the planned system would be collapsed. It is definitely the exception of claim D2S3J to happen.
Kemudian mengenai angka kematian ibu yang naik dan layanan kesehatan bagi perempuan, angka kematian ibu naik tadi sudah
saya sampaikan, tetapi perlu saya ulangi bahwa ini adalah membangun sistem, membangun sistem dan mengontrol sistem
itu. Dengan cara apa? Ya dengan sistem kartu ini. [Then about a rising maternal mortality rate and health care for
women, I have discussed a rising maternal mortality rate rise, but I need to repeat that this is about building systems, building
systems and controls that system. In what way? Yes with this card system.]
Claim
Anggarannya ada [There is a budget]
Ground Tetapi kalau sistemnya tidak dibangun, sistemnya tidak ada
manajemen pengawasan yang baik, sistemnya tidak dikontrol di lapangan, percuma anggaran itu akan menguap ke mana-mana.
Sistem itu akan berjalan dengan kondisi mau membangun, melakukan manajemen pengawasan
[But if the system is not built, the system has no good management control, the system is not controlled in the field, it
is useless, the budget would be waster. The system will run with a condition of willing to build, to perform management
oversight] Rebuttal
D2S3J
4.1.1.6 Qualifier-Claim-Ground-Rebuttal
Below is Jokowi’s argument relating to a question of how Jokowi-JK would realize their mission and vision relating to food productivity based on agribisnis
kerakyatan . They proposed to increase export in the form of value-added products.
Jokowi claimed that farmers actually can produce anything see claim below. He provided support in the form of observation that the government never provide
market for them the farmers. He also put a condition in which the farmers need to
be directed, guided given PPL and seeds. It is called rebuttal because it shows the claim under the reason that they need those supports in order the claim to happen.
The rebuttal is in line with Jo kowi’s qualifier “sebetulnya”. This qualifier means
that the farmers have the ability to produce anything, but they have not been valued to do so. It is called qualifier because it shows how much Jokowi valued his claim.
If he was sure 100 with his claim, he would have stated “petani itu pasti bisa
berproduksi apapun bisa ”.
Petani itu sebetulnya
…berproduksi apapun bisa. Jangan menganggap remeh petani.
[The farmer actually can...produce anything. Do not underestimate the farmer.]
Qualifier, Claim
asal diberi arahan, asal dikawal, asal diberi PPL, asal diberi bibit
[if given a referral , if guarded, if given PPL, if given seeds] Rebuttal
Persoalannya hanya kita pemerintah ini tidak pernah menyiapkan pasar untuk mereka. Kalau mereka sudah
diperintah untuk menanam pepaya, mustinya disiapkan industri ekstrak jus pepaya, yang bisa diekspor. Kalau mereka diperintah
di sebuah wilayah untuk menanam melon dan semangka mustinya juga pasarnya disiapkan. Industri pengolahan
pascapanen inilah yang sudah bertahun-tahun tidak pernah kita lihat dan tidak pernah kita kerjakan.
[The only problem is we the government have not prepared their market. If they have been instructed to plant papaya, we
should have prepare the extracts of papaya which can be exported. If they are asked in a region to grow melons and
watermelons, we should have prepared the market. Post-harvest processing industry is the one we have never seen and we never
done.] Ground
D5S2J
4.1.1.7 Qualifier-Claim-Ground-Warrant-Rebuttal
