215
35 73.450
347.100 0.212
36 75.210
356.300 0.211
37 77.540
366.900 0.211
38 78.770
377.400 0.209
39 80.970
386.700 0.209
40 83.050
396.800 0.209
Ulangan 2 Point
Tau Pa D 1s
Eta Pas 1
3.290 4.443
0.740 2
7.012 13.720
0.511 3
9.363 24.460
0.383 4
14.560 34.930
0.417 5
18.950 44.160
0.429 6
21.760 54.810
0.397 7
23.860 65.410
0.365 8
26.530 74.560
0.356 9
27.520 85.340
0.322 10
29.570 95.940
0.308 11
33.010 106.300
0.311 12
34.770 115.700
0.301 13
36.120 126.400
0.286 14
38.450 136.900
0.281 15
40.550 146.000
0.278 16
42.640 156.700
0.272 17
44.760 167.300
0.268 18
45.120 175.800
0.257 19
47.230 187.000
0.253 20
48.130 197.800
0.243 21
52.310 206.700
0.253 22
53.450 217.300
0.246 23
54.670 228.100
0.240 24
57.440 237.300
0.242 25
58.760 247.800
0.237 26
63.450 258.400
0.246 27
64.020 265.200
0.241 28
64.600 275.800
0.234 29
66.750 286.400
0.233 30
67.840 295.600
0.229 31
68.550 305.700
0.224 32
69.540 316.700
0.220 33
70.440 326.000
0.216 34
72.330 336.500
0.215 35
73.680 347.100
0.212 36
75.240 355.900
0.211 37
77.320 366.000
0.211 38
79.620 377.400
0.211 39
81.100 386.200
0.210 40
83.120 397.200
0.209
y = 0.6852x + 0.1304 R² = 0.9971
0.000 0.500
1.000 1.500
2.000 2.500
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s y = 0.6856x + 0.1293
R² = 0.9968 0.000
0.500 1.000
1.500 2.000
2.500
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s
82
Lampiran 14. Data analisis reologi CPO selama 4 minggu penyimpanan pada suhu 20, 25, 30, 35, dan 40
o
C lanjutan
2. Suhu Penyimpanan = 25
o
C Ulangan 1
Point Tau Pa
D 1s Eta Pas
1 4.293
4.883 0.879
2 6.931
14.380 0.482
3 10.390
24.720 0.420
4 11.830
35.370 0.334
5 12.990
44.380 0.293
6 14.820
54.850 0.270
7 16.550
64.880 0.255
8 18.300
76.100 0.240
9 19.570
85.380 0.229
10 21.240
95.810 0.222
11 22.940
106.500 0.215
12 23.510
115.800 0.203
13 26.500
126.200 0.210
14 28.100
136.800 0.205
15 29.700
146.000 0.203
16 30.120
156.600 0.192
17 31.540
167.400 0.188
18 33.870
176.200 0.192
19 35.840
187.000 0.192
20 35.850
197.700 0.181
21 38.750
207.400 0.187
22 39.550
217.600 0.182
23 40.120
228.500 0.176
24 41.770
237.400 0.176
25 42.630
247.900 0.172
26 44.850
258.500 0.174
27 46.530
264.800 0.176
28 47.320
275.800 0.172
29 48.220
286.400 0.168
30 49.120
295.200 0.166
31 51.340
306.200 0.168
32 52.340
316.700 0.165
33 53.640
326.000 0.165
34 55.230
336.500 0.164
35 56.750
347.100 0.163
36 57.230
356.300 0.161
37 59.570
366.900 0.162
38 60.420
377.400 0.160
39 61.240
386.700 0.158
40 62.640
395.900 0.158
Ulangan 2 Point
Tau Pa D 1s
Eta Pas 1
4.021 4.531
0.887 2
6.521 13.640
0.478 3
8.560 24.630
0.348 4
10.902 34.970
0.312 5
11.960 44.120
0.271 6
12.760 54.850
0.233 7
14.650 65.630
0.223 8
17.500 74.690
0.234 9
17.850 85.210
0.209 10
19.830 95.890
0.207 11
21.650 106.200
0.204 12
22.150 115.600
0.192 13
22.850 126.300
0.181 14
23.120 137.300
0.168 15
25.420 146.000
0.174 16
26.040 156.200
0.167 17
28.450 167.700
0.170 18
28.320 176.400
0.161 19
31.400 187.100
0.168 20
32.040 197.900
0.162 21
34.240 207.000
0.165 22
34.740 217.500
0.160 23
35.930 228.200
0.157 24
36.550 236.900
0.154 25
37.820 247.800
0.153 26
38.020 258.300
0.147 27
39.370 265.200
0.148 28
40.850 275.800
0.148 29
42.660 286.400
0.149 30
43.520 294.700
0.148 31
44.620 306.200
0.146 32
45.850 317.200
0.145 33
46.350 326.000
0.142 34
47.120 336.500
0.140 35
48.450 346.600
0.140 36
51.030 356.300
0.143 37
51.620 366.900
0.141 38
52.850 377.400
0.140 39
54.230 386.200
0.140 40
55.320 397.700
0.139
y = 0.7361x - 0.1230 R² = 0.9977
0.000 0.500
1.000 1.500
2.000
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s y = 0.7110x - 0.1208
R² = 0.9945 0.000
0.500 1.000
1.500 2.000
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s
83
Lampiran 14. Data analisis reologi CPO selama 4 minggu penyimpanan pada suhu 20, 25, 30, 35, dan 40
o
C lanjutan
3. Suhu Penyimpanan = 30
o
C Ulangan 1
Point Tau Pa
D 1s Eta Pas
1 3.941
4.663 0.845
2 4.512
13.770 0.328
3 8.042
24.460 0.329
4 9.740
34.970 0.279
5 10.650
44.300 0.240
6 12.410
54.850 0.226
7 13.020
65.230 0.200
8 15.120
74.560 0.203
9 16.130
85.380 0.189
10 17.560
95.810 0.183
11 18.440
105.000 0.176
12 19.540
115.600 0.169
13 20.330
126.300 0.161
14 21.460
137.100 0.157
15 22.630
145.800 0.155
16 23.520
156.600 0.150
17 24.630
167.400 0.147
18 25.960
176.500 0.147
19 27.450
187.500 0.146
20 28.520
197.800 0.144
21 29.850
207.100 0.144
22 31.240
217.400 0.144
23 33.110
227.900 0.145
24 34.520
237.500 0.145
25 35.670
247.900 0.144
26 36.740
258.500 0.142
27 36.530
265.200 0.138
28 37.850
275.800 0.137
29 38.420
286.400 0.134
30 40.120
295.600 0.136
31 41.660
306.200 0.136
32 42.360
316.700 0.134
33 43.230
326.000 0.133
34 44.640
336.500 0.133
35 46.130
347.100 0.133
36 47.850
356.700 0.134
37 48.640
366.900 0.133
38 49.530
377.400 0.131
39 50.120
386.700 0.130
40 51.740
397.200 0.130
Ulangan 2 Point
Tau Pa D 1s
Eta Pas 1
2.514 4.839
0.520 2
4.632 13.590
0.341 3
6.135 24.190
0.254 4
7.931 34.970
0.227 5
8.065 44.120
0.183 6
9.414 53.930
0.175 7
11.030 65.320
0.169 8
12.670 74.470
0.170 9
13.520 84.900
0.159 10
15.630 95.540
0.164 11
16.220 105.000
0.154 12
17.430 115.600
0.151 13
18.120 126.000
0.144 14
18.770 136.700
0.137 15
19.460 145.900
0.133 16
21.630 156.600
0.138 17
22.040 167.200
0.132 18
22.940 176.400
0.130 19
23.410 187.000
0.125 20
24.710 197.300
0.125 21
25.310 206.800
0.122 22
26.120 217.400
0.120 23
27.330 227.900
0.120 24
24.060 237.400
0.101 25
26.320 247.500
0.106 26
29.450 258.500
0.114 27
30.550 265.200
0.115 28
31.210 275.400
0.113 29
32.410 286.400
0.113 30
33.510 295.600
0.113 31
34.630 306.200
0.113 32
35.740 316.700
0.113 33
36.840 326.000
0.113 34
37.420 336.500
0.111 35
38.550 346.600
0.111 36
39.150 356.300
0.110 37
40.210 366.900
0.110 38
41.450 377.400
0.110 39
42.310 386.200
0.110 40
43.520 396.800
0.110
y = 0.7377x - 0.2210 R² = 0.9933
0.000 0.500
1.000 1.500
2.000
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s y = 0.7341x - 0.2894
R² = 0.9908 0.000
0.500 1.000
1.500 2.000
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s
84
Lampiran 14. Data analisis reologi CPO selama 4 minggu penyimpanan pada suhu 20, 25, 30, 35, dan 40
o
C lanjutan
4. Suhu Penyimpanan = 35
o
C Ulangan 1
Point Tau Pa
D 1s Eta Pas
1 1.421
4.707 0.302
2 2.412
13.720 0.176
3 3.041
24.550 0.124
4 3.951
34.930 0.113
5 4.551
43.900 0.104
6 5.863
54.720 0.107
7 6.102
65.230 0.094
8 7.201
74.520 0.097
9 7.512
85.120 0.088
10 8.413
95.980 0.088
11 8.664
105.000 0.083
12 8.912
115.500 0.077
13 9.412
126.200 0.075
14 10.440
136.700 0.076
15 11.510
146.100 0.079
16 11.930
156.600 0.076
17 12.870
167.300 0.077
18 12.440
176.400 0.071
19 12.310
187.000 0.066
20 14.310
197.600 0.072
21 14.550
206.500 0.070
22 15.830
217.300 0.073
23 15.730
228.400 0.069
24 16.840
237.300 0.071
25 17.340
247.700 0.070
26 17.230
256.000 0.067
27 18.370
265.200 0.069
28 18.630
275.800 0.068
29 18.940
286.400 0.066
30 19.730
295.600 0.067
31 20.510
306.600 0.067
32 21.430
316.700 0.068
33 21.740
326.000 0.067
34 22.530
336.500 0.067
35 22.140
347.100 0.064
36 22.510
356.300 0.063
37 22.640
366.900 0.062
38 23.630
377.400 0.063
39 24.120
386.200 0.062
40 23.630
396.800 0.060
Ulangan 2 Point
Tau Pa D 1s
Eta Pas 1
2.412 4.531
0.532 2
3.541 13.280
0.267 3
4.051 24.810
0.163 4
4.631 34.930
0.133 5
5.012 44.160
0.113 6
5.124 54.630
0.094 7
5.732 65.320
0.088 8
6.372 74.470
0.086 9
7.204 85.160
0.085 10
8.010 95.980
0.083 11
9.213 105.000
0.088 12
9.081 115.600
0.079 13
10.440 126.100
0.083 14
11.520 136.700
0.084 15
12.520 145.900
0.086 16
12.330 156.400
0.079 17
13.460 167.200
0.081 18
13.630 176.300
0.077 19
13.770 186.900
0.074 20
14.850 197.900
0.075 21
14.740 207.100
0.071 22
15.740 217.200
0.072 23
16.040 227.000
0.071 24
16.770 237.200
0.071 25
16.930 247.700
0.068 26
17.300 258.300
0.067 27
17.640 265.200
0.067 28
19.040 274.900
0.069 29
19.330 286.400
0.067 30
20.330 294.700
0.069 31
21.410 305.700
0.070 32
21.440 316.700
0.068 33
22.340 325.500
0.069 34
22.520 336.100
0.067 35
22.420 346.600
0.065 36
23.430 356.300
0.066 37
24.640 366.400
0.067 38
24.830 377.400
0.066 39
24.630 386.200
0.064 40
25.230 396.800
0.064
y = 0.7636x - 0.5970 R² = 0.9934
0.000
0.200
0.400 0.600
0.800 1.000
1.200 1.400
1.600
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s y = 0.7918x - 0.6523
R² = 0.9933 0.000
0.200
0.400 0.600
0.800 1.000
1.200 1.400
1.600
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s
85
Lampiran 14. Data analisis reologi CPO selama 4 minggu penyimpanan pada suhu 20, 25, 30, 35, dan 40
o
C lanjutan
5. Suhu Penyimpanan = 40
o
C Ulangan 1
Point Tau Pa
D 1s Eta Pas
1 0.921
4.619 0.199
2 1.021
13.420 0.076
3 1.451
24.590 0.059
4 2.435
34.970 0.070
5 3.852
44.120 0.087
6 4.231
54.680 0.077
7 5.210
65.760 0.079
8 5.632
74.600 0.075
9 5.885
85.380 0.069
10 6.213
95.590 0.065
11 7.020
105.100 0.067
12 7.410
115.500 0.064
13 8.041
126.200 0.064
14 8.221
136.800 0.060
15 9.531
146.000 0.065
16 10.210
156.700 0.065
17 11.030
167.200 0.066
18 10.440
175.600 0.059
19 11.410
187.300 0.061
20 11.450
197.200 0.058
21 11.750
207.300 0.057
22 12.410
217.300 0.057
23 13.620
227.900 0.060
24 14.740
236.500 0.062
25 14.230
247.900 0.057
26 14.730
258.300 0.057
27 15.730
265.200 0.059
28 16.330
275.800 0.059
29 16.520
286.400 0.058
30 16.230
295.600 0.055
31 16.850
305.700 0.055
32 18.660
315.800 0.059
33 19.000
326.000 0.058
34 20.510
336.500 0.061
35 21.740
347.100 0.063
36 21.520
356.300 0.060
37 22.650
366.900 0.062
38 23.520
377.400 0.062
39 23.750
386.200 0.061
40 24.120
397.200 0.061
Ulangan 2 Point
Tau Pa D 1s
Eta Pas 1
0.531 4.575
0.116 2
0.941 13.200
0.071 3
2.431 24.190
0.100 4
3.157 34.750
0.091 5
3.751 43.550
0.086 6
4.012 54.460
0.074 7
4.128 64.930
0.064 8
5.512 74.470
0.074 9
6.012 84.940
0.071 10
6.441 96.030
0.067 11
7.213 104.800
0.069 12
6.910 115.300
0.060 13
8.312 126.100
0.066 14
8.012 136.700
0.059 15
9.941 145.900
0.068 16
10.840 156.600
0.069 17
10.830 167.000
0.065 18
11.020 176.300
0.063 19
11.410 186.800
0.061 20
11.630 197.500
0.059 21
11.830 206.300
0.057 22
12.960 217.300
0.060 23
13.850 227.600
0.061 24
14.770 236.500
0.062 25
14.920 247.700
0.060 26
15.030 257.900
0.058 27
14.770 265.200
0.056 28
15.720 275.800
0.057 29
16.830 285.900
0.059 30
16.630 295.600
0.056 31
17.520 305.300
0.057 32
18.420 316.700
0.058 33
19.210 326.000
0.059 34
20.310 336.100
0.060 35
20.510 346.600
0.059 36
20.560 356.300
0.058 37
21.620 365.300
0.059 38
21.180 377.400
0.056 39
21.530 385.800
0.056 40
22.660 397.200
0.057
y = 0.8582x - 0.8798 R² = 0.9869
0.000 0.200
0.400 0.600
0.800 1.000
1.200 1.400
1.600
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ear St
re ss
Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s y = 0.8608x - 0.8908
R² = 0.9905 0.000
0.200 0.400
0.600 0.800
1.000 1.200
1.400 1.600
0.000 1.000
2.000 3.000
L o
g Sh
ea r
St re
ss Pa
Log Shear Rate 1s
86
Lampiran 14. Data analisis reologi CPO selama 4 minggu penyimpanan pada suhu 20, 25, 30, 35, dan 40
o
C lanjutan
B. Analisis reologi CPO selama 1 minggu penyimpanan
