Request-Refusal The Types of Dispreferred Responses Performed by Hiccup in How to Train Your Dragon 2 Movie
by giving no answer
.
The dialogue between Astrid and Hiccup below is the example of question-unexpected answer
.
Astrid : excited What did you tell him?
Hiccup : I didn’t
.
By the time he turned around, I was gone
.
Datum 3 Astrid and Hiccup discussed about Hiccup’s father who appointed him
to be the new chief of their village
.
Astrid encouraged him to try it first while stating some advantages he would get when Hiccup became the new chief
.
Astrid then asked Hiccup’s answer regarding this matter
.
Hiccup responded negatively as he was already gone before Stoick could hear his answer
.
The unexpected answer with the expression “By the time he turned around, I was gone” indicates Hiccup’s indirect answer
.
This leads to Astrid’s disappointment
.
The occurrence shows the question-unexpected answer as Hiccup does not answers the way Astrid expects him
.
Another example of question-nounexpected answer in dispreferred response can be seen by the dialogue between Fishlegs and Hiccup
.
The situation happened when Hiccup and Astrid reunited with their friends after
almost being captured by the dragon trappers
.
He and Astrid told them about the island that covered in icebergs and the unexpected move of the trappers
.
Hiccup’s friends asked him questions about their journey
.
Fishlegs then asked if there were any new dragon types which they had not seen in Berk
.
Fishlegs
seemed to not understood what Hiccup was trying to say, which resulted in Hiccup responded by explaining what exactly they watched when they came
across the island
.
Fishlegs : Any new dragons? Hiccup : No, this was different
.
Not the standard run-for-the- hills-hoo-ha I’ve come to enjoy
.
These guys were trappers
.
Dragon trappers
.
Datum 8 In the datum above, Hiccup does not respond Fishlegs’ question by
giving her the answer of the new dragons, but instead he tells them about the dragon trappers
.
This answer is categorized as the dispreferred response because Hiccup gives the unexpected answer and tells her “no”, which
indicates the less preferred answer Fishlegs expects
.
The dialogue between Astrid and Hiccup below is another example of question-unexpected answer dispreferred response
.
Astrid : But won’t that Bewilderbeast just take control of these guys, too?
Hiccup : They’re babies
.
They don’t listen to anyone
Datum 30 This datum happened when Hiccup and the other were preparing for the great
war between their dragons and Drago Bludvist’s Bewilderbeast
.
Since Drago’s dragon had taken control of their own dragons, Hiccup and the other
had no choice but borrowed the dragons from Valka
.
Astrid was worried about them, because Bewilderbeast could also take control of the dragons
.
However, Hiccup told her that the dragons were still babies and would not listen to anyone, including Drago’s Bewilderbeast
.
From the context above, Hiccup is indirectly saying “no” to the previous speaker, Astrid
.
By not saying “no”, Hiccup implied his meaning by telling her “They don’t listen to anyone”
.
Hiccup says the expression to explain the indirect “no” response to Astrid’s question
.