Conclusion Tujuan Pembelajaran CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS
48
Hughes, Arthur. Testing for Language Teachers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003
J.Leu, Donald Jr., Kinzer, Charles K. Effective Reading Instruction in the Elementary Grades. Columbus, Ohio: Merrill Publishing, 1987.
Karlin, Robert. Teaching Elementary Reading: Third Edition. New York: Harcourt BRACE Jovanovich Inc. 1980.
Lodico, Margeurite G. Dean T. Spaulding, Katherine H. Voegtle. Method in Educational Research. US America: Jossey-Bass. 2006
Mather, Peter and McCarthy, Rita. The Art of Critical Reading. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2012.
Moore, Amy L., http: learningrx.comreading-comprehension-research-paper.pdf Priyana, Joko. Interlanguage: English for Senior High School XI. Pusat
Perbukuan Departemen Pendidikan Nasional, 2008. Romli, Muhamad.
Improving the Students’ Reading Comprehension of Narrative Text through Story Mapping. Skripsi for undergraduate Syarif
Hidayatullah State Islamic University, 2014. Saulter, Joseph. Introduction Video Game Design and Development. New York,
McGraw-Hill America. 2007. Squire, Kurt. Video Games in Education. USA: Cambridge, MA, Comparative
Media Studies Department Massachusetts Institute of Technology. 2000. Sugiyono. Metode Penelitian Kuantitatif, Kualitatif dan RD. Bandung: Alfabeta
cetakan ke 8. 2009 Tavinor, Grant. The Definition of Video games Revisited. Oslo: The Philosophy
of Computer Games Conference, 2009. Tiedemann, John Patrick. New Literacies, New Contexts? a Theoretical
Definitions of Reading Context, Vanderbilt University: 2011. Ulmer, Constance et al. Creating Games as Reader Response and Comprehension
Assessment. http:www.americanreadingforum.orgYearbooks02_yearbo
okhtml16_Ulmer etal revised.htm : 2002.
Vehdat, Sedigheh and Amin Rasti B. the Effect of Video Games on Iranian EFL Learner’s Vocabulary Learning. Florida, Reading Matrix: An
International Online Journal, 2013
49
Woolley, Gary. Reading Comprehension: Assisting Children with Learning Difficulties. Netherland: Springer Science+Business Media B.V, 2011.
Appendix 1 50
This story is for question number 1-5, choose the right answer
The Donkey and The Dog
A washer man had a donkey and a dog. Both the donkey and the dog helped his master in many ways. One night, few thieves broke in the house of that
washer man. The dog heard them and started barking. The washer man got up and so did the neighbors. “What is that? A dog. Let us run, said the thieves. They
feared some dangerous consequences. By that time many people gathered in the street. They tried to run away but they were caught by the people.
The washer man said, “I am glad I had this dog in my house. I am sure the thieves would have looted me if my dog had not barked. The washer man was
highly proud of the dog. Every one too praised the dog. From that day, the donkey started thinking, “The master thinks that the
dog is a more useful animal than me. The donkey decided he will show his master, the washer man, that he too could be useful just like the dog. Few days
passed. One night, it so happened, two thieves again entered the washer man’s house. The thieves became aware of the animals, present in tha
t house. “We should be careful, friend I have heard that a dog guards this house, one thief said
to the other. As the thieves peeped in, they saw the dog sitting just outside the main
door. “It seems the dog is quite alert, said one thief. “It is better to leave this house alone. We had better go at once, the other
thief said and the two thieves fled. But unknown to the thieves, the donkey was watching all this. He thought, “It is a good opportunity for me to show my master
that I too can be useful to him. The thieves have run away. If I start shouting, the master will think that I have driven the thieves away and out of this house. And
the foolish donkey started braying loudly.
When the washer man heard the donkey bray at this odd hour, he got an
gry. He came out with a stick and thrashed the donkey. “This will teach him not to bray at night, he screamed. The donkey got all the thrashes in silence. It did
not know what was taking place. Just then the dog came to the donkey and said, “It is better to do your
duties than try to be like me. The donkey knew that the dog was right. There after both the donkey and the dog remained peaceful.
1. Which one that made the thieves run? a. Donkey
b. Dog c. Thieves
d. The Washer 2. What makes the Donkey start to bray?
a. It wants to show how useful it is b. the Donkey was hungry
c. The Donkey saw the neighbor d. The Donkey was confused
Appendix 1 51
3. What is the meaning of “odd hour” paragraph 6?
a. morning b. afternoon
c. midnight d. unusual hour
4. What is the moral of the story? a. Stealing is a crime
b. We should do our own job c. Take care of a dog and they will love you
d. We should care for animals
5. Why would the thieves run away? a. They already stole the goods
b. T hey don’t want to steal anymore
c. They are afraid of the Dog d. The Donkey scares them
This story is for question number 6-10, choose the right answer
Satan in Disguise
There lived an old tiger in a forest. He could not hunt animals as he used to do when he was young. It was becoming difficult to get prey. The tiger thought, I
have lost my strength and speed of my youth. Unless I find some trick, I will starve to death.
After long thoughts, the tiger struck upon a plan. He began to keep on saying I am very old. I have turned into a vegetarian. I have become a sanyasi. I
will not hunt animals and so on. Soon these words spread in the jungle. Innocent animals came to pay
respect to the tiger thinking that the tiger had turned into a saint. The tiger pounced on animals when they came to his cave.
These words fell in the ears of a fox. The fox began to think, Can a tiger become a saint? He was eager to find the truth.
Stealthily, the fox approached the tigers cave. He minutely and carefully examined the foot prints of animals. He found all foot prints going towards the
cave but not returning from the cave. He told all animals in the forest. The tiger is a cheat. Dont go to the cave.
The tiger had to starve to death.
6. What did the tiger do to find a new prey? a. It pretended to die
b. It started to eat leaves and fruits c. The tiger cheats so the animals will come to the tiger
d. The Tiger doesn’t like meat anymore 7.
The word “eager” paragraph 4 has the closest meaning to… a. Hoping
b. Uninterested c. Apathetic
d. Dreaming
Appendix 1 52
8. What happened after the fox found out the tiger was cheating? a. The Fox runaway scared
b. The Fox died of shock c. The Fox keeping the secret to itself
d. The Fox tells the other animals
9. Why the innocent animals called the tiger a saint? a. Because the tiger wanted to become young again
b. Because the tiger was not hungry at all c. Because the tiger don’t want to eat meat anymore
d. Because the tiger was on a diet
10. What is the moral value of this story? a. We should become a vegetarian
b. We should not spread other people secret c. Fox cannot be trusted
d. We should not be tricking people for our benefit This story is for question number 11-15, choose the right answer
The Farmer and His Lazy Sons
In Madhanpur lived a very hardworking farmer named Gopal. He has three sons Ram, Laxman and Hanuman. All three were strong and healthy. But they
were all lazy. Gopal was sad thinking about his sons and the future of his farmland.
One day, Gopal got a flash of an idea. He called all his sons and said, Ram Laxman and Hanuman I have hidden a treasure in our farmland. You
search and share the treasure among you. The three sons were overjoyed. They went to the fields and started
searching Ram started from one end. Laxman searched from the other end. And Hanuman did so from the centre. They dug each and every inch of the field. But
they could not find anything. Gopal said to his sons, “Dear boys Now you have tooled and conditioned
the field, why not we sow a crop Off went the sons to sow the crops. Days passed. Soon, the crops grew lushly green. The sons were delighted.
The father said, Sons, this is the real treasure I wanted you to share 11. What did Gopal do to make his sons work?
a. Gopal gave them food b. Gopal gave them his land
c. Gopal tricked them to find a treasure d. Gopal told them to find a job
Appendix 1 53
12. What was the hidden treasure for Gopal sons? a.
Gopal’s land b. Money
c. Animals’ farm d. Crops
13. the word “overjoyed” paragraph 3 has the closest meaning to…
a. Anxious b. Very Happy
c. Bored d. Dreadful
14. Where was the story happened? a. in a house near the river
b. Farmland c. Chicken Poultry
d. Stable
15. “….Gopal was sad thinking about his sons and the future of the
farmland…” the line on the first paragraph is called… a. Orientation
b. Resolution c. Plot Twist
d. Complication
This story is for question number 16-20, choose the right answer
The Short-Sighted Brothers
Three elderly brothers, all very short-sighted, lived in a large house on the outskirts of a city, in China. One day the youngest brother suggested that he
should take charge of the finances. “Elder brother’s sight is so bad, he cannot see how much money h
e’s receiving or giving, he said, “and people take advantage of his disability.
“As if you can see better, sneered the second-youngest brother. “If you’re saying our finances should be handled by the one who has the best sight, then it is
I who should be given charge. I can see better than either of you. “I have my doubts about that, said the eldest brother. “Let’s settle this
once and for all. I’ve heard the monastery is putting up a tablet inscribed with a saying, above the main doorway, tonight.
Let’s go there tomorrow and test our vision. Whoever can read the inscription with the least strain will get charge of
our money. Agreed? “Agreed, said his brothers in unison. “Good Now go away and let me get
a few winks. As soon as they had gone, the eldest brother sneaked out of the house and went to the monastery where he met a monk.
“I’ve heard you’re putting up an inscription over the doorway, he said. “Can you tell me what the inscription reads?
“Certainly. It’s a quotation from Confucius. It reads: Be Honest At All Times.
Appendix 1 54
The brother went away chuckling at his cleverness. A little later the second brother arrived there. “Can you tell me what the inscription you are going to put
up over the doorway reads? he said to the monk. “Everybody seems to want to know, said the man. It reads: Be Honest At All Times.”
“Is there any decoration around it? “The tablet has a flowery border.The second brother went away very
pleased with himself. Hardly had he gone when the third brother arrived there. He too enquired about the inscription and on being told what it was, asked if there
was any other writing on it. “Only the donor’s name, Wang Lee, at the bottom, said the monk.
The next morning the three short-sighted brothers made their way to the monastery.
“There’s the inscription, said the oldest when they drew near the entrance. “I can clearly make out the writing. It reads: Be Honest At All Times.
“Your sight is better than I thought, said the second brother. “But definitely not better than mine. Can you see the decoration around the
inscription? “Decoration? What decoration?
“There’s a floral decoration all around the tablet, said the brother, triumphantly.
“Very good, very good, applauded the youngest brother. “But can either
of you see any other writing on the tablet besides the inscription? “Other writing? intoned the second brother, his face falling. “What other
writing is there? “The name of the donor, Wang Lee, said the youngest brother, pointing.
“Can’t you see it? It’s at that corner. The monk they had talked to the previous evening came out of the
monastery just then and walked towards the short-sighted brothers. “Oh, you’ve come to see the inscription, he said. “So sorry. We couldn’t
put it up yesterday evening. We are going to put it up today. The short-sighted brothers realised their foolies.
16. What was the matter that three brother fight over? a. Their parents house
b. Their farm land c. Their money
d. Market kiosk
17. The word “applauded” has the closest meaning to…
a. Appreciate b. Mocking
c. Sulking d. Criticize
Appendix 1 55
18. Why would the Monk lie to the brothers? a. The brothers were trying to be honest
b. The monk wanted to make fun of them c. The brothers are lying to each other
d. The brothers can see clearly
19. “The short-sighted brothers realised their foolies.” the line is called…
a. Complication b. Orientation
c. Plot d. Resolution
20. Which of the following is correct based on the text? a. The brothers love each other
b. The brothers did not live together c. The monk was not giving them lesson
d. The brothers trying to trick each other
This story is for question number 21-25, choose the right answer
The Story of Hare and Tortoise
There was once an arrogant hare who wanted to prove that he was better than everybody else, so he chose the slowest animal in the county, the tortoise, and
invited him to a five mile race.
The tortoise accepted his challenge and trained hard for the event, while the hare walked around boasting that he was going to humiliate the tortoise and
make him look stupid.
The day of the race dawned. The tortoise set off at a slow and steady pace,
while the hare was dancing around laughing at him; other animals were laughing too, including the rabbit, the badger, and even the little hedgehog.
The hare became exhausted from all his dancing around, so he decided to have a nap. When he awoke, he realised that a few hours had passed and the
tortoise was nowhere to be seen. The hare panicked and ran the whole course as fast as he could, which was very fast indeed.
As he reached the top of the final hill, he could see the finish line in the distance, with the tortoise walking slowly across it, the victor.
21. The word “dawned” has the closest meaning to…
a. Finish b. Begin
c. Closing d. Meet
Appendix 1 56
22. What is the moral value of the story? a. Be modest
b. Sleeping while on a race is not good c. Eat much food before race
d. Do n’t try to challenge a tortoise
23. What did the tortoise do to win the race? a. The tortoise cheated
b. The tortoise helped by other animals c. The tortoise trained very hard
d. The tortoise used a roller skate to win
24. What happened after the hare took a nap? a. It continued to sleep
b. The hare won the race c. The hare cried
d. The hare run as fast as it could
25. Why would the Hare invite Tortoise to a race? a. Because tortoise is ugly
b. Because tortoise is a fast runner c. Because tortoise can be his friend
d. Because tortoise is slow This story is for question number 26-30, choose the right answer
Thirsty Crow and The Jug Of Water
On a hot day, a thirsty crow flew over a field looking for water. For a long time, she could not find any. She left very exhausted. She almost gave up.
Suddenly, she saw water jug below her. She flew straight down to see if there was any water inside. It was surprised because there was some water inside the jug.
The crow tried to push her head into the jug. Sadly she found that the neck of the jug was too narrow. Then she tried to push the jug down for the water to flow out
but she found that the jug was too heavy.
The crow thought hard for a while. Then she was looking around. She saw some pebbles. She suddenly had a good idea. She started picking up the pebbles one by
one, dropping it into the jug. As more and more pebbles filled the jug, the water level kept rising. Soon it was high enough for the crow to drink. “It’s working”
she said.
Appendix 1 57
26. What is the opposite meaning of word “suddenly”?
a. Slowly b. In a minute
c. Instantly d. Before that
27. Which one of the following is incorrect based on the story? a. The jug is half full
b. The crow is thirsty c. The crow is exhausted
d. The jug is full of water
28. What did the crow do to drink the water? a. it put pebbles inside the jug
b. it broke the jug c. The crow finds a nearby river
d. The crow did not drink at all
29. What is the moral value of the story? a. Giving up is the only option
b . Don’t get stressed over water
c. Get help from other if you want to drink d. Don’t give up if you want to achieve your goals
30. T he opposite word of “Narrow” is…
a. Wide b. Clean
c. Measure d. Thin
This story is for question number 31-35, choose the right answer
Three Feathers Story
Once upon time There was a king who had three sons. The two son were clever. The third son did not speak much so he was called Simpleton. When the
king had become old, he did not know which son should become the king. Then he got a bright idea and said; “Go forth, who brings me the most
beautiful carpet will be king after me”. He blew three feathers in the air, and said:
“You should go as they fly”. One feather flew to the east, the second to the west, but the third flew straight up and did not fly far.
So, one brother went to the right, and the other to the left. Simpleton was sad because his feather did not fly far. Then all at once he saw a trap-door close to
the feather. He found some steps, and went down the door. Then he came to another door, knocked at it. The door opened, and he saw a fat toad sitting. She
Appendix 1 58
ask ed what he wanted. He answered; “I should get the prettiest and finest carpet in
the world”. Then she called a young toad; “Bring me the great box” The young toad brought the box. The fat toad opened it, and gave simpleton a
carpet out of it. The carpet was so beautiful. So Simpleton thanked her, and brought it to the kingdom. Meanwhile his brothers just got some coarse
handkerchiefs from a shepherds’ wives whom they had met. When the king saw Simpleton’s carpet he was very astonished and said; ” Well, the kingdom belongs
to the Simpleton”. But his two brothers argued that it was impossible that simpleton should be king, They asked the king to make a new agreement.
Then the father said; “Who brings me the most beautiful ring will inherit the kingdom”. He blew three feathers, which they were to follow. Those of the
two eldest again went east and west, and simpleton’s feather flew straight up, and fell down near the trap-door. Again the fat toad gave him a ring sparkled with
jewels. Meanwhile his two brothers just got old carriage-rings. However they did not cease from tormenting the king until he made a third condition.
So the king declared; Who brings the most beautiful woman home will be the king”. He again blew the three feathers into the air. Then Simpleton went
down to the fat toad, and said; “I am to take home the most beautiful woman”. Then she gave him a yellow turnip which had been hollowed out. Mournfully
Simpleton said; “What am I to do with it?”. The toad answered; “Just put one of my little toads
into it”. Then Simpleton seized one little toad and put her into the yellow coach. Surprisingly the little toad turned into a beautiful maiden. So
Simpleton took her to the king. On the other hand, his brother brought peasant women to the kingdom.
When the king saw the women he said; “After my death the kingdom
belongs to my youngest son”. But the two eldest brothers kept arguing that whose wife could leap through a ring which hung in the center of the hall would be the
king. The king agreed. Then the two peasant women jumped through the ring but they fell which made their arms and legs broke. On the other hand, the pretty
maiden sprang through the ring as lightly as a deer which made the two peasants ceased. So Simpleton received the crown and ruled wisely the kingdom.
31. Which of these statements are correct based on the story? a. the eldest brothers have beautiful wife
b. The yellow turnip was eaten by the simpleton c. The simpleton is the new King
d. The eldest brothers have become the soldier
32. What is the moral value of the story? a. We should accept what has been given to us
b. find a wife from a fat toad c. Don’t be angry over a throne
d. Support your sibling
Appendix 1 59
33. What happened after the fat toad gave the Simpleton a yellow turnip? a. The simpleton ate it
b. He gave it to his father c. He throw it away
d. The simpleton put a toad inside
34. Where the eldest brothers’ feathers went?
a. east b. east and west
c. southeast d. nowhere
35. Why would the King use feathers to decide his kingdom future? a. He wasn’t sure of his sons
b. He hates his sons so he sent them away c. His sons is spoiled
d. The Queen asks him
This story is for question number 36-40, choose the right answer
The Monkeys and The Cap Seller
Once, a cap seller was passing through a jungle. He was very tired and needed to rest. Then, he stopped and spread a cloth under a tree. He placed his bag
full of caps near him and lay down with his cap on his head. The cap seller had a sound sleep for one hour. When he got up, the first
thing he did was to look into his bag. He was startled when he found all his caps were not there.
When he looked up the sky, he was very surprised to see monkeys sitting on the branches of a tree, each of the monkeys is wearing a cap of on its head.
They had evidently done it to imitate him He decided to get his caps back by making a humble request to the
monkeys. In return, the monkeys only made faces of him. When he begun to make gesture, the monkeys also imitated him.
At last he found a clever idea. ” Monkeys are a great imitator,” he thought. So he took off his own cap and threw it down on the ground. And as he had
expected, all the monkeys took off the caps and threw the caps down on the ground. Quickly, he stood up and collected the caps, put them back into his bag
and went away
Appendix 1 60
36. “…. each of the monkeys is wearing a cap of on its head. They had
evidently done it to imitate him…” The line above is called…
a. Complication b. Orientation
c. Resolution d. Plot Twist
37. Which of the following is incorrect based on the text? a. The monkey made fun of the cap seller
b. The cap seller was trying to beat the monkey c. The cap seller was frustrated
d. The cap seller tried to make the monkey imitate him
38. What happened after the cap seller try to make gesture to the monkey? a. The monkey chew the caps
b. The cap seller went away c. The monkey imitate him
d. The cap se ller grabbing the monkey’s tail
39. Which direction the monkey throw caps? a. to the river
b. to the ground c. to the air
d. to the hole
40. What is the opposite meaning of word “imitator”?
a. Artist b. Copycat
c. Trendsetter d. Tailor
Why Cats Chase Rats
Thousands of years ago, the Jade Emperor of China organized a race for animals. The first 12 animals to finish were to be given a place in the Chinese
Zodiac, and have a year named after them. The cat and the rat, both late-risers asked the ox to wake them at dawn on the day of the race.
The day has arrived, the ox tried to wake the cat and the rat, but without success. They would open their eyes, turn to the other side and go back to sleep.
The race was about to start. Unwilling to leave them, the ox coaxed them onto his back and started running. The rat woke up just as the ox was crossing the last
hurdle, a river. The sly rat knew that he could never beat the cat in the race. He
took the chance fate offered him and pushed the cat off the ox’s back. When the ox reached the other side, the rat jumped off and scampered to victory, just ahead
of the ox. The tiger came third, but he cheated. He crossed the river by using the
Appendix 1 61
backs of the animals swimming across as stepping stones, leaping from one to another.
So the 12-year cycle of the Chinese Zodiac begins with the rat. After him comes the ox who is followed by the tiger. After them come the rabbit, dragon,
snake, horse, goat, monkey, rooster, dog and pig, in that order. The cat, it must be noted, has no place in the zodiac. She wasn’t among the first twelve. In fact she
was lucky to finish, having almost drowned in the river. So is it any wonder that cats chase rats? They can never forget the
humiliation heaped on their ancestor by a tricky rodent 41. What is the opposite word of
“unwilling” on second paragraph? a. Hoping
b. Reluctantly c. Accepting
d. Grieving
42. Which animal came third on finish line? a. Cat
b. Rat c. Ox
d. Tiger 43. Why the Ox put the cat and the rat on its back?
a. it wants them to win b. it wants them to participate
c. the Ox hate them d. The cat and the rat loves to sleep on its back
44. What is the opposite meaning of “late-risers” paragraph 1?
a. Sleepyhead b. Wakes up early
c. Sleep late d. Night owl
45. What the tiger do to cross the river? a. it swim across the river
b. it flies above the animals c. the tiger crossing the bridge
d. it leap across using others back
The Three Runners
In the days when whites ruled South Africa and apartheid was the law of the land, two middle-aged blacks met in a whites only section of Johannesburg.
One of them had a permit to work in the area, the other did not. This meant he could be put behind bars for trespassing into an exclusive zone.
Appendix 1 62
Suddenly they saw a policeman coming towards them, and froze. Run whispered the man with the permit to his friend. Ill follow.
They started running and the policeman shouting Stop, stop, began chasing them.
Finally he caught the second man. Did you think you could outrun me he snarled. Show me your permit
The man, playing for time, began fumbling in his pocket and finally produced his permit.
The policeman was taken aback. He realized that he had been tricked. The man without the permit was now too far away to be caught.
When you had a permit why did you run he bawled. Doctors orders, said the man. He has asked me to run a mile every evening.
Oh, yes? sneered the policeman. Then why was your friend running? His doctor too has ordered him to run, said the man.
The policeman became red with anger. You think youre very smart, dont you? he snarled. But tell me, if you were
only running for your health why didnt you stop when you saw me running after you? And dont tell me you didnt see me chasing you... I know you did
Of course I knew you were running after me, said the man. Then why didnt you stop? asked the policeman, triumphantly.
It was stupid of me, said the man, but I thought you too had been ordered to
run by your doctor.” 46. Which country did the city of Johannesburg in?
a. United States of America b. Europe
c. South Africa d. Asia
47. “Suddenly they saw a policeman coming towards them, and froze” The line above
is called… a. Resolution
b. Orientation c. Re-orientation
d. Complication 48.
Why would there be “white zone” in Johannesburg? a. Because the city was ruled by the “white people”
b. Because the town was only painted white c. The people in the city wearing only white clothes
d. Because all the black people was killed
Appendix 1 63