Claim-Ground-Warrant Jokowi’s Argument Structures .1 Claim-Ground

4.1.1.3 Claim-Ground-Warrant

The claim of argument D3S5J is about the importance of using drones. Albeit there is a conjunction which shows opposition, the emphasis of his claim is in this utterance “Tetapi ketika depan kalau kita tidak memulai sekarang kapan lagi kita harus mulai?”. Why should the claim be realized? The answer of that question is the ground of the claim. In his argument, Jokowi conveyed that drone could be bought and the Ipad technology and satellite can also be done see ground below. The warrant between claim and ground in argument D3S5J is an evaluative warrant where there is an inference of making something better. Oleh sebab itu, drone di 3 wilayah ini penting sekali, meskipun kalau kita punya drone pun kita satelitnya masih ikut menyewa ke negara-negara yang lain. Tetapi ketika depan kalau kita tidak memulai sekarang kapan lagi kita harus mulai? [Therefore, drones in the 3 regions are imperative, though if we have drones, the satellites are still renting from other countries. But if we do not start now, when will we start?] Claim dronenya bisa kita beli sekarang dan ipad tekhnologinya bisa kita lakukan satelitnya pun juga bisa. [the drones we can buy now and technology of ipad, we can also do the satellites.] Ground Kita sekarang nebeng dulu tapi harus punya target bahwa kita harus punya satelit sendiri pada suatu saat. Ada targetnya [We are now renting but we should have a target that we must have our own satellite. There is a target] Warrant D3S5J Jokowi claimed that a clean governance can be achieved if there is a system building. He supported his claim by mentioning what he had done when he was a governor such as e-budgeting, e-procurement, e-purchasing, e-catalog, e-audit, online tax, online IMB. It is the ground of claim D1S1J. He warranted his claim and ground by conveying that those ways could be nationalized if Jokowi and JK were elected. That statement is a warrant where the inference between claim and ground in argument D1S1J related. Because e-budgeting, e-procurement, e-purchasing, e- catalog, e-audit, online tax, online IMB were mentioned by Jokowi as inference Indonesian people need to choose Jokowi-JK if they want to have a clean governance. That is the inference or in Toulmin called as a warrant which is taken from claim D1S1J and ground D1S1J. Kemudian yang kedua, pemerintahan yang bersih. Pemerintahan yang bersih bisa dilakukan apabila ada dua hal. Pembangunan sistem, sistem yang seperti apa? [Then the second, it is about a clean government. Good governance can be done if there are two things. Systems development, systems like?] Claim Telah kami lakukan dan telah kami buktikan baik kami menjadi walikota atau gubernur. E –budgeting, e-procurement, e- purchasing, e-catalog, e-audit, pajak online, IMB online. [We have done and we have proved to be a mayor or governor. E -budgeting , e -procurement , e - purchasing , e -catalog , e - audit , tax online , IMB online.] Ground Cara-cara seperti itulah yang kita perlukan dan bisa dinasionalkan. Semua daerah bisa, nasional bisa melakukan ini apabila Jokowi dan JK diberi amanah oleh rakyat untuk memegang pemerintahan ini. Warrant [Such ways that we need and those can be nationalized. All regions can do, national can do those ways if Jokowi and JK are given a mandate by the people to hold this government.] D1S1J As a new claim, Jokowi uttered that deep ship ports and ocean toll roads could make fairer for Indonesian people. To support his claim, ground below gives more observation about how it can make more justice by saying “nantinya harga semen di Sumatera, di Jawa, di Kalimantan, di Sulawesi di Nusa Tenggara, di Papua itu akan sama atau hampir sama ” [in the future, the price of cement in Sumatra, Kalimantan, Sulawesi, Nusa Tenggara, Papua will be the same or almost the same]. He warranted his claim and ground by uttering that our infrastructure was not built based on maritime principle albeit Indonesia is a maritime country. So in his warrant, Jokowi infers the situation where there is no justice stated in claim D2S4J and there is different price in many places see ground D2S4J. Kalau tol laut ini kita bangun, deep ship port kita bangun, di Sumatera, deep ship port kita bangun, di Jawa, deep ship port kita bangun di Kalimantan, deep ship port kita bangun di Sulawesi, di Papua ini akan memberikan rasa keadilan [If we build sea toll, we build deep ship port in Sumatra, we build deep ship port in Java, we build deep ship port in Borneo, we build deep ship port in Sulawesi, Papua. It will provide a sense of justice] Claim karena nantinya harga semen di Sumatera, di Jawa, di Kalimantan, di Sulawesi, di Nusa Tenggara, di Papua itu akan sama atau hampir sama. Tidak seperti sekarang ada sebuah harga yang sangat berbeda sekali [because later the price of cement in Sumatra, Java, Kalimantan,Sulawesi, Nusa Tenggara, Papua will be the same or nearly the same. Not like now, the pricings are very different] Ground karena infrastruktur tidak dibangun berdasarkan kelautan, karena kita adalah negara maritim dan laut tidak diberikan perhatian. [because the infrastructure is not built based on maritime principle, because we are a maritime country and the sea is not given attention.] Warrant D2S4J

4.1.1.4 Qualifier-Claim-Ground-Warrant