Instruments of the Data
                                                                                2005. Then, it was described in descriptive statistic. The item which had the highest presentation was considered as the tendency of students.
The second questionnaire which was a questionnaire for the materials development  expert  consisted  of  statements  and  responses  in  the  form  of
Likert  Scale.  Likert  scale  wass  a  scale  which  was  used  to  gain  information from  the  respondents.  It  was  used  to  indicate  the  strength  of  the  materials
development expert’s agreement and disagreement related to the statements given.  The  data  from  expert  were,  then,  measured  using  mean  central
tendency  and  analysed  using  a  formula  proposed  by  Suharto  2005.  The Likert Scale used in the second questionnaire uses 4 point range as follows.
Table 7: Likert Scale 4 Point Range No
Categories Score
1 Strongly Agree
4 2
Agree 3
3 Disagree
2 4
Strongly Disagree 1
The data from the expert was calculated by using a formula proposed by Suharto 2005:59 to find the range or the data interval. After that, the data
was converted into descriptive statistic. The researcher used mean X as the indicator of measurement.
Table 8: Data Conversion Table Suharto, 2005 Scale
Interval Descriptive Categories
4 3.25 ≤ X ≤ 4.00
Very Good 3
2.50 ≤ X ≤ 3.24 Good
2 1.75 ≤ X ≤ 2.49
Fair 1
1.00 ≤ X ≤ 1.74 Poor
2. Qualitative data
Qualitative  data  were  gathered  from  the  interview  and  observation. The  data  were  analysed  using  qualitative  data  analysis  model  proposed  by
Miles  and  Huberman  1994.  There  were  three  stages  of  data  analysis  as presented below.
Table 9: Qualitative Data Analysis Stage
Explanation
Data reduction The process of transforming masses of data into small
number of categories Data display
Organizing  information  that  permits  conclusion drawing and action
Data conclusion Deciding what things mean
The  interview  result  was  written  in  form  of  interview  transcript,  while  the observation result was written in form of observation vignette.