The First Draft of the Materials The Expert Judgment
continued
Table 27 shows that the presentation of the materials is good. It could be inferred from the mean resulted from the general judgment. The mean shows 3.50,
so the presentation of Unit 1 is categorized as good. Table 28: The Appropriateness of the Language of Unit 1
continued 4.
The developed tasks encourage students to
perform oral
communication effectively.
3.50 Good
5. The developed tasks encourage students
to be creative. 3.50
Good 6.
The developed tasks encourage students to work independently and in groups.
3.50 Good
7. The developed materials consist of
evaluation for students to measure their understanding
of the
developed materials.
3.50 Good
8. The
developed materials
provide vocabulary appropriate with the topic
being discussed. 3.50
Good
9. The developed materials contains science
terminology related to topic discuss in each unit.
3.50 Good
The general judgment of the presentation 3.50
Good
No. Evaluated
Aspect Items
Means Category
1. Language
The language used is relevant to students’ cognitive development.
4 Very
good 2.
The language of instruction can be easily understood by the students.
3.50 Good
3. The materials are developed in a
grammatical English. 3.50
Good
continued
Table 28 presents the result of expert s’ judgment related to the language of
the materials in Unit 1. The mean of the general judgment of the language is 3.75. Therefore, the language in Unit 1 is categorized as very good.
Table 29: The Appropriateness of the Layout of Unit 1
Table 29 presents the result of expert s’ judgment related to the layout of the
materials in Unit 1. The mean of the general judgment of the language is 3.50. Therefore, the language in Unit 1 is categorized as very good.
4.
Language The spelling of the language of
instruction is in accordance with spelling principle.
3.50 Good
5. The choices of words of the materials are
in accordance
with word
choice principle.
4 Very
good
6. The developed materials in a unit are
linked to materials in the next unit. 4
Very good
The general judgment of the language 3.75
Very good
No. Evaluated
Aspect Items
Means Category
1. Lay-out
The fonts used are no too various. 3.50
Good 2.
The fonts used are not too big or too small.
3.50 Good
3. The color of the materials are not
disturbing the reader. 3.50
Good 4.
The pictures are provided for aesthetic and functional purposes.
3.50 Good
The general judgment of the layout 3.50
Good